Printer Friendly


There's no way to synthesize Florine Stettheimer's florid fancies with the turbulent energy of Jackson Pollock, and why would anyone want to anyway? Doing just that, Suzanne McClelland's new paintings put the impossible at the service of the unreasonable. Stettheimer and Pollock do come to terms in McGlelland's Cynthia and Angela (all works 2000): The Abstract Expressionist's flung and poured paint morphs into something resembling the arabesque festoons of Stettheimer's twee ornamentalism, as well as lettering that spells out a series of broken phrases "i came to you," "you always said," "my eyes." Along with two other diptychs, Frankie and Tallulah and Nina and Sophia, Cynthia and Angela represents a break with McClelland's earlier work, and with the status quo of contemporary painting: It decisively sidesteps formalist self referentiality without sacrificing (indeed, while intensifying) formal stringency and invention. With the possible exception of some works by Kerry James Marshall, these are about the on ly paintings being made these days in which subject matter is irreducible to an emblematic device--which is just as much the case with figurative painters like John Currin (or Alex Katz) as it is with abstractionists like Karin Davie (or Brice Marden).

As their titles imply, these diptychs are portraits--double portraits-though not of the familiar sort: They are pictures of dialogue (McClelland cites Gertrude Stein's "word portraits" as an inspiration). The material they handle is language--specifically, language the artist has culled from videotapes she made of conversations between the mothers and daughters for whom each painting is named. (The videos, not meant to be exhibited, served essentially as sketches for the finished work.) As with any portraits, only those who know the subjects can judge for likeness, but each canvas within the diptychs conveys a sense of stubborn individuality, just as their pairing forms an entangled but conflicted unity that is differently constituted in each case.

Of these conversation paintings, Frankie and Tallulah is the densest visually but the simplest compositionally, with its clear contrasts of black against white, perspectival recession against projection. Nina and Sophia is the most unruffled and lyrical, with its watery fields of greenish yellow and pink floating over delicate curling tendril-like lines of polymer emulsion, not to mention its goofy, bulbous, Peter Max-ish lettering of scattered phrases, insistent yet faltering, like "you you you get into into my life." Cynthia and Angela is a vast, empty, resounding architecture infested with frothy marginalia. Each of these works evokes a specific ethos and makes enough room for the viewer to enter it. The paintings neither illustrate the words they contain nor subsume them to a purely visual schema. You can't read them all the way through, hut you can't just look at them as graphic shapes either. Instead, word and image, text and matter seem to erupt from within one another, each with an enormous plastic p ower with respect to the other. Four small single-panel paintings hanging in an adjoining room will seem more familiar to those who know McClelland's previous work, though they also pursue the notion of portraiture (one is a Dubuffet-esque Self Portrait). They are denser than their larger cousins, but less conclusive.
COPYRIGHT 2001 Artforum International Magazine, Inc.
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2001, Gale Group. All rights reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Title Annotation:exhibition of her paintings
Author:Schwabsky, Barry
Publication:Artforum International
Article Type:Brief Article
Date:Jan 1, 2001
Previous Article:MATTHEW RITCHIE.
Next Article:SARAH SZE.

Related Articles
"Painting on the Move". (Reviews).
Thomas Scheibitz. (Reviews: New York).
January 1983. (10 20 30 40).
Bernard Frize: Musee D'art Moderne de la Ville de Paris.
Global pursuits: Sunday Morning, Virginia.
Black Thursday: William Strutt's 'itinerant picture' ... an itinerant picture in search of a place in a public collection.
Robert Hoddle and nineteenth-century genre painting.
A modern life.

Terms of use | Copyright © 2018 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters