Upgrading to WAAS: only a few options exist; a WAAS buy-in adds real mission capability and workload reduction. but walk-away costs vary wildly with glass cockpits taking the biggest hit.
Today's IFR GPS installations are all about the augmented WAAS signal that's worthy of sole-means navigation. They're still a source of confusion and expense, but WAAS installations yield impressive automation and capability. Before you decide if WAAS is for you, you need to understand some behind-the-scenes facts and why you could be disadvantaged without WAAS GPS in your aircraft.
IT'S ABOUT SIGNAL QUALITY
WAAS and precision-GPS equipment, procedures and regulations are covered in TSO C146a. The technical and operational benefits of a WAAS interface are many, and the new WAAS GPS engines, processors and software are reliable and highly accurate. WAAS not only enhances GPS accuracy but also corrects the errors in GPS signals caused by ionospheric effects.
WAAS provides less than 1.5-meter horizontal accuracy and 3-meter vertical accuracy. Class 3 WAAS sensor capability means no other navigational gear is required. If this sounds like putting all the eggs in a single basket, it is. These owners are relying completely on quality installations.
Operational WAAS also doesn't require user to check RAIM--receiver autonomous integrity monitoring--which was an early GPS system for alerting a pilot if the GPS signal quality had gotten too poor for navigational use. All WAAS GPSs use Fault Detection and Exclusion (FDE), which detects satellite failure and ignores the failed satellites. This ultimately affects the signal integrity and performance of the unit, and may mean the box will only offer you an LNAV approach with no vertical guidance rather than the LPV you were hoping for. That's because the boxes are smart enough to "downgrade" a WAAS GPS approach back to a basic non-precision GPS approach 60 seconds prior to reaching the FAR This possibility is why the FAA is so particular of the placement of mode annunciation that alerts the pilot to GPS messages.
If a WAAS outage is predicted and NOTAM'd, then you should use the FDE program in the Garmin desktop simulators, the on-board RAIM prediction of the GPS itself, or using tools such as www.raimprediciton.net to see if you'll have adequate GPS signal at your destination at your planned arrival time. We've found that downgrades do happen, but not often and WAAS outages are a truly rare event.
On the flip side, WAAS GPS receivers can be sensitive to stray RF noise. Strobe noise, com radio interference, pulse noise and cell phones are a few enemies. We recall a certain Cessna Skyhawk with a WAAS unit that would lose satellite reception when flying in wet clouds. Seems the location of the antenna--directly aft of the windscreen--was being affected by precipitation static. Moving the antenna back another foot solved the problem. Garmin engineers admit that WAAS for small airplanes can cause some challenges given the close quarters of installed antennasand other systems.
What were once called GPS approaches are being renamed RNAV approaches, with the non-precision GPS approach mini-mums called LNAV (lateral guidance). The addition of WAAS means the unit can display a glidepath the way you'd expect with an ILS approach. These come in two official flavors: the LNAV/VNAV and the LPV. Without getting into the details, both function the same way from a pilot's perspective--you fly them to a decision altitude (DA) just like an ILS--but the LPV will let you fly to lower minimums if your GPS offers it. A properly interfaced WAAS panel-mount navigator can fly all of these procedures.
Garmin has also added "advisory guidance" to many LNAV approaches that they annunciate LNAV+V. This causes some confusion as it's really just a path you can follow to a reasonable visual descent point, but the approach is still technically a non-precision approach with an MDA, not a DA. The FAA has an entire section dedicated to WAAS procedures in AIM section 1-1-20. It's a must read for existing owners and for those contemplating WAAS GPS upgrades.
If you've flown RNAV approaches you'll know that the signal quality and resultant needle action is far more stable than a traditional ILS approach. There's no scalloping that can cause grief with a coupled autopilot, glideslope oscillation as you get close to the pavement. Given our choice between flying an ILS or an LPV to the same runway, the choice is a no-brainer.
THE GARMIN STANDARD
It's no secret that Garmin owns the GPS market with two of the most popular panel units ever made: the GNS 400W- and 500W-series navigators. These are WAAS-equipped right out of the box. The G1000 integrated suite has LRU GPS systems that are essentially remote GNS units. Early G1000s were not WAAS capable and upgrading them will empty the wallet. More on that later.
The first panel navigator with WAAS was the CNX80/GNS480 series, but Garmin pulled the plug on them after they bought UPS-AX Remaining units on the used market are capable but orphaned machines. Garmin-AT still supports these systems with open arms, but we would have to think long and hard about dropping our coin on one at this stage.
Honeywell's KLN94 standalone color GPS doesn't have a WAAS engine and it probably never will. You can still purchase a Garmin GPS155XL and corn-equipped GNC300XL. They can't be upgraded to WAAS either, and adding the accessories and parts to satisfy the old C129 (Al) standard will drive the price up to a questionable level.
There are plenty of used GNS430 and 530 units on the used market that can be upgraded to WAAS. Garmin does the upgrade for $2995, plus $800 if the trip to the factory reveals any discrepancies that need to be fixed. If an upgrade is your game plan, we say don't pay more than four grand for the used GPS to start. Remember, you'll still need to buy an appropriate navigational indicator. In some applications, you'll need other pricey accessories that can easily snowball an otherwise routine although complex installation.
Since WAAS GPS outputs lateral, vertical and nav flag data you'll need a navigational indicator. There are several indicator options here. Garmin's GI106A (made by Mid Continent Instruments) is the stand-alone indicator for displaying the data, as well as analogue VOR/LOC/glide-slope information which is switched internally by the navigator.
Bendix/King has the KI209A that can work with Garmin navigators and most HSI systems will work, too. Of course, you can go all out and display the WAAS data on an Aspen PFD, Garmin G500/600 PFD, Sandel EHSI or other EFIS display. If you have an older Bendix/King EFIS 40, the software can be upgraded to properly play the GPS glidepath data. The trip to Honeywell will cost a few thousand.
Nearly any autopilot that couples to a traditional ILS signal can fly a GPS glidepath. Diligence is critical when wiring this interface, however, because changes to autopilot wiring modification of the autopilot computer may be needed. Some inexperienced shops have turned out upgrades where autopilots won't fly the GPS glidepath.
Some autopilots aren't fully capable. S-TEC's popular System 30 and 50-series systems can't fly any glideslope, ILS or GPS. They will accept roll steering commands with the ST-901 GPSS steering system, and in our view this is a worthy option as it greatly improves autopilot tracking ability, and adds the ability to anticipate turns and fly procedure turns and holds. For non-S-TEC autopilots there are generic roll steering systems made by Icarus and DAC International. External roll steering add-ons can add several thousand dollars to an installation and won't be included in a bid for a basic installation.
Aspen's EFD1000Pro or Garmin G500/600-series PFDs have integral GPS roll steering activated with a push of a button. In this case, the concern is more how well the PFD itself plays with your autopilot.
Pilots are growing accustomed to this hands-crossed approach automation. It's important to discuss the autopilot interface with the installing shop so you understand what capabilities you will or will not have, after all the wires are crimped.
A FEW OTHER DETAILS
While your non-WAAS Garmin is taking its $2995 factory vacation, the avionics shop will replace the legacy GA56 GPS antenna with a new WAAS antenna that sports the same mounting holes but has a wider footprint. Accessing this antenna can be easy or it can be bloody hell, depending on the design of the headliner and overhead. Single-piece headliners like those found in many Beechcraft models could be the worst since they're susceptible to sagging after removal and reinstallation.
Any old, single-shielded coaxial cabling must be replaced with twin-shielded, low-loss cable. Owners underestimate this task and are often shocked by the labor price.
A remote mode annunciation might be required if the GPS is too far from the pilot's field of view. The shop will need to access the unit's main connector to wire lamps which could mean sizeable teardown and associated expense.
The paperwork and final testing chase shouldn't be underestimated as it's billable time. The existing GNS Flight Manual Supplement is replaced with an updated version, and final testing includes an evaluation flight. If the aircraft is on the AML for the installed system and there were no deviations to the criteria stated, there should be no need for an FAA field approval.
DOLLARS AND NONSENSE
While the lucky might escape a complete WAAS upgrade for under $4000, expect a non-glass cockpit project to be at least $5000 including the cost of the box upgrade. No matter what, be sure the shop offers an accurate proposal after they evaluate the existing installation.
The step up to WAAS in a glass cockpit has been a controversial and heated topic for owners because the costs are shocking. Garmin and Hawker Beechcraft offer an upgrade path for non-WAAS G1000 G58 Baron and G36 Bonanza aircraft. Each GIA63W LRU for the suite is $11,495 and Garmin offers a $1750 credit for the legacy GIA63 that's removed. There's also the GDU1045 MFD that's exchanged for $11,595 minus $1000 credit for the old MFD. That's just north of $30,000 in parts before a technician even picks up a screwdriver. Cessna's Service Bulletin SB07-34-07 lists the GPS/ WAAS modification kit for upgrade at $18,295 for single-engine G1000 models. Manpower is listed at approximately 11.5 hours.
Any Avidyne/Garmin-equipped Cirrus aircraft not equipped with WAAS will need the standard GNS factory upgrade, but some will need extra antenna work performed by Cirrus service centers. Depending on the software level of the Avidyne Entegra displays, factory software upgrades will be required. We're talking thousands here, too. While it's hard to imagine such capable glass-cockpit aircraft without WAAS the upgrade pricing is staggering to say the least.
Summarizing these findings is easy: If you want WAAS, there aren't that many options and all cost some real coin. For new installations, Garmin's 400W and 500W units set the standard. A new installation of a 430W starts at around $12K while a 530W demands around $15K. Upgrading an existing Garmin shaves some thousands. But these units still won't show airways or high-resolution weather. For airplanes that haven't seen a radio upgrade in years the 430W is a good value, in our view.
You could buy Bendix/King's KLN94 but we're getting vibes that this is a dead-end product without any WAAS potential. The same could be said for Garmin's GPS155XL and 300XL. The long-promised Hon eywell KSN770 NMS system will have WAAS and could threaten the Garmin navigator monopoly, but it could be another year before we see it. A lot can happen in a year. We'll keep you posted.
RELATED ARTICLE: UPGRADE TO WAAS AND ADS-B?
Since ADS-B is on the horizon, you may wonder how to best leverage a WAAS upgrade to comply with the ADS-B mandate. We have no idea.
Actually, that's not entirely true. The final rule on ADS-B compliance will not appear for another month or so and we'd hold off on any upgrade until then to be sure, but it's pretty clear that basic compliance can be done with a WAAS GPS and the Garmin GTX 330ES transponder.
The GTX 330ES has ADS-B output but gets its position data from a WAAS GPS, such as the 400W, 500W or GNS 480. Garmin says legacy non-WAAS GPS systems won't cut it because WAAS is required in the ADS-B mix due to requirements in vertical accuracy and overall integrity. The connection is via an RS-232 serial bus and GNS software version 3.30. The software upgrade is available in the field at no cost to owners. If you already have a GTX 330 and legacy GNS product you'll need to upgrade both units for ADS-B output.
As we've said before, the rub is that this is ADS-B out, but you won't get any ADS-B in--you won't see any traffic targets or get free weather data. The Gar-min-AT GDL90 Universal Access transceiver (UAT) has been available for years and will give you both. It has a built-in WAAS GPS, but you can't use that GPS for navigation and you'll need an MFD or compatible GPS screen to display the data. The GDI 90 will also run you about $7000 plus installation.
Garmin's new GTS 800-series TAS/ADS-B combination traffic system (see November 2009 Aviation Consumer) show both active traffic and ADS-B traffic if paired with the GTX 330ES. The entry-level GTS 800 is $9995 plus installation. As with the GDL 90, you'll need a display to show the traffic as well. As we go to press, the GTS 800 lacks the software needed to display ADS-B targets in true ADS-B symbology. It still processes ADS-B traffic but the symbology is from the active traffic side of the house. More capability and enabling software should be available in the coming months. Avidyne has announced an ADS-B upgrade to their TAS600 traffic system, too. Note that non-WAAS GNS units will work fine with the GTS 800 for active traffic, but that won't help your ADS-B compliance.
So a GTX 330ES factory upgrade for $1900 and a WAAS upgrade for $2995 (plus labor to change the antenna) is the least expensive step into the ADS-B world. But to see ADS-B targets, you'll need the GTS 800 system or a GDL 90 UAT.
While the ADS-B discussion is certainly turning heads, the continuing uncertainty and costs are turning some of those heads the other way. Perhaps some avionics manufacturer will seize this opportunity to offer a one-box solution that sweetens the upgrade to WAAS by offering full ADS-B built in.
(+) For IFR aircraft, the operational benefits are plentiful and growing.
(+) WAAS boosts autopilot capability to an impressive level.
(-) The installation is pricey and complex for traditional gauges, and can be prohibitively high for glass panels.
|Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback|
|Title Annotation:||AIRCRAFT UPGRADES; Wide Area Augmentation System|
|Publication:||The Aviation Consumer|
|Date:||Mar 1, 2010|
|Previous Article:||Avgas replacement: chicken, meet egg: GAMI'S new G100UL may be a drop-in replacement for 100 LL. the challenge will be devising a test program to...|
|Next Article:||Engine shop survey: zephyr gets top marks: Penn Yan, Poplar Grove, and RAM also saw customer accolades. good communication and responsiveness clearly...|