Printer Friendly

Price paid is high enough (sexual abuse of Native students at Gordon Indian residential school in Saskatchewan).

SAINT JOHN, N.B.

William Peniston Starr said he is "surprised and disappointed" by the number of lawsuits resulting from the years he sexually abused former students at the Gordon Indian residential school in Saskatchewan.

Starr, the former director of the school's students, denied the sexual abuse was as widespread as the lawsuits suggest.

More than 100 former students of the residential school have filed civil lawsuits in the Court of Queen's Bench as a result of sexual and physical abuse at the government-run school on the Gordon reserve north of Regina.

Starr, 66, was convicted three years ago of 10 counts of sexually assaulting 10 male students, ages seven to 14, when he was the administrator of the residential school between November 1960 and June 1981.

He was sentenced to four-and-one-half years in jail in 1993 and was released on Feb. 13, 1996.

"I pleaded guilty, I was incarcerated and I'm still in treatment -- what more can I say?" Starr said in a telephone interview on Wednesday from his home in New Brunswick. "I'm still trying to get my life back together."

Starr said he is "surprised and disappointed" when told of the number of lawsuits filed against him and federal government.

More than half of the 106 lawsuits filed so far have been settled out of court and more than $3 million in compensation has been paid to the victims.

"Good God," he said when told of the number of lawsuits, "they are certainly not all legitimate."

Starr, who is reunited with his wife, believes he has paid a high enough price for his sexual abuse and said the lawsuits are making it difficult for him to get on with his life.

"It is creating a great deal of stress," he said, adding he still suffers from bouts of depression. "I realize I wrecked their [the victim's] lives, but I also wrecked my life and there's nothing I can say to change things.

"There was so much wrong-doing, but I can't say how guilty and ashamed I am," he said. "They [the victims] would never believe me anyway."

One of Starr's early victims, who asked not to be identified, said he is struggling with emotional problems stemming from years of sexual abuse.

"There's a part of me that's angry and there's a part of me that says I should forgive," he said in a telephone interview Thursday. "I don't know what to think, I have a lot of anger for him, although my life has changed over the years."

The victim was also not impressed with Starr's comments, saying they fall short of an apology.

"He makes it sound as though it wasn't entirely his fault and it makes me angry to know he's already out of jail," he said.

In releasing Starr last February, the National Parole Board ordered him not to contact any of his victims or children under the age of 13 unless supervised.

The board also noted the former school administrator has undertaken numerous treatment programs and individual counseling for sexual abuse during his time in jail.

"You have come a long way in recognizing your behavior, accepting full responsibility, increased insight, victim empathy, and have developed a release prevention plan," the board told Starr in granting his release.

"Although it is not apparent that you have resolved your sexual identity, continued counseling and support will assist you in this regard," the board said.

The board also expressed concern about the effect the civil lawsuits would have on Starr.

"This is seen by the board as a stressor and must be managed by you (Starr), your wife and your supervisor."
COPYRIGHT 1997 Aboriginal Multi-Media Society of Alberta (AMMSA)
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 1997 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Author:Sutter, Trevor
Publication:Wind Speaker
Date:Mar 1, 1997
Words:606
Previous Article:Museum takes the `Native' out of Native gallery (Provincial Museum of Alberta).
Next Article:Agreement signed (between Yale First Nation and governments of Canada and B.C.).
Topics:


Related Articles
No rez school resolution is sight.
Dirty tricks alleged in residential school lawsuits.
Federal government settles with abuse victims (Gordon Indian Residential School).
Catholic residential school employees convicted.
Shingwauk's vision: a history of native residential schools.
There is danger in using people's pain (some worry lawyers may encourage victims of residential school system to sue gov't).
AIRS (Alberni Indian Residential School) trial resumes in Nanaimo court.
Sins of the fathers: the legacy of Indian residential schools is one of physical and emotional scars, nasty lawsuits, a questionable medical study,...
Church and government on trial (case launched by former students at Indian residential school in Port Alberni).
(Ovide) Mercredi says feds response inadequate.

Terms of use | Privacy policy | Copyright © 2026 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters |