Term breech trial discredited.
Now the American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology has published a stinging critique that concludes the original study was deeply flawed and its conclusions unsupportable. The article thoroughly itemizes the methodological flaws and clinical problems with the Term Breech Trial and their results state that "most cases of neonatal death and morbidity in the term breech trial cannot be attributed to the mode of delivery" and that the "analysis of outcome after two years has shown no difference between vaginal and abdominal deliveries of breech babies." (2) Their powerful conclusion is that "the original term breech trial recommendations should be withdrawn."
It will be interesting to see what recommendations might emerge based on this paper in light of the results of the trial, its aftermath and the lack of evidence to support current routine cesarean for breech babies. Even if the results of the Term Breech Trial are discredited, changing practice habits of practitioners who have lost their skills and confidence around facilitating vaginal breech births will be hard to accomplish. Maybe Ina May can start doing in-services at hospitals across the country on how to manage a vaginal breech birth.
(1) M.E. Hannah, W.J. Hannah, S.A. Hewson, E.D. Hodnett, S. Saigal and A.R. Willan, Planned caesarean section versus planned vaginal birth for breech presentation at term: a randomised multicentre trial: Term breech trial collaborative group, The Lancet; Volume 356, Issue 9239, October 21, 2000, pages 1375-1383.
(2) M. Glezerman, Five years to the term breech trial: The rise and fail of a randomized controlled trial American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Volume 194, Issue 1, January 2006, Pages 20-25.
|Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback|
|Title Annotation:||pregnancy and child birth|
|Date:||Mar 22, 2006|
|Next Article:||String of ACOG press releases support normal birth.|
|Planned Breech Homebirth.|
|Baby Is Breech, Now What?|
|Boldly into the breech controversy.|
|Maternal mortality risk rises with cesarean birth, falls with prenatal care.|
|Effective alternative treatments for breech presentation.|