Kelley wants independent pathologist for murder trial. >> Farmer's remains found in slurry tank >> Disappearance sparked huge search.
Byline: PAUL HEALY Crime Correspondent
A MAN accused of the murder of farmer Michael Gaine is seeking the services of an independent pathologist ahead of his trial.
US citizen Michael Kelley, 54, is charged with killing Mr Gaine at his farm in Carrig East near Moll's Gap in Kenmare, Co Kerry, in March last year.
Mr Gaine, who was 56, went missing on March 20, 2025 and his remains were found on the land and a slurry tank later in May.
Mr Kelley, who is originally from Maine in the States but whose address was given as Chapel Street, Tralee, Co Kerry, has been in custody since he was charged with murder in February.
The accused, dressed in a navy coloured sleeveless jacket and grey top, appeared via video link from Cork Prison.
His new barrister Michael O'Higgins SC, who came on record last month after Mr Kelley relinquished his previous counsel, yesterday asked the court for legal aid in order to bring on a documentary junior - due to the volume of documents in the case.
The court heard Mr Kelley's defence team had recently been given over 25,000 pages, including 1,000 emails and over 30 hours of interviews - all of which need examination. Judge Karen O'Connor granted the aid as Mr O'Higgins also indicated he intended to call upon pathologist Professor Jack Crane, who's based in the North, to prepare reports for the defence.
The matter was put back for mention on December 4 where the court will hear whether both sides are prepared ahead of the planned trial date on January 11.
The court was previously told there are an expected 191 witnesses in the book of evidence and it is estimated that the trial will last up to nine weeks.
PURPOSE Mr Kelley had sought for alternative counsel in the case, with the court hearing from then defence counsel Brendan Grehan SC who stated he had met the accused "a few times," but he understood that the man now wished for alternative counsel.
On another date in late October the court heard that Mr Kelley now wished to be represented by Mr O'Higgins.
At his initial District Court hearing in Tralee, Detective Sergeant Mark O'Sullivan of Killarney Garda Station said he arrested Mr Kelley for the purpose of charge at Castleisland Garda Station. He told the court. "Michael Kelley made no reply to the charge having first been cautioned."
The witness also said that the accused man was charged with the murder of Mr Gaine at his farm in Carrig East in Moll's Gap, Kenmare, on a date unknown between March 20 and 21 last year.
Gardai initially treated the disappearance of the deceased - who was last seen at a Centra shop on Kenmare on the morning of March 20 - as a missing persons case.
His disappearance sparked a massive search of the land.
Teams from the Civil Defence, Coast Guard and Defence Forces joined the Garda helicopter and multiple Garda units as well as more than 200 volunteers in the search.
In a media appeal at the time, gardai released CCTV footage which showed Mr Gaine leaving the Centra shop in Kenmare and getting into his brown RAV jeep.
news@irishmirror.ie
'' Kelley made no reply to the charge having first been cautioned DET SGT MARK O'SULLIVAN AT PREVIOUS HEARING
CAPTION(S):
VIDEO LINK Accused Michael Kelley
CUSTODY Kelley at previous hearing
Printer friendly
Cite/link
Email
Feedback
| |
| Author: | PAUL HEALY Crime Correspondent |
|---|---|
| Publication: | The Mirror (London, England) |
| Date: | Nov 14, 2026 |
| Words: | 563 |
| Previous Article: | RUSSELL GRANT. |
| Next Article: | Road chase after wife's cancer shock. |
| Topics: | |

Printer friendly
Cite/link
Email
Feedback