Printer Friendly

J.W. Spencer (1851-1921): his life in Canada, and his work on preglacial river valleys.


J.W. Spencer, born and buried in Dundas, Ontario, was a pioneer Canadian geomorphologist. After attending school in Dundas, he moved to Hamilton where he worked in a pharmacy, and was encouraged by local amateur geologists. He attended McGill University from 1871 to 1874, studied under William Dawson and Bernard Harrington, and graduated in the newly reorganized Applied Sciences program. He spent the summer of 1874 working as Robert Bell's assistant in Manitoba, and the following summer working in the Michigan copper mines as an assistant to a mine engineer, Luther Emerson. He obtained a position as science teacher at Hamilton Collegiate Institute (Fig. 1) in 1876. In 1877 he submitted his thesis on Michigan copper deposits to the university at G6ttingen, Germany and that summer he visited the university, passed his oral examinations and was awarded the Ph.D., becoming the second Canadian to earn a doctorate in geology. In 1880 he became Professor at King's College, Windsor, Nova Scotia. He concentrated his geological studies on the region around his birthplace at the head of Lake Ontario: at first mainly Paleozoic geology and paleontology, but by 1880 he had switched decisively to surficial geology, particularly the preglacial drainage of Lakes Erie and Ontario. In 1880 he travelled extensively in the United States and attended the AAAS meeting in Boston, where he met J.P. Lesley, who encouraged him to continue his studies of preglacial rivers. In 1882 he accepted a position as Professor and Director of the Museum of Natural History at the University of Missouri.



J.W. Spencer qui est ne eta ete inhume chez lui a Dundas en Ontario a ete un geomorphologue canadien qui a fait oeuvre de pionnier. Apres avoir ete 5. l'ecole a Dundas, il a demenage 5. Hamilton ou il a travaille dans une pharmacie, et c'est a ce moment que des geologues amateurs l'ont encourage a aller de l'avant. Il a frequente l'Universite McGill de 1871 a 1874, oh il a recu les enseignements de William Dawson et dc Bernard Harrington, et suivi avec succes la formation du programme nouvellement refondu en sciences appliquees. Durant l'ete de 1874, il a ete l'assistant de Robert Bell au Manitoba et, l'ete suivant, il a travaille dans les mines de cuivre du Michigan ou il a ete l'assistant Luther Emerson, ingenieur minier. En 1876, il a obtenu le poste de professeur de science a l'Institut collegial Hamilton (Fig. 1). En 1877, il a soumis sa these sur les gisements de cuivre du Michigan a l'universite de G6ttingen en Allemagne, et durant l'ete il s'est rendu a l'universite, y a passe ses examens oraux, puis a obtenu son Ph.D., devenant le deuxieme Canadien a obtenir un doctorat en geologie. En 1880, il est devenu professeur au King's College, a Windsor en Nouvelle-Ecosse. Il a concentre ses recherches geologiques sur la region de son lieu de naissance, a la source du lac Ontario : il s'est d'abord principalement interesse la geologie et a la paleontologie du Paldozoique, mais en 1880 ses interets avaient carrement change pour se porter sur la geologie de la surface, particulierement le drainage preglaciaire des lacs Ontario et Erie. En 1880, il a beaucoup voyage aux Etats-Unis, participant au congres de I'AAAS (association etasunienne pour l'avancement des sciences) a Boston, ou il a rencontre J. E Lesley qui l'a encourage a continuer ses recherches sur les cours d'eau prd-glaciaires. En 1882, il a accepte un poste de professeur et de directeur au musee d'histoire naturelle de l'Universite du Missouri.



Joseph Winthrop Spencer is probably unknown to most Canadian geologists, though the name may be familiar to some who have worked on the Quaternary of the Great Lakes region. His life and work are worth reviewing on several counts: Spencer was a native of Dundas, Ontario, and was one of the early investigators of the Paleozoic geology and paleontology of the region around the head of Lake Ontario. He was the second Canadian to earn a doctorate degree, with a thesis accepted by the university in Gottingen, Germany in 1877 (Middleton, 2003). For most of his life, he worked on preglacial river valleys in Ontario, and the origin and extent of proglacial precursors of the Great Lakes. In 1907 the Geological Survey of Canada published his book-length study of the origin of Niagara Falls (Spencer, 1907). Spencer taught high school in Hamilton, and was later a Professor at King's College in Windsor, Nova Scotia, but in 1882, at the age of 31, be left Canada for an appointment at the University of Missouri. He also served as State Geologist for Missouri and Georgia, before settling as a consultant geologist in Washington, D.C. Throughout his life he travelled widely, and often visited Canada to carry out further field investigations. In 1919 he returned for good, intending to live in Toronto, but died on October 9, 1921, before he could take possession of his new home.

Spencer was born in Dundas on March 26, 1851, and is buried there, in the family grave. He was the great grandson of Robert Spencer, an United Empire Loyalist and pioneer settler in Stamford township, Upper Canada (now Niagara Falls, Ontario). Spencer's father, Joseph, and his uncle, Benjamin (sons of Adam Spencer, ?1775-1815), moved to Dundas about 1828, and in 1834 his father built the Gore Grist Mills in Dundas, on the creek, known ever since as Spencer's Creek. Joseph, Jr. was his only son, and Joseph Sr. died by falling from the roof of the mill only a few months after his son's birth (Woodhouse, 1965, Part 2, p.5-6). The son, christened Joseph William, grew up in Dundas with his mother and five elder sisters, and was one of the first pupils to attend the new Union School, built in 1857. He became interested in natural history and chemistry, in part because of the setting of his home, near the head of the Dundas valley, and in part because of the influence of his teacher, J. Howard Hunter. Shaw (1924) recorded that "At fifteen Spencer outfitted a little chemical laboratory of his own and was becoming especially interested in the chemical characters of the minerals, rocks, and waters of the region in which he lived. At sixteen he was attempting quantitative analysis and all the while making short field trips, commonly with his teacher, who shared his enthusiasm ..."

About this time (1866), Spencer completed his school education, and he and his mother moved to Hamilton, where one of his married sisters (Annie Warren) also lived. Spencer went to work as an assistant at "T. Bickle, Retail and Wholesale Chemist" (see Sources and Notes), and began to associate with a group of Hamilton amateur geologists, at least two of whom (Col. Grant, and D.EH. Wilkins) were prominent in the Hamilton Association for the Advancement of Literature, Science and Art (Armstrong, 1958). Grant was a well-known fossil collector (Hewitt, 1986); for Wilkins see Sources and Notes.

In 1871 Spencer left for McGill University. He graduated in 1874 from the new program in Applied Science, obtaining a B.A.Sc. "with First Rank in Geology and Mineralogy." His teachers certainly included William Dawson and Bernard Harrington. Shaw (1924) claimed that Sterry Hunt and Elkanah Billings were also among his teachers, but Hunt taught at McGill only until 1868, and left in 1872 to become Professor at MIT (Zaslow, 1975, p.102; Boyle, 1993), and Billings never held an appointment at McGill (Clark, 1971), so if Spencer received instruction from them, it must have been informally. Shaw also claimed that Spencer won a Dufferin medal (the forerunner of the present Governor General's medals) but McGill has no record of this, and Spencer himself never claimed it. Spencer clearly adopted William Dawson as a surrogate father: he was strongly influenced by his views, particularly as regards glaciation (see below), corresponded with him faithfully until 1895, sought his assistance in obtaining teaching positions, and depended on him for advice, and for the loan of books, papers, and surveying equipment.

Following graduation, Spencer worked for the summer of 1874 for the Geological Survey of Canada as assistant to Robert Bell in the new Province of Manitoba (Shaw, 1924). The scientific results from this field season were meagre, but Robert Bell remained a friend for life. If Dawson was Spencer's surrogate father, Bell was his surrogate elder brother: his letters to Bell were more forthright, and extended from 1874 to about 1910 (luckily for historians, Bell never threw away any papers, not even letters marked "Destroy after Reading"! There is a break in the correspondence between March 1889 and December 1893: perhaps this resulted from their divergent views about glaciation).

Returning to Ontario in the fall, Spencer was unable to find work because of the recession then in progress. In June 1875 he left for Marquette, Michigan, and was hired as assistant to Luther G. Emerson, an engineer working for several of the native copper mines in the Upper Michigan Peninsula (BP, Sept. 12, 1875; see also Lankton, 1991). This work later became the basis of his doctorate degree. By the end of the year he was back in Canada, again searching unsuccessfully for work. 1876 was not a good year for Spencer: his brother in law (Peter Warren, married to Annie) was dying, and his mother and another sister were very ill. Nevertheless, Spencer managed to broaden his geological education that summer. He probably returned to Michigan, and he certainly visited mining and steel production regions in Pennsylvania (BP, Nov.23, 1876). Returning to Hamilton, he obtained a position as science teacher at Hamilton Collegiate Institute (HCI). His mother died in December.


In a letter to Bell (BP, Nov. 23, 1876), Spencer complained that he "... received the promise of a Mastership in Upper Canada College at a salary of $1000, board and lodging, etc ..." but when he returned to Hamilton in the fall "... there had been a dispute in the Council and some of the members would not allow my appointment because 'a McGill man must not deprive a Toronto man when the two are even' ..." Early in 1877, he wrote again describing his appointment at HCI: "The salary ... was the paltry sum of $600 but raised to $700 and with the standing of ... head of a department. There are fourteen teachers ... I have four classes in Chemistry, Physiology, Physical Geography, and shortly Geology, Botany, Zoology and Physics. In the meantime I have a class in Latin and others in History and Geography [it is not clear how that adds up to four!] ... I am going to try and make this the best science school in the Province outside of University College." (BP, Jan. 21, 1877).

The headmaster at HCI was George Dickson, and Spencer lodged with him during his first term of teaching. Though Dickson was trained in classical languages, he had a strong interest in geology. Beginning in 1873, he was active on the executive of the Hamilton Association, and was the first chair of the Geological Section established in 1883 (Armstrong, 1958). He was successful in making HCI one of the leading high schools in Ontario, and in 1885 he was appointed Principal of Upper Canada College (Rose, 1888). He lost this position in the reorganization of 1895, but with his wife, he founded St. Margaret's College for women, where he remained President until his death in 1910 (Morgan, 1912). He and Spencer remained friends for many years after Spencer left Hamilton.

While he was at HCI, Spencer certainly knew and taught Chemistry to Andrew Lawson, who was raised in Hamilton, Ontario, and was a star pupil at HCI from December 1878 until June 1880. Lawson worked part-time for the Hamilton Spectator, and considered becoming a journalist, or a medical doctor. A summer position as legal journalist in Montreal, and attendance at two courses at McGill soon convinced him that he was not cut out for either profession. In the fall he enrolled at the University of Toronto, and after working as an assistant to Robert Bell in 1882 in the Prairies (Lawson, 1926), he decided to become a geologist. He worked three more field seasons (in the Lake-of-the-Woods region), completed his M.Sc. in 1885, and was hired full-time by the Geological Survey. In 1890, after resigning from the Survey, he accepted a position at the University of California in Berkeley, where he remained for the rest of his long life (Vaughan, 1970). Though there is little evidence that be was influenced by Spencer, he is known to have presented a paper in 1885 to the Hamilton Association entitled "The physical development of the Niagara escarpment." This address was never published and the manuscript cannot be found in the Hamilton Association papers, or in Lawson's papers at Berkeley.

As a means of obtaining a better appointment, Spencer began to improve his professional credentials. In 1877, with the help of Dawson and Bell, he became a Fellow of the Geological Society of London, and he began to write up his Michigan work as a thesis to be submitted to the University of Gettingen, in Germany. Why Gettingen? The school was perhaps recommended to him by Bernard Harrington, his chemistry instructor at McGill. When Harrington completed his doctorate at Yale in 1871, it was perhaps the leading centre of geological studies in the USA. Clarence King, who later became Director of the U.S. Geological Survey, graduated there in 1863, and so did Arnold Hague, who spent the following three years studying in Germany, where he met another American, S.F. Emmons (Middleton, 2003; see also Geschwind, 1994). Their experiences were certainly transmitted to Harrington's instructors at Yale: none of Spencer's other friends and mentors had any experience of German universities.

Obtaining a doctorate was not then the arduous task that it later became. Even at famous German universities, a doctorate was earned mainly by passing qualifying exams, and by writing and defending a thesis. Spencer wrote to Dawson (DL, Oct. 31,1879):
 "Six months before I went to Germany,
 the College Authorities accepted my
 Monograph on the Copper-Bearing
 Rocks as my thesis. And then, sending
 my application and sketches of my life in
 Latin, I was admitted to the examinations
 for the degree on the 20th of July 1877.
 The special subjects of the oral were
 Geology (particularly Paleontology) and
 Mineralogy, as the leading subjects, with
 Natural History as secondary."

Spencer wrote his thesis in English and spent less than two months in Germany (McGill archives, letter to Harrington, May 30, 1877). When the thesis work was published in Canadian Naturalist however (Spencer, 1878a), Spencer acknowledges the assistance of Emerson and Bell, but does not mention any of the instructors at Gottingen. After his second visit to Europe (in 1886) he wrote (BP, Sept. 27, 1886):
 "When I was in Europe before, I came
 home without any wish to go back again."

During the three years that he taught at HCI, Spencer was hard at work on the geology of Southern Ontario. He published his first papers, which as well as his thesis included a paper on the taxonomy of the local graptolire fauna (Spencer, 1878b; based largely on specimens collected by Colonel Grant); began to prepare a series of papers on the Paleozoic geology; and most important of all, began to take a keen interest in the local gcomorphology and surficial geology. He took a particular interest in the origin of the Dundas valley, where the well records revealed a gorge buried deep beneath the present valley. He wrote to Bell (BP, Apr. 21, 1879):
 "... either there must have been a deep
 gorge scooped out by the close of the
 Pliocene, or else there is evidence of glacial
 action, and the Dundas valley, so[?] near
 to the lake, must have been a sort of fiord."

In March of that year, he wrote to Dawson (DP, Mar. 17, 1879):
 "... I am hoping to work up the subject. I
 have the use of surveying instruments,
 and I hope with the fine weather to collect
 all the facts I can, and get the accurate
 levels, so as to work up the geology of the
 head of Lake Ontario."

Dawson, after reading the list of all Spencer's activities (which included giving private lessons in geology to the Rev. Samuel Lyle, of Central Presbyterian Church, Hamilton: see Sources and Notes) wrote back:
 "I fear ... that you are working too hard.
 Be cautious lest you overtask your brain."

In a paper, published a few years later (Spencer, 1882, p. 229) Spencer recalled:
 "Having procured all the levels that ... were
 available, it became necessary to connect
 several places myself by instrumental
 measurements, which work was
 accomplished with the aid of Prof.
 Wilkins ... [so that by 1880] the proof that
 the ancient Grand river flowed down the
 Dundas valley was completed ..."


Despite his ambitions for science at the Hamilton Collegiate Institute, Spencer actively sought a better position. Already on August 27, 1878, Spencer had written to Dawson asking for a letter of support for his application for a position in Natural Sciences at the University of Virginia. In 1879, Henry How, a well known mineralogist and Professor at King's College, in Nova Scotia, died and the college began to look for a replacement (Vroom, 1941, p. 103-125). Kings was a small Anglican university, located at Windsor N.S. (Fig. 2): it later moved to Halifax and became part of Dalhousie University. Dawson wrote to the Principal, Professor Dart, recommending Spencer, and in October Spencer reported that he sent further testimonials from Dr. Harrington (Director of Applied Science at McGill), Dr. Robert Bell, and Mr. A.R.C. Selwyn (the Director of GSC). Letters had also been sent by Howard Hunter (he had moved from Dundas to become Principal at Brantford high school), and George Dickson. The Rev. James Carmichael, Rector of the Church of the Ascension, in Hamilton, wrote on his behalf to Bishop Binney: he mentioned in his letter that he knew Spencer not only in Hamilton, but also from his years in Montreal. Carmichael had an interest in science, was a keen microscopist, and a member of the Natural History Society of Montreal (see Sources and Notes). The Bishop, as President of the Board of Governors of Kings, would have had much influence in the appointment (McGill archives includes printed copies of all these letters). It is quite likely that Spencer became an Anglican while he was a student in Montreal: his uncles were Methodists, and so was his mother (census of 1871), and Spencer was not baptized in the Anglican Church in Dundas (the baptismal records are held at McMaster University). Spencer's change from his family's Methodism to Anglicanism, however, was not a conversion of convenience: he remained a committed Anglican throughout his life (Shaw, 1924).


Spencer wrote to Dawson (DP, Oct. 31, 1879) :
 "I preferred the position from the fact that
 I would have nothing but Science to
 teach, and be quite independent of that
 miserable Central Committee in Toronto.
 And again, it would be easier to get a still
 higher position, at some future day, even
 from a small college. Moreover my work
 ought to be pleasanter for I could shape
 my own courses."

He also mentioned that, should a position open up at the University of Toronto, he would be a candidate. This is the first of many references in his letters to his ambition to replace Edward J. Chapman as Professor of Geology in Toronto. After 1885, Spencer was discretely assisted in this ambition by George Dickson, who as Principal of Upper Canada College, was on the Board of the University of Toronto. Chapman had been serving there since 1853, but in fact he did not retire until 1895!

In March 1880 Spencer was apparently already at King's College. He wrote to Dawson (DP, Mar. 4, 1880):
 "I have very comfortable class rooms
 now ... I like [President Dart] very much
 indeed. So also the Prof. of Math. whose
 room is next to mine and consequently
 see every day ... [the college has] gone to
 about $400 expenses for my dept. since I
 came, but I expect to get no more out of

Nevertheless that summer he considered applying for a position to teach Geology, Zoology and Botany at Queen's University in Kingston, Ontario: as we will see, he soon became disillusioned with the Board of Governors at King's, and with President Dart.

He started to prepare his studies at the head of Lake Ontario as a large monograph in three parts. He returned from Nova Scotia to carry out an ambitious series of field studies, and wrote to Bell (BP, Nov. 18, 1880):
 "I had a good expedition up the
 Assemetquagan River, Quebec [a tributary
 of the Matapedia River in Gaspesie],
 visited my friends ... at Brampton Falls,
 Montreal, Ottawa, Kingston, Toronto,
 Brantford, three or four smaller places,
 Detroit, Cleveland, Albany, and Boston,
 where the AAAS meeting was held for
 nine days. I met lots of eminent people,
 made a number of nice friends, and have
 lots of invitations to the States, even as far
 south as Georgia for Christmas ..."

At the AAAS meeting in Boston, he met J.P. Lesley, the Director of the Pennsylvania Geological Survey, and a prominent geologist with a special interest in fluvial geomorphology (Chorley et al., 1964, p. 346-354). Lesley encouraged Spencer's interest in buried river valleys, and was perhaps more influential than any other person in determining Spencer's future research.

On February 3, 1881, he wrote to Lesley:
 "My paper on the Preglacial drainage is
 nearly ready ..."

And he wrote to Bell (BP, Feb. 19, 1881):
 "When you see the proofs you will be
 astonished. The work was carefully done
 with levels by the railways and myself. It
 is the best thing I ever did."

On March 1, 1881, he wrote again to Lesley:
 "At last, I have finished a manuscript for
 you ... After having printed this, I will
 supplement it next year ... and I will try
 and make the two papers contain my
 whole study of the Preglacial Drainage. I
 think I have a clue to the outlet of Lake
 Ontario, but of course it is more theoretical
 at present than based on my own
 observations. But next summer I will try
 and work out the truth."

 "Since seeing you, new life has been
 infused into my work. Living in this
 isolated region, one is very apt to get in a
 state of lethargy, when he never or rarely
 meets scientific men, and all reading is
 rather dry, after one's college duties are
 over for the day ... [at Boston] I think that
 you impressed in me more enthusiasm
 than all others, and so, if for nothing else,
 my visit to Philadelphia [during the
 Christmas vacation of 1880] amply
 rewarded me for the long journey."

The paper that Spencer referred to was his "Discovery of the Preglacial outlet of the Basin of Lake Erie ..." which was published in the Proceedings of the American Philosophical Society (Spencer, 1881; see his illustration reproduced herein as Fig. 3), and republished by Lesley in his Second Geological Survey of Pennsylvania (see Shaw, 1924, for reference).


>From this time on, Spencer set aside most of his other interests and concentrated on the geologically recent [i.e., post-Pliocene] history of the Great Lakes. The summer of 1881 was spent in an even more extensive field season in southern Ontario and upper New York State, and ended at another AAAS meeting, that year in Cincinnati, Ohio. In June he wrote to Bell (BP, June 12, 1881):
 "I would like to devote my whole time
 for a year or two to Fluvial Geology of
 America. It is a magnificent new field of

Though he did eventually carry out his program of fieldwork, many years were to pass before Spencer developed his mature thoughts on this subject (for a short summary of his later views on the modern Great Lake basins, see Spencer, 1890, from which an illustration is provided here as Fig. 4).


However, King's College was in the early stages of a major upheaval, which has been well documented recently in articles by Roper (e.g., 1999). Spencer was only marginally involved, but felt that he had been misled and betrayed by President Dart.

Even though he had been promoted to Vice-President, he reported to Dawson in the spring of 1882 (DP, April 5, 1882):
 "I have long been intending to go to the
 States, if I cannot do better here ... I have
 Friends ... trying to give me a position at
 Georgia State University."

The Georgia appointment came several years later, but by September 1882 he had left Canada for an appointment at the State University, in Columbia, Missouri (at a salary of $2000, substantially larger than anything that King's could offer). The position had been offered first to William Dawson himself, but he declined it and suggested Spencer.


Though his letters indicate that he was prepared at first to consider a glacial origin for the Great Lake basins, Spencer soon came to believe that the basins were largely fluvial in origin, formed by a preglacial river system. He was ambivalent about whether or not they were ever filled by ice sheets during the Ice Age. He would admit they were somewhat modified by glacial abrasion and deposition, but he thought that ice sheets, if they existed, would have been quite thin and incapable of eroding the basins themselves. He mostly ascribed glacial striae to the action of floating ice, and even attributed many moraines to accumulations from stranded icebergs (in these ideas he was strongly influenced by William Dawson: cf. Brookes, 2002). Later he became strongly opposed to the theory that proglacial lakes were formed by the agency of huge glacial dams. Spencer's view that glaciers, particularly ice sheets, were incapable of major erosion was not unusual in the nineteenth century. It was shared by Charles Lyell, J.E Lesley, T.G. Bonney, and many other noted geologists, even after the publication of Ramsay's book (1863), which is often cited as establishing the power of glacial erosion (for documentation see the review in Totten and White, 1985; and Chapter 2 of Tesmer, 1989). Indeed, exactly how effective ice sheets are as erosive agents was somewhat controversial even recently: for example, Chapman and Putnam (1984, p. 6) wrote:
 "The amount of erosion accomplished by
 the great Pleistocene glaciers is not subject
 to accurate measurement ... Most active
 erosion of the bedrock occurred on the
 brows of the escarpments and along the
 lowland routes taken by the principal
 streams of ice. The basins of Lakes
 Ontario, Huron and Superior extend to
 below sea level; as such scooping-out
 could not have been the work of a river, it
 is attributed to the glaciers, although this
 is the subject of some debate."

Spencer pioneered in the discovery of field evidence for preglacial river valleys. These included the channel at the head of Lake Ontario (Dundas) and another crossing the Niagara peninsula south of St. Catharines. His view, based on his studies of bedrock topography, was that before the glacial period (widely believed at that time to be quite short), the Lake Erie and Ontario basins were river valleys, and that the river, which he called the Erigan River, originally flowed north up the Grand River valley, then east through the Dundas buried gorge to the Ontario basin, with an exit near the present exit at the east end of Lake Ontario. Later investigations allowed him to extend and modify his scheme somewhat.

Buried channels exist, and remain incompletely explained (for a summary of work carried out in the United States not long after Spencer, see Bork, 2003; for later work, Flint, 1971, p. 232-239). Spencer's overall scheme of drainage has been reproduced frequently, more recently (with sceptical comments) by Tinkler (1994). Later work has revealed a much longer, more complex history of glaciation than was known in the nineteenth century, so channels buried in drift may be interglacial rather than preglacial. Nevertheless, Spencer's reconstruction of an ancient Great Lake river system, though regarded as speculative, was fairly generally accepted. After his work, little progress was made in Canada for many years. Recently, Greenhouse and Monier-Williams (1986) showed, using geophysical methods, that the Dundas valley ends abruptly (perhaps at a waterfall) near Copetown (a few miles west of Dundas). Flint and Lolcama (1986) confirmed the existence of Spencer's Erigan channel (south of St. Catharines). The larger role of the Erigan River remains unclear. Some American workers (e.g., Hansen, 1987) have suggested that the buried Teays channels in Ohio, Indiana and Illinois, whose status as a major preglacial drainage system also remains controversial, may have originally flowed northeast into the Erigan system.


I thank John Drake for drawing my attention to Spencer, and assisting materially in the early stages of research on his family and life. Archivists at McGill (especially Johanne Pelletier and Kathi Murphy), the National Archives of Canada, the American Philosophical Society, University of Manitoba (especially Brett Lougheed), McMaster University, the Hamilton Public Library, the Hamilton Educational Archives, and the Dundas Historical Museum (as well as several other libraries) were all very helpful. William Brisbin at the University of Manitoba, and Henry Roper at Dalhousie kindly supplied me with archival materials. Professors Otto Walliser and Dieter Meischner generously answered my queries about Spencer at Gottingen. I also thank my wife and friends for putting up with interminable reports about this study, my first real attempt at historical research, over the last three years. Comments from referees Ian A. Brookes and Randall E Miller helped improve the presentation.


Much of this article is based on archival (unpublished) sources. These include letters to William Dawson in the McGill archives (cited as DP, followed by the date of the letter), to Robert Bell in the National Archives (BP), and to J.P. Lesley in the American Philosophical Library in Philadelphia (LP). In quoting from the letters, I have standardized the spelling, capitalization, and punctuation. There is also an archive of Spencer's papers (SP) at the University of Manitoba, but unfortunately it includes almost no letters. The Canadian census of 1881 (available at, early Hamilton directories, and copies of Spencer's family's wills, have also been useful. A good bibliography of Spencer's publications is given by Shaw (1924), and the Bibliography of North American Geology gives an even more complete list. The only other obituary was a brief note by Holm (1921). Throughout his life, Spencer contributed to numerous Who's Who publications: the most informative entries are in the second edition (1910) of American Men of Science (Spencer was a "starred" geologist--meaning that the editors considered him to be among the top 100 geologist in America at that time); and in the first (1898) and second (1912) editions of Canadian Men and Women of the Time, edited by H.J. Morgan.

Throughout his life Spencer always signed his letters and papers "J.W. Spencer." He was christened Joseph William, but some time before his marriage (in 1896) he apparently decided to use the name "Winthrop," because he believed he was descended from the family that included the first Governors of Massachusetts and Connecticut. He never used three initials in his signature, though some reference works (see above) used all three first names. His marriage certificate is the first document which used Winthrop as well as William. His gravestone is engraved "J. Winthrop Spencer, Geologist," and the date of birth is given erroneously as 1850 (the same date is found in the first edition of Canadian Men and Women of the Time, but is corrected in the second edition). The medal later established by his wife as a memorial at the University of Manitoba is entitled the "Winthrop Spencer Gold Medal," awarded "for outstanding achievement in geological research by a student or graduate of the [university]." Recipients have included such well-known geologists as Thomas Oliver, Andrew Baillie, Peter Laznicka, and William Last.

For Tristram Biclde and his son John Wesley Bickle see Anonymous (1981) and Katz (1975, p.196).

James Carmichael (1835-1908) served as Rector of the Church of the Ascension, Hamilton, from 1878 to 1881. Before that he was an assistant at St. George's in Montreal. He became Bishop of Montreal in 1906 (K.M., 1991).

Samuel Lyle (1841-1919) emigrated to Canada in 1877, and the next year was appointed pastor of Central Presbyterian Church in Hamilton. He became one of the leading Presbyterian clergymen in Canada. He admired German philosophy and scholarship, and was a spokesman for liberal Protestantism. He was active in the Hamilton Association and twice served as its President--which probably explains his interest in geology (Hanlon, 1991).

David Francis Henry Wilkins (b. 1846) was a school teacher. When Spencer first met him he was teaching music in Hamilton. He attended McGill at about the same time as Spencer, and graduated in Applied Science a year after Spencer (McGill archives). He published five papers on geology, three in the Canadian Naturalist, two in the Journal and Proceedings of the Hamilton Association. In 1881 he was teaching in Chatham (census), and in 1890, when he published his last papers he was headmaster of Beamsville highschool (east of Hamilton).


Anonymous, 1981, Bickle, John Wesley, in Bailey, T.M., ed., Dictionary of Hamilton Biography, W.L. Griffin, v. 1, p. 18-19.

Armstrong, H.S., 1958, Geology in the Association, in MacBain, C.H., and others, 1958, The Hamilton Association for the Advancement of Literature, Science and Art: 100th Anniversary 1857-1957, Hamilton, Ontario, p. 41-51.

Bork, K.B., 2003, New frontiers: The evolution Of William G. Tight from geomorphologist to university president: Earth Sciences History, v. 22, p. 10-35.

Boyle, R.W., 1993, Geochemistry at the Geological Survey of Canada, 1842-1952: Earth Sciences History, v. 12, p. 129-141.

Brookes, I.A., 2002, GM Dawson and the glaciation of Western Canada: Geoscience Canada, v. 29, p. 169-178.

Chapman, L.J., and Pumant, D.E, 1984, The Physiography of Southern Ontario: Third Edition, Ontario Geological Survey Special Volume 2, 270 p.

Chorley, R.J., Dunn, A.J., and Beckinsale, R.P., 1964, The History of the Study of Landforms or the Development of Geomorphology: John Wiley and Sons, v. 1, 678 p.

Clark, "T.H., 1971, Elkanah Billings (1820-1876)--Canada's first paleontologist. Geological Association of Canada Proceedings, v. 23, p. 11-14.

Flint, J.J. and Lolcama, J., 1986. Buried ancestral drainage between Lake Erie and Ontario. Geological Society of America, Bulletin, v. 97, p. 75-84.

Flint, R.E, 1971, Glacial and Quaternary Geology: John Wiley and Sons, 892 p.

Geschwlnd, C-H., 1994, The beginnings of microscopic petrography in the United States, 1870-1885. Earth Sciences History, v. 13, p. 35-46.

Greenhouse, J.P. and Monier-Williams, M., 1986, A gravity survey of the Dundas buried valley west of Copetown, Ontario. Canadian Journal of Earth Sciences, v. 23, p. 110-114.

Hanlon, P., 1991, Lyle, Samuel: in Bailey, T.M., ed., Dictionary of Hamilton Biography, WL. Griffin, v. 2, p. 95-99.

Hansen, M.C., 1987, The Teays River: Ohio Division of Geological Survey, Ohio Geology, Summer issue, p. 1-6.

Hewitt, R.A., 1986, Paleontological work of Lt. Col. C.C. Grant on the Silurian rocks of the Niagara Escarpment at Hamilton, Ontario: Geoscience Canada, v. 13, no. 4, p. 270-276

Holm, T., 1921, Joseph Winthrop Spencer: American Journal of Science, ser.5, v. 2, p. 363-364.

Katz, M.B., 1975, The People of Hamilton, Canada West: Family and Class in a Mid-Nineteenth Century City: Harvard University Press, 381 p.

K.M., 1991, Carmichael, James: In Bailey, T.M., ed., Dictionary of Hamilton Biography, W.L. Griffin, v. 2, p. 29-30.

Lankton, L., 1991, Cradle to Grave: Life, Work, and Death at the Lake Superior Copper Mines: Oxford University Press, 319 p.

Lawson, A.C., 1926, Out of beaten paths: University of California Chronicle, v. 28, p. 58-77.

Middleton, G.V., 2003, Doctorate degrees earned by early Canadian geologists: Geoscience Canada, v. 30, p. 37-42.

Morgan, H.J., ed., 1912, Dickson, Mrs. Mary H. in The Canadian Men and Women of the Time: A Hand-book of Canadian Biography of Living Characters: Toronto, William Briggs, Second edition, p. 328.

Ramsay, A.C., 1863, The Physical Geology and Geography of Great Britain: London, Stanford, 145 p.

Roper, H., 1999, The Bishop, the President and the Professor: Turmoil at the University of Kings College in the 1880s: Journal of the Royal Nova Scoria Historical Society, v. 2, p. 94-117.

Rose, G.M., ed., 1888, Dickson, George. in A Cyclopaedia of Canadian Biography, being chiefly Men of the Time: Toronto, Rose Publishing Co., p. 760-762.

Shaw, E.W., 1924, Memorial of Joseph William Winthrop Spencer: Bulletin of the Geological Society of America, v. 35, p. 24-37.

Spencer, J.W., 1878a, On the Nipigon or copper-bearing rocks of Lake Superior, with notes on copper mining in that region: Canadian Naturalist, new series, v. 8, p. 5581.

Spencer, J.W., 1878b, Graptolites of the Niagara formation: Canadian Naturalist, new series, v. 8, p. 457-463.

Spencer, J.W., 1881, Discovery of the preglacial outlet of the basin of Lake Erie into that of Lake Ontario: American Philosophical Society Proceedings, v. 19, p. 300-337.

Spencer, J.W., 1882, Surface geology of the region about the western end of Lake Ontario: Canadian Naturalist, new series, v. 10, p. 213-236; 265-312.

Spencer, J.W., 1890, Origin of the basins of the Great Lakes of America: Quarterly Journal of the Geological Society of London, v. 46, p. 523-531.

Spencer, J.W., 1907, The Falls of Niagara, their Evolution and Varying Relations to the Great Lakes; Characteristics of the Power and the Effect of its Diversion: Geological Survey of Canada, 400 p.

Tesmer, I.H., 1989, History of Geology of Westernmost New York State: SUNY College at Buffalo, 214 p.

Tinkler, K.J., 1994, Deja vu: The downfall of Niagara Falls as a chronometer, 1845-1941, in Gayler, H.J., ed., Niagara's Changing Landscapes, Ottawa, Carleton University Press, p. 81-109.

Torten, S,M. and White, G.W. 1985, Glacial geology and the North American craton: Significant concepts and contributions of the nineteenth century: Geological Society of America Centennial_Volume 1, p. 125-141.

Vaughan, EE., 1970, Andrew C. Lawson: Scientist, Teacher, Philosopher: Arthur C. Clark, Glendale, CA, 474 p.

Vroom, EW., 1941, King's College: A Chronicle: Imperial Publishing Company, Halifax.

Woodhouse, T.R., 1965, History of the Town of Dundas: Dundas Historical Society, Dundas, Ontario, Part 1, 48 p.; Part 2, 48 p.; Part 3, 74 p.

Zaslow, M., 1975, Reading the Rocks: Macmillan, Toronto, 599 p.

Gerard V. Middleton

School of Geography and Geology

McMaster University

Hamilton, ON LBS 4K1

Send correspondence to: 90 St. Margaret's Rd, Ancaster, ON L9G 2K9
COPYRIGHT 2004 Geological Association of Canada
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2004, Gale Group. All rights reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Author:Middleton, Gerard V.
Publication:Geoscience Canada
Date:Jun 1, 2004
Previous Article:Phosphates: Geochemical, Geobiological and Materials importance.
Next Article:Geology of Canadian Wetlands.

Related Articles
Free wheeling.
J.W. Spencer (1851-1921): his life in Missouri and Georgia, and work on proglacial lakes.
A Short History of Watauga County.
Pilot's Last Act.

Terms of use | Privacy policy | Copyright © 2018 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters