Opioid safety varies in elderly with nonmalignant pair.
The risks of opioid use for elderly patients with nonmalignant pain vary considerably by different agents and by different durations of use, a study has shown.
Patients taking codeine for more than 180 days are at increased risk for cardiovascular events, and those taking oxycodone or codeine for only 30 days are at increased risk for mortality due to any cause, said Dr. Daniel H. Solomon and his associates in the rheumatology department and the pharmacoepidemiology division at Brigham and Women's Hospital, Boston.
"This study's findings do not agree with a commonly held belief that all opioids are associated with similar risk," the investigators noted.
They compared the safety profiles of different opioids for the treatment of nonmalignant pain in elderly patients because "relatively little attention has been paid" to this issue even though the use of these drugs has increased by 50%-100% in recent years. In contrast, patients and physicians are relatively well informed about the toxicities of NSAIDs used for the same indications.
Dr. Solomon and his colleagues analyzed information in two states' Medicare databases of pharmaceutical coverage for low-income patients (mean age, 79 years) between 1995 and 2005. They were able to match 6,275 subjects who took five of the most commonly prescribed opioids for a variety of baseline factors using propensity scores.
Hydrocodone was used as the reference exposure, to which codeine, oxycodone, propoxyphene, and tramadol were compared.
The risk of cardiovascular events including MI, stroke, heart failure, revascularization, and cardiac death was similar across the five opioid groups after 30 days of use, but by 180 days the risk with codeine was significantly elevated (risk ratio, 1.62), compared with the other four opioids.
This finding is surprising and requires validation in other study populations, the investigators said (Arch. Intern. Med. 2010;170:1979-86).
All-cause mortality was elevated after only 30 days of use for patients taking oxycodone (RR, 2.43) or codeine (RR, 2.05), but not for those taking other opioids.
In contrast, the risk of fracture of the hip, pelvis, wrist, or humerus was significantly reduced after 30 days of treatment for patients taking tramadol (RR, 0.21) or propoxyphene (RR, 0.54).
The risk of gastrointestinal adverse events--which included upper or lower GI bleeding and bowel obstruction--did not differ across opioid groups at either 30 days or 180 days. These risks remained consistent through a range of sensitivity analyses of the data. Importantly, the risks also were consistent regardless of whether patients were taking low, medium, high, or very high doses of the drugs. "The risks were substantial and translated into numbers needed to treat that would be considered clinically significant," Dr. Solomon and his associates wrote.
Major Finding: The risks of opioid use in elderly patients vary substantially according to the specific drug used and the duration of use.
Data Source: A propensity-matched cohort analysis involving more than 31,000 Medicare patients.
Disclosures: This study was supported by the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality. Dr. Solomon reported being an unpaid member of a celecoxib trial executive committee and an unpaid member of the data safety monitoring board for an analgesic trial, both sponsored by Pfizer.
VIEW ON THE NEWS
Opioids Not 'Interchangeable'
These findings "challenge the conventional notion that the safety profiles of opioids are generally interchangeable" and carry two important implications, said Dr. William C. Becker and Dr. Patrick G. O'Connor.
The first and most crucial implication is that the frequent use of codeine must be reexamined. "The untested but widespread assumption that codeine is safer from an addiction standpoint because of its lower potency may need to give way to these data demonstrating increased risk of cardiovascular events and all-cause mortality. If codeine is of middling efficacy for pain and is more risky than other opioids, there would be little reason to use it," they noted.
Second, the elevated fracture risk with opioid use "has solid biological plausibility" by two mechanisms of action: Opioids raise the rate of falls, and they suppress the production of androgen and estradiol, imperiling bone health. "Efforts to improve patients' understanding of safe medication-taking practices, providers' understanding of safe prescribing practices, and standardization of safety-oriented follow-up are sorely needed," they said.
DR. BECKER and DR. O'CONNOR are with Yale University, New Haven, Conn. They reported no relevant financial disclosures. These comments were taken from their invited commentary accompanying Dr. Solomon's report (Arch. Intern. Med. 2010;170:1986-8).
|Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback|
|Title Annotation:||MUSCULOSKELETAL DISORDERS|
|Comment:||Opioid safety varies in elderly with nonmalignant pair.(MUSCULOSKELETAL DISORDERS)|
|Author:||Moon, Mary Ann|
|Publication:||Family Practice News|
|Date:||Feb 1, 2011|
|Previous Article:||Central neuronal factors key to chronic pain.|
|Next Article:||Tx approaches vary for acute shoulder injuries.|