A site in history: archaeology at Dolni Vestonice/Unterwisternitz.Introduction
Whatever the journalist's definition of eastern Europe Eastern Europe
The countries of eastern Europe, especially those that were allied with the USSR in the Warsaw Pact, which was established in 1955 and dissolved in 1991. might be, let us state, as introduction to this Special Section, that Czechoslovakia is a country in Central, not Eastern, Europe. It is somewhat controversial to speak about its 'return to Europe', as some politicians would have it, as it has been there all the time.
VENCLOVA 1991: 306
Despite archaeology's focus on space and time, it often ignores the exact location in space and time of its own research. This essay seeks to examine varying grounds on which archaeological knowledge-claims have been made over time in relation to the well known Palaeolithic site, Dolni Vestonice, in the former Czechoslovakia. While it is necessary to consider the physical context of the artefacts that validate a particular hypothesis, at the same time it is also essential to unravel the social, historical, political and personal contexts within which the site, the materials and the investigators themselves are submerged.(1)
Palaeolithic archaeology, rooted in geology and positioned directly on the fault line demarcating the furthest edge of the humanities, combines the methodological aspects of natural sciences and the interpretive aims of social sciences. Its heavy reliance on stone tools, soil samples and geological profiles gives Palaeolithic archaeology the image of 'hard', or by extension 'objective', science. The appearance of agriculture, architecture, and cities in subsequent time periods substantially increases the distance between natural sciences and archaeology, flaming other archaeologies with a more humanistic mind-set. Thus Palaeolithic archaeology offers a pivotal case-study on the border between the historical development of a natural science, and a humanistic pursuit of interpretation of factual evidence.
Archaeological research operates within two contexts: one archaeological - the physical circumstances of the finds - and one culture-historical - the socio-political climate of the country in which the site is located, together with that of the researcher's country. These two contexts are inseparably bound. Giving meticulous attention to the archaeological context In archaeology, not only the context (physical location) of a discovery is a significant fact, but the formation of the context is as well. An archaeological context is an event in time which has been preserved in the archaeological record. is itself no guarantee of a value-free interpretation, for all interpretations claiming to be factually based, and scientifically tested, are constructed in relation to both material evidence and social reality (Gero et al. 1983; Pinsky & Wylie 1989; for a different approach to similar questions, see Patrick 1985).
What constitutes a location worthy of a survey, a site in a need of excavation, materials worth collecting, identifying and analysing varies over time: it is culturally determined, constructed and reconstructed. The 1853 drought in Switzerland exposed the 'Lake Dwellings', resulting - histories of archaeology tell us - in a large-scale excavation and the discovery of the Bronze Age Bronze Age, period in the development of technology when metals were first used regularly in the manufacture of tools and weapons. Pure copper and bronze, an alloy of copper and tin, were used indiscriminately at first; this early period is sometimes called the settlements (Trigger 1989: 83). Without doubting that the drought in question occurred, and helped to reveal the wealth of finds, one still has to question why the Swiss scientists were searching for ancient settlements in such a meticulous way, in that particular geographical location, at that point in time.(2)
Archaeological excavations and research, it is often written, should be problem-oriented, addressing specific questions formulated to deal with issues pertaining to the past (Renfrew & Bahn 1991; Thomas 1989). Yet one has to pause and consider the meaning of such a bold, basic statement in introductory text-books. What constitutes, at a specific point in history, in a specific geographic location, a question that needs to be dealt with? Presumably pre·sum·a·ble
That can be presumed or taken for granted; reasonable as a supposition: presumable causes of the disaster. , a question is posed so as to obtain an answer, and an answer that is seen as vital and interesting. The question itself is a lead toward an answer, that acquires interest and meaning in a particular context. The specific historical and social context gives meaning to that social construction called the past, be it local, regional, national, or universally human in scope.
History of European prehistory prehistory, period of human evolution before writing was invented and records kept. The term was coined by Daniel Wilson in 1851. It is followed by protohistory, the period for which we have some records but must still rely largely on archaeological evidence to
Palaeolithic archaeology operates within a time-bracket labelled as prehistory, the period before written records (Renfrew & Bahn 1991: 17). The term prehistory, as opposed to history, appears in England and continental Europe during the second half of the 19th century, signifying a separate, conscious aspect of the study of human existence (Chippindale 1988; Clermont & Smith 1990). At the time, prehistory was called prehistoire in France, preistoria in Italy, Vorgeschichte in Germany (Daniel 1963: 14). All these terms suggest a similar optimism: there was a tangible past before the occurrence of written records, knowable and worth naming. In Germany, with the concurrent rise of the nation state, the ancient past was viewed not only as something tangible but also something significant to the national identity, and prehistory 'changed its name' in 1886 from Vorgeschichte to Urgeschichte - indicating that it was the source (the prefix ur-) of history, rather than its antecedent ANTECEDENT. Something that goes before. In the construction of laws, agreements, and the like, reference is always to be made to the last antecedent; ad proximun antecedens fiat relatio. (Sklenar 1983). Neither England nor France followed suit. Czech intellectuals, on the other hand, in the midst Adv. 1. in the midst - the middle or central part or point; "in the midst of the forest"; "could he walk out in the midst of his piece?"
midmost of battles for language rights in the Austro-Hungarian empire, avoided using the existing loan word historie (history) that would have suggested links to Western traditions, and instead adopted the term pravek with its strong Slavic ring. The created word evoked the image of ancient ancestral time (the prefix pra-indicates antiquity, old age along direct kinship lines), a Slavic past which the present population descended from (vek is the Slavic root for age). These three different words - prehistory, Urgeschichte and pravek - may serve as the background against which the materials from Dolni Vestonice were interpreted in the 20th century.
The site of Dolni Vestonice is located near a village of the same name, in the southern part of the central section of former Czechoslovakia known as Moravia. The country itself was created in 1918, as one of several small nation-states that rose from the disintegrated Austro-Hungarian empire after the First World War. In many respects its making was more a result of a political failure in the sphere of multiculturalism, particularly mis-handling the language question, than a mature decision of all parties involved. Political boundaries were created that did not correspond with ethnic territories, resulting in the incorporation of long-settled linguistic minorities into the new national entity. Czechoslovakia was simultaneously part of Central Europe Central Europe is the region lying between the variously and vaguely defined areas of Eastern and Western Europe. In addition, Northern, Southern and Southeastern Europe may variously delimit or overlap into Central Europe. and the westernmost Slavic country, possessing at the time of its creation large German and Hungarian populations in addition to Czechs and Slovaks. Historically, the country has never been comfortable with its geographically expansive and threatening, but also inescapably influential and appealing, German-speaking neighbours to the west, south and north, an unease that is counteracted by an equally ambivalent relationship with its eastern neighbour - the former Soviet Union, heir to the Russian empire. This historically shaped and ideologically charged geographic location, with perceived ethnic attachments and emotional value, played a major role in the collective national identities of the Czechs, the Moravians and the Slovaks.(3) FIGURE 1 records how the boundaries of nation-states have moved across its location.
Dolni Vestonice lies in the southern part of the Moravian Karst The Moravian Karst (in Czech Moravský kras) is a karst (cave system) area to the north of Brno in the eastern part of the Czech Republic. This limestone area is a nature reserve containing around 400 caves in a 100 km² area. Four of the caves are open for public exploration. , traditionally a German region, later part of the contested Sudetenland. The village was known under its German name of Unterwisternitz, and the overwhelming majority of the population was ethnically German (Frolec 1985). Their identity within the newly formed state became unclear, since they had traditionally identified themselves as Austrian Germans under the Empire. As of 1918, they were no longer Austrian, and yet could not claim to be German either. The system that had allowed the ambiguity of a figure like the writer Franz Kafka Noun 1. Franz Kafka - Czech novelist who wrote in German about a nightmarish world of isolated and troubled individuals (1883-1924)
Kafka - who lived in Prague, but was Jewish in ethnic tradition and religion, and German in the literary language - had collapsed. Where the old imperial German language had distinguished between tschechisch (Czech) and bohmisch (Bohemian), the new national Czech language Czech language (chĕk), in the past sometimes also called Bohemian, member of the West Slavic group of the Slavic subfamily of the Indo-European family of languages (see Slavic languages). recognized only one state identity - Czechoslovak. This only contributed to the German sense of alienation from the Czechoslovak state's identity, an issue that developed into a serious problem in the 1930s, and an irreparable ir·rep·a·ra·ble
Impossible to repair, rectify, or amend: irreparable harm; irreparable damages.
[Middle English, from Old French, from Latin crisis by the beginning of the Second World War, with generous assistance from German and Czech political parties.
The site located in the 19th century
The hilly region of Southern Moravia was of historical interest for centuries, mainly due to its claim of having been the location of the first Slavic state - the Great Moravian empire (9th-10th centuries AD). The search for the exact site of this once powerful community captured the imagination of all local patriots from the 18th century, when land and nation became inseparable concepts in the popular imagination (Gojda 1991). The first mention of prehistoric finds is dated to the 17th century when a doctor at the emperor's court recorded mammoth bones recovered in the vicinity of the village (Absolon 1938; Klima 1954; Schwabedissen 1943; Svoboda 1991). Throughout the following centuries local doctors, teachers, botanists and naturalists made numerous records of extremely large bones, later identified as mammoth. The hunt for ancient fauna was replaced, in the second half of the 19th century, by a search for ancient human inhabitants, partly due to increased awareness of the antiquity of humanity (Ermarth 1978: 68):
The swelling tide of Darwinism in the '60s and '70s even exceeded the impact of Hegelianism in the '20s and '30s. Psychology, anthropology, economics, geography, philology phi·lol·o·gy
1. Literary study or classical scholarship.
2. See historical linguistics.
[Middle English philologie, from Latin philologia, love of learning , ethical philosophy, and even epistemology epistemology (ĭpĭs'təmŏl`əjē) [Gr.,=knowledge or science], the branch of philosophy that is directed toward theories of the sources, nature, and limits of knowledge. Since the 17th cent. were remodeled on Darwinian lines. The idea of natural evolution came to dominate the thought of the later nineteenth century in a way comparable to the fascination exerted by classical mechanics Classical mechanics
The science dealing with the description of the positions of objects in space under the action of forces as a function of time. Some of the laws of mechanics were recognized at least as early as the time of Archimedes (287–212 in the seventeenth century.
At the same time, optimism associated with the possibilities of science in answering questions previously in the realm of myth and fiction ran particularly high in the increasingly powerful German state. Bohemia and Moravia, still a part of Austro-Hungary at the time, were strongly influenced by these intellectual movements, in part due to their desire to gain independent recognition outside the empire and, in part, due to the traditionally strong ties with the German universities. The turn of the century was also marked by the growing nationalism and ethnic strife for recognition in many European countries. Consequently the intelligentsia in Central Europe, the local doctors, botanists, naturalists, geologists, as the practitioners of science, came to play the role of national revivalists, by providing scientific evidence for the importance of a local place. The Museum Society in Brno (the urban centre of Moravian intellectual life) was established in 1888, with a 12-member board of governors, including 10 amateur archaeologists and two historians (Frolec 1988).
The acceptance of evolutionary theory
The first Palaeolithic finds in Moravia came from the excavations at Byci Skala in 1867, and later other cave sites were discovered and recorded: Kulna, Pekarna and, in 1880, the Sipka cave (Sklenar 1983: 119; Svoboda 1991). In the process of this meticulous search, Karel Maska, the foremost Moravian prehistorian at the time, discovered the Predmosti open-air site with 20 skeletons in 1894 (Sklenar 1983; Klima 1951; Absolon & Klima 1977). This spectacular and unique find diverted the attention from the caves, that have yet to render anything comparable to paintings of Altamira found in 1878. Yet the French Palaeolithic has been considered the ultimate measure of achievement in prehistoric times, and most archaeologists in Central Europe focused on later periods, the Neolithic and the Bronze ages, that appeared to have been much more impressive in this area. The majority of the Neolithic sites excavated around the turn of the century contained artefacts that seemed suitable for interpretations related to the ethnic identities of their makers. Pottery, art objects, weapons and house remains were viewed as possessing style unique to ethnic groups, present and past.
The difference between the mid 19th century, when the first sites were located, and the beginning of the 20th, when they were excavated, marks a crucial divide in the social climate, and in the sense of crisis in the political, cultural, and historical expectations of most European states (Crawford 1992; Jalevich 1987). The initial fascination with, and unequivocal faith in, positivism positivism (pŏ`zĭtĭvĭzəm), philosophical doctrine that denies any validity to speculation or metaphysics. Sometimes associated with empiricism, positivism maintains that metaphysical questions are unanswerable and that the only at the end of the 19th century seemed to have faded, and the stage for the new century was set amidst an 'anarchy of world views' (Ermarth 1978: 80-81):
Increasingly after 1880 intellectuals in many fields began to question the ultimate validity and grounds of scientific conceptions and came to challenge the effects which such conceptions had upon the conduct of life. In contrast to the earlier positivism, one is confronted with the singular spectacle of science brought to witness against itself. In some circles confidence in science began to wane and belief in the objective truth of science was questioned... These decades witnessed various intellectual movements of revival and innovation which went under the various names of neo-idealism, neo-romanticism, vitalism vitalism (vīˑ·tl·i·z , voluntarism voluntarism
Metaphysical or psychological system that assigns a more predominant role to the will (Latin, voluntas) than to the intellect. Christian philosophers who have been described as voluntarist include St. Augustine, John Duns Scotus, and Blaise Pascal. , the 'new irrationalism', and the 'new metaphysics'.
The original archaeological research at Dolni Vestonice took place in a very specific historical and social climate of which it was a product, yet played an immensely powerful role in its construction. Understanding this relationship is essential, in order to unravel some of the reasons that stood behind the interpretations of the particular site and its materials later in the twentieth century.
The site Dolni Vestonice/Unterwisternitz excavated
A large-scale excavation began at the location in Southern Moravia in the summer of 1924. Dr Karel Absolon Karel Absolon (June 16 1877 - October 6 1960) was Czech archaeologist, geographer, paleontologist, and speleologist. He was born in Boskovice.
Absolon was grandchild of paleontologist Jindřich Wankel. , a professor at the University of Prague
Considering the local politics in the 1920s, it is noteworthy that both the Czech and the German press in Moravia covered the excavation extensively at the time, without mentioning any national issue at all. The same can be said about Absolon's 1924 report, which is remarkable in its complete absence of any nationalism, though full of patriotism and pride in the region. He includes both the Czech and the German place-names, and from his published diary it is clear that, but for one, all the workers at the excavation were local Germans (Absolon 1938). The report written in 1938 in Czech for the local professional audience does not offer any racial or ethnic theories, and stands in a sharp contrast to the articles that Absolon published at the same time in French and German anthropological journals. These will be discussed later on.
The site and the noblemen
The first brief note in foreign press appeared in The Illustrated London News Illustrated London News
Historic magazine of news and the arts, published in London. Founded in 1842 as a weekly, it became a monthly in 1971. A pioneer in the use of various graphic arts, it was London's first illustrated periodical, the first periodical to make extensive on 31 October 1925, under the most expressive title: 'A discovery as wonderful as that of Tutenkhamen's Tomb. Moravia over 20,000 years ago' (Absolon 1925) [ILLUSTRATION FOR FIGURE 3 OMITTED]. The impressive finds of the Egyptian tomb were replicated in Moravia, placing them on the same cultural level, while the British archaeologists were as successful as the Czechs in uncovering such treasures. This magazine later carried extensive coverage of the project, serving as the main source of information about it for the general public in the English speaking world, and for Western Europe Western Europe
The countries of western Europe, especially those that are allied with the United States and Canada in the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (established 1949 and usually known as NATO). in general. The second extensive report appeared a year later in German in the Acta Musei Moraviae, a local periodical put out by the museum of which Absolon was a curator (Absolon 1926). It may seem unusual that the report was not in Czech, the established official language of the newly independent country. Yet there were several reasons for this rather typical Central European phenomenon. Despite its newly acquired state of independence, Czechoslovakia continued to be dependent on Austria and Germany in many aspects, and scholarly language, education and research remained a powerful legacy of 300 years of cultural dependence. Most university-educated researchers, particularly those in physical and natural sciences, were trained in German. At the same time, even though Czech was then the accepted scholarly language in Czechoslovakia, such a spectacular site as Dolni Vestonice had to be made known to the very community from which the young archaeological establishment was trying to make itself independent. This peculiar situation persisted throughout the century, with different foreign languages playing the role of the master language. It continues to this day, and is not unique to Czechoslovakia, or even to Eastern Europe, but rather is expressive of the scientific capital of various countries, and the neo-colonial dependency of those that do not possess it.
Shortly afterwards, Absolon published articles for the professional audience in the French Revue Anthropologique and the German Tagungsberichte der deutschen Anthropologischen Gesellschaft. In both reports, he stressed the importance of the site itself as a new Aurignacian station in Moravia, and one of the largest in the world (Absolon 1927; 1928). A detailed description of the now-famous clay figurines appeared here for the first time, with the animal statuettes discussed as much as the (at the time) only female figurine, and the torso whose sex Absolon did not suggest. The description considered the figurine 'fortement steatometrique' [strongly steatopygic], a view that later changed, depending on the researcher (Absolon 1927: 86). None of these reports gave the statuettes any religious significance, and even though they were mentioned and described, they were not considered the highlight of the finds; 31 mammoths, after all, outweighed a 10-cm tall female figurine. The primary focus was the impressive number of mammoth bones recovered, the 'kitchen midden', with at least 31 complete individuals (Absolon 1927). The slaughter at the location was compared to the then-current extermination extermination
mass killing of animals or other pests. Implies complete destruction of the species or other group. of elephants in Africa, where Absolon calls for a protection law so as to avoid the fate that the mammoth met in Moravia (Absolon 1927: 88). Analogy with Africa and Australia was a frequent explanatory device in Absolon's writing, its connotations varying immensely over time, as did perceptions of race, and the primitive.
The most extensive popular coverage appeared in a series of lengthy articles in 1929 in The Illustrated London News. The articles contained most of the photographic evidence cited and widely used during the following decades by researchers discussing the site. The whole series carried an impressive title, 'An Amazing Palaeolithic "Pompeii" in Moravia', in a far from subtle comparison to the famous Roman site (Absolon 1929; 1936: 499):
As we learned from the Pompeii how the Romans lived, this 'prehistoric Pompeii' will reveal how primitive Europeans lived under the glacial conditions; the readers are introduced to the hearths and homes of the mammoth-hunters of Moravia.
This introduction carried several messages addressed to varied audiences, first and foremost in Europe. When Absolon points out later in the article, 'great light has been thrown on the antiquity of humanity', it is clear that it is only a certain part of humanity on whose antiquity light has been shed - the Europeans (Absolon 1929: 875). The 'homes and the hearths' make it a familiar sight, particularly to the British readers that are introduced to it. Further, the links created between England, where the article appeared, Pompeii, where the grand Roman history was suspended under the ashes of the volcano, and the 'prehistoric Pompeii' in Moravia covered with sand, so as to evoke the image of one grandiose, uninterrupted European past just waiting to be uncovered. At the same time, Absolon makes sure that Moravia is placed on the map of Europe, and of the world (Absolon 1929: 875):
Moravia has thereby become one of the most important countries for the study of the origin of man and human culture, as here under loess loess (lĕs, lō`əs, Ger. lös), unstratified soil deposit of varying thickness, usually yellowish and composed of fine-grained angular mineral particles mixed with clay. , we have the largest Palaeolithic stations in the world... the mammoth hunters are, in fact, the outstanding feature of Ancient Moravia... their habitations are of world-wide importance, because at the time of their occupation, Moravia was the scene where man passed through important phases in his development.
Patriotism on one hand, and regionalism re·gion·al·ism
a. Political division of an area into partially autonomous regions.
b. Advocacy of such a political system.
2. Loyalty to the interests of a particular region.
3. on the other, permeated all the writing. The newly established Czechoslovak republic was promoted vigorously, at the same time as it was subjected to internal battles between central Prague and provincial Moravia. This first article in the series is in particular a strong appeal for acceptance of Czechoslovakia, and Moravia, as European countries with the same glorious past, and for recognition of the local scholars as sophisticated archaeologists who know their field. 'I am fully aware of my great responsibility to future generations... and have adopted a firm scientific basis for research... the location has been explored methodically and in accordance with modern views', wrote Karel Absolon, proceeding to describe his excavation methods in detail, while leaving it to the specialist reader to decide who the future generations would be who would consider a Moravian archaeologist their forefather (Absolon 1929: 875). A similar appeal to the authority of science is also to be found in the 1927 French article, but none of the local ones, indicating the desire for Czechoslovakia to be included in the scientific circles of modern Europe. His concluding remarks echo this wish for recognition: 'I should be happy if some larger specimen of these Moravian prehistoric records could become part of the collections of the British Museum British Museum, the national repository in London for treasures in science and art. Located in the Bloomsbury section of the city, it has departments of antiquities, prints and drawings, coins and medals, and ethnography. of Natural History, as a proof of Czechoslovakia's respect for the great English nation' (Absolon 1929: 875).
The site and the primitive
The entire series of the articles presented Dolni Vestonice to the European audience, both lay and specialist, as a camp of mammoth-hunters, who caught the animals by cunning, appreciated their brains as a delicacy and created large numbers of decorative objects (Absolon 1929; 1936; 1937). Despite the occasional stress on sound scientific methods, Absolon constructed the whole interpretation as a suspenseful discovery narrative. He incorporated into the interpretations most of the current anthropological theories that suggested migration from Asia to the west, and later with the retreat of the ice-sheets northward. Absolon suggested that the skeletal material from Moravia, in combination with the artefacts, constituted sound proof that the Eskimos were descendants of fossil men of Magdalenian Europe, supporting his argument by citing a study in The Annals of Eugenics from 1926 (Absolon 1929).
The issue of race would develop over time, and one can notice a radical difference between the writing from the 1920s, and that from the late '30s. As mentioned earlier, from the beginning Absolon considered the occupants of Dolni Vestonice to have been 'primitive Europeans', yet drew his analogies from African and Australian cultures. The female figurine had four small holes on its head which, Absolon suggested, had feathers stuck in them as in African fetishes (Absolon 1929). The recovered pigment was associated with various stone slabs and round stones as toiletries toi·let·ry
n. pl. toi·let·ries
An article, such as toothpaste or a hairbrush, used in personal grooming or dressing.
toiletries npl → artículos mpl de aseo (= , and interpreted as evidence of body painting, similar to that of the Australian aborigines aborigines: see Australian aborigines. . The reasons for making such analogies were never stated, much less discussed or substantiated.
In 1935, Dolni Vestonice first appeared under the German name, Unterwisternitz, in a short report in the Zeitschrift fur Rassenkunde about human teeth recovered that were perforated in the same way as the animal teeth that presumably formed a necklace. This brief note itself is not in any way an indication of Absolon's adherence to racist views, yet the fact that he did publish the piece, short as it may be, in a journal that at the time already focused intensely on studies of racial differences and their implications for social policies is indicative of a greater historical milieu that he did not escape. We must remember that it was not only under the extreme and catastrophic developments of Nazi regime in Germany that race became an issue.
The then common belief in human differences rooted in biology surfaced the following year, when another report in The Illustrated London News discussed the latest clay figurines. Absolon expressed his hope that the most recent scientific methods would enable the study of fingerprints, so as to determine 'whether they differ from those of living men today' (Absolon 1936: 547). As much as African and Australian cultures were considered comparable to the fossil record in the 1920s and early 1930s, by the mid 1930s they were seen as different. Previously, 'European civilization' evolved where that of Africans and Australians stopped. In the later years, a serious attempt was made to prove that the 'Europeans' had completely separate ancestry. When a small ivory head was found at Dolni Vestonice in 1937, the news was announced under the heading 'By a Prehistoric "Leonardo da Vinci Leonardo da Vinci (də vĭn`chē, Ital. lāōnär`dō dä vēn`chē), 1452–1519, Italian painter, sculptor, architect, musician, engineer, and scientist, b. near Vinci, a hill village in Tuscany. "' of 30 thousand years ago: the Earliest Known Portrait of a Human Being - an Ivory Head' (Absolon 1937: 549). The importance of the find was expressed in unambiguous terms by Sir Arthur Keith Sir Arthur Keith (February 5, 1866—January 7, 1955) was a Scottish anatomist and anthropologist, and was a leading figure in the study of human fossils. Biography
Born in Aberdeen, he obtained a Bachelor of Medicine at the University of Aberdeen in 1888. , who wrote the introduction to the article (Keith in Absolon 1937: 549):
It is of particular interest to us Europeans - for it is a portrait of one of the white or Caucasian pioneers who began to colonize col·o·nize
v. col·o·nized, col·o·niz·ing, col·o·niz·es
1. To form or establish a colony or colonies in.
2. To migrate to and settle in; occupy as a colony.
3. Europe in the later phases of the Ice Age. It is not merely the early history of Moravia that is opening up, but the history of our European forefathers forefathers npl → antepasados mpl
forefathers npl → ancêtres mpl
forefathers npl → Vorfahren - and foremothers!(4) - soon after their first arrival in Central Europe.
With race becoming a major issue in the European context, Moravia had been recognized as a part of the 'civilized' world, a bearer of European history. The east Europeans did not have to ask for recognition when their material was useful in promoting a particular ideology - that of Caucasian Europeans. Local scholars did not mince words in making racial comparisons either: 'How crude are the faces of present-day Australian aborigines, or the pygmies of Central Africa, compared with this 'classical' portrait from old oriental civilizations, or even a modern drawing such as the head of Christ by the Dutch painter Jan Toroop in "Night in the Cathedral",' wrote Karel Absolon in 1937, and he expressed belief that the necessary exact scientific somatological analysis and anatomical construction would show measurable racial definitions (Absolon 1937: 552). The narrative to promote motherland and the native region was replaced in his writing during the 1930s as Czechoslovakia, and Moravia, were already accepted as a part of Europe. A peculiar combination of a pan-European historical narrative and scientific discourse emerged, aiming to provide a story of European racial purity, especially that of Caucasians of Christian faith. As mentioned earlier, the different treatment of the material before different readerships was most striking. The local audience was offered a slightly romantic, suspenseful account of six weeks of labour, discoveries and a vision of the future (archaeological and by extension also national) that reinforced the pride of place (Absolon 1938). The international readers were given proofs of all the current racial anthropological theories (Absolon 1927; 1936).
Less than two years later, Czechoslovakia was invaded and broken up, and Bohemia and Moravia, as Bohmen-Mahren, became a protectorate protectorate, in international law
protectorate, in international law, a relationship in which one state surrenders part of its sovereignty to another. The subordinate state is called a protectorate. of Germany. Karel Absolon ceased to be the director of the excavations at Dolni Vestonice, and new racial questions came into focus. These questions were equally rigorously explored with the latest scientific methods, but Slavic populations were no longer included in the sample of the Caucasian race Noun 1. Caucasian race - a light-skinned race
Caucasoid race, White people, White race
race - people who are believed to belong to the same genetic stock; "some biologists doubt that there are important genetic differences between races of human beings" .
During the first 15 years of excavations and research, Absolon and his team mainly aimed to uncover as large a space as possible and find out the size of the settlement. Originally, the physical space, its size and the mammoth-bone accumulations composed the context. The site was one large camp of mammoth-hunters. For these reasons, stratigraphy stratigraphy, branch of geology specifically concerned with the arrangement of layered rocks (see stratification). Stratigraphy is based on the law of superposition, which states that in a normal sequence of rock layers the youngest is on top and the oldest on the was observed only marginally, and relationships between artefacts were noted only toward the end of Absolon's research at Dolni Vestonice. The main goal was to put this Moravian site on the map, and prove the coexistence of mammoths and humans. Once that had become an accepted possibility in the mid 1930s, the clay, bone and ivory objects acquired a new meaning. They were no longer the mere decorations of the mammoth-hunters whose sheer existence had been in doubt. Rather, these objects themselves grew meaningful, as they could now reveal the identity of their makers. Relationships between the artefacts became the essential interpretive clues, and the association of the art objects with the mammoth bones was reduced to that of supporting context.
The need, and desire, to prove the contemporaneity of the ancient fauna and humans led to the inclusion of specialists on the team. Geologists, pedologists and palaeontologists participated in the analysis, mainly to assess the period of occupation, and their contribution consisted mainly in establishing credibility for the narrative that surrounded the prehistoric settlement. Their analyses were not included in the international publications, remaining only a part of the Czech technical reports.
The site Unterwisternitz excavated
In 1939, following the Munich agreement of the previous year, Czechoslovakia ceased to exist, and Bohemia and Moravia became a German protectorate, a situation that would last for the next six years. Charles University in Prague Other universities in the region were Krakow (1364) in Poland, Vienna (1365) in Austria and Heidelberg (1386) in Germany.
Its seal shows Charles kneeling in front of St. Wenceslas, surrounded by the inscription, Sigillum Universitatis Scolarium Studii Pragensis began teaching in German; and prehistory, labelled as 'the national science', became one of the most popular subjects. The head of the department Prof. Lothar Zotz published a number of articles on the prehistory of the region, arguing for the German ancestral ties to the land (Zotz 1940; 1944) [ILLUSTRATION FOR FIGURES 4, 5 OMITTED]. His best-known student Gisela Freund, the only published woman archaeologist to have worked in Moravian Palaeolithic research, undertook a comparison of the Unterwisternitz/Dolni Vestonice material with other Palaeolithic materials from the wider central European region, including the Willendorf collection for her dissertation research (Freund 1944). This project never took off, possibly due to a struggle between the University and the Forschungsstatte fur Urgeschichte des Ahnenerbe (Research Center for the Prehistory of Ancestral Heritage), a new research organization established by Himmler (Freund 1944: 3-10). The research centre achieved complete control over the site, the excavations and the retrieved materials from previous years, considering it too significant for its own goals to share it even with other German archaeologists. During the three following years, Dr Assien Bohmers attempted to 'correct the neglect of scientific techniques over the past fifteen years' (Bohmers 1941a: 45). Consequently, the foremost question that needed to be answered was that of stratigraphy, and the specific geological age of the culture located at the site (Bohmers 1941b). The German team shifted the focus from historically oriented prehistory to a natural-science-centred investigation that renewed close ties with geology. In collaboration with specialists on pollen and molluscs and with geologists, Bohmers announced that, for the first time, the Wurm Interstadial had been discovered and scientifically proven at this location (Bohmers 1941a: 45). The same site then was again a source of national pride, only of a different nation - German, and this time as a place of an overtly scientific breakthrough.
Yet this concern for science was not isolated from human issues. Bohmers ventured into the area of cultural materials as well, and offered an interpretation equally linked to the issue of race. According to according to
1. As stated or indicated by; on the authority of: according to historians.
2. In keeping with: according to instructions.
3. him, the art objects, rather than the mammoth bones, were the most important find, as from these one could get a glimpse of the world-view (Weltanschauung) of their makers (Bohmers 1941a: 47). Bohmers further explained that the characteristics of these artefacts, combined with the geological assessment of the deposits, confirmed the hypothesis that the people who inhabited the site were of the Cro-Magnon, Aurignacian or Brno race (Bohmers 1941a: 47). This, according to him, was significant as these people appeared after the 'annihilation' of the Neanderthal on the European, Asian and African continents, which was one of the greatest conquests of all times. These people were of a 'europide' shape and from them later came the 'Indogermans' (Bohmers 1941a: 47). Coming in the midst of a world war, an interpretation justified in such explicit racial terms needs little commentary.
Bohmers, like Absolon, remarked that the ivory head reflected the racial features of the population of Unterwisternitz/Dolni Vestonice and it 'was not for example Mongoloid or Negroid but rather a fully Indo-European racial group' (Bohmers 1941a: 51). Mainly due to its fairly distinct facial features Facial Features
See also anatomy; beards; body, human; eyes.
the condition of having an upper jaw that protrudes beyond the plane of the face. — gnathic, adj. , this piece attracted far more attention than other figurine fragments that may have had bodies but no faces. Bodies were assumed to be universally undifferentiated undifferentiated /un·dif·fer·en·ti·at·ed/ (un-dif?er-en´she-at-ed) anaplastic.
Having no special structure or function; primitive; embryonic. ; racially, ethnically indistinguishable, they only varied in the levels of fatness. The Vestonice figurine seemed steatopygic to Absolon, but fairly slim to Bohmers. Yet they both agreed that faces were the markers of difference.
In Bohmers' view, the physical space was the crucial context, but this time, the vertical aspect mattered more than the horizontal. Where Absolon wished to impress with breadth, Bohmers tried to secure the depth. The mammoth bones were no longer a major attraction; rather, racial definition and its dating dominated. Hence, the art objects in context - carefully positioned in a scientifically verified stratigraphic stra·tig·ra·phy
The study of rock strata, especially the distribution, deposition, and age of sedimentary rocks.
strat sequence - became the focus of research. The ancestors of the present population were 'Indogerman'; after all this was the German village, Unterwisternitz.
The site Dolni Vestonice excavated again
Seemingly uninterrupted by international turmoil, research returned to Dolni Vestonice shortly after the end of the Second World War. However, the village lost its German connotations as the entire population was expelled in 1945-6, and forcibly re-settled in Austria and Germany, while new Czech inhabitants moved in. Unterwisternitz became the Czech Dolni Vestonice, lending the illusion of Slavic permanence, while purging all memories of the German settlement in an effort to forget the horrors of the war. Needless to say, along with the village, control of the site passed back into Czech hands
In 1945, continuing what the German team had started, an interim Czech team carried out a very detailed geological and pedological study. During the war the entire area, as well as many others all over Europe, had been carefully mapped and surveyed for military purposes. A large number of scientific instruments that the army had for these purposes, became available to geologists who carried out survey for mining companies, and to construction companies that were re-building the roads in the post-war period. As a result, most research by archaeologists in Czechoslovakia at the time was closely tied-in to these enterprises, due to a lack of other equipment and funds.
The original reports from 1945-7 are not available, probably due to the transitional character of the post-war regime. In 1948 Czechoslovakia fell firmly under the domain of the Soviet Union, and anything written in the post-war period was either left unpublished or disappeared, only to reappear in the 1950s in an altered form. This gap is so striking that the proliferation of works that came out afterwards, dealing solely with stratigraphy, is even more astonishing. All of prehistory became one complex stratified stratified /strat·i·fied/ (strat´i-fid) formed or arranged in layers.
Arranged in the form of layers or strata. deposit that needed to be investigated. The group of researchers that worked at Dolni Vestonice after the war, Knor et al., summarized the situation very succinctly in the foreword to their 1953 volume (Bohm in Knor 1953: 5):
The entire problem of the Upper Palaeolithic and its typology typology /ty·pol·o·gy/ (ti-pol´ah-je) the study of types; the science of classifying, as bacteria according to type.
the study of types; the science of classifying, as bacteria according to type. , as well as the questions of the geological periodisation of the last glaciation, has come to be addressed, together with the methodical issues of open air sites, so successfully by the Soviet archeology. It became clear to us that further research at Dolni Vestonice must look for new approaches to work.
The last sentence sounds especially striking, since Bohm does not explain why it became clear, or what the new approaches were, yet it is obvious from the brief foreword and the reports themselves that 'further research' depended on this premise, or at least on its inclusion in the foreword. Following this Czech foreword was, we find, a Russian translation and, as the manuscript continues, a Russian translation for each contribution as well. We should remember that the years 1949-56 were politically severe, with show trials, labour camps and arrests of innocent people whose crime was their supposed 'betrayal of the republic'. Making one false step may have had severe consequences, particularly in fields so highly ideological, and at the same time public, as archaeology.
The adoption of the new approach was also followed by a removal of Dr Absolon from his research position, and his forced professional insignificance in·sig·nif·i·cance
The quality or state of being insignificant.
Noun 1. insignificance - the quality of having little or no significance
unimportance - the quality of not being important or worthy of note until his death in 1960, when his son, by then living in the United States United States, officially United States of America, republic (2005 est. pop. 295,734,000), 3,539,227 sq mi (9,166,598 sq km), North America. The United States is the world's third largest country in population and the fourth largest country in area. , was not even allowed to attend the funeral. Any bibliography of Karel Absolon's work is a clear testimony to his fate, the last date in it being 1947. The monograph on Dolni Vestonice that he was planning to publish never came out, and his monograph on Predmosti was posthumously edited in German by B. Klima (Absolon & Klima 1977).
In this era, complete immersion in the soils and their sequences was the safest approach to take. The scientific writing that previously supported and justified the dominant ideology The dominant ideology, in Marxist or marxian theory, is the set of common values and beliefs shared by most people in a given society, framing how the majority think about a range of topics, The dominant ideology is understood by Marxism to reflect, or serve, the interests of the was now used to protect the scholars from the ideology of their own society. Geology, pedology pedology
A branch of soil science focusing on the formation, morphology, and classification of soils as bodies within the natural landscape. Pedology seeks to understand how the properties and distribution patterns of soils worldwide (collectively called the pedosphere) have , palaeontology of micro-vertebrates became the safe haven 1. Designated area(s) to which noncombatants of the United States Government's responsibility and commercial vehicles and materiel may be evacuated during a domestic or other valid emergency.
2. for all those who supposedly studied past human societies. The justification for this complete avoidance of interpretation, and the exclusion of people from archaeological consideration, was found in adopting an extreme ecological perspective (Knor et al. 1953: 8):
Today, we are no longer interested in collecting objects, but rather in scientific observations, which can be done only through a systematic survey of all aspects of the Palaeolithic sites.... we were therefore not interested in flint artefacts, bone objects, figurines, skeletal remains of humans and animals, but rather in their depositional environment and how they related to it...
In order to be able to say anything about past societies, went the interpretative logic, one needs to know intimately the natural environment in which they lived. In the process of such detailed research, no one will talk about the people, their relations, or their social system, so went the underlying political logic. Consequently, the stratigraphic sequence became the context that needed to be analysed before anything else, a process that could - conveniently - last ad infinitum ad in·fi·ni·tum
adv. & adj.
To infinity; having no end.
[Latin ad, to + .
The situation in Eastern Europe stabilized after the mid 1950s, and the Cold War became less of an immediate and obvious presence. This loosening of political tensions opened the door for the prehistoric people to return to Dolni Vestonice, and the new work re-discovered humans in the past. However, these were not from 'pravek' (ancestral past) any more but rather from the international Palaeolithic. Science had arrived to stay but, in contrast with the earlier wartime writing, at least the prehistoric populations were not placed in the wide and general Wurm Interstadial, but in the more personal Palaeolithic, defined not in terms of the weather but the means of production Means Of Production is a compilation of Aim's early 12" and EP releases, recorded between 1995 and 1998. Track listing
Any attempt at interpreting the social context was bracketed with Soviet sites where similar situations occurred, or which Soviet archaeologists considered significant. Evoking this master reference and others within the Eastern alliance became a necessity, as most archaeologists had very little access to foreign materials, and theoretical developments in the West were unknown. All theoretical discussions of this particular time period cited the same work - Engels' The origin of the family, private property and state - accepting his scenario of matriarchy matriarchy, familial and political rule by women. Many contemporary anthropologists reject the claims of J. J. Bachofen and Lewis Morgan that early societies were matriarchal, although some contemporary feminist theory has suggested that a primitive matriarchy did , equality, and no private property. For example, Klima's interpretation of the social context reads (Klima 1963: 97):
The immense bone accumulation is not merely a sign of the abundance of animals in the area, but more importantly, it is the sign that numerous members of a matrilineal mat·ri·lin·e·al
Relating to, based on, or tracing ancestral descent through the maternal line. clan lived here for a long period of time, in prosperity, and sometimes even an overabundance o·ver·a·bun·dance
A going or being beyond what is needed, desired, or appropriate; an excess: teenagers with an overabundance of energy. of food, and that they did not feel excruciating, long-lasting hunger. Economic well-being was secured, besides gathering, by collective hunting, whose success depended on good organization, hunting strategies, and effective weapons. Even though these were in personal, individual possession, the fact that hunting was a collaborative effort, meant that the kill was communal property. The large size of the settlement and the large number of the accumulated bones fully prove the correctness of interpretation based on historical materialism historical materialism: see dialectical materialism. .
Stabilization of political boundaries in Europe since the second half of the 1950s resulted in a renewed cooperation with some western countries. In scientific research this led to a new attention to international publications. A longer overview of Moravian Palaeolithic research was published in 1957 in the German Quartar where Lothar Zotz was the editor, and it was in this journal that Moravian research was regularly presented throughout the 1960s, a tradition that continued when Gisela Freund succeeded Zotz as editor in 1968 (Klima 1963; 1965; 1968; 1991; Valoch 1959). Excavations at Dolni Vestonice in the 1950s and '60s recovered remains of a kiln with fired ceramic pieces (possibly covered by a hut-like structure), a burial of a woman, several pieces of human skeletons, and more mammoth bones (Svoboda 1994). All these attracted sufficient interest in Czechoslovakia, as well as abroad, and served as a vehicle to strengthen contacts with the scientific community in other European countries.
The most striking find came in 1986, as a part of a salvage operation 1. The recovery, evacuation, and reclamation of damaged, discarded, condemned, or abandoned allied or enemy materiel, ships, craft, and floating equipment for reuse, repair, refabrication, or scrapping.
2. during the construction of a controversial mega-dam project that flooded a vast area in the vicinity of Dolni Vestonice. A burial with three perfectly preserved skeletons drew instant attention, not only in Czechoslovakia but also in the wider archaeological community in Europe and North America North America, third largest continent (1990 est. pop. 365,000,000), c.9,400,000 sq mi (24,346,000 sq km), the northern of the two continents of the Western Hemisphere. . The three individuals were presented as a replacement for the skeletons from Predmosti that perished at the end of the war in 1945, allowing again for interpretations of the prehistoric people's lives: their difficult survival, their 'irrational religious beliefs', their 'strange burial practices' (Klima 1987: 252). Not unlike the significant finds at Dolni Vestonice in the 1930s, the three skeletons were presented as unique objects in Palaeolithic research, providing direct information about the 'prehistoric inhabitants of the European steppes' (Klima 1987: 252). The re-establishment of Dolni Vestonice as one of the more significant Palaeolithic sites in Europe on this new empirical basis created a new interpretive space for the researchers, as well as popular writers (Auel 1990: 492-647). Yet in scientific terms the space was largely to remain empty; the human finds generated much interest, but most technical work continued to focus on stone tool typologies.
The dramatic political events of 1989 in Eastern Europe brought about remarkably little change in archaeology, particularly Palaeolithic archaeology. The site of Dolni Vestonice is now frequently visited by Western researchers, but the theoretical approach remains relatively unaffected. Typology combined with scientific techniques dominates the research, and a basic evolutionary paradigm is the motivating force. Ideology or history, whether current, past, or even prehistoric, is considered irrelevant. The recent stasis of Palaeolithic archaeology in Czechoslovakia, and Eastern Europe in general, finds support in the continuing preoccupation with stone tool typology in Western European archaeology. It also lends credence to Communist-period research, and allows the possibility of claiming scientific neutrality all along.
In 1992 a remarkable short article entitled 'Who was Lothar Zotz?', by K. Sklenar, appeared in a small newsletter of the speleological society of Czechoslovakia. The author discusses the contributions of L. Zotz to 'Czechoslovak archaeology' (the entity which, if archaeology were to operate without a social context, would exist as a unified, local branch of independent science), arguing that his membership in the Nazi party Nazi Party
German political party of National Socialism. Founded in 1919 as the German Workers' Party, it changed its name to the National Socialist German Workers' Party when Adolf Hitler became leader (1920–21). was only formal, and any extreme pro-German rhetoric in his articles should be ignored for the sake of the scientific contributions made (Sklenar 1992: 16):
It is clear that he [Zotz] could not have reached his position without a membership in the ruling Nazi party; however, we all know from our own experience, how many capable people consider joining the party as a condition and a price for the opportunity to have a professional career, without internally identifying with the principles or even practices of the party.
I would suggest that this article closes the circle between the practice of war-time science under National Socialism, and post-war science under Communism, while retaining the perfect illusion of a neutral, rational scientific tradition.
Traumas born of the Second World War paralysed most social sciences and humanities in Central Europe, a condition only augmented in Eastern Europe by the experience of the Communist experiment. The consequence has been a theoretical silence, in need of a historicizing, self-reflexive discussion. Only such debate would enable social scientists to move from disciplines defined only by techniques, to more theoretically engaged studies that directly contribute to our knowledge of the human condition, past and present.(5)
Of all the branches of archaeology, work on the Palaeolithic has been positioned most closely to the natural sciences, due to a combination of the material available for study and the techniques involved in its investigation. This close connection to neighbouring realms such as geology has lent Palaeolithic archaeology the aura of objective science, even while the ultimate subject in question remains human and social. Within the Palaeolithic tradition this scientific connection has frequently blurred into scientism sci·en·tism
1. The collection of attitudes and practices considered typical of scientists.
2. The belief that the investigative methods of the physical sciences are applicable or justifiable in all fields of inquiry. , and a belief that interpretations represent the stumbling-block of proper neutrality. The stories that social scientists spin lead them astray from neutral facts and the material evidence; narrative obscures what would be otherwise clear data. Critics of the concept of neutral science have directed most of their attention towards textual deconstruction of interpretations, analysis of the structure and the underlying logic of the argument, presuppositions and hypotheses. Sociological and historical studies of developments in archaeology have shown the extent to which these are embedded in a socio-cultural context. However, this type of analysis leaves the choice of research techniques, material evidence, collaboration with other sciences, and what counts as data largely intact. A major insight of recent social study of science (e.g. Latour 1987; Shapin & Schaeffer 1985) is precisely that techniques are not neutral, and that facts - however factual - are social constructs, embedded in social and political contexts.
I have shown in the case of Dolni Vestonice that Palaeolithic archaeology is just as susceptible to social influences as any other branch of archaeology. In addition, the prospect of deciphering the enigma of human origins, the solution of the time and space question of when 'we' became what we are today, adds to the possibility of strengthening particular origin myths, territorial claims and justification of modern-day social phenomena. The interpretations of the site have clearly been used to promote different agendas over time. Research in the 1920s tried to promote the newly created state of Czechoslovakia, place it on the map of Europe and secure its position in the origins of civilization. Nationalism played an indirect role when the site was officially located in Moravia, Czechoslovakia; its location in an ethnically German part of the country was never mentioned. The overriding sentiment was less anti-German than a desire to emphasize that the Czech lands The "Czech lands" (Czech: České země) is an auxiliary term used mainly to describe the combination of Bohemia, Moravia and Czech Silesia. Today, those three historic provinces compose the Czech Republic. belonged to a pan-European civilized world. This claim of European unity turned towards a Caucasian racial affinity in the 1930s, and then, after the German occupation, the key racial category was narrowed down to the exclusion of Czechs. German research focused on the origins myth, as the question of 'Indogermans' came into prominence, and the site was in a sense rediscovered, and found to have been located in a German part of Europe all along. After the war, the historical and political context of communism framed a concentrated study of the means of production, affirming the correctness of the crudest form of Marxist theories. Internationalism in·ter·na·tion·al·ism
1. The condition or quality of being international in character, principles, concern, or attitude.
2. A policy or practice of cooperation among nations, especially in politics and economic matters. and economic production were re-told against the background of the earliest human history.
However, as I have shown in this historical study of Dolni Vestonice, it is important to note that not only the interpretations of the site varied over time, but that scientific techniques, methods of excavation and the choice of data shifted as well. As meticulously as Absolon uncovered a large horizontal space with numerous faunal remains in the 1920s and '30s, the German team carefully focused on the vertical space, the geological sequence and its dating. Both methods were just as scientifically solid and justified, as was the post-war preoccupation with stone tools and typology. Moreover, this consistent tradition of sound methodology gave the illusion of a single, neutral, apolitical a·po·lit·i·cal
1. Having no interest in or association with politics.
2. Having no political relevance or importance: claimed that the President's upcoming trip was purely apolitical. scientific enterprise evolving all along, even as researchers and local people come and go. Yet technology is no more neutral than interpretations, and facts are as social as are the words that talk about them; all can be alternately emphasized or ignored. Alison Wylie Alison Wylie is a feminist philosopher of science at the University of Washington, Seattle. In her own words, Wylie describes her interests in the following:
Acknowledgements. I would like to thank the Archaeology faculty at the University of California, Berkeley The University of California, Berkeley is a public research university located in Berkeley, California, United States. Commonly referred to as UC Berkeley, Berkeley and Cal for their support, especially Meg Conkey and Ruth Tringham. Mike Bisson, Lisa Lloyd, Peter Redfield, Bruce Trigger Bruce Graham Trigger (June 18, 1937–December 1, 2006) was a Canadian archaeologist.
Born in Preston, Ontario, he received a doctorate in archaeology from Yale University in 1964. , Barbara Voytek, Judit Zsoldos and the extended Tomasek family all have contributed directly to the history of this essay. Jiri Svoboda and Bohuslav Klima provided invaluable assistance during my research in Czechoslovakia, while the Social Science and Humanities Research Council of Canada, the Wenner-Gren Foundation and the University of California at Berkeley (body, education) University of California at Berkeley - (UCB)
See also Berzerkley, BSD.
Note to British and Commonwealth readers: that's /berk'lee/, not /bark'lee/ as in British Received Pronunciation. generously contributed monetary support. Finally, I must acknowledge the perceptive and helpful comments of two anonymous reviewers. All errors in fact or interpretation, however, remain my own responsibility.
1 In following the case of Dolni Vestonice over time, I will take a historicist position in assessing the value of its interpretations, suggesting the problematic nature of the notion of 'good' and 'bad' science. It is important to note that such a stance does not imply the non-existence of bad or unsuitable techniques, procedures or methods, only the absence of transcendental certainty beyond the reach of context or time. For a sampling of recent work in historical and sociological studies of science that informs this essay, see Bowler 1983; 1989: Clark 1991; Crawford 1992; Fortescue 1987; Foucault 1970; Haraway 1989; Latour 1987; Longino 1991; Lynch & Woolgar 1990; Rudwick 1985; Shapin & Schaffer 1985; Weiner 1989; and, of course, Kuhn 1970.
2 It does matter after all, as the historian of science L. Pyenson asks: 'why astronomy rose to such prominence in the Netherlands, despite a climate entirely unpropitious for star-gazing, while no such tradition emerged in a topographically well suited country of comparable size and temperament, Switzerland' (Pyenson 1989: 379). See Lowenthal (1985) on relations between nation and landscape.
3 In 1930 Czechs officially accounted for 51[center dot]1% of the population and Slovaks another 15[center dot]8%, while Germans (22[center dot]3%), Hungarians (4[center dot]8%) and Ruthenians (3[center dot]8%) made up the most substantial minorities, in addition to Jews (1[center dot]3%), Poles (0[center dot]6%), and - most likely underreported - Gypsies (0[center dot]2%) (Magocsi 1993: 132-3).
4 The remark refers to an argument between Absolon, who insisted that the head depicted a man, and Keith, who was convinced that it was a portrait of a woman. Neither provided an explicit rationale for his respective attribution of gender to the object.
5 Addendum addendum n. an addition to a completed written document. Most commonly this is a proposed change or explanation (such as a list of goods to be included) in a contract, or some point that has been subject of negotiation after the contract was originally proposed by : President Vaclav Havel Noun 1. Vaclav Havel - Czech dramatist and statesman whose plays opposed totalitarianism and who served as president of Czechoslovakia from 1989 to 1992 and president of the Czech Republic since 1993 (born in 1936)
Havel offered in 1992 an official apology to those Germans who were expelled at the end of the war, calling it an unjust punishment based on a faulty presumption of collective guilt. His speech was not welcomed on either side: the Czechs fear retribution and possible loss of property and land, the Sudeten Germans desired far more, beyond the act of recognition of injustice.
ABSOLON, K. 1925. A discovery as wonderful as that of Tutenkhamen's Tomb. Moravia over 20,000 years ago, Illustrated London News 31 October 1925.
1926. Bericht uber die palaeolithische Abteilung am mahrischen Landes-Museum und die palaeolithische Forschung in Mahren, Casopis Moravskeho Zemskeho Muzea 24(11).
1927. Une nouvelle et importante station Aurignacienne en Moravie, Revue Anthropologique 27(1927): 73-88.
1928. Uber die grosse Aurignac-Station bei Unter-Wisternitz in Mahren, Tagungsberichte der deutschen Anthropologischen Gesellschaft, Bericht fiber die 49. Versammlung in Koln: 57-61. Leipzig.
1929. An amazing Palaeolithic 'Pompeii' in Moravia - Parts I, II, III, Illustrated London News 23 November 1929, 30 November 1929, 14 December 1929.
1935. Ein Anhangsel aus einem fossilen Menschenzahn, Zeitschrift fur Rassenkunde: 317
1936. A vast prehistoric 'Pompeii' revisited, Illustrated London News 21 March 1936, 28 March 1936.
1937. The world's earliest portrait - 30 thousand years, Illustrated London News 2 October 1937.
1938a. Vyzkum diluvialni stanice lovcu mamutu v Dolnich Vestonicich na Pavlovskych kopcich na Morave: Pracovni zprava za prvni rok 1924. Brno. Palaeoethnologicka Serie c Serie C is the name of the third and fourth highest football leagues in Italy. It is broken up into Serie C1 (third tier) and Serie C2 (fourth tier).
In turn, Serie C1 consists of two divisions: Serie C1/A and Serie C1/B, both of 18 teams. .4.
1938b. Die Erforschung der diluvialen Mammut-jagerstation von Unter-Wisternitz an den Pollauer Bergen in Mahren: Arbeitsbericht uber das zweite Jahr 1925. Brno.
1945. Vyzkum diluvialni stanice lovcu mamutu v Dolnich Vestonicich na Pavlovskych kopcich na Morave: Pracovni zprava za treti rok 1926. Brno.
ABSOLON, K. & B. KLIMA. 1977. Predmosti, ein Mammutjagerplatz in Mahren. Prague: Academia.
ARNOLD, B. 1990. The past as propaganda: totalitarian archaeology in Nazi Germany, Antiquity 64: 464-79.
AUEL, J. 1990. The plains of passage. New York New York, state, United States
New York, Middle Atlantic state of the United States. It is bordered by Vermont, Massachusetts, Connecticut, and the Atlantic Ocean (E), New Jersey and Pennsylvania (S), Lakes Erie and Ontario and the Canadian province of (NY): Bantam Bantam
Former city and sultanate, Java. It was located at the western end of Java between the Java Sea and the Indian Ocean. In the early 16th century it became a powerful Muslim sultanate, which extended its control over parts of Sumatra and Borneo. .
BAYER, J. 1924. Eine Mammutjagerstation im Loss bei Pollau in Sudmahren, Die Eiszeit 1(2): 81-8.
BEN-DAVID, J. 1984. The scientist's role in a society: a comparative study. Chicago (IL): University of Chicago Press The University of Chicago Press is the largest university press in the United States. It is operated by the University of Chicago and publishes a wide variety of academic titles, including The Chicago Manual of Style, dozens of academic journals, including .
BOHMERS, A. 1940. Das eiszeitliche Frauenkopfchen von Unter-Wisternitz, Kleine Kostbarkeiten aus Kunst und Geschichte: 27-31. Berlin-Dahlem: Ahnenerbe Stiftung-Verlag.
1941a. Die Ausgrabungen bei Unter-Wisternitz, Forschungen und Fortschritte 17(3).
1941b. Reiche Funde eiszeitlicher Bildkunst, die Ausgrabungen bei Unter-Wisternitz, Germanien 2: 45-57.
1943. Die Erforschung yon Unter-Wisternitz Bericht fiber die Ausgrabungen von 1939-1942, Anthropos Forschungen 1.
CHIPPINDALE, C. 1988. The invention of the words for the idea of 'prehistory', Proceedings of the Prehistoric Society 54: 304-14.
CLERMONT, N. & P. SMITH. 1990. Prehistoric, prehistory, pre-historian... who invented the terms?, Antiquity 64: 97-102.
CRAWFORD, E. 1992. Nationalism and internationalism in science, 1880-1939. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press Cambridge University Press (known colloquially as CUP) is a publisher given a Royal Charter by Henry VIII in 1534, and one of the two privileged presses (the other being Oxford University Press). .
DANIEL, G. 1963. The idea of prehistory. Cleveland (OH): World Publishing.
DENNELL, R. 1990. Progressive gradualism grad·u·al·ism
1. The belief in or the policy of advancing toward a goal by gradual, often slow stages.
2. Biology , imperialism and academic fashion: Lower Palaeolithic archaeology in the 20th century, Antiquity 64: 549-58.
DIETLER, M. 1994. 'Our ancestors the Gauls': archaeology, ethnic nationalism Ethnic nationalism is a form of nationalism wherein the "nation" is defined in terms of ethnicity. Whatever specific ethnicity is involved, ethnic nationalism always includes some element of descent from previous generations. , and the manipulation of Celtic identity in modern Europe, American Anthropologist 96(3): 584-605.
ERMARTH, M. 1978. Wilhelm Dilthey Wilhelm Dilthey (IPA: [ˈdɪltaɪ]; November 19, 1833 – October 1, 1911) was a German historian, psychologist, sociologist, student of hermeneutics, and philosopher. : The critique of historical reason. Chicago (IL): University of Chicago Press.
FORTESCUE, S. 1987. The Communist Party Communist party, in China
Communist party, in China, ruling party of the world's most populous nation since 1949 and most important Communist party in the world since the disintegration of the USSR in 1991. and Soviet science. Baltimore (MD): John Hopkins University Press.
FOUCAULT, M. 1970. The order of things: an archaeology of the human sciences. New York (NY): Vintage.
FOWLER, D.D. 1987. Uses of the past: archaeology in the service of the state, American Antiquity 52: 229-48.
FREUND, G. 1944. Pschedmost. Doctoral Dissertation from the German Charles University in Prague.
GATHERCOLE, P. & D. LOWENTHAL (ED.). 1990. The politics of the past. London: Unwin Hyman.
GERO, J.M., D.M. LACY & M.L. BLAKEY (ED.). 1983. The socio-politics of archaeology. Amherst (MA): Department of Anthropology, University of Massachusetts The system includes UMass Amherst, UMass Boston, UMass Dartmouth (affiliated with Cape Cod Community College), UMass Lowell, and the UMass Medical School. It also has an online school called UMassOnline. . Research report 23.
GOJDA, M. 1991. The Ancient Slavs: settlement and society. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press Edinburgh University Press is a university publisher that is part of the University of Edinburgh in Edinburgh, Scotland. External links
GRAYSON, D.K. 1983. The establishment of human antiquity. New York (NY): Academic Press.
HARAWAY, D. 1989. Primate visions. London: Routledge.
HOBSBAWM, E.J. 1992. Ethnicity and nationalism in Europe today Europe Today is a daily radio news show on the BBC World Service about public affairs throughout Europe. It is presented by Audrey Carville at 17:00 GMT every weekday. External links
HODDER, I. (ed.). 1991. Archaeological theory Archaeological theory covers the debates over the practice of archaeology and the interpretation of archaeological results. There is no single theory of archaeology, and even definitions are disputed. in Europe. London: Routledge.
JALEVICH, B. 1987. Modern Austria: Empire and republic, 1815-1986. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
KLIMA, B. 1951. Karel Jaroslav Maka, Casopis Moravskeho Musea v Brne 36(2): 9-20.
1957. Ubersicht uber die jungsten palaolitischen Forschungen in Mahren, Quartar 9: 85-130.
1958. Upper Palaeolithic art in Moravia, Antiquity 32: 8-14.
1963. Dolni Vestonice. Prague: CSAV CSAV Center for the Study of Active Volcanoes (University of Hawaii)
CSAV Compañía Sud Americana de Vapores (Chilean Shipping Company)
CSAV Chief of Staff Aviation .
1965. Eine neue palaolithische Ritzzeichung aus der Pekarna-Hohle in Mahren, Quartar 15/16: 167-72.
1968. Das Pavlovien in den Weinbergholen von Mauern, Quartar 19: 263-73.
1987. Mladopaleoliticky trojhrob v Dolnich Vestonicich, Archeologicke Rozhledy 34: 241-54.
1991. Der palaolithische Massengrab von Predmosti, Versuch einer Rekonstruktion, Quartar 41/42: 187-94.
KNOR, A., V. LOZEK, J. PELISEK & K. ZEBERA (ed.). 1953. Dolni Vestonice. Prague: CSAV.
KOBYLINSKI, Z. 1991. Theory in Polish archaeology 1960-90: searching for paradigms, in Hodder (ed.) 223-47.
KRISTIANSEN, K. 1990. National archaeology in the age of European integration, Antiquity 64: 825-8.
LASZLOVSKY, J. & CS. SIKLODI. 1991. Archaeological theory in Hungary since 1960: theories without theoretical archaeology, in Hodder (ed.) 272-98.
LATOUR, B. 1987. Science in action: how to follow scientists and engineers through society. Milton Keynes Milton Keynes (mĭl`tən kēnz`), town (1991 pop. 36,886) and borough, S central England. Milton Keynes was designated one of the new towns in 1967 to alleviate overpopulation in London. It is the seat of the Open Univ. : Open University Press.
LONGINO, H. 1990. Science as social knowledge. Princeton (NJ): Princeton University Princeton University, at Princeton, N.J.; coeducational; chartered 1746, opened 1747, rechartered 1748, called the College of New Jersey until 1896. Schools and Research Facilities
LOWENTHAL, D. 1985. The past is a foreign country. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
LYNCH, M. & S. WOOLGAR (ed.). 1990. Representation in scientific practice. Cambridge (MA): MIT MIT - Massachusetts Institute of Technology Press.
MAGOCSI, P. 1993. Historical atlas A historical atlas is an atlas that includes historical maps and charts depicting the evolving geopolitical landscape. They are helpful in understanding historical context, the scope and scale of historical events and historical subjects (such as the expansion of the Roman Empire), of East Central Europe. Seattle (WA): University of Washington Press.
MILISAUSKAS, S. 1990. The People's revolution of 1989 and archaeology in Eastern Europe, Antiquity 64: 283-5.
NASH Nash , Ogden 1902-1971.
American writer known for his droll epigrammatic verse, much of which appeared in the New Yorker.
Noun 1. Nash - United States writer noted for his droll epigrams (1902-1971)
Ogden Nash , C. (ed.). 1990. Narrative in culture: The uses of storytelling in the sciences, philosophy, and literature. London: Routledge.
NEUSTUPNY, E. 1991. Recent theoretical achievements in prehistoric archaeology History is the study of the past using written records. Archaeology can also be used to study the past alongside history. Prehistoric archaeology is the study of the past before historical records began. in Czechoslovakia, in Hodder (ed.): 248-71.
PALLADINO, P. & M. WORBOYS. 1993. Science and imperialism, Isis 84: 91-102.
PATRICK, L. 1985. Is there an archaeological record The archaeological record is a term used in archaeology to denote all archaeological evidence, including the physical remains of past human activities which archaeologists seek out and record in an attempt to analyze and reconstruct the past. ? in M. Schiffer (ed.), Advances in archaeological method and theory 8: 27-62.
PINSKY, V. & A. WYLIE (ed.). 1989. Critical traditions in contemporary archaeology Contemporary Archaeology is a field of archaeological research that focuses on the most recent (20th and 21st century) past, and also increasingly explores the application of archaeological thinking to the contemporary world. . Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
PYENSON, L. 1989. What is the good of history of science?, History of Science 27: 353-89.
RENFREW, C. & P. BAHN. 1991. Archaeology: theories, methods, and practice. New York (NY): Thames & Hudson.
RUDWICK, M. 1985 The great Devonian controversy: the shaping of scientific knowledge among gentlemanly specialists. Chicago (IL): University of Chicago Press.
RUPKE, N.A. 1983. The study of fossils in the romantic philosophy of history and nature, History of Science 21: 389-413.
SCHWABEDISSEN, H. Z. Z. BEI DER WEHRMACHT. 1943. Stand und Aufgaben der Alt- und Mittelsteinzeitforschung im mahrischen Raum, Zeitschrift des Mahrischen Landesmuseums (n.s.) 3: 15-45.
SHAPIN, S. & S. SCHAFFER. 1985. Leviathan and the airpump. Princeton (NJ): Princeton University Press.
SHORE, C. & A. BLACK. 1992. The European communities and the construction of Europe, Anthropology Today 8(3): 10-11.
SKLENAR, K. 1985. Archaeology in Central Europe. Chicago (IL): University of Chicago Press.
1992. Kto byl Lothar Zotz?, Speleologie 3: 15-20.
SOFFER, O., P. VANDIVER, B. KLIMA & J. SVOBODA. 1993. The pyrotechnology of performance art: Moravian Venuses and wolverines, in H. Knecht, A. Pike-Tay & R. White (ed.), Before Lascaux: The complete record of the early Upper Paleolithic Noun 1. Upper Paleolithic - the time period during which only modern Homo sapiens was known to have existed; ended about 10,000 years BC
Palaeolithic, Paleolithic, Paleolithic Age - second part of the Stone Age beginning about 750,00 to 500,000 years BC and lasting : 259-75. Boca Raton Boca Raton (bō`kə rətōn`), city (1990 pop. 61,492), Palm Beach co., SE Fla., on the Atlantic; inc. 1925. Boca Raton is a popular resort and retirement community that experienced significant industrial development in the 1970s and 80s. (LA): CRC (Cyclical Redundancy Checking) An error checking technique used to ensure the accuracy of transmitting digital data. The transmitted messages are divided into predetermined lengths which, used as dividends, are divided by a fixed divisor. Press.
SVOBODA, J. 1989. Middle Pleistocene So far, the Pleistocene Series is not subdivided into formal units (i.e., Stages). Several solutions were proposed, and dedicated working groups are presently pursuing an agreed solution. adaptations in Central Europe, Journal of World Prehistory 3: 33-70.
(Ed.). 1991. Dolni Vestonice II, Western slope. Liege liege
In European feudal society, an unconditional bond between a man and his overlord. Thus, if a tenant held estates from various overlords, his obligations to his liege lord, to whom he had paid “liege homage,” were greater than his obligations to the other : ERAUL.
(Ed.). 1994. Paleolit Moravy a Slezska. Brno: AVCR. Dolni Vestonice Studies 1.
THOMAS, D.H. 1989. Archaeology. Fort Worth (TX): Holt, Reinhart & Winston, Dryden Press.
TRIGGER, B. 1984. Alternative archaeologies: nationalist, colonialist, imperialist, Man 19: 355-70.
1989. A history of archaeological thought. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
VALOCH, K. 1959. Losse un palaolithische Kulturen in der Tschechoslowakei, Quartar 10/11: 115-49.
VENCLOVA, N. 1991. Introduction: archaeology in Czechoslovakia: trends and approaches, Antiquity 65: 306.
WYLIE, A.M. 1989. The interpretive dilemma, in Pinsky & Wylie (ed.): 18-27.
YOFFEE, N. & A. SHERRATT (ed.). 1993. Archaeological theory: who sets the agenda? Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
ZOTZ, L. 1940. 1st Bohmen-Mahren die Urheimat der Tschechen? Leipzig: Johann Ambrosius Barth.
1944. Von den Mammutjagern zu den Wikingern: Ergebnisse und Aufgaben der bohmisch-mahrischen Vorgeschichtskunde. Leipzig: Johann Ambrosius Barth.
SILVIA TOMASKOVA, Department of Anthropology, University of California, Berkeley CA 94720, USA.