Nudibranch range shifts associated with the 2014 warm anomaly in the Northeast Pacific.
The winter of 2013-14 in the NE Pacific Ocean was unusually warm, with peak sea surface temperature (SST) anomalies greater than 2.5[degrees]C observed over a large part of the Gulf of Alaska in February (Bond et al. 2015). By May the warm SSTs had spread to the coastal zone and southward, where they merged with similarly warm anomalies resulting in part from reduced upwelling off southern California and northern Baja California (Leising et al. 2014). Despite the lack of even a moderate El Nino, the remainder of 2014 and early 2015 was marked by warmer than normal SSTs along the entire west coast of North America (Fig. 1) (Leising et al. 2014; CCIEA 2015). As indicated by the Pacific Decadal Oscillation (PDO) index, multivariate El Nino Southern Oscillation (ENSO) index (MEI), and the North Pacific Gyre Oscillation (NPGO), the entire region had undergone a major phase shift in ocean conditions (Leising et al. 2014), potentially similar to the 1976-77 climate shift in the North Pacific Ocean (Miller et al. 1994; Mantua and Hare 2002). Indeed, the value of the PDO index for December 2014 was the highest ever recorded for that month (Heberton 2015).
The California Current Ecosystem encompasses the coastline from Oregon to Baja California Sur. In this system positive values of the MEI and PDO are associated with warmer SSTs and reduced upwelling, and negative values of the NPGO are associated with weakened southerly flow and reduced nutrients and primary production (reviewed by CCIEA). As demonstrated by Schultz et al. (2011), these conditions (which include moderate to strong El Nino events) are correlated with increased intertidal abundance of nudibranch gastropods in California, especially southern species, and can sometimes also force long-term shifts in their northern range limits (Goddard et al. 2011).
Our observations in 2014 and early 2015 of nudibranchs and other sea slugs in long-term intertidal study sites in southern and central California, combined with dive reports from southern California, and posts on various photo and observation-sharing websites, indicated that similar range shifts and increases in abundance of southern species of sea slugs were occurring again in California. Most conspicuous among these was the dramatic increase in intertidal density in northern California of the bright pink dorid nudibranch Okenia rosacea (Kraybill-Voth 2015; Stephens 2015). We therefore intensified sampling of sea slug populations in northern California and southern Oregon, and alerted colleagues from northern California to Washington about changes they might expect to see in the composition of the nudibranch fauna. Here, we summarize our findings, not just to document changes in distribution and abundance associated with the unusual, non-El Nino related warming of 2014, but also because we predict that many of the species observed in this study will likely be carried to unprecedented northerly latitudes by the strong 2015-16 El Nino in the Pacific Ocean (Climate Prediction Center/ NCEP 2015).
Materials and Methods
To quantify the abundance of nudibranchs and other sea slugs we conducted timed counts in the low intertidal zone at 28 sites from Los Angeles County, California to Coos County, Oregon (Fig. 2, Table 1). Additionally, CH used SCUBA to sample four subtidal sites in Santa Barbara, Ventura, and Los Angeles Counties, and BG used SCUBA to sample Point Cabrillo, Monterey and the Santa Cruz Wharf. We also qualitatively sampled the sides of floating docks in Charleston, Oregon and the Santa Cruz and Monterey Harbors in California. Intertidally we focused on pools, the under-rock microhabitats supporting the sessile prey of nudibranchs, and green macro-algae known to support sacoglossan sea slugs. Intertidal surveys usually started approximately 1 h before low tide and lasted 2-3 h depending on the size of the site and the numbers of observers, which varied from one to seven. Subtidal surveys lasted approximately 60 minutes each, with the number of trained observers varying between one and three. For analyses and presentation, data for each species from the timed counts were converted to number of individuals [h.sup.-1] [observer.sup.-1]. When possible we collected vouchers specimens and deposited them in the Invertebrate Zoology Collection at the California Academy of Science (CAS). These are referenced below by CASIZ followed by the collection number. For additional reports of unusual occurrence, we monitored posts on Flickr, iNaturalist, OCDiving, SoCal Underwater Photographers on Facebook, and Bodegahead.blogspot.com. From these internet-based sources we used only records accompanied by an image and the date and locality of observation.
With two exceptions, we chose a cut-off date of 31 August 2015 for inclusion of new observations from all sources. The exceptions were (1) large Aplysia vaccaria observed subtidally on the Monterey Peninsula in mid-September 2015 (see Results), and (2) a large specimen of the nudibranch Janolus barbarensis found on 12 September 2015 (see Results). These individuals would have recruited months earlier to the benthos, prior to the full impact in the region of the developing 2015-16 El Nino.
While examining our results it became apparent that many of the species we observed in this study have only been observed at some of our northerly study sites during previous warm water events, especially moderate to strong El Ninos. Where appropriate we describe these patterns of occurrence, utilizing historical records and following Null's (2015) classification of El Nino events as weak, moderate or strong. Additionally, our study sites include those described by Schultz et al. (2011) and Goddard et al. (2011), and where appropriate we follow their geographic classification of nudibranch species in the region as southern, northern, or widespread.
We obtained historical records of occurrence from: (1) published literature, (2) the online database for the Invertebrate Zoology Collection at the California Academy of Science (CAS), (3) historical time series provided by Schultz et al. (2015) and Goddard et al. (2015), and (4) unpublished field accounts of California nudibranchs by James R. Lance, Richard A. Roller, and Gary R. McDonald. The field accounts of Lance and Roller are housed at CAS, and the data from the Lance accounts for outer coast sites in San Diego County are publicly accessible online (California Academy of Sciences and Goddard 2013). The McDonald data, which cover the years 1967-2010, primarily in central California, are in an unpublished spreadsheet sent to the senior author (G. R. McDonald, personal communication to JG, March 9, 2010). We reference specimens from CAS using the collection number, prefaced by CASIZ, or entire groups of conspecific specimens simply as "CASIZ collection records". As indicated above, those records are publicly available online.
Significant locality records of nudibranchs and other sea slugs in California and Oregon in 2014-15 are listed systematically by species and documented below. Nine of these represent new or previously unpublished northernmost locality records and are marked with an asterisk (*). The remaining 21 species included below have previously been recorded from at least as far north as we found them in 2014-15, usually during strong El Nino events, but typically occur significantly farther south. For each of these we note their usual and extreme northerly range limits and describe the anomalous patterns of distribution and abundance we observed from late 2013 through August 2015. Locality records obtained from non-peer reviewed sources or websites (excluding museum databases) are referenced in footnotes, as are images we posted online of specimens we found during this study.
* Placida cremoniana (Trinchese, 1892)
The single specimen of Placida cremoniana found on 10 Oct 2014 at 12 m at Stony Point, Santa Catalina Island (1) is the first record of this widespread tropical sacoglossan in the northeast Pacific north of La Paz, Baja California Sur (Angulo-Campillo 2002). Another specimen was found on 23 May 2015 at about 27 m depth at Casino Point, Santa Catalina Island. (2)
Navanax inermis (Cooper, 1863)
Navanax inermis is a Californian species rare north of Point Conception. It has been recorded as far north as the Bolinas Lagoon (Behrens 1998; Behrens and Hermosillo 2005) and Bodega Bay (Gosliner and Williams 2007), where it was reported by J. Standing and colleagues as rare to common. (3) The Bolinas record was linked by Behrens (1998) to the 1992-93 El Nino, and similarly the latter record from Bodega Bay can probably be linked to the strong El Nino of 1972-73, which coincided with sampling conducted by Standing et al. in the early 1970's in Bodega Bay. (3) On 4 June 2015 Grace Ha found one specimen of Navanax inermis in Bodega Bay. (4)
We found N. inermis crawling on the concrete wall below the Harbor Master's Office in the Monterey Harbor on 25 October 2014, 10 January 2015, and 21 May 2015, the first time we had seen this species in the Monterey Harbor since beginning observations there in 2008. On 14 May 2015 Robin Agarwal found a specimen in the Santa Cruz Harbor. (5)
Aplysia californica (Cooper, 1863)
Aplysia californica rarely occurs on the outer coast north of Point Conception, but has been recorded in bays as far north as Yaquina Bay, Oregon, the latter during the strong 1982-83 El Nino (Pearcy and Schoener, 1987).
On 1 December 2013, we found 20 individuals in the intertidal zone at Hazard Canyon Reef, the first we had seen in 14 years of approximately semi-annual sampling there. We did not find any at Hazard Canyon during two trips in May 2014, but observed two individuals on 18 May 2015. In temporally more limited sampling at Tarantula Reef beginning in 2009, we had not found A. californica until 2 February 2015, when the senior author counted 64 individuals. Similarly, two of us (WP and DM) have been sampling the Monterey Harbor since 2008 and found A. californica there for the first time on 23 September 2014, and through July 2015 had seen it there on five more visits. From August 2014 through April 2015 BG observed many A. californica, 8 to 15 m deep, off Monterey and Pacific Grove, and on 20 May 2015 found one specimen intertidally at San Dollar Beach, in southern Monterey County. By mid2015 high densities had also been reported from two sites on the outer coast of Sonoma County (6,7), as well as from San Francisco and Tomales Bays (Anonymous 2015; Bay Nature Staff 2015).
On 14 August 2015, Dr. Troy Nash and his summer Invertebrate Zoology class from the Oregon Institute of Marine Biology (OIMB) found three specimens on a wave-protected rocky shore (43.3400[degrees] N, 124.3750[degrees] W) at Gregory Point, near Charleston, Oregon (T. Nash, personal communication to JG, 22 Oct 2015). Based on the image posted by OIMB6 7 8, one of the slugs was about 17 cm long and found on the red alga Neorhodomela larix (Turner, 1819). These specimens are to our knowledge the first ever found on the outer coast of Oregon.
Examination of the dates of collection of the specimens at CAS of A. californica collected from Monterey Bay north since 1950 reveals that all but one were collected during El Nino events. CASIZ 57362, collected in San Francisco Bay in December 1984, may have been a 2nd generation holdover from the 1982-83 El Nino, one of the strongest on record.
Aplysia vaccaria Winckler, 1955
We have been sampling Naples semi-annually to monthly since fall 2006 and on 20 September 2013 found Aplysia vaccaria for the first time there. We recorded single specimens again in September, October, and November 2014. Aplysia vaccaria has been recorded as far north as Monterey Bay, California (Behrens 1991; Behrens and Hermosillo), and large specimens were observed subtidally by Cheryl Mitchell off the Monterey Breakwater on 18 September 2015 (9).
Olcenia angelensis Lance, 1966
This species has been recorded once from as far north as San Francisco Bay, in September 1964 (Lance 1966), and from Monterey Bay in September 1963 (Lance) and again in October 1971 (CASIZ 9168). 1963-64 was a moderate El Nino, but 1971 was a moderate La Nina. DM found one individual (10) of O. angelensis on the H dock in the Monterey Harbor on 30 September 2014 and more at the same locality in April and June, 2015. On 17 July 2015 Donna Pomeroy and Robin Agarwal found O. angelensis on floating docks in the Pillar Point Harbor in Half Moon Bay, San Mateo County (11).
Okenia rosacea (MacFarland, 1905)
Okenia rosacea (Fig. 3A) was present in low abundance at two sites in central California in spring 2014 (Fig. 4). However, by fall, its abundance at both sites had increased an order of magnitude, and by winter 2014-15 had reached levels not seen before at our historical study sites in central California (Table 2). The density observed at Sand Dollar Beach, Monterey County during the strong El Nino of 1997-98 matched the densities we observed in 2015, and brief, qualitative observations by the senior author at Scott Creek on 28 December 1997 indicated similarly high abundance. On 3 January 2015 Jackie Sones of the Bodega Marine Laboratory (BML) reported finding 14 0. rosacea in a 2 m section of low intertidal shore at Bodega Head, the first specimens she had seen of this species in ten years of sampling at Bodega Head (12).
On 21 January 2015 we counted 7.7 O. rosacea [h.sup.-1] [observer.sup.-1] at Coleman Beach, followed by 19.7 O. rosacea [h.sup.-1] [observer.sup.-1] at Glass Beach, Fort Bragg on 16 Feb 2015, the same day that Spencer Dybdahl Riffle (personal communication to JG, 17 February 2015) counted 46 individuals at Patrick's Point SP near Trinidad in Humboldt County, and the day before David Anderson (personal communication to JG 21 April 2015) found 12 individuals at False Klamath Cove in Del Norte County. In March BG observed 13 O. rosacea at Luffenholtz Beach, near Trinidad (CASIZ 204572) and another seven at Wilson Creek, False Klamath Cove (CASIZ 2014576). On May 7, two weeks after we asked him to be on the lookout for O. rosacea at Cape Arago, Oregon, Richard Emlet of OIMB and his Invertebrate Zoology class found a specimen just south of Sunset Bay, Cape Arago (R. Emlet, personal communication to JG, 8 May 2015).
In May, June and July 2015 in Oregon we found O. rosacea at Harris Beach, Lone Ranch, House Rock, Whiskey Creek, and Middle Cove, Cape Arago, and Gregory Point. The specimen from Lone Ranch on 18 July was spawning (Fig. 3 A), and the highest number of O. rosacea we found at the Oregon sites was 21 (or 1.0 individuals [h.sup.-1] [observer.sup.-1]) on 16 June 2015 at Whiskey Creek. We deposited specimens of O. rosacea from Whiskey Creek and Middle Cove, Cape Arago at CAS (CASIZ 204855 and 204854, respectively). On 2 July 2015 Spencer Dybdahl Riffle found abundant O. rosacea and egg masses intertidal ly at Patrick's Point SP, Humboldt County (13). On 28 August 2015 NT found one O. rosacea at North Cove Cape Arago, the first specimen ever recorded from that site.
The above specimens from Oregon are not only the most ever observed in the state, but the first recorded from Oregon since JG found one individual of O. rosacea at Middle Cove, Cape Arago on 24 July 1998, after 16 years of sampling for nudibranchs at Cape Arago, and during that year's exceptionally strong El Nino (JG, unpublished data and photograph). The only other record of O. rosacea in Oregon is from Steinberg (1963) who, based on observations by L. Andrews, recorded it (as Hopkinsia rosacea) from Coos Bay. However, Integripelta bilabiata, the sole prey of O. rosacea, does not occur inside Coos Bay, but rather on the open coast at nearby Cape Arago (JG, personal observations). Further, the specimen observed by L. Andrews was in an aquarium at OIMB and may actually have been collected in California (L. Andrews, personal communication to JG, 19 November 2009). Therefore, the northernmost verified locality for this species should be recorded as Gregory Point, Oregon.
* Trapania velox (Cockerell, 1901)
BG found one specimen at 5 m depth on sponges on a piling underneath the Santa Cruz Pier on 31 August 2015 (CASIZ 209038), extending the known range of this Californian species across Monterey Bay from Carmel, California (Behrens and Hermosillo). After one day in captivity in Santa Cruz, the specimen laid two egg masses. All records of Trapania velox from Carmel (in 2004, 2006 and 2009) (14,15) can be associated with weak to moderate El Ninos, or in the case of 2006, a short, weak La Nina following the 2003-04 and 2004-05 El Nino events.
Acanthodoris rhodoceras Cockerell in Cockerell and Eliot, 1905
This species has been found as far north as central Oregon (Goddard 1997), during the moderate 1991-92 El Nino, and the only other published record of this species from Oregon (Goddard 1990) can be associated with the strong 1987-88 El Nino. In August 2015, NT found a total of eight specimens during five trips to Hunters Cove, on the south side of Cape Sebastian, Oregon. The specimens were the dull colored form as pictured in Figure 15 of McDonald and Nybakken (1980).
Crimora coneja Marcus, 1961
Until recently Crimora coneja was known from only three mainland sites between Cape Arago, Oregon and San Diego County, California: Punta Gorda, Humboldt County (Goddard 1987), and Montana de Oro State Park and Morro Bay in San Luis Obispo County (16). On 18 June 2015 we found two specimens at Middle Cove, Cape Arago, and on 15 July two more at Whiskey Creek, and on 15 August one specimen at Lone Ranch. All of the specimens from Oregon were found on Hincksina minuscula, the only known prey of C. coneja. Additionally, three other new locality records were added in 2015: (1) Trinidad, Humboldt County by Cassidy Grattan (17), (2) Pillar Point by Matt Knoth (18), and (3) Palmer's Point, Humboldt County by Cassidy Grattan, who on 2 August reported 10 specimens from Trinidad (19). Since these reports additional specimens have been found at Pillar Point (20), and NT found a single specimen at North Cove, Cape Arago on 28 August.
During 14 years of observation at North and Middle Coves, Cape Arago from 1980 to 2008 Crimora coneja was found in seven years: three during the second year of strong El Nino events (1982-83, 1987-88, 1997-98), two during weak La Ninas (1984-85, 1985-86), and once during ENSO-neutral conditions (1981) (Goddard 1984, and unpublished data).
Polycera atra MacFarland, 1905
This southern species has been found in Oregon, mainly in bays, only during strong El Nino events (Goddard 1984, unpublished data) and has been recorded once from Westport, just inside Grays Harbor, Washington, during the 1997-98 El Nino (Lamb and Hanby 2005; A. Lamb, personal communication to K. Fletcher, forwarded to JG, 13 Sept 2012). On 17 June 2015 we found two specimens of P. atra on the sides of floating docks in the outer Charleston boat Basin.
Triopha maculata MacFarland, 1905
Although recorded from Bamfield, British Columbia (Millen 1983) and Cape Arago, Oregon (Goddard 1984), Triopha maculata rarely occurs north of Cape Mendocino, California. From 18 May to 4 July 2015 in Oregon we found T. maculata at Chetco Point, Harris Beach, Lone Ranch, House Rock, Whiskey Creek, Cape Blanco, all three coves at Cape Arago, and Squaw Island. One of us (NT) has been sampling four of these sites for nudibranchs since 2008 and never observed this species before, and records of T. maculata from southern Oregon between 1980 and 2010 show that it occurred mainly during El Nino events (Fig. 5). Large specimens have also been observed in the Charleston boat basin during El Nino events (JG, personal observations), and on 28 August 2015 NT found one specimen there 6 cm long.
Thordisa bimaculata Lance, 1966
Thordisa bimaculata has been reported from Isla Natividad, Baja California to Carmel, California (Lance). Although it can be locally abundant on rocky shores in San Diego County (Sphon and Lance 1968; California Academy of Sciences and Goddard 2013), there are only a few records of this species from Santa Barbara County (Sphon and Lance 1968; CASIZ 98793), none from San Luis Obispo County, and besides the single specimen reported by Lance from off Carmel, there have been few sightings from Monterey County (21). On 5 July 2015 Regina Roberts found a specimen laying an egg mass on a brown sponge at an unspecified depth off Point Joe, on the Monterey Peninsula (22).
We found a total of eight T. bimaculata on 6 November 2014, 30 January 2015, and 17 March 2015 at Tarpits Reef, Carpinteria. These were the first specimens we had found at that site since beginning semi-annual to quarterly sampling there in May 2008. At Naples we recorded our first specimens on 3 May and 5 November 2010, during that year's moderate El Nino, and did not find any more there until finding one specimen on 19 February 2015 and another on 22 April 2015. On 3 July 2015 CH found one specimen at 7 m at Carpinteria Reef, and on 1 September 2015 CH found one specimen of T. bimaculata at 7 m depth at Punta Bocana, Bahia Magdalena, Baja California Sur, a new southernmost locality for this species.
Felimare californiensis (Bergh, 1879)
CH found three Felimare californiensis at 8 m on Carpinteria Reef on 3 July 2015, and five more at this same site on 18 July 2015. This species appears to have gone regionally extinct in southern California in 1984 (Goddard et al. 2013), and these specimens are the first to be reported on the mainland of the Santa Barbara Channel since its recovery in the Southern California Bight began in 2003, near the end of the moderate 2002-03 El Nino (Hoover 2015).
Felimida macfarlandi (Cockerell, 1901)
This brilliantly colored chromodorid nudibranch has been recorded from Bahia Magdalena, Baja California Sur (Bertsch 1978) to Monterey, California (MacFarland 1966) but is usually found south of Point Conception. On 6 March 2015, Jon McNeill found one individual subtidally at Point Lobos (J. McNeil, personal communication and image to JG, 9 October 2015). This was followed by Dave Baessler's subtidal observations at the Monterey Breakwater of one specimen (23) on 7 July 2015, and two more (24) on 29 July 2015. These are the first specimens documented from the Monterey Peninsula since the strong 1998 El Nino, when Gary McDonald found one subtidally at Del Monte Beach (25). Gary McDonald also found one individual intertidally at Carmel Point in February 1986, during ENSO neutral conditions following a weak La Nina.
CAS has six lots of specimens of F. macfarlandi collected from the Monterey Peninsula in the following years: 1906, 1908, 1909, 1941, 1963 and 1978. Based on the values of the extended multivariate ENSO Index presented by Wolter and Timlin (2011), moderate El Nino events occurred in 1906, 1941, and 1963, and 1978 was a weak El Nino following the 197677 decadal climate shift. 1908-09 experienced weak to moderate La Ninas, indicating that either F. macfarlandi is not always dependent on El Nino conditions to reach the Monterey Peninsula, or that once arrived (in this case, in 1906) populations can persist locally for a few years through self-recmitment.
* Doriopsilla fulva (MacFarland, 1905)
Hoover et al. (2015) reinstated Doriopsilla fulva as distinct from D. albopunctata. The latter, which is more common intertidally in southern California, can be recognized externally by its white spots around and between the dorsal tubercles, compared to the single, apically-located white spot per tubercle on D.fulva. Doriopsilla fulva is also usually bright yellow in color and is more common intertidally than D. albopunctata north of Point Conception (Hoover et al. 2015).
We found one specimen of D.fulva, 8 mm long, at Whiskey Creek on 16 June 2015 (CASIZ 208751; Fig. 3B). This is the first record of this species in Oregon, and extends its known range from Abalone Beach in Humboldt County, California (Jaeckle 1984). NT found an additional specimen, 11 mm long, at Lone Ranch on 15 August 2015, and we found another specimen (26). 14 mm long, at Punta Gorda, California on 15 June 2015. On 22 Jan 2015 at Asilomar we recorded 28.2 D.fulva [obs.sup.-1] [h.sup.-1], the highest recorded since Nybakken and colleagues counted 24.7 [obs.sup.-1] [h.sup.-1] in April 1973, during that year's strong El Nino (see Schultz et al. 2015). Additionally, D.fulva was reported to be more abundant at Bodega Head in 2015 compared to previous years (27).
Doriopsilla gemela Gosliner, Schaefer and Millen, 1999
After seven years of approximately semi-annual sampling at Tarpits Reef, Carpinteria we found this species for the first time on 20 April 2015 and again on 19 May 2015. On both dates we found three large, mature adults (Fig. 3C), all with the combination of yellow gills and densely packed, opaque white spots concentrated in the middle of the dorsum characteristic of this species. At Naples we had observed single specimens on 5 February 2008, 29 November 2009, and 24 November 2012. However, on five of 11 sampling trips from April 2014 to May 2015 we found a total of nine specimens. BG found one specimen at 15 m off Point Cabrillo, Monterey on 13 October 2014. There is only one other verified record of this species in central California (also from 2014, off the Monterey Peninsula; see Hoover et al.), and the southern coast of Santa Barbara County, which includes Naples and Point Conception, appears to mark its usual northern range limit.
Hancockia califomica MacFarland, 1923
There are only two historical records of this species from north of Marin County: (1) Jaeckle's (1984) record from Trinidad, Humboldt County, which contrary to Behrens and Hermosillo is the northernmost record of Hancockia califomica, and (2) Behrens (2004) record for Fort Bragg, Mendocino County. However, the record from Fort Bragg was based on a misidentified specimen (28) of Dendronotus subramosus MacFarland, 1966 (confirmed by D. Behrens, personal communication to JG, 4 April 2008). On 23 May 2015 Jackie Sones found a specimen of Hancockia califomica at Coleman Beach, Sonoma County (29), and on 2 August 2015 Spencer Dybdahl-Riffle found a specimen, 5 mm long, at Trinidad (30).
Doto form A of Goddard (1996)
Doto form A is the most common Doto in the southern California bight and is commonly observed subtidally on campanularid hydroids growing on kelp and other macroalgae. It has been found as far north as Drake's Estero, Point Reyes National Seashore (Goddard 1996) but rarely occurs north of Point Conception. Goddard (1996) argued for the separation of this form from D. amyra Marcus, 1961 based on morphological and developmental evidence, and the genetic evidence presented by Shipman and Gosliner (2015) corroborate this. Compared to Doto amyra, Doto form A has cerata with brighter colored cores and longer, distinctly white papillae. It also has smaller eggs than D. amyra and planktotrophic development. Since mid-2014 Robin Agarwal and Donna Pomeroy have made numerous sightings of this species (cited as Doto amyra), frequently with its egg masses, in Morro and Monterey Bays, and at Pillar Point (31). BG collected two specimens from the Santa Cmz Harbor on 28 August 2015 (CASIZ 207370)
Dirona picta MacFarland in Cockerell and Eliot, 1905
Dirona picta has been reported from as far north as Cape Meares, Oregon (Goddard 1997) but has rarely been observed on the outer coast of Oregon (Goddard 1984: 159, 1990), and the only specimen recorded from Cape Arago was during the strong 1997-98 El Nino (JG, personal observations). We found single specimens of it on 17 June 2015 at Cape Blanco and in the Charleston outer boat basin, and another specimen at 5-Mile Point on 1 August 2015.
* Janolus anulatus Camacho-Garcia and Gosliner, 2006
On 13 August 2015 one of us (CH) found one specimen of Janolus anulatus at Tarpits Reef, the first seen there since the first specimens were recorded from this site on 9 May, 20 June, and 4 July 2012 (CASIZ 189 4 20) (32), following a transition from a weak La Nina to moderately positive values of the ME1. Previously, this species was known from La Jolla, California to Costa Rica (Behrens and Hermosillo; Camacho-Garcia et al. 2005).
Based on data collected by James Lance and colleagues from 1964 to 2002, J. anulatus (distinguished from J. barbarensis and referred to by Lance first as Antiopella sp. and later as Janolus sp.) peaked in abundance in La Jolla, California during strong El Nino events (excluding the 1987-88 event), as well as following the 1976-77 climate shift (Fig. 6).
* Janolus barbarensis (Cooper, 1863)
This Californian and Panamic species has been recorded from as far north as San Francisco Bay (Jaeckle 1983; Behrens and Hermosillo 2005) but is rare north of Morro Bay. On 28 July 2015 Benson Chow of the Tiburon Romberg Center collected one specimen in the Sausalito Marina, inside San Francisco Bay (CASIZ 207372). On 25 August 2015 Robin Agarwal found an additional specimen on the side of a floating dock in San Francisco Bay (33), a day after finding one in the Santa Cruz Harbor (34), where she had first sighted one on 15 October 2014 (35). On 11 September 2015 Shawn Brumbaugh and Chris Kwan found a J. barbarensis at the Spud Point Marina, Bodega Bay, California and informed Jackie Sones and Eric Sanford from BML, who the next day found one specimen 63 mm long on Bugula neritina on the side of a floating dock at the same locality (36).
Flabellina bertschi Gosliner and Kuzirian, 1990
This Panamic species ranges from the northern Gulf of California to Panama (Gosliner 1994), and has also been reported from the outer coast of Baja California (Goddard and Schickel 2000), as well as Catalina Island (Behrens, 2004; Behrens and Hermosillo 2005). Behrens (2004) represents the northernmost record of this species, but did not include an image or reference to voucher specimens. CH found one specimen (Fig. 3D) at 2 m depth at Big Fisherman's Cove, Santa Catalina Island on 2 January 2015, feeding on a species of Eudendrium similar to that shown with F. bertschi in Mexico in Fig. 4B of Millen and Hermosillo (2007).
* Flabellina cooperi (Cockerell, 1901)
Known mainly from southern California, the northern range limit of Flabellina cooperi has been Elkhom Slough, Monterey Bay since 1970 (McDonald 19S3). Green and Gosliner (2016) presented molecular genetic evidence that specimens of a previously unidentified Flabellina with smooth to slightly wrinkled rhinophores and a notum irregularly covered with opaque white pigment collected by JG from Tarpits Reef, Santa Barbara County (CASIZ 195988) and Coleman Beach, Sonoma County (CASIZ 195990) are identical to F. cooperi from La Jolla, and (see below) Santa Cruz, California. Coleman Beach is therefore now the northernmost locality known for F. cooperi. The two specimens of F. cooperi from Coleman Beach (CASIZ 181322 and 195990) were collected on 29 April 2009 and 25 March 2010, respectively, at the beginning and end of the moderate 2009-10 El Nino.
On 28 August 2015 BG found one specimen of F. cooperi (CASIZ 207369) (37) in the Santa Cruz Harbor, and based on the morphology of the above specimens included by Green and Gosliner, two specimens of Flabellina found on 27 April 2015 by DM on the sides of floating docks in the Monterey Harbor (38) can now also be assigned to F. cooperi. Additionally, we have been sampling Naples regularly since 2006 and from 28 February to 3 May 2010 found a total of 30 F. cooperi (e.g., CASIZ 182720, 195986, as Flabellina sp.) (39), our first specimens of this species at that site. More recently, we found our first specimens of F. cooperi at Tarantula Reef on 3 January 2015, and additional specimens at Tarpits Reef on 30 January and 19 May 2015.
The original sightings of Flabellina cooperi at Elkhom Slough consisted of a total of three specimens collected on 16 November and 7 December 1970, during a moderate La Nina (McDonald 1983). Two years later, during a strong El Nino, Gary McDonald (unpublished field data) found an estimated total of 30 individuals on 18 and 19 October 1972.
Flabellina iodinea (Cooper, 1863)
Although long known from as far north as the west coast of Vancouver Island (Bernard 1970) and Puget Sound, Washington (Bergh, 1879), this highly conspicuous species rarely occurs on the outer coast north of Monterey Bay (Gosliner and Williams 1970; Bertsch et al. 1972; Goddard et al. 2015; Schultz et al. 2015). There are no published records from Oregon, and the only recent record from Washington is from subtidally near Cape Flattery during the strong 1997-98 El Nino (Lamb and Hanby 2005; A. Lamb personal commmunication to K Fletcher, forwarded to JG, 13 Sept 2012). On 15 May 2014 we found our first specimen at Hazard Canyon Reef since beginning our sampling there in 1999. We found another specimen at the same site on 18 May 2015. Further north, we found a specimen of F. iodinea on 20 January at Scott Creek, and by May 2015, specimens had been found in Bodega Bay (40), Coleman Beach (J. Sones personal communication to JG, 23 May 2015), and Trinidad, Humboldt County (41). Flabellina iodinea was first reported from Trinidad by Jaeckle (1984). On 4 July 2015 Spencer Dybdahl Riffle counted 23 F. iodinea in the tidepools at Trinidad (42).
* Anteaeolidiella chromosoma (Cockerell and Eliot, 1905)
On 21 May and 7 June 2015 we found a total of four specimens on the H dock in the Monterey Harbor. This species was previously known from as far north as Morro Bay (Behrens 1980) and ranges south to the Galapagos Islands (Camacho-Garcia et al. 2005). On 15 July 2015 Robin Agarwal found a specimen in the Santa Cruz Harbor, on the north side of Monterey Bay (43), and on 25 August 2015 found two specimens and their egg masses in San Francisco Bay (44). At Naples, A. chromosoma was more abundant in the first half of 2015 than at any time in the past ten years, with a lesser peak in abundance during the 2009-10 El Nino (JG, unpublished data).
* Anteaeolidiella oliviae (MacFarland, 1966)
The northern range limit of this species has long been Duxbury Reef, Marin County, California (Gosliner and Williams 1970). On 21 January 2015 we found one specimen at Coleman Beach, Sonoma County, and on 16 February 2015 we found one specimen at Glass Beach in Fort Bragg, Mendocino County (Fig. 3E). The latter specimen had unusually pale cerata, probably reflecting an atypical complement of the anthozoans normally consumed by this species (Beeman and Williams 1980).
Emarcusia morroensis Roller, 1972
This small (to 15 mm) cryptic species has been found only a few times since its original description and has been reported from Mission Bay, San Diego to San Francisco Bay (Roller 1972; Gosliner 1990). It is known mainly from bays (Roller 1972; McDonald 1983; CAS1Z collection records) and has been previously observed on the outer coast only twice: in September 1972 from a buoy anchor chain in Monterey Bay (CASIZ 69806), and in December 2007 from 15 m depth off Redondo Beach (45).
On 20 May 2015 the senior author found six specimens intertidally on the south side of Point Dume, Malibu (46). Robin Agarwal found a specimen in Morro Bay in September 2014, and another on 26 July 2015 in the Monterey Harbor (47). Two specimens were found in the Santa Cruz Harbor in August 2015, one by BG on the 28th (CASIZ 207371) (48), and another on the 31st by Robin Agarwal (49).
Babakina festiva (Roller, 1972)
Babakina festiva is known from Nayarit, Mexico to Duxbury Reef (Behrens and Hermosillo 2005). However, it has been reported previously only twice from north of Point Conception (Gosliner 1990) and both sightings can be linked to the strong El Nino of 1987-88. In 2015 we found two specimens on the north side of Pigeon Point, one on 19 January 2015 (Fig. 3F), and the other on 3 July 2015. Three more specimens were observed between February and July 2015 in the Fitzgerald Marine Reserve in San Mateo County (50).
* Noumeaella rubrofasciata Gosliner, 1991
On 21 February 2015 CH found a single specimen laying an egg string (Fig. 3G) at 18 m depth at County Line Reef, extending the known range of this species north from Santa Catalina Island (Gosliner 1991). CH observed two more at County Line Reef on 19 April 2015, and five specimens at Big Kelp Reef, Malibu on 7 March 2015. These specimens are the first CH has observed at these sites in four and five years of observation, respectively.
Cuthona phoenix Gosliner, 1981
This slender, distinctive aeolid has reported once from Monterey Bay (Behrens 1991) and also been observed in Morro Bay and a few sites total in southern California, the Gulf of California, and Costa Rica (Behrens 1980 [as Tergipes sp.]; Gosliner 1981; Camacho-Garcia et al. 2005; CASIZ collection records). Cuthona phoenix has usually been found among hydroids growing on flotsam, floats, or giant kelp, Macrocystis. On 14 September 2014 Robin and Marisa Agarwal found two specimens on Macrocystis next to docks in Morro Bay (51), on 24 July 2014 one of us (DM) found four specimens on Macrocystis at the H dock in the Monterey Harbor (CASIZ 199397) (Fig. 3H), and on 24 August 2015 Donna Pomeroy found specimens on Macrocystis in the Santa Cruz Harbor (52).
We documented northward range shifts related to the 2014 warm anomaly in the NE Pacific for 30 species of nudibranchs and other benthic sea slugs. Nine of these were recorded from new northernmost localities (Fig. 7), and the remainder, including Okenia rosacea, which reached unprecedented densities in northern California and Oregon, were found at or near their known northern range limits. Only the strong El Ninos of 1982-83 and 1997-98, as well as the 1976-77 climate shift are known to have forced similar shifts in the nudibranch fauna of the region (Pearcy and Schoener 1987; Engle and Richards 2001; Goddard et al. 2011; Schultz et al. 2011; see Goddard 1984, p. 157; and specific results above). During the 1976-77 climate shift, when the PDO shifted from cold to warm phase, the total abundance of southern species of nudibranchs in central California increased as northern species declined (Fig. 2 in Schultz et al. 2011). We observed a similar transition in 2014-15 at sites we have been monitoring regularly since at least 2008 (Fig. 8).
Our results demonstrate a striking biological response to the 2014 warm anomaly in the North Pacific Ocean. They also (1) reinforce indications that the anomaly was part of a regional climate shift, and (2) further demonstrate, as originally proposed by Schultz et al. (2011), that intertidal populations of nudibranchs--with their short life cycles and planktotrophic larvae closely track nearshore ocean conditions. Range shifts of these brilliantly colored species therefore constitute useful biological indicators of regional ocean climate. In fact, for much of the Oregonian Biogeographic Province, which stretches from Los Angeles to the northern end of Vancouver Island (Briggs and Bowen 2012), the population fluctuations of one species alone, Okenia rosacea, may serve as a valuable indicator. Integripelta bilabiata, its encrusting bryozoan prey, is locally abundant to British Columbia, and as we predicted for 2015 (see Kraybill-Voth 2015; Stephens 2015; and Appendix, reference 21), when populations of this conspicuously pink dorid increase north of San Francisco, other southern species follow. Triopha maculata, which historically has occurred more frequently and at more sites than O. rosacea in Oregon, especially during El Nino events (Fig. 5), would also appear to be a good indicator of elevated SSTs and increased poleward transport of coastal waters. Similarly, in the Californian Province, the appearance of Janolus anulatus in the San Diego area has historically been highly correlated with strong El Nino events (Fig. 6).
The mechanisms by which southern species of nudibranchs expand their ranges northward include increased poleward and onshore transport of planktonic larvae from southern source populations, especially during periods of reduced upwelling and with the late summer development in the Southern California Bight of the poleward inshore countercurrent, which north of Point Conception in the autumn becomes the strong poleward Davidson Current (Strub and James 2002; Schultz et al. 2011). Upwelling in 2014 off northern Baja California and southern California was anomalously low (Leising et al. 2014), and episodes of strong poleward transport of surface waters were measured by High Frequency Radar (HFR) in Fall 2014 and Winter 2015 off California by the Central and Northern California Ocean Observing System (CeNCOOS).
For example, surface flows of at least 50 cm [sec.sup.-1] were observed from Eureka to Cape Blanco from 4 to 9 Feb 2015 (Fig. 9), fast enough and over a long enough period to transport entrained larvae that entire distance. In fact, it was after observing Okenia rosacea spawning during early winter 2015 at Scott Creek, and then checking the surface flows recorded by CeNCOOS, that we predicted the occurrence of Okenia rosacea and other southern nudibranchs in southern Oregon by mid-2015 and first contacted colleagues there to be on the lookout for them.
With a strong El Nino developing on the heels of the 2014 warm anomaly (Climate Prediction Center/NCEP 2015), we expect that nudibranchs currently reproducing in their new northerly ranges (e.g., Okenia rosacea and Anteaeolidiella chromosoma) will be transported (as larvae) even farther north in the coming year. Some, including both specialists like O. rosacea and relative generalists like Triopha maculata and Dirona picta, will find abundant encrusting prey, formerly beyond their geographic reach. Local recruitment and reproduction of subsequent generations, combined with the accelerating rise in ocean temperatures owing to global warming (Blunden and Arndt 2015; Gleckler et al. 2016), may then result in long-term persistence of some of these species in their new ranges, a contrast to the ephemeral appearances associated with previous warm-water events, particularly El Ninos (reviewed by Lluch-Belda et al. 2005). The effects of these newly arrived, specialized, fast-growing predators will then gradually ripple through the benthic epifauna, altering species interactions and potentially changing community composition as they consume large patches of their prey, some of which, such as sponges, can be very long-lived.
All of the species listed above have free-swimming, planktotrophic larvae [Schmekel and Portmann 1982 (for Placida cremoniana)-, Goddard 2004; Goddard & Hermosillo 2008; Goddard & Green 2013; JG and BG, unpublished data], and most, if not all, were carried northward and onshore into their new ranges as larvae. However, with no records of the widespread sacoglossan Placida cremoniana from between Santa Catalina Island and La Paz, Mexico, we cannot mle out a human-mediated introduction of this species to southern California, nor for that matter be certain of its region of origin. Therefore, excluding P. cremoniana, the average northward range shift for the nudibranchs found at new northernmost localities in 2015 was 151 km (SD =113 km, n = 8). This includes Flabellina cooperi moving north from Elkhom Slough to Santa Cruz, but not to Coleman Beach, where it was found in 2009-10.
Notably absent from the 30 species listed above is Phidiana hiltoni. The northward spread, starting in 1977, of this large aeolid nudibranch from Monterey appears to have been stalled since 1992 by a combination of oceanographic and geographic features in the vicinity of Duxbury Reef and Point Reyes and the short duration of its lecithotrophic larval stage (Goddard et al. 2011). Further spread north of this species should be closely monitored and may depend on a different mechanism, such as chance rafting of adults or egg masses on drift macro-algae or other floating substrata supporting growths of it hydroid prey.
Goddard (1987) surmised that the rarely observed dorid nudibranch Crimora coneja "may ... be primarily sublittoral, with rare intertidal outbreaks." Its appearance intertidally in northern California and Oregon in 2015, especially at new sites, combined with the timing of much of its historical occurrence at Cape Arago (see Results), is consistent with increased onshore transport during warm-water events driving larval recruitment from subtidal populations, part of the overall mechanism driving intertidal recruitment of the southern nudibranchs we observed in this study. The same may apply to Emarcusia morroensis, another rare species, which prior to this year, had to our knowledge never been observed on open coast rocky shores.
We thank Will and Ziggy Goddard for their expert assistance in the field, Jackie Sones and Eric Sanford of the Bodega Marine Laboratory for sharing their observations and knowledge of the intertidal fauna of Bodega Head and Sonoma County, and David Anderson of the National Park Service and Richard Emlet of the University of Oregon for sharing their respective observations of Okenia rosacea in northern California and southern Oregon. We also thank Kate Wayne, James Treneman and Dana Garves for assisting us at Cape Arago, Emily Anthony for her assistance in southern Oregon, Craig Comu and Anne Donnelly for their hospitality in Coos Bay, and Karin Fletcher for her persistence in helping obtain the dates of observation of southern nudibranchs pictured in Lamb and Hanby (2005). BG thanks Allison Gong and Josh Hallas for support and assistance in the field. We also thank Liz Kools for her assistance at CAS, Gary McDonald for sharing his field data and for permission to use two of his images, and three anonymous reviewers for their helpful comments which improved the manuscript. Finally, we would like to acknowledge Robin and Marisa Agarwal, Spencer Dybdahl-Riffle, Cassidy Grattan, Matt Knoth, Donna Pomeroy, and Ken-ichi Ueda. Their dedicated, ongoing observations of nudibranchs in California have added significantly to our knowledge of the shifting distributions of nudibranchs in the region.
Angulo-Campillo, O. 2002. New distributional records for opisthobranch mollusks from the Golfo de California, Mexico. Festivals, 34:117-120.
Anonymous. 2015. Return of the blob! Big purple sea slugs wash ashore in east bay. CBS SF Bay Area. Available from: http://sanfrancisco.cbslocal.com/2015/06/12/big-puiple-sea-slugs-wash-ashore-in-east-bay/. Accessed 27 July 2015.
Bay Nature Staff. 2015. Ask the naturalist: why are sea hares multiplying in Lake Merritt? Bay Nature, 26 May 2015. Available from: https://baynature.org/articles/ask-the-naturalist-why-are-sea-hares-multiplying-in-lake-merritt/. Accessed 27 July 2015.
Beeman, R.D. and G.C. Williams. 1980. Opisthobranchia and Pulmonata: the sea slugs and allies. Pp. 308-354 in Intertidal invertebrates of California (R.H. Morris, D P. Abbott, and E.C. Haderlie, eds.) Stanford University Press: Stanford, ix+690 pp.
Behrens, D.W. 1980. Pacific coast nudibranchs. Sea Challengers, Monterey, California. 112 pp.
--. 1991. Pacific coast nudibranchs. Sea Challengers: Monterey, California. 2nd edition. 107 pp.
--. 2004. Pacific coast nudibranchs, supplement II: new species to the Pacific coast and new information on the oldies. Proc. Calif. Acad. Sci., 55:11-54.
--. and A. flermosillo. 2005. Eastern Pacific nudibranchs. Sea Challengers, Monterey. 137 pp.
--. 1998. Range extension: Navanax inermis (Cooper, 1863). Opisthobranch Newslett., 24:19.
Bergh, L.S.R. 1879. On the nudibranchiate gasteropod Mollusca of the North Pacific Ocean, with special reference to those of Alaska, pt. 1. Proc. Acad Nat. Sci. Phila., 31:71-132.
Bernard, F.R. 1970. A distributional checklist of the marine molluscs of British Columbia: based on faunistic surveys since 1950. Syesis, 3:75-94.
Bertsch, H., T. Gosliner, R. Wharton, and G. Williams. 1972. Natural history and occurrence of opisthobranch gastropods from the open coast of San Mateo County, California. Veliger, 14:302-314.
Blunden, J. and D.S. Arndt (eds.). 2015. State of the climate in 2014. Bull. Amer. Meteor. Soc., 96:S1-S238.
Bond, N.A., M.F. Cronin, H. Freeland, and N. Mantua. 2015. Causes and impacts of the 2014 warm anomaly in the NE Pacific. Geophys. Res. Lett., doi:10.1002/2015GL063306
Briggs, J.C. andB.W. Bowen. 2012. Arealignment of marine biogeographic provinces with particular reference to fish distributions. J. Biogeogr., 39:12-30.
California Academy of Sciences, and J. Goddard. 2013. Opisthobranch gastropods observed by James R. Lance on the outer coast of San Diego County, 1953-2001. knb.298.2. Available from: https://knb.ecoinformatics.org/#view/ knb.298.2. Accessed 9 September 2015.
Camacho-Garcia, Y., T.M. Gosliner, and A. Valdes. 2005. Field guide to the sea slugs of the tropical Eastern Pacific. California Academy of Sciences, San Francisco. 129 pp.
CCIEA (California Current integrated ecosystem assessment). 2015. State of the California Current report. A report of the CCIEA Team (NOAA Northwest, Southwest and Alaska Fisheries Science Centers) to the Pacific Fishery Management Council, March 8, 2015. Available from: http://www.pcouncil.org/ wp-content/uploads/E 1 b NMFS Rpt2 MAR2015BB.pdf. Accessed 12 January 2016.
Climate Prediction Center/NCEP/NWS. 2015. El Nino/Southem Oscillation (ENSO) diagnostic discussion, 10 Sept 2015 Available from: http://www.cpc.ncep.noaa.gov/products/analysis monitoring/enso disc sep2015/ ensodisc.pdf. Accessed 7 January 2016. Engle, J.M. and D.V. Richards. 2001. New and unusual marine invertebrates discovered at the California Channel Islands during the 1997-1998 El Nino. Bull. So. Calif. Acad. Sci., 100:186-198.
Gleckler, P.J., P.J. Durack, R.J. Stouffer, G.C. Johnson, and C.E. Forest. 2016. Industrial-era global ocean heat update doubles in recent decades. Nature Climate Change, doi:10.1038/nclimate2915.
Goddard, J.H.R. 1984. The opisthobranchs of Cape Arago, Oregon, with notes on their biology and a summary of benthic opisthobranchs known from Oregon. Veliger, 27:143-163.
--. 1987. Observations on the opisthobranch mollusks of Punta Gorda, California, with notes on the distribution and biology of Crimora coneja. Veliger, 29:267-273.
--. 1990. Additional opisthobranch mollusks from Oregon, with a review of deep water records and observations on the fauna of the south coast. Veliger, 33:230-237.
--. 1996. Lecithotrophic development in Doto amyra (Nudibranchia: Dendronotacea), with a review of developmental mode in the genus. Veliger, 39:43-54.
--. 1997. Range extensions of eight northeastern Pacific nudibranchs. Opisthobranch Newslett., 23:13.
--. 2004. Developmental mode in opisthobranch molluscs from the northeast Pacific Ocean: feeding in a sea of plenty. Can. J. Zool., 82:1954-1968.
--, T.M. Gosliner, and J.S. Pearse. 2011. Impacts associated with the recent range shift of the aeolid nudi branch Phidiana hiltoni (Mollusca: Opisthobranchia) in California. Mar. Biol., 158:1095-1109, doi: 10.1007/s00227-011-1633-7.
--, T.M. Gosliner, and J.S. Pearse. 2015. Nudibranchs, Duxbury Reef, 1969-75, 2007-10. Dataset available from: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/280626454_Nudibranchs_Duxbury_ Reef 1969-2010. Accessed 5 August 2015.
--and B. Green. 2013. Developmental mode in opisthobranch molluscs from the northeast Pacific Ocean: additional species from southern California and supplemental data. Bull. South. Calif. Acad. Sci., 112:49-62.
--and A. Hermosillo. 2008. Developmental mode in opisthobranch molluscs from the tropical Eastern Pacific Ocean. Veliger, 50:83-96.
--and E. Schickel. 2000. Range extensions of six opisthobranchs to Punta Rosarito, Baja California. Opisthobranch Newslett., 26:21-22.
--, M.C. Schaefer, C. Hoover, and A. Valdes. 2013. Regional extinction of a conspicuous dorid nudibranch (Mollusca: Gastropoda) in California. Mar. Biol. 160:1497-1510, doi:10.1007/s00227-013-2204-x.
Gosliner, T.M. 1981. A new species of tergipedid nudibranch from the coast of California. J. Moll. Stud., 47:200-205.
--. 1990. New records of two rare aeolid nudibranchs from the coast of California. Veliger, 33:321.
--. 1991. Four new species and a new genus of opisthobranch gastropods from the Pacific coast of North America. Veliger, 34:272-290.
--. 1994. New records of Flabellinidae (Opisthobranchia: Aeolidacea) from the tropical Americas, with descriptions of two new species. Proc. Calif. Acad. Sci., 48:171-183.
--and G.C. Williams. 1970. The opisthobranch mollusks of Marin County, California. Veliger, 13:175-180.
--and G.C. Williams. 2007. Key to major opisthobranch clades. Pp. 783-788 in The Light and Smith manual: intertidal invertebrates from central California to Oregon (J.T. Carlton, ed.). University of California Press, Berkeley, xvii+1001 pp.
Green, B. and T.M. Gosliner. 2016. Revealing hidden diversity in Flabellinidae, a family of nudibranchs. Poster presented at Society for Integrative and Comparative Biology Annual Meeting 2016, Portland, Oregon.
Heberton, B. 2015. PDO breaks record for highest positive for month of December. Weather 5280, 14 January 2015. Available from: http://www.weather5280.com/blog/2015/01/14/pdo-breaks-record-for-highestpositive-for-month-of- december/. Accessed 27 July 2015.
Hoover, C.A. 2015. Phylogenetics and population genetics of Felimare califomiensis. M.S. thesis, Cal Poly Pomona. 63 pp.
--, T. Lindsay, J.H.R. Goddard, and A. Valdes. 2015. Seeing double: pseudocryptic diversity in the Doriop silla albopunctata-Doriopsilla gemela species complex of the north-eastern Pacific. Zool. Scripta, doi: 10.1111/zsc. 12123
Jaeckle, W.B. 1983. Additions to the opisthobranch mollusk fauna of Marin County, California, with notes on the biology of certain species. Veliger, 26:93-95.
--. 1984. The Opisthobranch Mollusks of Humboldt County, California. Veliger, 26:207-213.
Kraybill-Voth, K. 2015. A pretty pink nudibranch moves north, and it's a 'canary in the tidepool' for climate change. Bay Nature, May 10, 2015. Available from: https://baynature.org/articles/a-pretty-pinknudibranch-moves- north-and-its-a-canary-in-the-tidepool-for-climate-change/. Accessed 27 July 2015.
Lamb, A. and B.P. Hanby. 2005. Marine life of the Pacific northwest. Harbour Publishing, Madeira Park, British Columbia. 398 pp.
Lance, J.R. 1966. New distributional records of some northeastern Pacific Opisthobranchiata (Mollusca: Gastropoda) with descriptions of two new species. Veliger, 9:69-81.
Leising, A.W. et al. 2014. State of the California Current 2013-14: El Nino looming. Calif. Coop. Fish. Invest. Rep., 55:51-87.
Lluch-Belda, D., D.B. Lluch-Cota, and S.E. Lluch-Cota. 2005. Changes in marine faunal distributions and ENSO events in the California Current. Fish. Oceanog., 14:458-467.
Mantua, N. and S.R. Hare. 2002. The Pacific decadal oscillation. J. Oceanog., 58:35-44, doi: 10.1023/ A:1015820616384.
McDonald, G.R. 1983. A review of the nudibranchs of the California coast. Malacologia, 24:114-276.
--and J.W. Nybakken. 1980. Guide to the nudibranchs of California. American Malacologists, Inc., Melbourne, Florida. 72 pp.
Millen, S.V. 1983. Range extensions of opisthobranchs in the northeastern Pacific. Veliger, 25:383-386.
--and A. Hermosillo. 2007. The Genus Flabellina Voight, 1834 (Mollusca: Opisthobranchia) from Bahia de Banderas (Pacific Coast of Mexico) with Ecological Observations, the Description of a New Species, and the Redescription of Flabellina cynara. Proc. Calif. Acad. Sci., 85:543-559.
Miller, A.J., D.R. Cayan, T.P. Barnett, N.E. Graham, and J.M. Oberhuber. 1994. The 1976-77 climate shift of the Pacific Ocean. Oceanography, 7:21-26, http://dx.doi.org/10.5670/oceanog.1994.ll.
Null, J. 2015. El Nino and La Nina years and intensities. Golden Gate Weather Services, 20 July 2015. Available from: http://ggweather.com/enso/oni.htm. Accessed 27 July 2015.
Pearcy, W.G. and A. Schoener. 1987. Changes in the marine biota coincident with the 1982-1983 El Nino in the northeastern subarctic Pacific Ocean. J. Geophys. Res., 92:14,417-14,428.
Roller, R.A. 1972. Three new species of eolid nudibranchs from the west coast of North America. Veliger, 14:416-423.
Schultz, S.T., J.H.R. Goddard, T.M. Gosliner, D.E. Mason, W.E. Pence, G.R. McDonald, V.B. Pearse, and J.S. Pearse. 2011. Climate-index response profiling indicates larval transport is driving population fluctuations in nudibranch gastropods from the northeast Pacific Ocean. Limnol. Oceanogr., 56:749-763, doi: 10.4319/ 1o.2011.56.2.0749.
--, J.H.R. Goddard, T.M. Gosliner, D.E. Mason, W.E. Pence, G.R. McDonald, V.B. Pearse, and J.S. Pearse. 2015. Nudibranchs: Asilomar, Scott Creek, Pillar Point, 1969-2010. Dataset available from: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/280626461_Nudibranchs_Asilomar_Scott_Creek_Pillar_ Pt_1969-2010. Accessed 5 August 2015.
Shipman. C. and T.M. Gosliner. 2015. Molecular and morphological systematics of Doto Oken, 1851 (Gastropoda: Heterobranchia), with descriptions of five new species and a new genus. Zootaxa, 3973:57-101.
Schmekel, L. and A. Portmann. 1982. Opisthobranchia des Mittlemeeres: Nudibranchia und Saccoglossa. Springer-Verlag, Berlin. 410 pp.
Sphon, G.G. and J.R. Lance. 1968. An annotated list of nudibranchs and their allies from Santa Barbara County, California. Proc. Calif. Acad. Sci., 36:73-84.
Steinberg, J.E. 1963. Notes on the opisthobranchs of the west coast of North America IV. A distributional list of opisthobranchs from Point Conception to Vancouver Island. Veliger, 6:68-73.
Stephens. T. 2015. Roses bloom in tide pools: warm water brings southern sea slug to central coast. UC Santa Cruz Newscenter: http://news.ucsc.edu/2015/01/sea-slugs.html. Accessed 12 July 2015.
Strub, P.T. and C. James. 2002. Altimeter-derived surface circulation in the large-scale NE Pacific Gyres. Part 1. seasonal variability. Prog. Oceanogr., 53:163-183.
Wolter, K. and M.S. Timlin. 2011. El Nino/Southem Oscillation behaviour since 1871 as diagnosed in an extended multivariate ENSO index (MEI.ext). Int. J. Climatology, 31: 1074-1087, doi: 10.1002/joc.2336.
(1) Peterson, B. 2014. Warmer California waters bring new opportunities for photographers. Retrieved 12 July 2015 from: califomiadiver.com/warmer-califomia-waters-bring-new-opportunities 123/
(2) Halstead, A. 2015. Photos from Aaron Halstead's post in SoCal Underwater Photographers. Retrieved 11 September 2015 from: https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=10153463203903054&set:=gm.463220240513533 &type= 1 &theater
(3) Standing, J., B. Browning, and J. W. Speth. 1975. The natural resources of Bodega Harbor. State of California, Department of Fish and Game. 224 pp.
(4) Sones, J. 2015. Inhaling bubbles. The Natural History of Bodega Head, 4 June 2015. Retrieved 27 July 2015 from: http://bodegahead.blogspot.com/2015/06/inhaling-bubbles.html
(6) Sones, J. 2015. Munching at Miwok. The Natural History of Bodega Head, 23 May 2015. Retrieved 27 July 2015 from: http://bodegahead.blogspot.com/2015/05/munching-at-miwok.html
(8) http ://oimb.uoregon. edu/sea-hares/
(9) https://www.facebook.com/cheryl.mitchell.750/videos/888884974530765/; [Aplysia vaccaria in video at 0:36 and 5:05]
(10) https://www.flickr.com/photos/39365853@N07/l 5406214295
(12) Sones, J. 2015. Finally! The Natural History of Bodega Head, 3 January 2015. Retrieved 28 August 2015 from: http://bodegahead.blogspot.com/2015/01 /finally.html
(16) Goddard, J. and C. Hoover. 2011. Crimora coneja Marcus, 1961. Retrieved 11 September 2015 from: http://slugsite.us/bow2007/nudwk758.htm
(21) Bauder, C., 2001 Thordisa bimaculata from Carmel, California. Retrieved 7 September 2015 from: https://www.seaslugforum.net/fmd/3881.
(27) Sones, J. 2015. Sea salt. The Natural History of Bodega Head, 10 February 2015. Retrieved 8 August 2015 from: http://bodegahead.blogspot.com/2015/02/sea-salt.html
(28) Behrens, D. 2003. Hancockia califomica. The Slug Site. Retrieved 5 January 2016 from: http://slugsite.us/ bow/nudwk373 .htm
(29) Sones, J. 2015. Be still my ... The Natural History of Bodega Head, 25 May 2015. Retrieved 14 September 2015 from: http://bodegahead.blogspot.com/2015/05/be-still-my.html
(31) https://www.flickr.com/photos/30314434@N06/19114409924; https://www.flickr.com/photos/dpoml2/ 18492397230
(32) Goddard, J. 2012. Janolus anulatus Camacho-Garcia and Gosliner, 2006. Retrieved 28 2015 from: http:// slugsite.us/bow2007/nudwk785.htm
(35) https://www.flickr.com/photos/30314434@N06/14938263 624
(36) Sones, J. 2015. Straight outta Santa Barbara. The Natural History of Bodega Head, 12 September 2015. Retrieved 12 September 2015 from: http://bodegahead.blogspot.com/2015/09/straight-outta-santa-barbara.html
(38) https.7/www.flickr.com/photos/39365853@N07/l 6697361803
(40) Sones, J. 2015. Fiery and flamboyant. The Natural History of Bodega Head, 19 May 2015. Retrieved 28 August 2015 from: http://bodegahead.blogspot.com/2015/05/fiery-and-flamboyant.html
(41) https://www.flickr.com/photos/riffle_nature_photos/16898166880; http://www.inaturalist.org/observations/ 1387158
(42) https://www.flickr.com/photos/riffle_nature_photos/l 9287584140
(45) Kopp, K. 2007. Emarcusia morroensis Roller, 1972. Retrieved 26 August 2015 from: http://slugsite.us/ bow2007/nudwk581.htm
Jeffrey H. R. Goddard,  * Nancy Treneman,  William E. Pence,  Douglas E. Mason,  Phillip M. Dobry,  Brenna Green,  and Craig Hoover 
 Marine Science Institute, University of California, Santa Barbara, CA 93106-6150
 Oregon Institute of Marine Biology, Charleston, OR 97420
 Alameda County Office of Education, Hayward, CA 94544
 Science Department, California High School, San Ramon, CA 94583
 California State University, East Bay, Hayward, CA 94542
 Department of Invertebrate Zoology and Geology, California Academy of Sciences, San Francisco, CA 94118-4503
 Biological Sciences Department, California State Polytechnic University, Pomona, CA 91768
* Corresponding author: firstname.lastname@example.org
Table 1. Location of study sites shown in Figure 1. All sites intertidal unless indicated otherwise. Site Geographic coordinates Charleston Boat Basin (docks) 43.3453, - 124.3220 Gregory Point 43.3400, - 124.3749 Squaw Island 43.3375, - 124.3774 Cape Arago North Cove 43.3094, - 124.3986 Middle Cove 43.3026, - 124.4007 South Cove 43.3026, - 124.3988 Five-mile Point 43.2199, - 124.4003 Cape Blanco, north side 42.8401, - 124.5634 Hunters Cove, Cape Sebastian 42.3205, - 124.4261 Whiskey Creek (= Boardman SP of Goddard, 42.2227, - 124.3830 1990) House Rock 42.1130, - 124.3550 Lone Ranch 42.0997, - 124.3493 Harris Beach 42.0641, - 124.3087 Chetco Point 42.0436, - 124.2899 Wilson Creek 41.5947, - 124.1051 Luffenholtz Beach 41.0407, - 124.1209 Punta Gorda 40.2747, - 124.3640 Glass Beach, Fort Bragg 39.4513, - 123.8139 Coleman Beach 38.3632, - 123.0708 Pillar Point 37.4938, - 122.4994 Pigeon Point, north side 37.1847, - 122.3969 Scott Creek 37.0455, - 122.2380 Santa Cruz Wharf (subtidal) 36.9587, - 122.0178 Santa Cruz Harbor (docks) 36.9642, - 122.0018 Point Cabrillo (subtidal) 36.6214, - 121.9016 Monterey Harbor (docks) 36.6043, - 121.8912 Asilomar 36.6282, - 121.9421 Sand Dollar Beach 35.9216, - 121.4716 Hazard Canyon, Montana de Oro SP 35.2899, - 120.8845 Tarantula Reef, Jalama 34.4954, - 120.4968 Naples 34.4320, - 119.9493 Carpinteria Reef (subtidal) 34.3930, - 119.5400 Tarpits Reef, Carpinteria SP 34.3869, - 119.5166 County Line Reef (subtidal) 34.0472, - 118.9710 Big Kelp Reef (subtidal) 34.0046, - 118.7925 Point Dume, south side 34.0031, - 118.8037 Big Fisherman's Cove (subtidal) 33.4445, - 118.4847 Table 2. Comparison of abundance of Okenia rosacea at six sites in central California in early 2015 with historical highs recorded at same sites. 2015 No. [inds.h.sup.-1] Site Date [obs..sup.-1] Duxbury Reef 01/01/15 [congruent to] 12 (a) Pillar Point 02/17/15 122.7 Scott Creek 01/20/15 65.0 Asilomar 01/22/15 13.5 Sand Dollar Beach 01/31/15 40.0 Hazard Canyon 01/19/15 [congruent to] 150 Previous [highs.sup.1] No. [inds.h.sup.-1] [obs..sup.-1] Date Sampling period 0.0 6/69-12/75 6/69-12/75 0.7 Nov 2010 12/07-12/10 13.0 Jul 1993 9/88-2/95 0.2 Jan 2008 1/08-12/10 11.4 Mar 1978 6/75-10/78 0.3 Mar 2009 12/07-10/10 5.8 Oct 1969 10/69-7/73 1.0 Nov 2007 11/07-10/11 48.0 Dec 1997 Dec 1997 1.3 Mar 2009 3/08-3/14 [congruent to] 4 Mar 1968 5/67-11/71 4.4 Jul 2012 11/99-5/14 (a) Data from: R. Agarwall (http://www.inaturalist.org/observations/ 1156561) (1) Data from: Goddard et al. (2015) (Duxbury Reef); Schultz et al. (2015) (Pillar Point, Scott Creek, Asilomar); R. Roller, unpublished California field accounts, CASIZ collection (Hazard Canyon 1967-71); Goddard, unpublished data (Sand Dollar Beach and Hazard Canyon 1997-2015).
|Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback|
|Author:||Goddard, Jeffrey H.R.; Treneman, Nancy; Pence, William E.; Mason, Douglas E.; Dobry, Phillip M.; Gre|
|Publication:||Bulletin (Southern California Academy of Sciences)|
|Date:||Apr 1, 2016|
|Previous Article:||The return of the king of the kelp forest: distribution, abundance, and biomass of giant sea bass (Stereolepis gigas) off Santa Catalina Island,...|
|Next Article:||Seed collection and germination strategies for common wetland and coastal sage scrub species in Southern California.|