Printer Friendly

Who killed Tom Mboya? Declassifed documents raise new questions about the 1969 assassination of visionary nationalist Tom Joseph Mboya.

On 5 July it will be 47 years since Tom Mboya was assassinated outside Chhanni's Pharmacy on Government Road (now Moi Avenue). Up to this day, neither the real assassin nor his sponsors are known.

Mboya, who was only 39 years old when he was gunned down that Saturday morning, was arguably the architect of modern Kenya. Self-educated for the most part, Mboya rose to prominence on the strength of his organisational genius, his fearlessness and his oratory. He is today famous for his Mboya Students Airlift programme that took a generation of East Africans to college in the United States. But Mboya was a man of many firsts--a young man in a hurry, as he was once dubbed by Time magazine. At only 27, he became the president of the All Africa People's Conference, the precursor body of the OAU, unanimously elected by the delegates in Nkrumah's Accra.

[ILLUSTRATION OMITTED]

He was the lead negotiator for KANU (the Kenya African National Union) during the Lancaster House independence talks between 1961 and 1963.

He would be dead before the end of the decade. Almost 50 years later, it is still a mystery who his killers were and what motivated them.

At about 1pm on Saturday, July 5, 1969 he was standing outside Chhanni's Pharmacy chatting to the shop's owner Mohini Chhanni. She would later say that she heard what she thought was a tyre burst. Then Mboya fell into her arms, bleeding.

He never regained consciousness. The police launched the biggest manhunt in Kenya's history--over 400 police were assigned to the case. As riots swept across Nairobi, with Mboya's Luo compatriots blaming his murder on Jomo Kenyatta's Kikuyu, a suspect was miraculously found within 72 hours.

The trial of the suspected assassin, Nahashon Isaac Njenga Njoroge, a one-time KANU youthwinger who occasionally made money on the side by harassing Asian businessmen, was little more than a stage-managed farce. Njenga was convicted on the basis of dubious circumstantial evidence. The presiding judge, Alfred Henry Simpson, effectively ruled out any discussion of who may have sponsored Njenga. Those in the public gallery were vetted and monitored; journalists, especially foreign journalists, were mostly refused entry. Njenga had pleaded guilty to murdering Tom Mboya; the trial was merely a passage to his execution.

This smoothly managed showcase was however, almost ruined by a remark made almost casually by Njenga. "What about the big man?" he asked as he was being arrested.

With that remark, he posed a riddle that is, in many ways, at the heart of independent Kenya's politics. Historians, journalists and others have speculated for 40 years now over the identity of the Big Man. Fingers have silently pointed at individuals within President Jomo Kenyatta's inner circle. There has been a fair amount of speculation that foreign intelligence was involved--or at the very least, had sufficient motive to want Mboya dead, and in many ways gained from it. Or maybe it was a lone gunman, driven by pent-up personal grievances with the young dashing politician. Nothing has ever been proved or established.

The questions linger. Using recently declassified information from various sources, including the US State Department and documents from archives in Kenya and the UK, we will try to answer the basic questions surrounding Mboya's assassination: Who ordered the hit on Mboya? Was there a second gunman? Was there a link between Mboya's killers and an assassination plot almost six years later on Vice President Daniel arap Moi? Did Mboya know about the plot to assassinate Pio Gama Pinto? Was there a link between President Kenyatta, Bruce Mackenzie, Charles Njonjo and MI5? Did MI5 want Mboya out of the way?

Other questions: did Nahashon Njenga use Mboya's gun as later alleged (this is part of the somewhat absurd theory that Mboya planned to assassinate Kenyatta, Njenga knew about it and, in a fit of patriotism, killed Mboya instead, using Mboya's gun)?

Of Mboya's murder, then Vice President Daniel arap Moi would later say to parliament that it was "monstrously conceived but brilliantly planned and carried out".

It was a strange way to put it, especially because Mboya's death had precipitated the most severe riots in post-independence Kenya's history and had deepened existing ethnic and political divisions to the point that they threatened to break the country apart.

There are more practical questions surrounding that statement: considering Mboya had virtually no security on the day, was in fact by himself at a pharmacy in downtown Nairobi on a Saturday and at a time when the city is virtually deserted, it appears odd that Mr Moi would describe the assassination as "brilliantly planned and carried out". What does the former president know?

Also telling, was the brevity of the aftermath of assassination. "Biggest manhunt ever for Mboya's killers", the. Daily Nation announced in its headline the following Monday and in somewhat triumphant fashion. Three weeks later, on August 1, it was, however, Time Magazine that broached the unutterable: "A Kikuyu Suspect" announced its Mboya headline. However, when the alleged assassin was found and arrested, his trial strongly suggested that other forces were at play. Appearing in court on 13 August, the trial was over in a matter of weeks, Njenga convicted and sentenced to hang. Significantly, records of the trial in the Kenya National Archives have disappeared. Thus, in so many ways, the idea of the state's complicity in Mboya's killing is a major factor in the subsequent cover-up.

[ILLUSTRATION OMITTED]

At the same time, we also aim to explore the significance of Mboya's life and the implications of his death.

In many ways, with the death of Mboya, the nascent enterprise that was "project Kenya"--the building of a nation from what American writer Paul Theroux once called "the querulous republic", an assortment of ethnic communities fiercely competing for control of the centre--began to crumble. The sense of optimism that had come with independence and somehow survived the ideological discord within KANU, was extinguished with the assassination of Tom Mboya on that Saturday afternoon. Mahathir Mohamad, the Malaysian prime minister and architect of that country's post-colonial renaissance, was later to comment: "When you killed Tom, you lost 30 years."

1969 was in many ways a watershed year. Rumours in late 1968 that President Kenyatta had suffered a heart attack brought home to the nation but especially to the close circle around Kenyatta--known as the Kiambu mafia--that the founding president was not immortal. The politics of succession, which would become the enduring theme of Kenyan politics, began to play out in earnest.

Having neutralised the left wing of KANU in the mid-60s, first after the assassination of Pinto in 1965 and then with the sidelining of Jaramogi Odinga at the Limuru Conference in '66, Mboya, the obvious successor to Kenyatta, himself became a target for neutralisation by the Kiambu mafia. There had been an attempt on his life in ea rly 1969. By the middle of that year, Mboya found himself increasingly isolated on the domestic political scene. Internationally, the assassination of Robert Kennedy, an intimate friend and perhaps his biggest champion in the US, was a big blow to Mboya. With the British already quite nervous of his strong links with the US, the jostling around the Kenya presidency acquired added urgency, and rendered Mboya increasingly vulnerable.

There were, in short, many reasons and many people who wanted Tom Mboya dead. But first, let us fast-forward to 1975 and examine the story of a man called Jones Mukeka.

On Friday 7 February, 1975, less than three weeks before the body of Josiah Mwangi Kariuki would be found in the Ngong Hills and almost six years after the assassination of Thomas Joseph Mboya, a man named Jones Mukeka showed up at the US Embassy in Nairobi with some disturbing information. Claiming to have contact with "high-level Kamba and Kikuyu politicians", he disclosed that there was a plot underway to assassinate Vice President Daniel arap Moi.

Mukeka, a sometime trade unionist, elected councillor and unsuccessful parliamentary candidate, was working in Nairobi as a private investigator. Towards the end of his life--he died in 2005 in Machakos and in penury--he would give an interview to Nation writer Bob Odalo.

In that interview, he speaks of many things--his life and times with the high and mighty; his friendship with both Tom Mboya and J. M. Kariuki; how he had attended future US President's John F. Kennedy's wedding in Kennebunkport, Maine in 1963; his later association with JFK's brother, Robert Kennedy. He would remember where he was at lunchtime on 5 July, 1969 as his friend Tom Mboya was being gunned down; how he was among the first people at the crime scene. He would even claim in the interview that he was one of the last people to see J. M. Kariuki alive: they had sauna-ed together at the Hilton and repaired to the bar for a drink, soon after which J. M. Kariuki was picked up, the last time he would be seen in public. By the time of his death, then, Jones Mukeka had lived the full spectrum of the Kenyan experience of the past 60 years--from the bitterness of Emergency and the independence struggle to the euphoria and subsequent betrayal of uhuru. He was literally, a Kenyan everyman. And perhaps sensing the end was near, he speaks about it all in that interview with the Nation. Everything, that is, except his meeting on that Friday in February 1975 with an unnamed US Embassy official.

[ILLUSTRATION OMITTED]

But that encounter is captured in a declassified US State Department document. Classified as "Secret", entitled "Alleged Plot to Assassinate Vice President Moi", Mukeka's disclosures were immediately dispatched by US Ambassador Anthony D. Marshall to the Secretary of State in Washington. Ambassador Marshall, two years into his Kenya posting and a little bit wary of Mukeka's credentials, describes him as an "untested Embassy source".

In a sense then, Jones Mukeka was already falling down in the world. A graduate of Syracuse University in the mid-1960s, he had returned to Kenya and begun to cultivate high-level contacts in political and diplomatic circles. He had been a close confidant of then US Ambassador, William Atwood. Atwood's explosive book The Reds and the Blacks, about the Cold War and its impact on post-uhuru Kenyan politics, was banned by Kenyatta. Mukeka regularly wined and dined with Kenya's leading politicians. And although he still claimed to have contact with the likes of Vice President Moi and others, the fact that Ambassador Marshall attempts to put some distance between Mukeka and the US Embassy suggest that Mukeka no longer enjoyed his former access to the high and mighty.

What Mukeka had to say, however, was explosive enough for Marshall to immediately fire off a telegram to Washington. The plot to assassinate Moi was motivated, said Mukeka, by "Kikuyu unwillingness to accept Moi as Kenyatta's successor". Moi's Kikuyu allies, Attorney General Charles Njonjo and Commerce and Industry Minister Julius Kiano, were also targeted, Mukeka claimed. The assassinations would take place while Kenyatta was still alive. Moi's chosen assassin would be a Kalenjin, presumably to remove suspicion from the conspirators. President Kenyatta, alleged Mukeka, was aware of the plot.

While all this information was incendiary enough, it is with Mukeka's revelation of the identity of the chief conspirator that the intrigues begin. The plot to assassinate Moi, said Mukeka, was being organised by a man only known as Muigai, who also went by the nickname Lumumba. Furthermore, claimed Mukeka, Muigai was the same person who had arranged the assassination of Tom Mboya.

The Kenyatta regime, increasingly paranoid following the events of 1969--the assassination of Tom Mboya, the Kisumu riots, the arrest and detention of Jaramogi Odinga and other leaders of the Kenya People's Union--was silencing its critics by any means necessary. For J.M. Kariuki, who had loudly criticised the rampant accumulation of wealth and corruption of the clique around Kenyatta, this had resulted in death. For Jones Mukeka, this exile to Machakos was the beginning of a journey into obscurity.

At J.M. Kariuki's funeral in Nyandarua, Alphonce Okuku, Tom Mboya's younger brother, rose and addressed the crowd composed predominantly of Kikuyus. In a speech that borrowed from the German anti-Nazi dissident priest Gerhart Niemeyer's famous exhortation to stand up against dictatorship, Alphonce Okuku intoned: 'When they killed Pinto, you said it was because he was Indian. When they killed Tom Mboya, you said it was because he was Luo. Now what are you going to say about J.M.?"

It is a cruel ironv that it was VP Daniel arap Moi who had led the chorus of official denials. In parliament, it was Moi who stated the government's position: J.M. was in Zambia. Because neither Mr Moi nor the other politicians still alive from that time have ever spoken about what they know, it is a matter of speculation as to how much Moi actually knew about what had really happened to J.M. Kariuki.
COPYRIGHT 2016 IC Publications Ltd.
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2016 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Title Annotation:NA Declassified: KENYA
Author:Kantai, Parselelo
Publication:New African
Geographic Code:6KENY
Date:Jul 1, 2016
Words:2163
Previous Article:You talk about the collapse of the West as if it were a bad thing.
Next Article:The state of the African Union.
Topics:

Terms of use | Privacy policy | Copyright © 2020 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters