Printer Friendly

It's My Retirement Money, Take Good Care of It: The TIAA-CREF Story.

This book chronicles the history of TIAA-CREF. From the announcement in 1905 by Andrew Carnegie of "free pensions" for college professors to the establishment of TIAA in 1918 and CREF in 1952 and through the sweeping changes of the seventies and eighties, the book provides an insider's perspective through the keen eye of Dr. William C. Greenough, a staff member of TIAA-CREF form 1941 through 1979, which included terms as President from 1957-1967 and Chairman and CEO from 1963-1979.

His account of the innovation, growth, setbacks, and controversies over this 85-year period are fascinating. He spends a significant portion of the book detailing the critical role played by the Carnegie Foundation in helping to establish TIAA and support its activities throughout the years. Another large section of the book is devoted to the origins of the variable annuity concept and the establishment of CREF in 1952. This portion of the work is particularly insightful because the author was a leading character in the development of this radical, innovative concept. As a pioneer, his anecdotal style of presentation makes interesting reading. In speaking of his obsession with the genesis of the variable annuity, he states on page 84:

It was that specific conversation [with Dr. Harry Sauvain] that dropped into place

the final missing piece for the variable annuity. I can still remember how neatly it

all suddenly arranged itself in my mind. A lifetime annuity free to move up or down

in direct proportion to the value of a portfolio of common stocks. The |aha' idea was

|express everything in units, not dollars.' Go ahead and make guarantees, but express

them as units not dollars.

The final third of the book is devoted to issues and controversies that have arisen during the last two decades, such as the issue of premium taxation and licensing by the states, the controversy surrounding sex-based versus gender-neutral annuity payments, SEC registration of CREF, and social responsibility in investing.

Two of these issues are presented in a particularly insightful manner. Chapter 21, "Fair Annuity Benefits," provides an excellent discussion of the pros and cons of sex-based annuity payments. TIAA-CREF was a primary target for sex discrimination suits, and Dr. Greenough led the organization through a significant portion of time period involved, the seventies and early eighties. The equitable treatment of males and females in retirement programs is an issue that may always remain unsolvable, and to gain the insights of someone in the middle of the controversy in invaluable to anyone who teaches this subject.

The other chapter that provides a unique perspective is Chapter 13, "Socially Responsible Investing." This is one of the most complete essays on the subject that has appeared in the literature. This issue has become increasingly important in the last twenty-five years. Dr. Greenough's "inside perspective" as a leader of one of the nation's largest institutional investors provides a classic treatment of this subject.

The book has its flaws. There is repetition from time to time as references are made to topics that are treated elsewhere in the book. Dr. Greenough's writing style becomes laborious in certain sections as the book takes on the flavor of a diary where a steady stream of people and events are presented with little authorial expansion or insight. Dr. Greenough is especially persistent in presenting an extensive listing of credentials whenever he names anyone involved in this historical treatise. He wants this book to be a legacy to all the people involved, not just to his own involvement, so these flaws are easily forgiven by any reader who has an interest in pensions.

This book is must reading for ARIA members who teach or research in the pensions field. The book is much more than a history of TIAA-CREF. It provides invaluable insights into the history and evolution of the private pension system in the United States from the perspective of a key executive of the largest private pension in the world. It is an important addition to the bookshelf of any ARIA member.

The book has a sad footnote. Dr. Greenough passed away suddenly just before the book went to press. He would be proud of the final product, which will stand as a legacy to this pioneer of private pensions.
COPYRIGHT 1992 American Risk and Insurance Association, Inc.
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 1992 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Author:Smith, Barry D.
Publication:Journal of Risk and Insurance
Article Type:Book Review
Date:Mar 1, 1992
Previous Article:Risk, Information and Insurance.
Next Article:Benefits, Costs, and Cycles in Workers' Compensation.

Terms of use | Copyright © 2016 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters