Where are all the mother-heroines? Images of maternity in Soviet films of the 1930s.

Author:Rowley, Alison
Article Type:Critical essay
Geographic Code:4EXRU
Date:Mar 22, 2009
Words:6798
Publication:Canadian Journal of History
ISSN:0008-4107

In 1946 sociologist Nicholas Timasheff proposed that the 1930s marked an era in Soviet history that he termed the "Great Retreat." Timasheff argued that, beginning in 1934, the Soviet government backtracked from its revolutionary stance vis-a-vis women and the family because Party leaders came to see their own earlier policies as destabilizing and potentially harmful to society. He wrote that the effects of legalized abortion and easy divorce created an "unfavorable trend," one that "threatened to undermine both the labor supply and the strength of the nation at arms." (1)

Timasheff's ideas have had a long reach, having been accepted largely without criticism by several generations of scholars of Soviet women's history. (2) More recently, the term "retreat" has been questioned by David Hoffmann, who argues that the use of that word implies a return to pre-Soviet style families. (3) While he dislikes the word "retreat," he does not reject the accompanying idea that the Soviet government engaged in a pro-natalist campaign from the mid-1930s, similar to those undertaken by governments across Europe at the same time, and supported it with a large propaganda drive. Despite their assertions concerning the regime's promotion of maternity in the 1930s, none of the scholars referred to above has actually engaged in a close examination of the Soviet media. (4) The following article proposes to do just that by focusing on the depiction of mothers in Soviet films from the 1930s. Several questions will be addressed. Was there, in fact, a pro-natalist campaign in Soviet film? What types of mothers and families appeared on screen? Did the 1936 family legislation banning abortion and making divorce more difficult have any influence on the way mothers were portrayed? And why did Soviet mothers differ from their European counterparts, particularly those in Nazi Germany?

The emphasis on film in this article is a deliberate one. It is not meant to say that similar messages about maternity were not introduced in other Soviet media. They were. (5) But in terms of control over production and censorship, cinema was more closely tied to the party leadership than any other form of Soviet propaganda, with the possible exception of the central newspapers. (6) According to his daughter, Stalin used to watch films regularly in the Kremlin, usually after his evening meal and often in the company of other Soviet leaders. (7) When they were not at the Kremlin, these individuals were also able to pre-screen Soviet films in the projection rooms built into their country houses. (8) The Soviet leadership was deeply interested in every detail that appeared on screen. There is evidence that Stalin sometimes ordered certain frames or scenes removed from films, edited scripts prior to shooting, and even suggested titles for films. (9) This level of interest and supervision suggests that the mothers who graced Soviet screens in the 1930s presented the official view of Soviet motherhood and that the portrayal of their actions had the sanction of the regime's leaders.

I. The "Traditional" Mother

Cinematic depictions of what are often termed traditional stay-at-home mothers were rare in Soviet films of the 1930s. At the beginning of the decade, one such mother appeared in Nikolai Ekk's Road to Life (Putevka v zhizn', 1931), but it is debatable whether she was meant to endorse this type of behaviour for others. The film opens by contrasting the thievery and sheer physical dirtiness of a gang of orphans with the idyllic family life of Kol'ka, one of the film's eventual heroes. At the center of the idyll stands his mother. The film gives her no other name or function. (10) Indeed, her only memorable attributes are her long hair, which the camera fetishizes by drawing constant attention to it, and her apparent devotion to her family. (11) The film indicates that Kol'ka and his father thrive under her ministrations. Their living space is bright and clean. A sparkling cloth covers their table and the males are shown wearing similarly sparkling shirts. Instead of behaving like a hooligan, Kol'ka seems like the model teenager: he amuses himself with a radio set and by caring for his pet fish.

Since the mother binds the family unit together, it should come as no surprise that her sudden death (she is killed trying to stop a homeless boy stealing apples from an elderly street vendor) spells the end of this happiness. The film shows how the husband takes to drink and allows the apartment to become a dark and dirty place. The tablecloth disappears, replaced by bottles and unwashed dishes. The mother's absence is even more apparent on the night when Kol'ka's father tries to kill him; as he is being beaten, the boy cries out for his mother. The scene ends with Kol'ka fleeing to a life on the streets, the implication being that this would not have happened had his mother lived. However, Lilya Kaganovsky's analysis of the film argues that the mother's death Was necessary for the child's transformation into an ideal Soviet young man because her love "would [have] continue[d] to seduce Kol'ka into classless impassivity". (12) It is certainly true that the film suggests that Kol'ka's life will not significantly improve, or become secure again, until his mother's place is taken by the commune and its director, Comrade Sergeev.

Moreover, being a mother is not the only role presented to Soviet women in Road to Life. The inclusion of a female social worker offers a balance to the depiction of the mother since the two women receive roughly the same amount of time on the screen. The figure of the social worker can be interpreted as a type of substitute mother to the era's homeless children--in other words, to those who have been abandoned by their biological mothers. But she does not seek to replace these missing mothers entirely, for instance by adopting their children. Instead, she is involved in selecting which children will go and live in the commune, where the state will assume the place of parents and ensure that the children are brought up correctly. The depiction of the social worker reminds one of the Soviet maternity-oriented propaganda from the 1920s analyzed by Tricia Starks. Starks's research demonstrates that "[a]gitational plays and other propaganda transformed motherhood from a natural preserve of women to a skill to be acquired from health professionals." (13) Soviet health officials tried to replace traditional authority figures in the eyes of pregnant women and mothers. Nurses were shown as more knowledgeable than midwives, and doctors seemed to care more for children than biological fathers did. Soviet women were not trusted to bring up their own children. The intervention of state officials, symbolized by the practice of consultations, was actively encouraged. In Road to Life this transition is simply presented in its most extreme form, because the children who thrive in the film do so when removed from the family environment completely.

Given the importance of timing to the argument that I am making vis-a-vis the notion of the Great Retreat, it is noteworthy that this film was released a full five years before the issuing of the new family legislation that has received so much scholarly attention. Road to Life was distributed across the Soviet Union and abroad. It was named one of the best entries at the Venice Film Festival in 1932 and was celebrated as the first Soviet film to incorporate sound.

The success of Road to Life, however, should be contrasted with the fate of Lullaby, the only other Soviet film that attempted to depict motherhood in this way. Dziga Vertov's Lullaby (Kolybel'naia, 1937) glorified motherhood to the exclusion of any other role for Soviet women. Work on the film was underway as the debates on the 1936 family legislation swirled, and the finished product included a large number of images of breast-feeding women and well-fed toddlers. However, the film was seen as unacceptable by the time of its release in November 1937. It was pulled from distribution after just five days, and the film was not given a listing in the official annotated catalogue of Soviet films. (14) According to Hans Gunther, Vertov's film was rejected "because it was out of step with the spirit of the times." (15) Jeremy Hicks's recent book on Vertov fleshes out this statement by suggesting that a number of factors led to the film's shelving, from a shift in the industry away from documentaries to acted films, to the project's association with Boris Shumiatsky, the head of the film industry who was purged and eventually shot in 1938. Hicks also writes that the "absence of a review in Pravda supports the rumour that Stalin himself had indicated his displeasure at the film." (16) The results of the decision are less open to speculation: for the remainder of the 1930s Soviet women were not presented with female characters who chose to stay home and look after their families.

II. Motherhood and Work: The Marginalization of Fathers and the Demands of the State

In her article on Soviet and post-Soviet motherhood, Olga Issoupova argues that in the 1930s Soviet men saw their roles as husbands and fathers marginalized by the state. By forming a supportive alliance with Soviet women, the regime was able to take the place of men in the family unit. Fathers were excluded from childcare responsibilities and nurturing behavior as women were bombarded with images emphasizing the benefits and convenience of state-run childcare institutions. Eliminated from upbringing, fathers were only assigned financial obligations to their children through the payment of child support. This marginalization reached its apex when the "Mother Heroine" awards were created in 1944. As Issoupova notes, "The title 'hero father' was not introduced. The state gave the title and the money to the mother, and thus developed a direct relationship with her as the producer of the children, and the man was excluded from this relationship as an insignificant figure (if not as a competitor for the woman's loyalty)." (17)

Issoupova's arguments are particularly pertinent here since the cinematic depictions of Soviet working mothers throughout the 1930s support her overall conclusions. For instance, in one of the final films of the decade, Member of the Government (Chlen pravitel'stva, 1939) the heroine, termed an example for women and "a person of the Stalinist school" by one Soviet film review, does not have a stable and supportive partnership with her spouse. (18) Aleksandra is forced to rely on her own hard work, as well as the backing of the regime (personified by the local party leader), in order to support her family. The film opens by showing how Efim, Aleksandra's husband, hinders her development: he beats her for attending meetings of the women's group, he laughs when the party leader suggests that Aleksandra would make a good boss for the collective farm, and he disrupts the meetings she chairs once she does obtain the position. Jealousy over his wife's success in the public sphere leads Efim to abandon his wife and family.

Without a supportive husband, Aleksandra is forced to combine her parental and work roles. Several scenes show her balancing a baby on her knee as she does paperwork or bringing both of her children to a meeting at party headquarters. Never does the film suggest, though, that she should stop work and survive on child support payments from Efim. Nor does it say that she should remarry, rely on a new partner for material support, and have more children. Aleksandra is instead shown rejecting the advances of a male suitor by dumping a bucket of water over his head. In fact, it is her work achievements that will be foregrounded in the rest of the film's narrative, and her status as a mother will take an increasingly secondary role. This dynamic is particularly apparent in scenes that take place in Aleksandra's house. Her children's existence is usually symbolized by a toy rocking horse that appears in the background, since they themselves are rarely physically present in the hut. In the two instances when Aleksandra's youngest child is there, he sleeps through the scenes and, consequently, does not play an active role in them. What the viewer does see is a drastic transformation of the living space. When Efim returns after several years, the interior of the hut is almost unrecognizable with its new furnishings, decorative elements like curtains, and even a telephone. The implication is that the collective farm as a whole has thrived under Aleksandra's management,-and that its members have all seen their standard of living rise dramatically. But the private sphere is also no longer solely private. Aleksandra's success at work means that party officials often need to reach her at short notice (hence the telephone), and she is constantly interrupted by fellow collective farmers bringing their problems to her. Her maternal role remains secondary, for despite the new decor, there are no more toys visible than when Efim left. Finally the film ends with the heroine going to Moscow as a newly elected member of the Supreme Soviet. She is shown rehearsing a speech with Aleksei Stakhanov, the originator of the Stakhanovite movement, to increase labor productivity in the late 1930s. (19) In other words, the film concludes by celebrating the ultimate triumph of Aleksandra the model worker, not Aleksandra the ideal mother. (20)

A similar dynamic is at work in an earlier release--the 1934 film The Peasants (Krest'iane)--thereby suggesting that the family legislation had little effect on the depiction of working mothers. In this film, the heroine, Varvara Nechaeva, is a shock worker on a collective farm that raises pigs. In a truly fantastic dream sequence, her productivity singles her out and leads to national recognition: she appears on the front page of Pravda. Above her photograph the header describes Varvara as the best shock worker on her collective farm. (21) Without this fame, it is unlikely that the second part of the layout would have been possible, since it is the publicity surrounding her work achievements that brings her to the attention of Stalin. Beneath her photograph it is written "I congratulate you on the birth of a son. I. Stalin."

Once the newspaper image has scrolled upwards, the dream sequence takes a totally unexpected turn. During the day Varvara had just discovered that she is pregnant. The film incorporates this fact into her dream but completely erases Varvara's husband from the scenario. A brief animation interlude shows Varvara, and Stalin complete with mustache and greatcoat, walking down the street of a village. In a moment that recalls what Hans Gunther refers to as the "myth of the Great Family," a complete family unir is suggested, with Stalin carrying a young boy in his arms, while the child at one point stops to hug him. (22) By implication, the child is meant to represent Varvara's baby, Stalin is now his father, and his biological father has suffered total marginalization at the hands of the state. The dream does not become reality, though, because Varvara is killed towards the end of the film, before she gives birth to her child. Ironically, the murderer is her own husband who is trying to prevent the exposure of his past as a kulak. Again the regime's prioritization of work over family is expressed in the film in the way that her fellow villagers choose to remember Varvara. They name the collective farm after her and raise a plaque to that effect. Nowhere does it mention that she was going to be a mother. Her memory is meant to inspire others to work harder and not necessarily to have more children.

To return to the end of the decade, a final screen mother also owes her privileged position in Soviet society to hard work outside of the home. Like the other heroines discussed in this section, Natasha, the female lead in Komsomolsk--English title reflecting the geographical designation of Komsomolsk-on-the-Amuras opposed to Konsomolsk-na-Amure--(Komsomolsk, 1938), is a celebrated shock worker. After the new town of Komsomolsk-on-the-Amur has been built, she reconciles with her husband and retreats into a comfortable domestic life, complete with a new baby. However, as the heroine in Member of the Government, the demands of the public sphere are ever-present and can invade the sanctity of the home at any moment. The end of the film focuses on the plots and activities of a group of saboteurs. During a tea party with friends, Natasha goes to check on her crying infant, only to discover one of the saboteurs in the baby's room. He has come to ask for her assistance in tracking down the film's arch villain. Natasha does not hesitate: she returns her son to his crib, pauses long enough to telephone the secret police, and then leaves to capture the bandit. Over the next several minutes, Natasha is shown wading through water and struggling with dense foliage. She physically fights, and ultimately shoots, the saboteur. At no point does she stop to think about her child. She assumes that the friends she left in the apartment will care for him if he needs anything while she is gone, and she does not consider the possibility that he may be left motherless if she is harmed while trying to capture this enemy of the state. This section of the film's narrative is reminiscent of the end of Member of the Government in the way it suggests to Soviet women that motherhood can never be their most important duty, and that the bond between a woman and her child is not the most important one in her life. Instead, the demands of the state outweigh a woman's other responsibilities. (23)

The contrast between the messages given, to Soviet women and those presented to women elsewhere in Europe are quite dramatic. For instance, these types of public roles were not envisaged by Nazi leaders, and certainly not publicized to German women. Hitler's opinions concerning the position of women were made abundantly clear in his speech at the Nuremberg Party rally, when he stated that the birth of many children was the greatest contribution a woman could make to the nation, since ultimately a woman's supreme function was motherhood. (24) Indeed, Nazi propaganda only showed women as mothers and never in any other capacity. In Nazi Women, Cate Haste sums up the tone of this media campaign:

 Motherhood was glorified. In posters, paintings and sculptures of
 variable quality and sickliness, mothers were portrayed as the
 pivot of an idealized National Socialist family. The breastfeeding
 mother appeared on sometimes graphically deplorable posters and was
 sculpted for placing in public spaces. Painters depicted mothers
 surrounded by their families in warm, soft-toned agricultural
 settings, intended to invoke the peasant rural idyll within which
 the Nazi fantasy of ideal family life was framed. (25)

Nor was it suggested that women in Nazi Germany could combine family life with work. Instead, the government did everything it could to encourage women to leave the workforce, for instance by passing laws that offered financial incentives to do so. (26)

III. Maternity and Race

An even more glaring difference in the treatments of motherhood in Soviet and European cases concerns the issue of race. Again a comparison of Nazi Germany and the USSR is fruitful and germane, since the Nazi regime is often presented as the most pro-natalist one in Europe at that time. Almost immediately after coming to power, the Nazi party began to implement measures designed to control the fertility of German women. (27) May 1933, for instance, saw the introduction of new regulations concerning abortion. Anyone who performed an abortion on a "healthy Aryan" woman without acceptable medical reasons was now subject to a prison sentence of up to two years. Other laws concerning fertility, family life, and race followed in 1935. They forbade sexual relations between "Aryans" and Jews (or "Aryans" and other "non-racially fit" groups) and forced couples to obtain certificates proving that they were racially fit to marry. Another effort to dissuade the "unfit" from having children focused on access to medical care since Nazi maternity clinics did not treat women who were categorized as "racially inferior." Forced sterilizations were also a fact of life once compulsory sterilization was introduced in January 1934. It is estimated that about 320,000 people were forcibly sterilized between 1934 and the beginning of the war in September 1939. Michael Burleigh and Wolfgang Wippermann note that that figure constitutes 0.5 per cent of the German population. (28)

The Soviet stance on race and motherhood was expressed in Grigorii Aleksandrov's 1936 film Circus (Tsirk), which explicitly rejected and ridiculed the ideas promoted in Nazi Germany. The film opened with great fanfare; after a gala premiere in Moscow's Central Park of Culture and Rest, it then debuted in fourteen Moscow theatres. (29) In the first month of its release, four million people went to see Circus in Moscow and Leningrad alone. (30) The film was meant to publicize the Soviet stance to the widest audience possible, since foreign distribution was arranged and Circus was shown at the 1937 International Exhibition in Paris. With his famous, platinum-blonde wife Liubov' Orlova cast in the lead role, director Grigorii Aleksandrov introduced to the screen a heroine who had an inter-racial child out of wedlock. (31) When the viewer first sees Marion Dixon she is being chased by an angry mob wielding sticks. A close-up of one man shows him screaming "Beat her up!" in English. Marion only escapes by climbing aboard a train. As the camera zooms in on the back of the train, a logo is drawn to the attention of viewers. It situates the scene of the violence as the Southern United States (the car belongs to the "Southern Railway"), and the entire opening sequence of the film implies that intolerance is a fact of life in that part of the world. While the film will ultimately focus on the racial ideology of Nazi Germany, this first scene suggests that similar thinking was prevalent throughout the Western world. The scene ends with the image of a spinning globe. It is used to change the setting from the United States to the Soviet Union, to demonstrate symbolically how far the heroine must travel to find acceptance and security for her child, and to establish a clear contrast between Soviet and Western attitudes on issues of race.

By the time Marion Dixon arrives in Moscow, her career is being controlled by a German manager named Kneishits. Right from the start, this walking embodiment of Nazi values is meant to be a ridiculous, although at other times sinister, character who relies on artificial means to present a larger physique to the circus audiences; he controls Marion by means of threats. Kneishits senses immediately that Marion's attraction to the Soviet hero Martynov threatens to disrupt their relationship. As the two argue over whether to leave Moscow at the end of Marion's contract, Kneishits tells her that "They [men like Martynov] do not marry women like you," and that Martynov, as a "white" man, will despise her once he has seen her son. His opinions are even more forcefully presented at the end of the film when he disrupts the circus's new finale number, the "Flight to the Stratosphere." He enters carrying Marion's crying and frightened son, Jimmy, and begins to denounce her to the crowd. "This woman was the lover of a black man. She has a black child. A white woman with a black child," he shouts. But his words do not generate the intended shocked and horrified reaction so he continues with his diatribe. He says, "It's a racial crime. She has no right to live in a civilized society; she has no place among white people."

The Soviet crowd has a different impression. When Jimmy escapes from Kneishits's clutches, members of the audience protect him by shepherding him away from the German. Kneishits is laughed at and finally jeered out of the building. At this point, the film begins to emphasize the racial harmony that supposedly existed in the Soviet Union in the 1930s. The child continues to be handed around as members of the audience sing him a lullaby. The crowd is multi-ethnic, with representatives of various Soviet minority groups singing their snippets of the song in their native languages. Moreover, in a moment that directly contrasts with Marion's earlier treatment in the United States, an inter-racial couple is included in the sequence: a white woman is shown sitting with her arm around her black companion as he sings to Jimmy. In the end, it falls to the circus director to explain the crowd's reaction to an incredulous Marion and to voice the explicit Soviet rejection of Nazi ideas with respect to race. He states, "in this country we love all children, you can have as many as you want. Black, white, red, even blue, pink with stripes or purple with flowers. Go ahead."

Circus suggests that, instead of ostracism and violence, Marion will find acceptance and tolerance in the Soviet Union. The film also implies that she will find personal happiness in her relationship with Martynov. Despite her fears to the contrary, Marion's child does not reduce her desirability in his eyes. Instead she is presented as a worthy match for this exemplary New Soviet Man, who is beyond being influenced by racism. (32) Fittingly, the film ends by showing the lead characters marching in a May Day parade on Red Square. Again ideas of tolerance and diversity are promoted as his mother, instead of leaving Jimmy hidden and at home, brings him to the parade and thereby acknowledges her motherhood on a mass scale. The scene shows him being carried at the front of the circus's delegation. This point fits well with Karen Petrone's analysis of the racial diversity of physical culture parades in the USSR in the late 1930s. She writes, "In contrast to the focus of German gymnastics on the healthy bodies of the superior Aryan race, in physical culture parades the Soviet Union celebrated the physical strength of Europeans and Asians together. Slavic, Caucasian, and Asian men all marched bare-chested in the parade." (33)

Why were official Soviet ideas on race and maternity so different from those that swept across North America and the rest of Europe in the 1930s? The answer may lie in the realm of Soviet science, for in the late 1920s eugenics was banned in the USSR. Eugenics had had a long history in Russia. (34) Francis Galton's book Hereditary Genius was translated into Russian in 1875, and, prior to the revolution, a number of Russian intellectuals and medical practitioners followed the European literature on eugenics with interest. In the early 1920s, a Bureau of Eugenics was established as part of the Academy of Sciences, and the Russian Eugenics Society was founded under the 'auspices of the People's Commissariat of Health (Narkomzdrav). In December 1921, the USSR also joined the International Commission of Eugenics.

At the time eugenics had several broad appeals. At the popular level, it suggested that science would provide a better future--a particularly attractive notion to people who had just lived through the devastation of World War I, followed by two revolutions and a lengthy Civil War. To the new leadership of the country, eugenics, in the words of Mark Adams, "fit ideally the new emphasis on science as a way of undermining religion and improving the human condition; it entailed a scientific, materialist, biosocial concept of human beings; it sought to apply the results of genetics to benefit society; and it emphasized the human power to shape the future." (35) Finally, scientists were attracted to eugenics because the field assigned them a fundamental role in the rebuilding of society and created the possibility that their research would enable them to survive financially in a time of economic hardship. From 1920 to 1925, eugenics-inspired research thrived in the Soviet Union. Soviet scientists deviated from their Western counterparts in one respect, though: they were overwhelmingly hostile to ideas of sterilization. As Adams aptly puts it, "given the social realities, the common perception was that Russia needed not fewer births but many, many more." (36)

In 1925, however, eugenics as a discipline began to be called into question. In that year, an article by Vasilii Slepkov was published containing the first suggestion that eugenics was not compatible with Marxism since it ignored socioeconomic determinants of human behavior. Leaders of the eugenics movement, such as N. Kol'tsov in Moscow and I.A. Filipchenko in Leningrad, soon found their research institutes dismantled and themselves relieved of their university posts. In 1930 the Russian Eugenics Society and its journal were closed down. The final death-knell was sounded by the Great Soviet Encyclopedia, which, in 1931, described the ideas proposed by leading scholars in the Soviet eugenics movement as "bourgeois," "fascist," and "Menshevizing idealism." (37) This total rejection of eugenics paved the way in part for the rise of Lysenkoism in the 1930s. (38) Moreover, by 1936--when Circus was being filmed and released in the USSR--Lysenko's supporters had begun to allege that genetics was linked to the Soviet Union's ideological enemy, fascism.

IV. Conclusion

David Hoffmann writes in Stalinist Values that "by the 1930s, official soviet culture endorsed strong families, glorified motherhood, and strove to raise the birth rate." (39) These words summarize the standard interpretation of Soviet women's history in the 1930s. But Soviet films did none of these things. The Soviet families that appeared on the screen were hardly traditional or models that could be held up for emulation. Mothers were abandoned, subject to violence, and even killed. Fathers were depicted as violent destroyers of their families or marginalized individuals whose role in the care of their children was assumed by the state. The films hardly presented a pro-natalist picture to Soviet filmgoers. It is also important to note that the 1936 family legislation did not change the way mothers were depicted on screen. Instead, there was an almost decade-long continuity in the cinematic images of maternity, with the most "traditional" mother appearing in 1931, not in 1936 or after. (It is worth reiterating at this point that the only truly pro-natalist film to appear after the new decree, Vertov's Lullaby, was pulled from the screens after only five days.) Lastly, it must be emphasized that the role models suggested to Soviet women were quite different from those presented to women in other European societies, particularly in Nazi Germany. Eugenically inspired ideas concerning race and procreation were discredited in the Soviet Union, and Soviet women were not told to worry about their partner's "racial purity." The primary focus of Soviet women, it was suggested, should be on work and life outside of the home. Motherhood was presented as a secondary concern and one that should never interfere with labour productivity.

(1) Nicholas Timasheff, The Great Retreat." The Growth and Decline of Communism in Russia (New York, 1946), p. 197.

(2) See, for instance, Bernice Rosenthal, "Love on the Tractor: Women in the Russian Revolution and After," in R. Bridenthal and C. Koonz (eds.), Becoming Visible (Boston, 1977); Gail Lapidus, Women in Soviet Society (Berkeley, 1978); Robert Thurston, "The Soviet Family During the Great Terror, 1935-1941," Soviet Studies, 43 (1991), pp. 553-74; Barbara Clements, "Later Developments: Trends in Soviet Women's History, 1930 to the Present," in B. Clements, B. Engel, and C. Worobec (eds.), Russia's Women (Berkeley, 1991); and Wendy Goldman, Women, the State and Revolution (Cambridge, 1993).

(3) David L. Hoffmann, Stalinist Values (Ithaca, 2003), p. 89.

(4) Hoffmann, for instance, in his chapter "Stalinist Family Values," cites a half dozen issues of Rabotnitsa i krest'ianka, a women's magazine from the Leningrad region, and one article in the national organ for women, Rabotnitsa, from 1936 as the basis of his analysis. The only film he refers to is from 1939--Traktoristy (Tractor Drivers)--one that does not feature a heroine who is a mother. See Hoffmann, Stalinist Values, pp. 88-117.

(5) For instance, Lynne Attwood's Creating the New Soviet Woman (New York, 1999) discusses depictions of motherhood in Rabotnitsa and Krest'ianka, the two national periodicals for Soviet women; and Alison Rowley, "Such Women Could Not Have Existed Before: Visual Propaganda and Soviet Women in the 1930s," (PhD diss. Duke University, 2000) considers how maternity was presented on Soviet political posters and postage stamps as well as in national and regional periodicals for women.

(6) On Soviet newspapers in the 1930s, see Jeffrey Brooks, Thank You, Comrade Stalin!: Soviet Publie Culture from Revolution to Cold War (Princeton, 1999).

(7) Svetlana Alliluyeva (trans. P.J. McMillan), Twenty Letters to a Friend (New York, 1967), pp. 144-45.

(8) Svetlana Alliluyeva (trans. P. Chavchavadze), Only One Year (New York, 1969), p. 413.

(9) See G. Mar'iamov, Kremlevskii tsenzor: Stalin smotrit kino (Moscow, 1992), pp. 14-18, 33, and 113 for examples.

(10) Interestingly, she is seen as such a minor character that her image does not appear on the poster that accompanied the film's release. See A. Snopkov, R Snopkov, and A. Shkliaruk (eds), Russkii kinoplakat (Moscow, 2002), p. 53.

(11) The mother's long hair stands out beside the shorter bobbed cut worn by the social worker. A Russian woman's hair was an important signifier about her marital status in the Imperial period, and braiding it into the style worn by married women was an important part of the marriage ceremony itself. In the early Soviet period, wearing hair short was one way a woman could demonstrate her support for the new regime. See Mary Matossian, "The Peasant Way of Life," in W. Vucinich (ed.), The Peasant in Nineteenth-Century Russia (Stanford, 1968), pp. 15-16.

(12) Lilya Kaganovsky, "Forging Soviet Masculinity in Nikolai Ekk's The Road to Life," in H. Goscilo and A. Lanoux (eds.), Gender and National Identity in Twentieth-Century Russian Culture (DeKalb, 2000), p. 99.

(13) Tricia Starks, "A Fertile Mother Russia: Pronatalist Propaganda in Revolutionary Russia," Journal of Family History, 28 (2003), p. 420. Frances Bernstein reaches similar conclusions concerning the roles that were assigned to state officials in sexual health propaganda in the 1920s. See Bernstein's The Dictatorship of Sex: Lifestyle Advice for the Soviet Masses (DeKalb, 2007), pp. 122-28.

(14) See Sovetskie khudozhestvennye fil 'my toro II (1930-1957 gg) (Moscow, 1961).

(15) Hans Gunther, "Wise Father Stalin and His Family in Soviet Cinema," in T. Lahusen and E. Dobrenko (eds.), Socialist Realism without Shores (Durham, 1997), p. 183.

(16) Jeremy Hicks, Dziga Vertov: Defining Documentary Film (London, 2007), p. 115.

(17) Olga Issoupova, "From Duty to Pleasure? Motherhood in Soviet and Post-Soviet Russia," in S. Ashwin (ed.), Gender, State and Society in Soviet and Post-Soviet Russia (London, 2000), p. 33.

(18) Izvestiia, 9 February 1940, p. 4.

(19) On Stakhanov and Stakhanovism see Lewis Siegelbaum, Stakhanovism and the Politics of Productivity in the USSR, 1935-1941 (Cambridge, 1988); and Aleksei Stakhanov, Rasskaz o moei zhizni (Moscow: 1937).

(20) Member of the Government was one of a number of films that were restored in the 1960s and had some materials altered or removed. The version available today has had its ending changed. According to Maya Turovskaya, the original ending had Stalin appear during the speech scene. His presente would only have reinforced the message that Soviet women should define themselves through their work. See Maya Turovskaya, "Notes on Women and Film," Discourse, 17 (1995), p. 18.

(21) In a strange twist, Pravda's review of the film also refers to the heroine as a "shock worker-activist." Pravda, 19 March 1935, p. 4.

(22) Gunther, "Wise Father Stalin," p. 178.

(23) My thinking on this point has been influenced by Sarah Ashwin. She posits that Soviet officials attempted "to construct a particular set of gender relations--a triangular set of relations in which the primary relationship of individual men and women was to the state rather than to each other." Sarah Ashwin, "Introduction," in S. Ashwin (ed.), Gender, State and Society in Soviet and Post-Soviet Russia (London, 2000), pp. 1-2. Her point is valid for relationships other than between spouses as well. Certainly the promotion of the cult of Pavlik Morozov, the child celebrated for denouncing his father to the authorities, indicates that Soviet authorities thought the primary loyalty of children should be to the state.

(24) Michael Kater, Hitler Youth (Cambridge, Massachusetts, 2004), p. 83.

(25) Cate Haste, Nazi Women (London, 2001), pp. 87-88.

(26) For instance, the "June 1, 1933, Law to Reduce Unemployment, in its section 'Promotion of Marriages,' provided for marriage loans up to one thousand marks for those men whose wives gave up their jobs". See Gisela Bock, "Racism and Sexism in Nazi Germany: Motherhood, Compulsory Sterilization, and the State," in R. Bridenthal, A. Grossmann, and M. Kaplan (eds.), When Biology Becomes Destiny: Women in Weimar and Nazi Germany (New York, 1984), p. 284. Bock also notes that similar loan schemes existed in France, Italy, Spain and Sweden.

(27) For a discussion of the Nazi laws affecting German women's reproductive rights see Michael Burleigh and Wolfgang Wippermann, The Racial State: Germany 1933-1945 (Cambridge, 1991).

(28) Burleigh and Wippermann, The Racial State, p. 253.

(29) Izvestiia, 23 May 1936, p. 4.

(30) Maya Turovskaya, "Circus of 1936: Ideology and Entertainment under the Big Top," in A. Horton (ed.) Inside Soviet Film Satire (Cambridge, 1993), p. 92.

(31) Orlova, Stalin's favorite actress, had first been noticed for her role in the 1934 movie Happy Guys (Veselye rebiata). She went on to star in Stalin's favorite film, Volga-Volga, and to be highly decorated for her work in film and on stage. For details of her life, see the documentary Liubov' Orlova (Mosfilm, 1983) and Richard Stites, Russian Popular Culture (Cambridge, 1992), p. 92.

(32) On Martynov's status as paradigmatic "New Soviet Man" see John Haynes, New Soviet Man: Gender and Masculinity in Stalinist Soviet Cinema (Manchester, 2003).

(33) Karen Petrone, Life Has Become More Joyous, Comrades: Celebrations in the Time of Stalin (Bloomington, 2000), p. 34.

(34) On the history of eugenics in Russia and the Soviet Union see Mark B. Adams, "Eugenics in Russia, 1900-1940," in M.B. Adams (ed.), The Wellborn Science: Eugenics in Germany, France, Brazil, and Russia (New York, 1990); Loren R. Graham, "Science and Values: The Eugenics Movement in Germany and Russia in the 1920s," American Historical Review, 122 (1977), pp. 1133-64; Loren R. Graham, Between Science and Values (New York, 1981); and Paul Weindling, "German-Soviet Co-operation in Science: The Case of the Laboratory for Racial Research, 1931-1938," Nuncius, 1 (1986), pp. 103-9.

(35) Adams, "Eugenics in Russia, 1900-1940," p. 162.

(36) Ibid, p. 176.

(37) Cited in Adams, "Eugenies in Russia, 1900-1940)," p. 185.

(38) On Lysenko see David Joravsky, The Lysenko Affair (Chicago, 1986); Zhores Medvedev, Rise and Fall of T.D. Lysenko (New York, 1969); Nils Roll-Hansen, The Lysenko Effect: The Politics of Science (Amherst, New York, 2004); and Valery Soyfer et al., Lysenko and the Tragedy of Soviet Science (New Brunswick, New Jersey, 1994).

(39) Hoffmann, Stalinist Values, p. 88.

Alison Rowley is an associate professor in the Department of History at Concordia University. She is presently writing a book on Russian popular culture via the lens of the picture postcard.

COPYRIGHT 2009 University of Toronto Press
Copyright 2023 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.