The Kalhor scandal.
[ILLUSTRATION OMITTED]
Squalid dormitories, shared bathrooms and daily food rations were never part of Narges Kalhor's life--at least until mid-October. It was then that the 25-year-old Iranian filmmaker applied for political asylum in Germany, which initially required her to move into a camp near the Bavarian city of Nuremberg and to live with hundreds of other refugees from across the world. However, the worries of the young woman from a wealthy Tehran family were far greater than the discomfort of her new accommodation. Kalhor's decision was not a matter of choice: "I can't go back to Iran, my life would be in danger there," she observes.
Before being stranded with desperate refugees from countries including Iraq, Kosovo and Nigeria, Kalhor enjoyed a life most of her compatriots can only dream of, with her privileged background, a job in the media industry and the freedom to study and to devote herself to her film-making passion. But all that changed when she flew to Germany in October to attend a film festival aimed at addressing human rights issues.
There she presented her movie Darkhish, or The Rake, an adaptation of Franz Kafka's short story 'In the Penal Colony', which is about a violent machine torturing inmates in prison. Kalhor repeatedly pointed out her hope that people may see parallels between her film and the political situation in Iran. And as expected the provocative message of her work did not fail to leave its mark. Back home in Iran a scandal erupted which shook the political elite. But it has not been the movie alone causing this outrage. The scandal was compounded by the fact that Kalhor is the daughter of Mehdi Kalhor, cultural advisor and close ally of President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad.
Activism and propaganda
Kalhor claimed to have been taken by surprise when she found out that the news of her presenting a movie critical of the Iranian authorities had travelled to her homeland. However, she continues to pursue her critical activism. In a video posted on YouTube, Kalhor--wearing a green scarf, the colour of the Iranian protest movement--tells fellow film-maker Hana Makhmalbaf about her intention to support the Iranian opposition movement. In the clip Kalhor also claims to have attended the mass protests against Mahmoud Ahmadinejad after he was declared the winner of the presidential elections in June.
Kalhor's father gave the Iranian news agency his interpretation of the event. "This issue is one of the symbols of a media and the soft war that the opposition has launched," he said. According to Mehdi Kalhor, enemies of the regime are using his daughter for propaganda purposes. Meanwhile, his daughter told a German magazine she was convinced that the leadership in Tehran would not forgive her and her father would have delivered her "to the knife".
In early November the German authorities granted Kalhor a residence permit which allowed her to leave the camp. From a secret location she follows the news of protests against the regime in Tehran.
However, Mehdi Kalhor's daughter has paid a high price for freedom of expression with the loss of her family and her homeland, where the incident is interpreted by many as an example--albeit an extreme one--of the rift running not only through certain Iranian families, but through Iranian society as a whole.
Printer friendly
Cite/link
Email
Feedback
| |
| Title Annotation: | MOSAIC: Kalhor Scandal; Narges Kalhor |
|---|---|
| Author: | Keck, Reinhard |
| Publication: | The Middle East |
| Geographic Code: | 7IRAN |
| Date: | Jan 1, 2010 |
| Words: | 548 |
| Previous Article: | Taswir: pictorial mappings of Islam and modernity. |
| Next Article: | Tradition and transition. |
| Topics: | |
| First female Iranian skier all set for Olympics. |

Printer friendly
Cite/link
Email
Feedback