Printer Friendly

Multidrug resistant tuberculosis in HIV-negative patients, Buenos Aires, Argentina. (Research).

Initial multidrug-resistant (MDR) tuberculosis (TB) in HIV-negative patients treated at a Buenos Aires referral hospital from 1991 to 2000 was examined by using molecular clustering of available isolates. Of 291 HIV-negative MDRTB patients, 79 were initially MDR. We observed an ascending trend of initial MDRTB during this decade (p=0.0033). The M strain, which was responsible for an institutional AIDS-associated outbreak that peaked in 1995 to 1997, caused 24 of the 49 initial MDRTB cases available for restriction fragment length polymorphism. Of those, 21 were diagnosed in 1997 or later. Hospital exposure increased the risk of acquiring M strain-associated MDRTB by approximately two and a half times. The emergence of initial MDRTB among HIV-negative patients after 1997 was apparently a sequel of the AIDS-related outbreak. Because the prevalence of M strain-associated disease in the study population did not level out by the end of the decade, further expansion of this disease is possible.


Multidrug-resistant (MDR) tuberculosis (TB) in patients with a history of previous TB treatment is known as acquired MDRTB and usually reflects shortcomings in current treatment administration such as irregular drug supplies, inadequate treatment regimens, or poor patient compliance (1). On the other hand, MDR among new cases of TB (initial MDRTB) originates from infectious sources that are disseminating MDR bacilli in the community; this resistance is an indicator of treatment deficiencies accumulated over a prolonged period (2).

During the last decade, MDRTB has surged as an important global problem. The AIDS pandemic fostered this emergence by spreading the disease among immunodeficient institutionalized patients (3-5). According to the global antituberculosis drug resistance surveillance program of the World Heath Organization and International Union Against Tuberculosis and Lung Disease, Argentina was identified as an MDRTB "hot spot" in the mid-1990s (6). At that time, initial MDRTB in that country was fueled by contemporary AIDS-related hospital outbreaks, the most important of which originated at Muniz Hospital (7-12).

Located in Buenos Aires City, Muniz Hospital is the main Argentinean referral center for infectious diseases and provides for approximately 800 TB patients yearly. An appreciable proportion of the MDRTB cases diagnosed in the country (mainly from the Buenos Aires metropolitan area) are referred to this center for further bacteriologic assessment and clinical management. Soon after the emergence of HIV infection in 1982, TB grew into the most frequent AIDS-associated disease in the country. During the 1990s, the hospital underwent an extensive AIDS-related MDRTB outbreak while continuing to provide care for HIV-negative drug-resistant TB patients.

Throughout the 1990s, a total of 736 AIDS-related MDRTB cases were hospitalized in Muniz Hospital (1 [1991], 4 [1992], 10 [1993], 58 [1994], 149 [1995], 132 [1996], 159 [1997], 108 [1998], 79 [1999], and 36 [2000]; unpub. data). An IS6110 restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) study conducted in the first half of the decade of a sample of AIDS-related TB cases resistant to five or more drugs identified the so-called M strain as the main outbreak strain (9). Our RFLP database documents the predominance of the M strain among AIDS-related MDRTB cases investigated in this hospital during the second half of the decade (10). The infection disseminated to other healthcare centers in the metropolitan area, and secondary microepidemics were reported to be associated to the M strain (11,12).

Beginning in 1995, Muniz Hospital implemented a number of measures to stop the spread of MDRTB. Isolation rooms with portable HEPA filters became available in HIV buildings, and a separate ward was dedicated to HIV-associated MDRTB. Following the recommendations of a visiting team from the Division for TB Elimination at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, additional measures were gradually implemented beginning in 1996, including smear examination at admission, speeding of bacteriologic diagnosis through radiometric bacteriologic assay, ready availability of second-line drugs, and personal respiratory protection with N-95 masks (13).

Our study was directed at gaining insight into the impact of the MDRTB epidemic that occurred in Buenos Aires in the putatively immunocompetent population. We examined the trend of initial MDRTB in non-HIV patients treated at the Muniz Hospital during the last decade in the light of molecular clustering of available isolates.



Medical records of all HIV-negative patients with MDRTB (both inpatients and outpatients) diagnosed at Muniz Hospital from January 1991 to December 2000 were reviewed. All patients were routinely tested for HIV infection by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay after giving informed consent. The following patient data were collected: year of MDRTB diagnosis, age, gender, nationality, place of residence, site of TB disease, chest x-ray score of lesion extension (minimal, moderate, advanced), history of previous TB treatment, and underlying illnesses. MDRTB cases were defined as those caused by Mycobacterium tuberculosis resistant to at least isoniazid and rifampicin. MDRTB patients with a history of previous TB chemotherapy were defined as acquired MDRTB cases. Initial MDRTB was defined as that diagnosed in a patient without previous TB treatment. Initial MDRTB cases were classified according to possible exposure settings, including hospital (patients with a history of previous hospitalization or hospital attendance and healthcare workers), household, and undisclosed source of infection.

Bacteriologic Methods

Susceptibility to isoniazid, rifampicin, ethambutol, and streptomycin was determined according to World Health Organization standards. Susceptibility to kanamycin, p-aminosalycilic acid, and cycloserine was performed according to the Canetti, Rist, and Grosset method, whereas the pyrazinamidase test was used to infer pyrazinamide susceptibility (14).

DNA Fingerprinting

Available isolates of initial MDRTB cases were typed by IS6110 DNA fingerprinting by using the standardized protocol for M. tuberculosis (15). Briefly, DNA was extracted from bacilli suspensions and digested with the restriction enzyme PvuII. DNA fragments were electrophoresed in 0.8% agarose and vacuum-blotted into a positively charged nylon membrane. The IS6110 probe was a 245-bp DNA fragment amplified by polymerase chain reaction and labeled by the enhanced chemiluminescence gene detection system (Amersham International plc, Amersham, U.K.). M. tuberculosis Mtb 14323 was used as a reference strain. Hybridization patterns were compared visually. Isolates from one patient were considered to be part of a cluster if the IS6110 fingerprint matched that of a different patient within the study period.


We used the Mantel-Haenszel test to compare categoric data from groups of patients. For the comparison of age means, the Student t test was applied. The relative weight of initial MDRTB throughout the study period was analyzed by the Mantel test for linear trend. P values <0.05 were considered significant. The software used was Epi Info version 6.0 (16).


From January 1991 to December 2000, a total of 291 HIV-negative patients treated at Muniz Hospital were affected by MDRTB. Of these, 212 (72.9%) were acquired MDRTB cases, and 79 (27.1%) were unambiguously identified as initially MDR. The primary site of disease was pulmonary in all patients of both groups with a single exception. An accidental subcutaneous inoculation of a bacteriologist caused the only primary extrapulmonary case, which was obviously classified in the initial MDRTB group.

Demographic, clinical, and bacteriologic characteristics of both groups are compared in Table 1. Compared with acquired-MDRTB patients, patients with initial MDRTB showed significant differences in age, gender, and chest x-ray involvement. The presence of an underlying illness was not identified as a predisposing factor for initial MDRTB. Initial MDRTB patients were significantly younger and their lung lesions less advanced. Female patients predominated in this group. Initial MDRTB increased from 15.0% of total MDR cases in 1991 to 37.8% in 2000 (test for trend, p=0.00033, odds ratio [OR] = 3.45) (Figure 1).


Isolates from 49 of the 79 patients with initial MDRTB were available for DNA typing. Thirty-six (73.0%) of these 49 fit in six molecular clusters with RFLP patterns of six or more bands. The M strain was responsible for the largest cluster involving 24 (49.0%) of the 49 investigated cases. All patients in the M cluster lived and were treated in Buenos Aires City area. A flow tree is shown in Figure 2.


The second largest cluster occurred in four members of a Peruvian family who had immigrated to Argentina in 1999. The remaining four clusters consisted of two cases each. Samples from cases in two of these clusters had matching fingerprints with previously documented outbreak strains; the patients' histories were consistent with such hospital-acquired disease (7). The remaining four case-patients within the last two clusters were household contacts of two clearly identified index MDRTB cases.

Figure 3 shows the biennial number of initial MDRTB cases attributable to the M strain, other strains, and those unavailable for RFLP. Among those available for fingerprinting, the proportion of initial MDRTB associated with the M strain increased significantly in the period 1997-2000 when compared with previous years (21/36 vs. 3/13; p=0.03; OR=0.21).


The putative exposure setting and RFLP findings of the 79 initial MDRTB cases are described in Table 2. Hospital-related disease attributable to the M strain was detected in 15 cases from seven different health institutions in the metropolitan area. The M strain-associated disease was significantly more frequent among hospital-exposed cases when compared with patients who acquired the disease elsewhere (15/20 vs. 9/29; p=0.002; relative risk [RR] = 2.42; 95% confidence interval [CI] 1.33 to 4.40). The proportion of isolates lost for RFLP typing did not differ significantly between the groups compared above to analyze prevalence of the M strain in different periods (p=0.52) and exposure settings (p=0.11).


Initial MDRTB is contracted from a source case, whereas acquired MDRTB is the result of a prolonged history of inadequate treatment. Therefore, patients with initial MDRTB were substantially younger and their lung lesions less advanced. Women predominated in the initial MDRTB group, which might reflect the conventional female role as caregiver in the local population.

The ascending trend of the initial MDRTB in HIV-negative patients may be explained as a consequence of the AIDS-associated outbreak that occurred in the hospital during the 1990s. The M strain was preeminent in this phenomenon. Initial MDRTB cases attributable to this strain appeared at the peak of the AIDS-related epidemic, persisted beyond its decline, and did not reach a neat plateau at the end of the study period. These dynamics reflect the normal latency of infection and hint that a further expansion of the strain is still possible.

Hospital exposure increased the risk of acquiring M strain-associated MDRTB by approximately two and a half times. Thus, the hospital seems still to be the most likely setting for acquiring the M strain of MDRTB. However, 4 of 10 case-patients with an unidentified source of exposure were also affected by this strain. These patients were thoroughly interrogated again, and a previous institutional or household contact was virtually discarded. The failure to trace the index cases for these patients indicates the presence in the community of unidentified infectious cases harboring this highly resistant strain.

However, the marked increase of initial MDRTB cannot be ascribed entirely to the M strain. Other indigenous outbreak strains and strains recently introduced to the country contributed to this emergence, adding complexity to the MDRTB problem in the metropolitan area. Approximately one in every five case-patients with both initial and acquired MDRTB had recently migrated from a neighboring country where TB prevalence is higher than in Argentina, which suggests the influence of regional migration on local MDRTB rates.

The outcome of this investigation cannot be generalized to scenarios different from that of a referral center for infectious diseases. Other possible limitations of our study should be considered. Bias caused by laboratory cross-contamination is improbable because two or more isolates were obtained from every patient and susceptibility patterns were consistent in all cases. Data loss was appreciable: over one third of the isolates were lost for fingerprinting because of inadequate culture maintenance. Therefore, TB transmission might have been underestimated in our population, as shown by computer simulation studies (17,18). Eventually, misclassification of cases might have occurred. Some observations induced the idea of misclassification. A sudden shift from fully susceptible TB (RFLP not available) to M strain-associated MDR disease was documented in six of the cases classified in the acquired MDRTB group. We suggest that these patients were actually reinfected with the M strain while still being treated with standard chemotherapy at the hospital. As demonstrated by van Rie et al., exogenous reinfection is not uncommon among HIV-negative patients in settings with high prevalence of TB and the distinction between initial and acquired MDRTB in such situations becomes ambiguous (19).

The emergence of initial MDRTB among HIV-negative persons assisted in Muniz Hospital in the second half of the 1990s can be considered a sequel to the MDRTB epidemic that occurred among AIDS patients in Buenos Aires. The M strain has already exceeded nosocomial bounds and might be expanding in the community. The strain appears to be more prosperous than other contemporary MDR strains and is emerging as a persistent strain.
Table 1. Demographic, clinical, and bacteriologic features of
acquired versus initial multidrug-resistant tuberculosis (MDRTB) cases
among 291 HIV-negative patients, Muniz Hospital, Argentina, 1991-2000

 Acquired MDRTB Initial MDRTB p value
 (n=212) (n=79)

Age (y [+ or -] SD) 39.8 [+ or -] 35.3 [+ or -]
 13.2 15.0 0.013
Gender (male/female) 125/87 32/47 0.005
Origin (Argentinean/ 180/32 64/15 0.533
 foreign-born) (a)
Chest x-ray (minimal/ 2/52/158 10/38/31 <0.0001
Underlying illness (Y/N) 46/166 15/64 0.731
 Diabetes (N) 26 7 --
 Alcoholism (N) 9 1 --
 Silicosis (N) 2 1 --
 Steroid treatment (N) 2 3 --
 Substance abuse (N) 1 0 --
 Malignancy (N) 1 2 --
 Other (N) 5 1 --
Drug resistance, median
 number of drugs (range) 4 (2-8) 4 (2-6) --

(a) Neighboring countries (Peru, Bolivia, Paraguay).

Table 2. Distribution of 79 HIV-negative patients with initial
multidrug-resistant tuberculosis (MTDRTB) according to the
putative exposure setting and DNA fingerprint findings, Muniz
Hospital, Argentina, 1991-2000

Setting n (% of total) RFLP done (a) M strain

 Healthcare workers (b) 20 (25.3) 15 10
 Patients 7 (8.9) 5 5
Household 35 (44.3) 19 5
Unknown 17 (21.5) 10 4
Total 79 (100) 49 24

(a) RFLP, restriction fragment length polymorphism.

(b) Physicians, 6; nurses, 5; bacteriologists, 2; and auxiliary
staff, 7.


We thank Dick van Soolingen for the reference strain.

We acknowledge the support of the EEC INCO-DEV Program (ICA4-CT-2001-10087).


(1.) Chaulet P, Boulahbal F, Grosset J. Surveillance of drug resistance for tuberculosis control: why and how? Tuber Lung Dis 1995;76:487-92.

(2.) World Health Organization. Global Tuberculosis Programme and International Union against Tuberculosis and Lung Disease. Guidelines for surveillance of drug resistance in tuberculosis. WHO/TB/96.216 Geneva: The Organization; 1997.

(3.) Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Nosocomial transmission of multidrug-resistant tuberculosis to health care workers and HIV infected patients in an urban hospital: Florida. MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep 1990;39:718-22.

(4.) Pearson ML, Jereb J, Frieden T, Crawford JT, Davis B, Dooley SW, et al. Nosocomial transmission of multidrug-resistant Mycobacterium tuberculosis. A risk for patients and health care workers. Ann Intern Med 1992;117:191-6.

(5.) Valway SE, Greifinger RB, Papania M, Kilburn JO, Woodley C, DiFerdinando GT, et al. Multidrug-resistant tuberculosis in the New York State Prison system 1990-1991. J Infect Dis 1994;170:151-6.

(6.) Pablos-Mendez A, Raviglione MC, Laszlo A, Binkin N, Rieder HL, Bustreo F, et al. Global surveillance for antituberculosis-drug resistance, 1994-1997. N Engl J Med 1998;338:1641-9.

(7.) Aita J, Barrera L, Reniero A, Lopez B, Biglione J, Weisburd G, et al. Hospital outbreak of multiple resistant tuberculosis in Rosario, Argentina. Tuber Lung Dis 1996;77(Suppl 2):64.

(8.) Gonzalez Montaner LJ, Palmero DJ, Alberti F, Ambroggi M, Gonzalez Montaner PJ, Abate EH. Nosocomial outbreak of multidrug-resistant tuberculosis among AIDS patients in Buenos Aires, Argentina. XI International Conference on AIDS 1996 Jul 7-12; Vancouver, Canada. Abstract We.B.304.

(9.) Ritacco V, Di Lonardo M, Reniero A, Ambroggi M, Barrera L, Dambrosi A, et al. Nosocomial spread of HIV-related multidrug-resistant tuberculosis in Buenos Aires. J Infect Dis 1997;176:637-42.

(10.) Ritacco V, Di Lonardo M, Lopez B, Reniero A, Latini O, Barrera L. Persistance of an expansile multidrug resistant Mycobacterium tuberculosis strain in Buenos Aires hospitals. Proceedings of the American Society for Microbiology 102nd general meeting, Salt Lake City, May 2002.

(11.) Alito A, Morcillo N, Scipioni S, Dolmann A, Romano MI, Cataldi A, et al. The IS6110 restriction fragment length polymorphism in particular Mycobacterium tuberculosis multidrug-resistant strains may evolve too fast for reliable use in outbreak investigation. J Clin Microbiol 1999;37:788-91.

(12.) Poggio G, Togneri A, Reniero A, Insua A, Guerra A, Dinerstein E, et al. AIDS-related multidrug-resistant tuberculosis "M" strain spreads within two hospitals in Buenos Aires suburbs. Int J Tuberc Lung Dis 1997;1(Suppl 1):523.

(13.) Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Guidelines for preventing the transmission of Mycobcterium tuberculosis in health care facilities, 1994. MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep 1995;43 (RR-13):8-33.

(14.) World Health Organization. Global Tuberculosis Programme. Laboratory Services in Tuberculosis Control WHO/TB/98.258 Geneva: The Organization; 1998.

(15.) van Embden JDA, Cave MD, Crawford JT, Dale JW, Eisenach KD, Gicquel B, et al. Strain identification of Mycobacterium tuberculosis by DNA fingerprinting: recommendations for a standardized methodology. J Clin Microbiol 1993;31:406-9.

(16.) Epi Info: a word processing, database, and statistics program [computer program]. Version 6. Atlanta: Centers for Disease Control and Prevention; 1994.

(17.) Glynn JR, Vynnycky E, Fine PEM. Influence of sampling on estimates of clustering and recent transmission of Mycobacterium tuberculosis derived from DNA fingerprinting techniques. Am J Epidemiol 1999;149:366-71.

(18.) Murray M. Sampling bias in the molecular epidemiology of tuberculosis. Emerg Infect Dis 2002;8:363-9.

(19.) van Rie A, Warren R, Richardson M, Gie R, Enarson D, Beyers N, et al. Classification of drug-resistant tuberculosis in an epidemic area. Lancet 2000;356:22-5.

Domingo Palmero, * Viviana Ritacco, ([dagger]) Martha Ambroggi, ([double dagger]) Marcela Natiello, ([double dagger]) Lucia Barrera, ([dagger]) Lilian Capone, ([double dagger]) Alicia Dambrosi, ([double dagger]) Martha Di Lonardo, ([double dagger]) Nelida Isola, ([double dagger]) Susana Poggi, ([double dagger]) Marisa Vescovo, ([double dagger]) and Eduardo Abbate ([double dagger])

* Hospital F. J. Muniz, Buenos Aires, Argentina; ([dagger]) National Institute of Infectious Diseases "Carlos G. Malbran," Buenos Aires, Argentina; and ([double dagger]) University of Buenos Aires, Buenos Aires, Argentina

V. Ritacco is member of the Research Career of the National Council of Scientific Research (CONICET), Argentina, and holds grant PIP No. 02373 CONICET and PICT No. 05-09978 from SECYT, Argentina.

Dr. Palmero is a pulmonologist at the F. J. Muniz Hospital, Buenos Aires, and head professor of pulmonology at the Universidad del Salvador. His main research interest is multidrug-resistant tuberculosis.

Address for correspondence: Domingo J. Palmero, N. Videla 559 (1424) Buenos Aires, Argentina; fax: 54-11-4432-6569; email:
COPYRIGHT 2003 U.S. National Center for Infectious Diseases
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2003, Gale Group. All rights reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Author:Abbate, Eduardo
Publication:Emerging Infectious Diseases
Date:Aug 1, 2003
Previous Article:Nonmalarial infant deaths and DDT use for malaria control. (Research).
Next Article:Invasive group a streptococcal disease: risk factors for adults. (Research).

Related Articles
Rationale and methods for the National Tuberculosis Genotyping and Surveillance Network. (Tubercolosis Genotyping Network).
Molecular epidemiology of multidrug-resistant tuberculosis, New York City, 1995-1997. (Tuberculosis Genotyping Network).
Rifampin- and multidrug-resistant tuberculosis in Russian civilians and prison inmates: dominance of the Beijing strain family. (Research).
Mycobacterium tuberculosis Beijing genotype, the Netherlands.
Multidrug-resistant Mycobacterium tuberculosis in HIV-infected persons, Peru.
Spoligotyping and Mycobacterium tuberculosis.
Long-term follow-up for multidrug-resistant tuberculosis.
Nosocomial tuberculosis in India.
Extrapulmonary tuberculosis among Somalis in Minnesota (1).
Tuberculosis drug resistance and HIV infection, the Netherlands.

Terms of use | Privacy policy | Copyright © 2018 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters