Short communication - COMPARISON OF INPOUCH TF KITS AND DIAMOND'S MEDIUM FOR TRICHOMONAS GALLINAE IDENTIFICATION IN DOMESTIC PIGEONS.
Trichomonas gallinae parasitizes a variety of avian orders especially in domestic pigeons (Columba livia domestica, Order Columbiformes). A variety of methods have been reported for the identification of T. gallinae in pigeons. Diagnosis of T. gallinae was accomplished by microscopic examination of oropharyngeal swabs of pigeons (n=120, males=78, females=42) using microscopic examination of InPouch TF culture kits and cultures taken form modified Diamond's medium during various incubation time periods after post inoculation (PI). Total 68% pigeons were found positive for T. gallinae by InPouch TF kit and 55% were with modified Diamond's medium. Significant differences were found between incubation time of for InPouch TF kit (CI-99%, p=.001) and for modified Diamond's medium (CI-99%, p=.000<a).
No significant sex-related difference in diagnosis of T. gallinae was found for InPouch TF kit (p=.839) and for modified Diamond's medium (p=.765). InPouch TF as more sensitive method for the diagnosis of T. gallinae infections was also found to be practically efficient than Diamond's medium in recovering the parasite from specimens and may provide a readily available, low-cost substitute for the Diamond's medium in Pakistan.
Key words: InPouch TF kits, Diamond's medium, Diagnosis.
Trichomonas gallinae (Sarcomastigophora) is a zooflagellate which parasitizes a variety of avian orders and causes avian trichomoniasis. There are various morphologic forms such as pyriform (Tasca and De Carli, 2003) round, stalked amoeboid and bell-shaped amoeboid. The bell-shaped amoeboid form has been shown to cause cell damage to avian palatal-esophageal epithelium during disease onset and progression (Kietzmann, 1993). This protozoan is pear-shaped and measures about 7-11 um (Mehlhorn et al., 2009). It also has four anterior flagella and an axostyle. T. gallinae is not found in the cyst form (Levine, 1961). Trichomonas gallinae is considered one of most serious pathogen in pigeons all over the world causing high mortalities and massive losses in bird fauna, especially in columbiformes (Work and Hale, 1996; Villanua et al., 2006). Domestic pigeon, as the main host of T. gallinae plays an important role in the spread of this parasite among other members of the order and causes morbidity and mortality.
Despite of its significance to health of columbiformes, limited information of the prevalence of T. gallinae infecting domestic pigeons is available all over the world including Pakistan, because there are only limited investigation of this pathogen affecting domestic pigeons reported (McKeon et al., 1997; Dovc et al., 2004; Padilla et al., 2004; Luo et al., 2006; Sansano-Maestre et al., 2009; Zhang, 2009). Different methods have been reported for the identification of T. gallinae. Diagnosis of infection can be accomplished by direct smear method (wet mount), Wright-Giemsa staining technique and microscopic examination of material scraped from the oral cavity of infected birds (Stabler, 1951; Coles, 1980; Anderson et al., 2009; Qiu et al., 2012) or by the inoculation of such material culture on Diamond's medium (Kocan and Knisley, 1970; Honigberg, 1978; McKeon et al., 1997).
InPouch TF kits (BioMed Diagnostics, California; Bunbury et al., 2005; Bunbury, 2011) have also been used for identification of T. gallinae. Hofle et al., (2004) also identified flagellated protozoa as T. gallinae by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) in woodpigeons (Columba palumbus) in southwestern Spain. However, very few studies have been done for the comparison of sensitivity of all these methods. The aim of current research was to compare the sensitivity of the two mentioned methods as well as finding most appropriate technique identifying T. gallinae (Rivolta, 1878) in domestic pigeons, in Lahore, Pakistan.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Rearing Pigeons: Total 120 apparently health pigeons were purchases from local bird fanciers. All pigeons were tagged with different colored rings, cage-reared in the animal house of Department of Zoology, Govt. College University Lahore, Pakistan and supplied with commercial complete feed and corn (Qiu et al., 2012).
Grouping: All 120 pigeons were categorized according to their gender i.e. 78 males and 42 females (Tables 1). After measuring weight in grams using manual weight balance, pigeons were placed in four different categories of weight. The lowest range of weight was 181 grams and highest was 380 grams. Among those 14 pigeons were laying between 181-230 grams, 40 belonged to 231-280, 38 belonged to 41-55 weight group, while 28 were in category of 331-380. (Table 2).
InPouch TF Kit: All subjects were oropharyngeal swabbed for presence of trichomonad parasites using imported InPouch TF kits (BioMed Diagnostics, San Jose, USA). The InPouch culture kit consists of a double chambered plastic pouch separated by a narrow channel. It acts as a cell culture for parasites as well as a transparent chamber for immediate observing of sample which is equivalent to the wet mount method. The lower chamber is filled with 4 ml of a medium containing antibiotics and a fungal growth inhibitor (Kimsey, 1986). The culture medium contains reagents like trypticase, peptone, yeast extract, maltose along with other sugars, amino acids, inorganic salts, antimicrobial and antifungal drugs dissolved in normal saline phosphate buffer. Inoculated InPouch TF kits were incubated at 370C for 72hr and were examined under microscope (250 x magnification) for the presence of T. gallinae every after 24hr (Parker et al., 2003; Bunbury et al., 2005, 2011).
An inoculum of 1 to 10 organisms is enough to diagnose a positive test if the specimen is inoculated immediately after collection. InPouch kits which were remained free of trichomonad activity after 3 days of incubation were recorded as negative.
Modified Diamond's medium: Swabs taken from the oropharyngeal region were inoculated in modified Diamond's (TYM) medium. Bacto Agar (0.5 g) can also be added to original recipe of the medium which improved the isolation and growth but was not strictly necessary so we did not include it. Following ingredients were then dissolved in 600 ml of the distilled water. 20.0 g of trypton, 10.0 g of yeast extract, 5.0 g of maltose, 1.0 g of L-cysteine hydrochloride, 0.2 g of ascorbic acid and adjusted pH to 6.0 with 1N HCl. Solution was brought to 1000 ml with distilled water and autoclaved for 15 min at 121 degC under 15 lb. /in2 pressure to be sterilized. Then solution was dispensed in 10 ml quantities in 12 ml screw cap tubes. Each tube was supplemented with 0.5 ml antibiotic mixture Sodium penicillin G, Streptomycin sulfate, Grisiofulvin and 1 ml inactivated fetal calf serum.
Sterile cotton swabs containing sample were inoculated in tubes containing modified Diamond's medium (Diamond, 1957; Kocan and Knisley, 1970; Honigberg, 1978; McKeon et al., 1997; Tasca et al., 1999; Parker et al., 2003). Cultures were observed up to 72 hrs (three consecutive days) to check the growth of live motile parasites (Sansano-maestre, 2009).
Incubation time: After the inoculation of swabs in InPouch TF kits and modified Diamond's medium modified, kits and culture vials were placed in the incubator 370C (+- 0.5). Cultures were observed to check the growth of live parasites (Sansano-maestre, 2009) for the time intervals of 24 hours of post inoculation (PI) i.e. after 24 hours, 48 hours and 72 hours. InPouch kits and cultures which were diagnosed positive for T. gallinae were isolated from which were remained negative until 72 hours. After the 72 hours, those kits and cultures were recorded as negative which showed no trichomonad activity.
Statistical tools: The efficiency of different techniques were compared by using Chi square in SPSS for Windows (Release 16.0 standard version, SPSS Inc., Chicago, USA) (Villanua et al., 2006).
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Incubation Time: We have found significant differences (CI-99, p=.014) between incubation time of for InPouch TF kit (CI-99, p=.001) and for modified Diamond's medium (CI-99%, p=.000a. The results showed significant difference between weight groups for number of positive samples diagnosed by the InPouch TF kits (p=.001a. The results showed significant difference between weight groups and number of positive samples diagnosed by the Diamond's medium (p=.000). Figure 5 is showing the frequency of positive/negative samples by Diamond's medium among different weight groups.
Comparison of Diagnostic Techniques: Our results have shown that among diagnostic tests for identification of Trichomonas gallinae, InPouch TF kit was found to be more sensitive as compared to Diamond's medium. We have found much significant difference between the InPouch TF kit and modified Diamond's medium because p=.006<a.
Trichomonas gallinae, since it affects avian livestock is considered as an economically major pathogen, and imposes a considerable threat to the protection of endangered species of columbiformes (Silva et al., 2007). T. gallinae is a ubiquitous pathogen of columbiformes; infection is mostly asymptomatic but occasionally virulent strains of T. gallinae cause high mortality among affected domestic pigeons. Of the 120 birds examined in our study, we found 82 (68.3%) of the samples of swabs taken, positive for T. gallinae with InPouch TF kits (Cover et al., 1994; Bunbury et al., 2005). On the other hand 66 (55%) of the samples of swabs taken found to be positive for T. gallinae modified Diamond's medium (De Carli et al., 1979). In contrast to Cover et al., (1994), very significant difference between the InPouch TF kit and modified Diamond's medium was found.
The time was taken to diagnose T. gallinae by different tests after the post incubation of samples for 24hrs, 48hrs and 72hrs respectively. We have found significant differences between incubation time for InPouch TF kit and for modified Diamond's medium. Regarding the efficiency of the diagnostic tests, incubation time showed significant association between these techniques at pa. These show discrepancy with Al-Sadi and Hamodi (2011) who proposed males as more susceptible for T. gallinae.
Regarding the weight of animals, we found 11%, 33%, 31% and 23% of pigeons in 181-230, 231-280, 41-55 and 331-380 in the respective categories of weight in grams. We have found statistically significant differences between weight (grams) of pigeons and InPouch TF kits and Diamond's medium p>a.
Table 1 showing the frequency of pigeons among two different genders.
Table 2 showing the frequency of pigeons among different weight groups measured in grams.
Conclusions: Diamond's medium is considered as "gold standard" for identification T. gallinae in animals. On the other hand, InPouch TF kit has plenty of benefits over Diamond's medium used in glass vials. Pouches neither break nor easily spill out. The pouch is quite lighter and easier to handle in the field than a usual glass culture tube in the laboratory. Another advantage is that, if pouches are kept vertically after inoculation, protozoans are concentrated by gravity at the bottom of the pouch which enhances the identification of trichomonads. Unlike culture tubes of Diamond's medium, once inoculated, an InPouch is not needed not be reopened for repeated examinations. Also, aseptic technique in examining established cultures is not required. The one year long shelf life at room temperature of InPouch allows the convenient keeping of a supply of pouches.
So, it's more expenditure than the mount microscopy could be acceptable for these advantages along with its high sensitivity and potentially lower subjectivity in diagnosing infectious organisms.
Ultimately, we propose InPouch TF as more sensitive method as compared to Diamond's medium which makes it as perfect technique for the diagnosis of Trichomonas gallinae in avian fauna especially the fancy birds in field conditions as well as in the laboratory.
Al-Sadi, H.I. and Hamodi, A.Z. (2011). Prevalence and Pathology of Trichomoniasis in Free Living Urban Pigeons in the City of Mosul, Iraq. Veterinary World. 4(1):12-14.
Anderson, N.L., R.A. Grahn, K., Van-Hoosear and R.H. Bondurant (2009). Studies of trichomonad protozoa in free ranging songbirds: Prevalence of Trichomonas gallinae in house finches (Carpodacus mexicanus) and corvids and a novel trichomonad in mockingbirds (Mimus polyglottos). Vet. Parasitol. 161: 178-186.
Begum N., M.A.A. Mamun, S.A. Rahman and A.S.M. Bari (2008) Epidemiology and pathology of Trichomonas gallinae in the common pigeon (Columba livia) J. Bangladesh Agril. Univ. 6(2): 301-306
Bunbury, N., D., Bell, C., Jones, A., Greenwood, and P., Hunter (2005). Comparison of the InPouch TF culture system and wet-mount microscopy for diagnosis of Trichomonas gallinae infections in the pink pigeon Columba mayeri. J. Clinical Microbiology; 43:1005-1006.
Bunbury, N., (2011). Trichomonad Infection in Endemic and Introduced Columbids in the Seychelles. J. Wildlife Diseases, 47(3): 730-733
Coles E.H. (1980). Veterinary clinical pathology. 3. London: W. B. Saunders Company.
Cover, A.J., W.M. Harmon, and M.W. Thomas (1994). A New Method for the Diagnosis of Trichomonas gallinae. Infection by Culture. J. Wildlife Diseases, 30(3) 457-459.
De Carli, G.A., M.C.G. Pansera, and J. Guerrero (1979). Trichomonas gallinae (Rivolta, 1878) Stabler, 1938, No Trato Digestivo Superior De Pombos Domesticos, Columba livia, no Rio Grande do Sul - Primeiro Registro. Acta Biol Leopoldensia 1:85-95.
Diamond, L.S. (1957). The establishment of various Trichomonas of animals and man in axenic cultures. J. Parasitol. 43, 488-490.
Dovc, A., O., Zorman-Rojs, A., Vergles-Rataj, V., Bole-Hribovsek, U., Krapez, and M. Dobeic (2004). Health status of free-living pigeons (Columba livia domestica) in the city of Ljubljana. Acta Vet. Hungarica, 52: 219-226.
Gulegen, E., B. Senlik, and V. Akyol (2005). Prevalence of trichomoniasis in pigeons in Bursa province, Turkey. Indian Vet. J., 82(4): 369-370
Hofle, U., C., Gortazar, J.A. Oritz, B., Knipsel, and E.F. Kaleta (2004). Outbreak of trichomoniasis in a woodpigeon (Columba palumbus) wintering roost. European J. Wildlife Res. 50: 73-77.
Honigberg, B.M. (1978). Trichomonads of importance in human medicine. In: Kreiger, J.P. (Ed.), Parasitic Protozoa. Academic Press, Inc., New York, NY, 275-454.
Kocan, R.M., and J.O. Knisley (1970). Challenge infection as a means of determining the rate of Trichomonas gallinae-free immune birds in a population. J. Wildlife Diseases 6: 13-15.
Kimsey, P.B. 1986. Bovine trichomoniasis. In Current therapy in theriogenology 2, D. A. Morrow (ed). W. B. Saunders Company, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, 1143 pp.
Kietzmann Jr., G. E., (1993). Relationship of Trichomonas gallinae to the palatal-esophageal junction of ring doves (Streptopelia risoria) as revealed by scanning electron microscopy. J. Parasitol. 79, 408-415.
Levine, N.D. (1961) Protozoan parasites of domestic animals and man. Burgess, Minneapolis, Minnesota. 412 pages.
Luo, F., Y.B. Weng, J.F. Zhang, and G.Q. Li (2006). A survey of Trichomonas gallinae in pigeons in Guangdong Province of China. China Poultry, 28: 24-25 (in Chinese). Cross ref.
Mehlhorn, H., S., Al-Quraishy, A., Aziza, and M. Hess (2009). Fine structure of the bird parasites Trichomonas gallinae and Tetratrichomonas gallinarum from cultures. Parasitol Res. 105(3):751-6.
Mckeon, T., J., Dunsmore, and S.R. Raidal (1997). Trichomonas gallinae in budgerigars and columbid birds in Perth, Western Australia. Australian Vet. J. 75: 652-655.
Padilla, L.R., D., Santiago-Alarcon, J., Merkel, R.E. Miller, and P.G. Parker (2004). Survey for Haemoproteus spp., Trichomonas gallinae, Chlamydophila psittaci, and Salmonella spp. in Galapagos Islands columbiformes. J. Zoo. Wildl. Med., 35: 60-64.
Parker, S., J., Campbell, and A. Gajadhar (2003). Comparison of the diagnostic sensitivity of a commercially available culture kit and a diagnostic culture test using Diamond's media for diagnosing Tritrichomonas foetus in bulls. J Vet Diagn Invest. 15:460-465
Qiu, S.B., C., Yan, D.H. Zhou, J., Hou, Q.Q. Wang, Y., Linl, H.C. Fu, J., Zhang, Y.B. H.Q. Weng, Song, and R.Q. Lin (2012). High prevalence of Trichomonas gallinae in domestic pigeons (Columba livia domestica) in subtropical southern China African. J. Micro. Res. 6(13), pp. 3261-3264.
Sansano-Maestre, J., M.M. Garijo-Toledo, and M.T. Gomez-Munoz (2009). Prevalence and genotyping of Trichomonas gallinae in pigeons and birds of prey. Avian Pathol. 38: 201-207.
Silva, D., E., Barton, N., Bunbury, P., Lunness, D.J., Bell, and K.M. Tyler (2007). Molecular identity and heterogeneity of Trichomonad parasites in a closed avian population. Infection, Genetics and Evolution 7, 433-440.
Stabler, R.M. (1951). A survey of Colorado band tailed pigeons, mourning doves and wild common pigeons for Trichomonas gallinae. The J. Parasitology 37: 471-472.
Tasca, T. and G.A. De Carli (1999). Prevalence of Trichomonas gallinae form the upper digestive tract of the common pigeon, Columba livia in the Southern Brazilian State, Rio Grande Do Sul. Parasitol. Dia. 23, n.1-2, pp.
Tasca, T., and G.A. De Carli (2003). Scanning electron microscopy study of Trichomonas gallinae. Veterinary Parasitology, 118: 37-42
Villanua, D., U., Hofle, L.P. Rodriguez, and C. Gortazar (2006). Trichomonas gallinae in wintering common wood pigeons Columba palumbus in Ibis, Spain. Intern. J. Avian Sci. 148 (4): 641 -648.
Work, T.M., and J. Hale (1996). Causes of owl mortality in Hawaii, 1992-1994. J. Wildlife Diseases, 32, 266-273.
Zhang X.L. (2009). Prevalence of Trichomonas gallinae in pigeons in northern west of Shandong Province in China. Chin. J. Vet. Med., 45: 56-57 (in Chinese).
|Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback|
|Publication:||Journal of Animal and Plant Sciences|
|Date:||Jun 30, 2017|
|Previous Article:||Short communication - PHYSICOCHEMICAL FACTORS AFFECTING PERSISTENCE OF FRANCISELLA TULARENSIS IN SOIL.|
|Next Article:||BLAST DISEASE INTIMIDATION TOWARDS RICE CULTIVATION: A REVIEW OF PATHOGEN AND STRATEGIES TO CONTROL.|