Printer Friendly

Insurance in Socialist East Europe.

Insurance in Socialist East Europe

Insurance in Socialist East Europe by Paul P. Rogers, with the assistance of Bruno Schonfelder and Ehrenfried Schutte, (Praeger Publishers, 1988), 195 pages.

Reviewer: Krzysztof J. Stroianski, Ph.D., Assistant Professor of Statistical and Actuarial Sciences, The University of Western Ontario, Canada.

Roger's unprecedented account of insurance systems in the socialist countries of Eastern Europe not only is the first publication of its kind in English, but also it has few counterparts in other languages. It fills the existing information gap giving a broad spectrum of facts and comments on insurance legislation, institutions, practice and even insurance related research and education. The authors have used the best available written sources and in some cases also their personal contacts with managements of East-European insurance companies. Notably, the chapter on Poland gives a detailed presentation of financial and operational results. The book covers a wide and changing panorama of insurance systems and therefore has to be relatively general as well as selective. It is natural that a reader will find points that could or should be elaborated upon. What I found interesting is the authors' assertion that history and tradition often influence the current state of insurance; consequently, East-European socialist insurance systems are presented with references to their historical contexts.

The book is divided into four parts. It starts with a general introduction (by Rogers) giving the structure of insurance programs and describing conditions of their existence. Part two (by Schonfelder) is devoted to presentation of the two extremes in the East-European insurance system: East Germany with its highly centralized monopoly, directly subordinate to the GDR Ministry of Finance; and Yugoslavia with the most Western-like structure. The third part of the book (by Schutte) is entitled "Proud heritage" and talks about Poland's relatively well developed insurance system. The last part (by Rogers) is an overview of insurance systems in other East-European socialist countries, i.e. Bulgaria, Czechoslovakia, Hungary and Rumania.

It is difficult to briefly summarize the content of this multifarious book but some general observations are worth mentioning. For example, the authors point out that one of the features common to insurance systems in socialist countries is the state monopoly. They also indicate the possibility of changes in the organization of insurance due to economic reforms.

A fundamental issue, common to most socialist countries, is justification of insurance for state-owned enterprises. According to Soviet insurance theory and practice, many East-European countries, at some stage, accepted that this insurance is redundant. For instance in East Germany, the insurance of the state-owned enterprises (except for the state-owned farms) was officially abolished in 1962. The cost of repaying claims/damages was funded through the state budget. Six years later, insurance of the state-owned sector of industry was reintroduced following the example of other countries. Currently, all socialist countries carry fire and natural perils insurance for state-owned enterprises.

Further, compulsory insurance constitutes a large share of the insurance systems in socialist countries and, for example, in Bulgaria it makes up a majority of the entire portfolio. This is another feature which runs in parallel to the monopolistic structure of insurance in East Europe.

Yet another characteristic feature is financial passivity. Reserves and free assets are all deposited in the state budget or in state savings banks and earn interest which is lower than the rate of inflation. Only in Yugoslavia is limited freedom of investing reserves in state-owned enterprises allowed.

The costs of operating lines of insurance are usually low. This is related to the low quality of service, low salaries of insurance company employees, and simplified insurance techniques. For example in Poland, the costs of operating the state-owned company PZU were between 7.3% (1970) and 8.6% (1982) of the earned premium.

The authors indicated that a lower level of insurance exists in socialist countries than in Western countries. So, for example, in East Germany the constant dollar premium income in 1950 constituted only a half of the total premium written for this region before the war.

My criticism of this book concerns issues that have been omitted by the authors. I was disappointed to find a detailed classification of insurance types in Hungary and only a brief mention of the organization of insurance markets, especially since the Hungarian approach was a novum in the socialist system. The division of the only state-owned insurance company Allami Bizstosito in 1987 into two separate companies - Allami Bizstosito and Hungaria Bizstosito - was the first attempt to demonopolize insurance companies in socialist countries (except for Yugoslavia, where different republics have different insurance companies). It is worth noting that this split was ordered by the Hungarian government. Initially, both companies were assigned specific branches of insurance, as well as control of the respective parts of the financial reserves. Individual property and casualty insurance, all types of agricultural insurance and life insurance were assigned to Allami Bizstosito, while property insurance for the state-owned enterprises, automobile insurance, foreign insurance and reinsurance were handed over to Hungaria Bizstosito. The proportion of the size and number of employees at the time of the split was 2:1. To spur "competition", both companies received the right to underwrite all types of insurance (except export credit insurance). It must be stressed that the division of the only insurance company into two strong state-owned insurance institutions did not create a good foundation for the existence and development of smaller enterprises. They are being eliminated from the market by the two competing giants. Only in the field of life insurance, is there a third company. However, it is based on the state-owned savings bank.

Similarly, the presentation of Polish insurance left unmentioned the fact that the 1984 Act on property and life insurance allows for establishing new, state independent insurance firms that compete with the two state-controlled insurance companies PZU and Warta. Recently, three private insurance firms: Westa, Polisa and Tur were established. The prevailing criticism of the state monopoly in all sectors of the Polish economy creates a better climate for restructuring the insurance system there, but it is still uncertain if any of the three new companies will survive competition with the state-controlled companies.

Taking into account the fact that this is the first publication on East-European insurance in English, there is little doubt that it will be the most frequently cited material in studies concerning insurance or even insurance-related problems of the economy in this part of the world. It is truly an excellent source of information and one could only regret that there are many misprints, particularly in foreign words and bibliographies. Also, parts of the book look at things from an obviously Germanic perspective. Poles, for instance, would give 1772-1918 rather than 1763-1919 as dates of Poland's partition.


[1.] Bader H. et al. Lexicon der Wirtschaft: Versicherung, Verlag Die Wirtschaft, Berlin, 1982. [2.] Kolomin E.V. Gosudarstvennoe Strakhovanie v Sotsialisticheskikh Stranakh, Finansy i Statistika, Moscow, 1981.
COPYRIGHT 1990 American Risk and Insurance Association, Inc.
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 1990 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Author:Stroianski, Krzysztof J.
Publication:Journal of Risk and Insurance
Article Type:Book Review
Date:Mar 1, 1990
Previous Article:The Handbook of Employee Benefits, 2d ed.
Next Article:Automation in Insurance.

Terms of use | Copyright © 2017 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters