Printer Friendly

Utility manages to work with asbestos in coal-tar pipe wrap.

Utilities have long used hot-applied coal-tar coatings on buried steel pipe to mitigate the effects of corrosion. Until more modern, durable coatings were developed during the 1970s and 1980s, tens of thousands of miles of pipe installed throughout the United States were wrapped with this industry standard.

One of the reasons for this material's longevity and performance was that a barrier impervious to moisture was commonly impregnated into the coating matrix for added strength. For those utilities that specified asbestos felt (a roofing paper type of material) as the barrier, the applicability of federal and state health, safety and environmental regulations has been questioned. One such regulation is the New York State Department of Labor's Industrial Code Rule 56 with the stated purpose of reducing the risks to the general public which result from exposure to asbestos during construction and maintenance activities. Unlike OSHA requirements, this rule is not an occupational set of guidelines; however, to accomplish its purpose, similar safety requirements are mandated.

Although the presence of asbestos in coal-tar wrap was known to NMGas(tm)2 by way of its procurement documents, the issue of friability as related to public and worker health concerns was never questioned. It was not until the mid-'80s that awareness began to be raised when state highway construction inspectors discovered that wrap occasionally tested on abandoned gas pipe located on bridges contained chrysotile asbestos. When made aware of these situations, NMGas hired a licensed asbestos contractor with an approved program to provide remediation. The infrequent nature of these situations kept costs and management of the issue to a minimum. It was not until an NMGas employee, accustomed to working with coal-tar wrap in the course of his duties, observed the extensive precautions and personal protective equipment in use by the contractors, asked what precautions applied to company workers.

It was soon learned that current information and the research necessary to answer this employee's question lacked the depth and balance necessary to reconcile employee safety, public safety, regulatory compliance, and financial impact. At the time, the company began doing internal research and air sampling to increase its knowledge base and also developed and implemented an interim procedure to control the work. Subsequently, another NYS-highway construction project caused the removal, handling and disposal of two miles of coal-tar wrapped pipe at a cost of nearly $1 million. An expedited investigation and research took place in an attempt to reconcile some of the issues.

Transmission companies have historically reconditioned existing main for continued service which included the removal and replacement of the pipe coating. During the process, millions of square feet of coal-tar wrap containing asbestos was removed by mechanical means generating large amounts of airborne dust, debris and waste. Working with the Gas Research Institute, the transmission industry developed sophisticated equipment to perform the removal in a safe, environmentally sound manner. The equipment, manufactured by CUPS Systems, Inc., called the Enviro System(tm), removes, collects, transfers and containerizes the asbestos-contained material within the scope of safety and environmental regulatory criteria.

Activities performed by distribution companies where asbestos containing coal-tar wrap is encountered are fundamentally different than the transmission work. Usually, the reconditioning of entire pipelines does not take place; if the wrap is encountered, it's because of routine maintenance, or where tie-in work is occurring. Lastly, these activities involve small quantities of the wrap removed by hand methods. Distribution activities also allow for stricter administrative and procedural controls. NMGas decided rather than modeling the transmission companies and invest in equipment, it would be wiser to invest in research to determine the degree of risk to employees, the public, and the environment resulting from typical distribution activities.

Faced with a $1 million bill for one project, it was easy to justify committing resources to hire needed experts. In addition to outside legal counsel specializing in medical malpractice and asbestos cases, two individuals, distinguished in their fields, were retained to assist in the investigation: Dr. Morton Corn, Professor and Division Director, Environmental Health Engineering, Department of Environmental Health Sciences at Johns Hopkins University School of Hygiene and Public Health in Baltimore, and, Dr. Stephen Kamholz, Chief of Pulmonary Medicine at the State University of New York, Downstate Medical Center and Kings County Hospital.

An extensive list of questions was posed to the experts, including these of Dr. Corn:

* What is the significance of the bound nature of the coal-tar wrap in general; of the layer of asbestos felt within the coal-tar wrap and the release of individual asbestos fibers upon removal of the coal-tar wrap in Niagara Mohawk's maintenance efforts?

* Is the coal-tar wrap "friable" within the definition of Industrial Code Rule 56, i.e. are asbestos fibers released upon hand pressure?

* What are the results of the complete air-sampling tests, including area and personal monitoring?

* What is your opinion of the safety risk to workers and the public when using traditional (hand) methods of coal-tar wrap removal?

* What, if any, safety measures would you introduce to the removal efforts?

* How should coal-tar wrap removed from gas pipelines below ground be disposed of?

* How should above-ground pipe wrapped with coal tar coating be disposed?

The Questions Asked Of Dr. Kamholz Were:

* What is the asbestos-related pulmonary risk to workers most frequently associated with coal-tar wrapped pipelines?

* What is the asbestos-related pulmonary risk to the general public in proximity to the distribution activities related to coal-tar wrapped pipelines?

Johns Hopkins University Findings

Field testing was performed in Syracuse as part of the investigation and research performed by Johns Hopkins University.

The purpose of the testing was to measure levels of exposure to workers actually engaged in the wrap-removal process, and to determine if any significant concentrations of asbestos fibers which could affect the employee or the public existed upwind and/or downwind of the field removal operations. In addition, extensive laboratory testing of the coating material was performed.

During the testing, coal-tar wrap was removed from pipe under a variety of actual in-field and simulated conditions.

Normal (in trench) wrap removal occurred on facilities, pressurized and in service, purposely excavated for the test. All wrap was removed by hand methods only on both wet and dry surfaces.

The use of power tools, grinders, sanders, or burning apparatus was forbidden. In a worst-case simulation, 30 feet of 8-inch coal-tar-wrapped pipe was placed aboveground on timbers in a parking lot. The wrap was removed in a dry condition without being soaked with amended water.

Results Of The Field and Laboratory Testing

* The average weight percentage of chrysotile asbestos in the coating was 36 percent.

* The coal-tar wrap adheres strongly to the metal pipe substrate and coheres strongly to itself

* The coal tar wrap is not "friable", and all fibers are bound in the coating matrix.

* Exposures to airborne asbestos fibers were well in compliance with OSHA occupational exposure requirements specified in 29 CFR 1910.1001 during all field testing.

* OSHA exposure standards would not be exceeded if workers removed the coating by hand for eight continuous hours where the highest airborne concentrations were measured. It should be noted that actual removal for distribution activities takes only minutes and occurs infrequently.

* During the sampling, no asbestos fibers greater than 5 cm in length were detected in the environment 10 feet upwind or downwind of the testing.

Health, Safety And Environmental Recommendations

For typical distribution activities which cause the removal of coal-tar wrap by hand methods,

* Workers should receive asbestos awareness training and employ procedural controls using wet methods.

* If, after awareness training, workers still have concerns, respirators should be offered as an option.

* The small quantities of coal-tar wrap that fall into the trench during distribution activities should be left and buried. The material is non-friable and the fibers are bound within the coating matrix and, as such, do not pose a threat to workers, the public or the environment.

* Where distribution work occurs on above-ground facilities and wrap is removed, it should be collected and disposed of in a construction debris landfill.

* Scrap pipe, with the wrap still intact, should also be disposed of in a construction debris landfill.

Medical Findings

Dr. Kamholz was retained to investigate asbestos-related pulmonary risk to workers and the public in proximity to distribution activities. He reviewed the medical records of 135 NMG employees who had been involved with the wrap since 1958. In summary, his findings were:

* Asbestos exposure in workers performing distribution activities is at best casual and incidental to their job. There is no evidence which supports that these activities contribute to asbestos-related disease in the workers or the public.

* Distribution activities using manual removal methods do not release free asbestos to the air to become respirable and, therefore, pose no health concern to the workers or the public.

* Since removal occurs outdoors, the threat of exposure to the workers and the public is even further minimized.

* The use of special personal protective devices during distribution activities involving wrap removal is unnecessary. The use of respiratory protection for properly trained workers should be optional.

Outside legal counsel performed a thorough review of the state and federal regulations which govern the transportation and disposal of asbestos.

In each case it was found that the requirements of these regulations apply to friable asbestos and, as such, did not apply to the non-friable coal-tar wrap which existed in large chunks or pieces when removed by hand methods only. Extraordinary labeling, packaging or disposal methods were not required. New York State granted NMGas a variance from the Department of Labor Industrial Code Rule 56 for the removal and handling of coal tar-coated gas pipelines. The state essentially posed no regulatory burdens on NMGas other than those that NMGas had already imposed on itself.
COPYRIGHT 1996 Oildom Publishing Company of Texas, Inc.
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 1996 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Title Annotation:Niagara Mohawk Power Corp.
Author:Falise, Michael J.
Publication:Pipeline & Gas Journal
Date:Apr 1, 1996
Words:1617
Previous Article:Businesses must extend themselves for rule's sake.
Next Article:Trucking industry left in quandary over use of LNG.
Topics:

Terms of use | Privacy policy | Copyright © 2026 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters |