Printer Friendly

Challenging medical authority: the refusal of treatment by Christian Scientists.

As a member of a hospital ethics committee in a city with a very large Christian Science population, I have seen firsthand the stalemate between Christian Scientists and physicians, especially concerning the treatment of Christian Science children. Physicians claim that it is a violation of their professional duties to allow suffering that could be prevented by medical treatment. Christian Scientists claim that it contravenes their religious freedom to be forced to subject their children to medical treatment in violation of their religious beliefs. The stalemate is made more tragic since neither physicians nor Christian Scientists want children to suffer or die, yet Christian Scientists refuse even to have their sick children diagnosed for fear that the physicians will try to force them to accept medical treatment. Unlike most discussion of this topic, in this paper I will consider the Christian Science refusal cases as exemplifying a conflict of groups over authority within a pluralistic society.

Two Christian Science

Refusal Cases

From the medical perspective, the Christian Science community simply cannot be respected. What Christian Scientists understand as doing what is best for their children physicians perceive as serious threats to the fundamental rights of those children. Let us consider a case that most doctors and lawyers take to be a good illustration of why we should not recognize the authority of Christian Science parents or give equal respect and treatment to the Christian Science community. On a Thursday evening in early April of 1986, two-year-old Robyn Twitchell ate a normal dinner but experienced severe pain and vomiting shortly afterward. The pain and vomiting continued into Friday and Robyn's parents, both committed Christian Scientists, consulted several Church officials who determined that his pain was in his lower abdomen. After another day of intense pain and vomiting, on Saturday a Christian Science practitioner, Nancy Calkins, came to the Twitchell house to pray for Robyn. Robyn was still unable to hold down food or liquids, and so on Monday a Christian Science nurse was called who also ministered to Robyn. By Tuesday evening Robyn Twitchell died. An autopsy was conducted and it was determined that Robyn had a bowel obstruction, which, in the opinion of one physician, "could have been readily corrected by surgery with an almost one hundred percent chance of success."[1]

The mainstream position in medicine and law is that even in a pluralistic society a line needs to be drawn at the point where respecting a religious minority culture clearly jeopardizes the well-being of children. What makes the case of Robyn Twitchell so tragic is that a relatively simple operation could have saved his life. The fact that his parents refused even to secure a medical diagnosis meant that they were completely unaware of how seriously ill their son was. Indeed, in another highly publicized case, the parents whose failure to secure a medical diagnosis and simple treatment resulted in the death of their child have subsequently left the Christian Science Church and lobbied against statutory religious exemptions to the child abuse and neglect laws.[2]

In the case of Robyn Twitchell, it seems clear to most physicians that respecting the beliefs and choices of Christian Scientists meant that Robyn's right to life and his right to minimally adequate health care were jeopardized. From the medical perspective, he may as well have been left alone by his parents to die, given what little they did to save his life.

On such a view, respecting the wishes of these Christian Science parents meant that Robyn Twitchell was the subject of child neglect. When the Twitchell case is used as a model, Christian Science seems to be the kind of community that cannot and should not be given equal respect with the other communities in our pluralistic society.

Consider another case of Christian Science refusal that is perhaps more representative of die clash between medical and Christian Science perspectives. In 1990, Colin Newmark's parents began to worry. The health of this three-year-old son of Christian Science parents began deteriorating rapidly, and the parents reluctantly took Colin (a pseudonym) to a hospital in Delaware near where they lived. The physicians could not immediately tell what was wrong with Colin and they recommended extensive X rays and blood testing. The parents refused and took Colin home. Colin's condition continued to deteriorate and his parents returned to die hospital. X rays indicated that Colin suffered from an intestinal blockage, and his parents agreed to surgery to remove the blockage since they considered the procedure to be purely "mechanical."[3] "A pathological report on tissue taken from Colin's intestines during the surgery revealed that Colin was suffering from non-Hodgkin lymphoma. Five pathologists confirmed this diagnosis."[4]

The doctors in charge of Colin's case recommended chemotherapy and radiation, which would give the child a 40 percent chance of recovery. Without chemotherapy, the doctors argued, Colin would be dead in six to eight months. The form of chemotherapy proposed can result in kidney failure, hair loss, immunological and neurological problems, and, as a result of multiple blood transfusions, increased risk of infection. One of the doctors "predicted that chemotherapy would bring Colin near death and that the radiation treatments required would presumably render him sterile."[5] The Newmarks rejected the chemotherapy and attempted to remove Colin from the hospital to be placed in the care of a Christian Science practitioner. The hospital sued to obtain custody of Colin in order to authorize the chemotherapy, and tried to have Colin placed into a foster home where his caretakers would cooperate with the medical treatment regimen. The Delaware Supreme Court sided with the Newmarks.[6]

In many such cases it is not clear that medical science can save the life of a child or that the side effects of treatment are themselves not worse than the saving. We get a very different result if we take Colin's case instead of Robyn's as our model for assessing Christian Science refusal of treatment. The model of Colin is also consistent with the many children of Christian Scientists who seem to be quite healthy even though their parents don't accept medical authority. What is especially important about this case is that Colin's parents did not blindly refuse to seek all forms of medical diagnosis and help. In the end they refused one form of proposed therapy but, as I will argue, such a refusal could not seriously be said clearly to have jeopardized Colin's fundamental rights. It is not clear what would have been best for Colin. Indeed, if this case had not concerned Christian Scientists, die medical profession would probably have been undivided in supporting, or at least not challenging, the parents' decision.

The Christian Science Tradition

Since the Christian Science church was founded over a century ago by Mary Baker Eddy, Christian Scientists have been locked in a struggle with the medical profession. In her major book, Science and Health, Eddy argues that "Mind" not matter constitutes what is real. Each person should be able to be his or her "own physician, and Truth will be the universal panacea."[7] The power of prayer was thought to be an antidote to any ailment since the ailments themselves were really mental in origin. In some cases, Eddy suggested that people may need help in bringing their minds into alignment with "Mind." Such assistance, in the form of reliance on certain others, was meant only to help the individual to help him- or herself.

Eddy formed a group of practitioners who were to aid individuals in finding mental or spiritual solutions to their problems. In the early years of the church, these practitioners were in direct competition with medical physicians. One recent writer on the history of these developments concludes:

Whereas osteopathy and chiropractic [the other dominant challengers to medical physicians at the turn of the century] followed the strategy of getting legislation passed that would govern their practices, Christian Science pursued the policy of obtaining amendments to the existing medical practice acts that specifically exempted its practitioners from their provisions. Thus, unlike the others who were regulated by the state, Christian Science was able to maintain complete administrative control over its practitioners.[8]

From the early years of the development of both the Christian Science and the medical communities, struggles between the two groups have been common.

According to Christian Science doctrine, children sometimes suffer material discomfort due to the mental beliefs of their parents, who may thus affect their children's health by bringing their own spiritual lives into order through prayer. Such a position does not seem to be at odds with seeking medical care for these children while the parents work on their spiritual well-being. But this is not the case - for Mary Baker Eddy comments that "Hypocrisy is fatal to religion." When Christian Scientists put their faith in the power of prayer, it is thought that it would be hypocritical also to put their faith in medicine. Some Christian Scientists fervently believe that the power of prayer is greatly diminished if the faith of die person praying is so weak that medical help is sought at the same time. Indeed, Eddy says that it "is a grave mistake to suppose ... that Spirit and matter ... can commune together," and that "if we trust matter, we distrust Spirit."[9]

Yet the Christian Science doctrine about the medical treatment of children is not as clear-cut as is sometimes supposed. There is no room in Christian Science for an uncritical faith in the power of prayer in all cases. "Nothing is more antagonistic to Christian Science than a blind belief without understanding," Eddy says. And there is nothing in the doctrine to forbid anyone from seeking medical healing. Rather, there is a strong sense that when one does seek medical healing one has turned one's back on the power of prayer. But even Eddy herself came at die end of her life to advocate seeking medical care during delivery, and in Science and Health she allowed that surgery could be used to set broken bones.[10] Recently, the Christian Science Board of Directors has issued a restatement of Church policy, holding that

although it is entirely natural for students of Christian Science to rely on prayer, it is also important, when it comes to the care of children, that Scientists consider well their individual spiritual readiness, their own past experience and record, and the mental climate in which they live.... When circumstances result in a child's being brought under medical care, members of our Church would surely continue to cherish such a family and give them their full love and support during a challenging time. . . . To look upon another's progress with anything less than loving encouragement would not be Christian.[11]

Yet this restatement also reaffirms that seeking medical care "clearly departs from the practice of Christian Science" (p. 25).

These various nuances in the Christian Science doctrine, especially toward children, have resulted in a wide variety of Christian Science practices concerning sick children. The most interesting question from my perspective is why Christian Scientists have had such trouble seeing medical science as a diagnostic aid to their own attempts to remove disease through prayer. One reason for this may be that many Christian Scientists seem to take literally several passages in Science and Health which say that little children should not be exposed to false belief and superstition, that is, to medical science. Even to use medical science as a diagnostic tool would mean to give it credibility in the eyes of a child, which would diminish the authority of Christian Science and ultimately adversely affect the child, his or her family, and even the whole Christian Science community.

Yet since even Mary Baker Eddy is willing to allow that Christian Science practices are not able to effectuate cures in all cases and that some "mechanical" forms of medical science can be relied on (as in the cases of childbirth, broken limbs, and dentistry), it seems odd indeed not to remain open to the possibility that more illnesses than those related to obstetrics, orthopedics, and oral surgery can be helped by medical diagnosis. At very least, it would seem to make sense to know something about the physical condition of the body (even given that it is only effect and not cause of the illness) in order to be better able to direct one's spiritual resources.[12]

The Christian Science response is to insist that medical diagnosis is potentially pernicious in two important ways. First, according to the metaphysical doctrine that under-girds Christian Science, illness is caused by such "mental," rather than physical, factors as how the person thinks about his or her bodily states. Since medical diagnosis is aimed at identifying what is wrong with die physical body, acceptance of such diagnoses could make it harder for die person to change his or her conception of the health of the body. Second, once a medical diagnosis has been rendered, it will be much harder for the Christian Scientist to retain control over the decisions concerning one's own health or the health of one's children. Past experience has shown, as in the case of Colin Newmark, that once physicians get a patient under their influence they will try to force Christian Scientists to follow the medical regimen rather than the Christian Science one.[13] Medical diagnosis, so it is believed, can make things worse rather than better.

The official doctrine of the Christian Science church is to be opposed to medical diagnosis,[14] but as I have been arguing, even Mary Baker Eddy found value in medical diagnosis in some cases. It is true, though, that Eddy distinguished between those conditions that could be corrected by mechanical means and those conditions, namely diseases, that could not. And she remained opposed to diagnosis for disease, as has remained true of the official Christian Science doctrine. It seems to me, though, that until diagnosis is performed, it isn't clear whether mechanical correction or something requiring medication or an even more invasive intervention is called for medically. If removing a bowel obstruction is mechanical, as some Christian Scientists seem to believe, then it would make sense to allow, even to encourage, diagnosis when symptoms of possible bowel obstruction manifest themselves, as well as in several other cases. But Christian Scientists have by and large remained committed to refusing any form of medical practice.

Medical Authority

The medical establishment in the United States has opposed the refusal of medical care by Christian Scientists, whether by adults on their own behalf or by parents on behalf of their children. And individual doctors have often responded with contempt and outrage to the public position of the Christian Science church, namely that the power of prayer is more effective than the power of surgery and medicine. It is clear that the medical establishment has not seen the refusal cases as simply a matter of conflicting reliefs but as a struggle for authority.

In the early part of the twentieth century, medical doctors consolidated their power and tried to enlist legal authorities in enforcing some of their decisions about what is best for patients, especially in life-threatening situations. Most adult Christian Scientists, especially in recent times, have managed to avoid what they perceive as the interventionistic strategies of medical doctors by simply staying clear of doctors and hospitals.

Many of those who work in medical ethics have recently broken ranks with their colleagues in medicine by arguing that adult Christian Scientists should be allowed to pursue matters of health on their own terms. Indeed, three well-known scholars end a recent article on this subject with these words: "The right of patients to forgo life-sustaining treatment has been well established in health law and medical ethics."[15]

While many medical doctors continue to object strongly when Christian Scientists refuse treatment for themselves, the sharpest criticisms have been directed at those Christian Scientists who refuse treatment for their children. Unlike the case of Christian Scientists who refuse medical care for themselves, the reaction to Christian Science refusal of treatment for children has been nearly unanimous in the medical community.[16] The general consensus among physicians is well stated by Norman Fost: "We're interested not just in the kids who die. What we're concerned about are the hundreds and hundreds more who suffer from inadequate medical treatment."[17]

The American Academy of Pediatrics has recenty been spearheading a movement to remove the religious exemptions to child neglect statutes throughout the United States.[18] This campaign is fueled by die belief that Christian Scientists and Jehovah's Witnesses should be forced to subject their children to the full range of curative powers at the disposal of modern medicine. The growing involvement in these legislative matters by the AAP has come as a result of the belief that child neglect and abuse are on the rise in the United States and need to be confronted.[19] The religious exemption is seen as a major impediment to providing the best health care to all American children. By the end of 1993, three states - Hawaii, South Dakota, and Massachusetts - had recently changed their "state laws to remove language that allowed people to deny their children medical care for religious reasons.... The majority of states [had] language that makes criminal prosecution difficult."[20]

The nearly unanimous voice of die medical profession in rejecting the Christian Science position stems from the common socialization of medical students in the United States. The Hippocratic oath and its "do no harm" dictum, as well as the general principle of beneficence, have been interpreted in such a way that medical students are trained to be quite aggressive in pursuing what they believe will be least harmful and most beneficial for their patients. Once a determination, or diagnosis, has been made, it is considered to be harmful for the patient not to acquiesce in the regimen prescribed to overcome the diagnosed illness or disease. If a patient refuses to follow the prescribed regimen it is seen as a failure of the doctor, indeed a failure specifically in the sense that the aggressive pursuit of doing no harm and benefitting the patient has not been fulfilled.

But there is another tradition in medicine that apparently has not been as much discussed in medical schools, at least until quite recently, as has the dominant tradition I have just set out. This tradition can be traced back to Maimonides, who declared that "the physician should not treat the disease but the patient suffering from it."[21] This tradition has also found expression in the idea that physicians should treat their patients as persons.[22] At the moment I merely note that there is this alternative which, when made part of the common medical socialization, might produce a different set of attitudes and practices than those currently dominant in modern medicine.

Nonetheless, when patients challenge physician authority, this is perceived by their physicians as an affront to their medical expertise and ultimately to their status as authorities. And at least since medicine achieved a near monopoly over matters of health in the United States, the idea that there could be multiple authorities over matters of health is simply rejected out of hand. Medical science is conceived by physicians and lawyers alike to be the only legitimate way of promoting the health of the patient. Especially when the health of children is at stake, the medical and legal communities often unite to preserve the authority of medicine in matters of health, even when the members of a religious minority challenge this authority.[23]

Authority in a Pluralistic World

There has been a serious debate recently about the role of moral and political authority in a pluralistic world.[24] The term authority can be used in its "representation" sense as referring to someone who is given the ability to act or speak on behalf of another, or in its "expert" sense as referring to someone who is recognized simply to be more knowledgeable than most others in a certain domain of inquiry. One of the most important questions in the recent debates concerns whether these two senses should be merged, so that those who have the most knowledge are, by that very fact, more legitimately able to act or speak on behalf of the rest of the population. In contemporary medicine, the physician's authority in terms of expertise is often transmuted into the physician's authority in terms of legitimacy to represent the community in determining how people should behave. One variation of this transmutation occurs when a medical doctor declares that he or she should have the right to decide what is in the best interest of a patient and to mandate that the patient follow the doctor's regimen toward securing that interest.

The exercise of authority by one person over another can restrict the freedom of the other. If the person over whom authority is exercised is a mature adult, then such exercise of authority may be illegitimate insofar as it restricts this person's autonomy. The case of authority exercised over children does not normally raise the same problems since children generally are not thought to have autonomy. Parents must be able to exercise some authority over their children in order to properly instruct and protect them. However questionable the assumption may be in some regards, until quite recently this parental authority was assumed to be nearly inviolable.

Liberalism has traditionally placed very strong emphasis on individual rights to the exclusion of concern for the collective good of various groups. Various liberal theorists have talked of the rights of children, rights that are somewhat weaker than those of mature adults, but nonetheless strong enough to override the claims of various parents, families, or communities to act toward their children in ways that seem likely to harm these children.[25] Communitarians have been the most vociferous in arguing that traditional liberalism entrenches divisiveness and separateness, thereby making it difficult for groups, especially families, to achieve coherence and stability.

In pluralistic societies, there are multiple and overlapping social groups, indeed often so many groups with conflicting goals that it seems impossible to reconcile their competing claims. In such times it seems quite reasonable to focus on the individual rather than the group. But this is a mistake since focusing on the individual ignores issues of common treatment of members of a group.[26] Ethnic, linguistic, and religious groups, when they exist as minority groups within a strongly dominant culture, need some protection from the larger community that may engulf them at any time. Even in liberal societies minority rights have sometimes been trampled, especially the rights of religious minorities.

Charles Taylor has recently argued that there is a version of liberalism which would not so greatly risk harm to the collective goods and identity of minority groups:

A society with strong collective goals can be liberal, on this view, provided it is also capable of respecting diversity, especially when dealing with those who do not share its common goals; and provided that it can offer adequate safeguards for fundamental rights.[27]

The Christian Science refusal cases offer a very good testing ground of Taylor's version of liberalism since, it is often claimed, the right of children to basic levels of health is precisely what is threatened by the collective goals of the Christian Science community. In addition, the Christian Science community's cohesiveness is thought to be threatened by the possibility that the medical community could force Christian Scientists to subject themselves to the power of the scalpel instead of the power of prayer.

The Christian Science refusal cases are better understood as involving a conflict between two communities (Christian Science and biomedicine), than a conflict between two individuals (Christian Science parent and medical physician). The seemingly irreconcilable positions in these cases are due to conflicting world-views and conflicting conceptions of what counts as authoritative in matters of health, rather than as merely a dispute about what should be done for a particular child. Physicians and Christian Scientists act as if much more is at stake than merely the health of a particular child. Indeed, Christian Scientists often talk as if the very future of their church hangs in the balance. And physicians in their turn often talk as if the very future of medical progress or the integrity of medicine is at stake. This is why I think the issue is best addressed as a conflict of groups rather than as a conflict of individuals. While rank-and-file members of each group may voice sympathy for the other, the leadership of these groups, that is, those who speak for the groups themselves, seem hopelessly deadlocked.

The key question here is not only whether the physical health of a child is a fundamental right that should take precedence over such community goods as group cohesiveness, but also whether the medical community should be given exclusive purview in determining what is best for securing that right. The difficulty is that the Christian Science and medical communities give very different, and seemingly incompatible, accounts of what is the best method to secure health. Is this sociopolitical clash of communities something that is subject to compromise, or must one community "win out" even in a pluralisitic society? Taylor has claimed that "liberalism is not a possible meeting ground for all cultures, but is the political expression of one range of cultures, and quite incompatible with other ranges."[28]

Taylor is worried that even in a very diverse pluralistic society some groups may act in such a disruptive manner that they jeopardize the stability and coherence of the larger community. On this view, not all forms of authority can be challengeable. Some limits must be placed, especially where the overall community's survival is at stake or where fundamental rights of individuals are threatened. His view is that only a certain range of cultural diversity can be sustained, and hence only certain minority cultures can be tolerated, in a particular political society. The range of toleration should be determined by whether any fundamental rights of individuals or groups are likely to be violated by a minority culture that is seeking full recognition and respect within the larger community.

I have argued in a similar vein that some sort of compromise between liberalism and communitarianism is needed.[29] I draw a distinction not only between fundamental and non-fundamental rights, but also between systematic and occasional violation of these rights. Such distinctions are necessary since there are many things that could jeopardize the fundamental rights of individuals which hardly anyone would think constituted grounds for excluding the group that so jeopardized these rights. Consider, for example, the suspension of fundamental rights during a state of emergency. Arguably, the curtailment of a person's rights to free speech or freedom of the press, for instance, which would normally be seen as a violation of fundamental individual rights, would not be precluded if the emergency were severe enough.

It must be kept in mind that most cultures risk the occasional violation of some fundamental rights. What normally cannot be tolerated is when a minority culture systematically jeopardizes a fundamental right of the members of the larger community. The Christian Science refusal cases do not show such systematic jeopardizing of fundamental rights. In any event, religious liberty of the members of these groups is of very high value and in a pluralistic society should be given strong weight. Of course, this is not to say, as some Christian Scientists have argued, that this issue can be decided on grounds of religious freedom alone.

Seeking a Compromise

Today, the medical community and the Christian Science community continue to argue that all Christian Science refusal cases be treated alike. According to the American Academy of Pediatrics, neither Robyn Twitchell's nor Colin Newmark's parents should be allowed to refuse to accept medical authority. The position expressed by the AAP is hard to reconcile with the features of a pluralistic society. While it is important to protect fundamental rights, Christian Science is not alone in occasionally jeopardizing the fundamental rights of individuals. But it is relatively alone in discouraging its members from seeking medical diagnoses. Such a stance may pose a systematic risk to the fundamental rights of children. But it is not clear that Christian Scientists as a group should, on their own principles, discourage diagnosis. Indeed, the bylaws of the Christian Science Church state rather clearly that if "a member of this Church has a patient whom he does not heal, and whose case he cannot fully diagnose, he may consult with an M.D. on the anatomy involved."[30]

The compromise I propose involves the following elements. Medical science should be more attuned to the whole person who is the patient, especially in non-life-threatening situations, and hence be open to nonstandard approaches to health. Christian Science should be more open to the diagnostic services of medical science, so that what type of spiritual healing is needed can better be ascertained, and so that informed decisions can be made about when to consider medical help, especially in life-threatening situations. For both of these to occur, the socialization practices of the medical and Christian Science communities must be changed so that their members do not see themselves to be in opposition to each other. Medical professionals should be more open to the possibility that there are, at least, aspects of health that are not their sole purview. Christian Scientists should be more open to the possibility (seemingly admitted by Mary Baker Eddy) that there are aspects of health that are best dealt with by material (at least "mechanical") means.

This approach to resolving, at least temporarily, the stalemate between the Christian Science community and the medical community is more communitarian than liberal, since I remain committed to maintaining the coherence of these two communities. The compromise that I propose is meant to be respectful to both. This is not to say that all of the members of the Christian Science and medical communities will find my approach acceptable. Indeed, I suspect that many members of these communities will reject it. But this just points out to what extent this is a matter of compromise and not necessarily a matter of consensus.

One standard way to think about the divide between communitarianism and liberalism is to think that communitarians believe in consensus and liberals believe in compromise. One of the paradigms of communitarianism is the Quaker meeting, and one of the paradigms of liberalism is deliberations in Congress. Yet for consensus to be achieved in the Quaker meeting many people will have to accept a compromise; and in Congress, the deliberative compromises often center on the common good. In light of these paradigms, I wish to propose that in pluralistic societies the move toward consensus sometimes denies or submerges differences among groups, and that in some cases consensus runs contrary to communitarianism. Some compromises, on the other hand, really do leave group identities intact, since here both parties to a dispute temporarily must give a bit in order to achieve some higher social good.

The Christian Science refusal cases illustrate well the need to think in terms of compromise as well as consensus when conflicts arise between multiple authorities in a pluralistic society.[31] The rights of children, the authority of medicine, and the religious freedom of Christian Science must all be considered and balanced against each other. None of these factors should be considered overriding. Even a temporary solution to this problem can only occur when the Christian Science and medical communities recognize that there are both Colin Newmarks, who may do better without medical intervention, and Robyn Twitchells, who may do better with that intervention.

My proposed compromise is likely to occur only when the medical community becomes willing to give Christian Scientists some room to consider the results of diagnostic testing without worrying that some doctor has already contacted a public prosecutor to force the Christian Scientists to accept proposed medical care. In addition, this change is only likely to occur when the Christian Science community stops discouraging its members from seeking medical diagnoses, and in life-threatening cases, seeking medical care. Just as the socialization practices of the medical community need to change so that its members are more open to the Christian Science community, so the socialization practices of the Christian Science community need to change so that its members are more open to the medical community. Such a change in socialization practices, and the ensuing willingness to compromise, is vital for the survival of a pluralistic society that is as rich, and as diverse, as that in the United States.

Acknowledgments

This paper is a part of a longer manuscript, tentatively titled "The Socially Responsive Self: Essays on Social Theory and Professional Ethics," which was supported by a grant from the National Science Foundation's program in Ethics and Value Studies. I am grateful to Marilyn Friedman, Ralph Lindgren, Peggy DesAutels, Hugh LaFollette, and Carl Weuman for helpful comments on earlier drafts of this paper.

References

[1.] This is a paraphrase of tile opinion voiced by the emergency room physican on call at the hospital where Robyn was taken after death. Most of the details here are taken from Paula A. Monopoli, "Allocating the Costs of Parental Free Exercise: Striking a New Balance between Sincere Religious Belief and a Child's Right to Medical Treatment," Pepperditte Law Review 18 (1991): 323-24. [2.] See Rita Swan,"Faith Healing, Christian Science and the Medical Care of Children," NEJM 309 (1983): 163941. [3.] There is some dispute about this fact. The brief filed by Colin's parents when this case went to the Delaware Supreme Court asserts that the parents consented to this initial operation, at least in part, because of undue pressure by their doctor. [4.] See Patrick Bouldin, case note, Journal of Family Law 30 (1991-92): 673-81. [5.] Bouldin, case note, p. 675. [6.] Newmark v. Williams, 588 A.2d 1108 (Del. 1991). [7.] Mary Baker Eddy, Science and Health (Boston: First Church of Christ Scientist 1971 [1875]), p. 144. [8.] Norman Gevitz, "Christian Science Healing and the Health Care of Children," Perspectives in Biology and Medicine 34, no. 3 (1991): 421-38, at 425. [9.] Eddy, Science and Health. [10.] See Gevitz, "Christian Science Healing," pp. 427-28. [11.] Christian Science Board of Directors, "Christian Scientists and die Practice of Spiritual Healing," Christian Science Sentinel 93 (7 October 1991): 25. [12.] It should be noted that Mary Baker Eddy several times decries medical diagnosis for causing the very disease it seemingly diagnoses. See Science and Health, pp. 161 and 370. [13.] I am grateful to Peggy DesAutels for helping me to see why some Christian Scientists have such a strong reaction against medical diagnosis. [14.] I base this claim on various communications I have had with members of the central office of the Christian Science church in Boston. [15.] Stephen H. Miles, Peter A. Singer, and Mark Siegler, "Conflicts between Patients' Wishes to Forgo Treatment and the Policies of Health Care Facilities," NEJM 321 (1989): 48-50. [16.] The most notable exception is Norman Gevitz, "Christian Science Healing." [17.] Qtioted in Ronald Munson's popular textbook, Intervention and Reflection: Basic Issues in Medical Ethics, 4th ed. (Belmont, Calif.: Wadsworth Publishing Co., 1992), p.262. [18.] Monopoli, "Allocating the Costs of Parental Free Exercise," p. 331, [19.] Gevitz, "Christian Science Healing." p. 429. [20.] New York Times, 19 December 1993. [21.] As quoted in Emanuel Goldberger, How Physicians Think (Springfield, Ill.: Charles C. Thomas Publisher, 1965), p. ix. [22.] See Paul Ramsey, The Patient as Person (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1970). [23.] But things may be changing. At the appellate level both the Newmark and Twitchell cases were decided in favor of the Christian Science parents. [24.] For a good general discussion of the various issues involved in this debate see Richard De George, The Nature and Limits of Authority (Lawrence: University Press of Kansas, 1985). [25.] For a good selection of positions on this issue see William Aiken and Hugh LaFollette, Whose Child? Children's Rights, Parental Authority, and State Power (Totowa, NJ.: Littlefield, Adams, 1980). [26.] See my discussion of this point in the final chapter of Larry May, The Morality of Groups (Notre Dame, Ind.: University of Notre Dame Press, 1987). [27.] Charles Taylor, multiculturalism and the politics of Recognition (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1992), p. 59. [28.] Taylor, Multiculturalism, p. 62. [29.] See the last chapter of Larry May, Sharing Responsibility (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1992). [30.] Mary Baker Eddy, Church Manual of the First Church of Christ Scientist, in Boston, Mass. (Boston: The First Church of Christ Scientist, 1936 [1895]), p. 47. Some Christian Scientists also cite Science and Health, p. 444, where Mary Baker Eddy says that temporarily one may take a medical approach to healing. [31.] See Martin Benjamin, Splitting the Difference: Compromise and Integrity in Ethics and Politics (Lawrence: University Press of Kansas, 1990).
COPYRIGHT 1995 Hastings Center
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 1995 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Author:May, Larry
Publication:The Hastings Center Report
Date:Jan 1, 1995
Words:6162
Previous Article:Caring for patients in cross-cultural settings.
Next Article:The pro-life maternal-fetal medicine physician: a problem of integrity.
Topics:

Terms of use | Privacy policy | Copyright © 2026 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters |