Pochonia chlamydosporia promotes the growth of tomato and lettuce plants/Pochonia chlamydosporia promove crescimento de tomateiro e alface.
Pochonia chlamydosporia Zare and Gams is one of the most studied biological agents used to control plant-parasitic nematodes. It can produce chlamydospores, which enable it to survive in the soil without additional energy sources (MANZANILLA-LOPEZ et al., 2013). However, the ability of P. chlamydosporia to control endoparasitic nematodes, such as Meloidogyne spp. Goeldi, depends on rhizosphere colonization (MANZANILLA-LOPEZ et al., 2013).
The P. chlamydosporia fungus can colonize the rhizoplane and the internal tissues of the roots of some plants, in the manner of an endophyte (BORDALLO et al., 2002; ESCUDERO; LOPEZ-LLORCA, 2012; MACIA-VICENTE et al., 2009b; MONFORT et al., 2005). Once inside the root tissues, this antagonistic fungus shares the same niche as root-knot nematodes and is less subject to competition from soil microorganisms (ESCUDERO; LOPEZ-LLORCA, 2012). From the perspective of the biocontrol of nematodes, the endophytic colonization of roots by the fungus is a competitive advantage. The majori ty of the putatively highly expressed P. chlamydosporia genes are related to its endophytic behaviour, including the production of hydrolytic enzymes, transporters, proteases, chitinases and a large number of secondary metabolites (LARRIBA et al., 2014). As a result of this interaction with its host, the fungus can enhance the tolerance of the crop to biotic and abiotic stresses and promote plant growth (ESCUDERO; LOPEZ-LLORCA, 2012; MACIA-VICENTE et al., 2009b; MANZANILLA-LOPEZ et al., 2013; MONFORT et al., 2005).
Pochonia chlamydosporia acts as a growth-promoting agent of monocot and dicot crops, such as barley (MACIA-VICENTE et al., 2009b), wheat (MONFORT et al., 2005), lettuce (DIAS-ARIEIRA et al., 2011), pistachio (EBADI et al., 2009) and tomato (ESCUDERO; LOPEZ-LLORCA, 2012). However, the extent to which plant growth is promoted depends on the combination of the crop and the particular P. chlamydosporia isolate (MANZANILLA-LOPEZ et al., 2011).
In a previous study, we screened different isolates of P. chlamydosporia for the ability to manage the root-knot nematode Meloidogyne javanica (DALLEMOLE-GIARETTA et al., 2012). However, little is known about the effects of these isolates on plant growth. Thus, the aims of this study were to evaluate the colonization of tomato and lettuce roots by three isolates of P. chlamydosporia var. chlamydosporia and to characterize the effects of these organisms on plant development.
Material and methods
Pochonia chlamydosporia var. chlamydosporia Pc-3, Pc-10 and Pc-19 were isolated from soil naturally infested with Meloidogyne spp. and cultivated with vegetables in Vicosa, Minas Gerais State, Brazil (DALLEMOLE-GIARETTA et al., 2012). The fungal isolates were recovered by incubating pieces of colonized filter paper (SMITH; ONIONS, 1994) on corn meal agar (CMA, Difco, Detroit, MI, USA) at 25[degrees]C in darkness for 21 day.
Promotion of the growth of tomato seedlings
Two assays were performed to assess the potential of Pc-3, Pc-10 and Pc-19 to promote the growth of tomato cv. Santa Clara under laboratory conditions. Glass tubes (23 mm in diameter x 150 mm in length) were filled with 1.5 g of coconut fiber (Table 1), which was moistened with 7.5 mL (assay 1) or 6.5 mL (assay 2) of distilled water. After 12h, the tubes were capped and autoclaved at 121[degrees]C for 30 min. This process of sterilization was performed twice with an interval of 24h.
Fungal inoculum was applied to the substrate either as mycelial discs or as a conidia suspension. In assay 1, four discs (5 mm in diameter) were cut from the edge of a 21-day-old culture of P. chlamydosporia on CMA, and each disc was placed at a depth of 2 cm in a tube containing the substrate. In assay 2, P. chlamydosporia conidia were collected and suspended in sterile water, and the suspension was adjusted to provide 1.52 x [10.sup.6], 1.83 x [10.sup.5] and 1.92 x [10.sup.6] conidia per tube of the isolates Pc-3, Pc-10 and Pc-19, respectively. Sterile PDA discs and distilled water were used as controls. One pre-germinated tomato seed was added in each tube at a depth of 0.5 cm. The tomato seeds were previously disinfected with 70% alcohol (v [v.sup.-1]) for 1 min., then immersed for 10 min. in sodium hypochlorite diluted to 1% active chlorine (v [v.sup.-1]) and finally rinsed with sterile water. The seeds were then pre-germinated for 2 d in the culture medium described by Bordallo et al. (2002). For controls, tomato seeds were placed in the substrate without fungus. The tubes were transferred into a growth chamber at 25[degrees]C with a 16-h photoperiod.
The height and the fresh mass of the aboveground parts of the seedlings were recorded after 15 day. The experiment was carried out in a completely randomized design with 10 (assay 1) or eight (assay 2) replicates.
Root colonization and the use of carbon sources by P. chlamydosporia isolate Pc-19
Ten root segments, 0.5 cm in length, subjected to colonization by Pc-19 in assay 1 were incubated in Petri dishes on semi-selective medium (GASPARD et al., 1990) at 25[degrees]C, and the number of colonized segments was recorded after three days. The remaining root segments were stored in a solution containing formaldehyde, lactic acid and alcohol (FAA 50; 5:5:90, v [v.sup.-1] [v.sup.-1]) to study rhizospheric colonization. The root segments were prepared according to a protocol used for the observation of mycorrhizal associations (BRUNDRETT et al., 1996).
To investigate which carbon sources can be used by the isolate Pc-19, the culture medium was prepared using glucose (control), sucrose, cellulose or pectin and contained 8 g [L.sup.-1] of carbon, 2 g [L.sup.-1] of NaN[O.sub.3], 1 g [L.sup.-1] of [K.sub.2]HP[O.sub.4], 0.5 g [L.sup.-1] of MgS[O.sub.4], 0.5 g [L.sup.-1] of KCl, 0.01 g [L.sup.-1] of FeS[O.sub.4] and 17 g [L.sup.-1] of agar in distilled water (SUN; LIU, 2006). A mycelial disc 5 mm in diameter was cut from the edge of a 15-day-old culture of the fungus and was placed at the centre of each 9-cm-diameter Petri dish. The fungal biomass was recorded after 15 d of culturing at 25[degrees]C in the dark. To measure the fungal biomass, the culture medium was dissolved in 200 mL of boiling water, and the mycelium was transferred to a crucibie and heid at 105 C untii a constant mass was reached. The assay was arranged in a randomised design with seven replicates per treatment.
Root colonization of tomato plants by the Pc-10 isolate as determined by scanning electron microscopy (SEM)
Root segments from assay 1 and colonized by Pc-10 were fixed in phosphate buffer solution (0.05 mol. [L.sup.-1], pH 7.1) with 2.5% of glutaraldehyde for one hour at room temperature. They were washed six times in phosphate buffer solution (0.05 mol. [L.sup.-1], pH 7.1) for ten min. each time, dehydrated in an ethanol series of 30 and 50% for 10 min. at each concentration and placed in 70% ethanol in the refrigerator until the following day. Dehydration was then continued with an additional ethanol series of 80 and 95% for 10 min. each, followed by 100% ethanol for 15 min., three times. The samples were dried in a critical point dryer (Bal-Tec, model CPD 030, Germany) and mounted on aluminium stubs, sputter-coated in gold and viewed under a scanning electron microscope (Zeiss, model LEO 1430 VP, England).
Promotion of the growth of lettuce seedlings
The potential of the isolate Pc-10 to promote the growth of lettuce seedlings was assessed using the cultivars Veronica, Americana, Regina and Manteiga (Isla Sementes, Porto Alegre, Rio Grande do Sul State, Brazil). Each cultivar was evaluated separately, using the methodology described for assay 1. Root segments subjected to colonization by Pc-10 were incubated in Petri dishes on semi-selective medium (GASPARD et al., 1990) at 25[degrees]C, and the number of colonized segments was recorded after three days.
The data for each variable were tested using the Kolmogorov-Smirnov test to determine whether they were normally distributed. The Bartlett test was used to determine whether variances were homogeneous. The data were subjected to a one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA, F-test, p < 0.05). Treatment means were compared using tukey's HSD test (p < 0.05). Statistical analyses were performed using R software, version 2.12.2 (R DEVELOPMENT CORE TEAM, 2011).
Results and discussion
Promotion of tomato seedling growth
All isolates of P. chlamydosporia increased the height (from 1,179 to 1,404%) and the aboveground mass (from 1,350 to 1,650%) of tomato seedlings in assay 1, when mycelial discs were used as the source of inoculum, and from 72 to 103, and 100 to 148%, respectively, in assay 2, when the fungus was added to the substrate via conidia suspension (Table 2). No significant difference among the isolates was observed in either assay. Despite the differences between the assays, we concluded that the growth of tomato seedlings was promoted by the P. chlamydosporia var. chlamydosporia isolates, excluding the sole effect of the nutrients from the culture medium (CMA).
Microorganisms can stimulate plant growth both directly (i.e., via the production of plant hormones, biological nitrogen fixation, phosphorus solubilization, acceleration of the process of mineralization and siderophore synthesis) and indirectly (i.e., via the induction of systemic resistance, the production of antibiotics and antagonism in relation to pathogens) (HAYAT et al., 2010). Pochonia chlamydosporia can promote the growth of wheat seedlings via direct mechanisms, such as the production of growth regulators associated with the activity of peroxidase (MONFORT et al., 2005). In this study, it is likely that the increase in plant growth was related to an increase in the area of absorption of the roots, allowing them to overcome possible water stresses in the tubes.
Root colonization and the use of carbon sources by P. chlamydosporia isolate Pc-19
The fungus colonized all root segments of the tomato plants and also the coconut fiber used as a substrate for the plants (Figure 1A). A large quantity of chlamydospores was produced in the rhizoplane (Figure 1B), and the hyphae of the fungus penetrated into cells of the root cortex (Figure 1C). The fungus was able to use cellulose as a carbon source, as much as glucose and sucrose, with an average mycelial production (dry mass) of 0.135, 0.111 and 0.138 g using each of these carbon sources, respectively. However, poor mycelial growth was recorded when the fungus was grown in culture medium amended with pectin as the carbon source (0.009 g of dry mass).
This study provides evidence that Pc-19 can colonize tomato roots and use cellulose as a carbon source. Different species of plants differ in their abilities to allow the growth of P. chlamydosporia in the rhizosphere. Tomato, cabbage, crotalaria, beans, corn, kale, potato and pea are plants that favour the development of the fungus, whereas soybean, wheat, sorghum, aubergine and okra are plants that do not permit satisfactory development in the rhizosphere (MANZANILLA-LOPEZ et al., 2013). In addition to corroborating earlier findings of the ability of tomato to support P. chlamydosporia colonization (MANZANILLA-LOPEZ et al., 2013), we found that the fungus can form a tangle of hyphae similar to those formed by arbuscular mycorrhizae. It has been suggested that this nematode antagonist may act as an endophyte (MACIA-VICENTE et al., 2009a) and may increase the ability of the tomato to germinate, absorb water from the substrate and resist stress due to the deleterious effects of salts present in the coconut fiber substrate (DOMENO et al., 2009; HERNANDEZ-APAOLAZA et al., 2005). In addition, enhanced development of the plants may be associated with the chemical degradation of cellulose from the coconut fiber by enzymes produced by the fungus (ESTEVES et al., 2009; LARRIBA et al., 2014) and the subsequent translocation of carbohydrates, as well as nutrients like nitrogen and phosphorus, to the roots of the tomato plants, as has been observed with arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi (SCHREINER, 2007).
Root colonization of tomato plants by Pc-10 as determined by scanning electron microscopy (SEM)
After 15 days, P. chlamydosporia var. chlamydosporia isolate Pc-10 colonized the roots of tomato seedlings, forming a mantle of hyphae and producing conidia in some parts of the rhizosphere (Figure 1D and E). Thus, like Pc-19, this isolate was able to colonize tomato roots; this information can be used to guide the choice of crop rotation system to support good rhizosphere development. Greater development and reproduction of the fungus in the rhizosphere can improve the control of plant-parasitic nematodes (DALLEMOLE-GIARETTA et al., 2011; VIGGIANO et al., 2014).
Although the extent to which isolate Pc-3 colonizes rhizosphere has not been evaluated, based on the results of the growth promotion assays it is possible to speculate that, like Pc-10 and Pc-19, this isolate may efficiently colonize the rhizosphere of tomato plants (Table 2).
Promotion of the growth of lettuce seedlings
Pc-10 increased the aboveground mass of all the lettuce cultivars from 100 to 330% and the height of the cultivar Regina by 80% (Table 3). Colonization of the roots by the isolate was observed in 100% of the root system segments of the lettuce seedlings, for all the cultivars tested, when plated on semi-selective medium.
In addition to the growth promotion of the plants, the ability of P. chlamydosporia isolates to colonize tomato and lettuce roots may protect the hosts against nematodes and other soil pathogens. MONFORT et al. (2005) reported that the P. chlamydosporia isolate 4624 improved barley growth and reduced root colonization by the phytopathogenic fungus G. graminis var. tritici. The protection of the root system by P. chlamydosporia against fungal pathogens probably occurs via supplementation with nutrients and competition for infection sites, as has been observed with arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi (BORGES et al., 2007). Moreover, P. chlamydosporia induces a defense reaction in the plant, with the formation of papillae in the cell wall of the root system (BORDALLO et al., 2002). Further studies are needed to understand the mechanisms of action of the P. chlamydosporia isolates Pc-3, Pc-10 and Pc-19.
[FIGURE 1 OMITTED]
The isolates Pc-3, Pc-10 and Pc-19 of P. chlamydosporia promote the growth of tomato and lettuce seedlings. This fungus colonizes the roots of both plant species and produces hyphae and chlamydospores in the rhizoplane of tomato plants.
The authors would like to thank the National Council for Scientific and Technological Development (CNPq), the Foundation for Research Support of the State of Minas Gerais (Fapemig) and the Coordination for the Improvement of Higher Education Personnel (Capes) for their financial support.
BORDALLO, J. J.; LOPEZ-LLORCA, L. V.; JANSSON, H. B.; SALINAS, J.; PERSMARK, L.; ASENSIO, L. Colonization of plant roots by egg-parasitic and nematode-trapping fungi. New Phytologist, v. 154, n. 2, p. 491-499, 2002.
BORGES, A. J. S.; TRINDADE, A. V.; MATOS, A. P.; PEIXOTO, M. F. S. Reducao do Mal-do-Panama em bananeira-maca por inoculacao de fungo micorrizico arbuscular. Pesquisa Agropecuaria Brasileira, v. 42, n. 1, p. 35-41, 2007.
BRUNDRETT, M.; BOUGHER, N.; DELL, B.; GROVET, T.; MALAJCZUK, N. Working with mycorrhizas in forestry and agriculture. Canberra: Australian Centre for International Agricultural Research, 1996.
DALLEMOLE-GIARETT A, R.; FREITAS, L. G.; LOPES, E. A.; FERRAZ, S.; PODESTA, G. S.; AGNES, E. L. Cover crops and Pochonia chlamydosporia for the control of Meloidogyne javanica. Nematology, v. 13, n. 8, p. 919-926, 2011.
DALLEMOLE-GIARETT A, R.; FREITAS, L. G.; LOPES, E. A.; PEREIRA, O. L; ZOOCA, R. J. F.; FERRAZ, S. Screening of Pochonia chlamydosporia Brazilian isolates as biocontrol agents of Meloidogyne javanica. Crop Protection, v. 42, n. 1, p. 102-107, 2012.
DIAS-ARIEIRA, C. R.; SANTANA, S. M.; FREITAS, L. G.; CUNHA, T. P. L.; BIELA, F.; PUERARI, H. H.; CHIAMOLERA, F. M. Efficiency of Pochonia chlamydosporia in Meloidogyne incognita control in lettuce crop (Lactuca sativa L.). Journal of Food, Agriculture and Environment, v. 9, n. 3-4, p. 561-563, 2011.
DOMENO, I.; IRIGOYEN, N.; MURO, J. Evolution of organic matter and drainages in wood fibre and coconut fibre substrates. Scientia Horticulturae, v. 122, n. 2, p. 269-274, 2009.
EBADI, M.; FATEMY, S.; RIAHI, H. Evaluation of Pochonia chlamydosporia var. chlamydosporia as a control agent of Meloidogyne javanica on pistachio. Biocontrol Science and Technology, v. 19, n. 7, p. 689-700, 2009.
ESCUDERO, N.; LOPEZ-LLORCA, L. V. Effects on plant growth and root-knot nematode infection of an endophytic GFP transformant of the nematophagous fungus Pochonia chlamydosporia. Symbiosis, v. 57, n. 1, p. 33-42, 2012.
ESTEVES, I.; PETEIRA, B.; ATKINS, S. D.; MAGAN, N.; KERRY, B. Production of extracelular enzymes by different isolates of Pochonia chlamydosporia. Mycological Research, v. 113, n. 8, p. 867-876, 2009.
GASPARD, J. T.; JAFFEE, B. A.; FERRIS, H. Association of Verticillium chlamydosporium and Paecilomyces lilacinus with root-knot nematode infested soil. Journal of Nematology, v. 22, n. 2, p. 207-213, 1990.
HAYAT, R.; ALI, S.; AMARA, U.; KHALID, R.; AHMED, I. Soil beneficial bacteria and their role in plant growth promotion: a review. Annals of Microbiology, v. 60, n. 4, p. 579-598, 2010.
HERNANDEZ-APAOLAZA, L.; GASCO, A. M.; GASCO, J. M.; GUERRERO, F. Reuse of waste materials as growing media for ornamental plants. Bioresource Technology, v. 96, n. 1, p. 125-131, 2005.
LARRIBA, E.; JAIME, M. D. L. A.; CARBONELL-CABALLERO, J.; CONESA, A.; DOPAZO, J.; NISLOW, C.; MARTIN-NIETO, J.; LOPEZ-LLORCA, L. V. Sequencing and functional analysis of the genome of a nematode egg-parasitic fungus, Pochonia chlamydosporia. Fungal Genetics and Biology, v. 65, n. 1, p. 69-80, 2014.
MANZANILLA-LOPEZ, R. H.; ESTEVES, I.; POWERS, S. J.; KERRY, B. R. Effects of crop plants on abundance of Pochonia chlamydosporia and other fungal parasites of root-knot and potato cyst nematodes. Annals of Applied Biology, v. 159, n. 1, p. 118-129, 2011.
MANZANILLA-LOPEZ, R. H.; ESTEVES, I.; FINETTI-SIALER, M. M.; HIRSCH, P. R.; WARD, E.; DEVONSHIRE, J.; HIDALGO-DIAZ, L. Pochonia chlamydosporia: Advances and challenges to improve its performance as a biological control agent of sedentary endo-parasitic nematodes. Journal of Nematology, v. 45, n. 1, p. 1-7, 2013.
MACIA-VICENTE, J. G.; JANSSON, H. B.; LOPEZ-LLORCA, L. V. Assessing fungal root colonization for plant improvement. Plant Signaling and Behaviour, v. 4, n. 5, p. 445-447, 2009a.
MACIA-VICENTE, J. G.; ROSSO, L. C.; CIANCIO, A.; JANSSON, H. B.; LOPEZ-LLORCA, L. V. Colonisation of barley roots by endophytic Fusarium equiseti and Pochonia chlamydosporia: effects on plant growth and disease. Annals of Applied Biology, v. 155, n. 3, p. 391-401, 2009b.
MONFORT, E.; LOPEZ-LLORCA, L. V.; JANSSON, H. B.; SALINAS, J.; PARK, J. O; SIVASITHAMPARAM, K. Colonization of seminal roots of wheat and barley by egg-parasitic nematophagous fungi and their effects on Gaeumannomyces graminis var. tritici and development of root-rot. Soil Biology and Biochemistry, v. 37, n. 7, p. 1229-1235, 2005.
R DEVELOPMENT CORE TEAM. R: A language and environment for statistical computing. Vienna: R Foundation for Statistical Computing, 2011. Available from: <http://www.R-project.org>. Access on: Apr. 10, 2012.
SCHREINER, R. P. Effects of native and nonnative arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi on growth and nutrient uptake of 'Pinot noir' (Vitis vinifera L.) in two soils with contrasting levels of phosphorus. Applied Soil Ecology, v. 36, n. 2-3, p. 205-215, 2007.
SMITH, D.; ONIONS, A. H. S. The preservation and maintenance of living fungi. Wallingford: CAB International, 1994.
SUN, M. H.; LIU, X. Z. Carbon requirements of some nematophagous, entomopathogenic and mycoparasitic hyphomycetes as fungal biocontrol agents. Mycopathologia, v. 161, n. 5, p. 295-305, 2006.
VIGGIANO, J. R.; FREITAS, L. G.; LOPES, E. A. Use of Pochonia chlamydosporia to control Meloidogyne javanica in cucumber. Biological Control, v. 69, n. 1, p. 72-77, 2014.
Received on September 24, 2014.
Accepted on November 30, 2014.
Rosangela Dallemole-Giaretta (1), Leandro Grassi de Freitas (2), Everaldo Antonio Lopes (3) *, Marliane de Cassia Soares da Silva (4), Maria Catarina Megumi Kasuya (4) and Silamar Ferraz (2)
(1) Departamento de Ciencias Agrarias, Universidade Tecnologica Federal do Parana, Pato Branco, Parana, Brazil. (2) Departamento de Fitopatologia, Universidade Federal de Vicosa, Vicosa, Minas Gerais, Brazil. (3) Instituto de Ciencias Agrarias, Universidade Federal de Vicosa, Campus de Rio Paranaiba, Rod. MG-230, Km 7, 38810-000, Rio Paranaiba, Minas Gerais, Brazil. (4) Departamento de Microbiologia, Universidade Federal de Vicosa, Vicosa, Minas Gerais, Brazil. * Author for correspondence. E-mail: email@example.com
Table 1. Chemical characterization of the coconut fiber used as a substrate for the growth of tomato and lettuce plants. Macronutrients (g [kg.sup.-1]) Nitrogen Phosphorus Potassium Calcium 7.3 3.3 11.7 11.6 Magnesium Sulphur Sodium 4.8 5.1 0.4 Micronutrients (mg [kg.sup.-1]) Zinc Iron Manganese Copper Boron 502 3668 250 228 126 C/N ph 26.49 5.01 Table 2. Height and mass of the aboveground portion of tomato seedlings cv. Santa Clara grown on a coconut fiber substrate infested using mycelial discs (assay 1) or a conidia suspension of Pochonia chlamydosporia var. chlamydosporia isolates Pc-3, Pc-10 and Pc-19. Treatments Plant height (cm) Increase (%) Assay 1 Control 0.69 ([+ or -] 1.21) b -- Isolate Pc-3 9.45 ([+ or -] 3.15) a 1,269 Isolate Pc-10 10.38 ([+ or -] 1.36) a 1,404 Isolate Pc-19 8.83 ([+ or -] 2.68) a 1,179 Assay 2 Control 2.87 ([+ or -] 1.69) b -- Isolate Pc-3 5.83 ([+ or -] 1.07) a 103 Isolate Pc-10 5.00 ([+ or -] 1.52) a 74 Isolate Pc-19 4.95 ([+ or -] 1.81) a 72 Treatments Aboveground mass (g) Increase (%) Assay 1 Control 0.004 ([+ or -] 0.006) b -- Isolate Pc-3 0.063 ([+ or -] 0.028) a 1,475 Isolate Pc-10 0.070 ([+ or -] 0.021) a 1,650 Isolate Pc-19 0.058 ([+ or -] 0.022) a 1,350 Assay 2 Control 0.023 ([+ or -] 0.022) b -- Isolate Pc-3 0.057 ([+ or -] 0.023) a 148 Isolate Pc-10 0.046 ([+ or -] 0.020) a 100 Isolate Pc-19 0.048 ([+ or -] 0.018) a 109 Means ([+ or -] standard deviations) within a column in each assay followed by the same letter do not differ by tukey's HSD test (p < 0.05). Table 3. Height and fresh mass of the aboveground portion of the lettuce cultivars * Veronica, Americana, Regina and Manteiga grown on a coconut fiber substrate infested with mycelial discs of Pochonia chlamydosporia var. chlamydosporia isolate Pc-10 (Pc). Treatments Plant height Increase (cm) (%) Veronica + Pc 1.23 ([+ or -] 0.678) a -- Veronica - Pc 0.83 ([+ or -] 0.453) a -- Americana + Pc 1.45 ([+ or -] 0.626) a -- Americana - Pc 1.34 ([+ or -] 0.637) a -- Regina + Pc 1.78 ([+ or -] 0.646) a 80 Regina - Pc 0.99 ([+ or -] 0.321) b -- Manteiga + Pc 1.08 ([+ or -] 0.436) a -- Manteiga - Pc 1.21 ([+ or -] 1.115) a Treatments Aboveground mass Increase (g) (%) Veronica + Pc 0.02 ([+ or -] 0.013) a 100 Veronica - Pc 0.01 ([+ or -] 0.007) b -- Americana + Pc 0.03 ([+ or -] 0.017) a 200 Americana - Pc 0.01 ([+ or -] 0.005) b -- Regina + Pc 0.03 ([+ or -] 0.016) a 200 Regina - Pc 0.01 ([+ or -] 0.006) b -- Manteiga + Pc 0.043 ([+ or -] 0.016) a 330 Manteiga - Pc -- * Each cultivar was evaluated in a separate assay. Means ([+ or -] standard deviation) within a column in each cultivar followed by the same letter do not differ by F-test (p < 0.05).