Watching rights.
In Prague a couple of weeks ago, a high-level official in the Havel government who had been a leading dissenter when the Communists held power told me that he had attended a recent reunion of former Charter 77 spokespersons. For each year since 1977, when the charter was promulgated, three people, representing the different tendencies among the signers, have been chosen as spokespersons, a method of representation exemplifying the movement's commitment to pluralism and repudiation of cults of personality, even among dissenters. At the reunion these longtime advocates of human rights (and, in most cases, victims of abuse as well) discussed whether there is a common characteristic of human rights abuses in post-Communist Europe.It is a sad commentary on developments in the region that this question has begun to preoccupy some architects of the revolutions of the past three years. In Romania the authorities have tolerated, and sometimes encouraged, pogroms against gypsy communities, and in the former East Germany they have turned a blind eye to skinhead attacks on foreigners. In Latvia a new law deprives many residents who are not ethnic Latvians of their citizenship. In Czechoslovakia and Germany--and perhaps also soon in Bulgaria, where a law seems on its way to adoption--hundreds of thousands of people associated with the previous Communist regimes are barred, without regard to their individual actions and circumstances, from employment as teachers, journalists or many other responsible positions. Only President Arpad Goncz's refusal to sign legislation in Hungary and the Constitutional Court's ultimate rejection of it prevented a similar ban in yet another Eastern European state.
Worst of all, of course, in terms of suffering, are the wars being fought along tribal lines in the former Yugoslavia and the former Soviet Union. As we have come to expect from such conflicts, the wars between the Croats and the Serbs, the South Ossetians and the Georgians, and the Armenians and the Azerbaijanis are marked by horrifying crimes against non-combatants, who make up by far the greatest number of victims of the killings.
In all these violations of rights the common denominator is the demand for purification of the society. Those who are thought to sully that purity--ethnically, linguistically or politically--are blamed for every imaginable ill, whether it be the relatively novel phenomenon of crime in the streets or economic hardship or subversion. Someone must be held to blame for the failure of the revolutions of 1989 to 1991 to produce instant prosperity and happiness.
It is not only in post-Communist Europe that the demand for purification has become a dominant factor in abuses of human rights. There is the growing power of religious fundamentalism in several countries with large Islamic populations and attendant campaigns against alleged infidels and apostates; there are the escalating attempts by Israel to drive out Palestinians from Jerusalem and from the territories, which are referred to by their biblical names of Samaria and Judea; there are the rising xenophobic attacks on foreigners in several countries of Western Europe, and the continuing political climb of Jean-Marie Le Pen in France; and here at home there is the phenomenon of David Duke and Patrick Buchanan. It seems apparent that the manner in which the Bush Administration has dealt with the Haitian boat people reflects apprehension that a more generous response would have aided Bush's Republican challengers. Everywhere, whether in government office or not, the apostles of racial, religious and political purification seem to be shaping public policy, to the detriment of human rights.
An irony for post-Communist Europe is that the drive to adopt prohibitions against those associated with the former regimes is often championed most vehemently by those who were silent while those regimes held power. In Czechoslovakia, an Anti-Communist Alliance, which has been publishing lists of alleged collaborators, began its fight with the Communists about a year after the end of Communism there. (The Czechoslovak Foreign Minister, Jiri Dienstbier, told me that his ministry had been accused of harboring fifty-six spies; he seemed amused when I pointed out that the number was virtually identical to one of Senator Joseph McCarthy's charges about Communists in the State Department.)
Just before going to Prague, I attended a meeting in Salzburg, Austria, that brought together Europeans and Latin Americans concerned about the transition from authoritarian systems. There the most eloquent and outspoken defenders of the civil liberties of their former persecutors were the Eastern European dissenters who were never cowed into silence. The Polish essayists Adam Michnik and Kostek Gebert, the Hungarian philosopher Gyorgy Bence, the Czechoslovak journalist Jan Urban and the Russian parliamentarian and former long-term political prisoner Sergei Kovalyov all spoke out strongly against efforts to ascribe collective guilt to those associated with the previous regimes and to reverse the presumption of innocence ("revolutionary justice" in Bence's scornful characterization). Unhappily, the moral authority that such persons ought to enjoy has not always sufficed to prevent the enactment of "lustration" laws and other purification measures [see "Watching Rights," January 6/13].
In Prague, together with my colleague Jeri Laber of Helsinki Watch, I also spoke briefly with President Havel. We met in a room of the castle, surrounded by portraits of assorted Habsburgs who had been previous tenants of that edifice. If there were any physical traces of the Communists who had occupied the building for four decades, they escaped my notice. Havel began the meeting by recalling the days when his contacts with Laber in Prague had been arranged clandestinely and could be interrupted at any point by the police, and concluded by expressing eagerness to listen to international human rights critics. Those comments were effective reminders that in Eastern Europe today the opportunity to discuss openly the failings of governments there makes a vast difference. Those within the region who are taking advantage of that opportunity to denounce adventures in revolutionary justice and other purification measures are truly helping to keep alive the hopes that inspired their revolutions.
Printer friendly
Cite/link
Email
Feedback
| |
| Title Annotation: | human rights abuses in post-Communist Eastern Europe |
|---|---|
| Author: | Neir, Aryeh |
| Publication: | The Nation |
| Date: | Apr 6, 1992 |
| Words: | 988 |
| Previous Article: | The Secret life of a parking meter manufacturer. |
| Next Article: | Who bought your candidate & why. |
| Topics: | |

Printer friendly
Cite/link
Email
Feedback