Zane Gard, MD, and Erma Brown: sauna detoxification.
Gard and Brown employed a sauna protocol that was trademarked as the BioToxic Reduction (BTR) program. This protocol largely followed the "Purification Rundown" program established by L. Ron Hubbard's Scientology organization. Both protocols call for intensive sauna therapy preceded by vigorous exercise. They also call for increasing doses of oral niacin, which Hubbard believed to be critical for elimination of drugs and radiation during the sauna process. Individuals are required to ingest large quantities of water, B vitamins and minerals, plant oils, and calcium-magnesium liquid. A typical program calls for exercising 15 to 30 minutes followed by 30 to 60 minutes of sauna, then another 15 to 30 minutes of exercise followed by another 30 to 60 minutes of sauna, and a third period of exercise followed by a final 30 to 60 minutes of sauna. Individuals are monitored, and typically changes in exercise, sauna, and vitamin, niacin, and oil intake are implemented. Gard and Brown note that while physical symptoms typically reduce during the course of sauna detoxification, it still is not unusual for some individuals to experience symptom aggravation in the course of treatment. However, Gard and Brown observed significant reduction in physical symptomatology following the completion of the protocol for most individuals.
Gard and Brown were less interested in removing drugs and radiation and more concerned with detoxification of accumulated chemicals such as styrene, xylene, toluene, ethylbenzene, dichlorobenzene, chloroform, tetrachloroethylene, and trichloroethane. A literature review documents the progressive bioaccumulation of pesticides, plasticizers, preservatives, and other organic/inorganic chemicals in the water supply, air, and soil. Toxicology studies demonstrate a similar pattern of bioaccumulation in plants, single-cell organisms, and animals and consequently in humans. Gard and Brown wanted to do before-and-after comparisons of chemical content in individuals doing sauna detoxification therapy. Case reports were compelling, but critics would argue that such discussion remains anecdotal. Gard and Brown arranged for blood levels to be assayed for numerous toxicants prior to starting and upon completion of the sauna detox. Their data are summarized in a figure in part 3 of their review, as shown in Graph 5 (p. 8). The figure revealed that there were significant reductions of toxin levels in pre- and posttreatment levels. The average reduction of toluene, ethylbenzene, and xylene exceeded 90%, was nearly 90% for 1,1,1-trichloroethene, and exceeded 69% for DDE.
Zane and Card's data demonstrate compellingly that their sauna and detoxification program acts through chemical detoxification. It is not clear whether sauna alone would also demonstrate such an effective toxin elimination; their protocol required high doses of niacin, vitamin, mineral, and oil supplementation as well as vigorous exercise prior to sauna. However, given the success of their protocol, clinicians have followed their model in detoxification programs. In April 2006, Cecchini, Root, Rachunow, and Gelb reported the outcome of their treatment approach for workers who were exposed to toxicants following the September 11 World Trade Center destruction. (4) Among the more than 450 individuals who underwent sauna detoxification, a majority demonstrated improvement in quality of life, reduction in symptom severity, reduction in use of medications, improvement in balance and reaction time, and reduction in elevated TSH levels.
Recent technology has enabled sauna treatment to be possible with nontraditional sauna facilities. The least expensive and most portable devices employ far infrared heat. Infrared heat provided at 5 to 15 microns enables a safe form of sauna heating that can be tolerated comparably to traditional sauna treatment. Typically, infrared sauna programs do not require as much heat as traditional saunas; infrared sauna sessions are set at 120 to 130 [degrees]F compared with 150 to 180 [degrees]F in traditional saunas. The infrared saunas allow for a sauna/detoxification protocol to be administered in the office or at home.
Martin Pall, PhD, and the NO/ON00--Cycle
Martin Pall, PhD, has written extensively over the past decade about the role that nitric oxide (NO) and peroxynitrite (ON00--) play in chronic medical conditions including multiple chemical sensitivity, fibromyalgia, chronic fatigue, and myalgic encephalomyelitis. Pall thinks that the fundamental disorder created by the NO/ON00--cycle may also play a role in neurodegenerative, inflammatory, and autoimmune disease. In the Feb./March 2010 Townsend Letter, he outlined 10 strategies that may be employed in disrupting the "vicious" mechanism of the NO/ON00--cycle, most of which require nothing more than nutritional supplementation administered orally, intramuscularly, or intravenously. (5) The lynchpin in the NO/ON00--cycle is tetrahydrobiopterin (BH4). BH4 decreases dramatically when the NO/ON00--cycle is in disarray: elevated peroxynitrite and depleted tetrahydrobiopterin form the "central couplet" of the deranged cycle. To the degree that BH4 decreases and ON00--increases, there is greater oxidative stress, mitochondrial dysfunction, and inflammatory response. Pall demonstrates that a deranged cycle increases NF-kappaB leading to an increased production of inflammatory cytokines, including TNF-alpha. IV buffered ascorbate functions as a peroxynitrite scavenger, enables reduction of BH3 to BH4, and increases the synthesis of BH4. 5-methyltetrahydrofolate (5-MTHF) also acts as a potent peroxynitrite scavenger indirectly increasing BH4 levels. Perhaps the most intriguing approach to normalizing the NO/ON00--cycle is the use of the sauna.
In this issue Pall; Tapan Audhya, PhD; and John Green, MD, present intriguing data demonstrating the effect of sauna on raising BH4 and improving the NO/ ON00--cycle dysfunctioning.6 As compared with the rationale espoused by Gard and Ware, sauna treatment is shown to be effective not by chemical detoxification but by increasing BH4 synthesis and by stabilizing the NO/ ON00--cycle. Pall et al. show that in the chronic fatigue/chronic Lyme disease patient, biopterin (BH4) levels are low compared with normal controls. Even more remarkable, the peroxynitrite levels (ON00--) in chronic fatigue patients average more than five times higher than controls (as measured in the peroxynitrite marker 3-nitrotyrosine). Sauna treatment significantly increased BH4 levels and decreased the ON00--marker 3-nitrotyrosine. A related marker, neopterin, was also dramatically reduced. Pall et al.'s work offers an important scientific rationale for sauna therapy in the treatment of chronic disease that deserves further medical investigation.
(1.) Card ZR, Brown EJ. Literature review & comparison studies of sauna/hyperthermia in detoxification. Part I. Townsend Lett.1992;June:470-478.
(2.) Gard ZR, Brown EJ. Literature review & comparison studies of sauna/hyperthermia in detoxification. Part II. Townsend Lett. 1992;July:650-660.
(3.) Gard, ZR, Brown EJ. Literature review & comparison studies of sauna/hyperthermia in detoxification. Part III. Townsend Lett. 1992;Aug/Sept. Available at http://www.townsendletter.com/Nov2008/litreview1108.htm.
(4.) Cecchini, MA, Root, DE, Rachunow, JR, Gelb, PM. Chemical exposures at the World Trade Center: Use of the Hubbard sauna detoxification regimen to improve the health status of New York City rescue workers exposed to toxicants. Townsend Lett. 2006;Apri1:58-65.
(5.) Pall ML. How can we cure NO/ON00--cycle diseases? Approaches to curing chronic fatigue syndrome/myalgic encephalomyelitis, fibromyalgia, multiple chemical sensitivity, Gulf War syndrome and possibly many others. Townsend Lett 2010;Feb/March:75-84.
(6.) See p. 60.
Jonathan Collin, MD
Graph 5 Average Decrease in Blood Toxin Levels through BTR (from Townsend Letter October 1992. Issue #111) Average Blood Toxin Level for Patients Studied (in p.p.b.) Pro-BTfl Post-BTR Toluene 19.3 0.34 Ethylbenze 14.7 0.1 Xylene 72.9 0.94 1,1,1 Trichloro-ethane 7.7 0.92 D.D.E 5.7 1.8 Average reduction 93.7% 99.0% 90.8% 88.5% 69.8% # of patients studied 10 6 10 5 6 Note: Table made from bar graph.
|Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback|
|Title Annotation:||From the Publisher|
|Date:||Nov 1, 2013|
|Previous Article:||A sauna a day keeps the doctor away.|
|Next Article:||Clamping down on nutritional information: in Europe, you'd better watch what you say about supplements.|