Printer Friendly

Utility of Core Needle Biopsies and Transbronchial Biopsies for Diagnosing Nonneoplastic Lung Diseases.

Sampling error in small biopsies is a reality in the practice of lung pathology. Although the yield of these samples varies from high (sarcoidosis) to low (obliterative bronchiolitis) depending on the availability of image guidance and the size and distribution of the lesion being sampled, any type of pathology can be missed by any sampling method for a variety of reasons. This phenomenon is especially common when the lesion is nonneoplastic and patchy. Pathologists who deal with small lung biopsies must also be cognizant of a wide variety of artefacts and nonspecific changes that need to be mentally subtracted from the overall histologic picture before a specific abnormality is detected. (1,2) Even in cases where specific pathologic abnormalities are identified, their clinical impact may be enhanced, diminished, or modified by the clinical and radiologic context. For example, in the correct clinical context, a minute solitary nonspecific nonnecrotizing granuloma may be interpreted by the clinician as being supportive of sarcoidosis. On the other hand, a highly specific finding such as particles of food/vegetable material within lung parenchyma accompanied by the appropriate inflammatory reaction, may be downplayed or ignored because the clinical setting is deemed to be atypical or incompatible.

Nonneoplastic lesions can be missed or inadequately sampled by transbronchial lung biopsies, and occasionally even by core needle biopsies. Although the yield of the latter procedure is enhanced by computed tomography (CT) guidance and by the fact that a nodule or mass is relatively discrete and easier to sample than an ill-defined infiltrate, the fact that a needle is within a lesion radiologically is no guarantee of success ("the needle may be in the mass, but the mass is not in the needle"). Biopsies may obtain numerous cores and sample abundant tissue, all of which may prove to be normal lung, pleura, or skeletal muscle from the chest wall. Even when an adequate amount of abnormal tissue is present in the sample, the pathologic findings may be nonspecific or nondiagnostic. Given this background, it is important not to miss specific nonneoplastic findings when they are present, as their recognition can obviate the need for a second procedure, which is often an invasive surgical lung biopsy. While most pathologists are aware of the importance of findings such as granulomas or organisms, less common findings can be missed or misinterpreted, impacting patient care. Indeed, from the point of view of the patient and the bronchoscopist, a "nondiagnostic bronch" represents a poor outcome. The aim of this review is to provide surgical pathologists and pathology trainees with menus of specific nonneoplastic entities that can be diagnosed in small lung biopsies. The first part of the review will address core needle biopsies, while the second will focus on transbronchial lung biopsies. Table 1 offers a menu of nonneoplastic diagnoses that can be made in core needle biopsies of lung nodules, with examples illustrated in Figures 1 through 4. Table 2 provides a menu of nonneoplastic diseases that can be diagnosed by transbronchial lung biopsies. Selected entities are illustrated in Figures 5 through 15. Table 3 provides examples of terminology in pathology reports on these samples.


Core needle biopsies of the lung are percutaneous transthoracic biopsies typically performed under CT guidance (CT fluoroscopy or cone-beam CT) by a radiologist, the aim being to sample localized peripheral lung lesions, most commonly nodules or masses. In most instances, the clinical differential diagnosis includes a neoplasm. In biopsies where neoplastic cells are not found, the next question that arises is whether a specific nonneoplastic diagnosis can be made that would explain the presence of a lung nodule or mass. To answer this question, it is helpful to have a list of nonneoplastic abnormalities that may manifest as lung nodules or masses. This issue was specifically addressed in a recent study by Doxtader et al, (3) which provided details of the histologic features in these samples. A menu of possible diagnoses based on this study and the authors' experience is shown in Table 1. In a separate large series of cases in which core needle biopsies of the lung were compared to fine-needle aspirates, the rate of identification of specific benign lesions was significantly higher with the former. (4)

Mycobacterial Infection

Necrotizing granulomatous inflammation is the most common specific finding in core needle biopsies of nonneoplastic lung nodules. (3) A recent multi-institution study of 500 cases of lung granulomas from 7 countries demonstrated that the type of organism found within necrotizing granulomas in lung biopsies and resections varies greatly by geographic setting, reflecting the mycobacteria or fungi endemic in the area where the biopsy is performed. (5) Acid-fast bacteria (AFB) are the most common organisms in necrotizing granulomas in large swaths of the developing world. In core needle biopsies, they are most commonly identified within the necrotic center of the lesion. Tips for finding AFB have been published recently, one of the most important being that adequate time should be devoted to hunting for organisms by using at least an X40 objective lens. (6) We have seen many examples in which a cursory scan at low magnification has missed mycobacterial organisms. In any type of lung biopsy, AFB can be very few in number and nonuniformly distributed. Therefore, the absence of AFB in a small sample does not exclude the possibility of mycobacterial infection. Several studies clearly demonstrate the fact that mycobacterial cultures can be positive even when no organisms are detected by histology. (5,6) The converse is also true, that is, mycobacteria can be identified by histologic examination in cases where cultures are negative. (5,6) The reader should also be aware that in some settings in developed Western nations, nontuberculous mycobacteria (NTM)--most commonly Mycobacterium avium complex (MAC)--are more common in necrotizing granulomas of the lung than Mycobacterium tuberculosis. (5) It is worth noting that the presence of AFB within necrotizing granulomas does not necessarily imply tuberculosis, since NTM can cause identical pathologic findings. (6-8) The only definitive means for differentiating between M. tuberculosis and NTM are microbiologic cultures and polymerase chain reaction (PCR). Submitting a portion of biopsied tissue for cultures is an obvious solution to this problem, but in the authors' experience tissue for core needle biopsies is often not submitted for cultures, especially when a neoplasm is suspected clinically. In such cases, interventional radiologists usually submit the entire sample in formalin for histopathology. Although formalin-fixed material cannot be used for cultures for obvious reasons, PCR for mycobacteria can be attempted on formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded tissue. This usually requires send-out to a specialized reference laboratory, with a turnaround time of at least a few days. In general, the lower the number of AFB seen in the biopsy sample, the lower the yield of PCR. If PCR fails or if PCR testing is not available, an additional diagnostic procedure may be required to obtain fresh tissue for cultures. Bronchoscopy with bronchial washings and bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL) is especially effective for this purpose.

Infections Caused by Fungal Hyphae

Core needle biopsies can be used to diagnose lung infections caused by fungal hyphae, the most common fungus in this setting being Aspergillus organisms. The forms of aspergillosis that are likely to be biopsied with a core needle include chronic necrotizing aspergillosis, fungus balls (mycetomas), and invasive aspergillosis. Lesions that present as solid solitary lung nodules in smokers (so-called Aspergillus nodules9) are especially likely to be biopsied since they mimic lung cancer. The reader is reminded that the finding of septate fungal hyphae with narrow-angle branching is not pathognomonic of Aspergillus infection, since other fungi such as Pseudallescheria and Fusarium organisms can appear identical. For this reason, we use the term fungal hyphae in pathology reports rather than Aspergillus unless the organism has been proven to be Aspergillus by prior microbiologic cultures.

Infections Caused by Fungal Yeasts and Yeastlike Fungi

Granulomatous infections caused by fungal yeasts commonly manifest as peripheral lung nodules and can be sampled by core needle biopsies. (3) The 4 major fungi associated with lung nodules (usually necrotizing granulomas) are Histoplasma, Cryptococcus, Blastomyces, and Coccidioides organisms. Unlike fungal hyphae, morphologic identification of fungal yeasts and yeastlike fungi in necrotizing granulomas of the lung is feasible in most cases, and correlates well with cultures. In some cases, fungal yeasts may be present in tissue (sometimes in large numbers) but may not grow in cultures. This situation is most commonly encountered with solitary histoplasmomas of the lung, which invariably contain nonviable Histoplasma yeasts that almost never grow in cultures, even when large numbers of organisms are identified in tissue by histology. (2,3,5,7,8,10) In many areas in the United States where histoplasmosis is endemic, lung nodules characterized by necrotizing granulomas are the hallmark of remote or "healed" lung infection in immunocompetent individuals. In core needle biopsies, these lesions consist predominantly of necrosis and can be misinterpreted as an infarct or as tumor necrosis if the subtle rim of epithelioid histiocytes is not appreciated. (11,12) The necrosis contains variable numbers of uniform, tiny, oval-to-tapered yeasts with occasional narrow-based budding, diagnostic of Histoplasma. (7) The organisms are visible within necrosis on Grocott methenamine silver (GMS) but cannot be seen in the same areas on hematoxylin-eosin (H&E)-stained sections. (10) Periodic acid-Schiff-- generally a good stain for fungal organisms--is suboptimal for this form of histoplasmosis, since nonviable organisms stain very lightly or not at all and may be missed. Rarely, the disseminated form of histoplasmosis (discussed in detail in the section on transbronchial biopsies) can be sampled by core needle biopsies. Another fungal infection that can be diagnosed in core needle biopsies is cryptococcosis (Figure 1, A and B). It features organisms that are visible on H&E within histiocytes and multinucleated giant cells as well as within necrosis as faintly staining round yeasts with light gray cell walls surrounded by a clear space (Figure 1, A). Both necrotizing and nonnecrotizing granulomas can be encountered, and multinucleated giant cells can be numerous. The GMS stain is useful for highlighting the remarkable size variation and fragmentation that are hallmarks of this organism (Figure 1, B). (7) The mucicarmine stain helps to confirm the diagnosis when positive, but absence of staining does not exclude the diagnosis. Blastomyces organisms can also be identified on core needle biopsies. The classic tissue reaction is a mix of suppurative (neutrophil-rich) and granulomatous inflammation. The organisms are larger than Histoplasma or Cryptococcus organisms and are characterized by broad-based budding, double-contoured cell walls, and purple nuclear material. Coccidioides spherules with or without endospores can be identified by core needle biopsy within necrosis (Figure 2, A and B) or in granulomas or giant cells. Cases with a mix of spherules and endospores can be confidently diagnosed, but differentiation from Blastomyces is often difficult or impossible.

Organizing Pneumonia

Sampling of masslike consolidation or nonresolving localized opacities by core needle biopsy occasionally yields a lesion known as "organizing pneumonia," (3) characterized by the presence of fibroblast plugs ("Masson bodies") within airspaces (Figure 3, A and B). These plugs are composed of fibroblasts in a pale-staining or lightly collagenized background (Figure 3, A), and are liable to be mistaken for fibroblast foci (a hallmark of usual interstitial pneumonia). In contrast to fibroblast foci, fibroblast plugs are often clustered (ie, multiple plugs lie adjacent to each other); are frequently located adjacent to small pulmonary arteries (Figure 3, B); have serpiginous, branching, or dumbbell-like shapes; and may contain inflammatory cells such as plasma cells and pigmented macrophages. (2) Clinicians should be aware that organizing pneumonia can occur at the edge of other mass-forming processes such as neoplasms or infarcts. Whether a pathologic diagnosis of organizing pneumonia should be considered an adequate explanation for a mass or nodule therefore depends on the clinical context and radiologic findings.


Fibrous scars occasionally manifest radiologically as localized lung nodules and can be sampled with a core needle biopsy. (3) The so-called pulmonary apical cap is a common type of scar found at the apices of the lungs. It is wedge shaped, the base being at the visceral pleura and the apex in the subpleural lung parenchyma. It has a characteristic elastotic appearance (similar to solar elastosis of the skin) and often contains entrapped lung epithelium or lymphoid aggregates. As the name suggests, radiation-related scars occur after radiation for malignancy.

Pulmonary Langerhans Cell Histiocytosis

Since most cases of pulmonary Langerhans cell histiocytosis--a disease of adult cigarette smokers--are diagnosed by surgical or transbronchial biopsies, it is not widely appreciated that this condition can be diagnosed by core needle biopsy. Core needle biopsies are not commonly used because the tiny nodules seen in this disease are thought to be too small to sample with this technique. However, it has been shown that the diagnosis can be made by core needle biopsy even when the nodules are as small as 5 mm (Figure 4, A through C). (13) This diagnosis should be suspected when a heavy smoker presents with multiple tiny (millimeter-size) bilateral nodules (Figure 4, A). The stellate shape of the nodules that serves as an important clue to the diagnosis in surgical lung biopsies cannot be fully appreciated in needle biopsies. However, other diagnostic features remain appreciable, including sheets of Langerhans cells, variable numbers of eosinophils, and pigmented macrophages (Figure 4, B and C).

Other Specific Diagnoses

Miscellaneous causes of lung nodules diagnosable on core needle biopsy include intraparenchymal lymph nodes (often containing numerous dust-laden macrophages), abscesses (suppurative necrosis destroying lung architecture), nodular amyloidosis (deposits of amyloid associated with multinucleated giant cells), light chain deposition disease (similar to amyloid on H&E but negative for Congo red), and the rare entity known as pulmonary hyalinizing granuloma. The latter is not a true granulomatous lesion but instead is composed of dense bundles of hyalinized collagen. (2)

What If No Specific Diagnosis Can Be Made on a Core Needle Biopsy?

In some cases, the tissue sampled may be completely nonrepresentative, consisting only of fragments of normal lung, mesothelium-lined pleura, or chest wall (adipose tissue or skeletal muscle). Alternatively, the findings may consist of nonspecific chronic inflammation and/or fibrosis. Clearly, these findings do not account for the presence of a lung nodule or mass. Suggested wording in pathology reports in such cases is provided in Table 3. Depending on the characteristics of the nodule and the clinical setting, the clinician may elect to follow the lesion radiologically; obtain a repeated needle biopsy; use advanced bronchoscopic techniques such as electromagnetic navigation, ultrathin scope, or peripheral ultrasound; or proceed to surgical sampling.


Transbronchial lung biopsies are obtained by pulmonologists. The procedure involves introduction of a bronchoscope into the bronchial lumen, introduction of biopsy forceps through the bronchoscope, and subsequent piercing of the bronchus and extension of the biopsy forceps into alveolated lung in order to sample lesional tissue. The ideal sample should include 4 to 6 fragments of alveolated lung with or without fragments of bronchial wall. (14) Fragments that contain both alveolated lung and bronchial wall are counted as the former. We generally include a brief description of the sample obtained in order to give the clinician a sense of the adequacy of the specimen (Table 3). The number of transbronchial biopsy specimens (fragments) obtained and the size of the forceps used depend on the clinical and radiologic setting. It is common practice to use larger forceps and obtain a greater number of fragments when a nonneoplastic condition is suspected. For diffuse parenchymal lung disease, the bronchoscopist may choose to sample more than 1 lobe of the same lung. Unlike core needle biopsies, other types of specimens such as bronchial washings, brushings, BAL, transbronchial needle aspirates, and endobronchial biopsies can be obtained to complement information obtained from the transbronchial biopsy sample and optimize the diagnostic yield.

Although this review only addresses nonneoplastic lung diseases, it is worth noting that transbronchial biopsies occasionally sample unexpected malignancies in cases that appear nonneoplastic on clinical and radiologic grounds. The most classic example is lymphangitic carcinomatosis, but rarely lymphoma can also present with diffuse and bilateral lung opacities mimicking interstitial lung disease. (15,16)

Mycobacterial Infections

A wide variety of infections can be diagnosed by transbronchial biopsies, the most common being mycobacterial and fungal (Figures 5 through 7; Table 2). As with core needle biopsies, transbronchial biopsies can contribute to the diagnosis of tuberculosis as well as NTM infection. (6) Even when mycobacteria cannot be detected, the tissue reaction can be helpful in clinical decision-making. For example, in patients with suspected NTM infection, the finding of severe airway inflammation with granulomas can help to support the diagnosis, even if AFB are not demonstrable (Figure 5, A through C). This is because when MAC is isolated in sputum cultures, nonspecific colonization is often a concern, and the presence of an appropriate tissue reaction in the lung lends support to contention that the organism is truly pathogenic. A significant difference between transbronchial biopsies and core needle biopsies for the diagnosis of mycobacterial infections is that additional samples are often obtained along with transbronchial biopsies (bronchial washings, BAL, or bronchial brushings) and material is almost always submitted for cultures when infection is in the differential diagnosis, increasing the diagnostic yield.

Fungal Infection

Pneumocystis pneumonia is one of the most significant fungal infections diagnosed in transbronchial lung biopsies. Transbronchial biopsy is especially important in this infection because the organism cannot be cultured. Biopsies typically show a frothy material with dots within the airspaces accompanied by mild interstitial thickening. (17) In some cases, this classic appearance is absent, however, and the histologic picture may consist of minimal and subtle interstitial thickening only. Because of this possibility, GMS staining should be performed for any severely immunocompromised patient, even in the absence of intra-alveolar froth. Careful examination of the GMS stain will occasionally yield rare Pneumocystis cysts. Histoplasmosis can also be diagnosed in transbronchial biopsies. Pulmonary histoplasmomas are most commonly sampled by core needle biopsy, but occasionally may be approached with a transbronchial lung biopsy. Rarely, in immunocompromised individuals, histoplasmosis does not manifest as necrotizing granulomatous inflammation (Figure 6, A and B). Instead, granulomas are poorly formed (Figure 6, A) or absent, and fungal yeasts can be seen within enlarged histiocytes on H&E (Figure 6, B). It has been shown that this finding in lung biopsies is not only diagnostic of histoplasmosis but also highly suggestive of the disseminated form of the disease. (10) In contrast to histoplasmomas, the organisms are viable, cultures are often positive, and the outcome is dismal unless antifungal therapy is initiated. As in needle biopsies, cryptococcosis can be diagnosed in transbronchial lung biopsies. Blastomycosis is less common than histoplasmosis or cryptococcosis (Figure 7, A through C). Masslike consolidation is a common radiologic finding (Figure 7, A). The tissue reaction features a mix of suppurative (abscess-like) and granulomatous inflammation, often in the form of granulomas with a suppurative center. (7) Large fungal yeasts with double-contoured cell walls, broad-based budding, and purple nuclear material can be seen on H&E within the suppurative areas as well as within histiocytes and multinucleated giant cells (Figure 7, B and C). As with core needle biopsies, transbronchial biopsies are very useful for sampling infections caused by Aspergillus and other fungal hyphae, the most clinically significant being invasive aspergillosis.

Noninfectious Lung Diseases With Granulomas

Sarcoidosis and hypersensitivity pneumonitis are common indications for transbronchial lung biopsy (Figure 8, A and B). When sarcoidosis is suspected clinically, the pulmonologist may elect to additionally perform transbronchial needle aspiration and endobronchial biopsies in addition to transbronchial biopsies. (18) The pathology of sarcoidosis in transbronchial biopsies is characterized by the presence of well-formed nonnecrotizing granulomas within the interstitium (Figure 8, A). When present, hyalinized fibrosis is an important clue to the diagnosis. Special staining for microorganisms (AFB and GMS) should be performed to exclude the possibility of mycobacterial or fungal infection. If these features are present in a patient with bilateral mediastinal adenopathy with or without bilateral lung nodules, our practice is to use the phrase "nonnecrotizing granulomas consistent with sarcoidosis." The following link shows a digitally scanned whole slide image of a transbronchial biopsy from a case of sarcoidosis where this phrase was used in the diagnostic line of the pathology report: (http://epubdepot. view.apml?X=0&Y=0&zoom=0.778400960162489; accessed February 2, 2018). However, in cases where granulomas are rare, necrosis is present, hyalinized fibrosis is absent, or granulomas are few or poorly formed, we prefer a descriptive diagnosis such as "nonnecrotizing granulomas" or "granulomatous inflammation with focal necrosis." The differential diagnosis in such cases includes mycobacterial or fungal infection, hypersensitivity pneumonitis, and hot tub lung. As shown in Figure 8, A, granulomas dominate the histologic picture in sarcoidosis. In contrast, hypersensitivity pneumonitis is characterized mainly by mild chronic inflammation within the interstitium, granulomas usually being few and difficult to find. In fact, isolated multinucleated giant cells are more common (Figure 8, B). Radiologic features on high-resolution CT can be helpful in corroborating the biopsy findings (see Table 2). Aspiration of particulate matter (mainly minute microscopic food particles) into the lung parenchyma can be accompanied by granulomas or giant cells, and is one of the most commonly missed nonneoplastic diagnoses in small lung biopsies. The key to the diagnosis is the recognition of food particles, which are often degenerated (Figure 9, A and B). (19) Unlike acute aspiration pneumonia that is commonly encountered at autopsy, food particles in biopsy specimens are seldom found within the lumens of bronchi or bronchioles. Instead, they are more commonly seen in the walls of bronchioles or in alveolar septa (interstitium) adjacent to small bronchioles (Figure 9, A). The inflammatory reaction is highly variable. With remote aspiration, an occasional multinucleated giant cell or a few histiocytes may be the only clues that the material is foreign. In more florid examples, there may be acute or organizing pneumonia with foreign-body giant cells, or severe chronic bronchiolitis (Figure 9, A). The differential diagnosis of granulomatous lesions that can be diagnosed by transbronchial biopsy also includes talc granulomatosis. This entity is caused by trapping of particles of "filler" material within alveolar septal capillaries and their subsequent seepage into the perivascular interstitium where they elicit a foreign-body giant cell response (Figure 10, A and B). These particles are usually derived from intravenous injection of crushed oral narcotic pills. (7) Although the term talc granulomatosis persists for historical reasons, the filler materials more commonly encountered nowadays are microcrystalline cellulose and crospovidone. The strong birefringence of the former is a helpful diagnostic feature and can be recognized in transbronchial biopsies.

Noninfectious Causes of Lung Masses

Entities other than granulomatous infections and organizing pneumonia can occasionally cause masslike consolidation, and transbronchial biopsies of these lesions may be diagnostic. A classic example is exogenous lipoid pneumonia, in which foamy macrophages with coarsely vacuolated cytoplasm accumulate within lung parenchyma. In some cases, the macrophages are more prominent within airspaces (Figure 11, A and B). In others, they extend into the alveolar septa and are associated with interstitial fibrosis. This entity commonly produces masslike lesions in the lower lobes, and is seen in individuals who aspirate oily liquids, the most common being laxatives for constipation. (20,21)

Drug Toxicity

Transbronchial lung biopsies can play a role in the diagnosis of pulmonary toxicity caused by certain drugs. With some drugs (such as chemotherapeutic agents), the temporal relationship between the offending drug and subsequent lung injury may be fairly obvious. In other cases, atypical or subtle inflammatory reactions may be encountered, and the attribution of such reactions to drug toxicity may be problematic. (22) Since pathologic findings are never pathognomonic of any type of drug toxicity, the determination that an inflammatory reaction is attributable to a drug depends on onset of radiologic abnormalities after initiation of drug therapy, exclusion of other etiologies (such as infection), and resolution of radiologic abnormalities following cessation of therapy with the suspected offending drug. In this analysis, transbronchial biopsies contribute by helping to exclude infection and in demonstrating an inflammatory response that could plausibly be linked to the drug in question. For example, amiodarone toxicity can be suspected in patients who are taking amiodarone and whose biopsies show intraalveolar foamy macrophages in combination with organizing pneumonia, diffuse alveolar damage, or cellular interstitial infiltrates. Transbronchial lung biopsies may also play a role in the diagnosis of methotrexate toxicity, nitrofurantoin-induced interstitial pneumonia, and eosinophilic pneumonia. The following Web site is a useful resource when drug-induced lung disease is suspected: (accessed February 22, 2018).

Airspace Diseases

Pulmonary alveolar proteinosis is the prototype of airspace diseases that can be sampled by transbronchial lung biopsy (Figure 12, A and B). The main pathologic finding is filling of airspaces by granular, eosinophilic proteinaceous material (Figure 12, A) containing "acicular spaces" and eosinophilic globules (Figure 12, B). The alveolar septa are normal in most cases. Another predominantly airspace process amenable to transbronchial biopsy is eosinophilic pneumonia (Figure 13, A and B). It is characterized by the presence of numerous eosinophils within the airspaces, usually accompanied by macrophages and/or fibrinous material (Figure 13, A). Although the disease is defined by airspace eosinophils, interstitial eosinophils are also increased in number and occasionally dominate the histologic picture (Figure 13, B).

Diagnosis of Acute Lung Injury and Idiopathic Interstitial Pneumonias by Transbronchial Lung Biopsy

Both major forms of acute lung injury--diffuse alveolar damage and organizing pneumonia--are commonly encountered in transbronchial lung biopsies. Diffuse alveolar damage (Figure 14, A and B) may be seen in the acute stage, where it manifests as hyaline membranes (Figure 14, A), or in the organizing stage, in which hyaline membranes are infrequent or absent. In the latter, the most prominent feature is diffuse interstitial expansion by fibroblasts in a pale-staining background (Figure 14, B).23 The etiology of acute lung injury patterns is seldom discernible on histologic grounds.

Perhaps the most controversial issue regarding transbronchial lung biopsies is whether they can be used to diagnose usual interstitial pneumonia (UIP). Although Berbescu et al (24) convincingly demonstrated in 2006 that features of UIP can be appreciated in these biopsies, the concept initially engendered much resistance. Subsequent studies by other investigators over the years have confirmed that UIP can be diagnosed in transbronchial biopsies, although the proportion of cases in which transbronchial biopsy findings can be considered diagnostic varies widely in these reports. (25-27) As in surgical lung biopsies, the diagnosis of UIP requires a "patchwork pattern" characterized by alternation of interstitial fibrosis, scarring, and microscopic honeycomb change with normal lung. (28) Fibroblast foci, when present, support the diagnosis. Unfortunately, it is uncommon to encounter a transbronchial lung biopsy that has sampled the entire constellation of findings required for a definitive diagnosis; one such case is illustrated in Figure 15, A and B.

The recent flurry of reports on transbronchial cryobiopsy has sparked renewed interest in the use of bronchoscopy for the diagnosis of UIP and other diffuse parenchymal lung diseases. (29-31) This technique is similar in some ways to conventional transbronchial biopsy, a key difference being that the size of lung tissue obtained is larger, which is made possible by freezing the target lung tissue for a few seconds before biopsy with the aid of a cryoprobe. The frozen tissue is then removed with the bronchoscope. In addition to being larger than conventional transbronchial biopsy fragments, the tissue obtained in this manner is less prone to artefactual collapse and is thus easier to interpret. On the flip side, occasional serious complications have been reported, and questions regarding diagnostic yield persist. The hope is that this procedure will result in an increased diagnostic yield, compared to conventional transbronchial biopsy, and a lower complication rate than for surgical lung biopsy. Whether this expectation will come to fruition, and the settings where the use of this technique offer the most benefit, remain open questions.

Finally, pathologists should be wary of diagnosing nonspecific interstitial pneumonia (NSIP), lymphoid interstitial pneumonia, respiratory bronchiolitis-interstitial lung disease, or so-called desquamative interstitial pneumonia in transbronchial lung biopsies. These diagnoses are not reliable in small specimens because they can either be overturned or superseded by other pathologic findings that have not been sampled, or require detailed knowledge of the distribution of abnormalities that cannot be provided by a transbronchial biopsy. In some respects, all of these entities are diagnoses of exclusion that require extensive sampling that can only be provided by a surgical lung biopsy. For example, a transbronchial biopsy diagnosis of NSIP is unreliable because NSIP-like areas are common in UIP. Therefore, a transbronchial biopsy diagnosis of NSIP can easily be overturned by finding areas diagnostic of UIP in a larger specimen.

Transbronchial Lung Biopsies in Patients With Lung Transplant

Although a detailed discussion of lung transplant-related pathology is beyond the scope of this review, it is worth noting that transbronchial biopsy is by far the most common pathologic sample used for the diagnosis of acute cellular rejection and obliterative bronchiolitis, since these patients are poor candidates for open lung biopsy.

What If No Specific Diagnosis Can Be Made in a Transbronchial Biopsy?

Our approach is to briefly state the pertinent findings and a few pertinent negatives. In most cases, we summarize the comment with a statement such as "the findings are nondiagnostic." If the clinician has included a specific question or differential diagnosis on the pathology requisition, an attempt should be made to address these in the pathology report.


Clinical information is important for transbronchial biopsy interpretation in many ways. Knowing whether a lung lesion is a nodule/mass or an infiltrate is one of the most basic pieces of information that should be provided to the pathologist on the requisition form. Although pathologists look for all types of abnormalities in each biopsy, the significance of the findings observed can vary depending on whether the lesion is an infiltrate or a mass. If the patient is immunocompromised, this information should always be provided to the pathologist. This will ensure that subtle signs of infection are not missed, and it might alter the threshold at which the pathologist requests special stains for microorganisms. Transbronchial biopsies are thought to have a higher yield in immunocompromised hosts. (32) As discussed above, some diagnoses (such as UIP) are very difficult to make in small biopsies. In such cases, knowledge of the radiologic findings is helpful. Pathologists are far more likely to make a diagnosis of UIP if the clinical setting is appropriate (73-year-old man with interstitial lung disease and basilar-predominant reticular opacities on high-resolution CT) than in highly improbable or discordant settings (23-year-old woman with pure ground-glass opacities). Occasionally, the presence of a highly suggestive clinical setting might justify some relaxation of pathologic criteria. For example, eosinophilic pneumonia is usually diagnosed when large numbers of eosinophils fill the airspaces. However, in a young individual with bilateral consolidation unresponsive to antibiotics, striking peripheral eosinophilia, and numerous eosinophils on BAL, one might be justified in diagnosing eosinophilic pneumonia even if eosinophils are located predominantly within the interstitium rather than airspaces. Prior therapy can alter the pathologic picture. For example, eosinophilic pneumonia can regress dramatically after corticosteroid therapy. Some diagnostic labels in nonneoplastic lung disease are defined in such a way that they require an element of clinical judgement to be added to the pathologic diagnosis. For example, organizing pneumonia is a pathologic diagnosis but "cryptogenic" organizing pneumonia is a label that only clinicians can apply, since they are given leeway to decide if a particular etiology is plausible. For example, a clinician may decide that organizing pneumonia in a patient taking amiodarone is related to the drug, or that UIP in a particular patient is related to nitrofurantoin. Clearly, knowledge of the clinical history is required to make these judgements. Therefore, labels such as cryptogenic organizing pneumonia or idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis do not typically fall within the purview of the pathologist.


We hope that these lists/menus will be helpful for pathologists (especially pathology trainees and pathologists who are new in practice) when interpreting core needle biopsies or transbronchial lung biopsies that do not contain malignant cells. Recognition of these entities in small lung biopsies can spare patients the cost, discomfort, and risk associated with additional invasive testing.


(1.) Kendall DM, Gal AA. Interpretation of tissue artifacts in transbronchial lung biopsy specimens. Ann Diagn Pathol. 2003;7(1):20-24.

(2.) Mukhopadhyay S. Non-Neoplastic Pulmonary Pathology: An Algorithmic Approach to Histologic Findings in the Lung. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press; 2016.

(3.) Doxtader EE, Mukhopadhyay S, Katzenstein A-LA. Incidence and significance of benign diagnoses on core needle biopsies of lung. Hum Pathol. 2010;41(11):1430-1535.

(4.) Aviram G, Grief J, Man A, et al. Diagnosis of intrathoracic lesions: are sequential fine-needle aspiration (FNA) and core needle biopsy (CNB) combined better than either investigation alone? Clin Radiol. 2007;62(3):221-226.

(5.) Mukhopadhyay S, Farver CF, Vaszar LT, et al. Causes of pulmonary granulomas: a retrospective study of 500 cases from seven countries. J Clin Pathol. 2012;65(1):51-57.

(6.) Jain D, Ghosh S, Teixeira L, Mukhopadhyay S. Pathology of pulmonary tuberculosis and non-tuberculous mycobacterial lung disease: facts, misconceptions, and practical tips for pathologists. Semin Diagn Pathol. 2017;34(6):518- 529.

(7.) Mukhopadhyay S, Gal AA. Granulomatous lung disease: an approach to the differential diagnosis. Arch Pathol Lab Med. 2010;134(5):667-690.

(8.) Mukhopadhyay S, Wilcox B, Myers JL, et al. Pulmonary necrotizing granulomas of unknown etiology: clinical and pathologic analysis of 131 patients with completely resected nodules. Chest. 2013;144(3):813-824.

(9.) Muldoon EG, Sharman A, Paige I, Bishop P, Denning DW. Aspergillus nodules: another presentation of chronic pulmonary aspergillosis. BMC Pulm Med. 2016;16(1):123.

(10.) Mukhopadhyay S, Doxtader EE. Visibility of Histoplasma within histiocytes on H&E distinguishes disseminated histoplasmosis from other forms of pulmonary histoplasmosis. Hum Pathol. 2013; 44(10):2346-2352.

(11.) Mukhopadhyay S. Utility of small biopsies for diagnosis of lung nodules: doing more with less. Mod Pathol. 2012;25(S1):S43-S57.

(12.) Mukhopadhyay S. Role of histology in the diagnosis of infectious causes of granulomatous lung disease. Curr Opin Pulm Med. 2011;17(3):189-196.

(13.) Mukhopadhyay S, Eckardt S, Scalzetti EM. Diagnosis of pulmonary Langerhans cell histiocytosis by CT-guided core biopsy of lung: a report of 3 cases. Thorax. 2010;65(9):833-835.

(14.) Leslie KO, Gruden JF, Parish JM, Scholand MB. Transbronchial biopsy interpretation in the patient with diffuse parenchymal lung disease. Arch Pathol Lab Med. 2007;131:407-423.

(15.) Aranda C, Sidhu G, Sasso LA, Adams FV. Transbronchial lung biopsy in the diagnosis of lymphangitic carcinomatosis. Cancer. 1978;42(4):1995-1998.

(16.) Inaty H, Artiles C, Garcha P, Yadav R, Mukhopadhyay S, Sahoo D. Diffuse large B-cell lymphoma presenting as diffuse bilateral ground glass opacities and diagnosed on transbronchial lung biopsy. Ann Am Thorac Soc. 2017;14(4):605-607.

(17.) El Ghoul R, Eckardt S, Mukhopadhyay S, Ashton R. Fever and dyspnea in a 61-year-old woman with metastatic breast cancer. Chest. 2009;136:634-638.

(18.) Muthu V, Gupta N, Dhooria, et al. A prospective, randomized, double-blind trailcomparing the diagnostic yield of 21- and 22-gauge aspiration needles for performing endobronchial ultrasound-guided transbronchial needle aspiration in sarcoidosis. Chest. 2016;149(4):1111-1113.

(19.) Mukhopadhyay S, Katzenstein A-LA. Pulmonary disease due to aspiration of food and other particulate matter: a clinicopathologic study of 59 cases diagnosed on biopsy or resection specimens. Am J Surg Pathol. 2007;31(5): 752-759.

(20.) Panchabhai TS, Mukhopadhyay S, Sehgal S, Bandyopadhyay D, Erzurum SC, Mehta AC. Plugs of the air passages: a clinicopathologic review. Chest. 2016; 150(5):1141-1157.

(21.) Kupeli E, Khemasuwan D, Tunsupon P, Mehta AC. "Pills" and the air passages: a continuum. Chest. 2015;147(1):242-250.

(22.) Sehgal S, Velcheti V, Mukhopadhyay S, Stoller JK. Focal lung infiltrate complicating PD-1 inhibitor use: a new pattern of drug-associated lung toxicity? Resp Med Case Rep. 2016;19:118-120.

(23.) Mukhopadhyay S, Parambil JG. Acute interstitial pneumonia (AIP): relationship to Hamman-Rich syndrome, diffuse alveolar damage (DAD) and acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS). Semin Respir Crit Care Med. 2012; 33(5):476-485.

(24.) Berbescu EA, Katzenstein AL, Snow JL, Zisman DA. Transbronchial biopsy in usual interstitial pneumonia. Chest. 2006;129(5):1126-1131.

(25.) Shim HS, Park MS, Park IK. Histopathologic findings of transbronchial biopsy in usual interstitial pneumonia. Pathol Int. 2010;60(5):373-377.

(26.) Tomassetti S, Cavazza A, Colby TV, et al. Transbronchial biopsy is useful in predicting UIP pattern. Respir Res. 2012;13:96.

(27.) Pankratz DG, Choi Y, Imtiaz U, et al. Usual interstitial pneumonia can be detected in transbronchialbiopsies using machine learning. Ann Am Thorac Soc. 2017;14(11):1646-1654.

(28.) Katzenstein A-LA, Mukhopadhyay S, MyersJL. Diagnosis of usual interstitial pneumonia and distinction from other fibrosing interstitial lung diseases. Hum Pathol. 2008;39(9):1275-1294.

(29.) Ussavarungsi K, Kern RM, Roden AC, et al. Transbronchial cryobiopsy in diffuse parenchymal lung disease: retrospective analysis of 74 cases. Chest. 2017; 151(2):400-408.

(30.) Casoni GL, Tomassetti S, Cavazza A, et al. Transbronchial lung biopsy in the diagnosis of fibrotic interstitial lung diseases. PLoS One. 2014;9(2):e86716.

(31.) Griff S, Ammenwerth W, Schonfeld N, et al. Morphometrical analysis of transbronchial cryobiopsies. Diagn Pathol. 2011;6:53.

(32.) Jain P, Sandur S, Meli Y, et al. Role of flexible bronchoscopy in immunocompromised patients with lung infiltrates. Chest. 2004;125(2):712- 722.

Sanjay Mukhopadhyay, MD; Atul C. Mehta, MD

Accepted for publication February 23, 2018.

From the Department of Pathology, Robert J. Tomsich Pathology and Laboratory Medicine Institute (Dr Mukhopadhyay) and the Department of Pulmonary Medicine, Respiratory Institute (Dr Mehta), Cleveland Clinic, Cleveland, Ohio.

The authors have no relevant financial interest in the products or companies described in this article.

The article is based on a presentation that was held at the 2017 Pulmonary Pathology Society Biennial Meeting; June 14, 2017; Chicago, Illinois.

Corresponding author: Sanjay Mukhopadhyay, MD, Department of Pathology, Cleveland Clinic, Robert J. Tomsich Pathology and Laboratory Medicine Institute, 9500 Euclid Ave/L25, Cleveland, OH 44195 (email:

Caption: Figure 1. Cryptococcosis in a core needle biopsy. The patient was receiving corticosteroids and methotrexate for sarcoidosis and was diagnosed with cryptococcal meningitis and a lung nodule. A, Fungal yeasts with light gray walls are visible on hematoxylin- eosin. Most are surrounded by a clear space (arrows). B, On a Grocott methenamine silver stain, marked size variation is characteristic (note size difference between yeasts indicated by long and short arrows) (original magnification X400 [A and B]).

Caption: Figure 2. Coccidioides spherules in core needle biopsy of a solitary lung mass from an elderly nonsmoker who spent his winters in Arizona. A, A spherical structure suggestive of a fungal organism (arrow) is visible within necrotic debris (arrowhead). B, The structure is a spherule containing endospores, diagnostic of Coccidioides. Cultures were positive for Coccidioides organisms (hematoxylin-eosin, original magnifications X20 [A] and X1000/oil immersion objective [B]).

Caption: Figure 3. Organizing pneumonia in a core needle biopsy. A, Fibroblast plugs follow the contours of the airspaces as they move from one alveolar lumen to the next (arrows). The clustered arrangement of the plugs helps to differentiate them from fibroblast foci. Branching and serpiginous shapes are typical (arrowhead indicates a branch point). B, At high magnification, fibroblast plugs can be mistaken for fibroblast foci, the latter being a feature of usual interstitial pneumonia. The presence of a small artery (arrowhead) in close proximity to a fibroblast plug is a tip-off to the correct diagnosis, since it indicates that the plug is within a respiratory bronchiole or alveolar duct (hematoxylin-eosin, original magnifications X20 [A] and X400 [B]).

Caption: Figure 4. Pulmonary Langerhans cell histiocytosis diagnosed by core needle biopsy of the lung. A, Chest computed tomogram shows multiple tiny bilateral millimeter-sized nodules. B, Computed tomography-guided core needle biopsy of one of the nodules shows a cellular infiltrate rich in eosinophils. C, At high magnification, one can appreciate sheets of Langerhans cells (arrows) (hematoxylin-eosin, original magnifications X20 [B] and X400 [C]).

Caption: Figure 5. Nontuberculous mycobacterial infection in a transbronchial lung biopsy. The patient was an elderly woman who presented with cough. Mycobacterium avium complex was isolated on cultures from a sputum sample and 2 bronchial washings and confirmed by sequence identification. A, Chest computed tomogram shows bronchiectasis (short arrow) and a cavitary mass (long arrow) in the left lower lobe. B, Transbronchial biopsy shows severe chronic inflammation in the bronchial mucosa containing a few scattered multinucleated giant cells (arrows). C, Nonnecrotizing granuloma from the same biopsy. Note Langhans-type giant cell (arrow) (hematoxylin-eosin, original magnifications X100 [B] and X400 [C]).

Caption: Figure 6. Disseminated histoplasmosis in a transbronchial biopsy from a renal transplant recipient with bilateral ground-glass opacities. A, Very poorly formed granulomas are present within airspaces (long arrows). Organisms are only faintly visible at this magnification as tiny dots (short arrow). B, Under oil immersion, Histoplasma yeasts are visible within enlarged histiocytes on hematoxylin-eosin (arrows). Note eccentric chromatin dot in each yeast. Cultures were preliminarily reported as growing Histoplasma capsulatum 7 days after the biopsy diagnosis; final confirmation of culture results was obtained 2 weeks after the biopsy diagnosis (hematoxylin-eosin, original magnifications X200 [A] and X1000/oil immersion [B]).

Caption: Figure 7. Blastomycosis in a transbronchial lung biopsy from a young man who was receiving infliximab for presumed sarcoidosis. A, Chest computed tomogram shows a large cavitary mass in the left upper lobe (arrow). B, Transbronchial biopsy shows fungal yeasts in a background of granulomatous inflammation (arrows). C, At high magnification, features diagnostic of Blastomyces become appreciable. Note broad-based bud (black arrow), purple nuclear material (arrowhead), and "double-contoured" cell wall (white arrow). There is considerable acute inflammation in the background. In the microbiology laboratory, the direct fungal examination showed spherical structures that were initially thought to be suggestive of endospores of Coccidioides. Blastomyces dermatitidis was subsequently isolated in cultures of bronchial washings, bronchoalveolar lavage, and transbronchial biopsy and confirmed by DNA gene probe (hematoxylin-eosin, original magnifications X200 [B] and X600 [C]).

Caption: Figure 8. Sarcoidosis versus hypersensitivity pneumonitis in transbronchial biopsies. A, Interstitial granuloma in sarcoidosis (arrow). The granuloma is well formed and relatively large. It is surrounded by hyalinized fibrosis (arrowhead). B, Interstitial multinucleated giant cell in hypersensitivity pneumonitis (arrowhead). The giant cell contains a nonspecific endogenous inclusion (cholesterol cleft) and is present in a background of interstitial chronic inflammation composed mainly of lymphocytes. Note that the lymphocytic infiltrate is slightly accentuated near a bronchiole (short arrow) and tapers off away from the bronchiole (long arrow) (hematoxylin-eosin, original magnification X200 [A and B]).

Caption: Figure 9. Particulate matter aspiration on transbronchial biopsy. The patient had a history of multiple strokes, chronic aspiration, and nodular ground-glass opacities. A, There is severe chronic inflammation around a bronchiole (arrow). Several eosinophilic particles are identifiable in the adjacent interstitium (arrowheads). B, One of the particles at high magnification. This is a severely degenerated food particle (hematoxylin-eosin, original magnifications X40 [A] and X200 [B]).

Caption: Figure 10. Talc granulomatosis. A, Tiny nodules expand the alveolar septa. Foreign material is visible within the nodules even at this low magnification. B, At high magnification, microcrystalline cellulose particles are identifiable within the interstitium (short arrow), surrounded by multinucleated giant cells (long arrow) and foamy macrophages. As seen here, most of the particulate matter in talc granulomatosis is found in perivascular interstitium rather than within blood vessels (hematoxylin- eosin, original magnifications X40 [A] and X400 [B]).

Caption: Figure 11. Exogenous lipoid pneumonia in a transbronchial lung biopsy. A, Low magnification, showing an airspace-filling process. B, This alveolus is filled with foamy macrophages containing coarse vacuoles of varying sizes (arrow) (hematoxylin-eosin, original magnifications X20 [A] and X200 [B]).

Caption: Figure 12. Pulmonary alveolar proteinosis in a transbronchial lung biopsy. A, At low magnification, this fragment of alveolated lung shows filling of airspaces by eosinophilic material. B, The intra-alveolar material is coarsely granular and contains cholesterol cleft-like "acicular spaces" (arrow) and eosinophilic globules (arrowheads), both of which are diagnostically useful features (hematoxylin-eosin, original magnifications X20 [A] and X200 [B]).

Caption: Figure 13. Two examples of eosinophilic pneumonia in transbronchial biopsies. A, Numerous eosinophils are seen within airspaces. Note admixed macrophages. B, In this example, eosinophils are present within airspaces (arrow) but interstitial involvement is more striking (arrowheads) (hematoxylin-eosin, original magnifications X400 [A] and X200 [B]).

Caption: Figure 14. Diffuse alveolar damage in a transbronchial biopsy from a lung transplant recipient. A, Hyaline membranes are the hallmark of the acute phase. B, Organizing phase of diffuse alveolar damage from the same biopsy. Hyaline membranes are absent. The interstitium is expanded by fibroblasts in a pale background (hematoxylin-eosin, original magnifications X100 [A] and X200 [B]).

Caption: Figure 15. Usual interstitial pneumonia on transbronchial biopsy. A, A patchwork pattern is appreciable at low magnification. It is characterized by alternation of interstitial fibrosis (white arrow), architectural distortion, and microscopic honeycomb change (long black arrow) with normal lung (arrowhead). Fibroblast foci are present (short black arrow) in addition to collagen deposition. B, Another fragment from the same biopsy shows interstitial fibrosis with fibroblast foci (arrows) adjacent to normal lung (arrowheads) hematoxylin-eosin, original magnification X20 [A and B]).
Table 1. Nonneoplastic Diagnoses That Can Be
Made in Core Needle Biopsies of Lung Nodules/
Masses (a)

Diagnostic Category                     Diagnosis

Granulomas caused by        Tuberculosis and nontuberculous
  infection (mostly           mycobacterial infections
  necrotizing granulomas)   Aspergillosis
Granulomatous               Sarcoidosis
  inflammation,             Particulate matter aspiration
  noninfectious             Granulomatosis with polyangiitis
Scars                       Apical cap
                            Radiation-related scar
Others                      Organizing pneumonia
                            Intrapulmonary lymph node
                            Acute bronchopneumonia and
                            Pulmonary Langerhans cell
                            Nodular amyloidosis
                            Light chain deposition disease
                            Pulmonary hyalinizing granuloma

(a) Data derived from Mukhopadhyay (2) and Doxtader et al. (3)

Table 2. Transbronchial Lung Biopsies: Menu of Nonneoplastic
Diagnoses, With Key Pathologic Findings and Clinical Notes (a)

Diagnosis                   Key Pathologic Findings and Clinical Notes

Mycobacterial infections    Granulomatous inflammation, necrosis
                            Acid-fast bacteria
                            Clinical notes: highly variable clinical
                              presentation. Cultures are required for
                              confirmation of type of mycobacterium

Fungal infections           Granulomatous inflammation and/or necrosis
                              in most cases
                            Fungi: Pneumocystis, Aspergillus,
                              Histoplasma, Cryptococcus, Blastomyces,
                              Coccidioides, Nocardia
                            Clinical notes: most of these infections
                              can occur in immunocompetent
                              individuals, and many can manifest as
                              lung nodules that mimic lung cancer

Viral infections            Cytomegalovirus, adenovirus, herpes,
                            Clinical notes: variable presentation

Sarcoidosis                 Well-formed nonnecrotizing granulomas in
                            Hyalinized fibrosis
                            Lung away from granulomas is normal
                            Clinical notes: bilateral hilar/
                              mediastinal lymphadenopathy and/or
                              bilateral tiny lung nodules

Hypersensitivity            Lymphocytic infiltrate within interstitium
pneumonitis                   and airway walls, occasional
                              multinucleated giant cells or loose
                              clusters of histiocytes
                            Clinical notes: bilateral ground-glass
                              opacities with air-trapping and mosaic
                              attenuation. Typically occurs in never-
                              smokers. Look for history of exposure to

Particulate matter          Most common particulate matter: food or
aspiration                    vegetable particles (intact or
                              degenerating);much less common: pill
                            Usual tissue reaction: multinucleated
                              giant cells or histiocytes around or
                              near aspirated particles. Other tissue
                              reactions: acute or organizing
                              pneumonia, acute or chronic inflammation
                              in bronchiolar walls

                            Clinical notes: often not suspected
                              clinically. Can present as nodules or
                              infiltrates, and can occur in any lobe.
                              Look for history of recurrent pneumonia,
                              and predisposing factors (esophageal/
                              gastric abnormalities or surgery,
                              narcotics or drugs of abuse, neurologic

Talc granulomatosis         Filler materials (microcrystalline
(foreign body granulomas      cellulose, crospovidone or talc) within
in interstitium, caused       perivascular interstitium (alveolar
by intravenous injection      septa), with adjacent foreign-body giant
of crushed oral pills)        cell reaction
                            Clinical notes: chronic use of opiates for
                              chronic pain, venous access, multiple
                              episodes of care at different hospitals

Pulmonary Langerhans cell   Stellate interstitial nodules containing
histiocytosis                 sheets of Langerhans cells;these lesions
                              often also contain pigmented (smoker's)
                              macrophages, eosinophils, or lymphocytes
                            Smoker's macrophages within airspaces in
                              background lung
                            Clinical notes: essentially all adults
                              with this disease are smokers. Most
                              cases that are biopsied have multiple
                              bilateral millimeter-sized nodules
                              clinically suggestive of metastatic
                              tumor or miliary infection. Cases with
                              nodules plus cysts on HRCT can be
                              suspected or diagnosed by radiologists

Pulmonary alveolar          Granular eosinophilic material within
proteinosis                   airspaces
                            Clinical notes: "Crazy-paving" pattern on
                              high resolution chest CT is classic;
                              imaging appears worse than clinical

Eosinophilic pneumonia      Eosinophils within airspaces (usually
                              mixed with histiocytes and/or fibrinous
                            Very common to also find numerous
                              eosinophils within the interstitium and
                              around small blood vessels
                            Clinical notes: classic setting is
                              eosinophilia in peripheral blood and
                              peripheral lung infiltrates in young
                              asthmatic individuals

Organizing pneumonia        Fibroblast plugs within airspaces
                            Clues to differentiate from fibroblast
                              foci: fibroblast plugs are clustered,
                              serpiginous or branching, admixed with
                              inflammatory cells, located adjacent to
                              small artery
                            Clinical notes: often presents as
                              "nonresolving pneumonia," can manifest
                              radiologically as infiltrate(s),
                              opacity, nodule(s), or masslike

Diffuse alveolar damage     Hyaline membranes and/or diffuse alveolar
                              septal fibroblast proliferation
                            Clinical notes: often, but not always,
                              associated with acute respiratory
                              failure. Radiologic picture is often
                              misinterpreted as "pulmonary edema."
                              Cause is seldom evident from pathologic

Usual interstitial          Interstitial fibrosis in a "patchwork
pneumonia                     pattern," fibroblast foci, scarring,
                              honeycomb change
                            Typical clinical and radiologic context:
                              elderly individual, bilateral
                              basilar-predominant, peripheral
                              predominant reticular infiltrates.
                              Honeycombing may be too small to see on
                              high-resolution chest CT in significant
                              proportion of cases

Respiratory bronchiolitis   Lightly pigmented macrophages within the
                            The pigment is fine, light brown, and
                              contains a few black specks
                            Can be accompanied by emphysema or
                              interstitial ropy collagen
                              (smoking-related interstitial fibrosis)
                            Clinical notes: patient almost always is
                              or was a smoker

Drug-related lung disease   Diffuse alveolar damage, organizing
                              pneumonia, increased eosinophils,
                              cellular chronic interstitial pneumonia
                              History of drug therapy prior to
                              radiologic abnormalities No other
                              obvious cause for pathologic findings

Alveolar hemorrhage         Hemosiderin-laden macrophages (heart
                              failure or capillaritis)
                            Clinical notes: bilateral ground-glass
                              opacities. Hemoptysis and fulminant
                              course in GPA or Goodpasture syndrome.
                              Serology for ANCA and anti-GBM
                              antibodies very helpful

Chronic bronchiolitis       Inflammation in bronchiolar or bronchial
                            Clinical notes: tree-in-bud
                              opacities. Viral, bacterial, and
                              mycobacterial infections, or particulate
                              matter aspiration, are common causes

Acute bronchopneumonia      Acute inflammatory exudate (neutrophils,
                              fibrin, debris) within alveoli
                            Clinical notes: usually presents as

Lymphangioleiomyomatosis    Cysts with scattered abnormal smooth
                              muscle bundles in their wall
                            Immunostains for HMB-45 (often very weak
                              and focal) and cathepsin K can be very
                            Clinical notes: think of this diagnosis
                              when a woman presents with pneumothorax

Metastatic calcification    Diffuse calcification within alveolar
                              septa; no obvious underlying cause
                            Clinical notes: most common setting is
                              chronic renal failure

Acute cellular rejection    Exquisitely perivascular lymphoid
                              infiltrates in lung transplant biopsies
                            Clinical notes: clinical diagnosis of this
                              entity is very difficult

Chronic allograft           Significant narrowing of bronchiolar lumen
rejection (constrictive       by extrinsic fibrosis, or complete
bronchiolitis)                obliteration of bronchiolar lumen by
                              fibrous scar
                            Clinical notes: the usual clinical setting
                              is a persistent decline in the
                              [FEV.sub.1] occurring at least a year
                              after lung transplant. Incidence
                              increases to 50% at 5 years and 75% at
                              10 years after transplant

Abbreviations: ANCA: anti-neutrophil cytoplasmic antibody; CT,
computed tomography; [FEV.sub.1], forced expiratory volume in 1
second; GBM, glomerular basement membrane; GPA, granulomatosis with
polyangiitis; HRCT, high-resolution chest tomogram.

(a) Data derived from Mukhopadhyay. (2)

Table 3. Sample Pathology Reports on Core Needle Biopsies of Lung
and Transbronchial Lung Biopsies (a)

                  Clinical History
Biopsy Type and      Provided on
Diagnosis Type       Requisition        Diagnosis ("line diagnosis")

Core needle       Neurosarcoidosis,   Lung, right upper lobe, needle
biopsy,           concern for         biopsy--necrotizing
specific          Cryptococcus        granulomatous inflammation
diagnosis         infection           (numerous Cryptococcus
                                      yeasts present). (See comment).

Core needle       Lung nodule         Lung, right lower lobe, needle
biopsy,                               biopsy--fragments of alveolated
nondiagnostic                         lung and pleura with no
                                      significant pathologic changes.
                                      (See comment).

Transbronchial    Pulmonary           Lung, right upper lobe,
biopsy,           infiltrate          transbronchial biopsy--
specific                              nonnecrotizing granulomas
diagnosis                             consistent with sarcoidosis.
                                      (See comment).

Transbronchial    Infiltrate          Lung, right upper lobe,
biopsy,                               transbronchial biopsy--
nonspecific or                        minimal chronic
nondiagnostic                         inflammation. (See comment).

Biopsy Type and
Diagnosis Type                         Comment

Core needle       Sections show necrotizing granulomatous
biopsy,           inflammation with numerous Cryptococcus yeasts
specific          within the necrosis as well as in the
diagnosis         granulomatous infiltrate. The organisms are
                  visible on hematoxylin-eosin. Special stains will
                  be reported in an addendum. The findings were
                  discussed with Dr X on January 16, 2016.

                  Addendum: A Grocott methenamine silver stain
                  confirms the presence of numerous fungal yeasts,
                  supporting the diagnosis. Mucicarmine shows very
                  weak staining in occasional yeasts;the majority of
                  organisms are negative. A Ziehl-Neelsen stain for
                  mycobacteria is negative. The original diagnosis
Core needle       remains unchanged. This biopsy consists of tiny
biopsy,           fragments of alveolated lung and minute strips of
nondiagnostic     mesothelium-lined pleura. No granulomas or
                  malignant cells are identified. The findings are

Transbronchial    This biopsy consists of 5 fragments of alveolated
biopsy,           lung parenchyma and 3 of bronchial wall. There are
specific          multiple nonnecrotizing granulomas within the
diagnosis         bronchial wall and alveolar septa. The granulomas
                  are well formed and associated with hyalinized
                  fibrosis. Lung parenchyma away from the granulomas
                  is normal. Special stains for microorganisms (AFB
                  and GMS) are negative. The findings are consistent
                  with sarcoidosis.

Transbronchial    This biopsy consists of 3 fragments of alveolated
biopsy,           lung parenchyma. There are a few lymphocytes in
nonspecific or    the bronchial mucosa. No granulomas or malignant
nondiagnostic     cells are identified. The findings are

Abbreviations: AFB, acid-fast bacteria; GMS, Grocott methenamine

(a) These are examples of actual pathology reports signed out by one
of the authors. Exact phrasing varies from case to case depending on
the pathologic findings as well as the clinical setting. There are
many other valid and clinically valuable ways to phrase both the
diagnosis and the comment.
COPYRIGHT 2018 College of American Pathologists
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2018 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Title Annotation:Special Section--2017 (10th Biennial) Meeting of the Pulmonary Pathology Society, Part II
Author:Mukhopadhyay, Sanjay; Mehta, Atul C.
Publication:Archives of Pathology & Laboratory Medicine
Article Type:Report
Date:Sep 1, 2018
Previous Article:Fast Track to Accreditation: An Implementation Review of College of American Pathologists and International Organization for Standardization 15189...
Next Article:Update on Rare Idiopathic Interstitial Pneumonias and Rare Histologic Patterns.

Terms of use | Privacy policy | Copyright © 2019 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters