The politics of ambivalence: romance, history, and gender in Mary W. Shelley's Fortunes of Perkin Warbeck.
I am doomed to a divided existence and I submit. (1)Published in 1830, Mary Wollstonecraft Shelley's second and last historical romance, The Fortunes of Perkin Warbeck, elicited reviews that questioned not only her legitimacy as a historical romancer, but also the damaging effects her "feminine" imaginative excesses could have on both the historical record and the literary establishment. Reviewers were particularly piqued by Shelley's failure to "blend together with sufficient skill what is fictitious and what is true." (2) To the effect that this was a consequence of the author's sex, a critic for the New Monthly Magazine commented that the book's womanliness--its "peculiar charm" and "feminine delicacy of feeling"--paralleled its author's amateurish lapses: her tendency to "overlook the vraisemblance of the romance" and her "eagerness to impress upon readers her own peculiar view of the historical fact." (3) Taken together, contemporary reviews bring into sharp focus the role gendered assumptions played not only in establishing the context for Perkin Warbeck's subsequent neglect by almost two centuries of critics and scholars, but also in establishing and defining the terms for understanding late-Romantic contests between history and fiction for influence, authority, and readers. As one consequence, critics and scholars have overlooked or ignored indications that Shelley purposefully and consciously crafted Perkin Warbeck as a literary laboratory wherein she might test the relation between gender politics and narrative form. However, Perkin Warbeck denotes a significant development in her career-long preoccupation with understanding and anatomizing the ways in which gendered political discourse defines not only the material lives of readers, but their imaginations as well.
Until recently, Perkin Warbeck was routinely passed over in surveys of Shelley's fiction or quickly abbreviated as evidence of what happens when a Romantic author stoops to write for profit. To date, fewer than a dozen fully developed articles and book chapters take the novel as their principal subject, and even fewer approach it as more than a failed if ambitious historical romance. An air of de facto condemnation surrounds Perkin Warbeck, and the novel is often invoked as evidence of Shelley's flagging creative powers after the death of her poet husband, Percy B. Shelley. However, Perkin Warbeck can be accounted for more accurately as a transitional text that makes way for her turn toward domestic realism, biographical life writing, and travelogues during the last decades of her career. By extending and working through the conversations initiated in her romances of the 1810s and 1820s regarding the relationships of gendered and generic discourses, Shelley examines in Perkin Warbeck the ways in which the female and the feminine act as intersection points for a multiplicity of competing historical and literary discourses.
As readers of her early works often attest, Shelley's novels of the 1820s are richly intertextual and repay a reader's close attention to signs of authorial anxiety, metafictionality, and notions of influence. Equally remarked upon are the ways in which these novels reflect upon the authorial burden while also engaging with parallel conversations regarding the "good Cause" or, in Shelley's own words, "the cause of the advancement of freedom and knowledge--of the Rights of Women &c." (4) Most would agree that exactly what Shelley intended by "&c." cannot be known for sure--her slipperiness regarding slavery and workers' rights has been well documented--but what seems clear from Shelley's texts is that, for her as a professional female writer, the question of who can be an Author interlocked with questions of what could be spoken about and by whom. It is from within this context that Perkin Warbeck self-consciously invokes and locates itself against the masculine forms with which it was most likely to be compared by nineteenth-century readers: the encyclopedic Antiquarian Romance as practiced by Sir Walter Scott and the contrasting Republican form associated with Shelley's father, William Godwin. In the process, Perkin Warbeck explores the meaning of an anti-establishment hero in a literary form largely associated with establishment narratives and celebratory of masculinist historical traditions and imperial fantasies. What is uncovered is the historical romance's inadequacy to accommodate both the actualities of women's experience and the vision of the female romancer who, though interested in questions similar to those posed by the male masters of the form--questions regarding how national memory should be conserved and to what end fiction could be employed to do so--negotiated those questions from a vastly different subject-position. Perkin Warbeck's context both within the Shelley canon and within the larger scope of Romantic-era debates about readers and reading reflects her complex intertextual reconsideration of what roles she as a female author and the romance as a "feminine" genre could play in the liberal social project of perfectibility.
Shelley's composition and publication of Perkin Warbeck corresponded chronologically with a literary scene that was undergoing enormous stress as a result of democratizing literacy and that was actively engaged in debates about reading and readers. These debates had specific implications for female writers, whose works, according to social historians such as Ina Ferris, were "primarily defined as part of a cultural pragmatics aimed at shaping reading practices of new entrants into the culture of literacy: women, children, servants, and so forth." (5) "Feminine" genres such as the Gothic and the epistolary novels--media associated on one level with fictional heroines and their love plots, and on another with real-life female readers and female authors--were at the epicenter of debates regarding "moral" or "edifying" versus "trashy" kinds of reading. In addition, "novelism"--a quixotic malady brought on by a combination of unrestrained romance reading, an equally unrestrained imagination, and too much "sensibility"--was increasingly labeled the ruin of women who, like Charlotte Lennox's Arabella or Jane Austen's Catherine Morland, were incapable of distinguishing fiction from reality. By 1800, a powerful tide of anti-Jacobin sentiment and a backlash against social radicalism, especially Wollstonecraftian feminism, had complicated the female novelist's quest for legitimacy. Ironically, Mary Wollstonecraft's Vindication of the Rights of Woman (1792) was one of the first texts explicitly to argue that female readers should guard against the "romantic twist of mind" brought on by novel reading. (6) Instead, she states, women and young girls should read "those works which exercise the understanding and regulate the imagination" (331).
Shelley's gradual shift from romantic to realistic prose fiction during the last decade of her career suggests that she intended to distinguish herself from the "stupid novelists" upbraided by Wollstonecraft and other genre-reformers who believed that bad writing is bad for society (Wollstonecraft, 330). A concern for legitimizing prose fiction seems clearly a part of Shelley's 1826 published attack on Anna Brownwell Jameson's Diary of an Ennuyee (1826), in which she states: "Fiction must contain no glaring improbability, and yet it must never divest itself of a certain idealism, which forms its chief beauty." (7) At the heart of what Shelley calls her "hypercriticism" of Jameson's Diary, a work she admits has "great spirit and great enthusiasm," is a concern for distinguishing morally edifying fiction from cheap trickery (355). Calling Jameson's text a "fraud" and an "imposture," Shelley indicts "incongruous" generic mixtures that intentionally exploit a reader's gullibility and thus debase the values of reason and intellect: "having discovered that the sensitive, heart-broken, dying, dead diarist is a fictitious personage, we are angry at the trick of art that excited our real sympathy" (355). Shelley is unrelenting on the point that certain kinds of imposture are admissible and certain kinds are not. "The very laws of cavaliere serventeism in Italy are not more delicate, subtle, and yet strict, than those of fiction," Shelley argues, "and they are transgressed in the volume before us" (355). The connection between the laws of fiction and the social codes governing a married woman's attendance by a lover brings forward a full sense of the novel as a genre of and for the boudoir: a feminine space defined by secrets, seductions, and sensations, but also by absolute rules of play. As an antidote to the romance's imaginative excesses, realistic fiction must not cheapen sympathetic transcendence in readers. Authors must either maintain the lie, and thus readers' sympathetic transcendence, or build in codes that make clear what they are doing.
Worth noting is that Shelley's review of Jameson's Diary expresses disdain for a poorly executed imposture rather than for imposture itself. As such, it indicates an important framework for understanding Shelley's literary activities of the late 1820s, a time when notions of gender masquerade and generic imposture infiltrated both her private and professional lives. Recent scholarship has demonstrated the ways in which Shelley utilized "cross-dressing narrative" to manipulate readers' "gender-oriented expectations" by providing plot lines that "on the surface support male-oriented values but, below that surface, effectively undermine them." (8) A. A. Markley has reviewed contemporary theories of literary transvestism to argue that throughout Shelley's short fiction and novels, narratives of cross-dressing appear to reestablish the normative social order while at once demystifying the system of male domination. (9) Looking at the relationship between paratext and text in The Last Man (1826), Michael Eberle-Sinatra similarly writes that though seemingly resigned to male domination of the literary marketplace, Shelley consciously attempts to destabilize the naturalness of that gendered hierarchy by juxtaposing a genderless narrator in the Preface with the male speaker of the text proper. (10) In all cases, scholars' searches for signs of Shelley's open rebellion against the gender system garner proof that Shelley was a mistress of disguise, often hiding what we seek in plain sight.
Shelley's skill as an illusionist is perhaps nowhere better exemplified than in the circumstances surrounding Perkin Warbeck's composition. From her letters, we can surmise that Shelley probably began researching the novel's subject in late 1826. Around this same time, she took in and became close friends with Isabelle Robinson, an unwed mother from a wealthy family. A year later, while nursing Robinson through an illness, Shelley wrote to her friend Jane Williams, "You may guess how my time is taken up--I steal an hour for writing in the morning, & another for a walk at night." (11) The plots of her new novel and friendship were soon mutually informed by ideas of generic inversion and cross-dressing. To this effect, Betty T. Bennett's research uncovered not only that Shelley was privy to the marriage of Robinson to another woman, Mary Diana Dods, but that she played a crucial role in Dods's and Robinson's impersonation on the Continent of an eccentric but conventionally heterosexual married couple, Mr. and Mrs. Walter Sholto Douglas. (12)
By the fall of 1827, preparations for the "Douglases" elopement fully intersected with Shelley's literary study of imposture and dissembling. In late September, Shelley wrote two letters: the first, dated September 25, was to her father, William Godwin, requesting information on the Princes of the Tower, the children of Edward IV. The second, dated September 26, was to John Howard Payne, requesting passports for herself, her son, and the "Douglas family." In both cases, Shelley sought official documents--histories in the case of Godwin, travel papers in the case of Payne--as props for a sustained masquerade. To the extent that Shelley's efforts were successful, neither Dods, a woman passing as a man, nor Perkin Warbeck, a feminine history passing as a masculine romance, has attracted much attention in the century and a half since. Both "plots," however, dramatically reveal the intensity with which Shelley's art responds to real-life circumstances and issues.
The last of her novels written during the 1820s, Perkin Warbeck is also the last of Shelley's novels to be temporally dislocated. The movement toward temporal realism would culminate in Lodore (1835), her next work and a novel that Shelley herself worried might fail because there is "no writhing interest--nothing wonderful or tragic" (MWSL, 2:183, emphasis in original). Just as her fiction moved into the realm of realism after Perkin Warbeck, so too did Shelley's engagements with historiography proper. In the months following Perkin Warbeck's publication, Shelley wrote John Murray a series of letters outlining different historical projects for his family library, including a "history of Woman" and "Lives of Celebrated Women" (MWSL, 2:115). Shelley's proposals declare her interest in formally constructing the feminist history already inscribed in her historical fiction. Murray refused Shelley's proposals. In 1835, she instead went to work for Lardner and wrote a remarkable series of Lives for his Cabinet Cyclopaedia, a series which, according to literary historian Greg Kucich, "afforded special opportunities for a dissenting contributor like Mary Shelley to address ... a female readership's desire for advancement while participating more broadly in the shaping of social codes and practices for a newly ascendant class of readers." (13)
Perhaps a sign of Shelley's use of Perkin Warbeck as a training ground for the literary Lives that would follow is that the novel demands a great deal from its readers. Shelley assumes an audience with a shared background, and transactions packed with sociopolitical culture, history, and aesthetics often converge in passages of highly stylized melodrama. A book made from and about other books, it seems to reserve certain of its meanings for a specially initiated reader able to recognize its eclectic blend of the political, the temporal, and the poetical. As a brief catalogue of filiations, Perkin Warbeck imitates works of historiography proper (Francis Bacon, Edward Hall, and Raphael Holinshed); it imitates best-selling fictional works by best-selling authors (Sir Walter Scott and Godwin); and, more importantly, it imitates the popular consciousness within which these opposing literary species dwell. For this reason, Warbeck's original reviewers responded with ambivalence; they were quick to note its epic digressiveness, its refusal to stick to the traditional tale, its chaotic jumping between generic conventions, and its intricate weaving of too many subplots. "The great use of an intermixture of fiction in an historical romance," one reviewer wrote, "is to relieve the reader from many dry details, and agreeably to fill up the interstices between those events which rivet the attention" (ELJ, 351). The review continues: "Mrs. Shelley, however, is contented to follow her hero's fortunes through thick and thin; and instead of fixing, as we should have advised her to do, on a few circumstances of acknowledged interest and moment, and contriving that all narrative should tend toward them, she rather prefers patiently to act the part of the biographer and with utmost perseverance follows Warbeck through all his fortunes, whether his adventures be brilliant or stupid, fortunate or disastrous" (351).
From this review, one gets a sense of the transgressiveness of Shelley's brand of romance as a comprehensive index of Warbeck's hidden domestic life and adventures. At issue is Shelley's violation of the traditional romance form, a form defined as early as William Congreve's 1692 Preface to Incognita in terms of elevated language, noble characters, stock love-and-honor plots, fantastic improbabilities, and concern for readers. (14) In his unsigned review of Austen's Emma (1815), Scott similarly defines "romance," whether medieval or modern, in terms of heroes' changing fortunes and heroines' static state of sexual persecution. He makes clear that romance depends on the abduction, ravishment, and complete degradation of the heroine before the author may "condescend" "to shield her from persecution." (15) Scott's definition of romance lends support to feminist scholars' related contention that Romanticism, as a male romance, is at its core celebratory of violence against women. Indeed, reappraisals of the popular novel, the romance, and the pulp fiction market during the Romantic period have shown the ways in which "woman" and "romance" became inextricably intertwined commodities in an economy designed to ensure the privileges of "man" and "novel." (16)
It is in interrogating just these terms of a masculine economy that Mary Shelley's Perkin Warbeck reveals a crippling dividedness. As an antiromantic tale, it recounts the untold and often catastrophic histories of the actual women behind the Tudor accession such as those of Elizabeth Woodville, Princess Elizabeth, Lady Brampton, Jane Shore, and Lady Katherine Gordon. It also complements these real-world histories with recycled romance plots of female victimization. Shelley subtitles Perkin Warbeck "a romance," a genre that, as we have already seen, is associated with feminine readers, the rape of heroines, imaginative excesses, and overdrawn sensibility. Though the work is subtitled "a romance," the Preface to Perkin Warbeck suggests it be regarded more accurately as a revisionary history and legitimizes the ensuing narrative by arguing for both the vraisemblance and bienseance, for both the plausibility and propriety, of the novel's subject and approach. In such manner, Shelley questions whether in this instance fiction is not as close to the truth of patriarchal culture and society as factual history is, and in so doing, she also questions whether fiction is complicit in the continued propagation of violence against women. History and romance, it seems, tell the same story and in the telling lay the groundwork for that story's continued validity and supremacy. Shelley speaks to readers as a historian and describes her relationship with the Warbeck tale as it evolved from scholarship to invention. Stating that it was "first suggested ... as a subject for historical detail" and that "it is not singular that I should entertain a belief that Perkin was, in reality, the Lost Duke of York," Shelley also asserts that the pathos of his tale could not be communicated by dry historiography: "it would be impossible for any narration, that should be confined to the incorporation of facts related by old Chroniclers, to do it justice" (FPW, 5). Thus feminine romance is called in to make up for historiography's emotional flaccidity and inadequate attention to the women existing outside proper history's record.
Shelley's attempts to anticipate and defuse objections to her historical thesis that Perkin Warbeck was in fact the lost Duke of York are not entirely successful, a point again made clear by the novel's early critics. Worth noting are the ways in which reviewers as a whole locate Perkin Warbeck in terms of its relational positionality, that is, in terms of its self-conscious invocations, revisions, and recyclings not only of other literary texts, but also of the various cultural and social discourses upon which those texts depend for intelligibility and meaning. Among the most important of these discourses are the gender-oriented values of readers culturally conditioned to regard "masculine" history and "feminine" romance as warring spheres of possibility. (17) In Shelley's Preface, readers are made to understand that romance will act as a sort of corrective to history's regulation of what is both knowable and useful to know about the past. The contiguity of history and romance invites a reading in terms of ideological border crossings, cultural and temporal translations, and authorial transliterations.
Consider, for example, Perkin Warbeck's "Spanish chapters," the purely fictional, imagined account of Prince Richard's childhood domestic education that serves as an excuse to introduce the Moorish factor into the novel. Rewriting Hume's account of Warbeck as possibly Edward IV's illegitimate son, Shelley explains that Yorkist supporters secreted Prince Richard out of England under the assumed name and identity of Perkin Warbeck, the recently deceased son of Myhneer Warbeck, a Flemish Jew and Yorkist sympathizer. Mynheer Warbeck then called upon his sister, Madeline de Faro, to take the young prince with her on her scheduled return to Flanders. Despite their best efforts, Richard's cover is soon threatened, and Madeline whisks him to the safer climes of "bright Andalusia" and the bloody landscape of the Granadan wars. The "land of romance," Spain provides a literal and symbolic context for the hero's belief in an outdated chivalric code--a belief system that Anne K. Mellor argues "compellingly illustrates the ways in which historical and political forces control individual destinies.... [and] suggests that the masculine betrayal of family bonds is a practice inherited from the past." (18) No less important, Iberia serves as a contested space where the realities and fantasies of empire wrestle for control. The contest for discursive control centers upon the woman of color, Monina, the beautiful Christian Moor whom Shelley finally cannot imagine outside of the inherited paradigms of romance and colonialist fantasy.
In other of Shelley's writings, imperial Spain is tropically associated through the figure of Cervantes with political liberalism, individualism, chivalric honor, feudal tyranny, and theological despotism. Shelley scholar and editor Jeanne Moskal connects Shelley's "Cervantean touch" in the 1818 History of a Six Weeks' Tour to the "Spanish literary fashion" of the 1810s and the "matrix of political meanings" surrounding Britain's military investment in the Peninsular War. (19) Perkin Warbeck supports Moskal's reading as it carries forward Shelley's catalogue of Spain's multiple meanings into the 1820s, the so-called "ominous decade" during which, as they were in Robespierre's Reign of Terror, social critics and political liberals were rounded up, prosecuted, and executed for treason by the conservative Spanish government. Because Perkin Warbeck presents a bridge of sorts connecting distinct biographical periods in Shelley's career, this aspect of the text's political meaning is often overlooked in favor of readings focusing upon Shelley's psychobiographical transference of reading privileges from her husband to her father. However, during the 1820s and 1830s, Cervantes and the Spanish revolution played a definitive role in Mary Shelley's construction of a liberal political philosophy.
Indeed, as Moskal's reading of A Six Weeks' Tour demonstrates, as early as 1817 Shelley consciously identified herself "as one of the quixotic liberals who looked forward to the restoration of the constitution" (Moskal, 27). Shelley remained committed to Spanish political reform throughout her lifetime, and her work displays evidence consistent with a more than passing interest in the nation's multicultural history and politics. Shelley's 1837 literary history of Spain argues that Spanish unification during the fifteenth century turned Spain from a "land of romance," heroism, and tolerance into a "courageous and daring" empire of "stern and cruel spirit." (20) Poisoned by the hegemony of the Catholic Church and New World gold, "liberty of thought, as well as of action, was destroyed" and "glory, if not liberty; pride, though not independence" became modern Spain's conflicted inheritance (Lives, 26). Yet as Shelley notes in her 1826 review essay "English in Italy," though misguided, modern Spain provides a working model for popular revolution. The conflicting levels of political meaning and association are alive in Perkin Warbeck as well, where they are augmented by Shelley's explicit connection of Spain's conflicted though brilliant multicultural past to England's conflicted gender ideology and politics.
Through Perkin Warbeck, Shelley reveals the subordination of romance to the conservative forces of standard history. In so doing she dramatizes the limits of romance--especially of male-oriented chivalric romance--to bear witness to historical truth. In his Life of Chaucer, Godwin writes that "romance was the offspring of chivalry as chivalry again was the offspring of the feudal system." (21) As a sign of its feudal corruption, Shelley's last romance seems skeptical about what truths romance can claim, and what realities it can withstand. Neither clearly visceral like the Gothic nor conventionally empirical like Scott's documentary form, Shelley's romance is as glaringly absent of footnotes as it is of the supernatural. It features only two, a plug for Washington Irving's Chronicle of the Conquest of Grenada (1829) and an explanation for the novel's sympathetic portrayal of the real-life wife of Warbeck, Katherine Gordon, who appears in historical accounts as a sexual bounder and political opportunist. Because of their uniqueness, these editorial eruptions draw further attention to Spain and to historically maligned women as important symbols critical of tyranny and political oppression. Indeed, as a land at war theologically, ideologycally, and racially, Spain is a geographical mirror to English history's suppressed female influences.
Unlike her literary and historiographical predecessors, Mary Shelley spends a great deal of time outlining an imagined childhood for her hero, set in Castilian Spain at the time of the expulsion of the Moors. Breathtakingly beautiful, Spain is consistently misremembered and misrepresented by Prince Richard as a place of bucolic harmony and chivalric honor. His selective memory or perhaps inability to understand fully the ravages of Spain's religiously and racially defined civil war speaks directly to his failure to become a true and sage king in his own land. Richard's careless misreading of the Spanish characters Monina and Hernan de Faro--metaphoric and literal representations of romance--is especially noteworthy on this count as it speaks of a quixotic idealism that, as Moskal and Gary Kelly note, "became a staple of anti-Jacobin rhetoric" (Moskal, 31) during the 1790s and 1810 and gave rise to a subgenre of novels "show[ing] the Quixote figure as an impractical dupe to 'Jacobin' intriguers, conspirators, and seducers." (22)
It is worth noting at this point the footnote that accompanies Prince Richard's Spanish excursus. In the footnote, Shelley as historian-editor draws attention to the pure digressiveness of Richard's stay in Spain, and anticipates the objections of readers who wished Shelley had stayed even more strictly on the straight path. She also praises Irving's Conquest of Grenada, a work she states she would have liked to have written herself. In this way, the footnote draws attention to the core issue at the heart of the Spanish episodes: a definition of the historical romance---what it is (an intermixture of fact and fiction), why it is (to provide pleasure and moral instruction), and how it operates (in bold and prominent action)--and a comparison with Shelley's unorthodox practice. It is here that readers get a sense of Shelley's romance as an example of excess, but in a critically different way than traditionally assumed.
By drawing attention to Irving's chronicle of the Granadan wars, Shelley additionally underscores the ways in which the invented, interpolated Spanish episodes engage with a literary tradition that impedes the actual stories of Spain from being read and understood by English audiences. Consequently, the meanings of "Spain" shift confusedly from what is darkly foreign, and culturally and religiously alien to what is benign, "lovely and romantic" (FPW, 87). In such a sense, Spain thematically emerges in Shelley's text both as an analogue of literary romance and as a refraction of English readers' own imperial fantasies and anxieties. This thematic strain is extended into the story of Hernan de Faro's adoption by Spanish monks. De Faro's position trapped between two allegiances--one to blood, the other to Catholic society--forecasts Prince Richard's position as an anachronistic penitent to chivalry living in an age where chivalric mores and codes have little transcendent meaning or value. Unfortunately for all involved, it was to Spain that young Richard was sent, and there he learned to not think about the hardships of war on his people, but to consider only how to "carv[e] honor for himself with his sword" (FPW, 337). Such narrowness of ethical vision guides his behavior on the battlefields of Granada where, as a boy, he "burst on his foes, like an untrained dog, seeking only to slay," but as a man, fought with "forethought in his eye" and, in true quixotic fashion, carefully selected only "worthy and valorous opponents" (FWP, 94).
Prince Richard emerges from his adventures in Spain just as convinced of the glory of war as the innocent child he had once been. Like romance itself, he is poisoned by his aristocratic heritage and chivalric miseducation. Perhaps remembering her experiences as one of the first English travelers to witness the ravages committed by the Napoleonic campaign in 1814, Shelley strongly maintains in her 1830 romance that there is nothing chivalrous about real war. That Prince Richard fails to realize this is his central flaw: it is the key to the ruin his campaigns brought to the English people and to the ignominy associated with his name as an imposter and a fraud. A chief element of the Spanish chapters is their formation around a core antiwar rhetoric. Shelley directs readers to better understand the restorative effects of romance and to better qualify war's "manly" virtues. "It was not because they destroyed others," Shelley as narrator-historian explains, "that the warriors of old were famous for honour, courage, and fidelity; but because, from some motive springing from the unselfish part of our nature, they exposed themselves to danger and to death" (FPW, 61). In Shelley's view, there are few moral lessons to be gleaned from "details of war, descriptions of fields of battle, narrations of torture, imprisonment, and death" (61). Interestingly, in her catalogue of war's details, readers move from the grand, dehumanized landscape of battlefields to simple and intense images of the human body in pain: tortured, imprisoned, and finally, dead. Shelley uses such a pattern of description throughout the text to move readers from the impersonal rhetoric of chivalry to the immoral viciousness just underneath. Shelley asks readers to see what her hero cannot: the intellectual and spiritual falseness of chivalry. On this point, it is worth taking a moment to consider Shelley's account of the famous Battle of Alcala as a turning point for Prince Richard and for the narrative itself, and as the core of the novel's antiwar critique.
At the Battle of Alcala, Prince Richard self-identifies as Christian as well as English and in so doing underscores the devastating consequences that occur when religious and racial fervor are used to justify the atrocities of empire. Nothing could check his fury nor calm his rage, and the "battle was long and sanguinary" (91). The Moors are eventually repelled and then the surviving civilians take to the battlefield searching for the bodies of their husbands, fathers, wives, and children. Amidst the "peace of desolation" comes news that Richard's surrogate mother, Madeline, was struck down by the "savage cruelty of the enemy, as she strove to defend her daughter from impending slavery" (92). Madeline's death echoes Wollstonecraft's critique of the Eastern seraglio in the Rights of Woman, as well as Shelley's own earlier condemnation of the Eastern harem in Frankenstein's (1818) Safie episodes. Against this feminist echo is Richard's obdurate refusal to recognize death and destruction as the "gloomy lesson[s]" of war; rather, his quixotic imagination interprets the scene according to a narrow script of vengeance and honor (92). Upon seeing his "angel sister," Monina, grieve for the dead Madeline, Richard does not ruminate the toll of war but rather cries out for more, totally indoctrinated in the chivalric belief that war, murder, and mayhem turn honorable when predicated on a woman's tears: "Oh! For spring and battle, when I may avenge Monina's grief or die! Death is a thousand times preferable to the sight of her woe!" (FWP, 93).
Also in keeping with Shelley's earlier iteration of the Eastern heroine, Monina demonstrates a troubling perfidy that allows her to hear Richard's outburst, quickly forget her dead mother, and rededicate herself with fresh passion to his cause. Monina's reactions are in direct proportion to the stock melodrama of Richard's shrieks for vengeance. Both Richard's and Monina's bewitchment by honor stands in contrast with the later reactions of Katherine Gordon, the Scottish realist and fair inversion of Richard's Spanish heroine. "To the word honor," Shelley tells us, "[Katherine] had no reply. Yet it was a mere word here; in this case, a barren word, on which her life and happiness were to be wrecked" (FPW, 303). Not so with Monina, an invented figure who embodies the very essence of romance as a genre riddled with fatal "female" contradictions. "A being to worship and to love," with a "dreamy sweetness" and "a mystery in the profound sensibility of her nature," Monina is also "impetuous--wild--the slave of her own sensations" (FWP, 90). An amalgam of the spiritually light and dark, Monina has a "soft bosom" that "could harbour no emotion unallied to goodness" (90). She also, however, has the "devouring appetite" of a zealot and can speak with "syren-eloquence." Her physical presence is the "mirror of her mind," and thereby promises that she may be as dangerous as she is gentle (90).
Multicultural and multiracial, Monina, like her pirate father, Hernan de Faro, resembles an exotic figure in a conventional oriental tale. True to her role, she violently disrupts the text's gestures toward historiography proper and acts as a cog in a great romantic deus ex machina Mary Shelley employs at key moments to blend hypothesis (Perkin Warbeck really was the young Prince Richard of York) into fact (Perkin Warbeck confessed in 1499 to being a Flemish imposter). As such, she is a figure of willful agency in stark contrast with the novel's fully English and genuinely historical women. In the honor-obsessed Queen Elizabeth, the pathetic Princess Elizabeth, and the degraded Jane Shore--Edward IV's widow, daughter, and mistress--Shelley represents the distorted realities of women taught to value themselves only as commodities and to self-identify through the male acts of honor committed in their names. Unlike her English sisters, Monina, daughter of a converted Flemish Jew and a converted Moor, is able to travel without hesitation and with threatening ease from the war-torn landscape of Andalusia to the private rooms of English court. However, foreign even in her own religiously and ethnically defined Spanish context, she brings with her a sense of perpetual exile and an attendant hunger for community. Without a country, linguistically facile, newly Christian, and female, she operates in the space separating history and invention, and seems to embody Shelley's central argument with the ideological forces containing women and feminized genres as "others" even in their own domestic spheres. A devout penitent at the shrine of both Richard and Christian chivalry, she is more Catholic than the Catholics themselves and, perhaps for this reason, is reduced by the novel's end to a narrow plot beneath a defaced tomb on a Lisbon hillside. Forgotten except by those who celebrate her as Richard's most dedicated agent, she represents the innate potential of the culturally and textually marginal (for example, the dark heroine and romance) to strike back and to achieve agency through the very ideological systems designed to restrain their power and their claims to sociopolitical legitimacy.
Through Monina, Shelley's critique of chivalry extends to women; indeed, as she demonstrates in the Spanish chapters, women are as apt to be zealots of chivalric ideals as victims of those ideals. Ill-educated but well-financed women of ambition are painted as particularly dangerous in Shelley's text, a position that she holds in common with her mother and that she exemplifies in Lady Brampton, a marginal figure in traditional histories whom Shelley re-creates as a Yorkist hawk. The historical Lady Brampton was the English wife of a converted Anglo-Portuguese Jew, Duarte Brandao, alias Sir Edward Brampton. Brandao/Brampton is often pointed to by conspiracy theorists as the possible means by which the younger of the Princes of the Tower was secreted out of England. However, Brandao/Brampton denied any but the most superficial and harmless connection to Warbeck and insisted that, after traveling together briefly, they parted ways in Lisbon in 1487, four years before Warbeck would reappear as a claimant to the English throne. Though the connection between Warbeck and Sir Brampton is murky at best, we do know of Warbeck's specific connection to Brandao/Brampton's wife, Lady Brampton, for whom Warbeck acted as a page. It was with her that he traveled to Portugal, and thus it was through her that he may have made contact with Katherine Warbeck nee de Faro, the woman rumored to have assumed responsibility for the young prince's safety. (23) Despite her pivotal role as the employer of Warbeck and the one most likely to have known if he was indeed the lost prince, Lady Brampton most often appears as a footnote
within formal histories of the Warbeck conspiracy. In Shelley's tale, however, she is not only the pivotal link between Prince Richard and the Yorkist conspiracy; she is also a dangerous operative in a network of powerful female conspirators including the dowager Queen and Margaret of Burgundy. It is in Lady Brampton's frenzied battle cries that the text seems to underscore the cautions of Mary Wollstonecraft, who argues that the woman forced to exercise power solely through a male front (a son, a husband, a brother) internalizes the vices and follies of tyranny and becomes vicious.
Perkin Warbeck closes with an apologia for Katherine Gordon. Contained in the second of the novel's two footnotes, Shelley's formal intrusion as historian-editor draws attention to the singularity of her novel's ending and explains why it is necessary to have Katherine speak for herself: "I do not know how far these concluding pages may be deemed superfluous: the character of the Lady Katherine Gordon is a favourite of mine, and yet many will be inclined to censure her abode in Henry the Seventh's court, and other acts of her after life. I desired therefore that she speak for herself, and show how her conduct, subsequent to her husband's death, was in accordance with the devotion and fidelity with which she attended his fortunes during his life" (FPW, 339).
In open contrast with her historical sources, Shelley allows Katherine to speak for herself, an act of agency routinely denied women in traditional chronicles. And in speaking for herself, Katherine speaks of how an entirely conventional sexual education made her a figure to despise: "Remember I am a woman, with a woman's tutelage in my early years, a woman's education in the world, which is that of the heart--alas! for us--not of the head. I have no school-learning, no logic--but simply the voice of my own soul which speaks within me" (FPW, 398). As others have noted, Katherine's defense bears clear signs of Shelley's investment in the tenets of Wollstonecraftian feminism as well as, perhaps, an embedded autobiographical rejoinder to her own critics. Both patriarchal culture's greatest triumph and its greatest threat, Katherine's survival constitutes a form of feminine rebellion. She is exactly what her society and culture would have her be: selfless, protean, dependent, a creature who "must love and be loved" (FPW, 400). However, in actualizing society's feminine ideal she reveals the potential of that ideal to slip into a type of sexual monstrosity. Traditional history, Shelley points out, condemns Katherine Gordon for loving too many men too well, for proving that despite all efforts otherwise, a woman cannot be counted on to expire of love or to live by a romance script. It would have been easier, the imagined Katherine notes, if she had died. But she did not, and as far as society is concerned, female survival equates with a dangerous criminality, with dangerous proof that the feminine exists beyond and apart from masculine hegemony, which is itself a kind of romance, a fiction, a lie. Her will to live, radical and insuperable, defies all ideological constraints. Katherine is one of Perkin Warbeck's most potent representations of the power of feminine realism to withstand, and even counter, masculine Romantic sociopolitical ideology. With her comes a sense of Perkin Warbeck's modern feminist critique, a sense of society having rejected and defiled the woman monster it created. Yet this critique is hardly straightforward or without troubling inconsistencies. Though the text demonstrates sympathy in the abstract with women, the text reinstates violence as the means of containing marginal women (racial, ethnic, religious, or cultural outsiders). Monina and Lady Brampton, for example, remain trapped in the codes of the romance and are dead or humiliated by the novel's end. Only the Scottish heroine, who is both the "white rose" of Shelley's text and the sexually perfidious woman of proper history, escapes into the new terrain of the realistic novel.
Bennett contends that Perkin Warbeck's "operative theme is political" (Bennett, 356). More to the point, the novel is organized around ideas of imposture (political, sexual, and generic) and represents the Warbeck story in terms of characters who, caught in webs of language, busily "make" history before readers oppressively aware of what history has, in fact, made of them. As a sign of its literary hyperconsciousness, Perkin Warbeck is a text defined by rivalries (history and romance) inside rivalries (masculine and feminine) inside rivalries (English and non-English). It overtly makes present a desire for a special kind of reading activity open to the critical implications of its explicitly referenced predecessors and antagonists. In this manner, Perkin Warbeck functions as a multileveled socioliterary critique steeped not only in the nuances of its late-fifteenth-century historical subject, but also in the aesthetic and ideological inheritances informing its own production and reception. At its core, Perkin Warbeck is a text that explores how meaning happens, that reveals the mutable nature of "essential categories" (gender, race, romance, history), and that recognizes linguistic slippage over time and over genres.
Radford University
Radford, Virginia
(1.) Mary W. Shelley, The Fortunes of Perkin Warbeck, A Romance, in The Novels and Selected Works of Mary Shelley, ed. Doucet Fischer (London: Pickering & Chatto, 1996), 399. Hereafter cited parenthetically as FPW.
(2.) "Mary Shelley's 'Fortunes of Perkin Warbeck." The Edinburgh Literary Journal; Or, Weekly Register of Criticism and Belles Lettres 83 (12 June 1830): 350. Hereafter cited parenthetically as ELJ.
(3.) "Mary Shelley's 'Fortunes of Perkin Warbeck," New Monthly Magazine and Literary Journal 30.119 (November 1830): 457. Emphasis in original.
(4.) Mary W. Shelley, The Journals of Mary Shelley, ed. Paula R. Feldman and Diana Scott-Kilvert (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins UP, 1995), 553.
(5.) Ina Ferris, "Writing on the Border: The National Tale, Female Writing, and the Public Sphere," in Romanticism, History, and the Possibilities of Genre: Reforming Literature 1789-1837, ed. Tilottama Rajan and Julia M. Wright (New York: Cambridge UP, 1998), 87.
(6.) Mary Wollstonecraft, A Vindication of the Rights of Woman; with Strictures on Political and Moral Subjects, in The Vindications: The Rights of Men and the Rights of Woman by Mary Wollstonecraft, ed. D. L. Macdonald and Kathleen Scherf (1792; repr., Peterborough, Ontario: Broadview, 1997), 330. Hereafter cited parenthetically as Wollstonecraft.
(7.) Mary W. Shelley, "The English in Italy," in The Mary Shelley Reader, ed. Betty T. Bennett and Charles E. Robinson (New York: Oxford UP, 1990), 355.
(8.) Scott Simpkins, "They Do Men in Different Voices: Narrative Cross Dressing in Sand and Shelley," Style 26.3 (Fall 1992): 400.
(9.) A. A. Markley, "'The Truth in Masquerade': Cross-Dressing and Disguise in Mary Shelley's Short Stories," in Mary Shelley's Fictions: From Frankenstein to Falkner, ed. Michael Eberle-Sinatra (New York: St. Martin's P, 2000), 109-125.
(10.) Michael Eberle-Sinatra, "Gender, Authorship and Male Domination: Mary Shelley's Limited Freedom in Frankenstein and The Last Man," in Mary Shelley's Fictions, 95-108.
(11.) Betty T. Bennett, ed., The Letters of Mary Wollstonecraft Shelley, 3 vols. (Baltimore: John Hopkins UP, 1980-88), 2:6. Hereafter cited parenthetically as MWSL.
(12.) Betty T. Bennett, Mary Diana Dods: A Gentleman and a Scholar (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins UP, 1991). Hereafter cited parenthetically as Bennett.
(13.) Greg Kucich, "Mary Shelley's Lives and the Reengendering of History," in Mary Shelley in Her Times, ed. Betty T. Bennett and Stuart Curran (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins UP, 2000), 209.
(14.) William Congreve, Incognita or Love and Duty Reconciled, ed. H. F. B. Brett-Smith (Oxford: Basil Blackwell, 1922). "Romances," Congreve states, "are generally composed of the Constant loves and invincible Courages of Heros, Heroins, Kings and Queens, Mortals of the first Rank, and so forth; where lofty Language, miraculous Contingencies and impossible Performances, elevate and surprize the Reader into a giddy Delight" (5).
(15.) [Walter Scott], review of Emma, by Jane Austen, Quarterly Review 14.27 (October 1815; January 1816): 190.
(16.) Laurie Langbauer, Women and Romance: The Consolations of Gender in the English Novel (Ithaca: Cornell UP, 1990), 2.
(17.) See Tilottama Rajan, "Between Romance and History: Possibility and Contingency in Godwin, Leibniz, and Mary Shelley's Valperga," in Mary Shelley in Her Times, 88-102.
(18.) Anne K. Mellor, Mary Shelley: Her Life, Her Fiction, Her Monsters (New York: Routledge, 1988), 177-78.
(19.) Jeanne Moskal, "To Speak in Sanchean Phrase': Cervantes and the Politics of Mary Shelley's History of a Six Weeks' Tour," in Mary Shelley's Fictions, 25. Hereafter cited parenthetically as Moskal.
(20.) Mary W. Shelley, "Spanish and Portuguese Lives," in Mary Shelley's Literary Lives and Other Writings, ed. Lisa Vargo (London: Pickering & Chatto, 2002), 9, 26. Hereafter cited parenthetically as Lives.
(21.) William Godwin, Life of Geoffrey Chaucer, The Early English Poet: Including Memoirs of His Near Friend and Kinsman, John of Gaunt, Duke of Lancaster: with Sketches of the Manners, Opinions, Arts and Literature of England in the Fourteenth Century, facsimile ed., 4 vols. (1803; repr., New York: AMS P, 1974), 1:40.
(22.) Gary Kelly, The English Jacobin Novel, 1780-1805 (Oxford: Clarendon P, 1976), 146.
(23.) My accounting of Brandao/Brampton is heavily indebted to Ian Arthurson, The Perkin Warbeck Conspiracy (Gloucester: Alan Sutton, 1994).
Printer friendly
Cite/link
Email
Feedback
| |
| Author: | Garrett, Erin L. Webster |
|---|---|
| Publication: | CLIO |
| Geographic Code: | 4EUUK |
| Date: | Sep 22, 2007 |
| Words: | 7384 |
| Previous Article: | Conscience and the "gentle paines" of reform in A View of the Present State of Ireland. |
| Next Article: | Autobiography, activism, and the carceral: an analysis of the prison writing of Lady Constance Lytton. |
| Topics: | |

Printer friendly
Cite/link
Email
Feedback