Moose experimentally infected with giant liver fluke (Fascioloides magna).
ALCES VOL. 47:9-15 (2011)
Key words: Alces alces, experimental infection, Fascioloides magna, liver flukes, moose, Odocoileus.
The giant liver fluke (Fascioloides magna) develops normally in white-tailed deer (Odocoileus virginianus), wapiti (Cervus elaphus canadensis), and caribou (Rangifer tarandus caribou), but in moose (Alces alces) migrates extensively causing considerable damage to liver tissue (Pybus 2001). Moose are an abnormal dead-end host with few worms reaching maturity, and eggs are likely prevented from leaving infected livers by the resulting fibrosis and thick-walled, closed capsules unconnected to bile ducts (Lankester 1974). Infection in moose depends on continuous cohabitation with normal cervid hosts and appropriate conditions for transmission, including persistent aquatic habitat for the required, intermediate snail hosts of the genus Lymnaea.
The extensive and noticeable tissue damage seen in some moose has led to speculation that infection may cause death, particularly in nutritionally stressed animals (Pybus 2001, Lankester and Samuel 2007). Based on counts of flukes and liver cysts in dead moose, Murray et al. (2006) concluded that the giant liver fluke was a significant mortality factor responsible for a marked decline in the moose population in northwestern Minnesota. However, no clinical evidence exists that links the presence of flukes in livers with death of moose. To better understand any such impact on moose, we administered metacercariae of the giant liver fluke to 3 captive, hand-reared moose, observed their behaviour and weight gain following infection, and performed subsequent necropsies.
Moose were acquired in 1977 and 1978 as orphaned calves (0.5-2 months old) in the vicinity of Thunder Bay, Ontario where F. magna is unreported in deer. Two calves were infected shortly after capture; a third, obtained the previous year, was infected when 15 months old (Table 1). They were housed in a compound without access to any infected water body from the date of capture. Initially they were bottle-fed a formulated milk diet (385 mL of Carnation milk with an equal volume of whole milk and 2 egg yolks) supplemented with pelleted beet pulp, alfalfa hay, and commercial dairy ration (Nutrena Sweetflow-16; Lankester et al. 1993). Animals were weaned at 16-18 weeks of age and maintained thereafter on dairy ration and alfalfa hay supplemented sporadically with fresh browse.
Metacercariae were obtained from Baldwin Enterprises (Monmouth, Oregon, USA) and their viability on arrival was confirmed in a subsample by microscopic examination of flame cell movement. Both free and still-encapsulated metacercariae were counted and immediately administered in water by stomach tube to moose lightly anaesthetized with xylazine hydrochloride (Rompun, Haver-Lockhart Laboratories, Mississauga, Ontario, Canada).
Moose were observed daily and any clinical signs noted. They were eventually euthanized using T-61 (Hoechst Canada Inc., Montreal, Quebec, Canada), bled by cutting neck vessels, and hung to obtain whole weights; visceral organs were removed and inspected grossly. The liver was weighed, its volume measured by water displacement, and sliced at thickness of 1-1.5 cm. Migrating and encapsulated flukes were dislodged from liver tissue by gently agitating the slices in a pail of warm physiological saline, and were recovered by pouring the saline through a 2 mm mesh screen. Flukes were pressed gently between 2 glass microscope slides and examined for eggs in the uterus as an indication of maturity. They were measured to the nearest mm after formalin fixation. Protocols were approved by the Animal Care Committee of Lakehead University.
Both moose infected as calves showed depressed appetite for 7-10 days after infection, but thereafter resumed normal feeding and behaviour until they were euthanized 12.5-14 months later. A female yearling moose raised from a calf, but not infected, died at 14 months of age of accidental trauma and was considered a control; its liver weighed 3.3 kg and was 3,050 cc in volume.
Calf#1 was given 50 metacercariae when 2 months old and euthanized 12.5 months later; its liver weighed 4.9 kg with volume of 4600 cc and had a rounded marginal edge with a single 3 cm long immature fluke (Table 1). Seven capsules were present (4 were 3.5-4.5 cm and 3 were 1.0-1.5 cm in diameter), most in the vicinity of the hilus, with one protruding from the surface just beneath the serosa. Capsules had thickened, fibrous walls with incorporated black pigment. They were filled with brown-black, pasty material and the larger had a thin, stoney inner lining. Small, scattered patches (1-3 mm diameter) of black pigment were visible on the surface of the liver and in the omentum adjacent to the liver.
Calf#2 was given 35 and 75 metacercariae at 2 and 3 months old, and was euthanized 14 months after the first infection. Its liver appeared somewhat enlarged (6.1 kg and 5,650 cc) with rounded marginal edge. Eleven immature flukes (1.5-2.0 cm long) were recovered; 2 were in narrow (3-4 mm diameter) blood-filled tracts while the precise location of the others could not be determined. About 30-40% of the liver volume was comprised of thick-walled capsules and diffuse fibrosis. Ten capsules (3-4 cm in diameter) had thick, fibrous walls and 15 smaller capsules (1-1.5 cm) had a grey-black inner lining (not stoney) and were filled with grey-black (clay-coloured) pasty material. Meandering tracts with fibrous walls (1-2 mm thick) were filled with dark red blood. The antero-dorsal surface of the liver was covered with whitish fibrinous tags and adhered firmly to the diaphragm. Diffuse accumulations of black pigment were visible on the surface of the liver, in omental fat, and in mesentery and lymph nodes around the lower colon.
Moose #3 was given 225 metacercariae when 15 months old and euthanized 16 months later. It exhibited vigorous rutting behaviour and had developed average-sized antlers in the fall of its 3rd year. There was a whitish fibrinous coating over 25% of the diaphragmatic surface of the liver, but no areas of adhesions were seen nor was black pigment visible in the mesenteries. The liver (3.8 kg, 3600 cc) had a sharp marginal edge. Three whitish capsules (1.7-6.0 cm diameter) were visible as raised areas on the surface of the liver. They had fibrous walls 4-6 mm thick and were filled with pasty to hardened grey-black matter; no flukes were recovered.
Interpreting the results of parasitic infections reproduced experimentally is often difficult. In nature, the impact of infection on individuals commonly depends on dosage, or numbers of infective forms acquired, and over what time period (Samuel et al. 1992, Lankester 2002). These natural acquisition rates usually are unknown and experimenters may be tempted to exaggerate doses to ensure infection. Seldom is it practical to administer repeated small doses or "trickle infections" over a period of time, as would more closely approximate what probably occurs in nature (Prestwood and Nettles 1977). The outcome of infection may also depend on host age at first exposure and whether the initial exposure induces a degree of protection against further infection (i.e., concomitant immunity; Lankester 2002). The varying effects of dose on the outcome of F. magna infection are evident from experimental infection of mule deer, a host not commonly infected in nature (Butterworth and Pybus 1993). Mule deer fawns given 250-500 metacercariae all died within 163 days of infection, whereas 3 of 4 fawns given 50 metacercariae survived; flukes matured and eggs passed in their feces (Foreyt 1992, 1996).
In our experiment, F. magna was relatively efficient in reaching the liver of 2-month-old moose given doses presumed moderate. Considerable liver damage resulted but no worms reached sexual maturity; the longest was 3 cm but mature flukes can be 8 cm long (Pybus 2001). The parasite had lower success in reaching the liver of the moose infected at 15 months old and all flukes were dead 16 months after infection. Having to traverse the large functioning rumen of an adult moose may, in part, explain the lower recovery. Whether the diet provided to captive, experimental animals may have altered their response to fluke infections cannot be judged.
Cattle, like moose, are dead-end hosts of F. magna, yet commonly become infected in enzootic areas. Infections are generally sub-clinical and go undetected until slaughter (Wobeser et al. 1985, Pybus 2001). For example, 12 domestic calves given 1000 metacercariae each and monitored for 26 weeks were described as healthy but had conspicuous liver damage. Relatively few flukes were recovered (1-32) and weight gain of infected animals was similar to that of controls (Conboy and Stromberg 1991).
Weights of our infected calves were similar to those of calves raised at the facility in subsequent years (Lankester et al. 1993) and to those reviewed by Broadfoot et al. (1996) including weights of their 11-month-old farm-reared animals (206 kg for females and 228 kg for males); mean liver weight for both sexes was 4243 g (range = 3800-5500). Whole weights of wild, 2.5-year-old moose in Manitoba were higher (288 and 332 kg; Crichton 1979) but calves reared in captivity often weigh less than wild animals due to several factors including captive diets and digestive disorders (Addison et al. 1983, Welch et al. 1985).
In nature, calf and yearling moose are less likely to be found with giant liver fluke infection than older animals (Karns 1972, Pybus 1990, 2001). Is this because they are particularly susceptible to infection and die unnoticed, or are they somewhat refractory, either physiologically or because their feeding habits reduce the likelihood of infection? Our results suggest that calves are not unusually vulnerable to hepatic disease, but their feeding habits probably reduce exposure. Moose encounter fluke metacercariae while feeding on aquatic plants, and Lepitzki (1998) found that trematode metacercariae (presumably F. magna) appeared on aquatic vegetation in greatest numbers during June and in mid-August-early September in the marshes of Vermilion Lakes, Alberta. Adult moose consume submerged and floating aquatic plants in greatest amount from mid-June to mid-July (Cobus 1972, Fraser et al. 1982), but calves rarely forage in a similar manner at such a young age. The rumen fluke Paramphistomum spp. (although non-pathogenic in moose) is acquired similarly by moose ingesting metacercariae encysted on aquatic vegetation; moose <1.4 years old had fewer rumen flukes than older animals and calves <2.5 months had none in a study in Sibley Provincial Park, Ontario (Snider and Lankester 1986).
Poor recruitment is a feature of moose declines occurring in the past 15-20 years in areas west of Lake Superior (i.e., northwestern Ontario, southeastern Manitoba, and northwestern Minnesota; Lankester 2009). However, our results indicate that moderate doses of F. magna do not kill young moose and suggest that poor recruitment of young is unlikely explained by undetected calf mortality due to F. magna. An inference (Murray et al. 2006) that liver flukes elicit high moose calf mortality has been attributed to Karns (1972), but we could not confirm this interpretation. On the contrary, Karns (1972) reported that the net productivity of moose was greater in northwestern Minnesota where the prevalence of F. magna was 87%, than in the northeast where only 17% of moose were infected; this difference in productivity would seem related to factors other than liver fluke. Recently, Maskey (2008, 2011) concluded that a low and apparently declining prevalence of F. magna (<20%) was probably not the cause of a moose decline in North Dakota occurring simultaneously with a decline in adjacent northwestern Minnesota (Murray et al. 2006).
It is noted that the number of flukes (intensity of infection) in some moose in northwestern Minnesota was high (Murray et al. 2006). Moose classified as likely to have died of fluke infection were defined as those with "signs of severe pathological damage to tissue and organs and no other overt cause of death" or those where "liver flukes were abundant." Not surprisingly, this group had more flukes (48.1 [+ or -] 9.6, n = 23) than animals considered dying of non-fluke related causes (14.2 [+ or -] 2.2, n = 69). However, the high prevalence of infection (89%, n = 100) was similar to that (87%, n = 128) found >30 years earlier when the population was robust and moose hunting was reinstated (albeit intensity data were not reported, Karns 1972). Lankester (1972) examined a much smaller sample of moose from neighbouring southeastern Manitoba and found 64% of livers with signs of fluke infection; 1-5 immature flukes were recovered from 3 of 7 animals with liver damage. Butterworth and Pybus (1993) found flukes (16.7 [+ or -] 7.3, range = 5-30) in 52% of moose (n = 22) in Banff National Park in Alberta, and 2.7 [+ or -] 0.3 flukes (range = 2-3) in 63% of moose (n = 9) in Kootenay National Park in British Columbia. Pybus (1990) found 4% of adult moose (n = 191) with 3 [+ or -] 1 (range = 2-5) flukes in the foothills region of Alberta, and Shury (1995) found flukes (x = 8) in 40% of moose >6 years old (n = 10) from Banff National Park.
There are several other reasons why F. magna is unlikely a major factor in moose declines. This parasite has a disjunct distribution across North America and has never occurred in some areas where moose declines are known (Lankester 2009). As well, the prevalence of giant liver fluke infection increases with age of the host and reaches a plateau in older animals (Lankester and Luttich 1988, Pybus 2001). But the mean intensity of infection is similar within infected age classes, suggesting the development of an immunological resistance as infection accumulates (Pybus 2001). Results reported here, and the observations of Pybus (1990) suggest that moose react strongly to worms in the liver and liver hypertrophy accompanying infection may eventually mitigate some of the hepatic tissue damage. Lastly, liver fluke infections have an aggregated distribution in definitive host populations. Most individuals have relatively low-moderate numbers of worms while a few heavily infected animals carry the majority of the parasite population (Addison et al. 1988, Lankester and Luttich 1988, Mulvey and Aho 1993). Thus, even if the heaviest fluke infections can be shown to cause the death of moose, the greatest impact of the disease would be expected in only a relatively small portion of the population.
ADDISON, E. M., J. HOEW, D. G. JOACHIM, and D. J. MCLACHLIN. 1988. Fascioloides magna (Trematoda) and Taenia hydatigena (Cestoda) from white-tailed deer. Canadian Journal of Zoology 66: 1359-1364.
--, R. F. MCLAUGHLIN, and D. J. H. FRASER. 1983. Raising moose calves in Ontario. Alces 18: 246-270.
BROADFOOT, J. D., D. G. JOACHIM, E. M. ADDISON, and K. S. MACDONALD. 1996. Weights and measurements of selected body parts, organs and long bones of 11-month-old moose. Alces 32: 173-184.
BUTTERWORTH, E., and M. J. PYBUS. 1993. Impact of the giant liver fluke (Fascioloides magna) in elk and other ungulates in Banff and Kootenay National Parks. Parks Canada, Banff National Park, Banff, Alberta, Canada.
COBUS, M. 1972. Moose as an aesthetic resource and their summer feeding behaviour. Proceeding of the North American Moose Conference and Workshop. 8: 244-275.
CONBOY, G. A., and B. E. STROMBERG. 1991. Hematology and clinical pathology of experimental Fascioloides magna infection in cattle and guinea pigs. Veterinary Parasitology 40: 241-255.
CRICHTON, V. F. J. 1979. An experimental moose hunt on Hecla Island, Manitoba. Proceedings of the North American Moose Conference and Workshop 15: 245-279.
FOREYT, W. J. 1992. Experimental Fascioloides magna infections of mule deer (Ococoileus hemionus hemionus). Journal of Wildlife Diseases 28: 183-187.
--. 1996. Mule deer (Odocoileus hemionus) and elk (Cervus elaphus) as experimental definitive hosts for Fascioloides magna. Journal of Wildlife Diseases 32: 603-606.
FRASER, D., B. K. THOMPSON, and D. ARTHUR. 1982. Aquatic feeding by moose: seasonal variation in relation to plant chemical composition and use of mineral licks. Canadian Journal of Zoology 60: 3121-3126.
KARNS, P. D. 1972. Minnesota's 1971 moose hunt: a preliminary report on the biological collections. Proceeding of the North American Moose Conference and Workshop. 8: 115-123.
LANKESTER, M. W. 1974. Parelaphostrongylus tenuis (Nematoda) and Fascioloides magna (Trematoda) in moose of southeastern Manitoba. Canadian Journal of Zoology 52: 235-239.
--. 2002. Low-dose meningeal worm (Parelaphostrongylus tenuis) infections in moose (Alces alees). Journal of Wildlife Diseases 38: 789-795.
--. 2009. Understanding the impact of meningeal worm, Parelaphostrongylus tenuis, on moose populations. Alces 46: 53-70.
--., and S. LUTTICH. 1988. Fasciolodes magna (Trematoda) in woodland caribou (Rangifer tarandus) of the George River herd, Labrador. Canadian Journal of Zoology 66: 475-479.
--., and W. M. SAMUEL. 2007. Pests, parasites and diseases. Pages 479-517 in A. W. Franzmann and C. C. Schwartz, editors. Ecology and Management of the North American Moose (2nd edition). University Press of Colorado, Boulder, Colorado, USA.
--., T. WHEELER-SMITH, and S. DUDZINSKI. 1993. Care, growth and cost of captive moose calves. Alces 29: 249-262.
LEPITZKI, D. 1998. Giant liver flukes and snails in Banff National Park. Final report prepared for The Friends of Banff National Park, Heritage Resource Conservation (Banff National Park) and Alberta Sport Recreation Parks and Wildlife Foundation. Banff National Park Warden Office Library, Banff, Alberta, Canada.
MASKEY, J. J. 2008. Movements, resource selection, and risk analyses for parasitic disease in an expanding moose population in the northern Great Plains. Ph.D. Thesis, University of North Dakota, Grand Forks, North Dakota, USA.
--. 2011. Giant liver fluke in North Dakota moose. Alces 47: 1-7.
MULVEY, M., and J. M. AHO. 1993. Parasitism and mate competition: liver flukes in white-tailed deer. Oikos 66: 187-192.
MURRAY, D. L., W. B. BALLARD, H.A. WHITLAW, M. S. LENARZ, T. W. CUSTER, T. BARNETT, and T. K. FULLER. 2006. Pathogens, nutritional deficiency, and climate influences on a declining moose population. Wildlife Monographs 166: 1-30.
PRESTWOOD, A. K., and V. F. NETTLES. 1977. Repeated low level infection of white-tailed deer with Parelaphostrongylus andersoni. The Journal of Parasitology 63: 974-978.
PYBUS, M. J. 1990. Survey of hepatic and pulmonary helminths of wild cervids in Alberta, Canada. Journal of Wildlife Diseases 26: 453-459.
--. 2001. Liver flukes. Pages 121-149 in W. M. Samuel, M. J. Pybus, and A. A. Kocan, editors. Parasitic Diseases of Wild Mammals (2nd edition). Iowa State University Press, Ames, Iowa, USA.
SAMUEL, W.M., M. J. PYBUS, D. J. WELCH, and C. J. WILKES. 1992. Elk as a potential host for meningeal worm: implications for translocation. The Journal of Wildlife Management 56: 629-639.
SHURY, T. K. 1995. An update of giant liver fluke (Fascioloides magna) infection in ungulates of Banff National Park 1989-1994. Parks Canada, Western and Northern Service Centre, Calgary, Alberta, Canada.
SNIDER, J. B., and M. W. LANKESTER. 1986. Rumen flukes (Paramphostomum spp.) in moose of northwestern Ontario. Alces 22: 323-344.
WELCH, D.A., M. L. DREW, and W. M. SAMUEL. 1985. Techniques for rearing moose calves with resulting weight gains and survival. Alces 21: 475-491.
WOBESER, G., A. A. GAJADHAR, AND H. M. HUNT. 1985. Fascioloides magna: occurrence in Saskatchewan and distribution in Canada. Canadian Veterinary Journal 26: 241-244.
Murray W. Lankester (1) and William J. Foreyt (2)
(1) 101-2001 Blue Jay Place, Courtenay, BC, Canada, V9N 4A8; (2) Department of Veterinary Microbiology and Pathology, Washington State University, 413 Bustad Hall, Pullman, WA 99164-7040, USA
Table 1. Description of captive moose infected experimentally with metacercariae of the giant liver fluke (Fascioloides magna). All animals were captured as calves (0.5-2.0 months old; assumed born 15 May) in an area without F. magna and held in captivity without access to infected water until euthanasia. Calf Sex Age # of Infection (months) at metacercariae duration infection (months) 1 [male] 2 50 12.5 2 [female] 2.3 35.75 14 3 [male] 15 225 16 Calf Sex Body weight Liver weight Liver (kg) (kg) volume (cc) 1 [male] 291 4.9 4600 2 [female] 218 6.1 5650 3 [male] 334 3.8 3600 Calf Sex # # flukes capsules 1 [male] 1 7 2 [female] 11 25 3 [male] 0 3
|Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback|
|Author:||Lankester, Murray W.; Foreyt, William J.|
|Date:||Jan 1, 2011|
|Previous Article:||Giant liver fluke in North Dakota moose.|
|Next Article:||The impact of human recreational activities: moose as a case study.|