Printer Friendly

The SCLAIR story.

This article, inspired by a talk given at the Kingston Conference by the CIC's newest Honorary Fellow - Ted Newall, traces the SCLAIR story it start at Du Pont to present day developments at NOVA ChemicaLs Ltd.

The SCLAIR story started in 1954, when Du Pont Canada was split off from the former Canadian Industries Ltd., an E.I. duPont/ICI joint subsidiary. The new company had a growth objective, and looked forward to an expansion in capital resources. The first capital investment was the construction of a major research laboratory in Kingston, ON.

These two factors came together to provide an opportunity to use technology development as a way to expand into a new business.

First, a small low density polyethylene blown film line was operating at the films plant in Shawinigan, QC and this was seen as a growth business. Backward integration into polyethylene resin (not produced in Canada at that time) looked like an attractive opportunity. The second factor was the potential opportunities for polyethylene in new applications.

In the early 1950s, a number of processes were developed to manufacture high density linear polyethylene resin by processes that did not require the extremely high pressures of the traditional plants producing low density resins by free radical processes. One of these innovations was developed by the Du Pont parent company at its Central Research Laboratory in Wilmington, DE. The process was based on Ziegler-Natta catalysis and was unusual in that it polymerized in solution at a high temperature. In the U.S., the interest was in using the new technology to manufacture high density resins to augment the product line from the existing low density, high pressure, process.

In Canada, the situation was quite different. No low density facilities existed, but the film process required this material. An economic analysis soon showed that the limited size of the Canadian market ruled out building two plants. With the tariff situation at the time, the business would stand or fall on its sales in Canada, The only feasible option was to build one plant to produce both high and low density types of resin. There was one important aspect of the new process which was not fully appreciated at the time. The relatively high operating temperatures resulted in a short residence time in the reactor. This made it efficient to switch rapidly from one resin grade to another and serve the fragmented Canadian market.

The first major program at the Kingston Research Centre was aimed at extending the capabilities of this new process to produce low density resins by incorporating relatively large amounts of alpha-olefin comonomers. This material later came to be known as linear low density polyethylene (LLDPE). A team of chemists and chemical engineers was pulled together, consisting mostly of newly recruited graduates.

There were challenges in modifying the process to make the extended product range such as the reactor design, and process steps to incorporate and recover comonomer efficiently.

But the SCLAIR team soon discovered that the "make or break" issues were not in the process itself, but in the product development required to design products that would meet the requirements of film extrusion and other fabrication processes. When polymer started to come out of the 5 lb/hr pilot plant, the team was surprised to discover that LLDPE made to the same specifications as the traditional free radical material behaved quite differently in fabrication processes. Most alarmingly, film could not be extruded at any reasonable rate.

With great faith, the Board approved the construction of a manufacturing plant near Sarnia, ON with assurances from Research that the problems would be solved by the time the plant started up. This led to a period of intense R&D activity focused on developments such as:

* designing new extruder screws and die designs to accommodate the different theology of LLDPE

* discovering the effect of extrusion aids in eliminating the tendency to extrude film with a "snake skin" texture

* modifying film processes to optimize the film strength with the new resin

* working with customers to match resin design to processing equipment requirements (for example the injection moulding resins behaved quite differently than the high density resins that were being imported at the time) and

* selecting butene as the comonomer of choice as it economically provided a toughness advantage over the high pressure resins then available.

The R&D program was successful, and the world's first LLDPE plant started up near Sarnia in early 1960. A legacy of the program was a group of skilled people and a fund of knowledge in technical areas such as:

* rheology

* molecular structure

* the impact of molecular weight distribution on resin properties

* interaction between reactor design and product properties and

* the ability to jointly optimize resin design and fabrication conditions.

The product was named SCLAIR, after the nearby St. Clair River.

During the 1960s and early 1970s, the SCLAIR team (consisting of groups in Research, Manufacturing, Technical Service, and Head Office) focused on three areas:

* expanding the product range

* a series of step changes to the process which eventually increased the capacity of the original line almost nine times without replacing the reactor and

* additional forward integration (some as joint ventures) into areas such as liquid packaging systems, industrial and gas distribution pipe, industrial bags, and woven tape products.

By 1970, the SCLAIR process was well established and had been shown to provide unique flexibility:

* a density range from 0.915 to 0.960

* a melt index range from 0.2 to 100 or more

* unique narrow molecular weight distribution resins inherent in the catalyst system

* broad distribution resins through bimodality developed in the reactor system and

* the capability to incorporate alpha olefins from C3 to at least C12.

Back in 1967, the research team evaluated a single site catalyst in the solution process. In contrast to the conventional Ziegler-Natta catalysts, which have two or more active sites, the single site catalyst produced copolymers with uniform comonomer branch distributions, resulting in improved product mechanical properties. These product benefits were not economical with the catalysts available at that time. In the late 1980s, breakthroughs with metallocene catalysts made single site catalysts a commercial possibility.

Based on the process attributes and flexibility, the SCLAIR product team had developed a unique series of resins that led the way in opening up new markets. A few examples are:

* the first LLDPE industrial bag resins, which allowed a 25% down gauging in comparison to high pressure resins

* a set of high flow injection moulding resins at high and low density to meet the wide needs in product applications and

* a film resin for liquid packaging that provided toughness at economically attractive gauges, and unmatched heat sealing characteristics.

The SCLAIR process was unique in other aspects:

* it allowed the production of almost the complete range of products produced by other manufacturers

* as a result of the low residence time, transitions from one grade to another could be made quickly, with little off-spec material

* a full product range could be produced on a single manufacturing line and

* lot to lot uniformity was exceptional.

The SCLAIR product team continued to use these attributes beyond 1970 to develop a set of resins that commanded premiums beyond commodity market prices. When other producers ultimately developed competitive resins for some applications, the product team executed a strategy of developing premium resins for new applications. As a result, the SCLAIR process continued to deliver a premium product line. In 1976 a second polyethylene line was added at the Sarnia plant to maintain a world-scale production level, and provide a revenue base to support continued technology development. By this time a thriving export business had been established.

In the 1970s, competitors commercialized other processes to manufacture LLDPE. These were launched with much publicity about "new" products with greatly improved properties, ignoring the fact that SCLAIR resins had been on the market for over 15 years.

In 1980, the decision was made to exploit the polymerization technology by licensing it worldwide. Under the name SCLAIRTECH, the process was well received because of its ability to make a very wide range of high quality products in a single line at low cost. Licenses have been sold in Japan, Australia, Italy, Korea, China, India, Brazil, Venezuela, and Nigeria. Worldwide, there are now 11 SCLAIR lines in operation.

With the restructuring of Du Pont's global interests in the early 1990s, it became evident that SCLAIR was no longer a strategic fit, and would not attract the capital for expansion and continued technology development. Although R&D support had continued, it was evident that a step change improvement in the technology was required in order to maintain competitiveness. Significant increases in capital and technical effort would be needed. This led to the inevitable decision to divest the business to an organization that was in a position to provide the needed support to carry the technology into the 21st century.

In 1994, the SCLAIR polyethylene business was purchased by NOVA Chemicals Ltd., (then NOVACOR Chemicals Ltd.), the plastics and petrochemicals division of Alberta-based NOVA Corporation. NOVA Chemicals is the fourth largest ethylene producer, and with the acquisition of SCLAIR, the sixth largest polyethylene producer in North America. NOVA Chemicals operates gas phase UNIPOL technology to produce HDPE and LLDPE in plants in Mooretown, ON and Joffre, AB, respectively, as well as a high pressure LDPE plant, also located in Mooretown. The company also has significant assets in styrene and polystyrene.

Since 1994, NOVA Chemicals has been following a strategy of developing both the catalyst and solution process technology. The result is the next generation SCLAIRTECH technology, a highly flexible solution process capable of using either high activity Ziegler-Natta catalysts or metallocenes. The process and product advantages have been demonstrated at a pilot plant at the St. Clair River Site in Corunna, ON, which has been in operation since November 1995. The goal is to commercialize the new technology at a proposed facility in Joffre, AB, next door to two of NOVA Chemicals' ethylene plants.

The technical and commercial success of the SCLAIR team over a period of four decades is one of the real success stories of Canadian technology and business development. With the exception of the early work on the original high density process, virtually all of the developments were accomplished by Canadians in Canada. Through commitment to the next generation of SCLAIR technology, NOVA is carrying on this proud tradition.

As a staff member at the Du Pont Research Centre from 1955 to 1993, Gerry Dyer was involved in the early work on the product aspects or SCLAIR technology, and later as a member of the Sclair Business Team. Lynne Manuel worked on SCLAIR process and product development at Du Pont through the 1980s and early 1990s. Since May 1995 she has been leading the new SCLAIRTECH Product Development Group at the NOVA Research and Technology Centre. Don Robinson worked on several aspects of SCLAIR technology as a member of the Du Pont Research Centre staff from 1958 to 1994. He continued that role with NOVA, retired in 1995, and is now an Adjunct Professor at Queen's University, Kingston, ON.
COPYRIGHT 1997 Chemical Institute of Canada
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 1997 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Title Annotation:low density polyethylene development in Canada
Author:Dyer, Gerry; Manuel, Lynne; Robinson, Don
Publication:Canadian Chemical News
Date:Jan 1, 1997
Words:1857
Previous Article:Testing exceptionally mild cleansing bars containing colloidal oatmeal.
Next Article:Considering retirement packages.
Topics:

Terms of use | Privacy policy | Copyright © 2026 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters |