National nursing strategies in seven countries of the Region of the Americas: issues and impact/Estrategias nacionales de enfermeria en siete paises de la Region de las Americas: problemas y repercusion.
The emphasis on UHC across the Region of the Americas has brought a unique opportunity to evaluate the health workforce's capacity for meeting the Region's health needs. Nurses present a cost-effective solution for meeting health care demands (2, 3). The issue, as the International Council of Nurses (ICN) reported, is that the baseline nurse-to-population ratios differ among countries as widely as 100-fold (4). WHO indicates that, "availability and consumption of HRH is an important indicator of the strength of health" (5). Sources state the lack of adequate staffing affect the safety and quality of care delivery (6, 7). National policies must implement investments in quality of education, increased supply and adequate distribution, and appropriate resources for professionals, in order to recognize the impact of the workforce to care for global communities.
The purpose of this review was to identify and examine the current national nursing strategies and policy impact of workforce development regarding human resources for health in seven selected countries in the Region of the Americas: Argentina, Canada, Costa Rica, Jamaica, Mexico, Peru, and the United States. Utilizing the available literature, this review presents research that ascertains the baseline, ongoing progress, and achievements in these countries.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
This review of the literature was performed in July-September 2013. The seven countries--Argentina, Canada, Costa Rica, Jamaica, Mexico, Peru, and the United States--were chosen because they spanned North, Central, and South America, including the Caribbean. A digital search was conducted to identify and select documents from four areas: PubMed Central (National Center for Biotechnology Information, U.S. National Library of Medicine, Bethesda Maryland, United States); international/ national nursing organization websites/ databases; Ministry of Health (MOH) online documents; and the websites of PAHO and WHO. Selected studies met the following inclusion criteria: (a) published during the 5 years from 2008-2013; (b) discussed nursing workforce development in the specified countries; and (c) presented content relevant to nursing supply, strategy, distribution, education, and/or development.
On PubMed, the keywords used for retrieving studies were: nursing, future, workforce, strategy, distribution, education, supply, human resources, development, health workers policy, shortage, forecasting, demand, national, strategic, strategy AND the country name. In order to expand the search, keywords were also translated into Spanish and Portuguese. Titles and abstracts were reviewed for relevance in three research topics: (a) identification of national nursing strategy from 2008-2013; (b) role of a chief nursing officer (CNO) affiliated with the MOH; and (c) availability of current literature. On PubMed, 50 documents were retrieved, but 15 studies were excluded per the criteria.
After a thorough analysis of the available literature, a content synthesis was performed. Definitions were coded and condensed into themes corresponding with the five critical areas mentioned in the Toronto Call to action document (8) as follows: (i) define long-term policies for development, (ii) distribute appropriate quantity and skill level of workers, (iii) assess migratory forces of workers, (iv) dedicate practice to quality and safety, and (v) implement academic-practice partnerships germane to nursing workforce development.
A combination of documents identified from the review of the literature and those from governmental entities painted a fuller picture of the nursing workforce among these countries (Annex 1). The eight resources from government entities included the national policy agenda of each country that had one available. The digital search yielded a total of 52 documents (35 from PubMed; Table 1) that met inclusion criteria.
While all the countries had elements of national strategies enacted, only five of the seven countries had their own national nursing plan (Annex 2). Six countries had a CNO within the MOH. Although Jamaica did not have a national nursing strategy, its MOH did have a CNO. As for Peru, it was the only country among the seven that did not have a national nursing strategy or a CNO in its MOH at that time.
The literature search revealed sources of available data regarding the supply of nurses in the workforce. Canada, Mexico, and the United States had identified mechanisms for surveying the number of nurses, their distribution, and for forecasting workforce growth needs/shortages. Jamaica was currently developing metrics for capturing this data. Nurse-to-population ratios varied by country, with Canada having the highest ratio at 10.4 : 1 000 (9) and Costa Rica, the lowest at 1.82 : 1 000 (10). Trends in workforce distribution reflect an urban-centric distribution within each country. Canada and Jamaica specifically highlighted attrition challenges among newly trained nursing workforce, mostly due to migration (11-12). Within large urban centers, countries within the Americas face challenges of high workload, inadequate supplies, and poor access. Literature from Argentina, Jamaica, and Peru specifically highlighted this disparity (12-14).
Themes regarding nursing education were strongly emphasized. Literature from Argentina, Costa Rica, and Peru propose further policies required for accreditation standards (15-17). Education initiatives have ranged from development of national programs within diverse socioeconomic populations to international partnerships among global partners (14-15). Argentina and the United States produced literature that discussed government financial incentives to encourage students to pursue nursing (18-20). Five countries--Argentina, Canada, Costa Rica, Mexico, and the United States--had nursing strategies that emphasize proper training as a necessary component of overall workforce development.
The following is a brief analysis by county, listed in geographic order from north to south.
Canada. The National Expert Commission convened by the Canadian Nurses Association (CAN) (Ottawa, Ontario, Canada) developed A Nursing Call to Action in 2012 (6). The strategic theme was described as, "using nurses more effectively is key to a transformed system that will better balance acute care with primary care that is patient-centered, holistic, and offers many more services in communities and patients' homes" (6). The Commission called for multisectoral engagement to address key areas to support this type of nursing workforce. The plan of action for 2012-2017 incorporates extensive community involvement and actionable strategies under the guidance of the CNO of Health Canada (Ottawa, Ontario, Canada).
With over 34 million people, Canada's nurse/midwife-to-population ratio is 10.4 : 1 000 (9). Canada has seen an increase of 4.8% in the nursing workforce from 2007-2010, totaling 268 500 registered nurses (RNs; 6). Meanwhile, overall work-force shortages have created challenges to the supply of nurses (21). Migration and inadequate distribution continues to pose a problem. Apprehension about the work environment exists, so students select employment solely in urban areas or migrate elsewhere (11). Methods to improve distribution to underserved areas have adopted financial incentives as a way to retain nurses, and this has demonstrated promising results (22). Policy coordination among immigration and labor forces of foreign-trained nurses also expects to help meet the demand (23).
Canada has uniquely invested in regional training centers as a way of providing education and research opportunities for graduate and doctoral candidates. Centers built to promote nursing research may encourage regional schools to form consortiums to support best practices for improving integration and funding mechanisms (24). These programs clearly emphasize the fundamental value of nursing education to promote its workforce (21).
Canada has set the bar high for other countries. Its endeavors to improve its nursing workforce focus on both urban and rural areas, particularly in geographic areas with fewer resources. Efforts to expand its nurse-to-population ratio include inviting a regulated foreign nursing workforce to reduce the country's health disparities.
United States of America. The United States has been seen as a leader in nursing workforce development. A multisectoral committee, funded by the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation (Princeton, New Jersey, United States), devised the Institute of Medicine's (IOM) Future of Nursing: Leading Change, Advancing Health report (25). The collection of the IOM reports has been a catalyst for the federal government's role in health care reform.
The United States has a population of over 313 million, and a nurse/midwife-to-population ratio of 9.8 : 1 000 (26). Though there is overall growth (84.8 %) of employed RNs, ineffective distribution of trained nurses raises concerns, particularly in the western and northeastern parts of the country (3). Several obstacles, such as the aging workforce, predict "entry into nursing must continue to grow over the next two decades at a rate of 20% per decade in order to meet that demand" (19). Specific areas of the country, such as the Midwest, have targeted partnerships with schools to distribute trained nurses to meet the needs of the rural population (3).
The Affordable Care Act (ACA) has provided additional funding for nursing education. In 2012 alone, the Government of the United States invested US$ 58.7 million to bolster the nursing workforce through grant awards to educational institutions (18, 19). The United States has conducted an annual survey on nursing workforce through the National Sample Survey of Registered Nurses by the Health Resources and Services Administration (HRSA). Per the 2013 report, The U.S. Nursing Workforce: Trends in Supply and Education, the nursing workforce grew to 3.1 million, reflecting a 14% increase in RNs and 6% increase in licensed practical nurses (27). The CNO within the Office of the Surgeon General of the United States Department of Health and Human Services collaborates with policymakers to impact nursing leadership.
The United States consists of the largest population to report a marked increase (13%, 2005-2010) in its nursing workforce supply (28). The multidisciplinary approach is encouraging; however, extensive research on this topic is difficult to track. Workforce data metrics should be improved for accurate analyses. With HRSA no longer publishing a comprehensive survey of the nursing workforce, there are gaps in monitoring future workforce trends (29).
Mexico. Based on the World Health Assembly's Resolution 42.27 (30), Mexico has effectively implemented a national policy focused on primary health care through management and information technology. In 1995, Mexico established the Management Information System Human Resources in Nursing (SIARHE) with the assistance of the CNO. It is designed to accurately track the distribution and allocation of its nursing workforce by gathering data on nursing staff at institutions that compose the national health system.
The current national strategic plan for nursing workforce development is titled Technical Guide for Human Resources Allocation in Nursing (31). This guide has been implemented at the subnational level to shape HRH. Utilization of SIARHE data guides strategic planning, distribution, and capacity utilization of nurses. While the government has invested in forecasting metrics, work productivity has yet to produce definite outcomes (13).
Dilemmas with the workforce arise from a lack of formal education restricting nursing professional roles (13). The transition from training to clinical practice presents a daunting task. In one study, of the 40 000 graduates from health profession schools (of which 30% were nursing students), 32% did not pass professional competency exams (32). These graduates entered the workforce despite reservations about their own skills.
The Mexican government has invested 6.2% of its gross domestic product on health (33). Mexico has a population of approximately 114.8 million, with a nurse-to-physician ratio of 1.9 : 1 and a nurse/midwife-to-population ratio of 3.7 : 1 000. Currently, Mexico does not meet the OECD nurse: physician ratio of 2.8 : 1 (33, 34).
Mexico has had a long history of efforts to develop and implement a national nursing strategic plan. The CNO manages the country's resources regarding its workforce. Accreditation for nursing education demands additional support. Despite noted improvements, further work to expand the scope of practice of nursing specialties is crucial.
Jamaica. There was no national nursing strategic plan available for Jamaica at the time of the study, though the Nursing and Midwifery Act of 2005 defined the role of nurses, midwives, and nursing assistive personnel (35). The CNO collaboration within the MOH and Nursing Council Jamaica (NCJ) regulated the scope of practice and education policies. The NCJ comprises leaders known for their advocacy role in promoting nursing leadership to develop a national nursing plan. A recent project successfully integrated a database system to address human resources within public and private sectors (36).
Jamaica's population of roughly 2.8 million has a nurse/midwife-to-population ratio of 1.09 : 1 000 (37). Health professionals face concerns about resources and infrastructure that hamper the ability to maintain adequate nursing staffing (36). Insufficient training regulations and limited health technology also present additional challenges.
Evidence-based practice, however, has been a priority through the newly minted Caribbean Journal of Nursing, launched in 2013. It is an open access, peer-reviewed, scientific journal that aims to promote original research and academic manuscripts ranging from education to practice in the Caribbean (38).
Jamaica recognizes that the challenges of workforce shortages demand a coordinated approach, strengthened by research and data capacity in health care management (36). The Caribbean Community (CARICOM) has written a white paper supporting the development of tertiary education and nursing in the Caribbean. The document, based on the International Labor Organization's recommendations made at the 15th COSHOD conference, highlights that tertiary education promotes the single market economy within the country (39).
PAHO/WHO recently collaborated with CARICOM to discuss a nursing education agenda (40).
Costa Rica. The Costa Rica national strategy is a policy document developed by the College of Nurses of Costa Rica. The document, National Nursing Policy 2011-2021, outlines several variables as chief drivers in workforce development. Topics include interdisciplinary collaboration, education, and resource management. The CNO oversees such proposals, serving as the Chief of the Strategic Planning Unit of Health Interventions (17).
Costa Rica's emphasis on strategic planning focuses on the needs of its indigenous population. WHO reports stated workforce data distribution supporting a total of 3 653 nursing personnel, and a nurse/midwife-to-population ratio of 9.3 : 10 000 (10, 41). The MOH report, Primer Foro Nacional de Salud de los Indigenas, details the steps to provide health services to the remote Chirripo Indigenous territories, a population where most individuals (68.8%) are consistently unable to gain access to primary health care. The MOH, Social Security Fund, and the National Commission for Indigenous Affairs specifically decided to train indigenous volunteers for delivery of health services in the Chirripo territories (42).
Costa Rica has identified a national strategic plan, a CNO, and an indigenous pipeline to promote workforce development. Collective strategies have created a unique vision to promote health care delivery, combining rural-university partnerships and educators in the field. Government policies and resource distribution must reinforce such efforts for maintenance. Innovative project proposals are required for implementation of policy changes.
Peru. There was no publicly-available national nursing strategy for Peru found at the time of this review. However, the MOH had joined with the Ministry of Labor (MOL) to propose ideas to improve the nursing workforce environment. Ministerial Resolution No. 849-2012 (43) proposes and implements a nursing remuneration scale that can be fiscally supported. This Resolution formed a working committee with the Federation of Nurses and the Director of Human Resource for Health Development of the Peru MOH (MINSA) (43).
Peru has a population of more than 29 million, with a nurse/midwife-to-population ratio of 1.27 :1 000 (44). The highly urbanized population presents challenges in distribution, as the nursing workforce is assigned according to city, jungle, and coastal settings (3). In areas where physicians are scarce, nurses provide the majority of necessary health care services.
The Peru MOL reported nursing staff to be underutilized by 12%. Nurses must be present in leadership to influence administrative decisions. Workforce development efforts tackle disparities in levels of higher education with innovative policies. Even large cities, such as Lima, report only 8.3% of female staff with tertiary degrees in nursing (45). The impact of shortages is evidenced by overwhelming pressures to maintain sufficient infrastructure and balance workload. Dissatisfaction in professional roles persists as well. Care providers recently went on strike regarding work conditions and remuneration in 2013 (46). Unfortunately, demands to regulate salaries, prepare faculty, and promote interdisciplinary models for care impede progress (47).
The Government of Peru has recognized the value of collaborating across international borders. Joint programs engage in distance education to provide a bilingual 6-week online course (14). The use of online education presents an immense opportunity.
Peru faces challenges to improve its nursing workforce development. The country has experienced an economic boom in recent years, with a gross domestic product exceeding 5% (6.2%) in 2012 (2). This growth underscores its developments to improve health resources. Commitments to innovative education partnerships, expansion of programs availability, and encouragement of advanced nursing degrees are promising; however, the development of education accreditation standards is still a work in progress.
Argentina. The Argentine national nursing strategic plan is titled National Plan for Nursing Development (20). The document prioritizes the critical nature of nursing and human resources to health outcomes. The strategic plan incorporates quantifiable goals and an evaluative mechanism to track deliverables along with fiscal allocation. Goals high-light education and funding measures, such as primary care nursing training centers offered at public universities, and monitoring funds for scholarships, incentives, and professional activities, such as pension plans (20).
Literature from Argentina showcases a multidisciplinary approach to nursing workforce development. The use of in-service training serves an essential component in regard to improvement, management, and supervision (48). Yet, responses from undergraduate nursing students convey requests to supplement their training (49). Undergraduate accreditation standards require additional resources to ensure the quality of its overall nursing education.
There was no available data on the supply of nurses in Argentina; rather topics have focused on the dearth of nursing faculty. Sustained efforts included a special partnership with Loma Linda University (Loma Linda, California, United States), which provides an online Masters program with courses offered in English and Spanish. The one condition of the program requires that the international candidates serve as faculty in their home countries for a given length of time after graduation. The program's second cohort was composed of students from 13 countries; 45 of the 49 enrollees graduated from Loma Linda University's School of Nursing with a Master's Degree (16).
Argentina has developed a strong nursing national strategic plan with a CNO in its MOH. The national strategic plan emphasizes collaborative education, but available literature tends to highlight professional silos, by population (neonatal) or location (urban). Broader workforce assessments are required, particularly in rural areas. Development of strong workforce data metrics will aid collection of this information.
This review presents the fundamental nursing strategies of seven countries in the Region of the Americas available publicly in 2008-2013. It revealed that five of seven--Argentina, Canada, Costa Rica, Mexico, and the United States--had retrievable national nursing strategies. These countries, plus Jamaica, had CNOs in place within their MOHs.
Overall, these national nursing strategies prioritized multisectoral collaboration, professional competencies, and standardized educational systems. Argentina, Canada, Costa Rica, and the United States underscored necessary policies to align with workforce improvements that promote nursing leadership. Canada, Costa Rica, and the United States propose expanding the scope of practice to improve health care delivery among populations.
Argentina, Mexico, and the United States identified inefficient data management trackers for workforce supply and distribution. Suggestions for workforce development proposed the following: integrated partnerships among nurses in local communities (Argentina, Canada, and Costa Rica); in-service training (Argentina, Canada, Costa Rica, and the United States); and innovative methods, often using technology, in education and training (all seven countries).
Lastly, multisectoral stakeholders and governmental leadership must ensure that nursing advocates are available and vocal at every stage of planning, implementation, and evaluation. The Third Global Forum on Human Resources for Health, hosted by WHO and PAHO, was held in Recife, Brazil, on 10-13 November 2013. The assembly of leading experts in human and health resources crystalized the need to engage in further discussion and to partner to improve the global nursing workforce. Testimonies shared among the global nurses presented diverse, yet similar, themes with regard to the future of the nursing workforce. Pursuing UHC as the goal, nurses and midwives advocated to be present at the decisionmaking table: "[We] have a lot to offer, but we need to have much better data about [supply and distribution] and [workforce] capacity to respond to the changing needs of society" (50).
Because the study included only seven select countries (out of 47) that span the PAHO Region of the Americas from north to south, generalizations should be made with this limitation in mind.
Methodology was initially just searches of available literature on Pub-Med and individual MOH websites, but was subsequently expanded to multiple search engines and national/international organization sites. Direct requests to the MOHs attempted to verify information retrieved on national strategies and chief nursing officers. Four of the seven countries lacked publicly-available information about nursing data on their MOH websites. It is possible that restricted-access limited the results to fewer sources than are actually available.
Lastly, keyword searches had to be translated into Spanish to retrieve documents from the MOH websites of Argentina, Costa Rica, Mexico, and Peru. Nursing terminology varies in diverse countries, addressing the categorical difference of "who is a nurse." Many academic publications are only available in English, denying the opportunity of numerous quality manuscripts in their native language to become recognized. Given this underlying global discrepancy, the authors had limited resources to perform an extensive translation of documents found in their native language. Note none of the authors are native Spanish speakers.
Results suggest many obstacles hinder the ultimate goal of effective care delivery in the Region of the Americas. From regulation standards to the political climate, each country struggles with its own burden to prepare an efficient nursing workforce to meet population needs. Workforce development depends on proper leadership, multisectoral collaboration, and appropriate resources to educate, train, and empower nurses to be in the forefront. Despite seemingly overwhelming challenges, nurses can be advocates for universal health coverage. Evidence stemming from these countries in the Region of the Americas demonstrates the potential, efforts, and focus on improve nursing workforce development in order to provide safe, equitable, and quality health care.
For countries struggling to develop their own national nursing strategies, the PAHO/WHO program on HRH can offer technical guidance. Innovative strategies are underway to develop partnerships among countries in the Region, to share best practices, and to foster a culture of collaboration in the area of nursing HRH. For the next generation to tackle impending challenges, multisectoral involvement and governmental will are needed to ensure that nurses are present and heard at every stage of planning, implementation, and evaluation to meet population demands with the goal of UHC around the globe.
Results suggest many obstacles hinder the ultimate goal of effective nursing care delivery in the Region of the Americas. From regulation standards to the political climate, each country struggles with its own burden to prepare an efficient nursing workforce to meet population needs. Workforce development depends on proper leadership, multisectoral collaboration, and appropriate resources to educate, train, and empower nurses to be in the forefront. Despite seemingly overwhelming challenges, nurses can be advocates for universal access to health and universal health coverage.
ANNEX 1. Results of a search of the literature regarding the nursing workforce in seven countries in the Region of the Americas, 2008-2013 Relevance National Nursing Plan (yes/no), link per Country Literature review (digital search) criteria Argentina Yes: http://www.msal.gov.ar/images/ 6/11 stories/cofesa/2008/acta-03-08/ anexo-12-03-08.pdf Farina D, Rodriguez S, Erpen N. (2012) Mutto EM, Cantoni MN, Rabhansl MM, Villar MJ. (2012) Jones PS, Van Cleve L, King HE, Bossert E, Herrmann MM. (2010) Mutto EM, Cantoni MN, Rabhansl MM, Villar MJ. (2012) Mutto EM, Errazquin A, Rabhansl MM, Villar MJ. (2010) Ramacciotti K, Valobra A. (2010) Torres-Vigil I, Aday LA, Reyes-Gibby C, De Lima L, Herrera AP, Mendoza T, Cleeland CS. (2008) Rojas Adel V, Heredia AM. (1999) Espino S, Heredia AM, Davini C. (1994) Bianco M, Sonis A. (1986) Canada Yes: http://www2.cna-aiic.ca/CNA/ 12/14 documents/pdf/publications/nec/ NEC Report e.pdf Clarke SP (2013) WHO (2013) Freeman M, Baumann A, Akhtar-Danesh N, Blythe J, Fisher A. (2012) Lobo VM, Fisher A, Baumann A, Akhtar-Danesh N. (2012) Burkoski V, Tepper J. (2010) Fu K, Allen S, Ferris E. (2010) Kaasalainen S, Martin-Misener R, Kilpatrick K, Harbman P, Bryant-Lukosius D, Donald F, Carter N, DiCenso A. (2010) Leatt, P (2010) Barnighausen T, Bloom DE. (2009) Montour A, Baumann A, Blythe J, Hunsberger M. (2009) Regan S, Thorne S, Mildon B. (2009) Montelpare W, Biden E, Lee P, Sheps S, Dubois CA, Brault I. (2008) O'Brien-Pallas L, Hayes L. (2008) Costa Rica Yes: http://www.enfermeria.cr/Documentos/ 2/3 Pol%C3%ADticas_de_EnfermeriaEdicion1.pdf Meza-Benavides Mde L, Furegato AR. (2011) ICN (2012) Jamaica No 6/9 Lindo JL, Holder-Nevins D, Dover Roberts D, Dawkins P, Bennett J. (2013) Richter MS, Mill J, Muller CE, Kahwa E, Etowa J, Dawkins P, Hepburn C. (2013) Thaffe, N. (2012) Dunkley A. (2011) Gupta N, Alfano M. (2011) Gupta N, Dal Poz MR. (2009) Figueroa JP, Duncan J, Byfield L, Harvey K, Gebre Y, Hylton-Kong T, Hamer F, Williams E, Carrington D, Brathwaite AR. (2008) PAHO (2006) Jamaica-Ministry of Health. (2005) Mexico Yes: http://www.salud.gob.mx/unidades/cie/ 10/13 cms_cpe/ Osuna Torres BH, Gonzales Rendon MC. (2013) Sanchex, J.J. (2013) WHO (2013) Riley PL, Zuber A, Vindigni SM, Gupta N, Verani AR, Sunderland NL, Friedman M, et al. (2012) Squires A, Juarez A. (2012) Nigenda G, Machado MH, Ruiz F, Carrasco V, Moline P, Girardi S. (2011) Squires A, Beltran-Sanchez H. (2011) Huth MM, Gregg TL, Lin L. (2010). Nigenda G, Magana-Valladares L, Cooper K, Ruiz-Larios JA. (2010) Vazquez Martinez FD. (2010) Squires A, Beltran-Sanchez H. (2009) Gupta N, Zurn P, Diallo K, Dal Poz MR. (2003) Peru No 5/9 Allen CB, Smart DA, Odom-Maryon T, Swain D. (2013) WHO (2013) Izquierdo, A.B. (2012) Peru-Ministry of Health (2012) Peru-Ministry of Labor & Social Promotion. (2012) Gallagher-Lepak S, Block D, Rojas YE, Birkholz L, Melgar Moran CC. (2011) Oblitas FY, Loncharich N, Salazar ME, David HM, Silva I, Velasquez D. (2010) Curioso WH, Kurth AE, Cabello R, Segura P, Berry DL. (2008) Hsieh EJ, Garcia PJ, Roca SL. (2008) Torres-Vigil I, Aday LA, Reyes-Gibby C, De Lima L, Herrera AP, Mendoza T, Cleeland CS. (2008) Unites Yes: http://www.iom.edu/Reports/2010/ 11/17 of States The-Future-of-Nursing-Leading-Change- America Advancing-Health.aspx Auerbach DI, Staiger DO, Muench U, & Buerhaus, PI. (2013) US DHHS-HRSA (2013) WHO (2013) Staiger DO, Auerbach, DI, Buerhaus, PI. (2012) US DHHS-HRSA. (2012) Hirschkorn CA, West TB, Hill KS, Cleary BL, Hewlett PO. (2010) US DHHS-HRSA (2010) Wornast T, Smith A. (2010) Kalb KA. (2009) Kishi A, Green A. (2008) Brewer CS, Zayas LE, Kahn LS, Sienkiewicz MJ. (2006) Cadmus E. (2006) Lee LA,Jones LR.(2004) Siegel H, Deschenes J. (2001) Brandt CM. (2000) Valentine NM. (1996) ANNEX 2. Themes and availability of national strategic plans regarding the nursing workforce in seven countries in the Region of the Americas, 2008-2013 Themes of National Strategic Plans Multi- Professional Build sectorial competencies education Funding Country collaboration & skillset system structures Argentina X (a) X X X Canada X X X X Costa Rica X X X Jamaicab -- -- -- -- Mexico X X X Perub -- -- -- -- United States X X X X of America Themes of National Strategic Plans Broaden Nursing scope of Social/public Protections- Country leadership practice partnerships laws & ethics Argentina X X Canada X X X Costa Rica X X X X Jamaicab -- -- -- -- Mexico Perub -- -- -- -- United States X X of America Themes of National Strategic Plans In-service Workforce Country training data Argentina X X Canada X Costa Rica X Jamaicab -- -- Mexico X Perub -- -- United States X X of America (a) "X" indicates existence of theme in national strategic plan. (b) No national strategic plan noted at this time.
Conflicts of interest. None.
Disclaimer. Authors hold sole responsibility for the views expressed in the manuscript, which may not necessarily reflect the opinion or policy of the RPSP/ PAJPH and/or PAHO.
(1.) Khaliq AA, Broyles RW, Mwachofi AK. Global nurse migration: Its impact on developing countries and prospects for the future. Nurs Leadership. 2009;22(1):24-50.
(2.) Pan American Health Organization. PAHO Strategic Plan 2014-2019; 2013. Available from: https://52dc.wordpress. com / category / paho-strategic-plan-2014-2019/ Accessed on 30 April 2015.
(3.) United States Department of Health and Human Services-Health Resources and Services Administration (HRSA). The registered nurse population: Initial findings from the 2008 national sample survey of registered nurse; 2010. Available from: http: //bhpr.hrsa.gov/healthworkforce/ rnsurveys/rnsurveyfinal.pdf Accessed on 30 April 2015.
(4.) International Council of Nurses-International Centre for Human Resources in Nursing. Health human resource planning; 2008. Available from: www.icn.ch/ images/stories/documents/publications/fact_sheets/9a_FS-Health_Human_ Resources_Planning.pdf Accessed on 30 April 2015.
(5.) World Health Organization. Health systems statistics; 2013. Available from: www.who.int/whr/2013/ report/en/ Accessed on 30 April 2015.
(6.) Canadian Nursing Association. A nursing call to action: the health of our nation, the future of our health system; 2012. Available from: www.cna-aiic.ca/site-core%20modules/web/~/media/cna/ files/ en/2013_annual_report_e.pdf Accessed on 30 April 2015.
(7.) Zhu XW, You LM, Zeng J, Liu K, Fang, JB, Hou SX, Lu MM, et al. Nurse staffing levels make a difference on patient outcomes: a multisite study in Chinese hospitals. J Nurs Scholarship. 2012;44(3): 266-73.
(8.) Pan American Health Organization. Linea basal para la medicion de las 20 Metas Regionales para Recursos Humanos 2007-2015; 2007. Available from: www.paho. org/hq/index.php?option=com_content&view = category&layout=blog&id=1942&Itemid=3501 Accessed on 30 April 2015.
(9.) World Health Organization. Canada: health profile; 2013. Available from: www. who.int/gho/countries/can.pdf?ua=1 Accessed on 30 April 2015.
(10.) Pan American Health Organization. Health Situation in the Americas: 20 years. Basic Indicators 2014. Available from: www.paho.org/hq/index.php?option= com_docman&task = doc_view& gid=27299&Itemid=721 Accessed on 18 May 2015.
(11.) Freeman M, Baumann A, Akhtar-Danesh N, Blythe J, Fisher A. Employment goals, expectations, and migration intentions of nursing graduates in a Canadian border city: a mixed methods study. Int J Nurs Stud. 2012;49(12):1531-43.
(12.) Dunkley A. We are overworked, say nurses. The Jamaica Observer; 2011. Available from: http://m.jamaicaobserver.com/mobile/news/We-are- overworked--saynurses_10134625 Accessed on 9 May 2015.
(13.) Izquierdo AB. Formacion de la Enfermera en Salud Ocupacional-Nuevos Escenarios. Proceedings of the IV Congreso Peruano de Salud Ocupactional; 2012. Available from: http://sopeso.org/admin/files/archivos/02112012124821_sopeso_22.pdf Accessed on 30 April 2015.
(14.) Nigenda G, Magana-Valladares L, Cooper K, Ruiz-Larios, JA. Recent developments in public health nursing in the Americas. Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2010;7(3): 729-50.
(15.) Gallagher-Lepak S, Block D, Rojas YEU, Birkholz L, Melgar Moran, CC. Using distance technology to learn across borders: a virtual travel course in nursing. J Nurs Educ. 2011;50(8):483-6.
(16.) Jones PS, Van Cleve L, King HE, Bossert E, Herrmann MM. A bold adventure in innovation: an international off-campus master's degree program. J Nurs Educ. 2010; 49(10):587-91.
(17.) Colegio de Enfermeras y Enfermeros de Costa Rica. Politica Nacional de Enfermeria. San Jose, Costa Rica: Atabal; 2011.
(18.) United States Department of Health and Human Services-Health Resources and Services Administration (HRSA). Grant awards to bolster heath care workforce; 2012. Available from: www.hrsa. gov/about/news/2012tables/120829 workforce.html Accessed on 30 April 2015.
(19.) Auerbach DI, Staiger DO, Muench U, Buerhaus PI. The nursing workforce in an era of health care reform. New Engl J Med. 2013;368(16):1470-2.
(20.) Ministerio de Salud Argentina. Consejo Federal de Salud 8 y 9 de Mayo, 2008. Recursos humanos: Residencias Enfermeria. Available from:www.msal.gov.ar/ images/stories/cofesa/2008/acta-02-08/ anexo-4-acta-02-08.pdf Accessed on 30 April 2015.
(21.) Regan S, Thorne S, Mildon B. Uncovering blind spots in education and practice leadership: towards a collaborative response to the nurse shortage. Nurs Leadership. 2009;22(2):30-40.
(22.) Barnighausen T, Bloom DE. Financial incentives for return of service in underserved areas: A systematic review. BMC Health Serv Res. 2009;9:86.
(23.) Leatt, P. Noted from the editor-in-chief. Hlthc Papers. 2010;10(2):4-6. Available from: www.longwoods.com/content/21794 Accessed on 30 April 2015.
(24.) Montelpare W, Biden E, Lee P, Sheps S, Dubois C, Brault I. The future of the regional training centres: Planning for sustainability. Hlthc Pol. 2008;3:131-40.
(25.) Institute of Medicine. The future of nursing: Leading change, advancing health-report recommendations; 2010. Available from: www.iom.edu/Reports/2010/The-Future-of-Nursing-Leading-Change- Advancing-Health.aspx Accessed on 30 April 2015.
(26.) World Health Organization. United States of America: health profile; 2013. Available from: www.who.int/gho/countries/usa. pdf?ua=1 Accessed on 30 April 2015.
(27.) United States Department of Health and Human Services--Health Resources and Services Administration (HRSA). The U.S. nursing workforce: Trends in supply and education; 2013. Available from: http:// bhpr.hrsa.gov/healthworkforce/supplydemand/nursing/nursingworkforce/ nursingworkforcefullreport.pdf Accessed on 30 April 2015.
(28.) Staiger DO, Auerbach, DI, Buerhaus, PI. Registered nurse labor supply and the recession--are we in a bubble? New Engl J Med. 2012;366(16):1463-5.
(29.) Auerbach DI, Staiger DO, Muench U, Buerhaus PI. The nursing workforce: a comparison of three national surveys. Nurs Econ. 2012;30(5):253-60.
(30.) World Health Organization. Resolution WHA 42.27. Strengthening nursing/midwifery in support of the strategy for health for all. Proceedings of the Forty-second World Health Assembly. Geneva: WHO; 1989.
(31.) Ministry of Health of Mexico. Guia tecnica para la dotacion de recursos humanos en enfermeria; 2003. Available from: http:// salud.edomexico.gob.mx/html/descarga. php?archivo=Medica/ENFERMERIA.%20 GUIA%20TECNICA%20PARA%20 LA % 20 DOTACION % 20 DE % 20 RECURSOS%20HUMANOS%20EN.PDF. Accessed on 25 March 2015.
(32.) Vazquez Martinez FD. Competencias profesionales de los pasantes de enfermeria, medicina y odontologia en servicio social en Mexico. Rev Panam Salud Publica. 2010;28(4):298-304.
(33.) Campbell J, Dussault G, Buchan J, Pozo-Matin F, Arias G, Leone C, et al. A universal truth: no healthcare without a workforce. Proceedings of the third global forum on Human Resources for Health. Recife, Brazil: Global Health Workforce Alliance, World Health Organization; 2013.
(34.) World Health Organization. Mexico: health profile; 2013. Available from: www. who.int/gho/countries/mex.pdf?ua=1 Accessed on 30 April 2015.
(35.) Ministry of Health of Jamaica. Amended Nurse and Midwives Act; 2005. Available from: www.nursingcouncil.org.jm/index. php?option=com_joomdoc&task=document.download&path=council-regula- tions/ncj-ammended-act-2005-pdf& Itemid=65 Accessed on 30 April 2015.
(36.) Pan American Health Organization. Jamaican Health Workforce Plan Enhanced; 2006. Available from: www.paho. org/can/index.php?option=com_content&view = article&id = 118%3Ajamaican-health-workforce-plan-enhanced& catid=369%3Acan.-regional-cooperation-activities&Itemid = 1&lang = es Accessed on 30 April 2015.
(37.) World Health Organization. Jamaica: health profile; 2013. Available from: www.who.int/gho/countries/jam.pdf Accessed on 30 April 2015.
(38.) Bennett J. Editorial. Carib J Nurs. 2013; 1(1):1-2. Available from: http://ojs.mona. uwi.edu/index.php/cjn/article/ view/3693/3220 Accessed on 09 May 2015.
(39.) Read M. Key note address-15th meeting of CARICOM's COSHOD: Labor issues in the global arena, lessons for the Caribbean;2006. Available from: www.ilo.org/wcmsp5/ groups/public/--americas/--ro-lima/--sro-port_ of_spain/documents/meetingdocument/wcms_305989.pdf Accessed on 25 March 2015.
(40.) Pan American Health Organization. PAHO/WHO supports CARICOM-led efforts to conduct a comprehensive evaluation of national nurses training program. Available from: www.observatoriorh.org/?q=node/670 Accessed on 25 March 2015
(41.) International Council of Nurses--International Centre for Human Resources in Nursing. ICHRN: Nursing in Costa Rica; 2012. Available from: www.icn.ch images/stories/documents/pillars/sew/ ICHRN/Facts_Sheets/Nursing%20in%20 Costa%20Rica.pdf Accessed on 30 April 2015.
(42.) Primer Foro Nacional de Salud de los Indigenas; 2005. Available from: www. iadb.org/Research/legislacionindigena/ leyn/docs/C-R-Decreto-Eje33121- 06-SaludIndigena.doc Accessed on 25 March 2015.
(43.) El Peruano Normas Legales: 849-2012 MINSA; 2012. Available from: http://dataonline.gacetajuridica.com.pe/gaceta/ admin/elperuano/2012-26-10/26-102012. PDF Accessed on 30 April 2015.
(44.) World Health Organization. Peru: health profile; 2013. Available from: www.who. int/gho/countries/per.pdf?ua = 1 Accessed on 30 April 2015.
(45.) Diagnostico de la Formation Profesional en el Peru; 2012. Available from: www. mintra.gob.pe/contenidos/institucional/ consejo_nacional_del_trabajo/logros/ Diagnostico_final_en_proceso.pdf Accessed on 30 April 2015.
(46.) Depsky A. Peru: national doctors and nurses' strike intensifies. The Argentina Independent; 2013. Available from: www. argentinaindependent.com/currentaffairs/peru-national-doctors-and-nurses-strike-intensifies/ Accessed on 26 July 2013.
(47.) Torres-Vigil I, Aday LA, Reyes-Gibby C, De Lima L, Herrera AP, Mendoza T, et al. Health care providers' assessment of the quality of advanced-cancer care in Latin American medical institutions: a comparison of predictors in five countries: Argentina, Brazil, Cuba, Mexico, and Peru. J Pain Palliat Care Pharmacother. 2008;22(1):7-20.
(48.) Farina D, Rodriguez S, Erpen N, Miembros del Subprograma de Referencia y Contrarreferencia. La capacitacion en terreno como estrategia para la mejora de la calidad de la atencion de la salud. Arch Argent Pediatr. 2012;110(1):9-18.
(49.) Mutto EM, Errazquin A, Rabhansl MM, Villar MJ. Nursing education: the experience, attitudes, and impact of caring for dying patients by undergraduate Argentinian nursing students. J Palliat Med. 2010;13(12):1445-50.
(50.) International Council of Nurses-International Centre for Human Resources in Nursing. Nurses and midwives are committed to advancing UHC in the Global Forum on Human Resources for Health. Geneva, Switzerland: ICN; 2013.
Manuscript received on 31 October 2014. Revised version accepted for publication on 6 April 2015.
Rebecca O. Shasanmi,  Esther M. Kim,  and Silvia Helena De Bortoli Cassiani 
Suggested citation Shasanmi RO, Kim EM, De Bortoli Cassiani SH. National nursing strategies in seven countries of the Region of the Americas: issues and impact. Rev Panam Salud Publica. 2015;38(1):64-72.
 Human Resources for Health, World Health Organization (WHO), Abuja, Federal Capital Territory, Nigeria.
 Commission on Graduates of Foreign Nursing Schools International, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, United States of America.
 Nursing and Allied Health Personnel, Pan American Health Organization (PAHO), Washington, DC, United States of America. Send correspondence to Silvia Cassiani, email: firstname.lastname@example.org
TABLE 1. Number of documents retrieved from PubMed that met inclusion criteria for a study of nursing in seven countries, 2008-2013 Argentina Canada Costa Rica Jamaica No. % No. % No. % No. % Documents 5 14.7 9 26.4 0 0.0% 5 14.7 Mexico Peru United States No. % No. % No. % Documents 8 23.4 3 8.8 5 14.7