Printer Friendly

Method validation for cerebral spinal fluid human chorionic gonadotropin measurement with the Advia Centaur[R].

To the Editor:

Intracranial germ cell tumors account for 0.4%-3.4% of all brain tumors (1). These tumors can be divided into 2 groups, germinomas and nongerminomatous germ cell tumors. Genninomas, which are fairly treatable, arise from primordial germ cells that fail to migrate correctly in embryogenesis. Nongerminomatous germ cell tumors (including choriocarcinomas), which are more refractory to treatment, are differentiated tumors.

Measurement of human chorionic gonadotropin (hCG) [1] is an important adjunct method in the diagnosis of germ cell tumors. At high concentrations hCG can be detected in serum, but measurement of hCG concentrations in cerebral spinal fluid (CSF) is a more sensitive and reliable indicator of tumor presence (1). Pure germinomas are associated with very low concentrations of hCG in both serum and CSF. A subset of nongerminomatous germ cell tumors contains syncytiotrophoblastic giant cells. These tumors are associated with moderately increased concentrations of hCG (<1000 IU/L) in the serum, CSF, or both, and the survival rate in patients suffering these tumors is poorer than that for patients with pure germinomas (2). In contrast, choriocarcinomas, another subset of nongenninomatous genn cell tumors, are associated with very high concentrations of hCG (> 1000 IU/L) in both serum and CSF. Quantification of the hCG in CSF can be important in guiding treatment and monitoring response to treatment of these tumors (2).

Currently, all quantitative hCG assays in the us have been validated for use with serum only. Because matrix effects can influence test results when alternative sample types are used, the alternative sample type should be validated for the assay before clinical use. We have validated the Advia Centaur total hCG method, developed for use with serum and internally validated for use with urine (3), for use with CSF.

We performed the study with leftover samples collected for physician-ordered testing. Institutional review board approval was obtained for this study. We created a CSF pool by combining CSF samples from 50 patients. Chart review was performed to confirm that samples were from patients with no history of blood-brain barrier breakdown or central nervous system infection. Samples were accepted if they were clear and colorless. The limit of detection was evaluated by measuring hCG in the CSF pool 15 times. The mean hCG was 3.6 IU/L (range, 3-4.1 IU/L; SD, 0.4 IU/L). The minimum detection limit, calculated as the mean + 3 SD, was determined to be 4.7 IU/L with a CV of 9.7%.

Recovery studies were performed by diluting hCG-positive serum from a patient with a nongerminomatous germ cell tumor into the pooled patient CSF. Because different isoforms of hCG are produced during pregnancy, cancer, and postmenopausal states, a patient sample was used in place of commercially available hCG to ensure that the assay was validated using the correct hCG isoform. Recovery studies were performed in duplicate on 2 different days. Results from 1 experiment are shown in Table 1. Recovery of added hCG was >100% at all concentrations in both experiments. Measurements of hCG in CSF were linear up to 400IU/L [observed = (1.4 X expected) + 2.8; [r.sup.2] = 0.989].

The imprecision for twice-daily measurements over a 10-day period was evaluated by adding hCG-containing serum at 2 different concentrations to pooled patient CSF (total volume of serum added was <10%). Interassay imprecision (CV) was 4.6% at 153 IU/L and 2.6% at 510 IU/L.

It is important to note that most, perhaps all, hCG assays in the US are FDA approved for use as a marker for pregnancy, not as a marker for tumors. Nevertheless hCG assays are used to detect tumors. Various tumor types produce differing ratios of intact hCG to free [alpha]-hCG and free [beta]-hCG (4). In addition, different immunoassays preferentially recognize various forms of hCG (5). The Centaur assay does appear to preferentially recognize free [beta]-hCG (5). This characteristic makes this particular immunoassay less than optimal for use in measuring hCG as a tumor marker and is the reason that the sample used for recovery

assays was from a patient with a nongerminomatous germ cell tumor. Preferential free [beta]-hCG recognition does not, however, account for the difference in expected vs observed concentrations that we observed, because the recovery was calculated on the basis of a nongerminomatous germcell tumor patient sample diluted into normal serum vs normal CSF. Therefore the difference in recovery is attributable to a matrix effect.

In conclusion, the Advia Centaur total hCG assay can be used to detect hCG in CSF with very good precision. Recovery of hCG added to CSF was >I 00% at all concentrations tested, indicating a moderate matrix effect. This matrix effect should be taken into account when interpreting results. Any detectable hCG in CSF is abnormal. Very high CSF concentrations (>1000IU/L) suggest the presence of nongerminomatous germ cell tumors, which are usually refractory to treatment.

Grant/Funding Support: None declared.

Financial Disclosures: None declared.


(1.) Packer RJ, Cohen BH, Coney K. Intracranial germ cell tumors. Oncologist 2000;5:312-20.

(2.) Inamura T, Nishio S, Ikezaki K, Fukui M. Human chorionic gonadotrophin in CSF, not serum, predicts outcome in germinoma. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 1999;66:654-7.

(3.) Halldorsdottir AM, Carayannopoulos MO, Scrivner M, Gronowski AM. Method evaluation for total beta-human chorionic gonadotropin using urine and the ADVIA Centaur. Clin Chem 2003; 49:1421-2.

(4.) Stenman UH, Alfthan H, Hotakainen K. Human chorionic gonadotropin in cancer. Clin Biochem 2004;73:549-61.

(5.) Cole LA, Sutton, JM, Higgins TN, Cembrowski GS. Between-method variation in human chorionic gonadotropin test results. Clin Chem 2004; 50:874-82.

* These data have been published in part in an abstract at the 2008 AACC meeting, Washington, DC.

[1] Nonstandard abbreviations: hCG, human chorionic gonadotropin; CSF, cerebral spinal fluid.

Angela M. Ferguson

Bradley Ford

Ann M. Gronowski **

Department of Pathology and Immunology Division of Laboratory Medicine Washington University School of Medicine Saint Louis, MO

** Address correspondence to this author at:

Department of Pathology and Immunology

Division of Laboratory Medicine Washington University School of Medicine 660 South Euclid Avenue Box 8118 Saint Louis, MO 63110

Fax 314-362-1461


DOI: 10.1373/clinchem.2008.106757
Table 1. Recovery of total
[beta]-hCG from CSF by the Advia
Centaur total hCG assay.

 Observed mean
Expected, (range), IU/L Recovery,
IU/L (n = 2) %

6 9 (9.1-9.4) 155
12 16 (15.5-15.8) 132
24 27 (27.3) 115
119 141 (139-143) 118
238 289 (288-290) 121
357 428 (427-429) 120
476 532 (528-536) 112
714 936 (923-949) 131
833 980 (978-980) 118
952 1090 (1007-1173) 115
COPYRIGHT 2008 American Association for Clinical Chemistry, Inc.
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2008 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Title Annotation:Letters to the Editor
Author:Ferguson, Angela M.; Ford, Bradley; Gronowski, Ann M.
Publication:Clinical Chemistry
Article Type:Letter to the editor
Date:Aug 1, 2008
Previous Article:Instrument-specific matrix effects of calibration materials in the LC-MS/MS analysis of tacrolimus.
Next Article:Immulite vs Scantibodies IRMA plasma ACTH assay.

Terms of use | Privacy policy | Copyright © 2019 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters