Printer Friendly

The 'killer lake' of Cameroon.

In the early morning hours of Aug. 16, 1984, a parish priest, a young man named Foubouh Jean and others were riding in a van past Lake Monoun in the Republic of Cameroon, when they noticed a man on the roadside who appeared to be asleep on his motorcycle. But when the priest drew near the motorcycle, he discovered that the man was dead. As he turned back toward the van, he, too, collapsed. Jean and a companion, smelling a strange odor like that of car battery fluid, realized the air was deadly and began to run away. Jean's companion soon succumbed, but Jean managed to escape to the nearby village of Njindoun.

By 10:30 a.m., authorities had found a total of 37 people lying lifeless on the road, apparent victims of a mysterious chemical cloud that had enveloped a 200-meter-long stretch of the road that morning. No autopsies were conducted, but Emmanuel M. Njock Bata, a physician who examined the bodies, concluded that the people who had been traveling to market in the open air before dawn had died of asphyxia. Bata, now at Tulane University Medical Center in New Orleans, told SCIENCE NEWS that mucus and blood had oozed as foam from the victims' noses and mouths, and their bodies were rigid from seizure. They also had first-degree chemical burns on their skin, though their clothes were unaffected.

The results of an investigation, now being made public, indicate that the cloud that killed the people was generated naturally in Lake Monoun. This is the first known incidence of such a lethal, natural cloud, say the investigators.

There were several signs on Aug. 16 that the lake was involved. When Bata and a police commandant first neared the area at 6:30 that morning, they saw the smokelike cloud coming from the direction of the lake. The cloud reportedly tasted bitter and made them nauseated, dizzy and weak, so they retreated until 10:30 a.m., when it had dissipated. Between the lake and road, animals, grasses and shrubs had been killed, and plants on the shore had been flattened. Njindoun villagers also reported hearing a loud explosion from the lake about 11:30 the night before. And on Aug. 17, authorities noted that Lake Monoun was reddish brown, indicating that the normally placid waters had been stirred up.

The government of Cameroon, which had at about that time put down an attempted coup, was worried that the incident might have had political overtones, so they kept the event quiet, according to volcanologist Haraldur Sigurdsson. With the help of the U.S. Agency for International Development, Cameroon invited Sigurdsson and Joseph Devine, both at the University of Rhode Island in Narragansett, to Africa to work with Cameroon volcanologist Felix Tchoua in a study of the lake. The researchers were to determine whether the cloud had been produced naturally or by humans -- whether, for example, chemicals or explosives had been dumped into the lake.

Sigurdsson's group could find no evidence of human wrongdoing. And now that the U.S. and Cameroon governments have granted permission to air the story, the researchers can divulge their theory of the "killer lake." William Evans, who along with Theresa Presser and Katherine Pringle at the U.S. Geological Survey in Menlo Park, Calif., conducted the chemical analyses for the study, will present the researchers' findings Dec. 13 in San Francisco at the fall meeting of the American Geophysical Union.

When he first arrived at the lake, Sigurdsson suspected that the cloud had been produced by an abrupt volcanic eruption, because Lake Monoun is one of many small volcanic crater lakes in the region. Volcanic gases might have rushed up through the lake, expanding into an asphyxiating cloud of carbon dioxide and other gases. Indeed, the researchers found a 350-meter-wide volcanic crater on the lake bottom, close to where the people were killed. They also discovered tremendously high levels of bicarbonate ions -- which form from the dissociation of carbon dioxide -- and of carbon dioxide gas in the deep water of the lake. Later isotopic analysis of the carbon atoms produced results consistent with a volcanic origin.

But the complete chemical study of Lake Monoun worked against the idea of an abrupt eruption. The researchers report that the bottom waters contained little of the sulfur, halogens or other chemical signs typically associated with high-temperature volcanic activity. Moreover, Sigurdsson's group measured exceptionally high concentrations of ferrous ions (iron atoms with a +2 charge) in the deep water and large amounts of siderite, an iron-carbonate mineral, in the bottom sediments. The researchers concluded that the iron in the lake comes from the red dust that blows from the Sahel and Sahara. When the iron-rich dust falls into the lake, the ferric ions (iron with a +3 charge) are reduced to ferrous ions. This process is maintained as long as the dissociation of carbon dioxide to bicarbonate continues to make the lake acidic. And as long as ferrous ions and bicarbonate are pumped into the lake system, siderite is created. Given the chemical balances set up in the lake and the fact that the iron had accumulated slowly, over hundreds of years, the researchers concluded that the carbon dioxide, too, had seeped very gradually into the lake, and not as a result of a sudden volcanic eruption.

What, then, caused the cloud? Sigurdsson believes that the delicate chemical balances had strongly stratified the lake by maintaining high levels of bicarbonate in the deepest waters. Something disturbed this stratification, bringing carbonate-rich deep water up toward the surface. This sudden change in pressure would have released carbon dioxide gas "like when you open a soda bottle," says Sigurdsson. Such a burst created a 5-meter-high wave, which flattened the shoreline plants. And the resultant cloud, heavy in dense carbon dioxide gas, was carried by the westerly winds to the road, where it stayed near the ground. Apparently, says Sigurdsson, in the predawn hours there was not enough light for the Njindoun villagers to see the cloud. He suspects there might have been nitric acid in the cloud, which could have helped to make it visible in daylight and which might account for the skin burns. But at this stage, he says, "the burns remain a complete mystery."

Also left unanswered is what triggered the overturn of the lake water. Two Italian tourists 6 kilometers north of Lake Monoun reported feeling an earthquake on Aug. 15, but according to Sigurdsson this cannot be verified because the Cameroon seismograph was down at the time. The researchers also found an undewater landslide on the steep slopes near the lake bottom crater. Another possibility, says Sigurdsson, is that the pattern of winds blowing across the lake generated a current in the otherwise stagnant bottom waters.

"As far as we know, this event was unique -- certainly in its lethal effects," says Sigurdsson. "This type of process, however, had been considered in a very large lake in the East African Rift called Lake Kivu." This lake, too, is strongly stratified. According to Sigurdsson, engineers had considered using this stratification as a source of energy but abandoned the idea because they were afraid that they would induce a large gas burst. The big concern now, he says, is that this might occur naturally again in any one of the many other crater lakes in Cameroon, which may be stratified just like Lake Monoun.
COPYRIGHT 1985 Science Service, Inc.
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 1985, Gale Group. All rights reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Title Annotation:lethal natural cloud generated in Lake Monoun
Author:Weisburd, Stefi
Publication:Science News
Date:Dec 7, 1985
Previous Article:Throwing light on data-taking; electronic data-taking just isn't fast enough for some kinds of instruments. Starting from those applications, a new...
Next Article:Air-crew radiation doses climbing.

Related Articles
Cameroon: death by suffocation.
Cameroon: the first wave of clues.
Cameroon lake: new clues, new clouds?
Cameroon clouds: soda source?
Cameroon's killer lakes: a rising threat.
Lethal injection is inhumane, say researchers.
"Intelligent design," Natural Design, and the problem of meaning in the natural world.
3 million trees planned for 2007.

Terms of use | Copyright © 2017 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters