Printer Friendly

Midnight Pass closes.

Every now and then, nature reminds us that in Sarasota, we live on shifting sands.

IN SARASOTA, THERE'S ALWAYS THE sense of a landscape at risk, of homes that could vanish in a hurricane or resources that could be lost to our own improvidence. Once we've made our home at this magnificent point where sea, sky and land intersect, we tend to forget how much Sarasota and its offshore islands have altered through history, how impermanent the shoreline and its structures really are. What nature has so lavishly given can always be taken away. Nothing better epitomizes that eternal struggle between Sarasota's settlers and nature's restless energy than the story of Midnight Pass.

For years -- hundreds of years -- Midnight Pass separated Siesta Key and Casey Key. Through this swift inlet, waters from Little Sarasota Bay poured into the Gulf, and boaters traveled the pass back and forth from Gulf to bay. In recent decades, it was a popular spot for picnics and family outings; people would search for crabs in the calm shallows on the bayside, and children loved to ride the speedy currents that rushed through the narrow pass towards the Gulf. The pass also helped reduce pollution in the bay through an ongoing exchange of waters.

The pass closed on Dec. 5, 1983. Our memories are short, and it's surprising how many people now believe the pass closed naturally. But it didn't.

One of the recurring themes in the inlet's history is its movement. In the 1840s, charts of the region show "Buccaneers Pass" separating Siesta and Casey keys, later renamed Midnight Pass. Those historical charts show the wild, migrating pass moving both north and south across a three-mile stretch of coastline during the past 100 years.

By 1960, Midnight Pass had been in about the same place for a while -- say, 20 years or so. To place things historically: Mote Marine Laboratory had just moved to the south end of Siesta Key, and the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers was starting to dredge the Intracoastal Waterway. Midnight Pass was not widened or deepened as part of the Intracoastal project, although much of the rest of the bay bottom was scraped or dynamited to make the bay deep enough for commercial barges to carry goods to Southwest Florida from faraway ports.

When the dredges moved on, Midnight Pass began to move to the north. It didn't happen overnight, but by the mid-1970s, folks began to talk about the fate of the inlet. It was much narrower than it once was, and it was on the move.

Smart folks who could read the message Mother Nature was sending began to move, too. Mote Marine Laboratory packed up its records and relocated to City Island. As described in a Mote Marine Laboratory document in 1990, besides the growth of Mote's scientific endeavors: "Another and even more compelling reason to move |from Siesta Key~ came stealthily, almost imperceptibly, as Midnight Pass filled in and barred the Lab's vessels access to the Gulf... simultaneously the sea nibbled at the Laboratory's grounds and reduced their 10-acre site by a few acres every year. It was inevitable that the Mote Marine Laboratory would not only lose its channel to the Gulf but also that, in the inexorable onslaught of the waves, the shark tanks, the docks, the trailers, would be gobbled up by the Gulf. A move had become imperative."

Mote moved to City Island in Sarasota in 1978. And Midnight Pass kept narrowing and moving north, right to the front door of two homes by mid-1983.

Pasco Carter, a retired engineer, was the first threatened. Carter and his wife received permits to place eight-by-eight-foot sandbags in front of their home as the waves began to break against the sides of the swimming pool. Well-known artist Syd Solomon was next to be menaced. His home and studio began to show the wear of waves, and sandbags soon were his beach frontage, too.

Any housing next to the Gulf of Mexico on barrier islands is precarious. Areas near inlets are especially risky because beach erosion there is at its worst. In light of the migratory nature of Midnight Pass, many have questioned how Carter and Solomon were ever allowed to build in the region in the first place.

But once structures have been erected, local government tends to look favorably on efforts by the homeowners to save them. As the pass ate away at their property in late 1983, Carter and Solomon came up with an idea they were able to sell to local and state governments: let them move the pass back to the south, away from their million-dollar homes. Permits were granted on an emergency basis, and the first of what would turn into many dredging attempts was made to relocate Midnight Pass.

A new channel was dredged, then the old pass was bulldozed closed, so water would flow through the new channel. But Midnight Pass refused to move over. Solomon and Carter made five more attempts to dredge a new channel for the pass, but it stayed stubbornly shut. The problem, coastal geologists later said, was the current wasn't strong enough to push the sand through the newly dug pass. Water found it easier to move through the wider and deeper Venice Inlet to the south, or Big Pass to the north, leaving little Midnight Pass to slowly collect sand and fill.

Carter and Solomon had won approval to relocate the pass on the condition they would keep it open for two years. After six attempts costing in excess of $150,000 (three times more than they had originally estimated) they successfully petitioned governments to give up the ghost of Midnight Pass, citing financial hardship. Today, their houses stand secure, protected by a comfortable margin of sandy beach.

But debate on the pass, such a beloved spot for local boaters and beachgoers, continued. A "blue ribbon" panel of environmental experts was convened and decided a one-time, major dredging to reopen the pass should be done. The county applied for necessary permits, but after state officials ruled against issuing the permits (arguing that the pass was ready to close naturally) the county decided not to pursue the matter. A group of pass-opening proponents banded together and, in 1985, the Midnight Pass Society began a shovel brigade that briefly did open the pass before officials bulldozed the tiny waterway closed.

Lawsuits were filed. Administrative hearings were held. Rulings by state officials said the pass was closing anyway, so what's the big deal? You can't reopen it. Eventually, most people lost interest in the story of Midnight Pass.

Now, 10 years later, most experts agree that Little Sarasota Bay is dirtier -- one of the most polluted bodies of water in the region, in fact -- and the area less environmentally productive than it was when the pass was open. Seagrasses, mangroves, freshwater marshes, fish, clams and scallops are rapidly disappearing -- or are gone -- from the area.

Not all of this can be blamed on the closing of Midnight Pass. More than 30,000 septic tanks in the Little Sarasota Bay area dump almost 430,000 pounds of phosphorous and nitrogen into the bay each year. Projected development could increase those chemicals 25 percent in the next 20 years. Officials have set a goal of developing a central sewer system for the area but, with price tags between $100-$700 million, no financial commitments have been made. Still, reopening the pass would probably dilute the pollutants and result in a cleaner, better environment for marine life in Little Sarasota Bay.

Did Midnight Pass close naturally? No. Was it going to close anyway? No one knows. Should it be re-opened? If we want a cleaner Little Sarasota Bay and access to the Gulf for boaters, yes. If we want to stay out of a costly battle to redirect natural forces, no.

On March 13, 1993, Midnight Pass briefly reopened -- or at least a powerful storm pushed winds and waves across south Siesta Key, a few yards north of Syd Solomon's. A few months later, Sarasota County officials issued a building permit for a house on the area where the pass briefly flowed.
COPYRIGHT 1994 Clubhouse Publishing, Inc.
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 1994 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Title Annotation:15 Years of Sarasota; waterways in Sarasota, Florida
Author:Roat, Paul
Publication:Sarasota Magazine
Date:Apr 1, 1994
Words:1365
Previous Article:A grand old house is destroyed.
Next Article:Sarasota elects its first black commissioner.
Topics:


Related Articles
The mortal sea: will we care enough to turn back the clock for Sarasota's waters?
Sarasota cuisine: a guide to fine dining in Sarasota.
Sarasota cuisine: a guide to fine dining in Sarasota.
Sarasota cuisine.
To HAVE and to HOLD.
Adventures in dining: Recipe for the ultimate Sarasota dinner a couple, a kayak and one of the fabulous old-Florida restaurants along our secluded...
Midnight pass madness. (Street Talk).
Burning issue: Sarasota County is preparing to spend millions of dollars to try to obtain permits and re-open Midnight Pass. Should that happen?
Checking in: finding your place in the Sarasota sun.
Your place in the sun: local resorts have all the comforts of home--and more.

Terms of use | Privacy policy | Copyright © 2026 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters |