Printer Friendly

SEC bans selective disclosure.


The SEC voted in August to approve a rule prohibiting U.S. public companies from disseminating important information to securities analysts, institutional investors and others before releasing it to the general public. In the past, select groups sometimes benefited by investing on the basis of financial information they had received from companies before the public did.

Chairman Arthur Levitt of the SEC said the rule--known as regulation FD (for "fair disclosure")--will "bring all investors, regardless of the size of their holdings, into the information loop, where they belong." Sources familiar with the SEC's plans expect the rule will take effect later this year. It does not apply to foreign issuers of securities.

Because it increases public companies' communication responsibilities, the rule will affect CPAs in industry. And, by making it easier for individual investors to get breaking investment news, the rule also will have an impact on both CPAs who provide personal financial planning services and their clients.

After proposing a draft version of the rule in December 1999, the SEC received more than 6,000 comment letters and, in response, modified some of its original provisions so the rule would not affect special groups, such as journalists and corporate bond-rating organizations, whose efforts benefit all investors. The final rule also allows lower-rank company employees to privately discuss company information with journalists and securities analysts.

If company executives accidentally disclose important information to analysts or others, the rule requires them also to release it to the public within 24 hours.

While the rule does not interfere with the SEC's power to institute administrative proceedings or seek other remedies, which could include civil penalties, neither does it provide a legal basis for investor suits against companies that violate it.

Supporters as well as opponents of the final rule are apprehensive about it. Barbara Roper, director of investor protection at the Consumer Federation of America, said that while her advocacy group supports the rule, she is unsure whether its influence will be permanent. "It relies on effective SEC enforcement, which I think we'll get under the current leadership," she said, but also noted that changes in the political climate could weaken the rule's impact.

Others, however, are concerned the rule will be fully enforced and backfire, thwarting the SEC'S intent. They worry that companies fearful of violating the rule's provisions will immediately begin to reduce the amount of information they voluntarily release.

Margaret Draper, a spokesperson for the Securities Industry Association, a trade group, said, "This industry is based on getting information. By cutting off analysts' access to it, the rule will cause investors to get less information on which to base their investment decisions despite the SEC's noble intent."

Large investors don't necessarily agree. Ann Yerger spoke on behalf of the Council of Institutional Investors, a lobbying group. "We don't think this is going to put an end to communications between corporations and shareholders," she said. Earlier, in a comment letter to the SEC, the council said, "Issuers will find it nearly impossible to attract investors, large or small, if they refuse to communicate concerning their earnings, operations and other key developments within the company. We are confident that, in order to continue attracting capital, issuers will meet the market's demand for investment information even after the adoption of regulation FD."

A fact sheet and other information about the rule are available on the SEC Web site at
COPYRIGHT 2000 American Institute of CPA's
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2000, Gale Group. All rights reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Title Annotation:corporate communications; securities law
Publication:Journal of Accountancy
Geographic Code:1USA
Date:Oct 1, 2000
Next Article:Outsourcing: make it work for your company.

Related Articles
Are we risking the integrity of our securities markets?
Registration, listing and disclosure of potentially abusive corporate tax shelters.
SEC Releases Interpretive Advice on Regulation FD.
After Regulation FD: talking to your constituents.
SEC orders CEOs, CFOs to certify accuracy of annual reports. (SEC News).
Implementing Sarbanes-Oxley: early feedback. (Regulatory).
Regulation FD: coping in the trenches: CFOs tell how the SEC's stricter disclosure rules have changed the way they release financial information...
Corporate governance reform: what it means for associations.
Independent directors are a good thing: a financial advisory firm CEO argues that smart companies are treating Sarbanes-Oxley requirements as an...

Terms of use | Privacy policy | Copyright © 2019 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters