Printer Friendly

Shock Cities: The Environmental Transformation and Reform of Manchester and Chicago.

Shock Cities: The Environmental Transformation and Reform of Manchester and Chicago. By Harold L. Platt (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2005. xvi plus 628 pp. $49.00).

The dust jacket illustration of this book is L.S. Lowry's The Lake (1937). As Lowry's definitive statement on the urban scene in Salford/Manchester, The Lake evokes some of the central subjects of Harold L. Platt's Shock Cities: The Environmental Transformation and Reform of Manchester and Chicago. Dominating the center is a nightmarescape of miasmatic water; the milky colored river Irwell spills over its banks and overwhelms the industrial city. The Irwell in this painting, as described by Michael Howard,
 brings dissolution to the city. The polluted urban waterways, once a
 dynamic transport system serving Victorian industry, have now grown
 stagnant. The water, which should be clean and life-enhancing, has
 become denaturalized and dead. Here, in stark contrast with the clean
 waters of the countryside, nature has been damaged and now, it would
 seem, takes its revenge. (1)

We are presented with a visual representation of an "industrial ecology," the creation of which is the central focus of this work. Lowry suggests that it is industry, trade, and the polluted river, not the inhabitants, that is responsible for the city's dissolution.

In this book Platt grounds his analysis in the "people, rather than their technological systems and institutional structures." (2) The inhabitants of these industrial sacrifice zones were living the shock, as opposed to travelers or those wealthy enough to live upwind and upstream. He recognizes that this is a twoway relationship; the creation of these industrial ecologies then reflects back on the human community's health and well-being, leading to demands for reform. This is a very ambitious endeavor, not only exploring the creation of these "shock cities" (a term coined by pioneering urban historian Asa Briggs) through a comparative approach, but also detailing their reform.

For social historians there is much here to recommend. By putting questions of social and environmental justice at the center, Platt does an exemplary job of uncovering the cultural and political construction of physical space in these two revolutionary cities. The cross-Atlantic trade in ideas and their impact on urban development and reform is a well-developed theme, and Platt lends support to Daniel Rodgers' contention that late 19th century Progressivism took shape within a trans-Atlantic context. (3) Edwin Chadwick's "Sanitary Idea" of the mid-19th century, along with the accompanying miasmatic theories of disease causation, greatly impacted Chicago's response to water pollution and urban disease. The spread of this idea, and the later development of scientific biology and germ theory, clearly demonstrates the complex interplay between science, technology, and political and social movements. But we also see the cross-pollination of grassroots urban reform movements, such as those of Charles Rowley in Manchester, and Jane Addams in Chicago. A "politics of social and geographic exclusion" is also well-mapped in this book, as alongside environmental sacrifice zones we see the concurrent development of the "garden suburb". (4)

Each chapter begins with either an individual or an event that crystallizes the theme of that part of the book: Alexis de Tocqueville's notes on a visit to industrializing Manchester; the dispatches from Manchester by the London Morning Chronicle reporter Angus B. Reach; Chicago's great spring flood of 1849; the 1867 opening of Chicago's "Two-Mile Crib" drawing fresh water from Lake Michigan; the 1852 winter flood of Manchester and the Holmfirth dam catastrophe. This device humanizes the narrative, and helps Platt build his case around the people who lived and died in these places.

In these cities the search for an ultimate sink for human and industrial wastes (in both liquid and gaseous forms) was an on-going dialectic between technological fixes and unintended consequences. Platt's comparative approach shows the selective use of science and technology as determined by each city's institutional structures and political cultures. There were no simple answers to these complex issues, and there was no universal scientific truth to appeal to. Another important area of exploration is the "interplay between external markets and local developments, paying particular attention to the effects of the energy demands of a commercial economy on urban land-use patterns." (5) Smoke abatement movements in both cities illustrate this interplay, as do the two large canal projects: the Chicago Sanitary and Ship Canal, and the Manchester Ship Canal.

Platt uses three case studies to "unpack the intricate interplay of energy and environment" in these two cities: waterworks, horses, and the brewing industry. This is an effective device, but unbalanced in application. There is much less attention paid to horses than to the other two, and there is an over-emphasis on the importance of the brewing industry as a case study of the technological construction of industrial ecologies. The mechanization of the brewery may serve "as a microcosm of changes in the industrial city's energy system", but the point could have been made more succinctly without damaging the overall effectiveness of this work. Coming in at a weighty 498 pages (609 with notes included), this book could have been pared down somewhat in this area and in chapter four, but scholars interested in the history of scientific brewing and the early development of Chicago might disagree. (6)

The transformation of these two important cities, both their industrialization as well as the reform of the newly created industrial ecology, is well documented in this study. Both social and environmental historians will benefit from the comparative and interdisciplinary perspective, as well as the clear and convincing dialogue between the human subjects and the environments they inhabited. Embracing outside markets and constant change, industrialism is a revolution that starts but has no clear ending. But as the reform of these cities demonstrates, the narrative of industrialization does not have to be one of decline. If one returned to the site of Lowry's painting The Lake today they would find a nature reserve along the banks of the Irwell where the factories and warehouses once stood. A socially constructed landscape, yes, but a "shock city" no more.

Matthew Osborn

Green Mountain College


1. Michael Howard, Lowry: A Visionary Artist (Salford, UK, 2000), 154.

2. Harold L. Platt, Shock Cities: The Environmental Transformation and Reform of Manchester and Chicago (Chicago, 2005), xiii.

3. Ibid., 439.

4. Ibid., 20.

5. Ibid., 86.

6. Ibid., 258.
COPYRIGHT 2007 Journal of Social History
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2007, Gale Group. All rights reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Author:Osborn, Matthew
Publication:Journal of Social History
Geographic Code:4EUUK
Date:Mar 22, 2007
Previous Article:Subterranean Cities: The World Beneath Paris and London, 1800-1945.
Next Article:Cities of the World: A History in Maps.

Related Articles
Unitarian philanthropy and cultural hegemony in comparative perspective: Manchester and Boston, 1827-1848.
Cost benefit of providing comprehensive case management for lead-burdened children.
No justice, no latte?
The Dome.
The Chimney of the World: A History of Smoke Pollution in Victorian and Edwardian Manchester.
Deathstalker Coda.
Edens Lost And Found.

Terms of use | Privacy policy | Copyright © 2021 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters