Within-tree and tree-age variation of selected anatomical properties of the wood of Ugandan-grown Eucalyptus grandis.
The challenges of utilizing Eucalyptus grandis thinnings prompted a study into its anatomical properties with the aim of identifying its potential based on the within-tree axial and tree-age variation. Fiber length, fiber diameter, vessel length, vessel diameter, vessel average, ray height, and ray frequency at 3, 6, 9, and 12 years were studied. Axial sample portions at 25, 50, and 75 percent of tree height were collected from western Uganda and prepared for maceration, microtomy, and microscopy. Analysis of variance and Tukey's test were used to obtain axial and tree-age variation. Fiber length (819 to 1,077 [micro]m) decreased axially in higher tree ages of 6, 9, and 12 years and increased with tree age. Fiber diameter (10 to 13.4 [micro]m) varied inconsistently axially and decreased with tree age. Vessel length had no consistent axial pattern but decreased with tree age (338 to 548 [micro]m). Vessel diameter showed higher values at 75 percent and increased with tree age (93 to 138 [micro]m). Vessel average did not vary axially but decreased with tree age (8 to 11 vessels per [mm.sup.2]). Ray height did not vary axially but increased with tree age (107 to 278 [micro]m). Ray frequency decreased with tree age (8 to 10 rays per [mm.sup.2]). E. grandis trees at the ages of 3, 6, 9, and 12 years have anatomical properties suitable for production of strong pulps although with a modest proportion of fines. Comparative research on cloned E. grandis varieties and their implied industrial potential would be appropriate to improve utilization of this fast-growing tree species.
Studies that improve the availability of knowledge on the anatomy of wood are important for sustainable management of forests and their utilization (Naji et al. 2011). The desired properties of wood material used in wood product production industries, such as the pulping industry, depend greatly on the anatomical properties of wood (Zbonak et al. 2007). The fast-growing economy of Uganda, estimated at 7.2 percent per annum (Uganda Bureau of Statistics 2014), has fostered a construction boom that has increased the demand for wood and its related products. In the struggle to satisfy the high demand for wood products, the wood supply fraction of the market has increased the preference for faster-growing tree species, such as Eucalyptus grandis W. Hill ex Maiden 1862, over traditional and indigenous tree species that have longer rotations. E. grandis is the most traded and one of the most grown multipurpose wood species in Uganda, dominating over 43 percent of the market share (World Wide Fund 2012). Given the good growth results of E. grandis in Uganda (Saw Log Production Grant Scheme [SPGS] 2010), it is important to study its properties, specifically the anatomical properties at the different ages of tree growth, in order to support its sustainable production and efficient utilization. Most important to note is that the utilization of E. grandis in Uganda is limited to timber, poles, and fuelwood, yet there could be potential to venture into other products, such as wood pulp, if more knowledge about the characterization of its wood quality is made available. This dilemma has skewed the wood products market in Uganda toward a huge demand for trees between the ages of 2 and 14 years, mainly as poles and timber, although knowledge on their general wood quality and specific anatomical properties is limited. Moreover, the thinnings from E. grandis plantations are not optimally utilized because their value added is limited; therefore, tree farmers do not get optimal value for the wood thinnings (SPGS 2010), probably owing to limited knowledge of the quality of wood of the thinnings at the specific thinning ages. In-depth research to provide more knowledge on the specific anatomical properties at such juvenile wood tree ages of E. grandis could be a basis for improved, optimal, and diversified utilization of the tree species. Given that Uganda does not have any wood pulp industries, obtaining such knowledge on the wood quality of trees at the ages of 3 to 12 years would support the development of the wood pulp industry so as to diversify the utilization of E. grandis thinnings.
E. grandis is a hardwood tree species with a diverse range of anatomical features that can be characterized as vessel frequency, solitary vessel percentage, vessel diameter, vessel member length, fiber length and diameter, libriform fiber length, ray frequency, and ray height (Chang-ming and Xin-ying 1994). This study specifically characterized the fiber length and diameter, vessel length and diameter, ray height, vessel average, and ray frequency. For clarity in this article, we use the term "vessel length" to mean the length of a single vessel element. In order to guide rotation-specific utilization, the variation of these anatomical features with tree age was studied as well at the ages of 3, 6, 9, and 12 years. This choice of tree ages was based on the real demand for trees between the ages of 2 and 14 years and the inefficient and suboptimal utilization of trees in that age range and because this is the only stock available to satisfy the high demand for wood in Uganda (SPGS 2010).
Malan (1990) emphasized the existence and importance of the variations of the anatomical properties of E. grandis within species and site of growth and with age of the tree. The fact that different species show different relationships between anatomical features at different tree ages justifies the importance of knowing the specific anatomical features at a specified tree age in order to guide utilization (Zhu et al. 2008). In some species of the Eucalyptus, there exists known relationships. For example, Pisuttipiched (2004) noted that there was a direct relationship between fiber dimensions and tree age of E. camaldulensis up to a particular age limit beyond which there are no changes. Several other authors have researched and observed radial patterns of variation in more genera and clones of eucalyptus. These include Ramirez et al. (2008) on E. globulus and Quilho et al. (2000) on clones of E. grandis X E. urophylla. Much as Malan (1990) described the variation of the anatomy of E. grandis grown in South Africa, his emphasis detailed the correlation and prediction among anatomical features, especially in the radial positions. There are limited studies and hence limited literature on the axial variation of anatomical properties of E. grandis both within a tree and among trees of different ages. It is thus important to identify and document the anatomical features and biometry at the different ages of growth and their within-tree axial variations of the wood of E. grandis.
Studying the anatomy of E. grandis grown in Uganda is important because there are several afforestation programs in the country that have suffered challenges related to utilization, probably because some of its properties are not well documented. Specifically, the anatomical properties of E. grandis and their variations with age are not known. Further, the implications of the specific anatomical properties at the specific ages of tree growth are not documented to aid efficient utilization of Ugandan-grown E. grandis. For example, knowing the fiber length of a tree at a certain age will guide the design of processing technology, such as saw kerf size, that efficiently processes the wood with those specific properties and nature of fibers at that tree age. On the other hand, the availability of information on a property such as fiber length could support the establishment of wood pulp industries, especially if the study finds it desirable for pulp and paper production. In practice, the available thinnings are not effectively and efficiently utilized owing to the similar challenges of unknown properties that would aid their utilization, as noted by Harrison and Windhorst (2010). Studies that provide information on the properties of wood at different tree ages will guide the choice of processing technology and the avenue of utilization and provide a basis for structural designs, as suggested by Zziwa et al. (2009).
As part solution to the utilization challenges of E. grandis wood in Uganda, a study was conducted with the general objective of identifying the anatomical properties of E. grandis grown in Uganda and their within-tree axial and tree-age variations. Specifically, the study was conducted to (1) assess the within-tree axial variations of fiber length, fiber diameter, vessel length, vessel diameter, vessel frequency, ray height, and ray frequency at ages 3, 6, 9, and 12 years; (2) assess the variation of the selected properties of E. grandis at ages of 3, 6, 9, and 12 years; and (3) identify the potential uses of E. grandis at ages 3, 6, 9, and 12 years based on the anatomical properties obtained. Obtaining such knowledge of the anatomical properties of E. grandis, such as the fiber length of trees at different ages for Ugandan-grown trees, could be used to accurately estimate the optimal harvesting age for specific products, in turn supporting the appropriate choice of processing technology. In addition, such information could further aid the establishment of wood processing factories that target wood at the different times of the thinning regimes rather than waiting on the perceived maturity of the trees.
The study was carried out on E. grandis plantations in Kabarole district in western Uganda. The region is known not only for excellent yield of E. grandis but also for the availability of stands at different tree ages that were a prerequisite for this study. Such prevalence of stands with trees at the different ages of growth was the basis for the choice of the study area. Kabarole district lies on the slopes and ranges of Mountain Rwenzori, bordered by the districts of Kasese in the south, Kamwenge in the southeast, Kyenjojo in the east, and Bundibugyo in the north and west. Kabarole lies between 00[degrees]15"N and 10[degrees]00"N and between 300[degrees]00"E and 310[degrees]15"E. It lies at an altitude of 1,300 to 1,800 m above sea level. The climatic conditions of the area are generally wet with temperatures ranging from 20[degrees]C to 30[degrees]C and a bimodal rainfall pattern ranging from 1,200 to 1,500 mm per annum. Geologically, the area has black loams (volcanic), while a few places have red sandy clay loams occasionally aligned by soft laterites (Rucker 2005).
A locality with all the desired tree age stands was identified at Kaswa village in Busoro subcounty, Kabarole district of western Uganda. Three trees of good bole were identified from each tree-age stand in a localized site of the plantation. The heights and diameters at 1.3 m were taken and recorded for further processing and specimen preparation. Three circular discs 15 cm in height were obtained from each tree at the 25, 50, and 75 percent levels of tree height for specimen preparation.
Each disc was quarter sawn to obtain a scantling with a cross-section surface 0.04 m long and 0.02 m wide from each quarter. This gave a total of four scantlings from each disc that were further cut into 0.02-[m.sup.2] cubes and prepared for maceration and microtomy.
Maceration and microtomy
Macerated samples were obtained by further sectioning to obtain smaller samples of approximately 0.004 by 0.004 by 0.01 m manually using a hacksaw from the 0.02-[m.sup.2] scantling for maceration. These were immersed in a solution that contained 10 percent 0.3 M hydrogen peroxide, 50 percent glacial acetic acid, and 40 percent water. The suspended wood material was left for 3 days with constant monitoring, shaken, and stirred to acquire a milky suspension with visible tissue strings. The solutions were rinsed with distilled water and placed on slides for microscopy.
Staining was done using a solution of Sudan IV and propylene to increase color contrast for better identification during microscopy. Microtomy samples were prepared by boiling the 0.02-[m.sup.2] cubes in glycerin for 3 hours to soften and were sectioned in the radial, tangential, and axial dimensions using a sliding microtome. The sections were mounted and stained with Safranin to enhance microscopy assessment.
Microscopy and data recording
Using a BA 212 biological light microscope, calibration was done using the standard eyepiece calibrator to obtain a view-field dimension of 0.12 [m.sup.2] that was used to measure the features observed from the slides of the macerated samples. Using slides with macerated material, length and diameter dimensions of 10 randomly viewed vessels and fibers were taken at a magnification of X10. The diameters of fibers and vessels were measured at the midportion of their length. Each measurement was repeated three times and averaged to improve the accuracy of the record. Using slides with wood sections, ray height was measured at a magnification of X10. All vessels and rays viewed in each section were counted and expressed as a ratio of the view-field calibration of 0.12 [m.sup.2] to obtain vessel frequency and ray frequency per unit area.
The measurements from the maceration observations were recorded and analyzed using STATA version 12 and MINITAB version 14 computer software packages to obtain mean estimates of fiber length, fiber diameter, vessel length, vessel diameter, vessel frequency, ray height, and ray frequency within and among trees at the ages of 3, 6, 9, and 12 years. Analysis of variance was done, and the critical difference among each of the means was obtained using Tukey's test to separate the means at the different tree ages and within the tree height levels. Analysis and iterative comparison of data from previous authors was done to obtain the potential uses of the wood of E. grandis at the different tree ages based on the properties obtained.
Within-tree variation of anatomical properties of E. grandis
Fiber length and diameter.--Within-tree fiber length of E. grandis varies from 819 to 1,077 [micro]m and generally decreases from 25 to 75 percent of tree height level (Table 1). This pattern is significant among the older trees at 6, 9, and 12 years. However, this pattern is not significant among the 3-year-old trees. Generally, longer fibers are identified at 25 percent of tree height than at 75 percent of tree height. Fiber diameter did not show any consistent observable patterns, especially in the 9-year-old trees (Fig. 1). Nevertheless, there were more observations of a pattern in the 6- and 12-year-old trees, showing a higher fiber diameter at the 25 percent portion, the lowest at the 50 percent portion, and then higher at the 75 percent portion.
Vessel length, diameter, and average.--The axial variation of the vessel length of E. grandis did not show a consistent pattern, with values ranging from 374 to 548 [micro]m (Table 1). However, the absolute values of the vessel length portray lower values at the 25 percent portion, highest values at the 50 percent tree level, and lower values at 75 percent of tree height. Uniquely, the vessel length of the 9year-old trees did not show statistical significance depicting uniform lengths of vessels at all the tree height levels. On the other hand, the 3-year-old trees portrayed the most vivid and clear variation among the three height levels compared with the other age groups. The diameter of vessels did not show a conspicuous pattern, but there is a general observation that the 75 percent portion of the tree had vessels with larger diameter estimates within 93 to 138 [micro]m (Table 1). Consequently, for nearly all tree ages, the vessel diameter at 50 percent tree level is not significantly different from that at 75 percent of the tree height, leaving the 25 percent portion of the trees with more significantly different estimates of vessel diameter. However, this does not apply to the 9-year-old trees, which did not show any variation in vessel diameter. The within-tree axial variation in vessel average was not significant for all tree ages. The absolute number of vessels per unit area was higher at 75 percent of the tree height than that at 25 percent of the tree height, within the range of 11 to 18 vessels per [mm.sup.2] (Table 1).
Ray height and frequency.--Ray height was generally inconsistent in all age groups, with estimates in the range of 107 to 278 [micro]m (Table 1). However, the 3- and 12-year-old trees showed distinct and clear variation within the tree levels compared with those in the 6- and 9-year-old trees. Moreover, the 9-year-old trees did not show any variation of ray height from 25 to 75 percent of tree height. Considering that three of the four age groups showed absolute figures that depict an increase in ray height at 75 percent of the tree, a generalized weak pattern can be deduced that ray height increases from 25 to 75 percent of tree height. The number of rays per square millimeter was also similar without any significant difference in all the tree height levels of all the age groups, with a range of 8 to 10 rays per [mm.sup.2] (Table 1).
Variation of anatomical properties of E. grandis with tree age
Fiber length and diameter.--The fiber length of E. grandis varies significantly with a progressive increase with tree age. However, Tukey's separation of means indicates that the 9- and 12-year-old fiber lengths are similar (Table 2). The fiber diameter follows a similar pattern, where there is a significant difference in the wood of trees at 3 and 6 years, while those of 9 and 12 years are not significantly different, with a general increase from 3 to 12 years (Fig. 2). Most important to note is the huge range of the absolute values for the fiber diameter of the 12-year-old trees compared with the other tree ages, which showed hardly any observed dispersion (Fig. 2).
Vessel length, diameter, and average.--The vessel length of E. grandis varies significantly among all tree ages. There is also a notable drop in vessel length after 9 years. Nevertheless, there is a general rise in vessel length with tree age. Vessel diameter is observed to have a sharp rise from the 3-year-old trees to the 6-year-old trees. The 6-yearold tree stand was observed to have the highest vessel diameter with a gentle drop toward the 9- and 12-year-old trees. There is a significant reduction in the number of vessels with increasing tree age (Table 2), with the highest estimate of 16 vessels per [mm.sup.2] at 3 years to the lowest of 11 vessels per [mm.sup.2] at 12 years.
Ray height and frequency.--The height of the rays increased significantly with tree age in an estimated range of 242 to 970 [micro]m. Notable, too, is the sharp significant rise of ray heights from the 3-year-old trees to the 6-year-old trees (Fig. 2). The frequency of rays takes on a gradual reducing trend with nonsignificant estimates ranging from 9 to 10 rays per [mm.sup.2].
Potential uses of Ugandan-grown E. grandis based on their anatomical properties
A comparison of the Ugandan-grown anatomical wood properties with values of industrial fiber estimates from other studies in the industry was done so as to describe the potential of Ugandan-grown E. grandis wood (Table 3). Following the remarks and comments (Table 3) on each comparison of anatomical properties of this study with the desired industrial estimates, it was observed that E. grandis grown in Uganda has generally good-quality wood at the four tree ages.
Within-tree variation of anatomical properties of E. grandis
Fiber length and diameter.--For all the tree ages studied, the fiber length of E. grandis is higher at 25 percent of tree height and lower at 75 percent. This trend of variation in fiber length is in agreement with the findings of Quilho et al. (2006). This variation was more significant in the 9- and 12year-old trees. The fiber length of the 3-year-old trees shows similarity at 25 and 50 percent of tree height, and it decreases at 75 percent of tree height. Considering that the estimates of fiber length in all axial positions of all the trees at all the ages are above the critical length of 250 [micro]m, as noted by Pirralho et al. (2014), they are all desirable for pulping and papermaking.
Although there is no dominant and conspicuous pattern in axial variation of fiber diameter, there is a general increase from 25 to 75 percent of the tree, an observation that is in agreement with the earlier study of Malan (1991). The diameter of fibers of E. grandis varies more from 25 to 75 percent of the tree in the 6- and 12-year-old stands. This increment could be explained by the increase in proportion of juvenile wood in the sections that are above 75 percent of tree height, which often have larger lumens that in effect provide wider diameters of the fibers. The trend of increasing fiber diameter is in agreement with the findings of Taylor (1973) and Bhat et al. (1990). Subsequently, this could probably imply that the wood in the crown parts of E. grandis will undergo more machining and seasoning defects, such as wash-boarding, warping, and collapse.
Vessel length, diameter, and average.--The most common pattern of variation of vessel length is the increase from the 25 percent portion of the tree to the 50 percent portion and a slight fall toward the 75 percent portion. Greater vessel length at the upper parts of the tree is in line with the findings of Ohshima et al. (2005). This might imply that there would be more porosity and have implications on dimension stability during processing. The increased porosity could be a result of more surface area provided by the greater lengths and thus the presence of more pits. The diameter of vessels does not show a consistent pattern from 25 to 75 percent of tree height, similar to the findings of Rao et al. (2002) on studies of E. tereticornis. For all age-groups, the average number of vessels per unit area did not vary from 25 to 75 percent of tree height. This non-significance was also observed by Naji et al. (2011), although it was in contrast to earlier observations of Leitch (2001). This consistency for vessel average within the tree suggests that E. grandis has an even distribution of vessels from the bottom to the top of the tree. Generally, the within-tree axial variations of vessel length, diameter, and average number of vessels per unit area of E. grandis suggest that the wood at 75 percent of tree height is more porous owing to the larger sizes of the vessels and their frequency and hence having implications on pressure treatment, dimension stability, and seasoning defects, such as splitting. Such a condition calls for the provision of the deserved care and choice of processing technology.
Ray height and frequency.--The ray height of E. grandis is observed to have no significant variation and no consistent pattern along the height of the tree. This limited variation in axial ray height was also observed by Gryc et al. (2008) in a study of similar hardwood species. In addition, the variation in the frequency of rays at all levels of tree height was not significant. The limited variation of ray biometry was also observed by Quilho et al. (2000). Such uniformity of ray properties in Ugandan-grown E. grandis would imply that the utilization properties of the wood that are based on characteristics of rays, such as shear strength, cleavage resistance strength, and the volume of pulp-content fines, are likely to be consistent within and among trees of different ages.
Variation of anatomical properties with age
Fiber length and diameter.--The fiber length of E. grandis increases with tree age significantly for the 3- and 6year-old tree stands. However, both the 9- and the 12-yearold stands have similar fiber length. The general increase in fiber length with tree age of E. grandis is in agreement with the earlier findings of Bhat et al. (1987). The range of 780 to 970 [micro]m obtained for fiber lengths across all ages suggests that the fibers of all tree ages are reliable and conducive for pulp production. Moreover, the increment of fiber length with tree age is an indication of increased pulp properties, namely, pulp burst strength, folding endurance, tearing strength, and tensile strength (Pirralho et al. 2014). Much as Foelkel (2009) gives optimal fiber length for pulp production to be at the age of 7 to 10 years, Ugandan-grown E. grandis obtains the required fiber length at 3 years and hence is conducive for pulp production. Subsequently, the fiber length of E. grandis at 3 years is desirable for paper production because it falls within the desired range as reported by other authors (Oluwafemi and Sotannde 2007). This is characteristic of fast-growing tropical trees, with the very high mean annual increment benefiting from the relatively high annual rainfall estimates that probably support the rapid development of long fibers. The fiber diameter of the 12-year-old trees has a range that conspicuously differs from the other tree ages. This could probably be attributed to the uniformity of the fibers at a particular tree age that was observed during the experimentation process.
Fiber diameter generally decreased with tree age and is observed to have statistically similar values for trees that are 9 and 12 years of age. Decreasing fiber diameter with tree age was also observed by Rao et al. (2002) in other Eucalyptus species. The higher values of fiber diameter at younger tree ages are a reflection of juvenile tree cells that are characterized by larger cell vacuoles that demonstrate higher fiber diameters. On the other hand, following the increasing fiber length with tree age, from laboratory observation, the longer fibers tended to be visually slimmer, hence the smaller diameter with greater tree ages. Moreover, the phenomenon of the Poisson ratio could explain this occurrence; that is, when geometrical bodies are elongated in the longitudinal dimension, they tend to be constrained in the radial planes, resulting in the reduction of fiber diameter with increasing fiber length and tree age. In effect, when the cells elongate, they often get smaller in diameter in the process of formation.
Vessel length, diameter, and average.--The vessel length and diameter of E. grandis increased with tree age from 3 to 6 to 9 years and then decreased in the 12-year-old trees, and these variations are statistically significant. This occurrence is similar to the findings of Kurjatko et al. (2006) for related hardwood tree species. The increase in vessel length could be attributed to the increased physiological demands of larger-crowned trees at the older tree ages, as highlighted by Mencuccini et al. (2005). The increase in vessel length with tree age could imply increased permeability as a parameter for pressure impregnation. However, the argument of Foelkel (2009) puts E. grandis at a disadvantage in pulping because it has higher values for vessel length, vessel diameter, and frequency that cause the presence of the undesirable fines. The vessel average of E. grandis generally decreased with tree age. This is probably attributed to a reduction in growth rates that is expected as the tree grows older. Following the anatomical discourse that relates wood permeability to impregnation as being determined by vessel frequency, there is a possibility that the wood of E. grandis at the age of 12 years will offer more resistance to impregnation than at younger ages. The observation that vessel frequency decreases with tree age is a positive attribute in pulp production because pulp fines are decreased. Pulp fines are known to decrease the grade of pulps. Therefore, Ugandan-grown E. grandis wood could have pulps with lower fines from older trees (9 and 12 yr old).
Ray height and frequency.--The general trend of the increasing height of rays with age of E. grandis agrees with the findings of Saravanan et al. (2013) and Toong et al. (2014) for related commercial timbers. Further, such trends of ray characteristics could imply an increase of fuzzy grain owing to lower structural stiffness on machining along the grain for the older trees as a result of larger areas provided for by the lumens of opened rays when cleaved open by machines. The decreased number of rays as the tree grows older could be explained by the decreased physiological demands of trees at older tree ages and the presence of fewer portions of juvenile wood. Older trees have lower growth rates and hence a reduced need for rays that transport nutrients in the radial direction, as opposed to higher juvenile wood proportions with higher physiological demands at younger tree ages that would demand the presence of larger rays. Subsequently, such lower values of ray frequency give less movement during processing and seasoning, especially in the axial dimension of wood among the older trees.
Potential uses of Ugandan-grown E. grandis based on tree age and anatomical properties
E. grandis wood grown in Uganda showed properties that give an indication of the potential of producing good-grade pulps. With specific reference to fiber length, as a predictor of quality pulps, E. grandis grown in Uganda was found to have comparable lengths as noted earlier by Foelkel (2009) and later by Pirralho et al. (2014). Noticeable is the availability of desired lengths of fibers, even at 3 years of tree age for plantations that have been subjected to fertilizer application and minimal tending. Such fiber lengths at 3 years of tree age are more common in clonal varieties of Eucalyptus than in the pure stands. This could imply that with more focused tending and silviculture, the quality of fibers and eventually pulps would be appropriate for paper production.
Conclusions and Recommendations
Within-tree axial variation showed that the fiber length and diameter of E. grandis vary significantly. Whereas fiber length decreases with tree height, fiber diameter does not show a consistent pattern. Vessel length and diameter and ray height have inconsistent patterns, with significant variations from 25 to 75 percent of tree height, with the exception of the 9-year-old trees, which do not show significant variation. Vessel average and ray frequency equally did not show significant variation with tree height.
The variation of E. grandis properties with tree age showed that fiber length increases with tree age in the range of 780 to 970 [micro]m, while fiber diameter decreases with tree age in the range of 12 to 11 [micro]m. Both vessel length and vessel diameter increase with tree age in the ranges of 387 to 532 [micro]m and 97 to 132 [micro]m, respectively, while vessel average decreases with tree age in the range of 16 to 11 vessels per [mm.sup.2]. Ray height increases with tree age in the range of 242 to 970 [micro]m, while ray frequency decreases with tree age in the range of 9 to 10 rays per [mm.sup.2].
The fiber length and fiber diameter of E. grandis at the ages of 3, 6, 9, and 12 years grown in Uganda have the potential for production of paper pulps with high tensile and tear strength, formation, and burst characteristics. Based on the observed vessel and ray characteristics and variations, the 6-year-old tree rotation would best suit moderate pulp properties with lower fines and a higher quality per unit of pulp because most vessel characteristics are on the high side compared with industrial estimates for related tree species. Generally, based on wood anatomical properties, the wood of Ugandan-grown E. grandis is capable of producing good-strength pulps but with moderate volumes of fines.
Much as the development of hybrid clonal Eucalyptus species plantations in Uganda is still low in terms of acreage, the potential is high. Therefore, there is a need to conduct similar anatomical studies on the properties of E. grandis clonal varieties at different ages of tree growth. This will probably aid future optimal utilization of the newly introduced Eucalyptus clones in Uganda's private-sector tree fanning. Further, economic evaluation of harvesting time and rotation ages of E. grandis needs to be studied to support the findings of this study with economic and financial viability at harvesting.
The authors are, respectively, Lecturer, Senior Lecturer, and Professor Dept, of Forestry, Biodiversity and Tourism, College of Agric. and Environ. Sci., Makerere Univ., Kampala, Uganda (firstname.lastname@example.org [corresponding author], email@example.com, firstname.lastname@example.org). This paper was received for publication in October 2015. Article no. 14-00070.
The study was conducted with the support of funding by the Carnegie Corporation of New York to Makerere University, Uganda, and the support of the Department of Wood Science at Stellenbosch University, South Africa.
Bhat, K. M., K. V. Bhat, and T. K. Dhamodaran. 1987. Effect of age and location on pulpwood quality of Eucalyptus grandis. Kerala Forest Research Institute, Peechi-Thrissur, Kerala, India. 23 pp.
Bhat, K. M., K. K. Bhat, and T. K. Dhamodaran. 1990. Wood density and fiber length of Eucalyptus grandis grown in Kerala, India. Wood Fiber Sci. 22(1):54-61.
Chang-ming, W. and Z. Xin-ying. 1994. Studies on wood anatomy of Eucalyptus globulus under different habitats. Acta Bot. Sin 36(1) 31-38.
Foelkel, C. 2009. Papermaking Properties of Eucalyptus Trees, Woods, and Pulp Fibers. Associacio Bracileira Tecnica de Cellulose e Papel, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil. 110 pp.
Gryc, V., H. Vavrcik, M. Rybnicek, and E. Premyslovska. 2008. The relation between the microscopic structure and the wood density of European beech (Fagus sylvatica L.). J. Forest Sci. 54(4): 170-175.
Harrison, J. and K. Windhorst. 2010. Markets for thinnings and prunings. Sawlog Prod. Grant Scheme Newsl. pp. 20-22.
Kurjatko, S., J. Kudela, and R. Lagana. 2006. Wood structure and properties. In: 5th International Symposium on Wood Structure and Properties, September 3-6, 2006, Silak, Slovakia; International Union of Forest Research Organizations (IUFRO), Vienna. 522 pp.
Leitch, M. A. 2001. Vessel-element dimensions and frequency within the most current growth increment along the length of Eucalyptus globulus stems. Trees 15(6):353-357.
Malan, F. S. 1990. Eucalyptus improvement for lumber production. Division of Forest Science and Technology, CSIR, Pretoria, South Africa, pp. 1-19.
Malan, F. S. 1991. Variation, association and inheritance of juvenile wood properties of Eucalyptus grandis Hill ex Maiden with special reference to the effect of rate of growth. S. Afr. Forestry J. 157:16-23.
Mencuccini, M., J. Martinez-Vilalta, D. Vanderklein, H. A. Hamid, E. Korakaki, S. Lee, and B. Michiels. 2005. Size-mediated ageing reduces vigour in trees. Ecol. Lett. 8(11):1183-1190.
Naji, H. R" M. H. Sahri, T. Nobuchi, and E. S. Bakar. 2011. The effect of growth rate on wood density and anatomical characteristics of rubberwood (Hevea brasiliensis Muell. Arg.) in two different clonal trails. J. Nat. Prod. Plant Resour. 1(2):71-80.
Ohshima, J., S. Yokota, N. Yoshizawa, and T. Ona. 2005. Examination of within-tree variations and the heights representing whole-tree values of derived wood properties for quasi-non-destructive breeding of Eucalyptus camaldulensis and Eucalyptus globulus as quality pulpwood. J. Wood Sci. 51(2): 102-111.
Oluwafemi, A. and O. A. Sotannde. 2007. The relationship between fibre characteristics and pulp-sheet properties of Leucaena leucocephala (Lam.) De Wit. Middle-East J. Sci. Res. 2(2):63-68.
Pirralho, M., D. Flores, V. B. Sousa, T. Quilho, S. Knapic, and H. Pereira. 2014. Evaluation on paper making potential of nine Eucalyptus species based on wood anatomical features. Ind. Crops Prod. 54(March):327-334.
Pisuttipiched, S. 2004. Effect of tree age on wood properties of Eucalyptus camaldulensis in Thailand. Thai J. Forestry 23:152-160.
Quilho, T., I. Miranda, and H. Pereira. 2006. Within-tree variation in wood fibre biometry and basic density of the urograndis eucalypt hybrid (Eucalyptus grandis X E. urophylla). IAWA J. 27(3):223-254.
Quilho, T., H. Pereira, and H. G. Richter. 2000. Within-tree variation in phloem cell dimensions and proportions in Eucalyptus globulus. IA WA J. 21 (1):31-40.
Ramirez, M., J. Rodriguez, M. Peredo, S. Valenzuela, and R. Mendonca. 2008. Wood anatomy and biometric parameters variation of Eucalyptus globulus clones. Wood Sci. Technol. 43(1-2): 131-141.
Rao, R. V., S. Shashikala, P. Sreevani, V. Kothiyal, C. R. Sarma, and P. Lai. 2002. Within tree variation in anatomical properties of some clones of Eucalyptus tereticornis Sm. Wood Sci. Technol. 36(3) 271-285.
Rucker, R. G. 2005. Spatial Variability of Soils on National and Hillslope Scale in Uganda. Cuvillier Verlag, Gottingen, Germany.
Saravanan, V., K. T. Parthiban, I. Sekar, P. Kumar, and S. Vennila. 2013. Radial variations in anatomical properties of Melia dubia cav. at five different ages. Sci. Res. Essays 8(45):2208-2217.
Saw Log Production Grant Scheme (SPGS) 2010. SPGS timber market study. SPGS, Kampala, Uganda.
Taylor, F. 1973. Anatomical wood properties of South African grown Eucalyptus grandis. S. Afr. Forestry J. 84(l):20-24.
Toong, W., J. Ratnasingam, M. Roslan, and H. Rasmina. 2014. The prediction of wood properties from anatomical characteristics: The case of common commercial Malaysian timbers. BioResources 9(3):5184-5197.
Uganda Bureau of Statistics. 2014. The 2014 statistical abstract. Uganda Bureau of Statistics, Kampala, Uganda.
World Wide Fund. 2012. National timber trade and FLEGT solutions for Uganda. World Wide Fund, Kampala, Uganda.
Zbonak, A., T. Bush, and V. Grzeskowiak. 2007. Comparison of tree growth, wood density and anatomical properties between coppiced trees and parent crop of six Eucalyptus genotypes. IUFRO 1991:1-10.
Zhu, J. Y., D. W. Vahey, C. T. Scott, and G. C. Myers. 2008. Effect of tree-growth rate on papermaking. Appita J. 61(2): 141-148.
Zziwa, A., Y. N. Ziraba, and J. A. Mwakali. 2009. Timber use practices in Uganda's building construction industry: Current situation and future prospects. J. Inst. Wood Sci. 19(1):48 53.
Table 1--Within-tree anatomical property estimates and pattern impressions. (a) Mean values at tree height levels (n = 300) Age Property (yr) 25% Fiber length 3 819.6 [+ or -] 166.69 (s) ([micro]m) 6 1,000.0 [+ or -] 116.8 (d) 9 1,013.6 [+ or -] 112.9 (d) 12 1,077.2 [+ or -] 79.4 (d) Fiber diameter 3 11.2 [+ or -] 3.255 (s) ([micro]m) 6 11.0 [+ or -] 2.003 (d) 9 11.2 [+ or -] 2.139 (s) 12 11.8 [+ or -] 2.404 (d) Vessel length 3 373.6 [+ or -] 114.2 (d) ([micro]m) 6 500.80 [+ or -] 84.18 (s) 9 534.4 [+ or -] 132.8 (s) 12 417.2 [+ or -] 107.8 (d) Vessel diameter 3 93.50 [+ or -] 32.48 (d) ([micro]m) 6 106.07 [+ or -] 16.86 (s) 9 107.03 [+ or -] 20.06 (s) 12 123.50 [+ or -] 30.99 (d) Ray height 3 253.70 [+ or -] 67.1 (d) ([micro]m) 6 218.60 [+ or -] 67.81 (d) 9 107.03 [+ or -] 20.06 (s) 12 278.40 [+ or -] 54.03 (d) Vessel average 3 16.032 [+ or -] 2.681 (s) (per [mm.sup.2]) 6 12.378 [+ or -] 2.261 (s) 9 12.833 [+ or -] 1.329 (s) 12 11.365 [+ or -] 1.471 (s) Ray frequency 3 10.133 [+ or -] 1.593 (s) (per [mm.sup.2]) 6 10.200 [+ or -] 1.7 (s) 9 8.925 [+ or -] 1.086 (s) 12 8.942 [+ or -] 1.12 (s) Mean values at tree height levels (n = 300) Age Property (yr) 50% Fiber length 3 835.7 [+ or -] 155.04 (s) ([micro]m) 6 928.8 [+ or -] 113.37 (s) 9 937.6 [+ or -] 105.3 (d) 12 972.0 [+ or -] 108.9 (d) Fiber diameter 3 13.4 [+ or -] 3.928 (d) ([micro]m) 6 10.0 [+ or -] 0.000 (d) 9 11.2 [+ or -] 3.255 (s) 12 10.6 [+ or -] 1.628 (d) Vessel length 3 450.0 [+ or -] 125.2 (d) ([micro]m) 6 508.0 [+ or -] 85.79 (s) 9 548.0 [+ or -] 109.3 (s) 12 471.2 [+ or -] 124.9 (s) Vessel diameter 3 99.53 [+ or -] 24.39 (s) ([micro]m) 6 113.93 [+ or -] 18.5 (d) 9 109.33 [+ or -] 15.04 (s) 12 135.93 [+ or -] 35.65 (s) Ray height 3 206.60 [+ or -] 47.96 (d) ([micro]m) 6 243.72 [+ or -] 46.06 (s) 9 109.33 [+ or -] 15.04 (s) 12 242.40 [+ or -] 48.66 (d) Vessel average 3 15.617 [+ or -] 2.948 (s) (per [mm.sup.2]) 6 11.640 [+ or -] 2.306 (s) 9 11.801 [+ or -] 0.889 (s) 12 11.270 [+ or -] 0.969 (s) Ray frequency 3 9.775 [+ or -] 0.802 (s) (per [mm.sup.2]) 6 9.750 [+ or -] 0.649 (s) 9 9.283 [+ or -] 1.11 (s) 12 9.450 [+ or -] 1.03 (s) Mean values at tree height levels (n = 300) Age Property (yr) 75% Fiber length 3 685.0 [+ or -] 115.97 (d) ([micro]m) 6 936.8 [+ or -] 136.51 (s) 9 868.4 [+ or -] 152.1 (d) 12 862.4 [+ or -] 109.6 (d) Fiber diameter 3 11.2 [+ or -] 3.255 (s) ([micro]m) 6 11.6 [+ or -] 2.336 (d) 9 11.6 [+ or -] 2.336 (s) 12 12.4 [+ or -] 2.502 (d) Vessel length 3 338.0 [+ or -] 112.5 (d) ([micro]m) 6 438.8 [+ or -] 95.92 (d) 9 529.2 [+ or -] 87.7 (s) 12 455.6 [+ or -] 116.5 (s) Vessel diameter 3 97.77 [+ or -] 21.93 (s) ([micro]m) 6 109.10 [+ or -] 16.55 (s) 9 107.07 [+ or -] 18.12 (s) 12 137.57 [+ or -] 36.44 (s) Ray height 3 268.20 [+ or -] 76.59 (d) ([micro]m) 6 238.77 [+ or -] 65.79 (s) 9 107.07 [+ or -] 18.12 (s) 12 208.10 [+ or -] 53.22 (d) Vessel average 3 18.167 [+ or -] 3.676 (s) (per [mm.sup.2]) 6 13.180 [+ or -] 2.932 (s) 9 12.487 [+ or -] 2.345 (s) 12 11.980 [+ or -] 1.707 (s) Ray frequency 3 9.567 [+ or -] 0.722 (s) (per [mm.sup.2]) 6 10.042 [+ or -] 0.997 (s) 9 9.758 [+ or -] 1.18 (s) 12 9.275 [+ or -] 1.15 (s) Within-row 1-way ANOVA Age Signifi- Property (yr) cance P Fiber length 3 S 0.000 ([micro]m) 6 S 0.000 9 S 0.000 12 S 0.000 Fiber diameter 3 S 0.000 ([micro]m) 6 S 0.000 9 NS 0.098 12 S 0.000 Vessel length 3 S 0.000 ([micro]m) 6 S 0.000 9 NS 0.103 12 S 0.000 Vessel diameter 3 S 0.018 ([micro]m) 6 S 0.000 9 NS 0.196 12 S 0.000 Ray height 3 S 0.000 ([micro]m) 6 S 0.000 9 NS 0.196 12 S 0.000 Vessel average 3 NS 0.117 (per [mm.sup.2]) 6 NS 0.338 9 NS 0.305 12 NS 0.421 Ray frequency 3 NS 0.458 (per [mm.sup.2]) 6 NS 0.650 9 NS 0.207 12 NS 0.656 Within-row 1-way ANOVA Three-point pattern axial Age F at [alpha] = var. summary Property (yr) 0.05 (25%--50%--75%) Fiber length 3 94.42 ([micro]m) 6 30.33 9 101.06 12 344.19 Fiber diameter 3 40.86 ([micro]m) 6 62.08 9 2.33 12 51.47 Vessel length 3 71.24 ([micro]m) 6 55.08 9 2.28 12 17.04 Vessel diameter 3 4.06 ([micro]m) 6 15.74 9 1.63 12 14.96 Ray height 3 73.68 ([micro]m) 6 14.42 9 1.63 12 136.97 Vessel average 3 2.29 (per [mm.sup.2]) 6 1.12 9 1.23 12 0.89 Ray frequency 3 0.8 (per [mm.sup.2]) 6 0.44 9 1.65 12 0.43 (a) The letters "(d)" (different) and "(s)" (same) indicate Tukey's mean separation statistic after 1-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) within a row. S = significant; NS = not significant. Table 2.--Estimates of biometry variation with tree age (a) Mean estimates [+ or -] SD at each tree age Property n 3yr Fiber 360 780.10 [+ or -] 162.11 * length Fiber 360 11.944 [+ or -] 3.645 * diameter Vessel 360 387.20 [+ or -] 126.27 * length Vessel 360 96.933 [+ or -] 26.743 * diameter Ray 360 242.83 [+ or -] 70.04 * height Vessel 143 16.605 [+ or -] 3.243 * average Ray 143 9.825 [+ or -] 1.104 * frequency Mean estimates [+ or -] SD at each tree age Property 6 yr 9 yr Fiber 955.20 [+ or -] 126.60 * 969.87 [+ or -] 138.36 (NS) length Fiber 10.867 [+ or -] 1.894 * 11.333 [+ or -] 2.626 (NS) diameter Vessel 482.53 [+ or -] 93.98 * 537.20 [+ or -] 111.63 * length Vessel 482.53 [+ or -] 93.98 * 107.81 [+ or -] 17.87 * diameter Ray 955.20 [+ or -] 126.60 * 939.87 [+ or -] 138.36 * height Vessel 12.399 [+ or -] 2.527 * 12.373 [+ or -] 1.650 * average Ray 9.997 [+ or -] 1.178 (NS) 9.322 [+ or -] 1.147 (NS) frequency Mean estimates [+ or -] SD at each tree age Property 12 yr Row statistic ([alpha] = 0.05) Fiber 970.53 [+ or -] 133.16 (NS) P = 0.000, F = 355.62 length Fiber 11.600 [+ or -] 2.334 (NS) P = 0.000, F = 25.47 diameter Vessel 448.00 [+ or -] 118.68 * P = 0.000, F = 277.21 length Vessel 132.33 [+ or -] 34.98 * P = 0.000, F = 309.77 diameter Ray 970.53 [+ or -] 133.16 * P = 0.000, F = 14.77 height Vessel 11.538 [+ or -] 1.412 * P = 0.000, F = 34.8 average Ray 9.222 [+ or -] 1.347 (NS) P = 0.016, F = 3.58 frequency (a)* = significantly different; (NS) = not significantly different (within-row Tukey mean separator indicator). Table 3.-Potential uses of Ugandan-grown E. grandis at 3, 6, 9, and 12 years based on their anatomical properties. Age Estimate by Estimated range Property (yr) this study by this study Fiber length 3 780.10 780-939 ([micro]m) 6 955.20 9 970.53 12 939.87 Fiber diameter 3 11.600 11-12 ([micro]m) 6 11.333 9 10.867 12 11.944 Vessel length 3 387.20 386-537 ([micro]m) 6 482.53 9 448.00 12 537.20 Vessel diameter 3 96.933 97-132 ([micro]m) 6 109.70 9 132.33 12 107.81 Ray height 3 242.83 234-353 ([micro]m) 6 233.70 9 242.97 12 252.89 Vessel average 3 16.605 11-17 (per [mm.sup.2]) 6 12.399 9 12.373 12 11.538 Ray frequency 3 9.825 9-10 (per [mm.sup.2]) 6 9.997 9 9.322 12 9.222 Age Industrial estimate Property (yr) and source Fiber length 3 700-1,300 (Pirralho et al. 2014) ([micro]m) 6 600-1,100 (Foelkel 2009) 9 12 Fiber diameter 3 16-17 (Pirralho et al. 2014) ([micro]m) 6 9 12 Vessel length 3 218-273 ([micro]m) 6 9 12 Vessel diameter 3 72-80 ([micro]m) 6 9 12 Ray height 3 148-143 ([micro]m) 6 9 12 Vessel average 3 11-18 (per [mm.sup.2]) 6 9 12 Ray frequency 3 9-11 (per [mm.sup.2]) 6 9 12 Age Property (yr) Remarks and comments Fiber length 3 Generally higher than 250 [micro]m, and ([micro]m) 6 therefore fit for pulp production pulp. 9 Increased folding endurance for pulp and 12 tearing strength at 6, 9, and 12 yr. All tree ages are suitable for good strength pulp production. Fiber diameter 3 Low external midfiber diameter. Lower ([micro]m) 6 taper and increased pulp mat formation. 9 Fit for pulp production pulp. 12 Vessel length 3 Generally higher vessel length and ([micro]m) 6 therefore lower-quality pulp yield 9 because longer and larger vessels yield 12 high volumes of fines in the pulp, which lowers the grade. Vessel diameter 3 Generally higher vessel length and ([micro]m) 6 therefore lower-quality pulp yield 9 because longer and larger vessels yield 12 high volumes of fines in the pulp, which lowers the grade. Ray height 3 Very low ray proportions imply reduced ([micro]m) 6 fibers and better pulping yields. 9 12 Vessel average 3 Lower number of vessels per unit area (per [mm.sup.2]) 6 supports lower nonstructural fiber 9 content and higher pulp yield. Trees 12 older than 6 yr are more desired. Ray frequency 3 The lower figure for ray frequency (per [mm.sup.2]) 6 contributes to a lower volume of 9 parenchyma and better pulp yield. 12
|Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback|
|Author:||Sseremba, O.E.; Mugabi, P.; Banana, A.Y.|
|Publication:||Forest Products Journal|
|Date:||Nov 1, 2016|
|Previous Article:||Properties of juvenile and mature wood and their effects on the bending properties of lumber in Pinus taeda growing in Tochigi, Japan.|
|Next Article:||Influence of density and equilibrium moisture content on the hardness anisotropy of wood.|