Printer Friendly

The Tudor Queens of England.

The Tudor Queens of England

David Loades

Continuum 264pp 25 [pounds sterling]

ISBN 978 1847250193


One of the more remarkable features of 16th-century royal history is the large number or women rulers, consorts or regents who, at various times and in different places, held the fate of nations in their hands. It is remarkable because the received wisdom at the time was that it was against the divinely ordained scheme of things for a woman to hold the reins of power. Yet this prejudice faltered when major European royal dynasties were forced to rely on women for their survival.

Mary of Guise and Mary Stuart in Scotland, Catherine de Medici in France, Isabella of Castille, first joint ruler of a united Spain, Margaret, Duchess of Savoy and Margaret, Duchess of Parma, both of whom ruled the Spanish Netherlands in the Habsburg interest, were all vital to their respective families. And, of course, in England the Tudor dynasty was kept alive for exactly half a century by Mary and Elizabeth. There is certainly a rich vein of material to be quarried here by any scholars wanting to write about not only the political history of the period but also complex attitudes to gender.

Professor Loades' book offers a way in to this multi-layered subject, though the title is strangely misleading. Loades begins his account with Catherine de Valois, who became Henry V's queen in 1420, and he then moves on to tell the stories of Margaret of Anjou, Henry VI's queen, Elizabeth Woodville, consort to Edward IV, and Elizabeth of York, who can only be regarded as a 'Tudor' queen because she married Henry VII. Henry VIII's wives and daughters duly make their appearances but interspersed with them are Jane Grey and Mary Stuart. In all, Loades chronicles the lives of 14 royal ladies, only eight of whom actually qualify as 'Tudor'.

The scheme of the book is both chronological and thematic. Thus, while spinning a continuous thread from Catherine de Valois to Elizabeth I, the author also presents a typology. Margaret of Anjou is characterised as a 'dominatrix' and Elizabeth Woodville as a 'lover'. Some are grouped: Anne Boleyn, Jane Seymour and Catherine Parr are the 'Domestic Queens' and Jane Grey and Mary Stuart, the 'Queens who Never Were'.

In his introductory essay, 'Image and Reality', Loades explains how the English monarchy, over the last 600 years, has repeatedly had to redefine itself. In late medieval times, if all went well in the royal marriage bed, the queen was a subordinate creature helping to set the tone of the court and, above all, manufacturing sons. Unfortunately, all did not always go well. When the king died, as Henry V did after only two years of married life, the consort became a non-person. Catherine de Valois had to resign herself to the placing of her son with others who attended to his upbringing and ruled in his name. But at least she was free to marry again.

But what if the king was ineffectual, prevented by mental weakness from keeping a firm hand on the tiller? Such was the case with Henry VI. Ills consort, Margaret of Anjou, could have stayed in the background while rival nobles squabbled for power. But Margaret, concerned for the rightful inheritance of her son, became embroiled in the Wars of the Roses and was destined to endure the death of her son in battle and the murder of her husband in the Tower. Nothing was left for her but to retire eventually to peaceful seclusion in her native France.

Marriage for medieval kings was a dynastic and national duty involving negotiation with other royal houses. Therefore Edward IV's clandestine nuptials with Elizabeth Woodville, the daughter of a mere English gentleman, inevitably caused resentment and jealousy from which neither dynasty nor nation recovered.

By the time Edward VI died in 1553 the nobility were no longer able to lay violent hands on the crown. The political nation was determined on the maintenance of the Tudor dynasty even though it meant Mary and, after her, Elizabeth ruling as queens in their own right. But England struggled with this novelty. Mary provoked rebellion by her marriage to Philip of Spain and Elizabeth caused scarcely less angst by declining to take a husband. By 1603 England had still not made up its mind what queens were for. The process of discovery would continue for another three centuries.


The search for Tudor women is endless: if not Anne Boleyn's sister then Penelope Devereux, 'the brightest star in Queen Elizabeth I's court' and, according to Sally Varlow's The Lady Penelope (Andre Deutsch, 8.99 [pounds sterling]), a direct descendant of Henry VIII, her mother being 'the love-child of the king and Mary Boleyn, sister of Anne'. Lady Penelope was the object of more than a hundred love sonnets written by Sir Philip Sidney, enmeshed in a world of Catholic sympathies and intrigue, high born, well married, with a tragic end, so hers is a fascinating life, vividly told. Kelly Hart's Tudor finds are many. The Mistresses of Henry VIII (The History Press, 20 [pounds sterling]) brings together not only the well known, such as Mary Boleyn and Bessie Blount, but a stream of others: from daughters-in-law, a family tutor, an adulterer, a 'witch and a prophet'. The twist is that the six-time married monarch was not 'a consummate philanderer' but rather a serial adulterer--as he was a serial husband. JG



Robert Hutchinson had a former life with Jane's De fence Weekly, which may explain what drew him to Thomas Howard, 2nd Duke of Norfolk who fought for Richard III at Bosworth and commanded the English army that annihilated the Scots in that battle. But, sadly, Howard's legacy of political and military acumen later ran into the sand as House of Treason: The Rise and Fall of a Tudor Dynasly (Weidenfeld & Nicolson, 20 [pounds sterling]) explains with panache. Of Howard's descendants, would-be kingmakers, two were traitors and another was beheaded for treason, before England's premier family regained its power. JG
COPYRIGHT 2009 History Today Ltd.
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2009 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Author:Wilson, Derek
Publication:History Today
Article Type:Book review
Date:May 1, 2009
Previous Article:Signposts the Tudors: in the first of an occasional series exploring the ways in which topical historical subjects are being tackled in a variety of...
Next Article:The Sisters Who Would Be Queen: The tragedy of Katherine, Mary and Lady Jane Grey.

Terms of use | Privacy policy | Copyright © 2018 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters