Report turns "economy-versus-environment" argument on its head.
Attempts to place a monetary value on nature have been criticized by those who believe that such valuation commoditizes and cheapens what is in truth immeasurable. In practice, however, people regularly assign value to nature in the choices they make. The problem is that in normal practice nature is generally not valued unless it is converted to something. Forests, for example, are not assigned value except to the extent they are turned into timber. With a zero value, nature has almost always been the loser in standard economic equations. As the authors of the new study point out, "the decisions we make about ecosystems imply valuations (although not necessarily expressed in monetary terms). We can choose to make these valuations explicit or not...but as long as we are forced to make choices, we are going through the process of valuation." The study has raised eyebrows among some traditional economists, who are accustomed to keeping environmental values "external" to their calculations.
The reported estimate of $33 trillion may be conservative. Values for some biomes (such as mountains, arctic tundra, deserts, urban parks) were not included. Furthermore, the authors note that as ecosystem services become more scarce in the future, their economic value will only increase.
The new report is a breakthrough in establishing the economic importance of nature's services in supporting human economies. It should prove useful to development planners, economists, and policymakers who face the daily task of assigning some value to nature and making choices about its future. For researchers, it is a virtual encyclopedia of disparate studies on this new and evolving field. For more information on this topic see "Valuing Nature's Services" in State of the World 1997 and an upcoming feature article in WORLD WATCH.
|Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback|
|Author:||Abramovitz, Janet N.|
|Date:||Sep 1, 1997|
|Previous Article:||Elephants of southern Africa must now "pay their way."|
|Next Article:||New measures of material consumption.|
|A healthy environment and a healthy economy can go hand-in-hand.|
|How copywriters turn words into dollars.|
|Letter to the editor.|
|A case of bad timing.|
|Summertime and the living's ... easy?|