Woo Suk Hwang, a biologist at Seoul National University in South Korea, claimed that he had cloned (created an exact genetic copy) human stem cells (see SW, 5/10/04). Stem cells can become any of the body's cell types. Scientists think stem cells may someday help treat diseases, so Hwang's research caused a stir when it was published in two articles in the journal Science.
To avoid publishing phony research, scientific journals require experts to review all research papers before they are published, says Monica Bradford, executive editor of Science. The experts read the papers and review the data to make sure the scientists followed the scientific method, a step-by-step method of conducting experiments. Reviewers of Hwang's submissions didn't realize that his papers were based on phony data. Because it appeared that Hwang followed the scientific method, he passed this review process.
Cheaters usually get caught when other scientists try to repeat the experiments, says George Daley, a stem-cell scientist at Harvard Medical School. Before that could happen, someone in Hwang's lab blew the whistle.
The hoax was a letdown for stem-cell scientists, but they're not giving up: "There's a new race on to do what Hwang claimed to have done," says Daley. Adams
|Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback|
|Title Annotation:||LIFE/SCIENTIFIC METHOD|
|Article Type:||Brief article|
|Date:||Apr 17, 2006|
|Previous Article:||An elephant's tale.|
|Next Article:||Cosmic clues.|
|Doctor who? Scientists are treated as objective arbiters in the cloning debate. But most have serious skin in the game.|
|The death of Dolly.|
|Bad copies. (Letters).|
|The New York Times Book of Fossils and Evolution.|