Retrofit autopilots: you'll pay for precision: a rate-based s-tec may be a cost-effective solution, but avidyne's DFC90 and Bendix King KFC225 attitude-based models easily outperform it.
For years, S-Tec (now Cobham Avionics) has dominated the autopilot retrofit market with thousands of STC approvals, from Cessna 150s to Beech 1900s. But S-Tec isn't the only game in town.
Century and Bendix King still build autopilots, too. There's also Avidyne's DFC90. It's a drop-in, AHRS-based solution for replacing and increasing the performance of existing S-Tec systems.
Here's a look at the current retrofit autopilot market that's trending toward digital interfaces, increased reliability and higher costs.
Since pilots buy autopilots to fly the aircraft more smoothly and with more accuracy than a human, it's easy to have unrealistic expectations on what a modern system can do and how well it might perform.
Rather than an automatic pilot, the better description is flight control system. That's because what we're really asking the system to do is maintain aircraft stability, particularly when turbulence and out-of-trim conditions depart the airframe from the intended roll-and-pitch axis.
In addition, we expect full-featured systems to precisely fly all segments of an instrument approach, including course reversals and holding patterns, following the lead of integrated GPS navigators and FMS systems.
Attitude-based systems do all of that more precisely than a rate-based system. It's all about the precision and stability of the reference source that feeds the autopilot computer. An attitude-based autopilot computer receives roll and pitch signals from a compatible attitude gyro (or digital AHRS, in a PFD-equipped aircraft). A rate-based autopilot works by reference from a rate gyro inside an electric turn coordinator, arguably a less stable reference, especially in turbulence as the turn coordinator bounces.
As we reported in the instrument upkeep article in the January 2013 issue of Aviation Consumer, PFD systems equipped with non-spinning, electronic gyros have become the preferred sources for driving autopilots. They're more precise, reliable and promise a longer life. You'll still need a backup attitude gyro, but it doesn't need to have the outputs for driving the autopilot. The Al-IRS does that when connected to a digital gyro emulator/converter (Garmin's GAD43 or Aspen's EA100).
While arguably less precise than attitude-based autopilots, rate-based models are notoriously easier to install, cheaper to purchase and might require less upkeep than attitude-based models. But there's a performance tradeoff, especially when installed in quicker airframes. A lower-end rate-based model may be an acceptable match for an Archer, but not enough autopilot for a speedier Malibu, for example.
BENDIX KING KFC225
Once the leader of the autopilot market, Bendix King introduced the KFC225 for new production Beech Bonanzas and Barons. The all-digital, attitude-based KFC225 was intended as a modern replacement for the venerable KFC200/150. Ben-dix King made significant improvements when designing the KFC225, eliminating the heavy KC295 remote flight guidance computer in favor of a flat-pack, self-contained computer/ controller that mounts in the radio stack. It reengineered the KS270-series mechanical servo actuators to an improved servo speed control, or tach feedback, design. Plus, it added an integrated altitude preselect and vertical speed function, eliminating the remote KAS270 altitude selector system. There's also voice prompting and an optional yaw damper that still requires a separate yaw rate gyro.
The KFC225 went out of production during Bendix King's hiatus from the market, but it's back in the lineup with an interface that's based around Garmin's G500/600 and Aspen's Evolution PFD. When the KliC225 was introduced, the STC included the KCS55A mechanical HSI system and the K1256 flight director gyro. Now, the installation approval is blanketed under Garmin and Aspen STCs. But that doesn't make the KFC225 a player in all aircraft, although Bendix King says the STC list is expected to grow. For now, it's available for the Beech Baron and Bonanza series, Cessna 421 and 414, Piper Navajo Chieftain and the newer GippsAero G8. Bendix King says the system will be approved for the Cessna 210 series and the Piper PA46 Malibu Mirage in mid 2014.
Pricing for the KFC225 starts at $28,000, but that doesn't include an Aspen or Gar-min PFD or a gyro emulator. Aspen's single-screen Evolution PFD is roughly $15,000 installed, while a G500 might easily top $20,000. You could install the system with the 1(1256 flight director gyro, priced at $20,000, and the KCS55A slaved compass system with HSI for $17,000, but we can't see why anyone would do that. If you have an existing KFC200, a KFC225 could be an easier retrofit than starting from scratch, since some of the existing servo mounts and other supporting hardware might be utilized.
Forget the rumors that Century isn't making autopilots any more. There are four current-production models in the Century lineup and all are compatible with Aspen's EA100 autopilot gyro emulator (it can also replace the 52D-series attitude gyro in vintage CII, III and IV autopilots).
Century's Alan Flewitt says the company holds more autopilot STCs (over 1600 approvals) than any other autopilot manufacturer. It also offers field and factory support for vintage systems from its headquarters in Mineral Wells, Texas.
The expandable C2000 autopilot remains the company's top selling system, available in a basic single axis or up to a three-axis configuration that Century calls the "Total Solution" model. It has roll, pitch, flight director and yaw damper.
In the basic roll configuration, the C2000 has heading hold/select, VOR, localizer and back course intercept and track. When interfaced with an HSI, the system is designed to intercept a course at shallow angles, but when equipped with a traditional CDI there's an automatic 45-degree course intercept function. With GPS steering, a $2854 option, the system will intercept a GPS course and approach at any angle.
The pitch expansion option adds altitude hold, attitude cornmand, glideslope capturing and tracking, control wheel steering and pitch trim prompting. Altitude hold systems that have trim prompting warn the pilot when the aircraft is out of trim so they can manually trim the pitch axis. Automatic electric pitch trim, requiring an additional trim servo, takes care of that chore automatically.
If there's a downside to installing the C2000, it's the amount of radio stack space that's required to accommodate the 2.25-inch-tall control head. Century's solution to this is the $20,000 C4000 and $16,500 Triden systems. These are similar to the C2000 (using the same model servos) but have different control heads (the C4000 uses a Dzus 43r : rail mount while the Triden fits in a 3-inch ATI cutout). While these systems currently have limited STC approvals, adding an aircraft on a case-by-case basis could be easy.
Flew itt says since the C2000, Triden and C4000 all fly exactly the same way, the FAA doesn't require demonstration flight testing for approval. That saves a huge amount of time in the approval process. While the SIC list is growing, current applications include the Cessna 182 and 421, Beech Bonanza and Piper Comanche.
Both the C4000 and Triden systems have, in our view, busy displays. There are no fewer than 20 mode annunciators in the C4000. But then again, it has a lot of modes, including integral GPS steering, vertical speed select and hold, plus glideslope capturing (from either above or below the glideslope--a useful feature that many systems don't have).
S-Tec's entry-level model is the $9793 System 20. It's esssentially a wing leveling and nay tracking system that's integrated into a turn coordinator/controller, with optional heading command (requiring a compatible directional gyro, HSI or PFD). There's also an optional $2300 ST-901 GPSS system. S-Tec offers an upgrade for adding altitude hold to the system, requiring a pitch computer, pitch servo and pressure transducer. This makes it the System 30 with trim prompting.
Other basic models include the panel-mounted System 40 and 50, using a separate turn coordinator and controller. These systems are nearly identical to the System 20 and 30, except for mounting (none will support automatic trim). The way we see it, there's little advantage buying the two-piece 40 or 50 system unless you want localizer backcourse tracking, a function that's lacking in the 40 and 50. On the other hand, the System 50 is all self-contained, with a pitch computer built into the console. The System Thirty requires the installation of a remote pitch computer--increasing the labor effort.
STEC's flagship retrofit system is the 55X, with self-contained computer/controller. It has vertical speed command, nay tracking and glideslope capturing, GPSS and it supports automatic electric pitch trim (a $5500 option). There's also the optional SA-200 altitude prese-lect/alerter with voice callouts. At $11,733, it includes a new United Instruments encoding altimeter. The $5710 ST-360 alerter is available, with less automation and more complex feature set.
The System 60-2 is aimed at larger aircraft and has remote pitch and roll guidance computers. It has many of the features of the 55X, less GPSS.
For add-on altitude hold, there's the PSS (pitch stabilization system). It supports automatic pitch trim and has glideslope capturing. The System Thirty Alt is also a stand-alone altitude hold system, less autotrim and glideslope interface.
Avidyne's DI.C90 plug-and-play retrofit autopilot is designed to drive S-Tec servo actuators, while plugging into an existing S-Tec 55X mounting rack and wiring harness. What's compelling about a DFC90 upgrade is transitioning from the S-Tec's analog, rate-based concept to a digital attitude-based platform. It interfaces with the Al-IRS in Avidyne's Entegra or Aspen's Evolution PFD. This means earlier Cirrus models, to name one high-performance application, will benefit from the DFC90.
If you've flown a Cirrus that's equipped with an S-Tec 55, you might have noticed sloppy approach coupling and tracking, especially in strong winds. The DFC90 solves these issues, based on our evaluation. It also steps the interface up a few notches, with airspeed hold that's commanded on the airspeed bug of the PFD. Unlike the 55X, the DFC90 doesn't require manual arming of its GPSS mode. It automatically engages GPSS mode when you're tracking a GPS course. There's also a fully functional flight director.
The other draw is envelope protection, including a straight-and-level mode that recovers from unusual attitudes (recovering to wings-level from 60 degrees of bank and 30 degrees of pitch). The DFC won't let the aircraft get too slow or too fast, pitching up or down accordingly.
We like the DFC9Os ergonomic design, with mode logic designed for an easy transition from a 55X. But don't expect a while-you-wait drop-in installation. Most existing Entegra and Evolution PFD systems will need to be upgraded--running anywhere from $3500-$6000--on top of the $9990 cost for the autopilot computer. Installation might cost $1500 to $2000, including flight testing.
Avidyne recently added STC approval for the DFC90 and Aspen Evolution combination for a wide variety of Beech Bonanza applications, as well as approval for some models of the Cessna 182.
The key is selecting the proper autopilot for your mission and airframe. Since an autopilot will likely expand your mission, consider one with advanced approach capability, especially if instrument flying is your plan. For higher-end aircraft, accept that pricier, higher-end autopilots will be better suited than entry-level models. This includes models with autotrim, yaw damper and attitude-based control logic.
For tighter budgets and lighter airframes, the S-Tec 20 is our top pick if you can live without altitude hold. You can always upgrade later by adding the additional components. The Avidyne DFC90/Aspen Evolution combination wins for performance. With a growing STC list, it could be the easiest way to advanced functionality at a lower cost.
There's a wide variety of autopilot models to choose from.
Digital AHRS improves autopilot reliability and performance.
Even an entry-level autopilot upgrade is a major investment.
Avidyne's DFC90 digital autopilot computer, top photo, takes an input from Avidyne's Entegra or Aspen's PFD. It's designed to drive S-Tec servos, while utilizing the existing wiring.
Century Flight Systems
RELATED ARTICLE: DIGITIZED FLIGHT CONTROL
IMadbilid-MMI II While Honeywell's KFC225 is a digital autopilot, it was born in the era of the KI256 spinning attitude gyro, an analog pitch and roll source. Despite some reliability issues early on, the KFC225 and KI256 did a stellar job of flying all of the aircraft for which it was approved. But drop an AHRS-based (attitude heading reference system) digital gyro emulator in the mix (Garmin's GAD43 or Aspen's EA100) and the KFC225 becomes nearly a complete digital system, with a level of performance and reliability no rate-based system can touch. While the GAD43 and EA100 are digital-to-analog converters, receiving digital pitch, roll and yaw data in, and then outputting analog data to the autopilot, sourcing a digital reference has safety and maintenance advantages.
Because an autopilot that's driven by a failed mechanical gyro will likely remain engaged--flying erroneous pitch and roll commands--digital gyro emulators have built-in health monitoring algorithms that will immediately disengage the autopilot if an AHRS fault is detected. Through software, digital gyro emulators make calibration and configuration easier and more precise, allowing technicians to precisely set autopilot bank angles and flight director command bar voltages without having to perform time-consuming spinning gyro alignments. That means less down time.
AUTOPILOT SYSTEMS COMPARED SYSTEM FLIGHT AXIS THEORY MOUNTING MAJOR FUNCTIONS S-TEC 20 ROLL ROLLP RATE-BASED TURN NAVTRACK, S-TEC 30 ITCH COORD ENROUTE/LOC APPROACH ONLY S-TEC 40 ROLL ROLL, RATE-BASED PANEL NAV TRACK, S-TEC 50 PITCH CUTOUT ENROUTE/LOC APPROACH ONLY S-TEC 55X ROLL, PITCH, RATE-BASED RADIO GS TRIM STACK CAPTURE/TRACK, VERTICAL SPEED COMMAND S-TEC 60-2 ROLL, PITCH, RATE-BASED PANEL GS TRIM CUTOUT CAPTURE/TRACK, PITCH COMMAND S-TEC 60PSS PITCH, TRIM PRESSURE PANEL STANDALONE ALT CUTOUT HOLD, GSCAPTURE.VS COMMD. S-TEC 30ALT PITCH PRESSURE PANEL STANDALONE ALT SWITCH HOLDJRIM PROMPT BENDIX/KING ROLL, PITCH, ATTITUDE RADIO ALT PRESELECT.GS KFC225 TRIM, YAW STACK CAPTURE, VOICE PROMPT CENTURY 2000 ROLL, ATTITUDE RADIO ATTITUDE BASED EXPANDABLE STACK COMPATIBLE WITH PITCH ASPEN CENTURYTRIDEN ROLL, PITCH, ATTITUDE PANEL INSTRUMENT TRIM, YAW CUTOUT CUTOUT CONTROLLER, LCD CENTURY 4000 ROLL.PITCH, ATTITUDE RADIO DZUS-MOUNT LED TRIM, YAW STACK CONTROLLER, GPSS AVIDYNE DFC90 ROLL, PITCH, ATTITUDE RADIO ENVELOPE TRIM STACK PROTECTION, DRIVES S TEC SERVOS SYSTEM PRICE S-TEC 20 $9783 S-TEC 30 $15,589 S-TEC 40 $9994 S-TEC 50 $16,014 S-TEC 55X $24,867 S-TEC 60-2 $21,436 S-TEC60PSS $12,556 S-TEC 30ALT $8345 BENDIX/KING $30,000 KFC225 CENTURY 2000 $13,298 CENTURYTRIDEN $14,439 CENTURY 4000 $19,995 AVIDYNE DFC90 $9990
|Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback|
|Publication:||The Aviation Consumer|
|Date:||Feb 1, 2014|
|Previous Article:||From Sleaze to truth.|
|Next Article:||Turbochargers: care and feeding: careful engine operation and preventive maintenance should allow a turbo to last well over 1000 hours. good...|