Critical voices: points of view in and on The Thin Red Line.
The Thin Red Line (1998) marked a return to filmmaking twenty years after Terrence Malick's previous release, Days of Heaven (1978), and thirty-five years removed from his debut film, Badlands (1973). The Thin Red Line signaled a shift to a new genre for Malick and his first away from the broad landscapes of rural, middle-Western America. In the period between his first two films and his third, a substantial body of critical literature blossomed, giving rise to certain expectations for this new project. Though Badlands and Days of Heaven displayed relatively concise narrative subjects, each garnered attention for their dense mythic underpinnings. Given these existing thematic proclivities, a film set during World War II didn't necessarily signal a significant departure for Malick. The majority of critical responses tentatively agree on the genre label for The Thin Red Line--this is a war film--as long as one understands 'war' from a variety of angles.[ILLUSTRATION OMITTED]
The film is based on James Jones' 1963 novel of the same name, and Malick's treatment comes after an earlier film version released in 1964. Some have argued, rightly I believe, that The Thin Red Line fits best in the category of post-Vietnam American film making, akin to Apocalypse Now (1979) and The Deer Hunter (1978), generally considered 'anti-war' films; compared with, say, the orthodoxy of the Good War mystique surrounding most popular World War II projects, cinematic or otherwise. (1) Additionally, Malick's personal history with philosophy, especially the work of Martin Heidegger, has become a rather popular interpretative lens during his absence from and return to filmmaking. He studied with Stanley Cavell at Harvard and as a Rhodes scholar at Oxford, though he never completed his doctoral work. A number of readings explore the film as a manifestation of Heideggerian themes on Being and mortality. (2) These are thematic readings, as none of Malick's films make any explicit, diegetic references to Heidegger or philosophy. Some writers ally the film with themes of transcendence and nature, (3) while others focus narrowly on its visual and aural patterns. (4) More conventional narrative analyses are in abundance as well, discussing the film in terms of its representation of a particular historical event (i.e. the battle of Guadalcanal). (5) Each of these contextualizing postures--thematic hallmarks, genre placement, historical record, and Malick biography--provide the basis for the dominant trends in the analyses of The Thin Red Line.
[ILLUSTRATION OMITTED]
One of the intriguing aspects of the film is better represented in the criticism than in a simple recounting of the plot (or even a casual viewing). It's a quality that arises through a careful survey of the sundry articles, essays, chapters and books on the film. These analyses don't serve merely to illuminate some picture of the film, though they certainly accomplish that in the outstanding cases; they also mirror a perplexing quality imbedded in the mise-en-scene. This is perhaps most evident in terms of one notorious filmic device: the voiceover. In broader terms, the issue of voiceover in Malick connects to point of view, which is vitally important in The Thin Red Line, though also in the war film genre as a whole. It is particularly central in terms of a fundamental ambiguity common to many of film history's exemplary cases. (6)
[ILLUSTRATION OMITTED]
The Thin Red Line is such an exemplary case, on all accounts. There are, on the one hand, points of view internal to the film, expressed through character and voiceover. That these are slippery and difficult to pin down is fairly uncontroversial. On the other hand, there is the more problematic issue of the film's point of view. There is a basic tension between the plurality and divergence of points of view in the film and Malick's elusive presentation of them, notably, through voiceover, which the literature on the film somewhat unwittingly embodies and reflects. Such confusion and subtlety presents a challenging interpretive obstacle, making it difficult to cohesively evaluate the extent of the film's dense, often conflicting thematic manifestations, be it Heideggerian, religious, political, historical or otherwise. A meta-narrative analysis of the voiceovers in the film will demonstrate the ways in which they exhibit a variety of thematic points of view while simultaneously inviting confusion as to their more general purpose. After this picture becomes clearer, some of the film's other devices, which operate on a similarly ambiguous plane, will come together to illustrate Malick's tenuous relationship with genre conventions and style.
Voices and Voiceovers
There is a curious and telling fact about the critical responses to The Thin Red Line and its voiceovers. Take, for example, this passage from Forms of Being: Cinema, Aesthetics, Subjectivity by Leo Bersani and Ulysse Dutoit, discussing the film's final moments:
The voice we hear is that of Witt, who has been killed. It is as if he were speaking for all the other men, and also as if his being able to do so didn't depend on his being alive ... These complex final moments encapsulate the work of the entire film. (7)
If these moments do in fact encapsulate the entire film, and the Witt voiceover is crucial to that account, then Bersani and Dutoit have a potentially serious problem. The voice is not Witt's, played by Jim Caviezel. There are a couple ways one can go about explaining this. The DVD subtitles provide the first clue, which attribute the voiceover to Train (John Dee Smith), another soldier. However, the subtitles lack consistency, crediting near identical sounding voiceovers to different characters at different points. Another proof requires a less scientific strategy, admittedly, but worth considering: listen closely to both characters, ignoring what comes on screen, and it seems fairly clear the voice comes from Train, not Witt. Various editions of the screenplay give no indication as to who might be speaking in those dying moments, which leaves the question open. Anecdotal evidence indicates that Malick recorded most of the voiceovers in post production, (8) somewhat unbeknownst to many of the film's cast and crew. (9) Looking through the relatively extensive academic essays written on the film, as well as any number of popular critical responses, it seems that Bersani and Dutoit are not alone on this issue. Here runs a short-list of the conflicting and questionable attributions found in the literature on Malick's film:
They walk through the trees, Witt's inner voice invoking nature: 'Who are you, to live in all that many forms?' (10) As Charlie company leave Guadalcanal and are taken back to their ship on a landing craft, we hear the final voiceover from Witt, this time from beyond the grave: "Oh my soul, let me be in you now. Look out through my eyes, look out at the things you made, all things shining." (11) It seems clear[...] that at least the majority of them [the voiceovers] are attributable to Witt. (12) "Does our ruin benefit the earth, aid the grass to grow, and the sun to shine? Is this darkness in you too? Have you passed through this night?" asks Witt after the taking of Hill 210. (13) As the camera follows Welsh looking after his men in the lush green twilight, a voiceover--not Welsh's but Witt's--comments on the subjectivity of all human vision: "One man looks at a dying bird and hinks there's nothing but unanswered pain. Another man sees that same bird and feels the glory." (14) "What is this war in nature?" is the first sentence we hear, murmured earnestly by the AWOL soldier Witt at the start of the film. (15) 'What's this war in the heart of nature?' asks Private Witt in the first narration of The Thin Red Line. (16) We hear his [Witt's] voice-over a few minute later, and he has become the transparent eyeball: "O My Soul, let me be in you now. Look out through my eyes. Look out at the things you made. All things shining.' (17) "This great evil, where did it come from?" Wit [sic] asks. (18) Welsh's assertions are confounded by Witt's questions: 'What is this war in the heart of nature?' 'Where does this evil come from?' (19) At the beginning of the film, Witt in voice-over asks, 'What's this war at the heart of nature?' (20)
Looking through these references and others, one point of consensus seems to arise: many of the voiceovers belong to the same character, whoever that may be, although, like many aspects of the film, there are exceptions to this rule. Some analyses build their entire reading of the film around the assumption that certain voiceovers belong to Witt. A few writers acknowledge the difficulty of correctly attributing the voiceovers then make loose conclusions, or fail to question why the link between speech and speaker is so difficult to identify.
[ILLUSTRATION OMITTED]
David Davies comes close to evaluating this aspect of the film. The quote from Davies listed above comes at the end of a section in which he discusses the ambiguity, "Some voiceovers are difficult to attribute because the cues that serve us well in other cases lead here to conflicting attributions." (21) It is not clear whether Davies means the cues from other films or cues from other parts of The Thin Red Line. He goes on to give an example in which a voiceover seems to belong to Witt "given its content" yet plays over shots of Welsh (Sean Penn), Witt's superior. (22) The qualification 'given its content' suggests he believes previous voiceovers belong to Witt, that previous instances were obvious, that one can safely guess what sort of things Witt would say at this stage. Needless to say, I'm skeptical such clarity is evident at this stage, or possibly any.
In a book dedicated to Malick and his films, Lloyd Michaels makes even more curious claims. At one point he ascribes a Train voiceover to Private Bell (Ben Chaplin) almost solely based on the convention that voiceovers belong to the character most prevalent on screen, a convention Michaels admits Malick frequently disregards. (23) Remarkably, this same voiceover others attribute to Witt. (24) In another instance, Michaels determines "after several viewings" that the final voiceover belongs to Witt. (25) He never provides any contextual explanation, that is, why it makes sense in terms of the film as a whole.
Looking at the first five minutes of the film closely, one might start to wonder how such widespread confusion came about. There are two voiceovers in that span, which constitute the only clear speech. Given the proximity of these moments, it ought to be somewhat clear whether or not each voiceover came from the same person. The first voiceover plays invisibly over footage of trees and plants, a voice pondering 'this war in the heart of nature' and similar, philosophic sounding ideas. The delivery of these first lines is clear and at the center of the film's focus, leaving a firm impression of the voice not just in terms of content, but in terms of rhythm and intonation and so forth. The next clearly audible speech also begins in voiceover, but, just a few seconds later, Malick reveals a character delivering the speech--Witt. Ignoring the fact that the subtitles, even at this early stage, identify Train as the first speaker, any suspicion of difference between the first speaker and the second should demand an admission of uncertainty, a sign to pay close attention to this ambiguous system of reference. Yet, across a sizeable body of critics coming from multiple backgrounds and with varying agendas, none suggest that Train might be the speaker of these opening lines and few investigate the ambiguity as an integrated device of the film's content. The question then, is whether these writers have failed to look at the film with sufficient attention or if the film intentionally invites such confusion.
[ILLUSTRATION OMITTED]
Numerous writers insist that the film defies genre norms and classical narrative structure (26)--a good indication not to trust its apparent conventions regarding voiceover--but still go on to analyze the film with the same critical posture. Many of these same writers refer to Malick's previous two films and their unconventional use of voiceover; voiceovers that, on first glance, have the sound and feel of traditional voiceover but perform an alternative function when viewed in the context of the film as a whole. (27) Despite some clear differences between the voiceovers in Malick's first films and his third--the voices come from multiple characters, primarily men instead of women--there still seems to be a fundamental similarity in their lack of plot-narrative function.
[ILLUSTRATION OMITTED]
Ultimately, I do not wish to discuss the voiceovers in the film strictly in terms of their isolated content, or even voiceover in general terms. However, there is something emblematic and illuminating that comes out of pairing the critical responses with similarly constructed devices in the film. Indeed, the plenitude of misattributions inadvertently brings to light one of the more fundamental qualities of the film: the ambiguity, plurality, and equality of points of view, narratively, thematically, and critically. It is not a coincidence that across such a wide body of literature on The Thin Red Line, only a couple of sources definitively object to the 'Witt voiceovers'. Amy Copland's essay, Form and Feeling, provides one such contention. She includes the following footnote with regard to the film's first voiceover: "The voice is not actually Jim Caviezel's (Sandhya Shardanand, assistant to Terrence Malick, private communication)." (28) Her footnote comes with the conclusion that "the filmmakers intended viewers to attribute the voiceover to Witt." (29) This claim stands by itself, however, buried in footnotes without any substantial critical links to the rest of her analysis. Equally important, however, if this voice from the opening monologue is the same voice so many ally with Witt in the rest of the film, and that voice is not Jim Caviezel's, then none of the other voiceovers necessarily belong to Witt, either.
Missing from the opening list of misattributed voiceovers is a different kind of misattribution, this time a misattribution of character. In his summary of the film, Michel Chion refers to an earlier section of his own essay, stating, "Gaff talks about his youth, his experience of the worst." (30) The character that actually states these lines is Private Train (Smith), not Gaff, played by John Cusack, a popular and generally recognizable actor. Besides the fact that Gaff is not present at the end of the film, and the fact that Cusack and Smith bear little resemblance to one another, consider Chion's summary of the film as a whole. Chion never mentions Train in his entire book, or Gaff apart from this singular instance, even though both occupy relatively similar narrative space (more than many of the film's so-called 'stars', in fact). This speaks not only to the narrowness of Chion's analysis, centering primarily on just two characters (Witt and Welsh) in a film notoriously slippery in its focus on any one individual, but to a larger and more worrying trend.
[ILLUSTRATION OMITTED]
In a review of Chion's book, Ian-Malcolm Rijsdijk points out the Gaff-Train confusion, while also raising a lone voice of concern over the attribution of the film's final voiceover:
It is a critical commonplace (which Chion follows) that the final voiceover in the film is spoken entirely by Witt. However this has always troubled me as much aurally as interpretatively: why do viewers automatically assume it is Witt, and what in the film supports such an assumption? (31)
Rijsdijk starts to discuss Train and how he fits into this scene, but then takes an equally bizarre turn by dividing the final voiceover between Witt and a third character, Doll. Though he concedes to the ambiguity of the voiceovers--"The possibility that Doll's voice is present in the final voiceover is only that, a possibility"--Rijsdijk never fully addresses the issue as a reflection of the film's content; instead, he points out another questionable voiceover ascription from Chion and moves on. (32)
[ILLUSTRATION OMITTED]
Train occupies a much more central role than most critics, not just Chion and Rijsdijk, seem to have noticed. Not only do most analyses fail to identify Train as the source of various key voiceovers, but they fail to mention him at all, Rijsdijk notwithstanding. With shorter reviews of the film, like those found in newspapers and periodicals, it seems somewhat understandable that an unfamiliar, second tier cast member could go without recognition. In Anthony Lane's review of the film originally published in The New Yorker, he mentions most of the principle cast, but also a list of actors (not necessarily their characters, incidentally) with fewer lines and screen time than Train: John C. Reilly, George Clooney, and John Travolta; even Elias Koteas' Captain Staros, arguably the character with the most lines and narrative focus of any character in the film, receives no mention at all. Longer analyses of the film fall victim to the same compartmentalized critical gesturing. (33) Bersani and Dutoit's rather substantial chapter on Malick's film never mentions Train, either, and, similarly, still manages to make note of Clooney and Travolta. The curious fact here is not the lack of attention on Train, or the excessive focus on Witt, or even the casual mentioning of Hollywood heavyweights delivering just enough lines to warrant space on the promotional material; rather, the issue is that so many of these analyses build the core of their interpretations around a particular image of Witt, an image largely conceived on the assumption that certain voiceovers are Witt's.
How has Train been so universally ignored? In some ways, his role possesses a purposely invisible quality, like that of a Gospel witness, which partially explains why so many miss his impact on the film, the focus being drawn to that which he attests: namely, Witt. That Witt represents a sort of Christ figure is evident in a number of details: the sacrificial, ritualized nature of his death, his insistence on the reality of 'another world', and his primacy in catalyzing the plot. Train's invisibility also suggests a device common to the genre: the faceless and unremarkable conflation of human individuals in the chaos of war, occasionally at the expense of arbitrary and unwarranted hero worship (think, the critical focus on the visible, major stars/characters over lesser ones).
The confusion over voiceovers rarely surfaces in analyses of the film as an intentional strategy. My basic argument is that the voice-overs technically belong to Train, though such a reading need not necessarily be the case. That is, the tacit assumption that Witt delivers the bulk of the voiceovers is a poor one, and it would have to be demonstrated more rigorously. In a similar sense, the variety of thematic readings of the film do not necessarily stand in mutual exclusion, though they do when taken at face value. The broader point to be drawn is that the film encourages dramatically different readings with relative ease without ever fully endorsing one, presenting a range of ideas within the narrative, as well as in its broad and often conflicting allusions. Davies discusses this tension, picking up on the "astonishing diversity of readings," (34) but he uses this primarily as a starting point for his own, bounded analysis rather than one exploring the reasons for such diversity as principally significant. On its own, falsely attributing voiceovers is a minor incident. To substantiate the charge of misattributed voiceovers and their subservience to a more elusive strategy, other elements of the film would need to show similar complexities, embracing points of view while undermining them.
Genre Conventions
One way in which the film creates confusion is its simultaneous denial and embrace of genre conventions. Some analyses hail The Thin Red Line's unparalleled realism in presenting the horrors of war, while others heavily criticize its narrative meandering and pseudo-philosophic musings. There are just enough elements of convention to bait those looking for something of the historical or 'objective', but its subtle subversiveness can also frustrate those same critics. On the flip side, those critics looking at the film purely in terms of its philosophic and Heideggerian illustrations seem to lack cohesiveness in their evaluation of the film, having denied or ignored some of the most basic facts about it. In the context of his own Heideggerian reading, Robert Sinnerbrink summarizes a potential drawback of this approach actualized in a similarly aimed essay, "What recedes from view in this reading is the film as a film, the detail of its narrative structure, the significance of its characters and their situation, the complexity of its sound and imagery." (35)
In that first category of historical readings, there are reviews like Tom Whalen's, another perpetrator of misattributed voiceover: "What keeps us from reaching out and touching the glory?' wonders Witt. Well, in the narrative context the answer might be that we'd get a finger shot off." (36) Whalen generally bemoans the film's ponderous tone and fixation on nature as a betrayal of the realities of the war. Nicholas Cull approaches the film from a similar, historically minded perspective, but arrives at opposite conclusions: "Death and life, honor and ignominy are apportioned at random, with no regard to a character's moral worth or military prowess. Malick's vision offers a realism more profound than the pyrotechnics of Stephen Spielberg's Saving Private Ryan" (37)--more on that film shortly.
The film does portray one major action sequence with gritty realism, tragedy, and loss--those established genre trademarks. However, this key battle scene finishes half-way through the film's nearly three hour run time, dispelling its climactic power. Martin Flanagan analyzes this battle scene, describing a few ways in which Malick acknowledges the conventions of a war film action sequence while subverting them at the same time:
It could be argued that this is the peak of the movie's appeal to formal and generic convention. Yet, the sequence does not make for comfortable or obvious viewing. Audience identification is complicated by the fact that the assault is led by John Cusack's Captain Gaff, a recognizable star but a character who seems to appear from nowhere to take us through the highlight of the movie. Malick, contrary as ever, seems to want to simultaneously disavow and celebrate the presence of star names throughout (...) Furthermore, the withholding of a master shot of the objective means that the spatial relationships of the scene are never fully clarified for the audience, a strategy that mirrors Malick's more general refusal to map out the territory of his narrative according to the codes of the war movie. However, more traditional techniques like slow motion, point of view shots and rapid cutting do gradually come to feature in the scene, establishing a degree of formal affinity with the war film. (38)
Flanagan rather perceptively points out exactly the predicament in which Malick places a critic. There are two sides to every coin and neither necessarily trumps the other. For every identifiable star, there is a non-star; or, for every star, there is an untimely death (Woody Harrelson), negligible screen time (Travolta), or a bizarrely timed entrance and exit (Cusack, Clooney). Michaels makes similar observations about genre conventions in relating the film to its World War II twin released the same year, Steven Spielberg's Saving Private Ryan (1998):
With its avoidance of the established generic tropes of the war film, multiple voiceovers, elliptical editing, metaphysical musings, and prolonged denouement, Malick's film seemed opaque compared to Spielberg's classical narrative and patriotic appeal to cultural memory. (39)
[ILLUSTRATION OMITTED]
Flanagan and Michaels both demonstrate ways in which Malick strays from genre norms, but never so far as to completely dismiss them, at least providing enough plot and simple narrative coherency to keep the film grounded in basic events.
The music in the film also runs across a spectrum of classifications. On the one hand, the Melanesians that help open the film sing simple hymns with no musical accompaniment. The score, on the other hand, utilizes a variety of modern and classical techniques, often registering only a low, hypnotic tone that sounds both organic and industrial. Morrison and Schur analyze two of the more obscure musical sources in Malick's films, including a cult recording used in The Thin Red Line:
"Cosmic Beam Experience" is an album that features four long compositions and one short one, all relatively indistinguishable in a wash of orchestral proto-New Age music, with titles like "Heal Yourself" and "Love Sweet Love." The specter of transcendental meditation, it is not too much to suggest, hovers over both Syntonic Research and the Cosmic Beam Experience. What they signify in Malick's work is that quality of inclusiveness that returns to a central theme. (40)
Somewhere in between the Melanesian hymns and the 'proto-New Age' music lies pieces of borrowed or quoted classical compositions, like Gabriel Faure's Requiem. Chion and Davies both discuss the implementation of Charles Ives' The Unanswered Question into the score, as well. (41) Finally, at the film's close, as the credits roll, Malick reintroduces the Melanesian choir but supplements the singing with the Hans Zimmer score, blending the film's most simple musical form with its most complex.
The presentation of nature in the film also embraces multiple points of view, another fact reflected in the literature. Malick presents resplendent images of nature in each of his films, but the effect has never been more divisive than with The Thin Red Line. Chion argues that the images of nature in The Thin Red Line are not presented symbolically or as counterpoint, "Malick does not contrast a good, peaceful nature with human beings who sully and profane it with their murders." (42) For Chion, Malick foregrounds nature and integrates it into the same narrative space as the human action. This angle seems at odds with the view taken by Ron Mottram, "Malick's use of nature and natural beauty rises to the level of a powerful sign for a higher good." (43) Where Chion resists reading nature symbolically or ideally, Mottram links Malick's film to Thoreau's "transcendental vision of nature as a link to a deeper reality," (44) The merits of both arguments aside, it seems surprising that such divergent analyses belong to the same film, and these are just two of the numerous critical angles taken up.
This tensional relationship to genre standards, music, and nature functions on a largely interpretive level, but Malick also consistently plays the same paradoxical game with specific moments within the diegesis. He mixes the high with the low, the ordinary with the extraordinary, the regular with the irregular. Aboard the military ship early in the film, as soldiers variously express their fears and skepticism in the sloppy grammar of lower class America, Malick cuts to a soldier playing the violin. The film's score plays uninterrupted over this shot, muting whatever music might be coming from the violin and providing continuity with the next image of a soldier shaving down a piece of wood, carving a makeshift knife. The second shot begins as a medium close-up, obscuring the piece of wood and the knife used to shape its blade. The gesture of the carving, the movement of the arms and the focus of the eyes, lends both activities a similar rhythmic quality. The violinist's bow is the soldier's knife, and the violin the sculpted piece of wood. By delaying the reveal, Malick elevates each act onto a similar plane, blurring the line between the sophistication of a classical instrument with the brutal reality of a combat weapon.
[ILLUSTRATION OMITTED]
This sort of repetition and variation occurs throughout the film with objects, imagery, and sounds, placing objects in relation to one another in such a way as to strip them of singular values and meaning. The crocodile from the opening shot, for instance, also slips into the film later on. Casting doubt on its initial suggestiveness, Michaels comments, "Even the status of the crocodile as a significant symbol is deliberately called into question when, away from the line, the victorious GIs celebrate the capture of a far less threatening crocodile displayed on the back of an army truck." (45) In a more sweeping gesture, Kenneth Turan succinctly illustrates the level of ambiguity Malick elicits, "From its unnerving opening look at a crocodile floating half above and half below a surface of green slime, 'Thin Red Line' has a tendency toward shots that might be metaphorical but then again might not." (46)
With regard to character types, Malick again embraces outwardly conflicting points of view. Although many characters never receive enough screen time to display a great deal of depth or development, they do convey some rather provocative complexities. Nick Nolte's Lt. Col. Tall appears to be a stock man-in-charge, hell-bent on victory. However, Tall delivers moments of reflection rare for a man of his type. On the morning of a key battle, Tall reminisces about his days at the Point when he read Homer (in Greek), quoting a line about the 'rosy-fingered dawn' (in Greek) while admiring the morning twilight. Tall's counterpoint in the film, Captain Staros, refuses to blindly throw his men into the line of fire and effectively ensure their deaths. His character is very much a moral and intellectual center of the film; he is educated, compassionate, and principled. Yet, his character also falls to his knees in prayer, searching for guidance through faith in some incorporeal presence. His faith could easily come across as superstitious, or as Kaja Silverman derisively describes it, a call to an extraterrestrial void. (47) As an unexpected facet of a character carrying so much moral weight, however, more flattering interpretations are just as viable.
In each of these elements, genre convention, imagery, music, and character, Malick adds a subtle ambiguity that invites confusion and, more importantly, contemplation. Indeed, the film begs a lot of questions, literally and figuratively. The final five minutes embody this point as well as any sequence. A final voiceover begins immediately after Train finishes speaking and over a shot void of focus on a particular character:
Where is it that we were together? Who were you that I lived with, walked with? The brother. The friend. Darkness, light. Strife and love. Are they the workings of one mind? The features of the same face? Oh, my soul. Let me be in you now. Look out through my eyes. Look out at the things you made. All things shining.
During the reading of this final monologue, only two previously identified characters appear, Private Doll (Dash Mihok) and Sergeant Welsh, with Doll receiving the most screen time. He looks out at the sea from the ship's stern, though not obviously in the same direction as the following shot. As the voiceover shifts to more abstract proclamations--"Oh, my soul, let me be in you now"--the view shifts to a direct shot overlooking
the water, only ocean, land, and the ship's wake visible. Surprisingly, only one writer attributes this voiceover to Doll, and even then, it's split between Witt and Doll. (48) Though the words convey something buoyantly reverent taken out of context, the music has the same mysterious, severe tone from the opening shot. The content of the voiceover gradually becomes more and more perplexing, just as the deliverer of the voiceover becomes less and less attributable to anything on screen. Who is this speaker? Who is he addressing? Talking about these same lines, Bersani and Dutoit conclude, "There can be no answers to these questions." (49) They effectively extrapolate this conclusion to all of the questions asked in the film. Each character seems to represent one way of answering these questions, whether through Witt's pseudo-Christian transcendentalism or Welsh's pessimistic realism. Perhaps more accurately, and more fundamentally, Michaels observes, "Although the film raises questions and examines points of view, it does not attempt to provide definitive answers." (50) Just actions require definitive explanations, a definitive point of view. As a war film, this has a particular effect, as if all conflict arises out of an unnecessarily hasty drive toward rigorously fixed points of view. Malick consistently encapsulates and includes things together--lightness and dark, the high and the low, the real and the surreal, the historical and the mythic--which partially dispels an obvious moral code in the film.
Significantly, the film does not end on the shot overlooking the ocean, its corresponding monologue, and dreary musical tone. All fade out. Malick shows three subsequent shots: three Melanesians paddling down a river, two birds of paradise, and a solitary plant sprouting from a round, unidentifiable object sitting along the watery banks of a beach. The only dominant sounds are that of wind and moving water. The final word is not given to any one character, but to the world itself in all its variance, in its remission. This puts some emphasis on the inability of speech to provide concise conclusions, allowing the sounds and images of the natural world and its Edenic form to take over--a possible return to paradise but an ultimately inconclusive one.
Referencing an article by Bill Schaffer, Robert Silberman comments that point of view is everything in war and, accordingly, in war films (51). Silberman further notes that Malick's film and its closing moments "provide an unmediated, nonverbal argument for the radiant splendor of the world and the victory of a faith in spirit, although that does not necessarily answer the fundamental questions that haunt the film," (52) Here again, a writer epitomizes the difficulty of proclaiming anything too definitively, recognizing the mystifying ambiguity of the film while still trying to pin down something fixed and sure.
Yvette Biro picks up on a thread from Cilles Deleuze that beautifully mirrors this relationship between the literature on The Thin Red Line and a specific quality in it:
Deleuze analyzes how perception relies on elliptical, drifting, and fundamentally weak relationships that transform the narrative, and he concludes that intensity lies in the gaze of the protagonists. They, and through them the viewers, invest objects with meaning, emotional content, and the need to understand the world opening before them. (53)
Malick's film provides multiple characters and objects of attention, drifting in and out of the narrative without a singular focus, an elliptical rhythmic patterning. He frequently deploys medium close-ups of his characters, sitting on a spectrum of gazes offered by those massed together in war, then closes his film without any speech, and without any gaze. There is a need to understand the world opening before us, and Malick provides a plethora of gazes to choose from, and a correspondingly disparate range of voiceovers, then, in its closing shots, none--only a world projected on screen, all things shining. The only sure things are invisible to us, hidden beneath a murky cloak of human action and speech.
Notes
(1) John Streamas, "The Greatest Generation Steps Over The Thin Red Line," in The Cinema of Terrence Malick: Poetic Visions of America (Directors' Cuts), ed. Hannah Patterson (New York: Wallflower Press, 2004): 137-147.
(2) See Robert Clewis, "Heideggerian Wonder in Terrence Malick's The Thin Red Line," Film and Philosophy 7 (2003): 22-36; Simon Critchley, "Calm--On Terrence Malick's The Thin Red Line," in The Thin Red Line (Philosophers on Film), ed. David Davies (Abingdon: Routledge, 2009): 11-27; Hubert Dreyfus and Camilo Salazar Prince, "The Thin Red Line: Dying Without Demise, Demise Without Dying," in Davies., 29-43; Marc Furstenau and Leslie MacAvoy, "Terrence Malick's Heideggerian Cinema: War and the Question of Being in The Thin Red Line," in Patterson, 173-185; Kaja Silverman, "All Things Shining," in Loss: the Politics of Mourning, ed. David L. Eng and David Kazanjian (Berkeley: University of California P, 2003): 323-42; Robert Sinnerbrink, "A Heideggerian Cinema?: On Terrence Malick's The Thin Red Line," Film-Philosophy 10 (2006): 26-37.
(3) See Michel Chion, The Thin Red Line (Bfi Modern Classics) (Annapolis: British Film Institute, 2004); Lloyd Michaels, Terrence Malick (Contemporary Film Directors) (Urbana: University of Illinois P, 2009); Ron Mottram, "All Things Shining: The Struggle for Wholeness, Redemption and Transcendence in the Films of Terrence Malick," in Patterson, 13-23; Stacey Peebles-Power, "The Other World of War: Terrence Malick's Adaptation of The Thin Red Line," in Patterson, 148-159.
(4) See Leo Bersani and Ulysse Dutoit, Forms of Being: Cinema, Aesthetics, Subjectivity (Annapolis: British Film Institute, 2004); Amy Copland, "Form and Feeling in Terrence Malick's The Thin Red Line," in Davies, 65-86; David Davies, "Vision, Touch, and Embodiment in The Thin Red Line," in Davies, 45-64; James Wierzbicki, "Sound as Music in the Films of Terrence Malick," in Patterson, 110-122.
(5) See Martin Flanagan, "'Everything a Lie': The Critical and Commercial Reception of Terrence Malick's The Thin Red Line," in Patterson, 123-136; Streamas, 137-147; Tom Whalen, "'Maybe all men got one big soul': Hoax Within the Metaphysics of Terrence Malick's The Thin Red Line," Literature-Film Quarterly 27 (1999): 162-66.
(6) See George Wilson, Narration in Light: Studies in Cinematic Point of View (New York: The Johns Hopkins UP, 1988).
(7) Bersani and Dutoit, 135.
(8) Davies, 58.
(9) James Morrison and Thomas Schur, The Films of Terrence Malick (New York: Praeger, 2003): 85.
(10) Chion, 76.
(11) Critchley, 26.
(12) Davis, 59.
(13) Dreyfus and Prince, 40.
(14) Michaels, 76.
(15) Morrison and Schur, 26.
(16) Mottram, 15.
(17) Peebles-Power, 154.
(18) Silverman, 33.
(19) Sinnerbrink, 32.
(20) Streamas, 139.
(21) Davies, 58.
(22) Davies, 58.
(23) Michaels, 69.
(24) See Chion, 76.
(25) Michaels, 73.
(26) See Copland, 70; Michaels, 63-65; Flanagan, 1 30-135.
(27) See Chion 53-54; Morrison and Schur 34-38.
(28) Copland, 85.
(29) Ibid., 85.
(30) Chion, 86.
(31) Ian-Malcolm Rijsdijk, "Apprehending Beauty: Michel Chion on Terrence Malick's The Thin Red Line," Film-Philosophy 10 (2006): 50.
(32) Ibid., 51-52.
(33) Anthony Lane, Nobody's Perfect: Writings from the New Yorker (Great Britain: Picador, 2002): 269.
(34) Davies, 46.
(35) Sinnerbrink, 30.
(36) Whalen, 163.
(37) Nicholas J. Cull, "Review: [untitled]," The American Historical Review 104(1999): 1050.
(38) Flannagan, 132.
(39) Michaels, 18.
(40) Morrison and Schur, 83.
(41) Chion, 9-14; Davies, 49.
(42) Chion, 41.
(43) Mottram, 15.
(44) Ibid., 15.
(45) Michaels, 76.
(46) Kenneth Turan, "'Red Line': A Distant Epic," LA Times Calendar Live, http://www.calendarlive.com/movies/reviews/cl-movie981 223-3,0,5219708.story.
(47) Silverman, 329.
(48) Rijsdijk 51.
(49) Bersani and Dutoit, 170.
(50) Michaels, 23.
(51) Silberman, 166.
(52) Ibid., 170.
(53) Yvette Biro, Turbulence and Flow in Film: The Rhythmic Design, trans. Paul Salamon (New York: Indiana UP, 2009).
Jeremy Millington is a PhD student in philosophy at Temple University. He completed his MSt in Film Aesthetics at the University of Oxford.
Printer friendly
Cite/link
Email
Feedback
| |
| Author: | Millington, Jeremy |
|---|---|
| Publication: | CineAction |
| Geographic Code: | 1CANA |
| Date: | Jun 22, 2010 |
| Words: | 6414 |
| Previous Article: | Refiguring Rambo: competing imperatives in the high concept war film. |
| Next Article: | Representing the human condition in the Great War: William Boyd's the New Confessions and the Trench. |
| Topics: | |

Printer friendly
Cite/link
Email
Feedback