Printer Friendly

Value gifts on the date given.

The Fifth Circuit reaffirmed that under IRC section 2512, a gift's value is determined on the date it is given. The court also decided that a discount used to determine the present value of a previously transferred interest was allowable if it was the amount a willing buyer would require to cover any additional taxes under section 2035.

Charles T. McCord Jr. and his wife, Maw, along with their four sons, established McCord Interest Ltd. (MIL), a Texas limited partnership. The couple received all the class A limited partnership interest in MIL and 82% of the class B limited partnership interest, for a total contribution of $12.3 million.

On Jan. 12, 1996, the McCords gave all their class B limited partnership interest to two charities, their sons and each son's generation-skipping trust by executing an assignment agreement. The gifts were in dollar amounts of the net fair market value of MIL and not stated in percentages of interest. An independent appraiser determined the value on the date of the gift as $89,505 for each 1% of class B limited partnership interest. In March 1996, all the recipients signed a confirmation agreement, which translated the dollar value of the gifts into percentages of interest.

The McCords timely filed a 1996 gift tax return that reflected the appraiser's value of their gifts. They took annual exclusions of $60,000 each and charitable contribution deductions of $209,173 each. In addition, they reduced the value of their gifts by the amount of the gift tax payable for gifts to the nonexempt donees, which reflected the fact that the donees assumed the payment. They also deducted the actuarially determined present value of the nonexempt donees' liability (which the donees had agreed to pay) for any additional estate taxes if one or both taxpayers died within three years of the gift, based on section 2035.

The IRS issued a deficiency to both taxpayers, saying the McCords understated the gifts' fair market value and should not have taken the discount for the nonexempt donees' potential liability under section 2035. The McCords contested the deficiencies in the U.S. Tax Court. The Tax Court initially found in favor of the taxpayers on all issues, then two years later, in what the Fifth Circuit would later call an unusual proceeding that employed a "novel methodology," the Tax Court reversed its earlier decision.

Result. For the taxpayers. The Fifth Circuit reversed and remanded the case, saying the Tax Court majority erred in relying on the recipients' agreement, since it came two months after the gift and the donors were not a party to it. The appellate court also determined the value of the gifts was properly discounted because:

* The transfer tax rate on the date of the gift would be of interest to a willing buyer for discount purposes. Section 7520 provides the interest rates.

* A willing-buyer/willing-seller test would allow a discount for potential additional federal estate taxes if one or both of the taxpayers died within three years of the gift and it is sufficiently determinable to be taken into account.

* Succession of McCord Jr. v. Commissioner, 98 AFTR2d 2006-6147 (8/22/2006).

Prepared by Gary D. Rider, J.D., instructor of business, and Darlene Pulliam, CPA, Ph.D., professor of accounting, both of the College of Business, West Texas A&M University, Canyon.
COPYRIGHT 2007 American Institute of CPA's
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2007, Gale Group. All rights reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Author:Rider, Gary D.
Publication:Journal of Accountancy
Date:Apr 1, 2007
Words:559
Previous Article:IRS scores victory over alleged tax shelter.
Next Article:Dirty little secrets of 401(k) plan fees.
Topics:


Related Articles
Gift tax return filing traps and opportunities.
Gifting compensatory stock options.
Estate planning strategies.
Gift may create income or gain to donor: think a gift results in no income or gain to the donor? Gifts of encumbered property, installment notes and...
Income tax consequences of certain gift transactions: some transfers may result in income or gain to the donor.
Iceberg ahead! Navigating the murky waters of gift-tax-return preparation.
Inadequate disclosure of gifts of closely held business interests.
No annual gift tax exclusion for gift of LLC membership units.
IRS curbs use of Crummey powers.
Family limited partnership transfers were indirect gifts of stock.

Terms of use | Privacy policy | Copyright © 2021 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters