John Pier and Jose Angel Garcia Landa, editors. Theorizing Narrativity.
John Pier and Jose Angel Garcia Landa, editors. Theorizing Narrativity. Berlin: De Gruyter, Narratologia series volume 12, 2008. 464 pp. $98.00Theorizing Narrativity is a very ambitious and extensive anthology of essays on basic questions of narrative theory. The subjects it addresses are both foundational and wide ranging: its essays explore what narrative is, how it is best conceptualized, what its salient features are, and where its boundaries might be situated. Its many topics include tellability, eventfulness, causality, chance, repetition, and transfictionality, while the genres it investigates include literary, dramatic, legal, and hypertext narratives. The collection begins with and is framed by Gerald Prince's lucid account of "Narrativehood, Narrativeness, Narrativity, and Narratibility," which provides state-of-the-art definitions of these contiguous concepts.
Roland Barthes has suggested that the post hoc fallacy--that an event that comes after another is often thought to have been caused by it--may be the mainspring of narrative. John Pier takes up this intriguing thesis and provides an ingenious dialogue with it which produces one of the most sustained and perspicacious analyses of the relation between temporally sequenced and causally conjoined events we have. Pier goes on to propose a valuable account of reading narrative that moves from a "heuristic" practice derived from trial-and-error inferential reasoning to a retrospective semiotics based on the theory of abductions originated by C. S. Pierce and extended by Umberto Eco. Employing a comparable kind of approach, Meir Sternberg's essay. "If-Plots: Narrative and the Law Code," explores the narrative underpinnings of the law code by virtue of the storytelling implicit in its numerous "if ... then ..." constructions, and identifies three forms of "antecedent futurity." In this way, Sternberg brings a new corpus of texts into the realm of narrative and narratology.
Werner Wolf takes up the underexplored subject of chance in narrative. This is an extremely impressive essay that deftly covers all aspects of this elusive topic: chance events in fictional worlds, the role of chance in different genres, the use of chance in the construction of the text, the reader's processing of chance events, the significance of the position of chance turns within the narrative (at the beginning, middle, or end), and the changing concepts of chance in history. Wolf usefully differentiates among the contingent, the accidental, and the coincidental and goes on to show, aided by effective analyses of the role of chance in Greene's Pandoslo and Hardy's Tess, how the use of chance helps disclose the implied worldview in the narrative.
One of the wonderful surprises in this collection is the excellent essay by Jukka Tyrkko on the dynamics of multilinear linear narratives, both in narrative fiction and in hypertexts. His impressive analysis investigates the nature, status, history, and reception of what he calls "kaleidoscope narratives"; this group includes unfixed or fragmented works like Cortazar's Hopscotch, Marc Saporta's Composition # 1, lexicon novels (Pavics Dictionary of the Khazars), and hypertext narratives. This account is a welcome correction to discussions that often ignore the history of multilinear texts before hyperfiction: it is also a worthwhile contribution to narrative theory in its own right.
Equally suggestive but less successful in its present form is Michael Toolan's essay, "The Language of Guidance" which seeks to determine how a narrative guides readers to the "heart of the matter" (307). The main thrust of the paper is to suggest that significant lexical frequencies can reveal important features of a work's meaning and import. The conclusions derived from the list of recurrent words in a text, however, can only take us so far. Once we compare the prevalence of the word "dead" in Joyce's "The Dead" with the paucity of "grace" (three instances) in "Grace" the story that precedes it in Dubliners, we immediately realize that the relative absence of a word can be at least as important as its insistent repetition. Similarly, "gnomon" appears only once in the entire collection but is a key to the book's structure and interpretation. Toolan is definitely on to something significant, but I suspect he will not get very far without a more capacious methodology.
Two important essays draw much needed attention to narrative in drama and to the status of drama as narrative. Monika Fludernik provides compelling analyses of the role of narrators in many plays, a masterful critique of the narratological neglect of drama, and a series of powerful arguments for the inclusion of drama in narrative theory. She shows that both an approach to narrative based on events, as well as an approach based on narration, will have to include drama and demonstrates her theses with persuasive accounts of narration in Tom Stoppard's Travesties and David Edgar's Entertaining Strangers. Ansgar Nunning and Roy Sommer also take up this subject. They provide a very useful differentiation between mimetic and diegetic narrativity, note the varying degrees of narrativity a work may possess, and outline the range of diegetic narrative elements in drama (they enumerate eighteen such elements). Together, these two superb papers offer a compelling and perhaps irrefutable analysis of the narrative status of drama; it will no longer seem tenable to affirm that narratives are only those representations of events that are narrated rather than enacted.
Marie-Laure Ryan gives a very stimulating account of what she calls "transfictionality," or the relations between two distinct texts by different authors that are related to one another, such as Defoe's Robinson Crusoe and Coetzee's Foe. She offers a compelling model that is at once more focused and useful than Genette's hypertetuality and transtextuality and, at the same time, goes much further than Dolezel's notion of the "postmodern rewrite," She traces out the distinctive forms of transfictionality through the history of writing, covering oral, print, electronic, and digital media and providing an excellent appendix on the nature and status of game narratives. The volume ends with a fascinating essay by Jose Angel Garcia Landa, "Narrating Narrating: Twisting the Twice-Told Tale," on what he argues is the repeated nature of all narrative and thus the curious status of repeated stories within stories. As narrativization is a remaking of previously narrativized events, it follows that notions like tellability, point of view, and event need to be redefined in view of the interactional situatedness of narrative. An entirely new light is cast on the retrospective dimension of narrative, such as foreshadowing, hindsight bias, and the double logic of narrative.
The importance of this volume can be measured in both by the new concepts and approaches set forth and by the return to earlier debates by its authors. To take a basic example, the definition of narrative, we find Gerald Prince revising his earlier formulations to read, "a logically consistent representation of at least two asynchronous events that do not presuppose or imply each other" (19). John Pier in turn emends Prince's new definition to yield, "the representation of at least two real or fictive events in a time sequence, either of which might presuppose or entail the other" (118). Peter Huhn surveys a vast range of such definitions in his account of the narrativity of events; David Rudrum opposes essentialist theories of narrative and offers instead a "family resemblance" theory that focuses instead on what narratives do; and Beatriz Penas Ibanez asserts that narrativity is "a (con-) textual interpretive effect derived as much from a way of reading a text as from a way of writing a text" (244). Finally, Monika Fludernik argues that, for purely textual narrative, "narrativity consists in the evocation of a fictional world focusing on one or several human (or quasi-human) consciousnesses whose experience of that world is the topic of the narrative" (366).
All in all, this is a genuinely major volume of important and original work by many of the most highly respected narrative theorists in and around Europe. It furthers the debates on the nature of narrative and narrativity, adds important new concepts like eventfulness and transfictionality, examines and reanimates the notions of cause, chance, and m ultilinearity, and extends the analysis of narrative into relatively new areas such as drama, law codes, and hypertext fiction. It is an essential volume for scholars, theorists, and students who wish to be aware of the most important, original, and exciting work in narrative theory being done today.
Brian Richardson
University of Maryland
Printer friendly
Cite/link
Email
Feedback
| |
| Author: | Richardson, Brian |
|---|---|
| Publication: | Style |
| Article Type: | Book review |
| Date: | Mar 22, 2011 |
| Words: | 1371 |
| Previous Article: | Monika Fludernik. An Introduction to Narratology. |
| Next Article: | Gordon Campbell and Thomas N. Corns. John Milton: Life, Work, and Thought. |
| Topics: | |

Printer friendly
Cite/link
Email
Feedback