So let us settle for this one point: Press quotes a person using an alias, who quotes another individual anonymously, saying that employees of PT-Freeport Indonesia, our Indonesian mining affiliate, carry AK-47s. Press has made this charge before, quoting different unnamed sources. The truth is that our employees do not have guns; that would violate Indonesian law.
Why is it that none of the hundreds of outsiders who toured our operations in the past year have ever stepped forward to make this charge, other than anonymously to Eyal Press?
Why is it that none of the various investigations of human rights--which all determined that PT-FI employees were not involved in the violations--have ever raised this issue?
Why is it that none of the dozens of legitimate news media who visited our mine in the past year--unlike Press, who has never been there--have ever made this allegation?
Because this charge is a lie. Like much of Press's story, it is fiction, part of a smear campaign being waged by him and a small group of other fringe pseudo-journalists.
We regard our operation to be a model of economic development that minimizes environmental impacts and respects the rights of the local indigenous peoples. We are not perfect, but we are trying. We will continue to work with responsible individuals and groups to improve our operations, and we will not be swayed by individuals like Press, whose sole contribution to the debate is to spew mud and mendacity.
Thomas J. Egan,
Senior Vice President and
Senior Administrative Deputy
to the Office of the Chairman,
The author replies:
You would think that Thomas Egan, whose company dumps thousands of tons of untreated mine tailings into the rivers of Irian Jaya on a daily basis, would hesitate before accusing others of engaging in activity whose end result is to create rivers of poison. In any event, Egan moans about not having adequate space to dispel the "false illusion" my article created, thus avoiding almost all substantive engagement with it. Perhaps Freeport could correct any mistaken impressions by taking out some fullpage ads in The Progressive to set the readers straight, as it has already done in The New York Times, The Weekly Standard, The Texas Monthly, and other publications since word about the human-rights and environmental problems at its mine began to spread.
As for Egan's sole substantive point, below is a photograph, kindly provided by my anonymous source, of a group of people at the Carstensz Pyramid, the highest mountain between the Andes and the Himalayas, within walking distance of Freeport's mine. This picture was taken on the morning that my source was abruptly awakened by the sound of guns being fired against the side of a mountain. The man holding the gun and one other person are shown wearing what appear to be standard company jackets. The hard hats also seem to be Freeport standard issue. My source spoke with the gun-toter, who told him he worked as an engineer for Freeport.
|Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback|
|Title Annotation:||includes author's reply to the response; response to 'Jim Bob's Indonesian Misadventure,' June 1996 by Eyal Press|
|Article Type:||Letter to the Editor|
|Date:||Aug 1, 1996|
|Previous Article:||Slimed again.|