REDESCRIPTION OF TWO MILKWEED BUTTERFLIES OF GENUS DANAUS, KULK.
Two species of genus Danaus Kluk (1802), Danaus chrysippus Linnaeus (1758) and Danaus genutia Cramer (1779), commonly called monarchs, queens and milkweed butterflies are re-described. This re-description is based on coloration of wings, structure of mouthparts, maxillary palpi and internal male and female genitalia. The occurrence of these species of butterflies is new record from Jamshoro, Sindh, Pakistan.
Keywords: Re-description, Butterflies, Danaus KULK, Jamshoro, Sindh.
The genus Danaus Kluk (1804) belongs to subfamily Danainae (Nymphalidae: Lepidoptera) commonly called Monarchs, Queens and Milkweed butterflies. By the end of the 18th century, four species of genus Papilio (Papilio chrysippus L., Papilio plexippus L., Papilio genutia Cramer and Papilio gilippus Cramer) which are now included in Old World species of genus Danaus Ackery and Vane-Wright (1984). During the nineteenth century European taxonomists especially from German added five further Old World species under the different generic names Danais Latreille, Danaida Latreille, Euploea Fabricius and Limnas HA1/4bner, finally Danaus was considered as a genus. Eleven species of Danaus species are now recognized Ackeryand Vane- Wright (1984). Out of eleven species, five old world species found in Australia, other five species are distributed worldwide and one species Danaus chrysippus L. is cosmopolitan.
Danaus is divided into three subgenera, Danaus that comprises three species, Salatura Moore comprises four species and Anosia HA1/4bner comprises four species. Species of the genus Danaus are most noticeable and abundant among all recorded butterflies; all the species are medium to large size and multicolored, such as orange, yellow or brown with black and white marking Larsen (1977, 1984). Mostly other group of the milkweed butterflies dwells in the forest, but species of the genus Danaus found in open country, ranging from semi-desert to light woodland and coastal areas. The color of Danaus and their bad taste serves as defense mechanism therefore predators avoid to eat them (Brower et al., 1967).
Jamshoro district has variable geographical conditions such as semi desert, agriculture areas and revirine belt along with river Indus. To keep in mind such variable habitats, it was need to work on the genus Danaus.
The larvae of these species feed on milkweed, which grows throughout Jamshoro. Many scholars carried out research on the butterfly fauna throughout the world including Pakistan; they reported different species of Danaus on morphological characters. Due to climatic change, pollution and use of pesticides the species of butterflies going to decline. Therefore, there was great need to work on the species of Danaus to know their recent status and these species are redescribed on the basis of morphological characters along with male and female genitalia.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The specimens were collected from the different localities of district Jamshoro. The terminology followed of Ehrlich (1958), with modifications from the classical and recent literature for the Lepidoptera Matsuda (1976); Scoble (1992); Mielke et al. (2004); Paluch et al. (2008); Leite et al. (2010 a, b, 2011). Color patterns were identified, following the descriptions of Owen et al. (1994). For the examination of male and female genitalia, the abdomen of the specimen was removed from the body, boiled into 10% potassium hydroxide (KOH) for five minutes. The abdomen was dissected with the help of fine pointed forceps from lateral side, genitalia was separated from abdomen, washed with tap water and then examined under the dissecting microscope. Genital material was preserved into micro vial with a drop of Glycerin and pinned with specimen. Genital terminology is followed of Klots (1970) and Winter (2000). All measurements were taken in millimeters.
The measurements of various parts of the body were taken with the help of an ocular micro millimeter and illustration was made by using ocular graph on the dissecting microscope.
Genus Danaus KLUK (1804)
Coloration: Head black with tufts of white scales, antennae and proboscis black, maxillary palpi covered with white and black scales; thorax black with white spots, fore and hind wings tawny; abdomen yellow.
Shape: Head round, antennae slender without scales, gradually clavate but without a distinct club-shaped, eyes large, maxillary palpi well developed, slightly compressed, proboscis long and highly coiled; thorax, fore wings simple, terminal margins never dentate or caudate, hind wings with terminal margin never dentate, cell closed, with patches of modified scales around the cell; legs with tibia as long as the femur with long hairs, in females wide and club-shaped, with four segments, all firmly joined together; abdomen slender. Key to the species of genus Danaus KLUK (1804) of Pakistan
1. Fore wing tawny with black boarder, apical half of the wing black with white bands; hind wing tawny, black boarder with two irregular series of white spots, inmale under side black and white spot; veins marked with black bands; apophysis posterior, thorn - like; ductus bursae long; corpus bursae balloon like with rod like cornuti (Fig. 1)Danaus genutia Linnaeus --- Fore wing bright orange with black border, apical half of the wing black with white spots but shape of spots not as above ...........2
2. Hind wing bright orange, outer border black with two regular series of white spots, upper side one black spot in male; veins prominently marked with black bandsDanaus plexippus Linnaeus --- Hind wing tawny, outer boarder black with one series of white spots; veins without black bands.................................................................................3
3. Fore wing tawny with black boarder; hind wing tawny, black boarder with one series of white spots; corpus bursae stumpy; corpus bursae balloon like with plate like cornuti (Fig. 2) Danaus chrysippus Cramer --- Fore wing furiginous black with very broad subhyaline streaks and bluish white spots; apophysis rod like, corpus bursae bean shaped Danaus limniace Cramer
Coloration: Head black, white spotted with tufts of white scales, eyes brownish black, antennae and proboscis black, maxillary palpi covered with black and white large scales; thorax black with white spots, forewings, ground color tawny, upperside brighter than underside, half of the apical part black with white bands, veins marked with broad black bands, costal margin, apex and terminal margin black with semicircular white spots, hind wings, ground color tawny, upperside brighter than underside, veins marked with broad black bands, apex and terminal margin black with two rows of semicircular white spots; abdomen yellowish.
Shape: Head (Fig. 1c): Head round, eyes large, antennae slender, without scales, maxillary palpi well developed, third segment small, proboscis large, highly coiled.
Thorax: Fore Wing (Fig. 1d): Triangular, longer than hind wing, costa widely arched, apex round, termen slightly concave, discoidal cell elongated, covered half length of wing; veins, Sc (Subcosta) arises from the base of wing, ending at the middle of the costal margin, R (Radial) arises next to and parallel to Sc, at distally forks into R1 and Rs, later being divided into R2, R3, R4 and R5, R2 and R3 parallel and ending before apex of the cell, R4 ending at the apex of the cell, R5 ending on the terminal margin, M1 begins from upper apex of discal cell, M2 begins from middle of the discal cell, M3 begins from lower apex of the discal cell, Cu1 and Cu2begin separately from discal cell for an unequal distance, A2 arises from the axillary region, separately from the distal cell up to the tornus of the wing.
Hind Wing (Fig. 1e-1f): Somewhat oval shaped, costa straight, termen sinuated, dorsum straight, discoidal cell more than half length of the wing; veins, Sc+ R1arises from the axillary region, short and separated from R1, humeral (h) curves toward the proximal region of the costal margin begins from Sc+R1 and Rs, M1 originated from upper apex of the discal cell, M2 originates from middle of the discal cell, M3 originates from lower apex of the cell, Cu1 parallel to Cu2, two veins A2 and A3arise from the axillary of the wing, A2 ending at the tornus of wing, A3 ending at dorsal margin.
Abdomen: Abdomen slender, a pair of protrusible brushes of hairs at the abdomen end of male Male genitalia (Fig. 1g): Symmetrical, Uncus sclerotised, elongated downward curved, slender at apex, tegumen short, broad dorsally, saccus V-shaped, valva elongated, basal part narrow, outer margin sinuated, inner margin sinuated with small hair, distally somewhat rounded lobe covered with hair, aedeagus broad, long, curved, anteriorly narrow, posteriorly broad.
Female Genitalia (Fig. 1h): Papillae anal small, somewhat rounded, covered with hair, apophysis posterior large, thorn-like, apophysis anterior reduced, ductus bursae large, highly covered, corpus bursa large, balloon-like with pair of rod-like sclerotised cornuti.
Material examined: 15 and 13, Jamshoro, 23- 24.iii.2013, 16-18.iv.2013. leg. (B. Mal). Deposited at Entomology laboratory, Department of Zoology, University of Sindh.
Comparative notes: Danaus genutia is closely related to Danaus plexippus having veins marked with black bands in both fore andhind wings but differ in having apical of fore wings black with white bands.
Coloration: Head black, white spotted with tufts of white scales, eyes brownish black, antennae black, maxillary palpi covered with black and white large scales; thorax black with white spots, forewings, ground color tawny, upperside brighter than underside, half of the apical part black with white bands, costal margin, apex and terminal margin black with semicircular white spots, hind wings, ground color tawny, upperside brighter than underside, three black spots around the cell, in male one scent- producing white spot with a thick black border in post discal area, apex and terminal margin black with one row of semicircular white spots; abdomen yellowish.
Shape Head (Fig.2c): Head round; antennae slender, eyes large, maxillary palpi well developed, second segment larger than first and third segment, proboscis large, highly coiled.
Thorax: Fore Wing (Fig. 2d): Triangular, slightly longer than hind wing, costa widely arched; apex round, termen slightly concave, discoidal cell closed, elongated, well over half length of wing; veins, Sc (Subcosta) arises from the axillary of the wing, ending at the middle of the costal margin, R (Radial) arises next to and parallel to Sc, at distally forks into R1 and Rs, later being divided into R2, R3, R4 and R5, R2 and R3 ending before apex of the cell, R4 ending at the apex of the cell, R5 ending on the terminal margin, M1 begins from upper angle of discal cell, M2 begins from middle of the discal cell, M3 begins from lower angle of the discal cell, Cu1 and Cu2 begin separately from discal cell for an unequal distance, A2 arises from the axillary region, separately from the distal cell up to the tornus of the wing.
Hind Wing (Fig. 2e): Pear shaped, costa straight, apex round, termen sinuated, dorsum straight, discoidal cell closed, more than half length of the wing; veins, Sc+ R1 arises from the axillary region, short and separated from R1, humeral (h) curves toward the proximal region of the costal margin begins from Sc+R1 and Rs, M1 originated from upper angle of the discal cell, M2 originates from middle of the discal cell, M3 originates from lower angle of the cell, Cu1 parallel to Cu2, two veins A2 and A3 arise from the axillary of the wing, A2 ending at the tornus of wing, A3 ending at dorsal margin.
Abdomen: Abdomen yellowish orange; a pair of protrusible brushes of hairs at the abdomen end of male Male genitalia (Fig. 2f-2g) Uncus sclerotised, curved, slender distally; tegumen broad; juxta plate-like, bilobed; saccus V-shaped, without saccular process; valva broad, outwardly curved, distally cone-shape lobe with small hair; aedeagus broad, rod-like, dorsoventrally curved, dorsally a pair of hex-dentate thecal appendage, ventrally membranous lobe Female Genitalia (Fig. 2h): Papillae anal small, triangular, beset with small scales, apophysis posterior large, thorn-like, apophysis anterior reduced, ductus bursae short, wide, corpus bursa large, balloon-like with pair of plate-like sclerotised cornuti.
Material examined: 23 and 30, Jamshoro, 23- 27.iii.2013, 15-19.iv.2013.leg. (B. Mal). deposited at Entomology laboratory, Department of Zoology, University of Sindh.
Comparative Notes: Danaus chrysippus is closely related to Danaus plexippus having on obvious single scent-patch on hind wing of male but differ in having hind wing with a row of white spots on black terminal margin.
Table No. 1. Measurements of different body parts of Danaus genutia C. (Sample sizen.10)
Body parts of specimens###(Male)###Mean###St. Dev.###(Female)###Mean###St. Dev.
###Range (mm)###(mm)###(mm)###Range (mm)###(mm)###(mm)
Length of head###(2.0-2.4)###2.2###0.14###(2-2.5)###2.26###0.19
Length of thorax###(7.1-7.4)###7.3###0.12###(7.2-7.5)###7.36###0.14
Length of abdomen###(11.9-12.4)###12.1###0.23###(12-12.4)###12.14###0.14
Total body length###(18.8-19.1)###18.27###0.13###(19-19.4)###19.14###0.19
Length of antenna###(12-12.2)###12.06###0.08###(12-12.5)###12.18###0.21
Span of fore wing###(34.8-35)###34.7###0.41###(35-35.4###34.08###0.17
Span of hind wing###(27-27.3)###27.16###0.15###(27-27.5)###27.22###0.22
Sample size of each stage of measurement was ten specimens
Table No. 2. Measurements of different body parts of Danaus chrysippusL.
Body parts of###(Male)###Mean###St. Dev.###(Female)###Mean###St. Dev.
Specimens###Range (mm)###(mm)###(mm)###Range (mm)###(mm)###(mm)
Length of head###(2-2.3)###2.2###0.12###(2-2.4)###2.22###0.14
Length of thorax###(7-7.4)###7.28###0.16###(7-7.4)###7.22###0.16
Length of abdomen###(11.7-12.4)###12.06###0.28###(11.9-12.4)###12.12###0.21
Total body length###(18.8-19.1)###18.9###0.13###(18.9-19.1)###18.9###0.10
Length of antenna###(11.9-12.2)###12.04###0.11###(12-12.3)###12.12###0.13
Span of fore wing###(34.8-35.3)###34.9###0.23###(35-35.4)###35.01###0.14
Span of hind wing###(26.9-27.3)###27.14###0.18###(27-27.4)###27.19###0.17
Sample size of each stage of measurement was ten specimens.
Two species of genus Danaus KLUK (1804) Danaus genutia C. and Danaus chrysippus L. recorded by many researchers from different localities of different provinces of Pakistan viz: Abbas et al. (2000) from Skardu region; Roberts (2001) from different localities of Pakistan; Zahoor et al. (2003) from Faisalabad; Akhtar et al. (2006) from Lahore; Mohammad and Ahmed (2013) from Bahram Dehri (Khyber Agency); Khan et al. (2007) from Azad Kashmir; Tayyab et al. (2012) from Bahawalpur; Parveen and Ahmed (2012, 2014) from Kabal, Swat and Kohat (KPK) and Sajjad and Burhan (2012) from Multan. These species have recorded for the first time from Jamshoro, Sindh. Previously, scholars described these species based on external morphological characters (shape of mouth parts, wing venation and wing coloration etc.), studies of this nature in comparison with presence of large and diverse fauna of butterflies is not sufficient for the taxonomists to distinguish from relative species or subspecies.
Previously they ignored their genital structure, because most of the species are similar in the morphological characters but their genitalia is different from one another that is why these species are described on the basis of the genitalia.
Tables 1 and 2 show that, there was slight difference in body size of Danaus genutia(Cramer) and Danauschrysippus L., and their body color is also same. Sometime through morphological charaters, we cannot identify species of the same genus. Therefore, genital structure of male and female of the species is the most important source in taxonomy for clear identification of the different species and subspecies. Lepidoptera classification is based on genitalia. The shape, structure and dimensions of genital parts as uncus, tegumen, vinculum, vulvae and aedeagus of male and papillae, apophysis, ductus bursae and corpus bursae of female as the major parameters and played vital role in establishing species status. Therefore here we have described and illustrated internal and external male and female genitalia of both species which further provided the distinct differentiation in both species.
Abbreviation: A - Anal vein M- Median vein Aed- Aedeagus Prb- Proboscis Ap.ant- Apophysis anterior R- Radius vein Ap.postApophysis posterior Sac- Saccus C.brs- Corpus bursae Sc- Sub costal Cu- Cubitus Teg- Tegumen D.brs- Ductusbursae Thec.apen- Thecal appendage E- Eye Unc- Uncus H- Humeral Vlv- Valva Max.p- Maxillary palpi
Acknowledgement: Author is highly grateful to the Higher Education Commission for Financial Support for research by Ph.D Fellowship for 5000 Scholars" (Indigenous) Scheme, Batch-VII, (2011).
Abbas, M., M.A. Rafi, M. Inayatullah, M.R. Khan and H. Pavulaan (2002).Taxonomy and distribution of butterflies (Papilionoidea) of the Skardu region, Pakistan. International Lepidoptera survey. 3(9): 01-15.
Ackery, P.R. and R.I. Vane-Wright (1984). Milkweed butterflies. London: British Museum (Natural History).
Akhtar, M.S. and F.T. Butt (2006). Study of seasonal variations of Danaus chrysippus (Linnaeus) from Lahore. Punjab Univ. J. Zool., 21(1-2): 009-017.
Brower, L.P., J.V.Z. Brower and J.M. Corvino (1967).Plant poisons in the terrestrial food chain. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, USA. 57: 893-898.
Ehrlich, P.R. (1958). The integumental anatomy of the monarch butterfly Danaus plexippus L. (Lepidoptera: Danaidae). University of Kansas Science Bulletin 38: 1315-1349.
Haroon, M. and T. Ahmad (2013). Diversity of butterfly fauna of Union Council Koaz Bahram Dheri, Pakistan. J. Entomology and Zoology Studies. 1(6): 113-117.
Khan, M. R., M. A. Rafi, M. Munir, S. Hussain, M.W. Baig and M.W. Khan (2007). Biodiversity of Butterflies from Districts Kotli, Mirpur and Bhimber, Azad Kashmir. Pakistan J. Zool., 39(1): 27-34.
Klots, A.B. (1970). Taxonomist's Glossary of Genitalia in Insects. Lepidoptera of Copenhagen, Munksgaard. 2: 115-130.
Winter, W.D. (2000). Basic techniques for observing and studying moths and butterflies. Lepidopterists' Society, New Haven, CT. 433p.
Larsen, T.B. (1977). Recent expansion in the range of Aporia crataegi (Linnaeus) in east Jordan (Pieridae). Nota Lepidoptrologica 1(1): 19-21.
Larsen, T.B. (1984). Butterflies of Saudi Arabia and its neighbours. London: Stacey International. 161p.
Leite, L.A.R., M.M. Casagrande, and O.H.H. Mielke (2010a). External Morphology of the Adult of Heraclides anchisiades capys (HA1/4bner, 1809) (Lepidoptera Papilionidae). I. Head, cephalic appendages and cervical region. Braz Arch Biol Techn, 53(5): 1119 - 1126.
Leite, L.A.R., M.M. Casagrande and O.H.H. Mielke (2010b). External Morphology of the Adult of Heraclides anchisiadescapys (HA1/4bner, 1809) (Lepidoptera Papilionidae). II. Thorax and thoracic appendages. Brazilian Archives of Biology and Technology. 53(6): 14071416.
Leite, L.A.R., M.M. Casagrande and O.H.H. Mielke (2011). External Morphology of the Adult of Heraclides anchisiades capys(HA1/4bner 1809) (Lepidoptera Papilionidae). III. Abdomen. Brazilian Archives of Biology and Technology. 54(1): 331336.
Owen, D.F., D.A.S. Smith, I.J. Gordon and and A.M. Owiny (1994). Polymorphic MA1/4llerian mimicry in a group of African butterflies: a reassessment of the relationship between Danaus chrysippus, Acraeaen cedon and Acraeaen cedana (Lepidoptera: Nymphalidae). J. Zoo., 232: 3- 108.
Matsuda, R. (1976). Morphology and evolution of the insect abdomen: With special, reference to developmental patterns and their bearings upon systematic. Oxford, Pergamum Press. 435p.
Mielke, C.G.C., O.H.H. Mielke and M.M. Casagrande (2004). Estudocomparado de morfologia externa de Zaretis itys itylus (Westwood) e Agrias claudina anneta (Gray) (Lepidoptera, Nymphalidae, Charaxinae). I. Cabeca, apAndices e regiAPound o cervical. Revista Brasileira de Zoologia. 21: 357-369.
Paluch, M., M.M. Casagrande and O.H.H. Mielke (2008). Morfologia externa do adulto de Actinote melanisans (Lepidoptera: Heliconiinae: Acraeini). Revista Brasileira de Zoologia 25: 456-478.
Perveen, F. and A. Ahmad (2012). Exploring butterfly fauna (Lepidoptera) of Kohat, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, Pakistan. Entomological Studies. 1: 94-107.
Roberts, T.J. (2001). The butterflies of Pakistan. Oxford University Press.
Sajjad, A., S. Saeed and S. Burhan (2012).Yearlong association of butterfly populations with flowering plants in Multan, Pakistan.Pakistan Entomologist. 34 (2): 105-110.
Tayyab, M., A. Suhail and M. Arshad (2006). Biodiversity of lepidopterous insects in agro- forest area of Bahawalpur. Pakistan Entomologist. 28 (2): 25-30.
Winter, W.D. (2000). Basic techniques for observing and studying moths and butterflies.Lepidopterists' Society, New Haven, CT. 433p.
Zahoor, M. K., A. Suhail, J. Iqbal, Z. Zulfaqar and M. Anwar (2003). Biodiversity of Noctuidae (Lepidoptera) in Agro-Forest Area of Faisalabad. Intl. J. Agri. Bio., 5 (4): 560563.
|Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback|
|Publication:||Journal of Animal and Plant Sciences|
|Date:||Jun 30, 2015|
|Previous Article:||BEHAVIOUR ANALYSIS OF BASIC INPUTS PRICES IN IRAN'S LIVESTOCK SUBSECTOR.|
|Next Article:||VIGILANCE BEHAVIOR AND POPULATION DENSITY OF COMMON LARGE HERBIVORES IN A SOUTHERN AFRICAN SAVANNA.|