Voss, Ralph F. Truman Capote and the Legacy of In Cold Blood.
In what is a highly readable, engaging study of Truman Capote's important novel In Cold Blood, Ralph F. Voss offers a wide-ranging study of Capote's work that will appeal to Capote scholars as well as to general readers interested in Capote's novel, its roots in Capote's own colorful life, and its ongoing importance to American culture in the intervening half century. Voss's book proves especially strong as he offers a contrarian view to the prevailing sense of Capote as originator of "the nonfiction novel," suggesting that Capote's work more importantly draws on other currents in the writing of historical novels and of true crime fiction rather than innovating a new subgenre in its own right. Finally, Voss offers an interesting and, for Capote scholars, indispensable update to what he calls Capote's "legacy in Kansas" as he tracks the continued effects in the present day of In Cold Blood on the lives of the Kansans-turned-characters in Capote's pages.
For Voss, any understanding of Capote's In Cold Blood necessarily roots itself in what he calls "Capote's ruinous celebrity" (14), and Voss's work retraces with aplomb the now-familiar narratives of Capote's troubled life as a youth, his emergence into the circles of New York literati and of the gay subcultures of the city, his meteoric rise to fame in print and in the film adaptations of Breakfast at Tiffany's and In Cold Blood, and his gradual but flashy decline as a writer through travel, excess, and increasing personal and artistic turmoil. In depicting these phases of Capote's life and career, Voss acknowledges his obvious debt to Gerald Clarke's Capote (1988), considered the landmark biography of Capote, and to George Plimpton's Too Briefa Treat (2004), and it is true that he draws heavily on these two writers in the initial pages of his book. Still, Voss demonstrates very successfully how In Cold Blood was enabled and emboldened in its scope and ambition by the very courting of celebrity that defined Capote's life and ultimately destroyed it.
Once Voss moves more solidly into his own contentions about Capote's style and in particular to his assertion that Capote's much-heralded "invention" of the nonfiction novel "represents a kind of evolution or, more accurately, a kind of reinvention" (99) of the older forms of the historical novel and of true crime fiction, Voss's argument gathers particular strength, bolstered by his own copious research of the New York Public Library's Truman Capote Papers. For Voss, In Cold Blood derives in large part from Capote's grounding in the Southern Gothic tradition of writing, an attribute only accentuated by Capote's collaboration with Harper Lee during the research and writing of his novel, especially given the Southern Gothic characteristics so prominently on display in Lee's own novel To Kill a Mockingbird. For Voss, Capote's treatment of Holcomb, Kansas, as a sleepy town thrust abruptly and irrevocably into the modern sense of malaise that accompanies such a grisly murder--here, a killing not just of the Clutter family but of a whole community's (perhaps false) sense of security--cannot be separated from the Southern Gothic's own frequent recourse to the sometimes-violent "crumbling and decay of antebellum culture" and its "lingering romantic nostalgia" (47). In this sense, Voss argues that Capote inevitably sees rural Kansas through the lens of his own years in Monroeville, Alabama, where he and Harper Lee ("Nelle" to Capote and her other friends) found their own idyll compromised by the intrusions of an ever-encroaching outside world and finally destroyed by Capote's fractured family life and his parentally-imposed exile to the boarding schools of Connecticut and New York City.
Where Voss's work reaches its argumentative apogee, however, is his culminating discussion of the legacy of In Cold Blood in the lives of those Kansans depicted there. While Capote's novel certainly records the demise of the Clutters and their murderers, Richard "Dick" Hickock and Perry Smith, it less clearly depicts a final tally of the personal and social costs of the events of the Clutter murders, their investigation, the trial, and the criminals' subsequent execution for the residents of Holcomb themselves and for those tasked with bringing Hickock and Smith to justice. Voss's own exhaustive tracking of the novel's more minor characters, their lives, and their ongoing perceptions of the novel, of the subsequent films (the multiple In Cold Blood adaptations as well as the various biopics about Capote himself), and of how Capote's novel changed their existence in Holcomb and elsewhere proves to be his most fascinating and original contribution to the body of Capote scholarship. Voss takes his reader to present-day Holcomb, to the memorials erected there to the CI utter family, to the graveyards, and even to the scene of the murders themselves at the Clutter home (which, much to the reader's macabre surprise, has people living in it who aren't afraid to discuss the gruesome events that took place at their own residence many years ago). Voss moves comfortably beyond the citation of other scholars in this final chapter of his book precisely because he is the only one to document the ongoing traumas of these Kansans--"real lives most assuredly do not go away," Voss reminds us (213). His inclusion of key photographs and his review of lesser-known pieces of local journalism, personal interviews and the like, turn Voss's book into the latest monument to a particularly painful episode in these lives, providing a useful counter-narrative to the often gossipy tone of Plimpton's and others' earlier work on these subjects.
While Voss's book evidences certain weaknesses--his chapter on "the gay subtext of Capote's novel" would benefit from the updated paradigms and language of more recent scholarship in gay and lesbian literary studies, for instance--his book capaciously surveys and extends Capote scholarship in vivid, accessible prose. Particularly as we approach the fiftieth anniversary of Capote's novel, those interested in Capote's writing as well as its reception, the critical response, its ongoing shaping of American culture, and its traces upon the particular lives of the Kansans it depicts will find Voss's work not to be missed.
TRENTON HICKMAN, Brigham Young University
|Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback|
|Publication:||Studies in the Novel|
|Article Type:||Book review|
|Date:||Dec 22, 2013|
|Previous Article:||Maurer, Sara L. The Dispossessed State: Narratives of Ownership in 19th-Century Britain and Ireland.|
|Next Article:||Editor's introduction.|