Pancytopenia--clinico-haematological studies of bone marrow examination.
MATERIAL AND METHOD: In our study we reviewed all cases of pancytopenia diagnosed from January 2009 to December 2012 at Department of Pathology, Gandhi Medical College. The study included all cases of pancytopenia i.e. hemoglobin less than 9 gm/dl, total leucocyte count less than 4, 000 cells/cumm, platelet count less than 1, 00, 000 per cu mm, who underwent bone marrow examination.
Patients who had received chemotherapy or immunosuppressive drugs and those who had dual pathology were excluded. Recording of clinical details was done from the medical records. Hematological parameters were reviewed, leishman stained peripheral and bone marrow aspiration smears were examined in detail.
RESULT: A total of 155 patients who presented with pancytopenia were studied. The study group consisted of 82 males and 73 females with a male to female ratio of 1.12:1.
The age of patients ranged from 2 to 80 years (Mean age 28 years). Out of 155 cases, 36 cases were in paediatric age group (0-14years) which consisted of 23 males and 13 females. Maximum cases--60 were observed in the age group of 20 to 40 years of which 26 were male &34 females. In the age group 40-60, only 21 cases were reported with 11 male and 10 females. Thus male preponderance was observed in pediatric age group whereas female preponderance was seen in 2040 year age group. There was no significant difference in sex distribution in 40-60 years age group.
The most common cause of pancytopenia among the 155 cases was found to be megaloblastic anemia which was present in 67 (43.22%), with maximum number of cases in 20-40 years age group, male: female ratio was 1.79:1(43:24), the second most common cause of pancytopenia was hypoplastic anemia 20/155 (12.90%) followed by Dimorphic anemia 13/155 (8.38%) with maximum frequency of cases in females both under 14 and 20-40 years age group, male female ratio being 0.81:1 and 0.85:1 respectively.
Other causes of pancytopenia found in our study were hypersplenism (3.22%), aplastic anemia(2.58%), ITP (1.93%), MDS (1.29%), one each of Myeloproliferative disorder, Chediak Higashi syndrome, Congenital dyserythropoietic anaemia, Pure red cell aplasia, erythroid hyperplasia and gaucher's disease. No definitive diagnosis was established in 10 cases due to laboratory constraints.
Generalised weakness & pallor was noted clinically in all patients of pancytopenia.
The following table presents the distribution of cases according to presenting complaints and physical findings:
Table 2: Distribution of cases-presenting complaints and physical findings. Sl. Symptoms Number No. of cases 1 Fever 45 2 Epistaxis 17 3 Gum bleed 8 4 Petechiae 3 5 Rash 9 6 Haemetemesis 5 7 Hematuria 5 8 Malena 7 9 Bleeding 3 Per rectum 10 Pedal edema 14 11 Facial edema 4 12 Icterus 7 13 Jaundice 9 14 Hepatomegaly 26 15 Splenomegaly 47 16 Lymphadenopathy 17 Sl. Most common cause 2nd most common cause No. 1 Megaloblastic anemia (27/67) Hypoplastic anemia (11/20) 2 Megaloblastic anemia (5/67) ITP (2/3) 3 Hypoplastic anemia (3) ITP(1/3) 4 Hypoplastic anemia (3/20) -- 5 Hypoplastic anemia (5/20) ITP (Megaloblastic anemia (2/67) 6 Hypersplenism (2/5) MDS (1/1), Megaloblastic anemia 7 Megaloblastic anemia (3/67) Aplastic anemia(1/4), 8 Megaloblastic anemia (2/67), MDS(1/1). ALL(1/9), Hypersplenism (2/5) Hypoplastic anemia(1/20) 9 Megaloblastic anemia (2/67) Dimorphic anemia (1/13) 10 Megaloblastic anemia (9/67) Dimorphic anemia(1/13), BM reactive to infection(1/8) 11 Megaloblastic anemia (1/67), -- dimorphic anemia (1/20) 12 Megaloblastic anemia (5/67) Hypoplastic anemia (1/20) 13 Megaloblastic anemia (5/67) BM reactive to infection (2/8) 14 Megaloblastic anemia (12/67) Hypoplastic anemia (3/20) 15 Megaloblastic anemia (20/67) Hypersplenism(5/5), Dimorphic anemia (5/13) 16 Megaloblastic anemia (6/67) ALL (3/6)
For bleeding manifestations -epistaxis, hematuria, malena and bleeding per rectum, most common cause was found to be megaloblastic anemia while hypoplastic anemia was common cause for gum bleed, petechiae and rash. Haematological parameters in 3 subgroups of pancytopenia observed were as follows:
Severe anemia (Hemoglobin less than 5 gm %) was found in more than 50% cases in megaloblastic anemia, hypoplastic anemia, dimorphic anemia and bone marrow reactive to chronic infection. Most common cause for this was hypoplastic anemia(13/20 or 65 % cases).
Moderate (Hemoglobin-5-8 gm %) and mild (Hemoglobin-8-9 gm %) anemia were found most commonly in megaloblastic anemia in 55.22% (37/67 cases) and 8.9 % (6/67 cases) respectively.
Platelet count less than 50, 000/cumm were found in 85%, 69.2% and 66% cases of hypoplastic anemia, dimorphic anemia and megaloblastic anemia respectively.
We encountered 17 patients of sub leukemic leukemia (9 ALL and 8 AML), their age ranged from 16 to 60 years.
ALL had higher number of cases under 14 years of age with a total of 9 (5.80%) cases having male: female ratio 2:1, while, AML cases were 8(5.16%), which were more common in 20-40 years age group with male female ratio of 1:1.66.
We also observed one case of storage disorder i.e gaucher's disease, a 8 years old boy who presented with fever, weakness and splenomegaly. Also one case of Chediak hegashi syndrome, 4 year old boy who presented with hypo pigmented macule on trunk, pedal edema, oculo-cutaneous albinism and hepatosplenomegaly.
DISCUSSION: Reviewed retrospectively all 155 cases of pancytopenia who have undergone bone marrow aspiration in a time span of four years. Clinical details--age, sex distribution, presenting symptoms and signs were noted from medical records, hematological parameters, findings of leishman stained peripheral blood picture and bone marrow aspiration smears were reviewed. The underlying cause of pancytopenia was studied in all cases and observations were compared to other studies published in literature.
The age of patients ranged from 2 to 80 years with mean age of 28 years pancytopenia were observed more in males (52.9%), with male to female(M:F) ratio of 1.12:1.
Age and sex distribution was compared with other studies
The most common presenting complaints in our study were generalized weakness and easy fatigability (100%), followed by fever (29%). The most common physical findings were pallor (100%) followed by splenomegaly (30.3%) and hepatomegaly (16.7%).
The symptoms were mostly attributed to anemia and thrombocytopenia.
Variations in the frequency of the various diagnostic entities causing pancytopenia have been attributed to difference in methodology and stringency of diagnostic criteria, geographic area, period of observation, genetic differences and varying exposure to myelotoxic agents, etc. (4)
The commonest cause of pancytopenia reported in various studies throughout the world has been aplastic anemia. (4). This is sharp contrast with results of our and other studies conducted in India where the commonest cause was found to be megaloblastic anemia (5, 7, 8). This seems to reflect the higher prevalence of nutritional anemia in Indian subjects.
Megaloblastic anemia constituted 43.2% cases in our study as compared to 72% reported by Khunger JM et.al ;and 68% by Tilak V et al. both of the studies have stressed the importance of megaloblastic anemia being major cause of pancytopenia. It is a rapidly correctable disorder and should be promptly notified. (4, 7). Although bone marrow aspiration studies are uncommon in suspected cases of megaloblastic anemia. But, if the diagnosis does not appear clear and hematological assays are not available, bone marrow aspiration is indicated. As facilities of folic acid and vitamin B 12 levels are not routinely available in most centres in India. (5)
Prevalence of aplastic anemia varies from 10% to 52% among pancytopenic patients. (8) The incidence of hypoplastic in our study was 12.9 % (20/155 cases)which correlated with the corresponding figures in study done by Khodke K et al. and the Khunger JM et al., both observed an incidence of 14 %(7, 8).A higher incidence viz 29.5% was reported by Kumar R et al (5)
We encounterd 10.9 % incidence of subleukemic leukemia, compared to 5 % reported by khunger JM et al. Kumar et al reported 12 % incidence of aleukemic leukemia. Pancytopenia was the common feature in our study: this correlated with corresponding finding in the studies by Kumar R et al and Khunger JM et al (5, 7). The diagnosis of Acute Leukemia was based on bone marrow aspiration studies morphologically and we reported 8 cases of AML and 9 cases of ALL. Kumar et al reported 5 cases of ALL, 13 cases of AML, 2 cases of Hairy cell leukemia out of 166 cases of pancytopenia, over a 6 year period. (5)
We came across 8 cases of chronic infection in our study, 3 of them were tubercular constituting 5 % of total cases. In our study no cases of malaria was found whereas Khunger J.M et al reported malaria 1%, Tilak V et al 3.9% and Kumar et al of 3 % of total cases (4, 5 7).
Reported incidence of Multiple Myeloma in pancytopenia patients was 4% by Khodke K et et al, 1.3 % by Tilak V et al and 1 % by Khunger JM et al. (4, 7 8) while we have not found any case of multiple myeloma having pancytopenia.
We found a single case of Gauchers disease in our study.Kumar R et al, Khunger JM et al and Khodke et al have not reported any case of storage disorder as a cause of pancytopenia In their studies (5, 7, 8).
CONCLUSION: Pancytopenia is not an uncommon hematological problem encountered in clinical practice and should be suspected on clinical grounds when a patient presents with unexplained anemia, prolonged fever, tendency to bleed, lymphadenopathy and hepatosplenomegaly. No specific symptoms are related with any specific diagnosis.
In our country main cause of pancytopenia being fortunately megaloblastic anaemia which responds very well to treatment if diagnosed correctly in time.The present study concludes that detailed haematological investigations along with bone marrow examination in cytopenic patients are not only helpful in understanding the disease process but also to diagnose or to rule out the causes of pancytopenia and planning further investigations and management of these patients.
ACKNOLEDGEMENT: I would like to extend special thanks to Dr Sharda Balani, and technical staff Mr K.P. Verma.
(1.) Kar M, Ghosh A. Pancytopenia Journal. Indian Academy of Clinical Medicine. 2002; 3:29-341.
(2.) Ishtiaq O, Baqai HZ, Anwer F, Hussai N., " Patterns of pancytopenia patients in a general medical ward and a proposed diagnostic approach". [Last accessed on 2007]. Available from:http://www.ayubmed.edu.pk/JAMC/PAST/16-1/osama.htm-206K-6/24/2007.
(3.) Guinan EC, Shimamura A. Wintrobe's Clinical Hematology. In: Greer JP, Foerster J, Lukens JN, Rodgers GM, Paraskevas F, Glader B, editors., "Acquired and inherited aplastic anemia syndromes". 11th ed. Philadelphia: Lippincott Williams and Wilkins; 2004. pp. 1397-419.
(4.) Tilak V, Jain R. "Pancytopenia-A Clinico-hematologic analysis of 77 case", Indian J Pathol Microbiol.1992;42:399-404. [PubMed].
(5.) Kumar R, Kalra SP, Kumar H, Anand AC, Madan M. "Pancytopenia-A six year study." J Assoc Physicians India. 2001;49:1079-81. [PubMed].
(6.) Tijendersingh, "atlas and text of hematology", page 106.
(7.) Khunger JM, Arculselvi S, Sharma U, Ranga S, Talib VH. "Pancytopenia-A Clinico-hematological study of 200 cases." Indian J PatholMicrobiol. 2002;45:375-9. [PubMed].
(8.) Khodke K, Marwah S, Buxi G, Vadav RB, Chaturvedi NK., "Bone marrow examination in cases of pancytopenia" J Academy Clin Med. 2001;2:55-9.
(9.) Verma N, Dash S, " A reappraisal of underlying pathology in adult patients presenting with pancytopenia." Trop Geogr Med 1992;44:322-7.
(10.) Bajracharya SB, Pande R, Bhandari PB, Sinha R, Guragain P., " An Approach to Aplastic anemia.", Medical Journal of Shree Birendra Hospital. The Journal of the Royal Nepalese Army Medical Corps 2005;7:82-83.
(11.) "International agranulocytosis and aplastic anemia study. Incidence of aplastic anemia, the relevance of diagnostic criteria. ", Blood 1987;70:1718-21.
(12.) Keisu M, Ost A. "Diagnosis in patients with severe pancytopenia suspected of having aplastic anemia", Eur J Haematol 1990;45:11-4.
(13.) Hossain MA, Akond AK, Chowdhary MK et al, "Pancytopenia-A study of 50 cases", Bangladesh Journal of Pathology 1992;1:9-12.
(14.) 14.B N Gayathri and KadamSatyanarayanRao, "pancytopenia: a clinico hematological study", J Lab Physicians. 2011 volume 3, issue no.1, page 15-20.
[1.] Rajendra Kumar Nigam
[2.] Rajni Chaudhary
[3.] Reeni Malik
[4.] Devendra Gour
[5.] Atul Shrivastava
[6.] Ankita Tripathi
[7.] Rajnikant Ahirwar
[8.] Rubal Jain
PARTICULARS OF CONTRIBUTORS:
[1.] Professor, Department of Pathology, Gandhi Medical College, Bhopal, Madhya Pradesh.
[2.] Assistant Professor, Department of Pathology, Gandhi Medical College, Bhopal, Madhya Pradesh.
[3.] Head Of the Department, Department of Pathology, Gandhi Medical College, Bhopal, Madhya Pradesh.
[4.] Associate Professor, Department of Community Medicine, Gandhi Medical College, Bhopal, Madhya Pradesh.
[5.] Senior Research Office, Population based Cancer Registry, ICMR, Gandhi Medical College, Bhopal, Madhya Pradesh.
[6.] D.C.P Student, Department of Pathology--Studying, Gandhi Medical College, Bhopal, Madhya Pradesh.
[7.] PG Student, Department of Pathology--Studying, Gandhi Medical College, Bhopal, Madhya Pradesh.
[8.] PG Student, Department of Pathology--Studying, Gandhi Medical College, Bhopal, Madhya Pradesh.
NAME ADDRESS EMAIL ID OF THE CORRESPONDING AUTHOR:
Dr. Rajendra Kumar Nigam, C-116, Shahpura, Bhopal, Madhya Pradesh, India--46209.
Date of Submission: 30/10/2013.
Date of Peer Review: 31/10/2013.
Date of Acceptance: 18/11/2013.
Date of Publishing: 22/11/2013.
Table 1: Common causes of pancytopenia with age and sex distribution in the study S. no. Disease Total Male Female Most common cases age group 1 Megaloblastic 67 43 24 20-40 anemia 2 Hypoplastic 20 9 11 00-14 anemia 3 Dimorphic 13 6 7 20-40 anemia 4 ALL 9 6 3 00-14 5. AML 8 3 5 20-40 6 Bone marrow 8 3 5 20-40 reactive to infection Table 3: Age, sex distribution compared to those in other studies of pancytopenia S, no Authors No. of Age M:F cases range(y) 1 Khunger JM et al (2002) (7) 200 2-70 1.2:1 2 Kumar R et al (2001) (5) 166 12-73 2.1:1 3 Khodke K et (2001) (8) 50 3-69 1.3:1 4 Tilak V et al (1999) (4) 77 5-70 1.14:1 5 B N Gayatri et al (2011) (14) 104 2-80 1.2:1 6 Present study 155 2-80 1.12:1 Table 4: A comparison of the first and second most common causes of pancytopenia in different studies Study Country Year no. of cases International agranulocytosis Israel & 1987 319 anemia study Europe group (11) Keisu & Isreal& Europe 1990 100 Ost (12) Hossain Bangladesh 1992 50 et al (13) Verma & India 1992 202 Dash (9) Tilak & India 1999 77 Jain (4) Kumar India 1999 166 et al (5) Khodke India 2000 50 et al (8) Bajracharyarya Nepal 2005 10 et al (11) B N Gayathri India 2007 104 et al (10) Present study India 2012 155 Study Commonest cause 2nd Most Commonest Cause International agranulocytosis Hypoplastic MDS anemia study anemia (52.7%) (4.5%) group (11) Keisu & Neoplastic disease Hypoplastic Ost (12) radiation (32%) anemia (19%) Hossain Hypoplastic Chronic malaria & et al (13) anemia chronic kalaazar Verma & Hypoplastic Megaloblastic Dash (9) anemia (40.6%) anemia (23.26%) Tilak & Megaloblastic Hypoplastic Jain (4) anemia (68%) anemia (7.7%) Kumar Hypoplastic Megaloblastic et al (5) anemia (29.51%) anemia (22.3%) Khodke Megaloblastic Hypoplastic et al (8) anemia (44%) anemia (14%) Bajracharyarya Hypoplastic Megaloblastic et al (11) anemia anemia B N Gayathri Megaloblastic Hypoplastic et al (10) anemia (74.04%) anemia (19%) Present study Megaloblastic Hypoplastic anemia (43.2%) anemia (12.9%)
|Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback|
|Title Annotation:||ORIGINAL ARTICLE|
|Author:||Nigam, Rajendra Kumar; Chaudhary, Rajni; Malik, Reeni; Gour, Devendra; Shrivastava, Atul; Tripathi,|
|Publication:||Journal of Evolution of Medical and Dental Sciences|
|Article Type:||Clinical report|
|Date:||Nov 25, 2013|
|Previous Article:||Congenital adrenal hyperplasia: presentation in a male infant.|
|Next Article:||Volume preloading prior to subarachnoid block: comparison between hetastarch (6%), polygelatin, Ringer's lactate solution.|