Rapid diagnosis of pneumococcal meningitis and pneumonia with synpneumonic effusion using a novel streptococcus pneumoniae immunochromatographic assay.
There are a number of problems associated with demonstrating the microbial etiology of the infectious process by conventional methods. For instance, only one third of the patients produce sputum suitable for culture, and the results lack specificity due to nasopharyngeal carriage of Pneumococci in healthy individuals. (1, 2, 3) Although blood cultures are specific, they have low positivity rates of less than 10%. Pneumonia cases are associated with pleural effusion (4) and a pathogen is recovered in less than half of those patients who undergo diagnostic pleural tap. (5) Finally many patients are pretreated with an antibiotic which decreases the diagnostic yield by culture. (6)
The need for improved speed and accuracy in etiologic diagnosis of Streptococcus pneumoniae infection has led to the development of a rapid urinary assay for detecting pneumococcal cell wall components common to all 92 serotypes namely the NOW assay, (BINAX; Scarborough, ME). (7) It has also been validated with cerebrospinal and pleural fluid. (8) The Binax NOW S. pneumoniae test is an in vitro rapid immuno chromatographic assay for the detection of S. pneumoniae antigen in the urine of adult patients with pneumonia and in the cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) and pleural fluid of patients of all ages, with meningitis and pleural effusion. In conjunction with culture and other methods, it is intended to aid in the diagnosis of both pneumococcal pneumonia and pneumococcal meningitis.
The aim of the study was to ascertain the usefulness of Binax NOW test when performed on CSF and pleural fluid, and provide information on the findings of semi-automated culture for the identification of S. pneumoniae.
METHODOLOGY: The study was carried out by the Department of Microbiology, over a period of 24 months from February 2009 to January 2011. Paediatric patients in the age group of 28 days to 60 months, presenting to the department of paediatrics of three different teaching hospitals, with synpneumonic effusions and suspected bacterial meningitis were prospectively included in the study. A detailed history and consent was obtained from the parent accompanying the child. Clearance was obtained from the institutional Ethics Committee before the start of the study.
In patients with synpneumonic effusions, thoracocentesis was performed and pleural fluid was taken for estimation of protein, sugar, cell count, cell type, C-reactive protein (CRP), Gram's stain and culture and antimicrobial susceptibility. In patients with meningitis lumbar puncture was done and CSF used for estimation of the same parameters as with pleural fluid. Both pleural fluid and CSF were stored at -700 C for pneumococcal antigen detection. Pleural fluid samples with positive ICT were also subjected to Polymerase chain reaction (PCR). Cultures were performed using semi-automated BACTEC 9050 from BD, while identification and sensitivity (Minimum Inhibitory Concentration--MIC) was done using automated walkaway 40 system from Siemens.
Streptococcus pneumoniae antigen detection in pleural fluid and CSF was performed using the Binax NOW[R] for S. pneumoniae, Scarborough, ME, USA. The frozen samples were thawed to room temperature. In Binax NOW[R] Streptococcus pneumonia test (2), rabbit antipneumococcal antibody is adsorbed onto a nitro cellulose membrane (the sample line), and goat anti-rabbit IgG is adsorbed onto the same membrane as a second stripe (the control line). A second set of rabbit anti pneumococcal antibodies are conjugated to gold particles and dried onto an inert fibrous support. A swab is dipped into the specimen (CSF/ pleural fluid) and inserted into the test device and a citrate buffer is added to facilitate antigen flow and the device is closed. If pneumococcal antigen is present in the specimen, it binds to the gold--conjugated rabbit antibodies and the resulting complex is captured by the immobilised rabbit IgG stripe, forming the sample line. In addition, immobilized goat anti-rabbit IgG captures excess conjugated rabbit antibody, forming the control line. Results are read visually (pink line) after 15 minutes, with the appearance of the control line only signifying a negative test and the appearance of both the control and sample lines signifying a positive test (Figure 1).
RESULTS: The study population included 104 paediatric patients (62 males and 42 females, aged between 28 days and 60 months) with suspicion of bacterial meningitis and bacterial pneumonia with pleural effusion. Diagnosis was based on clinical signs and symptoms, laboratory investigations (increased WBC count, elevated CRP levels in both blood and CSF /pleural fluids, cytology and biochemical tests of the fluids and Gram's stain of the fluid) and radiological diagnosis in case of pneumonia. There were 90 patients with suspected bacterial meningitis and 14 with bacterial pneumonia with pleural effusion. The ICT result was positive in 19 of 104 samples. Of the 90 CSF samples 10 were Binax--NOW positive and of the 14 pleural fluid samples, 9 were positive. The distribution of the different test results are shown in Table 1. Using culture and ICT alone-Of the total 19 cases which were positive, 6 patients were culture positive for S. pneumoniae either in blood or body fluid or both. Among these 6 patients, three patients grew S. pneumoniae both in the blood and body fluid. Of the 13 patients in whom S. pneumoniae was negative in culture, 3 patients were positive for non-pneumococcal organisms (Streptococcus mitis-1, Staphylococcus epidermidis-1 and Pseudomonas spp-1), of the remaining 10 patients, no organisms were grown either in the blood or body fluid. Of the 85 patients in whom the ICT was negative, none of these patients had S. pneumoniae grown either in blood, CSF or pleural fluid.
Using Gram's stain and ICT alone--of the 19 cases which were ICT positive, 9 patients showed pus cells and Gram positive cocci in pairs and short chains in Gram's smear of the fluid, while the 85 patients with ICT negative results showed neither pus cells nor any organisms. Of the 104 patients, 18 were on antibiotic treatment before hospital admission. 6 of them had a positive ICT result (33%), while of the remaining 86, who were not on prior antibiotic treatment, 13 had a positive ICT result (15%). There were 4 patients who had received antibiotic and were culture negative but positive for Binax NOW ICT assay.
DISCUSSION: The detection of pneumococcal antigen in cerebrospinal fluid, (10) sputum and broncho-alveolar lavage (BAL) fluid (12) specimens as a method in diagnosis of pneumococcal infection has been previously documented. However, it is not performed commonly in pleural fluid samples (13, 14 8). Earlier studies have used a variety of techniques, such as counter immuno electrophoreses, agglutination tests and enzyme immunoassays to identify S. pneumoniae polysaccharide capsular antigen in pleural fluid samples. (15,16,17) But these methods are laborious and time-consuming, when compared to the NOW method used in this study, which is a rapid and simple ICT test with a reported sensitivity of 50 to 80% and a high specificity for the detection of S. pneumoniae antigen up to 1 month after pneumonia onset with results available in just 15 minutes. (18,19,20)
As is evident from this study, the use of ICT led to greater increases in pneumococcal positivity yields, compared to culture alone, in patients with prior antimicrobial treatment than in those without. Patients who had received antibiotics prior to the lumbar puncture / pleural tap were less likely to have viable organisms in their CSF/ pleural fluid for isolation on culture, thus enhancing the value of non culture based tools such as the Binax ICT in these patients. Overall when compared to culture, the sensitivity of ICT in the present study was 100% (6/6) and specificity was 89.5% (85/95).
In our study, the ICT results on pleural fluid samples confirms its excellent sensitivity of 100% (2 of 2) and moderate specificity of 58% (7 of 12) for the diagnosis of pneumococcal pneumonia. The addition of the pleural ICT test allowed the detection in 9/14 (64%) cases of pneumococcal pneumonia as compared to pleural culture alone 2/14 (14%). All the 9 pleural fluid samples which were ICT positive were subjected to polymerase chain reaction (PCR) which was also positive for S. pneumoniae. Although PCR may be useful in this setting but it is time consuming, expensive and requires specially trained staff.
In the 90 patients with suspected bacterial meningitis, 10 samples of CSF were positive by ICT test. However, only in four of these patients could we culture S. pneumoniae from blood and CSF. Thus, there were 6 patients with a positive Binax Now test and a negative culture. At the same time S. pneumoniae was not cultured from any patient in whom Binax-Now was negative. The possible explanation for this could be that Binax-Now is more sensitive in detection of pneumococcal pneumonia from CSF, or that it could be having low specificity. To determine this, further studies and data may be required and probably also PCR to detect pneumococcal antigen in CSF to help determine the usefulness of this test in the diagnosis of pneumococcal meningitis.
We observed false-positive results in 3 patients due to micro organisms other than S pneumoniae, namely S. mitis, Staph. epidermidis and Pseudomonas spp. This finding can be explained by the cross reactivity of cell wall antigen components among the genus Streptococcus. As for Staph. epidermidis and Pseudomonas spp., they may have been probable skin contaminants, as these patients recovered fully after a course of antibiotics and second sample of fluid could not be drawn. Another probability of so called false positive results of the ICT noted may have actually been caused by mixed infections. (19)
In our study the ICT results in comparison to culture, showed 100% sensitivity and 89.5% specificity. Other studies have also shown excellent sensitivity and specificity with ICT results. A study by Jose M. Porcel et al showed 70.6% sensitivity of ICT results on pleural fluid samples and specificity of 93.3% (21). In another study, Ploton et al showed in a paediatric population, the NOW test result to be positive in all 15 pleural fluid samples yielding S. pneumoniae in culture (14). In yet another study by J C Moisi et al, compared to culture the Binax NOW S. pneumoniae ICT was >99% sensitive for the diagnosis of pneumococcal meningitis. (9)
Based on our results, ICT was positive in 6/18 patients (33%) who were on prior antibiotic treatment as compared to 13/86 (15%) who had no prior exposure to antibiotics. These results are similar to what was reported by Marie Gisselssen Solen et al (22). In the study by J C Moise et al also, the prior use of antibiotics did not adversely affect the ICT results (24.2% with prior antibiotic use versus 12.2% without) (9). There are studies which do not concur with this as seen in the study by Gutierrez et al (19). Thus based on our study it may be inferred that prior exposure to antibiotics does not alter the results of ICT. This will have clinical implications as it is not uncommon for patients to be started on antibiotic therapy before they present at a secondary or a tertiary care centre.
In conclusion, detection of the pneumococcal antigen by the Binax NOW S. pneumoniae ICT in pleural fluid/ CSF is easy, quick and makes treatment of complicated pneumonia and meningitis suitable and early. Some of its advantages are its high sensitivity and specificity in CSF and pleural fluid, which make it ideal as a point of care test, requiring minimal equipment and expertise. The test is rapid and portable, taking just 15 minutes for test results. The kit is stable at 15 -25[degrees]C and its sensitivity is less affected by prior antibiotic use when compared to culture. Some of the disadvantages of the test are its high costs, false positivity due to cross reactions with other related bacteria, persistence of positive results up to one month after an acute infection may create confusion in cases of recurrent multiple infections and in children where nasopharyngeal carriage of S. pneumoniae is common urine samples cannot be used as test samples because these organisms are excreted in the urine. More data is required to determine its sensitivity in detecting pneumococcal infections to decide whether this would be a cost-effective tool or not.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT: I sincerely thank Dr. Gopi A for helping me in the preparation of the manuscript and Dr. Sumati Muralidhar for reviewing the article and for her valuable suggestions.
1. Lentino JR, Sucks DA. Non value of sputum culture in the management of lower respiratory tract infections. J Clin Microbiol 1987; 25:758-762.
2. Chalasani NP, Valdecanas MA, Gopal, AK, McGowan JE Jr, Jurado RL. Clinical utility of blood cultures in adult patients with community acquired pneumonia without defined underlying risk. Chest 1995; 108: 932-936.
3. Campbell SG, Marrie TJ, Anstey R, Dickinson G, Ackrovd-Stolarz. S. The contribution of blood culture to the clinical management of adult patients admitted to the hospital with community--acquired pneumonia: a prospective observational study. Chest 2003; 123: 1142-1150.
4. Fine MJ, Aubble TF, Yealy DM, Hanusa BH, Weissfeld LA, Singer DE et al. A prediction rule to identify low-risk patients with community-acquired pneumonia. N Engl J Med 1977; 336: 243-250.
5. Porcel JM, Vives M, Esquerda A, Agustin Ruiz. Usefulness of the British Thoracic Society and the American college of Chest Physicians guidelines in predicting pleural drainage of non-purulent parapneumonic effusions. Respir Med 2006; 100: 933-937.
6. Korsgaard J, Moller JK, Kilian M. Antibiotic treatment and the diagnosis of Streptococcus pneumonia in lower respiratory tract in adults. Int J Infect dis 2005; 9: 274-279.
7. Smith MD, Derrington P, Evans R, Creek M, Morris R, Dance DA et al. Rapid diagnosis of bacteremic pneumococcal infections in adults by using the Binax NOW streptococcus pneumonia urinary antigen test: a prospective controlled clinical evaluation. J clin Microbiology 2003; 41: 2810-2813.
8. Andreo F, Dominguez J, Ruiz--Manzano J, Prat C, Blanco S, Lores L et al. Usefulness of antigen detection in pleural fluid by immunochromatographic assay for diagnosis for pneumococcal pneumonia. Clin Microbiol Infect 2006; 12: 682-684.
9. JC Moise, SK Saha, AG Falade, BM Njanpop--Lafourcade, J Oundo, AKM Zaidi et al. Enhanced diagnosis of pneumococcal meningitis using the Binax NOW S. Pneumonia immunochromatographic test: a multi site study. Clin Infect Dis 2009; 48 (suppl 2): S49-S56.
10. Samara Z, Shmuely H, Naheem E, Dina Paqhis, Josef Ben--Ari. Uses of the NOW Streptococcus pneumoniae urinary antigen test in cerebrospinal fluid for rapid diagnosis of pneumococcal meningitis. Diag Microbiol Infect Dis 2003; 45: 237-240.
11. Zhang XP, Deng KE, Ye YQ, Luo WTl. Rapid detection of pneumococcal antigen in sputum in patients with community acquired pneumonia by Coagglutination. Med Microbiol Immunol (Berl) 1988; 177: 333-338.
12. Jacobs JA, Stobberingh EE, Cornelissen EI, Elisa I, M Cornelissen, Marjolein Drent. Detection of Streptococcus pneumonia antigens in bronchoalveolar lavage fluid samples by a rapid immunochromatographic membrane assay. J Clin Micrbiol 2005; 43: 4037-4040.
13. Le Monier A, Carbonnelle E, Zahar JR, Muriel Le Bourgeols, Eric Abachin, Gilles Quesne et al. Microbiological diagnosis of empyema in children: comparative evaluation by culture, polymerase chain reaction, and pneumococcal antigen detection in pleural fluids. Clin infect Dis 2006; 42: 1136-1140.
14. Ploton C, Freydiere AM, Benito Y, Bendridi N, Mazzocchi C, Bellon G et al. Streptococcus pneumonia thoracic empyema in children: rapid diagnosis by using the Binax NOW immunochromatographic membrane test in pleural fluids. Pathol Biol (Paris) 2006: 54: 498-501.
15. Martinez-Vazquez C, Pedreira JD, Cabre-Verdiel J, Miquel C, de Buen ML, Gallart MT et al. Etiolgical diagnosis of pneumococcal pneumonia by counter immunoelectrophoresis. Med Clin (Barc) 1979; 73: 324-326.
16. Boersma WG, Lowenberg A, Holloway Y, Kuttschrutter H, Snider JA, Koeter GH. Rapid detection of pneumococcal antigen in pleural fluid of patients with community acquired pneumonia. Thorax 1993; 48: 160-162.
17. Requejo HI, Guerra ML, Dos Santos M, Cocozza AMl. Immunodiagnosis of community acquired pneumonia in childhood. J Trop Pediatr 1997; 43: 208-212.
18. Genne D, Siegriest HH, Lienhard R. Enhancing the etiologic diagnosis of community acquired pneumonia in adults using the urinary antigen assay (Binax NOW). Int J Infect Dis 2006; 10: 124-128.
19. Guttierrez F, Masia M, Rodriguez JC, Antonio Ayelo, Bernardo Soldan, Laura Cebrean et al. Evaluation of the immunochromatographic Binax NOW assay of community acquired pneumonia in Spain. Clin Infect Dis 2003; 36: 286-292.
20. Marcos MA, Jimenez de Anta MT, de la Ballacasa JP, J. Gonzalex, E. Martinez, E. Garcia et al. Rapid urinary antigen test for diagnosis of pneumococcal community acquired pneumonia in adults. Eur Respir J 2003; 21: 209-214.
21. Jose M Porcel, Augustin Ruiz-Gonzalez, Miquel Falguera, Antoni Nogues,Carles Galinda, Jordi Carratala et al. Contribution of a pleural antigen assay (Binax NOW) to the diagnosis of pneumococcal pneumonia. Chest 2007; 131: 1442-1447.
22. Marie Gisselssan-Solen, Anita Bylander, Christina Wilhelmsson, Ann Hermanssen and Asa Mehur. The Binax NOW test as atool for diagnosisiof severe acute otitis media and associated complications. J Clin Microbiol. September 2007; 45: 3003-3007.
Anjana Gopi, Jagadeesh, Ravi Kumar.K. L, Rashmi. M, Ashwini, Shwethalatha Shenoy
[1.] Associate Professor. Department of Microbiology, KIMS Hospital and research centre, Bangalore.
[2.] Professor. Department of Microbiology, KIMS Hospital and research centre, Bangalore.
[3.] Professor & Head. Department of Microbiology, KIMS Hospital and research centre, Bangalore.
[4.] Consultant Microbiologist. Department of Microbiology, Gokula Metropolis diagnostic Laboratory, MSRMH, Bangalore.
[5.] SRF, Pnuemonet lab, Department of Microbiology, KIMS Hospital and research centre, Bangalore.
[6.] SRF, Pnuemonet lab, Department of Microbiology, KIMS Hospital and research centre, Bangalore.
Dr Anjana Gopi, Aanchal, 19/33-1, 1st main road, 2nd cross, Jayamahal extention, Bangalore--560046.
TABLE 1: Distribution of different test results Samples CSF Pleural Fluid Total 90 14 Increased WBC 51 09 Blood CRP positive 60 14 Fluid CRP positive nil 14 Blood culture positive 04 01 Fluid culture positive 02 02 Gram positive cocci in pairs or chains 03 06 Increased protein and decreased sugar 07 10 Binax NOW positive 10 09
|Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback|
|Title Annotation:||ORIGINAL ARTICLE|
|Author:||Gopi Anjana; Jagadeesh; Ravi, Kumar K.L.; Rashmi, M.; Ashwini; Shenoy, Shwethalatha|
|Publication:||Journal of Evolution of Medical and Dental Sciences|
|Article Type:||Clinical report|
|Date:||May 6, 2013|
|Previous Article:||A comparative study of dermatoglyphics (finger tip pattern) in patients with myocardial infarction and control group.|
|Next Article:||Outcome of cataract surgery in a soft eyeball.|