Printer Friendly

Conflict and Resolution at the Table: The Role of Food in the TV Series Succession.

Introduction


Beginning in the 1980s, a series of foreign movies appeared that focused on cooking and eating-Tampopo (1985), Babette's Feast (1987), Like Water for Chocolate (1992), Eat Drink Man Woman (1994)--what Steve Zimmerman has identified as the subgenre "food film" (29). Encouraged by the box office appeal of these foreign food films, American filmmakers started to make food the central focus of their films--Big Night (1996), Julie & Julia (2009), Chef (2014). At the same time, a series of books of collected essays appeared devoted to the critical study of food and film: Bower (2004), Zimmerman and Weiss (2005), Keller (2006), Ferry (2014), Hertweck (2014), Lindenfeld and Parasecoli (2016). These studies have not just focused on the food film but on the role of food in both movies and TV in general. Here, we examine the role that food plays in Jesse Armstrong's HBO comedy/drama TV series, Succession (2018-2023).

Succession, which ran for 39 episodes over four seasons, tells the story of billionaire Logan Roy, and the company he runs, Waystar RoyCo, a global media and entertainment conglomerate. As Logan ages, his three children by his second wife, Kendall, Siobhan (Shiv), and Roman vie for who will succeed him. Logan also has another child, Connor, by his first marriage. When the series begins, Logan is married to his third wife, Marcia. The main characters also include Tom Wambsgans, who becomes Shiv's husband in the course of the show, and Greg Hirsch, often known as Cousin Greg, whose grandfather is Ewan Roy, Logan Roy's brother.

Although Succession clearly has taken inspiration from contemporary media magnates such as Rupert Murdoch, Robert Maxwell, Sumner Redstone, and their families, the series is also inspired by the dynastic machinations of ancient Rome (Swisher "Comic"). Indeed, the TV series that it most resembles is 1 Claudius (1976). Like I Claudius, Succession is nominally a "drama series," but is better described as a black comedy or dark satire about big business, power, and wealthy dysfunctional celebrity families. The Roy siblings constantly jab at each other with witty one-liners and savage insults. They are selfish, privileged, and snarky, yet their vulnerabilities in the face of their omniscient authoritarian father and their sharp humor allows the audience to empathize, and keep watching what are truly despicable human beings. Jesse Armstrong, the creator and head writer of the show, commented: "I love it when people laugh because it should be funny" (Swisher, "The Munsters").

The humorous intent of the show is one clue to the role of food in Succession. Another is Jesse Armstrong's admitted interest in food. Talking about his ritual in the writers' room of starting the day by asking each writer to talk about mundane details of their life, Armstrong explained: "Mainly I am just interested in what people have had for dinner ... if it's good, bad, where they've been, what they're cooking. I am just quite food focused" (Swisher, "The Finale")

It is this pervasive role that food plays in our lived experiences that has attracted scholars from a wide range of disciplines working within the larger disciplinary framework of Food Studies. Food is seen as more than just a matter of production and consumption. Food allows people to express "who and what they are, to themselves and to others" (Mintz 13). The varying ways in which a human group eats signal "its diversity, hierarchy and organisation, but also, at the same time, both its oneness and the otherness of whoever eats differently" (Fischler 275). Building on such theoretical perspectives of the role of food in society and foundational texts such as Mintz (1985), Poppendieck (1986) and Belasco (1989), Food Studies officially became a discipline of academic study with the establishment of NYU's Food Studies Program in 1996 (Nestle 168). Emily Contois describes Food Studies as an "interdisciplinary, inherently politicized field of scholarship, practice, and art that examines the relationship between food and all aspects of the human experience, including culture and biology, individuals and society, global pathways and local contexts." A Food Studies perspective allows the use of a range of concepts to illuminate the meaning and representation of the most basic and commonplace of human activities.

Here we use concepts of commensality, table manners, hospitality, and food as cultural capital to understand how the writers and directors of Succession use food as a means of containing the titanic family conflicts within the civilized boundaries of a series of mealtime gatherings, and leavening the drama with humor as a product of the juxtaposition of the seriousness of the intense struggle and the commonplace of eating, as well as reminding the audience of the immense wealth of the Roy family.
Food in Film and Television


In this article, we make no distinction between movies and TV drama series regardless of how awards ceremonies like the Oscars and the Emmys distinguish them. These days, TV drama series more and more resemble film in their budgets and production values, the size of the screen they are streamed on, and the opportunity to be binge-watched in viewing times similar to movies.

Research on food in film/TV can be roughly divided into two main areas of focus: food films, where food is the main thematic content, and food as an element in a general or peripheral sense. In a food film, "food production, preparation, service and or consumption play a non-operative and memorable role in the development of character, structure, and theme" (Keller 1). TV drama series examples of this genre are The Bear (2022) and From Scratch (2022). In the second research focus, food as a peripheral element has always figured in movies since their inception. However, with greater sophistication of the technology of lighting, camera lenses, and film stocks together with a turn to realism in the 1970s, food was increasingly used for what it could symbolize (Zimmerman 26-27). So Italian food in mafia movies such as The Godfather (1972) is used to symbolize ethnicity and solidarity between often warring Cosa Nostra families, or regionally in Annie Hall (1977) as when Woody Allen, the quintessential East Coaster orders "alfalfa sprouts and mashed yeast" in a Los Angeles restaurant, or transgressivism as in Jack Nicholson's rant against diner standardization in 5 Easy Pieces (1970).

A large body of food in film research has focused on how individual movies use food to explore many different socio-cultural themes from social class, gender, and ethnicity to religion, politics, and nationality (Lindenfeld and Parasecoli 4). Other research has examined the role of food in an entire national or regional film movement, for example post-war Japanese film (see Hayford) and food's role in an individual director's complete oeuvre, for example, Stanley Kubrick (see Nicholson). In this article, we explore how food is used to symbolize wealth, temper the passions of the protagonists in their struggle to control Waystar RoyCo, and to leaven the conflict with humor in order to ensure the audience's continued engagement with the dysfunctional Roy family.

Food, Wealth, and Social Class

Pierre Bourdieu has shown that social class membership can be manifested through embodied cultural capital in the form of taste intertwined with the objectified cultural capital of food choices in terms of exclusivity and quantity (243). Conspicuous consumption of the most desirable food has long been used to "display wealth and worldliness by making clear distinctions between haves and have nots" (Lindenfeld and Parasecoli 20). This distinction is illustrated by the Italian quinto quarto. In Testaccio, Rome's historic home of slaughterhouses into the 1970s, the butchery practice was to divide cattle carcasses into quarters for sale according to social class rank. The prime cuts went to the aristocracy; the second-best cuts to the clergy; the third to the middle classes; and the fourth to the military. What was left-the offal-was called the quinto quarto or "fifth quarter," and was sold to the lower classes (Edwards 61). These class membership distinctions are graphically illustrated in The Last Laugh (1924). The main character Jannings' rags-to-riches story is marked by a contrast between the impoverished food served up at his niece's wedding and the lavish meal he eats at a fancy hotel restaurant. Yet despite his change of fortune, Jannings' lower-class origins are still on display through his ignorance of elite rules of etiquette, suggesting that "'refined' choices about food presentation serve to keep elite conspicuous consumption inconspicuous" (Baron et al. 52).

Food presentations not only refer to the food itself and the table manners by which it is to be consumed but also include the accoutrements of eating: dining rooms, banquet rooms, place settings, kitchens, cooks, and servers, copious examples of which we are privy to in Downton Abbey (2010-2015). In the TV series Bridgerton (2020-2023), we witness the lavish foods that are served up to the titled aristocracy: ice cream, pastries, and tea with abundant amounts of sugar, markers in Regency England of both wealth and the power of the British Empire to provide the rich with such luxuries. Also, the eating of venison as seen in the series, speaks not only to wealth but to the exclusive access of the aristocracy to the monarchy, in this case George, Prince of Wales, who served as regent for his insane father, King George III. The crown controlled the hunting rights to almost a third of the country (LaCombe 84). Although sugar consumption had become increasingly common by the Regency period (Mintz 96), elaborate dessert creations still marked immense wealth. In the scenes at Gunter's Tea Shop, we see the refined wealthy eating ice cream, an elaborate and costly dish at the time.

In other shows, extreme wealth is often portrayed as providing access to perverse appetites and greed. In Twin Peaks, the mega-rich brothers Ben and Jerry Horne display their wealth through their consumption of exotic foods. In S1E2, Jerry somehow brings baguettes filled with butter and brie back from his trip to Paris. We see Ben hungrily devouring the baguette and talking with his mouth full about the deliciousness of an authentic Parisian baguette. In S3E6 of Billions, the greedy gourmandizing of the hedge-fund rich is satirized in the grotesque consumption of ortolan (songbirds drowned in Armagnac and eaten whole) a practice banned by the European Union in 1979. A similar ortolan feast appears in Succession, which we will discuss in full later. At the ortolan dinner in Billions, a still hungry Mike "Wags" Wagner, COO of Axe Capital, asks real-life celebrity chef Wylie Dufresne whether he has any ortolans leftover. Dufresne replies, "you know what they say about ortolan? 'One is bliss, two is gluttony.'" To which Wags replies, "How about three?" George Reynolds notes that "Taking a third ortolan is the perfect summation of the more-is-more self-gratification of the elites portrayed on Billions, " ready to go in showrunner Brian Koppelman's words "beyond gluttony for their particular form of satisfaction, no matter who has to get drowned in Armagnac as a result of it" (Kafka). It is a similar journey that "the entitled tech bros, narcissistic celebrities, and know-it-all foodies" (Cea) are willing to take in The Menu (2022 ) as they travel by boat to an exclusive restaurant on a private island in search of the "ultimate" meal at $1,250 a head.

Movies such as The Menu and shows like Billions, Succession, and The White Lotus, have been described as belonging to the genre of "eat the rich." As Sam Adler-Bell puts it, we the viewers can "indulge in a fantasy of extravagance, and then, remembering we'll never have it for ourselves, relish watching it turn to (literal) shit." But what distinguishes Succession is that there is only one character, Tom Wambsgans, who fits the description of the greedy gourmand, and he is only rich through marriage to Shiv Roy. In fact, while lavish displays of food are often present, the Roys by birth are rarely seen to actually consume any of it. As Tejal Rao argues, "When it comes to the high-powered Roy dynasty, food is for the weak and striving."

Juxtaposition

Juxtaposition involves placing two or more visual or aural elements side by side such that the interaction of their proximity creates more meaning than if the elements were in isolation. In filmmaking, these elements may be words in the script, actors, props, in either the same shot (mise-en-scène) or edited shots (edited juxtaposition) (Giannetti 155). A classic example of mise-en-scène juxtaposition is the scene in Harold Lloyd's Safety Last! (1923) where he is seen dangling from a clock face with the street far below. The scene is made more comic and thrilling precisely because Lloyd and the street far below are kept in the same frame through the cunning placement of the camera. It is the unity of space rather than the juxtaposition of separate shots that gives it emotional intensity (Giannetti 73). A classic example of edited juxtaposition is Jaws (1975), where the continual cutting between the happy beachgoers above the water and the shark underneath it creates a sense of fear and anticipation of what awful act is to come.

An example of food-related juxtaposition is a scene in a packed-out Manhattan diner in When Harry Met Sally (1989). Sally responds to Harry's doubts that women can fake orgasms by enacting such a loud dramatic orgasm that the other diners fall silent and stare at her. Harry's utter mortification mirrors the cringing embarrassment that the movie audience feels until the camera cuts to a middle-aged woman diner who turns to the waiter and says: "I'll have what she's having." Juxtaposition in Succession is mainly mise-en-scène and the effect is more one of ironic chuckling than laugh out loud guffaws. Many scenes in Succession juxtapose tense corporate takeover exchanges between allies and enemies with mundane acts of eating triggering humor through the placement of the serious and dramatic with the trivial and commonplace (Wright 32).

Commensality, Table Manners, and Hospitality

Table manners are social agreements or a system of taboos, originally designed to ensure that violence did not break out at dinner (Visser 3). In those earlier days, diners brought their own knives and eating implements to the table, utensils that could easily be weaponized in case of a dispute. Today, table manners persist as markers of accepted civility and deference, solidarity and hierarchy. As such, the study of table manners allows insights into how the network of social relationships of the larger society is structured and maintained (Elias 45).

Connected to table manners is the concept of commensality. Commensality--the act of eating together--is derived from the root word mensa, the Latin for "table" which suggests a sharing of the table, or derived from the root mensalis, the Latin for what is on the table, and so the eating of food together. Commensality, as it is understood in anthropology, is minimally defined as eating and drinking together, which may or may not include the sharing of food and the sharing of a table and may occur in either informal or formal settings as a daily or special event (Kerner 1). Commensality has been variously described as a site for socialization, civilization, solidarity, cultural identification, social demarcation, and hierarchical distinction (Jonsson 7). Table manners can be seen as a set of guiding principles for the act of eating together, ensuring and enhancing commensality, in the context of more formal dining, and especially in the context of hospitality.

Felicity Heal describes five consistent underlying principles that have governed hospitality in an English context: (i) host/guest relationships are 'natural,' (ii) a guest can bring honor and status to the host, (iii) hospitality is 'noble,' (iv) altruism is an established and expected part of social life, and (v) hospitality and the social relationships it creates are just as important as those relationships created in a commercial transaction (22). Tom Selwyn describes the kind of social relationships hospitality can engender: "Hospitality converts: strangers into familiars, enemies into friends, friends into better friends, outsiders into insiders, non-kin into kin" (19).

A classic cinematic example of how these three elements interact together is the famous Thanksgiving dinner scene in Charlie Chaplin's Gold Rush (1925). Chaplin's little tramp character has to endure a winter in the Klondike prospecting for gold without any food and the ever-present threat of being cannibalized by other starving prospectors. Driven by intense hunger, Chaplin cooks his boot for Thanksgiving dinner and shares it with another prospector Big Jim McKay. The poverty of the meal and the brutality of its surroundings are juxtaposed against the cultural expectations of Thanksgiving of abundance, family, and hospitality. Against this background of starvation, Chaplin maintains the rules of civilized eating. He carefully bastes the boot with its juices and then carves it into two portions to share with his companion. He delicately eats the sole, making sure to extract the hobnails, sucking on them as if they were bones, and then with skilled fork work he twirls the bootlaces as if they were spaghetti, politely patting his chest to assist his digestion. What makes this scene so funny is the juxtaposition of the mundanity of the rituals of the table and the horror of starvation, the civility of hospitality and potential threat of cannibalism, which is graphically illustrated in the movies How Tasty Was My Little Frenchman (1971) and Delicatessen (1991).
Food in Succession


We now analyze Succession from the three perspectives of food discussed. First, we look at food as a symbol of wealth, class, and power. Then we examine food as a representation of the commonplace juxtaposed with the drama of intense internecine corporate warfare, triggering humor. And finally, we look at food as a marker of status, cooperation, and hierarchy through the concepts of hospitality, commensality, and table manners.

Food as a Symbol of Wealth

Bridging shots are most often used to remind us of just how wealthy the Roy family is. These include shots of fleets of black SUVs, helicopters, and private jets. Similarly, wealth is symbolized by numerous bridging shots of the hustle and bustle of the waitstaff, and kitchen help involved in preparing and serving food. In S1E4, at the RECNY Ball charity dinner, which is sponsored by the Roy family, there are shots of the waitstaff fussing around preparing for the dinner, and there are further shots of food preparation at Shiv and Tom Wambsgans' wedding at a castle in England at the end of Season 1 along with the wedding of Logan Roy's ex-second wife, Caroline Collingwood, in a Tuscan villa at the end of Season 3. The same hustle and bustle of the waitstaff appears in the Roys' family homes at the New York apartment in preparation for Thanksgiving (S1E5) and at their summer home in the Hamptons (S2E1) with the opening of the house for the summer season, restocking of the kitchen, preparations for lunch, and shots of an opulent table setting.

The dazzle of feverish food preparations sits in contrast to the actual minimal focus on the food itself as a symbol of wealth. For the most part, the food that is consumed, especially by Logan Roy, is commonplace. When Kendall is summoned by Marcia in S1E6 to talk to his father over dinner, Logan is eating a burger while watching a game on TV. Although Kendall says his father should not be eating "that shit," he eventually eats the food that has been offered to him, suggesting that he understands the offer of the burger as an act of reconciliation on the part of his father and his acceptance a signal of rapprochement and bonding. In S4E1, Logan sits in a diner with Colin, his security guard and fixer, reading a laminated menu. Logan's association with simple meals may be seen as a nod to his impoverished origins or perhaps as an indication of the frugality which contributed to his enormous wealth. On the other hand, Kendall's disgusted reaction to burgers points to his and his sibs' rarified upbringing and may explain their often-expressed derision of commonplace food. In S3E9 in Tuscany, Roman mockingly orders "a club sandwich and a Cuba Libre" from Kerri, their father's personal secretary and new love interest, an effective putdown casting her as someone who would know and consume such pedestrian fare. In S4E2 at Connor's bachelor party in a karaoke bar, Roman makes a disparaging comment about wings, that quintessential American dish: "I wonder what kind of creature these wings are from ... I know, it's a mammal." In S4E7, Shiv in a cutting insult to her now estranged husband derides him as a "Mr. Mild" and "a one-pepper menu item."

Boardroom and shareholders meetings have tables groaning with food, though it seems to be only the standard ham and cheese rolls. The most extravagant display of food is not displayed by the Roy family but by Lukas Mattson, the owner of GoJo, a trendy and highly successful streaming service. The Mattson character is loosely modeled on Daniel Ek, the Swedish CEO and co-founder of Spotify. Mattson is about to buy out Waystar RoyCo, and in S4E5 summons the Roy siblings to the GoJo executive retreat on a mountain top in Norway. We see lavish displays of food including pigs being roasted over a spit, no doubt symbolic of how Mattson intends to deal with the Roy sibs in their price negotiations.

As we have already mentioned, the only self-professed gourmet in the family, as we will see, is Tom Wambsgans, but he shares none of the cosmopolitan upbringing of his in-laws in New York, the Hamptons, and Europe-Tom is from Minnesota--nor, of course, their extreme wealth. His manifestations of wealth and class are conveyed through the conventional snobbism of foodies. In S4E7, Tom plays host at the election tailgate party in his luxury apartment. He tries to convince Nate Sofrelli, Shiv's ex-lover and top Democratic operative, to try the biodynamic German wine: "It's the kind of wine that separates the connoisseurs from the weekend Malbec morons."

For the most part, the Roy family manifest their extreme wealth by not eating: "If You're Eating, You're Losing ... food is for the weak and striving" (Rao). It suggests that the manifestation of wealth through the excessive and conspicuous consumption of luxury food-greedy gourmandizing-has been replaced by the total suppression of appetite, an expression of both individual power and the wealth to afford Ozempic. Rao notes that this is especially true in Season 4. In S4E7, the sibs meet at the exclusive 2 Michelin star Jean-Georges restaurant to discuss the arrangements for their father's funeral. The setting exudes the Roy family wealth, but we do not see them eating. In earlier seasons, there are examples of the sibs curbing their eating. In S2E7, Roman and Shiv decide to stop at a convenience store to fill themselves up before visiting their mother for lunch rather than eat the pigeon their mother is serving up. Refusing food can be understood as an insult, especially when that food is offered by one's mother. Their refusal is no doubt part of the long simmering resentment of what they consider her abandonment of them when her marriage to Logan fell apart. In S2E8, Caroline confides to Shiv: "I should have had dogs" rather than children.

Of course, there are production costs, inconvenience, and technical limitations connected with working with food in movies (Zimmerman 25), but there are many instances where we do see characters eating, but these are the strivers. In S3E4, we see Waystar RoyCo executives Frank Vernon and Karl Muller eating lunch from plastic containers and Frank pops a French fry in his mouth. Later, in S4E5 when the Way star team flies to Norway to negotiate the sale of the company to Lukas Matsson, the same senior executives are seen heaping their plates with buffet food. Another Waystar executive, Hugo Baker, has his plate piled so high that one of GoJo staff shouts: "Hey, easy buddy, leave some for us." Of course, the two characters that we see eating the most are Cousin Greg, who is trying to worm his way up in the company, and the biggest striver of all, Tom Wambsgans, as we shall see in numerous later examples. In S4E7, Matsson confides to his new ally Shiv: "I'm about to take a shit in your husband's mouth and I'm pretty sure he's going to tell me it tastes like coq au vin." The quintessential scene which demonstrates Logan's power over his striving eating underlings comes in S2E3 and the viscous hazing game of Boar on the Floor. Logan has discovered someone has been leaking company secrets and commands Greg, Tom, and Karl to grunt and grovel on the floor like pigs and eat hot dogs until one of them admits their guilt.

But by Season 4, even Tom understands the power of not eating. At the breakfast buffet in the Norway negotiations in S4E5, he refrains from eating, and calls out to his colleagues eating Matsson's food: "Ambush! You took the bait, fattened for the kill." Earlier in S4E1, he complains to Greg that the date he has brought to Logan's birthday is "wolfing all the canapés like a famished warthog." Bridget, the date, marks herself clearly as striver not only because she eats the party food, but because she is carrying what Tom describes as "a ludicrously capacious bag." No matter that this is a $3,000 Burberry bag, its ostentation jars with the understated but luxurious clothes of the Roys. Food symbolizes wealth for the Roy dynasty not through the act of consuming of luxurious meals but through their ability to provide lavish amounts of food for others who by their very act of eating yield power to the abstaining Roy family.

Food as a Representation of the Commonplace

Bathos is a story-telling technique that juxtaposes serious ideas with the ludicrous or commonplace in an attempt to create humor. Succession often uses food and dining juxtaposed with the serious talk and plotting about who will succeed Logan Roy.

The first example is in SIE2. Logan Roy is in the ICU after collapsing during his 80 (th) birthday party. As Roy's children discuss what to release to the press about their father's condition that will not panic the stock market, we see Tom, Shiv's fiancé at the time, daintily and meticulously and with deft fork work eating a chocolate cake reminiscent of Chaplin's bootlace noodle twirling. There is a similar scene in S4E4. Logan has just died from a pulmonary embolism on an airplane en route to a crucial business deal. His children are devastated and still reeling from his death as they continue to plot with and against each other about who will take over the company. There is a type of wake combined with a board meeting of shareholders at Logan's palatial apartment. Tom approaches the siblings to give his condolences hoping to glean some information about the succession in which he also considers himself a contender. Again, he is holding a plate of food. This time, a fish taco. "I'm sick with grief," Tom says, to which Shiv, now separated from Tom, shoots back: "Oh, you're sick with grief? Well, you might want to put down that fish taco. You're getting your melancholy everywhere." It is the bathetic presence of the fish taco that allows the audience to tolerate Tom's phony sympathy and Shiv's vicious put down.

Another example comes in S1E4. Connor, Logan's oldest son by his first marriage, is in charge of organizing the RECNY Ball, the company's annual foundation gala. We see him fussing around making sure everything is in order and at one stage expresses his concern that the place settings are not correct. Normally, Logan Roy would give a speech at the dinner, but given that he has only just got out of hospital, Kendall sees this as an opportunity to show that he is ready to take over the company and plans to announce his father's retirement. However, Logan, though still clearly unwell, has heard about Kendall's plan and has made it to the dinner, determined that he will make the speech instead of Kendall and show that he is still in charge of the company. Amidst all this internecine conflict, and while a highly fraught Logan and Marcia are discussing Kendall's plot to depose his father, Connor spots that Marcia has difficulty spreading the butter on her dinner roll. He whisks away her side plate, storms into the kitchens in a rage and tells his workers that the butter is too cold to spread and that they are all fired. Later, Logan asks Marcia why Connor was so upset. "The butter was too cold," she responds. We go from the titanic family struggle for control to the trivial issue of spreadable butter. That Connor is more concerned about the temperature of the butter and his role as the maitre d' for the event, underlines his distance from the family power struggle.

A third example of the use of food as a trigger for bathos comes in S2E1. Logan has invited his children and key operatives to lunch at the opening for the season of his country house in the Hamptons. His intention is to announce major plans for the company. His children are all expecting some kind of hint as to who will take over from him. We see the house staff bringing in hampers of food into the kitchens, and the preparation of an elaborate steak and lobster lunch is underway. Unfortunately, there is a terrible smell throughout the house. Eventually the stench is traced to a chimney, a place that racoon mothers often choose to have their pups. Soon Logan's staff discover a sack of rotting racoon carcasses stuffed up the chimney, no doubt deliberately placed there by a contractor disgruntled by Logan's constant lowballing. Logan orders his staff to throw the steak and lobster into the trash-a symbolic act of wealth and power in itself-because he believes that the smell of the rotting racoons has permeated the food and orders out for pizza. We see the incongruity of a fancy Hamptons house with a beautiful table setting ready for a tense business lunch with pizza boxes lined up down the middle of the table.

In S3E2, Connor, Kendall, Roman, and Shiv meet secretly at Kendall's ex-wife Rava's apartment. Kendall is trying to persuade his siblings to join him in a move to take over Waystar RoyCo from their father. However, Logan knows what is going on and sends a box of doughnuts as a way of telling them that he is onto their scheming. The camera fixes on Connor inspecting the doughnuts that look a lot like Krispy Kreme, standard gas station fare, and he is about to eat one. Again, it is the juxtaposition of the commonplace doughnuts amidst plots to take over the company that provokes humor. Shiv tells Connor not to eat the donuts. Roman says it is OK, they are not poisoned. Shiv then says she is out of the cabal. Kendall responds: "Is it the doughnuts? Have you been spooked by doughnuts." Later when Shiv meets up with her father, she says: "Thanks for the doughnuts" as a way of signaling her shifting allegiances.

A final example is in S3E6. Kendall and Tom meet in a diner. Tom is facing a prison sentence as the fall guy for a Waystar scandal. Kendall is trying to leverage Tom's potential incarceration to persuade him to join his bid to take over the company. Tom orders from a large, laminated menu sheet. "I will take the griddle hero special with double hash browns. Fully loaded. A large waffle and a large cup of room temperature water." As Tom orders, Kendall's mouth drops open in amazement at the amount of food Tom is ordering. When it is Kendall's time to order, he looks up from the menu and says: "I might just watch him." The hearty diner food contrasts with Kendall's lunch choice of "shaved fennel salad" in S3E3. And it certainly contrasts with Tom's epicurean tastes as revealed in the ortolan dinner in S1E6, as we will discuss later. Tom explains his food choices: "Rasputin would take a dose of arsenic with his breakfast to build up his resistance." Hence, the diner food is preparation for what he will have to eat in prison. So, the juxtaposition of the absurdity of the diner food and Kendall's attempts to peel Tom away from allegiance to his father with promises of immunity provokes humor and leavens the ruthless intensity of the plotting.

Commensality, Table Manners, and Hospitality

There are several mealtime gatherings in Succession which permit the exploration of the concepts of commensality, table manners, and hospitality and how they are intertwined with the machinations of the Roy family.

Right from the start in S1E1, the dining table plays a major role in the series. Prior to Logan's 80th birthday lunch, Logan and his son Kendall are fighting over the future of the company. It takes place in the dining room, where the table is set for the upcoming meal. The perfect order of the place settings is juxtaposed against the disorder of Logan and Kendall's relationship. The 'order' of the dining table is further reinforced when Marcia, Logan's wife, calls the guests to the table. She says: "The meal is ready. Don't be late. Find your places." Meals need to have everyone present to start and diners, at least in this more formal meal, have designated places, thus representing the relationships of those present at the table. And there is a formal toast to Logan's health in honor of his accomplishment of reaching the age of 80. Toasts require that all guests honor the toastee by drinking regardless of their feelings towards the honoree or the alcohol they are obliged to imbibe. The act of drinking the toast also symbolizes the degree of trust between the host and the guests. In the same way that a handshake once conveyed the lack of a weapon, the host assures the guests through the toast, and the guests manifest their acceptance of that assurance, that the drink is not poisoned.

The next family dinner is Thanksgiving. The dinner is on the eve of a major board meeting with a vote of confidence/no confidence in Logan Roy's leadership. Logan's estranged brother, Ewan, a board member, has arrived from Canada, and is a surprise guest at the dinner. It has been many years since Logan and Ewan have seen each other. Marcia announces at the beginning of the Thanksgiving dinner that it is going to be family style, a reminder of what a Thanksgiving dinner symbolizes and that family feuds need to be put aside, at least while at table. The meal also symbolizes hierarchy and the division of social roles. Marcia, as the matriarch, calls the guests to table and announces the rules of the meal, as she did at the birthday meal. Logan is clearly the patriarch of the family as symbolized by his carving of the turkey. This is doubly important on this occasion. Logan is still recovering from his illness and has to be supported by his wife as he struggles to carve the turkey, demonstrating that he is still the functioning head of both the family and Way star RoyCo. But as his family watches his uncertain attempts to carve, they sense that his time in control is almost over. There is a strained though polite conversation between Logan and his brother at the table, but once removed from the social constraints of the dinner table, an old family feud bubbles to the surface, and Ewan and Logan start arguing, resulting in Ewan deciding to walk out on his brother. It is a further reminder of Logan's isolation and precursor of the sibling rivalries that are about to break out amongst his children.

In S2E5, the dinner table is the site for negotiation between the Roy and Pierce families with regard to a takeover. The Pierces are an old money, leftward-leaning, New England family who own newspapers and magazines of a similar cultural reputation to the New York Times. On the other hand, the Roys represent right-leaning, new money, and own popular news channels similar to Fox TV. While the Pierces are definitely interested in the money that Logan Roy can offer, they are reluctant to sell their publications empire to barbarians. Logan Roy is well aware of the class distinctions and in a family conversation to discuss their takeover strategy in preparation for a week they are going to spend with the Pierces at their home in Plymouth Rock, Logan cautions: "Don't shit into the tureen." The trappings of the dinner represent the identity of the Pierces: egalitarian but status conscious, highly cultured but wanting to appear casual and down to earth. In the kitchen, before the meal begins, Nan Pierce, the matriarch of the family, invites the cook to join them at dinner, an invitation the cook declines. The invitation is a showy attempt at egalitarianism for the benefit of the authoritarian Roys, the insincerity of which the cook well understands. When dinner is ready, Nan Pierce, as befits her role as the matriarch and responsible for supervising the cooking of the meal, brings in the roast herself to the applause of the guests seated at the table. In the Pierce home, unlike the non-religious Roys, they say grace, but in keeping with their liberalism, Nan acknowledges as befitting their New England roots, that their saying grace is heavily "unitarian." It consists of Naomi Pierce reciting lines from Shakespeare while holding a silver receptor or ladle. After which Nan says: "Soup's on, people." Conversation alternates between table mates and the whole table. The two families are sounding each out as a proxy for negotiation. Can the Roys present themselves as erudite enough to be trusted by the Pierces? And can the Roys contain their barbarism in the face of the Pierces' blueblood pretensions? It is the etiquette of table manners that mediates the potential conflicts in this meeting of incompatibles. At one stage, the conversation moves to talk of an alleged fascist news announcer at ATN (Roy's TV news channel) of which Tom is the head. The potential embarrassment is averted when Tom and Shiv, following the required table manners protocol, excuse themselves from the table on the pretext that "they have to check on their dog Mondale."

In S2E10, there is an example of one of the most taboo rules of table manners-eating off another's plate, especially without their permission. The backstory to this incident is Tom's increasing concern that he will be made the scapegoat for a company scandal. Tom is also angry with Shiv for her suggestions that they should have an open relationship. Shiv is contrite and offers to talk to her father about not making Tom the scapegoat. Tom shoots back that he will talk to Logan himself. Later, Tom tries to confront Logan at dinner, sitting down next to him. He wants to communicate to Logan that he refuses to be the one sacrificed. He says nothing, but leans over and, to Logan's astonishment, helps himself to some chicken off Logan's plate. Then Tom abruptly leaves, saying: "Thank you for the chicken." Shiv asides: "My God! I've never seen the chicken power play before." Tom's thank you is reminiscent of Shiv thanking her father for the doughnuts but instead of conveying compliance, Tom's words suggest defiance. Later, Logan complains to Shiv in an angry tone: "He ate my fucking chicken! What's next? He'll stick his cock in my potato salad?" Violating table manners has allowed Tom to assert himself and Logan's angry response speaks to the degree of violation Logan feels about the raid on his plate and what is clearly accepted as his rightful food domain.

One last example references the origins of table manners. This time, the violation concerns not the inalienable rights to the food on one's plate, but the safeguards against the threat of violence at the dinner table. In S3E8, the family is gathered for the Tuscan wedding of Kendall's mother, Logan's second ex-wife. Kendall invites his father to his villa for dinner. Logan is still in conflict with his son and brings his own food both as an affront to Kendall's hospitality and a sign of his distrust. Kendall insists that Logan try a plate of mozzarella. Historically, fear of poisoning has always been a concern when rivals are commensal. Logan signals his suspicions by offering a taste of the mozzarella to Iverson, Kendall's young son and Logan's only grandson. Kendall intuits his father's ploy, saying that he would be "broken" if Logan died. Brian Cox, the actor who plays Logan Roy, has a more nuanced interpretation of this scene. Logan understands that Kendall wants him to think that the food is poisoned and so plays along with this by offering the food to his grandson. He has no intention of poisoning his grandson, but he has every intention of outwitting his son once again (Swisher "Connor's").

Putting These Three Perspectives on Food Together

All three elements of the use of food in Succession come together in a series of scenes between Tom and Greg. In S1E6, Tom invites Greg out for dinner, partly in the spirit of his mentorship role, but mainly to keep Greg on his side. Greg says that he just got his first paycheck and is happy to go out to eat. He asks Tom if he knows California Pizza Kitchen. He says that it is "pretty delicious" and they make a Cajun Chicken Linguini just the way he likes it. Tom is aghast at the suggestion and responds: "You probably have quite an under-educated palette. So let's go out and I'll teach you and show you how to be rich."

Next, we see Greg and Tom at dinner together. They are at one of the most exclusive pop-ups in the city, having the full tasting menu. When Greg asks why there are no prices on the wine menu, Tom says that it is because the prices are obscene: "Here's the thing about being rich. It's fucking great. You feel like a superhero." And as a further symbol of that wealth the next dish on the menu is ortolan or songbird. Eating ortolan is a potent symbol of wealth. Not only is it expensive, illegal, and so highly exclusive (Tom says they are "privileged"), but it also involves an elaborate and seemingly ludicrous dining etiquette. Diners traditionally eat the bird whole while covering their heads with a napkin. We see Tom and a bewildered Greg, their heads veiled, consuming the birds. Tom reverently explains that some say that the napkin masks the shame, but others say that it heightens the pleasure. After eating the bird, Greg admits that he had already eaten with his grandfather, and that if he eats any more songbirds, he's going to hurl.

This sequence combines all the ways that food is used in Succession. The consumption of the ortolan symbolizes wealth, but not the extreme wealth of the Roys. Such brazen and conspicuous consumption is a mark of the strivers: a performance of "obsession, ambition, and excess" (Reynolds), a display of too much wealth but no style. It is a behavior that the Roy family members would shun. They have the true wealth and power: they do not eat. Logan especially understands the need, as Baron et al. pointed out earlier, that the rich need to "keep elite conspicuous consumption inconspicuous" (52). The commensality of the ortolan carnality binds Tom and Greg together as accomplices not only in the consumption of illegal songbirds but in the shredding of sensitive documents about Waystar; documents which could have incriminated Logan. Kendall had previously told Tom that his father loved employees who "ate shit for him." Reynolds notes: "After their act of corporate shit-eating, it's now time for Tom and Greg to devour their reward." And throughout all this, the display of elitist gluttony is seasoned by humor: the juxtaposition of the ingenue Greg, lover of California Pizza Kitchen and the pompous gourmand Tom with napkins shrouding their heads, united in their buffoonery.
Conclusion


In this article, we have argued that food in Succession can be examined with regard to three aspects: food as a symbol of wealth, class, and power; food as the commonplace mediator of intense drama triggering humor; and food as a marker of hierarchy, solidarity, and civility, through the concepts of commensality, table manners, and hospitality.

In symbolizing wealth, class, and power, Succession uses the traditional markers of retinues and accoutrements, but the display of food is nuanced. Displays of appetite may signal a certain level of wealth, but not extreme wealth. Acts of eating are usually confined to the 'strivers': Waystar RoyCo executives, and above all, Greg and Tom. Despite his claim to be a "superhero," Tom does have to eat. He is the archetypal late-capitalist, start-up gourmand, eager to flash his wealth through his food snobbery. But for the mega-rich members of the Roy family, the role of food as a symbol of wealth is understated. When we do see Logan eating, it is the ubiquitous burger of the masses. His food consumption is as inconspicuous as his cozy but luxury heritage brand cardigans (MacDonnell). As has been argued, the real marker of wealth and class in the era of Ozempic is the power not to have to eat.

What allows us to sustain our engagement with the despicably spoiled and amoral Roy family over four seasons is, as we have argued, the use of humor to leaven their acrimonious struggles. One trigger for humor, we have described, is the juxtaposition of the commonplace in the form of food with the serious and intense corporate drama. It is a sly not a belly-laugh humor, but it does provide comic relief from the tension of the succession struggle. It is a reminder of the universal biological necessity of eating, like defecating, most often provided by the hilarious buffoonery of Tom and Greg.

We have also shown how Succession illustrates the commensality of the dinner table in contrast to the dog eat dog of the boardroom table. The dining table provides some kind of civility and respite from the chaos of the dynastic bloodletting around and beyond the boardroom table. Table manners set boundaries that allow potentially hostile diners like Logan's brother Ewan or the rival Pierce family to meet and talk. And the hospitality of the host can offer rapprochement as when Logan offered his son Kendall a burger, or a promise of complicity as when Tom takes Greg out to the ortolan dinner, or even the threat of death as when Logan hints that a plate of mozzarella that Kendall offers him is poisoned.

With the death of Logan Roy in S4E3, the use of food in the show recedes. There is no longer need to suggest Logan's vast wealth through shots of armies of food staff. There is no need for scenes of family dining now that the death of Logan Roy has fractured the family hierarchy and solidarity, and the unchecked rivalries of the sibs and other pretenders to the leadership of Way star RoyCo is released. And there is no more need for humor as Tom, the king buffoon and striver, is anointed the successor to Logan Roy, albeit as the puppet and chief "shit eater" of Lukas Matsson, the actual owner of Waystar RoyCo.

Works Cited

Adler-Bell, Sam "The Movie Industry's Confused 'Eat the Rich' Fantasy." Vulture, 7 Feb 2023, vulture .com/2023/02/the-movie-industrys-confused- eat-the-rich-fantasy.html. Accessed 16 Oct 2023.

Armstrong, Jesse, creator. Succession. HBO Entertainment, 2018-2023.

Baron, Cynthia, et al. Appetites and Anxieties: Food, Film, and the Politics of Representation. Wayne State UP, 2014.

Belasco, Warren James. Appetite for Change: How the Counterculture Took on the Food Industry. Pantheon Books, 1989.

Bourdieu, Pierre. "The forms of capital." Handbook of Theory and Research for the Sociology of Education, edited by John G. Richardson, Greenwood, 1986, pp. 241-58.

Bower, Ann L., editor. Reel Food: Essays on Food and Film. Routledge, 2004.

Cea, Max. "Eating the Rich Shouldn't Be So Satisfying." Esquire, 21 Nov 2022, esquire.com/entertainment/movies/a42005064/eating-the-rich-movies-the- menu-wealth-criticism/. Accessed 16 Oct 2023.

Contois, Emily J. H. "From the Editor: The Many Potential Futures of Food Studies." Graduate Journal of Food Studies, vol. 4, no. 2, https://doi.org/10.21428/92775833.bc4901f0.

Edwards, Nina. Offal: A Global History. Reaktion Books, 2013.

Elias, Norbert. The Civilizing Process. Blackwell, 1994.

Ferry, Jane. Food in Film: A Culinary Performance of Communication. Routledge, 2003.

Fischler, Claude. "Food, Self and Identity." Social Science Information, vol. 27, 1988, pp. 275-93.

Frost, Mark, and David Lynch (creators). Twin Peaks. Lynch/Frost Productions, 1990-1991, 2017.

Giannetti, Louis. Understanding Movies. Pearson, 2017.

Hayford, Charles W. "Food, Family, and History in Japanese Postwar Film." Food on Film: Bringing Something New to the Table, edited by Tom Hertweck, Rowman & Littlefield, 2014, pp. 109-24.

Heal, Felicity. Hospitality in Early Modern England. Oxford UP, 1990. Hertweck, Tom, editor. Food on Film: Bringing Something New to the Table. Rowman and Littlefield, 2014.

Jonsson, Hakan, et al. "What Is Commensality? A Critical Discussion of an Expanding Research Field." International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, vol. 8, no.12, 2021, pp. 1-17, https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph 18126235.

Kafka, Peter, host. Billions. Recode Media with Peter Kafka, Vox, July 18. 2018, https://open.spotify.com/episode/4Tu34VxuEHOOvGIVKFmUrA

Keller, James R. Food, Film and Culture: A Genre Study. McFarland & Co., 2006.

Kerner, Susanne, et al, eds. Commensality: From Everyday Food to Feast. Bloomsbury, 2015.

Koppelman, Brian, et al. (creators). Billions. Showtime Entertainment, Best Available!, Eightnin' Production Rentals, 2016-2023.

EaCombe, Michael. Political Gastronomy: Food and Authority in the English Atlantic World. U of Pennsylvania P, 2012.

Lindenfeld, Laura, and Fabio Parasecoli. Feasting Our Eyes: Food Films and Cultural Identity in the United States. Columbia UP, 2016.

MacDonnell, Chloe. "Why the 'Ludicrously Capacious' Bag on Succession Was Such a Faux Pas for the Very Wealthiest." The Guardian, 30 Mar 2023, https://www.theguardian.com/fashion/2023/mar/30/ succession-burberry-bag-bridget. Accessed 17 Oct 2023.

Mintz, Sidney. Sweetness and Power: The Place of Sugar in Modern History. Viking, 1985.

Nestle, Marion. Slow Cooked: An Unexpected Fife in Food Politics. U of California P, 2022.

Nicholson, Mervyn. "My Dinner with Stanley: Kubrick, Food, and the Logic of Images." Fiterature/Film Quarterly, vol. 29, no. 4, 2001, pp-279-89.

Poppendieck, Janet. Breadlines Kneedeep in Wheat: Food Assistance in the Great Depression. Rutgers UP, 1986.

Rao, Tejal. "On 'Succession,' If You're Eating, You're Losing." The New York Times, May 16, 2023, https://www.nytimes. com/2023/05/16/dining/hbo-succession-food.html. Accessed 16 Oct 2023.

Reynolds, George. "Why the Greedy Gourmands of 'Succession' and 'Billions' Are Obsessed With Ortolans." Eater, 21 Nov 2018, www.eater.com/2018/11/21/18101843/ortolans-bird-napkin-billions-succession. Accessed 16 Oct 2023.

Selwyn, Tom. "An Anthropology of Hospitality," In Search of Hospitality: Theoretical Perspectives and Debates, edited by Conrad Lashley and Alison J. Morrison, Butterworth-Heinemann, 2001, pp.18-37.

Swisher, Kara, host. '"Comic Cowardice or False Power' (with Lucy Prebble)." HBO's Succession Podcast, season 2, episode 3, 31 Oct 2021, omny.fm/shows/succession/comic-cowardice-or-false -power-with-lucy-prebble?in_playlist=podcast. Accessed 16 Oct 2023.

--. "'The Finale' (with Jesse Armstrong and Frank Rich)." HBO's Succession Podcast, season 2, episode 9, 13 Dec 2021, omny.fm/ shows/succession/the-finale-with-jesse-armstrong-and- frankrich?in_playlist=podcast. Accessed 16 Oct 2023.

--. "'The Munsters' (with Jesse Armstrong, Frank Rich, and Ben Smith)." HBO's Succession Podcast, season 3, episode 1, 26 Mar 2023, omny.fm/shows/succession/the-munsters-with-jesse -armstrong-frank-rich-and-b?in_playlist=podcast. Accessed 16 Oct 2023.

--. "'Connor's Wedding' (with Jesse Armstrong, Mark Mylod, and Brian Cox)." HBO's Succession Podcast, 10 Apr 2023, omny. fm/shows/succession/connor-s-wedding-with-jesse-armstrong-mark-mylod-a. Accessed 17 Oct 2023.

Visser, Margaret. The Rituals of Dinner. Penguin, 1992.

Wright, John. Why Is That So Funny? Limelight Editions, 2007.

Zimmerman, Steve. "Food in Film: A Star Is Bom." Gastronómica, vol. 9,no. 2, 2009, pp.25-34.

--, and Ken Weiss. Food in the Movies. McFarland, 2005.
COPYRIGHT 2024 American University in Cairo
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2025 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Author:Bell, David; Moran, Theresa
Publication:Alif: Journal of Comparative Poetics
Date:Jan 1, 2024
Words:8587
Previous Article:Art You Can Taste: Cooking and Eating in a Gallery.
Next Article:Extract from the Novel Kohl and Cardamom.

Terms of use | Privacy policy | Copyright © 2026 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters |