Printer Friendly

One gene governs finch beak size: Galapagos bird's postdrought molecular evolution detailed.

Natural selection can sometimes work one gene at time, a new study of Darwin's finches suggests.

Variants of one gene had a major effect on rapid changes in beak size after a drought, researchers report in the April 22 Science. The finding may help explain how Darwin's finches evolved into 18 species in an evolutionarily speedy 1 million to 2 million years.

A drought that struck the Galapagos island of Daphne Major in 2004 and 2005 put adaptation of some of Darwin's iconic finches on fast-forward. Competition for scarce seeds pitted medium-sized ground finches (Geospiza fortis) with big beaks against large ground finches (G. magnirostris) with big beaks. Big-beaked medium ground finches lost that contest. They died in large numbers, but medium ground finches with small beaks survived by eating small seeds. As a result, medium ground finches on the island tended to have smaller beaks after the drought than before.

Genetic variants of the HMGA2 gene control beak size in the birds, evolutionary geneticist Leif Andersson and colleagues now report. Birds with large-beak varieties of the gene were at a strong disadvantage during the drought, the researchers find.

The study takes "arguably the most elegant story in evolutionary biology and then fills in the nitty-gritty molecular details," says Hopi Hoekstra, an evolutionary biologist at Harvard University. While the researchers don't know precisely how the gene influences beak size, the work may help scientists better understand the genetic underpinnings of evolution, she says. "This is a beautiful and big first step."


Andersson, of Uppsala University in Sweden, teamed with Princeton University's Peter and B. Rosemary Grant, who have been documenting changes in populations of Darwin's finches for decades. The researchers previously discovered that a gene called ALX1 controls whether beaks are blunt or pointy (57V: 3/7/15, p. 7). But beak shape didn't seem to play a role in surviving the drought, the team found. Instead, beak size changed.

Andersson's group narrowed the search for the gene controlling beak size to a stretch of DNA that contains HMGA2 and three other genes. The researchers can't rule out that the other genes also affect beak size but say HMGA2 is the gene most strongly associated with the trait. It accounts for almost 30 percent of the shift in beak size during the drought, Andersson says. HMGA2 protein is known to help regulate how other genes are turned on or off. In humans and mice, the gene is associated with height, face development and other traits.

Birds that have two copies of the large-beak variant of the gene have big beaks, while two copies of the small-beak variant produce little beaks. Birds with one of each have intermediate-sized beaks. The small-beak variant was found 61 percent of the time in finches that survived the drought, but only 37 percent of the time in birds that died.

It's unusual for a single gene to have such a strong effect on survival, says plant ecologist Thomas Givnish of the University of Wisconsin-Madison. Researchers have documented many cases in which multiple genes each affect a trait a little bit. Genes with big effects may explain rapid evolutionary shifts.

Small-beak variants of HMGA2 aren't new changes brought on by the drought, Andersson says. The variant has been around for a long time, perhaps 1 million years or more, and may have come from interbreeding with tree finches, the researchers find.

Interbreeding between species is proving to be a powerful evolutionary force, says Daniela Palmer, an evolutionary biologist at the University of Chicago. Researchers are documenting more and more examples of interbreeding influencing evolution of organisms as diverse as butterflies and humans (SN: 3/5/16, p. 18), she says. "Hybridization contributes major genetic variation to shape adaptation."

Caption: Medium ground finches (Geospiza fortis, shown) shifted from big beaks to small ones after a drought. Most of that shift was traced to big-and small-beak variants of a gene called HMGA2.
COPYRIGHT 2016 Society for Science and the Public
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2016 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Title Annotation:GENES & CELLS; HMGA2 gen in Darwin's finches
Author:Saey, Tina Hesman
Publication:Science News
Geographic Code:0PACR
Date:May 28, 2016
Previous Article:Exoplanet trio could harbor life: worlds orbiting cool star are good place to look for aliens.
Next Article:Ions, not neurons, may oversee sleep: potassium spike in brain initiates eye-opening jolt, study finds.

Terms of use | Privacy policy | Copyright © 2022 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters |