Lumbar extensor muscle profile of rural milk production workers/ Perfil da musculatura extensora lombar de trabalhadores rurais na atividade leiteira.
Brazil earned an outstanding place among the main milk producing countries in recent years, ranking fifth globally. Brazil produced 35 billion liters of milk in 2015, 35.2% corresponding to the Southern area. There are 5 million rural establishments in the country, 1.3 millions of which are milk producers (1). While the beef trade business is characterized by a predominance of large livestock producers, milk cattle is most often tended by small and medium-sized producers to become a source of family income as main or secondary activity (2).
The work of milk producers comprises several tasks, from the handling, feeding and milking of animals to environment and tool cleaning, milk storage and final product consumption. Some such tasks demand considerable physical effort from workers (3). According to Santos Filho (4), many workers also perform parallel activities in farms to make profit of resources and spaces and increase their income. As a function of the large number of tasks they perform, such workers do not have time for non-occupational activities, which causes physical exhaustion and consequent impairment of their quality of life (5).
Agricultural work, milking more in particular, involves lifting and transporting loads, repeated movements and adoption of inadequate body postures. For this reason it is an occupation that poses considerable risk to postural health, including spinal and limb deviations, repeated strain injury and low back pain (4-6).
In the daily work of rural workers, the low back extensor muscles participate in a large number of actions. When the strength of the abdominal muscles is reduced and there is imbalance between the trunk flexor and extensor muscles, low back pain, dysfunction and muscle fatigue might ensue. These conditions might threaten the motor function of the lumbar spine and are a risk factor for chronic low back pain and other disorders with direct impact on the quality of life and work life of rural milk production workers (7-9).
Muscle strength is intimately related to functional capacity. Muscle strength is the ability of muscles to develop or resist isometric, isokinetic or isotonic force. Dynamometry is a method used to measure muscle strength and investigate the characteristics of a given muscle over time (10-12).
Among the varieties of dynamometry, isometric lumbar extension dynamometry (ILED) is considered a satisfactory instrument for occupational evaluation and monitoring especially of populations of workers whose activities demand high levels of strength (13). In addition, there is also a need to quantify physical factors associated with the activities performed to improve diagnosis and preventive actions (14).
Given the relevance of milk production and the high physical demands to which rural workers are exposed, the aim of the present study was to investigate the isometric lumbar extension strength of rural milk production workers engaged.
The study population included rural workers in the area covered by Alto Jacui and Northwest Colonial Regional Development Council (Conselho Regional de Desenvolvimento--COREDE) selected by means of convenience sampling and without previous sample size calculation. Participants were 47 rural workers affiliated with the Technical Assistance and Rural Outreach Company/Southern Credit and Rural Assistance Company (Empresa de Assistencia Tecnica e Extensao Rural/Associacao Sulina de Credito e Assistencia Rural --EMATER/ASCAR), Rio Grande do Sul, Brazil. Participants came from the following municipalities: Cruz Alta, Boa Vista do Cadeado, Boa Vista do Incra, Salto do Jacui, Fortaleza dos Valos, Condor, Joia, Panambi, Coronel Barros and Pejucara.
In compliance with Resolution no. 466/2012, which establishes Guidelines and Regulatory Standards for Research Involving Human Beings, the study was approved by the research ethics committee of Cruz Alta University (Universidade de Cruz Alta--UNICRUZ) ruling no. 1,100,982. The participants signed an informed consent form.
Data collection was performed with the support of EMATER/ASCAR (RS), State University of Santa Catarina (Universidade do Estado de Santa Catarina--UDESC) and UNICRUZ; the latter also made its physical therapy laboratory available.
The following procedures were used for data collection:
* Application of the Worker's Questionnaire adapted from Moraes (15), which comprises open- and closed-ended questions to collect specific, personal and work conditions data;
* ILED, which was performed by means of a isometric lumbar extension measurement system developed by Laboratory of Instruments (LABIN), UDESC (16) . This system is based on the one used by Eichinger et al. (14) with an additional support to evaluate subjects at 140[degrees] of trunk anterior flexion. The goal of this modification is to avoid interferences with the strength momentum derived from anthropometric factors.
The device comprises a MioTool[R] system and a plank coupled to a hip posterior support. This support is adjustable and serves to place subjects in a way to achieve a 140[degrees] angle between the trunk and the thighs by adjusting the length of the chain that connects the load cell to the pull handle. Three measurements are previously made with subjects in straight position and the arms relaxed along the trunk, to wit, distance from shoulder to ground, trochanter to ground and fifth metacarpophalangeal joint axis to ground. These measurements are used to calculate the length of the chain needed to achieve a 140[degrees] angle. The isometric strength measurement system used is depicted in Figure 1. The dynamometer component that measures strength is a S-beam load cell with four strain gauges configured as a Wheatstone bridge circuit. Deformation of the load cell generates an electrical signal proportional to the strength applied. The dynamometer was calibrated before data collection. The four-channel data acquisition system comprises signal conditioners and a 14-bit analog-to-digital converter. In addition, it includes data acquisition and exploration software specifically designed for system management, which allows adjusting parameters (acquisition frequency, data collection time and visual feedback of curves), real-time acquisition monitoring and recording files, which are easily exported to data analysis software.
The load cell was connected to the MioTool[R] system, which allowed measuring the variation of lumbar strength as a function of time.
Descriptive analysis included calculation of the mean and standard deviation of the following parameters: peak force, total work, mean power and conventional ratio. Means were analyzed through the t-test (independent samples). All the analyses included calculation of the 95% confidence interval (p<0.05).
Most participants were women (57.45%) whose average age was lower compared to the men (women, 46.15 [+ or -] 7.56 years old; men, 50.45 [+ or -] 9.44 years old). Married participants predominated among both men and women, 95% and 96.30%, respectively (Table 1).
Most participants had attended incomplete elementary education; women, 44.44%; men, 50%. About 14.81% of the women and 10% of the men had completed higher education courses (Table 1).
Table 2 shows that the body mass and height were higher among the men compared to the women, however the difference in height was not considerable. Most participants from both sexes--48.15% of the women and 65% of the men--had worked in milk production for more than 20 years. The smallest proportion of participants were away from work or on sick leave--women, 3.70%; men, 5%.
Fifty percent of the men worked 40 hours per week and the other 50% more hours. Among the women, 51.88% worked 40 hours and 44.44% more hours. Only 25.93% of the women and 20% of the men performed physical activity (Table 2).
Table 3 describes the mean peak and mean force values and their comparison per sex; statistically significant difference was detected for both variables (p<0.05).
Tables 4 and 5 describes correlations between ILED peak force and mean force measurements; no statistically significant difference was detected.
The spinal extensor muscles seem to be one of the main agents involved in the early manifestation of low back pain. Training protocols targeting these muscles were effective to reduce low back pain and prevent new cases. Thus being, methods to assess the lumbar extensor muscle strength and function are relevant (17).
Muscle strength is the ability of muscles to generate or resist force, and is considered the most relevant physical asset of human beings, being related to both health and physical performance at various age intervals (12,14).
Muscle strength might be influenced by intrinsic or extrinsic factors. Among the former, the following stand out: muscle fiber cross-sectional area, number, contraction velocity and type, coordination, sex and age. In turn, the extrinsic factors include: time of the day, training method, motivation and nutrition (18).
Dynamometry has been recently used for assessment of muscle strength for being a non-invasive, easy-to-apply and low-cost method, in addition to providing reliable muscle strength parameters (12,14 . Some authors asserted that lumbar dynamometry for assessment of the trunk muscle strength has paramount importance in the evaluation of the global physical capacity, particularly in regard to individuals who perform activities involving physical overload (19,20).
In the present study, we found that the lumbar strength levels were higher among the men compared to women, indeed, 204.67% superior, thus agreeing with the results of the studies by Eichinger et al. (14) and Cardozo et al. (21). This difference might be attributed to the fact that men exhibit larger muscle mass, and thus produce greater force in general compared to women (21).
In a study with 50 women aged 30 to 50 years old, Guedes et al. (22) compared the effect of different strength training frequencies on the isometric lumbar muscle strength. The average strength was 611.52 [+ or -] 167.68 N in the group that trained 2 to 3 times per week and 700.11 [+ or -] 149.06 N in the group that trained 4 to 5 times per week. In the present study, the lumbar muscle strength was lower among the women, 571.34 [+ or -] 190.36 N. However, this difference might be due to differences in the profile of samples, as the population of the present study included participants who performed or not physical activity, while Guedes et al. (22) exclusively analyzed women who performed strength training.
The maximum isometric lumbar extension strength (N) found in the present study, 1,169.35 [+ or -] 289.96 N for men and 571.34 [+ or -] 190.36 N for women, were both superior to the ones reported by Soares et al. (12), 1,048.6 [+ or -] 235.2 N and 548.8 [+ or -] 156.8 N, respectively; Soares et al. (23), 1,117.2 [+ or -] 240.1 N and 475.3 [+ or -] 184.24 N, respectively; and Silva (16), 695 [+ or -] 229 N and 360 [+ or -] 85 N, respectively. These findings suggest that the isometric lumbar traction strength might be higher among individuals who live and work in rural areas compared to the ones who work in urban environments, such as offices, for instance, for performing activities involving greater overload.
Milk production depends on individuals who perform tasks involving considerable physical overload and inadequate body posture. According to Kirkhorn et al. (24) and Fathallah et al. (25), musculoskeletal diseases are the most frequent and high-cost conditions in rural areas. In the present study, we found that the lumbar extensor muscle profile of rural milk production workers was characterized by higher values for the men compared to the women, 1,169.35 [+ or -] 289.96 N and 571.34 [+ or -] 190.36 N, respectively. This difference might be attributed to the fact that men exhibit higher body mass levels, and consequently produce greater force.
By comparison to other studies, we found that rural workers develop higher levels of strength, which might be due to the fact they perform activities that involve greater physical overload compared to urban workers. We collected quantitative data on the isometric lumbar extension strength of individuals engaged in milk production, which represents a contribution to the literature, since it comprises few studies on this population of workers. For this reason, our results might serve as ground for future studies.
The measurement method used proved to be adequate, and thus might be applied to the monitoring of the trunk function of rural workers. In addition, for being a practical and low-cost method, it might be used in practice since the time of hiring employees for a same job, for the purpose of monitoring and characterizing the return-to-work criteria following sick leaves and layoffs.
However, further studies with larger samples and including variation in anthropometric measurements, occupation, sex and age should be performed with instruments similar to the one we used in the present study to corroborate the scientific understanding on the subject of interest and to contribute to decision-making by occupational professionals.
The present was a participative and planned study that involved the Center of Health and Agricultural Sciences (Centro de Ciencias da Saude e Agrarias--CCSA), undergraduate physical therapy course, UNICRUZ, LABIN, Center of Health and Sport Sciences (Centro de Ciencias da Saude e do Esporte--CEFID), UDESC Foundation and EMATER and ASCAR. It further had the support of Social Thematic Group, Milk Network Program (Milk Cattle Production System in Northwestern Rio Grande do Sul Research-Development Network Program). Participants were rural milk production workers from ten municipalities covered by Alto Jacui and Northwest Colonial Regional (COREDE), Rio Grande do Sul. The study had support from Institutional Program of Undergraduate Research Grants (Programa Institucional de Bolsas de Iniciacao Cientifica da UNICRUZ-PIBIC) and National Council of Scientific and Technological Development (Conselho Nacional de Desenvolvimento Cientifico e Tecnologico CNPq). Our thanks to everybody.
(1.) Instituto Brasileiro de Geografia e Estatistica. Producao da Pecuaria Municipal [Internet]. Rio de Janeiro: IBGE; 2015 [cited 23 Oct 2017]. v.43. 49p. Available at: https://biblioteca.ibge.gov.br/visualizacao/ periodicos/84/ppm_2015_v43_br.pdf
(2.) Federacao da Agricultura e Pecuaria do Estado de Sao Paulo. Bovinos de leite [Internet]. 2010 [cited 23 Oct 2017]. Available at: http://www.faespsenar.com.br/faesp/pagina/exibe/faesp/produtos/ bovinos-de-leite/697
(3.) Oliveira CC. A ergonomia na atividade leiteira: avaliacao das condicoes de trabalho nos ordenhadores na regiao de Campo Mourao--PR [MA dissertation]. Ponta Grossa: Universidade Tecnologica Federal do Parana; 2011.
(4.) Santos Filho JC. Estrategias de organizacao do trabalho na atividade leiteira em propriedades de agricultura familiar [MA dissertation]. Maringa: Universidade Estadual de Maringa; 2009.
(5.) Tonial A. Avaliacao da prevalencia, perfil e sintomatologia dos disturbios osteomusculares relacionados ao trabalho em membros superiores nos ordenhadores da Grande Florianopolis [MA dissertation]. Florianopolis: Universidade Federal de Santa Catarina; 2004.
(6.) Haeffner R, Sarquis LMM, Haas GFS, Heck RM, Jardim VMR. Prevalencia de lombalgia e fatores associados em trabalhadores de uma empresa agropecuaria do sul do Brasil. Rev Bras Med Trab. 2015;13(1):35-42.
(7.) Barros SS, Angelo RCO, Uchoa EPBL. Lombalgia ocupacional e a postura sentada. Rev Dor. 2011;12(3):226-30. http://dx.doi.org/10.1590/ S1806-00132011000300006
(8.) Tahara N, Gatti AC, Rafachino ECB, Walsh IAP. Efeitos de um programa educacional e de exercicios fisioterapeuticos na avaliacao da dor e da capacidade funcional em individuo com lombalgia: relato de caso. Arq Cienc Saude Unipar. 2008;12(1):61-6. https:// doi.org/10.25110/arqsaude.v12i1.2008.2230
(9.) Instituto Brasileiro de Geografia e Estatistica. Pesquisa Nacional de Saude 2013: percepcao do estado de saude, estilos de vida e doencas cronicas [Internet]. Rio de Janeiro: Instituto Brasileiro de Geografia e Estatistica; 2014 [cited 20 Oct 2017]. Available at: ftp:// ftp.ibge.gov.br/PNS/2013/pns2013.pdf
(10.) Arab AM, Salavati M, Ebrahimi, I, Ebrahim MM. Sensitivity, specificity and predictive value of the clinical trunk muscle endurance tests in low back pain. Clin Rehabil. 2007;21(7):640-7. https://doi. org/10.1177/0269215507076353
(11.) Borges Junior NG, Domenech SC, da Silva ACK, Dias JA, Sagawa Junior Y. Estudo comparativo da forca de preensao isometrica maxima em diferentes modalidades esportivas. Rev Bras Cineantopom Desempenho Hum. 2009;11(3):292-8.
(12.) Soares AV, Carvalho Junior JM, Fachini J, Domenech SC, Borges Junior NG. Correlacao entre os testes de dinamometria de preensao manual, escapular e lombar. Rev Acta Bras Movimento Humano. 2012;2(1):65-72.
(13.) Demoulin C, Grosdent S, Smeets R, Verbunt J, Jidovtseff B, Mahieu G, et al. Muscular performance assessment of trunk extensors: A critical appraisal of the literature. In: Sakai Y (Ed.). Low Back Pain. Londres: InTech; 2012.
(14.) Eichinger FLF, Soares AV, de Carvalho Junior JM, Gevaerd MS, Domenech SC, Borges Junior NG. Dinamometria lombar: Um teste funcional para o tronco. Rev Bras Med Trab. 2016;14(2):120-6. https:// doi.org/10.5327/Z1679-443520162415
(15.) Moraes LFS. Os principios das cadeias musculares na avaliacao dos desconfortos corporais e constrangimentos posturais em motoristas do transporte coletivo [MA dissertation]. Florianopolis: Universidade Federal de Santa Catarina; 2002.
(16.) Silva L. Proposta de metodo de avaliacao da forca de extensao lombar por meio da dinamometria [MA dissertation]. Florianopolis: Universidade do Estado de Santa Catarina; 2015.
(17.) Smith D, Bissell G, Bruce-Low S, Wakefield C. The effect of lumbar extension training with and without pelvic stabilization on lumbar strength and low back pain. J Back Musculoskelet Rehabil. 2011;24(4):241-9. https://doi.org/10.3233/BMR-2011-0301
(18.) Fernandes AA, Marins JCB. Teste de forca de preensao manual: analise metodologica e dados normativos em atletas. Fisioter Mov. 2011;24(3):567-78. http://dx.doi.org/10.1590/ S0103-51502011000300021
(19.) Udermann B, Mayer JM, Murray SR. Quantification of Isometric Lumbar Extension Strength Using a BackUP Lumbar Extension Dynamometer. Res Quarterly Exercise Sport. 2004;75(4):434-9. https://doi.org/10.1080/02701367.2004.10609177
(20.) Santos LJM. Dinamometria isocinetica lombar. EFDeportes [Internet]. 2002 Jun [cited 10 Nov 2017];8(49). Available at: http:// www.efdeportes.com/efd49/dinam.htm
(21.) Cardozo DC, Alves H, Simao R, Polito MD. Avaliacao da forca muscular extensora do tronco: influencia do genero e do estado de treinamento. ConScientiae Saude. 2016;15(3):401-6. https://doi. org/10.5585/ConsSaude.v15n3.6246
(22.) Guedes WA, Farias DL, Tibana RA, Nascimento DC, Vieira, DCL, Tajra V, et al. Efeito de diferentes frequencias de treinamento sobre a forca muscular isometrica da coluna lombar em mulheres praticantes de treinamento de forca. Educ Fisica Rev. 2013;7(1):1-10.
(23.) Soares AV, Carvalho-Junior JM, da Silva L, Domenech SC, BorgesJunior NG. Valores normativos da dinamometria lombar: um teste funcional para o tronco. In: Anais do IV Simposio em Neuromecanica Aplicada; 2013 Nov 26-28; Florianopolis. Florianopolis; 2013. p. 55-6.
(24.) Kirkhorn SR, Earle-Richardson G, Banks RJ. Ergonomic risks and musculoskeletal disorders in production agriculture: recommendations for effective research to practice. J Agromedicine. 2010;15(3):281-99. https://doi.org/10.1080/1059924X.2010.488618
(25.) Fathallah FA, Miller BJ, Miles JA. Low back disorders in agriculture and the role of stooped work: Scope, potential interventions, and research needs. J Agric Saf Health. 2008;14(2):221-45. https://doi. org/10.13031/2013.24352
Correspondence address: Themis Goretti Moreira Leal de Carvalho Rua Coronel Luiz Azevedo, 509--Centro--CEP: 98170-000--Tupancireta (RS), Brazil--E-mail: firstname.lastname@example.org
Niltiane da Veiga Leonardi , Leandro de Moraes Kohl , Lincoln da Silva , Emanueli Broch Orsolin , Giovani Sturmer , Noe Gomes Borges Junior , Themis Goretti Moreira Leal de Carvalho 
 Undergraduate Physical Therapy Course, Center of Health and Agricultural Sciences (Centro de Ciencias da Saude e Agrarias--CCSA), Cruz Alta University (UNICRUZ) Cruz Alta (RS), Brazil.
 Universidade Federal de Santa Catarina (UFSC)--Florianopolis (SC), Brazil.
 Center of Health and Sport Sciences (Centro de Ciencia da Saude e do Esporte--CEDIF/LABIN), State University of Santa Catarina (Universidade do Estado de Santa Catarina--UDESC)--Florianopolis (SC), Brazil.
Caption: Figure 1. Data acquisition system.
Table 1. Sociodemographic data relative to the study participants, Rio Grande do Sul, 2017 (n=47). Characteristics Category Female Male (measurement unit) (Percentage) Sex 57.45 42.55 Marital status Single 3.70 0 Married 96.30 95 Divorced or separated 0 5 Educational level Incomplete elementary school 44.44 50 Complete elementary school 11.11 10 Incomplete secondary school 7.40 0 Complete secondary school 11.11 25 Incomplete higher education 3.70 0 Complete higher education 14.81 10 Complete specialization 7.40 5 Table 2. Clinical characteristics of participants, Rio Grande do Sul, 2017 (n=47). SEX Characteristics Category Female (measurement unit) (Mean/SD) Age Years 46.15 [+ or -] 7.56 Body mass Kg 70.07.2 [+ or -] 15.60 Height M 1.60 [+ or -] 0.03 Length of work Less than 1 year (Percentage) in milk 7.41 production 2 to 5 years 3.70 6 to 10 years 22.22 11 to 15 years 7.41 16 to 20 years 11.11 More than 20 years 48.15 Occupational Active 96.30 status Away from work/ 3.70 sick leave Weekly working 30 hours/week 3.70 hours 40 hours/week 51.85 More than 40 44.44 hours/week Physical Yes 25.93 activity No 74.07 SEX Characteristics Category Male (measurement unit) (Mean/SD) Age Years 50.45 [+ or -] 9.44 Body mass Kg 81.11 [+ or -] 10.06 Height M 1.72 [+ or -] 0.07 Length of work Less than 1 year (Percentage) in milk 0 production 2 to 5 years 5 6 to 10 years 15 11 to 15 years 15 16 to 20 years 0 More than 20 years 65 Occupational Active 95 status Away from work/ 5 sick leave Weekly working 30 hours/week 0 hours 40 hours/week 50 More than 40 50 hours/week Physical Yes 20 activity No 80 SD: standard deviation; Kg: kilogram; M: meter. Table 3. Mean, standard deviation and correlation per gender of isometric lumbar extension dynamometry results, Rio Grande do Sul, 2017 (n=47). SEX Female Male (mean [+ or -] SD) (mean [+ or -] SD) Peak force (N) 571.34 [+ or -] 190.36 1.169.35 [+ or -] 289.96 Mean force (N) 441.04 [+ or -] 153.23 921.28 [+ or -] 250.71 Female vs. male (p value) Peak force (N) 0.000 Mean force (N) 0.000 SD: standard deviation; N: Newton. Table 4. Correlation of peak force (N) between isometric lum- bar extension dynamometry measurements, Rio Grande do Sul, 2017 (n=47). Lumbar extension p<0.05 isometric dynamo- metry time-points Women Men T1-T2 0.674819754 0.476478378 T1-T3 0.701436321 0.211700150 T2-T3 0.967686614 0.560524485 Table 5. Correlation of mean force (N) between isometric lumbar extension dynamometry measurements, Rio Grande do Sul, 2017 (n=47). Lumbar extension p<0.05 isometric dynamo- metry time-points Women Men T1-T2 0.897137927 0.774839874 T1-T3 0.670471592 0.412160859 T2-T3 0.773740508 0.581788949
|Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback|
|Title Annotation:||ORIGINAL ARTICLE|
|Author:||Leonardi, Niltiane da Veiga; de Moraes Kohl, Leandro; da Silva, Lincoln; Orsolin, Emanueli Broch; St|
|Publication:||Revista Brasileira de Medicina do Trabalho|
|Date:||Jul 1, 2018|
|Previous Article:||Assessment of a physical activity program on the medical-hospital costs of a healthcare company/ Avaliacao de um programa regular de atividade fisica...|
|Next Article:||Work-related musculoskeletal pain and its association with common mental disorders among employees of a poultry producing company in Southern Brazil/...|