Elghanayan brothers bust up family business with remarkable equanimity.
The Iranian-American Elghanayan brothers, who were partners in a multibillion-dollar real estate empire that extended throughout New York and Washington, D.C., have officially split and divided their assets amicably. Henry (Houchang), 69, K. Thomas (Kamran), 64, and Frederick Elghanayan, 61, were partners for nearly 40 years in a $3 billion dollar real estate company that oversaw 8,000 apartments and nine development sites in New York and nine office buildings in New York and Washington. But on March 4, the day after their mother died and the day before their father died, the brothers split over differences of opinion in succession and company expansion issues. Henry, the brother who initiated the split, wanted his son Justin, 31, the only offspring of the three brothers who is active in the family business, to be named as successor. "I was more interested in the question of succession because my son was in the business," Henry said. "At some point, I thought it was better for the whole family that we divide." But Henry also had a difference of opinion with his two brothers over the issue of development and expansion of their company. Henry told The New York Times he wanted to be an independent developer, going further than just buying existing office buildings but actually erecting new ones, and he also wanted to take on partners by creating an investment fund, something his brothers opposed. After discussion about revising the partnership produced no suitable compromise, Henry sent his brothers a legal notice in August 2008 that he wanted out of the family partnership that ran the Rockrose Development Corporation--one of Manhattan's largest developers of residential buildings. The notice was required under a partnership agreement they drew up in 1989 after Jeffrey, another brother, left the business for California. The split, which became official September 29, was relatively pleasant. To decide how to divide the assets, Michael P. Korotkin, the Elghanayans' real estate lawyer, set out two envelopes, one of which contained a plastic coffee stirrer. Whoever picked the envelope containing the coffee stirrer would be the one to call heads or tails in a coin toss. If he called the toss correctly, he would get first pick of three groups of assets that were previously divided. As it turned out, Henry chose the envelope with the coffee stirrer, and correctly called tails during the coin toss. Henry ended up with the section that contained the "Rockrose" name and the majority of the family's development sites, as well as eight residential buildings with 2,634 apartments. Tom and Fred, who remain together as partners, were left with 13 apartment buildings with more than 5,000 apartments, the office buildings and properties in Long Island City. They now operate in the family's longtime offices on Park Avenue South as TF Cornerstone. [ILLUSTRATION OMITTED] Henry said that although he was both "sad and nostalgic" on the day he officially left, he looked forward to "starting a new enterprise with different people." The Elghanayans' interest in real estate began at a young age. Nourallah, the Elghanayans' Iranian-born father, was a manufacturer in Iran. In the 1950s, he and his wife, Victoria, moved their family to Queens; at the time, Henry and Tom were just children. Nourallah and Victoria had continued their lives between Iran and Queens even after settling in New York. Although he was born in Iran, Tom told The Real Deal online last year that his ties to his native country have weakened. "I'm American--100 percent. Look, I relate to my father some, but he's very Persian and has strong emotional ties to the place. But I think even that has weakened because, when they had the revolution, they executed my uncle [Habib Elghanayan] when the ayatollah came to Iran. My uncle was the leader of the Jewish community in Iran," Tom said, adding that he immigrated to the United States at a young age and had no real memories of his native Iran. But their Iranian father did play a large role in their lives, helping the brothers start their first project in 1970, when they began renovating small buildings in and around Greenwich Village. Their father had given Henry and Tom $100,000 to start the business, and the brothers had put everything they had into renovating the six-story walkup. But just as they finished, the real estate market crashed. Henry and Tom only managed to sell one of the six apartments. The two brothers, along with Fred--who later joined the business--each moved into one of the apartments and used the ground-floor unit as their office. "We were very lucky to sell that one unit," Henry told The New York Times. "We needed the money." But the market eventually righted itself and the brothers each began buying other buildings in Manhattan and Brooklyn Heights. In 1977, they converted an industrial building on East 46th Street into Turtle Bay Towers, with 337 rental apartments. Ten years later, they renovated a landmark warehouse into the Archive, with 479 rental apartments at 666 Greenwich Street. Then, in the 1990s, the Elghanayans began converting office buildings into rental apartments in the financial district, and branched out to areas on the Queens waterfront and in Long Island City. And, after the attack on the World Trade Center, the Elghanayans bought a half-dozen office buildings in Washington, D.C. Over time, the brothers developed a clear division of labor: Fred, an engineer, handled construction. Tom, a graduate of Yale and Harvard Business School, did development and acquisitions. Henry, a lawyer, handled financing and, later, commercial buildings. Their youngest brother, Jeffrey, who left the partnership in 1989, is an architect. "That's part of the secret of our success," Henry said. "We didn't step on each other's toes." While the real estate market continues to be unstable, the brothers are confident that they can come out on top after the economy recovers because they are not burdened by heavy debts; they say they have a great opportunity to buy distressed assets from other developers and their lenders "at below replacement cost." |