Printer Friendly

Phillips, Paul. A Clockwork Counterpoint: The Music and Literature of Anthony Burgess.

PHILLIPS, PAUL. A Clockwork Counterpoint: The Music and Literature of Anthony Burgess. Manchester, UK: Manchester University Press, 2010. 467 pp. 65.00 [pounds sterling].

Paul Phillips's A Clockwork Counterpoint provides a comprehensive overview of the music and writings of Anthony Burgess. Phillips argues that composing classical music was Burgess's true labor of love, since he was only rarely compensated for his music, most of which went unperformed during his lifetime. Phillips, a conductor himself, was given unprecedented access to Burgess's musical scores by Burgess's widow, and he is clearly an expert in this subject matter.

Apart from cataloguing the wide range of musical forms and genres in which Burgess worked, Phillips explores the ways Burgess's love for music shaped his writing, distinguishing him from contemporary writers/composers such as Paul Bowles and Bruce Montgomery, who regarded writing and composing as separate pursuits. According to Phillips,
   Burgess constantly sought ways to unite both halves of his creative
   personality, either by setting words of his favorite authors to
   music, incorporating musical characters and themes into his books,
   or, more radically, assigning musical structure to fiction, whether
   this meant writing novels in sonata form, or, as in the case of
   Napoleon Symphony, modeling the form and character of a novel on
   Beethoven's Eroica. (4)

Throughout A Clockwork Counterpoint, Phillips suggests that to understand Burgess's writing you must understand his music.

Phillips's overarching point--that the ability to write and the desire to compose were interrelated aspects of Burgess's genius--is carefully and convincingly made. Burgess believed that a writer needed a musical ear and strove to make his prose sound and feel like music. In so doing, he hoped to emulate canonical writers with musical backgrounds such as John Milton, whose father was a composer, James Joyce, who worked briefly as a professional tenor, and even William Shakespeare, who Burgess believed possessed considerable musical knowledge (112). Phillips explains how Burgess wrote and composed in the same unusual way, moving from beginning to end with no revisions: "This uncommon creative process helps to explain Burgess's astonishing prolificacy as a writer and composer" (186). From compositional process to finished product, Phillips illuminates Burgess's distinctive integration of music and literature.

Although clearly an admirer of his subject, Phillips maintains an objective perspective, addressing Burgess's artistic and personal limitations directly. He offers a particularly frank examination of Burgess's deficiencies as a lyricist:
   Burgess's skill in writing words to be sung rarely matched his
   ability as a novelist or adapter of spoken plays.... He often
   lacked the sensitivity to the melody of language that great
   lyricists possess.... Although he could achieve a delicacy in his
   music, his manner of speaking reveals his shortcomings as a
   lyricist, for he spoke in an aggressive, sometimes hectoring
   manner, with an accented staccato attack, forced from the back of
   the throat, that could be almost painful to listen to. No matter
   how much he may have admired or desired it, the fight touch of the
   natural lyricist was a gift that Burgess simply did not possess.

Phillips also discusses the discrepancies in quality that characterized Burgess's music, pointing out that some of his pieces--such as his solo and chamber works for the oboe and recorder--called for notes beyond the range of the specified instruments. Although he connects these foibles to Burgess's lack of formal training and the infrequency with which he heard his music performed, Phillips also--for better or worse--speculates freely, attributing such artistic mishaps to troubled aspects of Burgess's personal life, such as the ambivalence he felt toward his son:
   Given the fact that many of Burgess's works for oboe and recorder
   ignore practical performance considerations and are ill-suited for
   these instruments, one is forced to wonder what he could have meant
   by writing such unplayable pieces for his son. As Burgess
   acknowledged, he was a neglectful parent, too preoccupied with his
   writing and composing to take much notice of the high-spirited
   urchin who often ran naked through the house and the neighborhood.

The claim that Burgess subconsciously or perhaps deliberately wrote unplayable music for his son due to a lack of fatherly feeling is highly subjective and may skate too close to psychological theorizing for some. Yet even though some of his conclusions are farfetched, Phillips's candor regarding his subject's flaws makes it easy to trust him when he praises Burgess's best works such as Symphony No. 3 in C, Mr. W.S., his ballet based on the life of Shakespeare, and his compositions for solo guitar and guitar quartet.

The problems with this book have more to do with form than substance. Firstly, it is overbroad: Phillips assesses every book by Burgess, even those, such as 1985, that he openly admits have nothing to do with music. Secondly, rather than begin with an analysis of the works by Burgess that best combine his musical and literary talents, Phillips chose to organize his study as a biography, a strange decision given that Burgess composed most of his music late in life after the death of his first wife, Lynne. Since Andrew Biswell's recent biography, The Real Life of Anthony Burgess, deals primarily with B urgess's early life and first marriage, A Clockwork Counterpoint, which mainly focuses on the years of his second marriage, complements Biswell's fine biography nicely, but its chronological structure means that Phillips leads with the weakest, least relevant part of his manuscript; the second half of A Clockwork Counterpoint is more engaging and informative than the first.

Phillips also refuses to tell us in plain language what Burgess's music sounds like. The following description of Sonatina in G Major is fairly representative:
   The opening Allegretto movement offers a fine example of Burgess's
   early style, combining lyricism and traditional harmonic practice
   with the modernist's avoidance of predictability. The curious
   alternation of G# and D major chords in bars 14-18 recalls a
   similar alteration of chords with roots a triton apart (C and F#)
   in "'Saturn" from The Planets. The perfect authentic cadence in
   bars 21-2, replete with 4-3 suspension, is Burgess's way of tidily
   wrapping up in traditional fashion a passage that--through the use
   of irregular phrase lengths, unusual harmonic progressions, and an
   atypical approach to modulation--is less ordinary than its apparent
   simplicity suggests. (51-52)

Only a trained musician or musicologist would be able to understand all or even much of what is being said here, which is unfortunate since Phillips's otherwise lucid prose aims for the widest possible audience. Phillips does provide numerous examples of sheet music by Burgess, but again--given that his stated purpose is to analyze Burgess's music and literature together--his use of technical musicology and printed music are of little value to people who know of and appreciate Burgess through his literature.

In sum, this smart, edifying book is essential for the Burgess scholar, though its subject ultimately emerges as a clever and versatile composer, not a great or particularly important one.

THOMAS HORAN, The Citadel, The Military College of South Carolina
COPYRIGHT 2011 Johns Hopkins University Press
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2011 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Author:Horan, Thomas
Publication:Studies in the Novel
Article Type:Book review
Date:Dec 22, 2011
Previous Article:Ketabgian, Tamara. The Lives of Machines: The Industrial Imaginary in Victorian Literature & Culture.
Next Article:Rajan, Tilottama. Romantic Narrative: Shelley, Hays, Godwin, Wollstonecraft.

Terms of use | Privacy policy | Copyright © 2020 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters