Indirectal in literary Estonian.
The morphology, mostly verb morphology, of languages with grammatical evidentiality expresses the origin of information. According to Willet's (1988: 57-58) typology, the most common evidentiality opposition is that between direct and indirect evidentiality. Direct evidentiality refers to information relying on a speaker's perception. Indirect evidentiality can be divided into reported evidentiality and inferred (inferential) evidentiality. Reported information can be hearsay or folklore. Hearsay evidentiality has become grammaticalised in the Estonian language, occurring in the indirectal category.
The term indirectal relates to the category of the mode of reporting in the Estonian grammar, on which basis Ratsep established the system of moods in the Estonian language. The mode of reporting is a supra-moodal verb category whose two members--the direct mode of reporting or the directal and the mediated mode of reporting or the indirectal--can be differentiated on the basis of the source of information: in the former case the source of information is identified with the speaker, while in the latter the speaker acts as a mediator. Direct modes of reporting are indicative, conditional and direct imperative. The indirectal is a verb category that morphologically occurs in two moods--quotative and reported imperative (Ratsep 1971:58-59).
A recent academic grammar of Estonian makes no reference to the indirectal as an independent verb category. The mode of reporting is one of the grammatical meanings expressed in a verb's mood category. The indirect mode of reporting or the reportive nature of information rendered by a sentence is expressed by the quotative mood; the reportive nature of a command is expressed by the jussive (Erelt et al. 1993:34-37). The morphological moods of Estonian rely on the opposition of direct and reported information. The Estonian quotative mood and the jussive express reported evidentiality which is a subtype of indirect evidentiality.
In actual language usage the function of indirectal moods is performed by several morphological, lexico-morphological and syntactic means. Traditional form-focused language description methods do not allow the treatment of linguistic means with identical functions as members of one and the same category which is why in the present article Ratsep's (1971:61) purely morphological category of mode of reporting is extended. I shall take into account both functional and semantic properties of a linguistic means to provide a uniform description of all forms of expression of the indirectal mode of reporting in literary Estonian regardless of whether they form a morphological paradigm or not.
Mode of reporting is a functional-semantic category whose members are, depending on the source of information, the directal and the indirectal which serve two types of communication aims: statement and command. The object of research of the present article is restricted to the means of expression of the reported or indirect statement in literary Estonian. The research is corpus-based; the analysed literary language material comprises journalistic and fiction texts over the period of one hundred years. Journalistic language and fiction are two central registers of literary language which, on the one hand, influence and shape and, on the other hand, reflect public literary usage. Qualitative research of those two gives an insight into the existing indirectal means of expression in the literary language. The aim is to explain and compare the share and dynamics of indirectal means of expression in literary Estonian based on the example of two sublanguages. The problems of direct (the imperative) and reported (the jussive) command have been discussed by Erelt (2002b) and Erelt and Metslang (2004).
Viewing the indirectal as a functional-semantic category enables a looser codescription of lexical and grammatical transitions and to point to the category's lexical (or lexical-syntactic etc.) expressions. By deciding that the indirectal is a grammatical category it should be accepted that certain lexical means have become grammaticalised, i.e. belong to grammar and not lexis. Grammaticalisation is a one-way transformation process where a fully meaningful linguistic unit becomes a linguistic unit carrying grammatical information and therefore loses its syntactic independence and concreteness of meaning. The paradigmatic status of the linguistic unit also changes (Hopper, Traugott 1993). Lexis-centred language description is offered by the cognitive paradigm which, besides focusing on lexical grammar as an inseparable whole and the lexical basis of the meaning of grammar tools (systematic-functional approach) also talks about the lexical conditionality of grammar as a whole, as well as lexis and lexical meaning as the engines in grammatical formation and changes (e.g. Hoey 2005). The transformation process heading towards lexicon has been viewed as lexicalisation which mostly occurs in words and phrases with a syntactic function and whereby a linguistic expression carrying a grammatical meaning obtains an independent meaning and becomes part of the lexicon (e.g. Brinton, Traugott 2005).
From the methodical point of view this is a qualitative corpus study of material drawn from the Corpus of Estonian Literary Language (CELL) of 1890-1990. Four periods were analysed: the 1890s, 1930s, 1970s and 1990s. The analysed journalistic and fiction texts from four periods comprise a total of eighty thousand words: ten thousand words from each text type in each period.
There are three groups of indirectal means of expression, depending on the syntactic construction where they typically occur. In elementary sentences the indirectal is expressed in the predicate or adpositional phrase; in complex sentences it occurs in the form of reported speech. Tables 1 and 2 list the means of expression of the indirect statement in Estonian by frequency and give an overview of the share and dynamics of one or another indirectal means of expression in the Estonian journalistic language and fiction to the others. In the following chapters of the article, the functional, semantic and formal description of the means of expression and the usage analysis of indirectal means of expressions over one hundred years are presented.
3. Expressing an indirect statement in the predicate
In the predicate an indirect statement is expressed by moodal means and infinite verb forms and modal verbs functioning as predicates (see Table 3).
3.1. Moodal means
The quotative is a vat-marked mood whose main function is to present reported information. Reported information can be hearsay or rumour. Typological linguistics considers a reference to the source of information the most important property of the evidentiality category (Aikhenvald 2004). Therefore Estonian can also be considered a language with grammatical evidentiality. The expression of evidentiality in Estonian has been studied by several authors, see e.g. Erelt (2002) and Erelt et al. (2006) and the references contained there.
The indirectal function is secondarily fulfilled by the compound tenses of the indicative. Their primary role is to express temporal relationship. The fact that the speaker has become distanced from the time of the event creates a situation of reported information and questions the validity of the information. In the indirectal function, the perfect form on of the auxiliary olema 'be' or the past perfect auxiliary oli may be omitted from the sentence and the indirectal meaning is attached to the past participle-nud functioning as a finite verb in the sentence (Kunnap 1992, 1994, Muizniece et al. 1999).
3.2. Infinite verb forms functioning as finite verbs
In addition to the single past nud-participle, da-infinitive also functions as an indirectal finite verb. The form and function of the single past participle as a predicate is identical with the predicate participle which occurs in folklore and monological narrative and is characterised by diachronically independent development (Kunnap 1992:209, Muizniece et al. 1999:527-529). The independent development version is supported by the grammaticalisation of the vat-marker of the quotative mood from a present participle construction (see Campbell 1991). Stolz (1991:45-49) considers the use of participles in indirectal meaning the principal shared characteristics of the Baltic language area. The North-Estonian da-infinitive quotative mood has, similarly with indirectal participle predicates, emerged from infinite constructions with perception or reporting verbs (Magiste 1952).
3.3. Indirectal modal verbs
The indirectal links primarily to epistemic modality related to likelihood. The more indirect the information, the less credible it is, which is why in interpreting the meaning of a sentence the meanings of indirectal evidentiality and epistemic modality intertwine--one the one hand, one cannot be entirely sure about the reported information and, on the other hand, insecurity renders the source of information doubtful. Through an interim step of epistemic modality the indicative imperfect form pidi 'had to' of the deontic modal verb pidama 'must, have to' has grammaticalised into a post-modal quotative auxiliary (Erelt 2001). On the other hand, the modal verb has preserved its lexical meaning and expresses the meaning of the mood in the form pidavat.
There is no complete research on Estonian perception verbs although several grammaticalisation tendencies have been noted. Naima, paistma, both 'seem', tunduma 'feel' and lexicalised verb forms kuulukse 'hear', naikse 'seem', tunnukse 'feel' are complete modal verbs when they occur together with an infinite verb form (Ratsep 1978:188), which is generally partitive -vat of the present participle. Viitso (1976:157-158) has considered it necessary to include the punctual of the grammatical category into the description of the inflection type of verb, "as naikse, kuulukse, tunnukse only describe what seems to be, has been heard or feels like at the moment of speaking." On the other hand, imperative particles such as vaata / vata / vat, vahi, kae 'look!', kuule / kule 'listen!', have emerged from perception verbs (Metslang 2004:248). The perception verb form kuulukse, transitive verb kuulma 'to hear' and intransitive kuulduma have an indirectal function.
3.4. Corpus analysis
The journalistic language of the 1890s is characterised by abundant forms of the indirectal and ambiguity of meanings. There was no normative grammar of literary language; functional styles had not emerged yet and language use was greatly influenced by everyday language. Under the influence of German analytical grammar thataffected Estonian for a long time, a number of auxiliary constructions were used, this explaining the German word order with the verb in the end of the sentence (1).
(1) Hiljuti saa-nud ta wast kirja, mille-le were-ga nimi alla kirjuta-tud ol-nud. AJA1890\epo0103 recently get-PTCP s/he perhaps.PRCL letter.GEN what-ALL blood-COM name down write-PTCP be-PTCP 'He is reported to have received a letter signed with blood recently.'
Back then, grammarians (E. Ahrens (1853), F. J. Wiedemann (1875), K. A. Hermann (1884)) advised to express a reported statement with the past participle (1), (2), da-infinitive (3), (6) or vat-marked form. The frequency of those forms in journalistic language is given in Table 1. As to the single nud-participle (1), (2) there is often ambiguity of meaning: a form can carry the function of either the indicative or quotative mood. In such cases context may help to understand, although not always. In example (1) particle vast helps to decide in favour of the indirectal. In example (2) the writer is not a witness of the event and points to the fact that information is being reported by using the single past participle in the indirectal function. The speaker also uses the past perfect form oli olnud to render the information.
(2) Ta ol-i heina niit-ma-s olnud ja wihma aja-l uhe-s isa ja noorema wennaga kodu haka-nud mine-ma, kui kargatus kai-nud ning ta elukuunla kustuta-nud. AJA1890\epo0105 s/he be-PST.3SG meadow.GEN scyth-mINF-INE be-PTCP and rain.GEN time-ADE one-INE father.GEN and younger.GEN brother-COM home begin_to-PTCP go-mINF when lightening struck-PTCP and s/he.GEN lifecandle.GEN switch_off-PTCP 'He had been scything in the meadow and was about to go home with his father and brother when suddenly lightning struck and killed him.'
The indirectal is also expressed by the da-infinitive construction with mainfinitive (3), (4) which occurred in the texts of the 1890s only 5 times, as well as nud-/tud-participle (5) or da-infinitive (6), (36).
(3) Lehe-st saa-da kuus nummer-t aasta-s ilmu-ma ja maks-ta 1 rubla. AJA1890\epo0105 newspaper get-dINF six issue-PRTV year-INE publish-mINF and costdINF 1 rouble.GEN 'The newspaper is reported to publish six issues a year and cost 1 rouble.'
(4) Kirja-s seis-nud, et kui Perier septembrikuu-l Lyoni soida-b, ta aga warema-lt Caserio ara surma-ta on lask-nud, siis ka tema elukuunal saalsamas kustu-ma pida-da ... AJA1890\epo0103 letter-INE stand-PTCP that if Perier September-ADE Lyon.INE drive3SG he but earlier-ABL Caserio.GEN off kill-dINF is let-PTCP then also he.GEN lifecandle very_place switch_off-mINF have_to-dINF 'The letter is reported to have said that if Perier goes to Lyon in September, having had Caserio killed first, his own life will end at the very place ...'
(5) Kuulu jarele olla ajalehe toimetaja Bandi mortsukas Ajaccio-s kinni woetud ... AJA1890\epo0103 hearsay.GEN according_to over be.dINF newspaper.GEN editor Band.GEN killer Ajaccio-INE adhere take-PTCP 'According to hearsay newspaper editor Bandi's killer has been arrested in Ajaccio ...'
(6) Kewade poole teata-si-me, et hra H. Laas Tartu-s tahta pollutoo lehte asuta-da. AJA1890\epo0105 spring.GEN toward notify-PST-1PL that mr Laas Tartu-INE want.dINF agricultural.GEN newspaper.PRTV establish-dINF 'In spring we wrote that mr. Laas from Tartu had been reported to want to start an agricultural newspaper.'
Although the grammar books of the early 19th century suggested a construction formed with the verb pidama as a counterpart for the German conjunctive, analysis data (5 cases out of 155) show that the Estonian literary language of the 1890s preferred simple native forms. The verb pidama is used in sentences in dainfinitive (4). In later periods the past simple form pidi with ma-infinitive became rooted (7), (16). In contemporary spoken language the use of the past simple form pidi with ma-infinitive is wide-spread in reporting events that (are believed to) happen in the present or future, or in predictions (Toomet 2000).
(7) Rezoldt pid-i kihlweo ka siis woit-ma, kui walja tule-ks ... AJA1890\epo0104 Rezoldt must-PST.3SG bet.GEN also then win-mINF if out come-COND 'Rezoldt was said to win the bet even if ...'
The only instance of the use of the indirectal hearing verb kuulukse is example (8). In addition, the material contained certain constructions with the indirectal verb kuulma. Those constructions cannot be regarded as reported speech, as the verb kuulma cannot be considered a secondary speaking verb either (see Chapter 5). There were a total of 27 examples (Table 1) with the verb kuulma (in four different forms): 4 examples of da-infinitive (9), 14 examples of 1st person plural (10), 1 example of 3rd person plural (12) and 8 examples of 3rd person singular (11) of indicative present. In 20 sentences the verb kuulma occurred together with conjunctions nagu 'as' or kuda ~ kuida ~ kuidas 'how'. The source of information has been determined only in those sentences that contain 3rd person singular. In other cases the source of information is impersonal.
(8) Liia sadu-de ule kuulukse rahwas-t nurise-wat. AJA1890\epo0104 overmuch.GEN rain.PL.GEN about hear people-PRTV complain-QUOT 'People are reported to complain about too much rain.'
(9) Kuda kuul-da, minna see asi waidleja-te kaebtuse paale senati ... AJA1890\epo0104 how hear-dINF go.dINF that thing debater- PL.GEN complaint.GEN on senate.INE 'The parties of the dispute are reported to take the matter to the senate ...'
(10) Kuda ustawa-lt poolt kuule-me, pole sellekordse-d naitleja-d mitte koik "Wanemuise" seltsi-st ol-nud, nagu meie kirjasaatja eksikombel teata-s, waid saal on ka teisi naitlejai-d olnud. AJA1890\epo0105 how trusty-ABL side hear-1PL is_not this_time.PL actor-s not all Wanemuine.GEN society-EL be-PTCP as our correspondent mistakenly notify-PST.3SG but there is also other.PRTV actor.PL-PRTV be-PTCP 'It has turned out that this time not all actors were from the society "Wanemuine" as was mistakenly reported by our correspondent, but there were other actors as well.'
(11) Kuida "P.B." kuule-b, on pr. Jantschewskaja palwe "Kolowan"i toimetamise ja waljaandmise asjus tahelepane-ma-ta jae-tud. AJA1890\ole0107 how P.B. hear-3SG is mrs Jantschewskaja request.GEN Kolowan.GEN editing.GEN and issuing.GEN regarding take_notice-mINF-ABE leavePTCP '"P.B." has found out that mrs. Jantschewskaja's request regarding editing and issuing "Kolowan" has been ignored.'
(12) Nagu "Nowosti" kuule-wad, tule-wat teedeministri kasu-l Wene raudteede saadiku-d 12. weebruari-l Peterburi-sse kokku ... AJA1890\pos0804 as Nowosti hear-3PL come-QOUT Minister_of_Roads.GEN order-ADE Russian.GEN railways.GEN representative.PL 12 February-ADE St.Petersburg-INE together 'According to "Nowosti" the Minister of Roads has summoned the representatives of Russian railways to St Petersburg on 12 February ...'
Fiction texts contain fewer instances of reported statements per 10 000 words than journalistic texts. While the indirectal forms employing da-infinitive and nud-participle were dominant in journalistic texts, the occurrence of quotative mood with vat-form was somewhat higher in fiction texts (13), (15). One sentence contains a predicate participle (14).
(13) Wana poiss isegi oli tema-st kiit-nud, et weel kusagil julgema-t mees-t maailma-s tema silma otsa ei ole-wat juhtu-nud. AJA1890\pro0011 old boy even representative be.PST.3SG he-EL praise-PTCP that yet somewhere most_daring-PRTV man-PRTV world-INE he.GEN eye.GEN upon NEG be-QOUT come_to_pass-PTCP 'The bachelor himself is said to have praised him as the most daring man he had ever seen.'
(14) Laew, mis min-d nuud kandi-s, tul-nud Hiina merest ja lai-nud Madakaskari kaudu Ahwrika randa. AJA1890\pro0019 ship that I-PRTV now carry-PST.3SG come-PTCP Chinese sea-EL and go-PTCP Madagaskar.GEN through Africa.GEN shore.INE 'The ship that was carrying me now is said to have come from the Chinese sea and headed to Africa through Madagaskar.'
In three cases, a construction with da-infinitive has been used as an indirectal. One or two instances of this trend can be found in the fiction texts of all periods. Sentence (15) contains both a vat-marked and da-infinitive indirectal.
(15) Ta nimeta-b ennast alatuma-ks inimese-ks, et ta seda tege-ma pida-wat, aga ta ei woi-da teisiti. AJA1890\pro0081 s/he.GEN call-3SG himself-PRTV lowest-TRNSL person-TRNSL that s/he that.PRTV do-mINF have_to-QUOT but s/he NEG can-dINF otherwise 'They say he is calling himself the lowest person for having to do this but they also say he just can't help it.'
The only instance of the verb pidama is in past simple (16).
(16) Tartu pidi kaitse-tud saa-ma ... AJA1890\pro0029 Tartu must-PST.3SG protect-PTCP get-mINF 'Tartu is reported to get protection ...'
The journalistic texts of the 1930s contain almost four times fewer cases of the indirectal than the earlier period. Predominantly (19 cases out of 24), sentences contain quotative mood with the vat-marker recommended in Muugi's grammar (1928:103) and orthological dictionary (1933). It has two tenses: present (17) and preteritum, which is a perfect tense, formed from the quotative auxiliary olevat and the past participle of the main verb (18). The synthetic nuvat-quotative suggested as a neologist form instead of the latter never became rooted in literary language and no instances of the nuvat-form were found in the analysed material. Other morphological indirectal forms have retreated from journalistic language.
(17) Malaga wiimas-te teade-te jargi ole-wat poliitilisi-l pohjusi-l mahalastute arw palju suurem ... ESMA\esma302 Malaga latest.PL.GEN message.PL.GEN according be-QOUT political.PL-ADE reason.PL-ADE executed.PL.GEN number much bigger 'According to the latest news from Malaga, the number of those shot for political reasons is much bigger ...'
(18) Selle jarele ole-wat walitsuswagede lennukid soorita-nud 65 pommitamisretke, walitsuswastaste ohujoud aga 67. Seejuures ole-wat alla tulista-tud uheksa walitsuse lennuki-t, kuna walitsuswastaste kaotused tous-wat 32 lennuki-le. ESMA\esma226 that.GEN according be-QUOT governmental.PL.GEN airforce.PL completed-PTCP 65 bombing_mission.PRTV antigovernment.PL.GEN airforce but 67 whereas be-QUOT down shot-PTCP nine government. GEN aircraft-PRTV while antigovernment.PL.GEN losses.PL ariseQUOT 32 aircraft-ALL
'After that, government airforce is reported to have completed 65 bombing missions and the antigovernment airforce 67, whereas 9 goverment aircraft are reported to have been shot down while the losses of the antigovernment forces are said to amount to 32 aircraft.'
Sentence (19) contains both a construction with the verb pidama and an impersonal past participle. Those two are the only examples in the journalistic texts of the 1930s expressing the indirectal in the predicate in addition to the vatmarked quotative mood per 10 007 words. While 55 cases of the single past participle were found in the journalistic texts of the 1890s, only one instance occurred in the material of the 1930s (wallutatud in example (19)).
(19) Nadala keskel pid-i-d walitsuswaed ole-ma saawuta-nud rea tahelepanuwaarseid woite, kusjuures walluta-tud ka Toledo linna, kuid nuud teatawad walitsuswastased, et ... ESMA\esma241 week.GEN middle must-PST.3PL government_forces.PL be-mINF gainPTCP line.GEN remarkable-PRTV victory.PL.GEN whereby conquerPTCP also Toledo city.PRTV but now notify-3PL antigovernment.PL that 'In the middle of the week government forces were reported to have gained a number of important victories, including conquering the city of Toledo, but antigovernment forces have reported that ...'
The reportive construction with the transitive verb kuulma characteristic of the journalistic language of the 1890s occurs in the journalistic texts of the 1930s only once and the intransitive verb kuulduma twice.
(20) Siis luge-si-me ja kuul-si-me Jugoslaavia naiskongressi-lt, et tei-l on asuta-tud kodumajanduskoda, mis koosne-b uksnes naiste-st. ESMA\esma222 then read-PST-3PL and hear-PST-3PL Jugoslavia.GEN women_conferenceABL that you.PL-ADE is found-PTCP home_economics_chamber what consist-3SG only woman.PL-EL 'We then read and heard from the Jugoslavian women conference that you have founded a home economics chamber that consists of women only.'
(21) Pariisi borsi-l on arewad ajad, kuuldu-b, et Prantsuse frank lange-b uuesti. ESMA\esma239 Paris.GEN stock_market-ADE is trobled.PL time.PL hear-3PL that French.GEN frank fall-3PL again 'Times are troubled at the Parisian stock market as the French frank is expected to fall again.'
In fiction texts the dominance of the vat-marked quotative mood is not so evident. In sentence (22) it is accompanied by da-infinitive indirectal. As to the use of the past participle, an essential change has taken place compared to the forms present in the fiction texts of the 1890s. By following the pattern of folklore, the single past participle is now employed as a stylistic tool; a random sample consisting of 10 002 words contained 6 instances of predicate participle, two of them in example (23).
(22) Ta olla ju ka naise vot-nud, aga naine ole-vat endine niisugune ... ILU1938\ram0064 he be.dINF CLC too wife.GEN take-PTCP but woman.GEN be-QUOT former that_kind 'They say he's got married, but the wife is known to be a former ...'
(23) Eks naised lai-nud siis uhte tallu kokku ja palu-nud kovasti Jumala-t, et ta pehmema-t ilma anna-ks ... ILU1937\ram0044 PRCL woman.PL go.PST-PTCP then one.INE farm.INE and pray-PTCP hardly God-PRTV that he nicer-PRTV weather.GEN give-COND 'The women had gathered on a farm and prayed to God for nicer weather ...'
The material contains one example (24) of the indirectal use of the hearing verb. Texts from more recent periods do not contain the hearing verb in the indirectal function.
(24) Ol-i kuul-da, et Juri-t on nah-tud mingisuguse voora naise-ga. ILU1938\ram0064 be-PST.3SG hear-dINF that Juri-PRTV is see-PTCP some_kind strange.GEN woman-COM 'Juri was said to have been seen with a strange woman.'
The journalistic texts of the 1970s contain only one example (25) of the use of the grammatical quotative mood per 10 002 words.
(25) ... teata-s Hiina RV valitsus, et ta on tuumarelvakatsetuste keelustamise vastu, sest see jat-vat ta ilma voimaluse-st tugevda-da Hiina kaitsevoimet. AJA1970\ed0039 announce-3SG China.GEN People_Government.GEN that he is nuclear_testing.PL.GEN ban.GEN against because it leave-QUOT he.GEN without possibility-EL strengthen-dINF China.GEN defensive_potential-PRTV '... the People's Government of China announced that it was against banning nuclear testing because it would alledgely deprive China of its defensive potential.'
Fiction texts contain fewer instances of reported statements compared to earlier periods, but the range of indirectal means of expressions has not decreased in language usage. The vat-marked quotative mood (26) continues to dominate and there are two cases of the use of the indirectal da-inifinitive (28). The narrative predicate participle that has disappeared from journalistic language is still present in fiction (27). In example (29) the past perfect of the secondary speaking verb of the reporting clause can be regarded as indirectal.
(26) Ta vaja-vat hoolitsu-st ja ta-l ei ole-vat keda-gi, kes taha-b end puhendada ... ILU1970\ilu0078 he need-QUOT taking_care-EL and he-ADE NEG be-QUOT anyoneCLC who want-3SG himself.PRTV devote-dINF 'They say he needs taking care of and doesn't have anyone willing to devote himself to ...'
(27) "Eks see ol-nud sedaaegu jah, kui kaks kratti, tulesabad sarina-l taga, Matasjarve kaeva-si-d," utle-s vanaema ... ILU1970\ilu0088 PRCL it be-PTCP that_time yes when two devil.PRTV fire_tale.PL sparking-ADE behind Matasjarv.PRTV dig-PST-3PL say-PST.3PL grandmother ... '"That's how it had been when two devils had been digging Lake Matasjarve with their tails sparking," grandmother said ...'
(28) Aga kasu? olla preili kusi-nud. ILU1970\ilu0053 but benefit be.dINF miss ask-PTCP 'But what about benefits? the miss had reputedly asked.'
(29) Margit oli tahenda-nud, et maailm arene-b omaenese seaduste jargi ... ILU1970\ilu0069 Margit be.PST.3SG notice-PTCP that world evolve-3SG its_own.GEN law.PL.GEN according_to 'Margit had noticed that the world evolves according to its own laws ...'
The journalistic texts of the 1990s also contain only one example of expressing a reported statement in the predicate (30). The adessive indirectal (see Chapter 4) that occurs in the material of the 1970s, has become deeply rooted in the journalistic texts of the 1990s. Sentence (30) contains two cases of the adessive indirectal (sonul, vaitel).
(30) Kuid et iga-l firma-l saa-b Tederi sonul olla vaid uks arinimi, ei ole-vat Trendy EWI Groupi kaasamine kriminaalprotsessi tema vaitel mille-ga-gi pohjenda-tud. AJAE1990ar0005 but that each-ADE company-ADE can-3PL Teder.GEN according_to_word be.dINF only one business_name NEG be-QUOT Trendy EWI Group.GEN involving criminal_procedure.GEN he.GEN according_to_statement what-COM-CLC founded-PTCP 'But as each company can, according to Teder's own words, have only one business name, involving Trendy EWI Group into the criminal procedure is completely unfounded.'
In fiction texts the use of indirectal has been stable; the use of form is slightly more versatile. Next to the vat-marked quotative mood (31), there are instances of the narrative single past participle (32). Archaic style is expressed by the dainfinitive verb form olla (33). Past perfect, which is now also being used to express the indirectal in literary language (33), is the most wide-spread form in the spoken language of the given period (Toomet 2002:253). Although the scope of this article does not cover indirectal command, its use can be seen in example (31) which employs the jussive form tulgu.
(31) Utle-s, et minu-l ole-vat amet selge ja tul-gu mina tema-le appi. ILU1990\ilu0223 say-PST.3SG that I-ADE be-QUOT profession clear and come-JUSS I heALL help-INE 'He said that I was known to be familiar with the profession and should help him.'
(32) Pere ol-nud koik koos ja istu-nud parajasti soogilaua-s ja akki haka-nud eeskoja-s hirmus larm peale. ILU1990\ilu0223 Family be-PTCP all together and sit-PTCP just_then dinner_table-INE and suddenly begin-PTCP anteroom-INE terrible noise on 'The family was said to have been all together, sitting at the table, when suddenly an awful noise started in the hall.'
(33) ... kohalikud "viikingid" olla sealt sada kakskummend "kolonne-t" piiritus-t ara veda-nud. ILU1990\ilu0249 local viking.PL be.dINF from_there hundred twenty unit-PRTV spiritPRTV away carry-PTCP '... the local "Vikings" were said to have taken away from there one hundred and twenty units of spirit.'
(34) Herman oli oel-nud-ki, et ju tema on-gi see Anna paratamatu saatus. Anna oli selle peale vait jaa-nud ... ILU1990\ilu0284 Herman be.PST.3SG say-PTCP-CLC that CLC he is-CLC this Anna.GEN inevitable faith Anna be.PST.3SG this.GEN on silent become-PTCP 'Herman had said that he probably was Anna's inevitable faith. Anna had then become silent ...'
4. Expressing an indirect statement with an adpositional phrase
Reported statements are expressed by adpositions kohaselt, jargi, both 'according to' arvates, meelest, arust 'according to opinion', sonul 'according to words', vaitel 'according to statement', teatel 'according to message', hinnangul 'according to judgement', andmetel 'according to data', etc. The source of information in an adpositional phrase and synonymous constructions is marked by a genitive modifier or a modifying phrase. The modifier of an adposition can be a) noun, e.g. kuulu jargi 0, seaduse jargi (39); b) proper noun modifying a noun, e.g. Tiit Salumae sonade kohaselt 0, or c) independent proper noun, e.g. Tederi sonul (30); d) personal, e.g. tema vaitel (30), or e) possessive pronoun, nt oma sonul (35) (the referent of the latter is revealed by context--Ehala in example (35) and Teder in example (30)).
(35) Ehala ei tea oma sonu-l seni-ni, kuidas Kunnap teda oma ansambli-sse kutsu-da oska-s. AJAE1990\ar0019 Ehala NEG know own according_to_word-ADE still-TRM how Kunnap he.PRTV own band-INE call-dINF know_how-PST.3SG 'According to his own words, Ehala still doesn't know how Kunnap asked him to join the band.'
The function of an adposition can be adopted by a verb form (Uuspold 2001, see also Jaakola 1997). For example, the verb form (gerund) arvates of the verb arvama 'opine' is a different part of speech and as an adposition takes a genitive modifier and expresses the indirectal. Synonymous with the adposition arvates are postpositions meelest and arust which did not occur in the analysed material.
The journalistic texts of the 1990s are strikingly abundant in constructions that have the same function as adpositional phrases containing jargi, kohaselt and sonutsi 'according to words', pointing to someone who is making a statement or to another source of information. In all cases the main word of the construction is a singular adessive noun which does not change freely in number and is not referential, e.g. vaite-l 'statement', sonu-l 'word', utluse-l 'utterance', teate-l 'message', kinnituse-l 'assertion', hinnangu-l 'judgement', arvamuse-l 'opinion', ettepaneku-l 'proposal'. The only exception is, of course, the plural pair of parallel forms andme-te-l / andmei-l 'data'. An adessive noun can be replaced by an adpositional phrase whose main word is adposition jargi and kohaselt, e.g. vaitel and vaite jargi / kohaselt, sonul and sonade jargi / kohaselt, hinnangul and hinnangu jargi / kohaselt, etc. Although the stem of the adessive noun is substantive, it semantically relates to activity and expresses speaking, e.g. a precondition for the use of the adpositional construction Tederi sonul 'according to Teder's words' in example (30) is an act of speaking (Teder sonas, et ... 'Teder said that'). Based on form and function I shall call the construction the adessive indirectal whose adessive main word I shall treat as an adposition. Relying on the meaningful link of nouns sona, vaide, teade, kinnitus, etc. with a verb expressing the act of speaking and the productive template characteristic of derivation, the emergence of the adessive indirectal can be explained by deverbal derivation from speaking verbs. In that case vaitel, sonul, utlusel, teatel, etc. have no direct semantic formational link with the lexical meaning of the adessive substantive and we are dealing with the nominalisation of an event of speaking (see also Kasik 2002:214). Procedural meaning also explains why those expressions do not change in number and why they are non-referential. (For adessive adverbial constructions, see Sahkai 2006.)
4.1. Corpus analysis
A characteristic of the adpositional constructions in the journalistic texts of the 1890s is that information is presented as rumour; by using substantive as a modifier of the adposition, (kuuld 0, (36), teade (37)) the actual source of information remains vague. The substantive kuuld : kuulu 'hearsay, rumour(s), story or stories that are not entirely reliable' usually occurs in the set phrase kuulu jarelejargi. Synonymous with it is the same-stem adverb kuuldavasti 'according to rumours or hearsay, as they say, as can be heard' (EKSS II, 4:627), which can be found in the journalistic texts of the 1930s (40). The adpositional sonutsi 'according to [sb's] words' formed by the adverbial suffix -tsi was not found in the corpus material.
(36) Sugise-sed tagawarawaeliste harjutused jaa-da kolera kartuse parast tanawu pida-ma-ta, teata-wad paalinna lehed kuulu jarele. AJA1890\epo0104 autumn-ADJ.PL reserve.PL.GEN exercise.PL remain-dINF cholera.GEN fear.GEN for_reason.POSTP this_year held-mINF-ABE report-3PL capital.GEN newspaper.PL rumour.GEN according_to 'This autumn's reserve exercises are to be cancelled for fear of cholera, the capital's newspapers report according to hearsay.'
(37) Uleuldine kolerahaigete arw paalinna-s on uuemate teatete jarele 362 suur. AJA1890\epo0104 total cholera_patient.PL.GEN number capital-INE is latest.PL.GEN news.PL.GEN according_to 362 big 'The total number of cholera patients in the capital is 362 according to the latest news.'
Until the 1990s, neither journalistic nor fiction texts contained instances of adpositions clearly indicating an indirectal meaning. Before the 1990s, the adpositions jargi jarele and kohaselt rather referred to laws or other texts. In the journalistic texts of the 1890s the adposition jarele refers to a law in 10 cases, emphasising the authoritative nature of the source.
The analysed fiction texts contained no instances of expressing a reported statement with an adpositional phrase.
In the journalistic texts of the 1930s the extent of expressing a reported statement with an adpositional phrase has not changed compared to the previous period. The source of information is still unspecified, e.g. Malaga wiimaste teadete jargi (17). As in the 1890s, the adposition jargijarele is used to refer to law (38). In 1890s the only adposition used was jarele; by 1930s it has been replaced by the adposition jargi, although in sentence (38) jarele also occurs.
(38) Wenemaa-l praktiseeritawa kombe jarele, milline abielu aga pole makse-w Hispaania ega ka Inglise seaduse jargi. ESMA\esma301 Russia-ADE practice.GEN custom.GEN according_to such marriage is.NEG valid-PRTCP Spain.GEN neither also England.GEN law.GEN according_to
'... according to the customs followed in Russia, although such a marriage is not valid according to the laws of Spain or England.' The adverb kuuldavasti has been used to express a reported statement twice (39).
(39) Kuuldavasti pee-takse preaegu labiraakimisi hispaania tenori Alcaide kulaskaikude ule Tallinna. ESMA\esma293 according_to_rumour hold-IMPS.PRS at_this_moment negotiation.PL.PRTV Spanish.GEN tenor.GEN Alcaide.GEN visit.PL.GEN over Tallinn.INE 'According to hearsay they say that there are negotiations about the Spanish tenor Alcaide's visit to Tallinn.'
Fiction texts contain one indirectal adposition--arvates--in sentence (40). However, this is not a clear case of the use of indirectal, as it raises the theoretical issue of whether someone's own thoughts can be reported or not. Kerge (1979) has viewed this problem in relation with reported speech and drawn the line between the first and the second person--it is impossible to refer to someone else's thoughts unless they have been voiced.
(40) Sisulise-lt pole minu arvates mingi-t muudatus-t. ILU1938\ram0066 in_essence-ABL is.NEG I.GEN according_to_opinion nothing-PRTV change-PRTV 'I don't think there has been any change.'
The journalistic texts of the 1970s contain the first examples of the adessive indirectal: 1 instance of the adposition teatel (41) and 5 instances of andmeil (42).
(41) Informatsiooniagentuuride teatel ei ole praktilise-lt mingi-t lootus-t lei-da kokkuvarisenud hoone alt ellujaanui-d. AJA1970\ed0048 news_agency.PL.GEN according_to_message NEG be practically-ABL nothing-PRTV hope-PRTV find-dINF collapsed.GEN building.GEN under survivor.PL-PRTV 'According to news agencies, there is practically no hope of finding survivors under the debris of the collapsed building.'
(42) NSV Liidu Teaduste Akadeemia radioloogiakomisjoni andmeil oli 1958. aasta-ks Jaapani-s sadene-nud maapinna-le ... AJA1970\ed0039 Soviet.GEN Union.GEN Sciense.PL.GEN Academy.GEN radiology_committe.GEN according_to_data is.PST.3SG 1958 yearTRNSL Japan-INE fall_PTCP ground_ALL 'According to the radiology committe of the Academy of Sciences of the Soviet Union, by 1958 had fallen to the ground of Japan ...'
There is one instance of the adp,osition jargi (43), and for the first time the adposition kohaselt (44) occurs. As in earlier periods, the adpositional construction is used refer not to a person as the source of information, but to a document, e.g. law, report, project, etc.
(43) URO Teaduskomitee aruande jargi laks iga-l aasta-l ... AJA1970\ed0039 UN.GEN Science_Committee.GEN report according_to went every-ADE year-ADE ...
'According to UN Science Committee's report, every year ...'
(44) ... Noukogude sojalaevad soit-si-d kokkuleppe kohaselt 10. veebruari-l Havanna sadama-sse. AJA1970\ed0048 Soviet.PL.GEN warship.PL sail-PST-3PL agreement.GEN according_to 10th February-ADE Havanna.GEN port-INE 'The Soviet warships ... entered, according to the agreement, Havanna port on 10 February.'
Fiction texts contain no instances of the use of the adpositional indirectal.
The journalistic texts of the 1990s contain only one quotative mood form (30); the same sentence contains two instances of referential adpositional phrase, i.e. Tederi sonul and tema vaitel. The adessive indirectal that emerged in the 1970s had become deeply rooted in the journalistic language of the 1990s. In comparison with earlier periods it can be said that in the 1990s there was a pragmatic change in information exchange and referring to the source of information became obligatory. This statement is supported by a sudden increase in the use of reported speech which had probably been the basis for the emergence and spreading of the adessive indirectal that first occurs in the material of the 1970s. The fiction texts contained only one instance of the adessive indirectal and even this occurred in a social context characteristic of journalistic texts (50).
Compared to earlier periods, the use of other adpositions has also increased: 13 instances of kohaselt, 9 instances of jargi and 3 instances of arvates. There is a tendency for the source of information to become more concrete, e.g. the adposition jargi is still used to refer to law but also to persons as the source of information (45). The adposition kohaselt 0 also refers to law, as well as to a personal source of information (49).
(45) Jaak Joala meenutuste jargi oli see kuuekumnendate keske-l ... AJAE1990\ar0019 Jaak Joala.GEN recollection.PL.GEN according_to is.PST.3SG it sixties.PL.GEN middle-ADE 'According to Jaak Joala's recollecitons, it happened in the mid-sixties.'
(46) Haaveli arvates on ETK kauplusekettide edu kaupmeeste-le hea-ks julgustuse-ks ... AJAE1990\ar0020 Haavel.GEN according_to_opinion is ETK.GEN supermarket_chain.GEN sucess merchant.PL-ALL good-TRNSL encourage-TRNSL 'According to Haavel's opinion, the sucess of ETK supermarket chains is very encouraging for merchants ...'
(47) Esialgse kava kohaselt sunni-b uus kindlustusselts Leedu-s jargmise aasta alguse-s. AJAE1990\ar0008 initial.GEN plan.GEN according_to birth-3SG new insurance_company Lithuania_INE next.GEN year.GEN beginning-INE 'According to the initial plan, the new insurance company will be founded in Lithuania at he beginning of the next year.'
(48) Krediidiasutuste seaduse kohaselt laiene-vad muud ettevotlus-t reguleerivad oigusaktid krediidiasutuste-le ... AJAE1990\ar0015 Credit_Institution.PL.GEN law.GEN according_to spread-3PL other.PL.PRTV entrepreneurship-PRTV regulating.PL.PRTV legislative_document.PL.PRTV credit_institutions.PL-ALL 'According to the Credit Institutions Act, legislative documents regulating other entrepreneurship are applied to credit institutions ...'
(49) ... Tiit Salumae sonade kohaselt on valitsuse-ga asjaajamine kullalt-ki kulm ning aeganoudev toiming. Tiit Salumae.GEN word.PL.GEN according_to is government-COM doing_business rather-CLC cold and time_consuming activity 'According to Tiit Salumae, doing business with the government is a rather cold and time-consuming activity.'
Relying on the empirical material it can be concluded that the adessive indirectal is a linguistic means characteristic of journalistic language. Kasik's (2002, 2005) qualitative treatment of the syntax of news shows that pieces of news are texts in texts, i.e. the text of news is not produced by a journalist but press representatives, PR secretaries and other officials who communicate with the press and whose task is to merely mediate text. To an ever greater extent, pieces of news consist of direct quotes or near-quote references, which is also reinforced by the material used for the present article. Journalists' role in communicating information is minimal; they mostly just write down what others say to them. Their role is to let the readers know what they have been told and what other people have had to say about it. This means that a journalist is a mediator of information. The same trend can be detected in Finnish journalistic language (Kalliokoski 2005:23-25).
In fiction texts, the function of adpositions is based on examples (50), (51), 0, more indirectal than in earlier periods.
(50) Mis puutu-b Venemaa kaotuste-sse, siis oli-d need Vene poole hinnangul 48000 surnu-t ja 158000 haavatu-t. ILU1990\ilu0196 what concern-3SG Russia.GEN loss.PL-INE then be.PST-3PL they Russia.GEN side.GEN accoring_to_judgement 48000 dead-PRTV and 158000 wounde-PRTV 'As to Russia's losses, they were, according to Russians, 48,000 dead and 158,000 wounded.'
(51) Sest kuulu jargi leid-nud ta aastate eest talu tuhja-na ja sama laoki-l eest ning asu-nud lihtsalt sisse ... ILU1990\ilu0068 because rumour.GEN according_to find-PTCP s/he year.PL.GEN behalf farm.GEN empty-ESS and as_same_as neglected-ADE behalf and settlePTCP simply in 'They say that he had found the farm empty and neglected many years ago and simply settled in ...'
(52) Seltsimees Suursoo arvates on lihtsam olla juht kui alluv ... ILU1990\ilu0245 Mr Suuroo.GEN according_to_opinion is easier be.dINF leader than subordinate 'Mr Suursoo thinks that it is easier to be a leader than a subordinate ...'
5. Expressing an indirect statement in a complex sentence. Reported speech
Reported speech is a linguistic presentation based or known to be based on another linguistic presentation. Reported speech in Estonian has been studied by Kerge (1979). Reported speech can constitute a sentence or a text passage longer than a sentence. It is hard to draw a line between reported speech and other types of reporting. While reported speech functions on the text level and covers every situation and line in the reported text, the indirectal means of expression are viewed as a grammatical phenomenon which is expressed separately in each predicate and is considered part of morphosyntax. This article does not view textual reported speech; it focuses on the lexical-syntactic occurrence of reported speech in literary Estonian.
The syntactic structural parts of reported speech are the reporting clause and the reported part, whereas the latter is subordinate to the reporting clause as an object sentence. The reporting clause can be at the beginning, in the middle or at the end of a passage and contains a speaking or thinking verb referring to the reporting situation or a nominal derived from the verb, e.g. jutt 'story', sona 'word', markus 'remark', teade 'message'. Reported speech also includes mediations with impersonal references if those provide the time and place of reporting. Table 1 distinguishes between reported speech with verbal and deverbal reporting clause; the analysed fiction texts contained no reported speech with a deverbal reporting clause.
Speaking verbs are divided into primary verbs, with speaking as reporting in the foreground (e.g. raakima 'speak to', konelema 'to talk', jutustama 'to tell', utlema 'to say', mainima 'to mention' etc.), and secondary verbs which mark activities that take place while speaking, although the speaker has a different aim expressed by speaking (e.g. noomima 'to admonish', kaebama 'to appeal', kiitma 'to praise', lubama 'to promise' etc.) (Ratsep 1972). The dynamics of primary and secondary speaking verbs in journalistic and fiction texts is illustrated in Table 4.
5.1. Corpus analysis
In the journalistic texts of the 1890s there were 35 instances of reported speech, whereas in 11 cases the same sentence contained other indirectal means of expression as in sentence (6). The share of using primary and secondary speaking verbs in reported speech is equal. In several examples, the primary speaking verb is not used in relation with the speaker or mediator of the message; instead, the verb is modified by the means of communication--a telegram (53), newspaper or message.
(53) Hiljuti wast teata-s telegramm, et soda kahtlemata lawe-l seis-ta. AJA1890\epo0103 recently perhaps.PRCL announce-PST.3PL telegram taht war no_doubtingly limen-ADE stand-dINF 'Recently a telegram reported that war was inescapable.'
The journalistic language of later periods, especially the1990s, is characterised by expressing the indirect statement with an adpositional phrase and the emergence of a new construction, the adessive indirectal. The material of the 1890s and 1930s does not contain any instances of the adessive indirectal. There are, however, some examples of the use of the so-called noun bases for expressing the indirectal (deverbal nominals vaide 'statement', teade 'message', utlus 'utterance', kinnitus 'assertion', arvamus 'opinion', hinnang 'judgement', substantives andmed 'data', sona 'word' with the latter also having been converted into the verb sonama 'to say a word' which occurred in 6 cases of reported speech in the journalistic texts of the 1990s).
(54) Suure imestuse-ga luge-si-n "E. P." Nr. 24 kelle-gi g. teatus-t, et saalse karskuse seltsi "Edasi" pidu-l, teise-l Suwiste puha-l, "Wanemuise" naitlejad mangimas ol-nud. AJA1890\epo0105 big.GEN amazed-COM read-PST-1SG E.P. No. 24 someone.GEN-CLC g. statement-PRTV that there.GEN abstinence.GEN society.GEN Edasi.GEN party-ADE second-ADE Whitsuntide-GEN feast-ADE Wanemuine.GEN actor.PL playing be.PTCP 'I was amazed to read from "E. P." No 24 someone called g's statement that the actors of Wanemuine had been playing at the party of the abstinence society "Edasi" on the second feast of Whitsuntide.'
In fiction texts there were 14 instances of reported speech; 9 of them contained a speaking verb.
In the journalistic texts of the 1930s the share of reported speech is already smaller than in the previous period. There are no striking changes as to expressing a reported statement with a complex sentence. The double expression of the indirectal has diminished: in the journalistic texts of the 1890s the indirectal was found together with reported speech in 11 instances; in 1930 only 3 examples were found (55).
(55) Abessiinia asekuninga marssal Graziani terwisliku seisukorra kohta teata takse Rooma-st, et juba warsti ole-wat ooda-ta taielikku terwenemis-t. ESMA\esma242 Abyssinia.GEN vice_king.GEN marshal Grazian.GEN healthy.GEN condition.GEN about report-IMPS.PRS Rome-EL that already soon beQUOT expect-dINF complete.PRTV recovering-PRTV 'Rome reports that marshal Graziani of the Abyssinian viceroy is expected to regain his health completely.'
Fiction texts contained 6 instances of reported speech; 5 of them contained a primary speaking verb.
In the journalistic texts of the 1970s, the indirect statement occurred in the form of reported speech in 11 cases; 9 of them contained a primary speaking verb. Sentences (56) and (57) contain secondary compound verbs arvamust lootust avaldama; sentence (57) also contains the non-finite gerund construction koneldes.
(56) Hotelli einelauapidaja avalda-s arvamus-t, et Tartu on Baltikumi-s ... AJA1970\ed0046 hotel.GEN buffet_owner express-PST.3SG opinion-PRTV that Tartu is Baltic_state-INE 'The hotel's buffet owner thought that Tartu was in the Baltic states ...'
(57) Avatseremoonia-l konel-des rohuta-s akadeemik Alvar Aalto kunsti ja kunstitegelaste vastutus-t uhiskonna ees ning avalda-s lootus-t, et kunst teeni-b ka edaspidi rahvas-t. AJA1970\ed0031 opening_ceremony-ADE speak-GER emphasise-PST.3SG academy_member Alvar Aalto art.GEN and artist.Pl.GEN responsibility-PRTV society.GEN before and express-PST.3SG hope-PRTV that art serve-3SG also further people-PRTV 'Speaking at the opening ceremony, academy member Alvar Aalto emphasised the responsibility of art and artists before society and expressed a hope that art will continue to serve people.'
As to fiction texts, the 1970s is the only period with more instances of reported speech than in journalistic texts (24 and 11 respectively).
In the journalistic texts of the 1990s there is a noticeable increase in the use of reported speech compared to earlier periods. This has been the foundation for the emergence of a new type of reporting, the adessive indirectal (see Chapter 4). The accompanying phrase of reported speech is strongly dominated by primary speaking verbs (87 instances). A secondary speaking verb has been used in 10 sentences.
In fiction, no considerable changes regarding reported speech were found.
In the article, the indirectal is viewed as a member of the category of mode of reporting. The mode of reporting is a functional-semantic category covering a language system and its two members can be differentiated by the relationship between the speaker and the source of information. In an indirectal reporting situation the speaker is the mediator of information; the source of information is a person not present in the reporting situation. The indirectal mode of reporting serves two communication aims, statement and command. Means for expressing both a mediated or indirect statement and a mediated or indirect command can be found on different levels and in different components of a language.
Different languages have different means for expressing the mode of reporting. In typological linguistics the category whose main function is to mark the source of information is called evidentiality. Evidentiality shows whether the speaker has himself witnessed an event (direct evidentiality), draws conclusions about the event based on the facts known to him (inferred evidentiality) or has heard about the event from someone else (reported evidentiality). In this context, the indirectal mode of reporting is a means of expressing quotative evidentiality.
In a more broad-scale description of the Estonian language, indirectal-based categorisation is probably not very practical. However, it is a necessary postulate in fulfilling the aim of this article.
The analysis of empirical material confirms the presumption that journalistic language reflects social changes, while fiction remains rather stable over decades. As for journalistic texts, the 1890s and 1990s clearly stand out, as there are considerably more instances of the use of indirect statement in those periods. The indirectal means of expression, however, are different in the two periods.
The language use of the 1890s is characterised by abundant forms of the indirectal and ambiguity of meaning, especially in participle predicate which was the most wide-spread indirectal verb form in journalistic texts. Constructions that have become rooted in modern language vary in the language use of the 1890s. The style of fiction is considerably more uniform compared to journalistic language. The meaning of forms in fiction is clearer and syntax more correct.
In 1930 the use of indirectal statements decreases fourfold; most changes have taken place in journalistic texts. The use of form has become more uniform, which confirms the influence of language planning on literary language. While the 1890s were dominated by the single past participle and da-infinitive, the 1930s witness the triumph of the vat-marked quotative mood which is recommended in an orthological dictionary by Muuk (1933). The narrowing list of forms refers to language planning, although the synthetic form -nuvat of the neologist quotative mood never became rooted in literary language. The reason may be that one of the functions of the past participle form -nud overlaps with the novel nuvat-form.
The journalistic material of the 1970s is insignificant. The 1970s is the only period when reported speech can more often be found in fiction texts than in journalistic texts. A new indirectal means of expression in journalistic texts is the adessive indirectal, e.g. sonul 'according to word', vaitel 'according to statement', teatel 'according to message', hinnangul 'according to judgement', andmetel 'according to data', kinnitusel 'according to assertion'. The indirectal means of expression in fiction texts have not changed considerably.
Transfer to the Information Age leads to an increased share of reported text in the 1990s. The indirectal means of expression are restricted to the adpositional phrase and reported speech which provide the source of information. If the quotative is used, the source of information remains impersonal and the form does not comply with the requirements of journalistic text as a text type.
A part of this work was supported by the Estonian Science Foundation, Grant No. 6147 and No. 5970. I would like to thank Ass. Prof. Krista Kerge for her comments on the manuscript which I have used in this article.
Abbreviations 1, 2, 3 first, second, third person ABE abessive ADE adessive ADJ adjective ALL allative CLC clitic COM comitative COND conditional dINF da-infinitive EL elative ESS essive FEM female GEN genetive GER gerund ILL illative IMP imperative IMPS impersonal INE inessive JUSS jussive mINF ma-infinitive NEG negation marker PL plural POSTP postposition PRCL particle PRS present PRTV partitive PST simple past PRTCP presnt participle PTCP past participle Q question marker QUOT quotative SG singular TRM terminative TRNSL translative
Aikhenvald, Alexsandra Y. (2005) Evidentiality. Oxford University Press.
Brinton, Laurel J., and Elizabeth Closs Traugott (2005) Lexicalization and Language Change. (Research Surveys in Linguistics.) Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Campbell, Lyle (1991) "Some grammaticalization changes in Estonian and their implications". In Approaches to Grammaticalization. Vol. 1, 285-299. Elizabeth Closs Tragott, Bernd Heine, eds. (Typological Studies in Language, 19/1.) Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
CELL. Corpus of Estonian Literary Language. <http://www.cl.ut.ee/korpused/baaskorpus/ index.php?lang=en> (13.06.2007).
EKSS = Eesti kirjakeele seletussonaraamat. [Dictionary of Standard Estonian.] I-VI. 1988-. Tallinn: Eesti Keele Instituut.
Erelt, Mati (2001) "Some notes on the grammaticalization of the verb pidama in Estonian". In Estonian: Typological Studies V, 7-11. M. Erelt, ed. (Publications of the Department of Estonian of the University of Tartu, 18.) Tartu: University of Tartu.
Erelt, Mati (2002a) "Evidentiality in Estonian and some other languages: Introductory remarks". Linguistica Uralica 38, 2, 93-97.
Erelt, Mati (2002b) "Does Estonian have the jussive?". Linguistica Uralica 38, 2, 110-117.
Erelt, Mati, Reet Kasik, Helle Metslang, Henno Rajandi, Kristiina Ross, Henn Saari, Kaja Tael, Silvi Vare (1993) Eesti keele grammatika II. Suntaks. [Estonian Grammar II. Syntax.] Tallinn: Eesti Teaduste Akadeemia Keele ja Kirjanduse Instituut.
Erelt, Mati, Reet Kasik, Helle Metslang, Henno Rajandi, Kristiina Ross, Henn Saari, Kaja Tael, Silvi Vare (1995) Eesti keele grammatika I. Morfoloogia. Sonamoodustus. [Estonian Grammar I. Morphology. Word-formation.] Tallinn: Eesti Teaduste Akadeemia Eesti Keele Instituut.
Erelt, Mati, Helle Metslang (2004) "Grammar and pragmatics: Changes in the paradigm of the Estonian imperative". Linguistica Uralica 40, 3, 161-178.
Erelt, Mati, Helle Metslang, Karl Pajusalu (2006) "Tense and evidentiality in Estonian". In Topics in Subjectification and Modalization, 125-136. B. Cornillie, N. Delbeque, eds. (Belgian Journal of Linguistics, 20.) Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Hoey, Michael (2005) Lexical Priming: A New Theory of Words and Language. London, New York: Routledge
Hopper, Paul, Elizabeth Closs Traugott (1993) Grammaticalization. (Cambridge Textbooks in Linguistics.) Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Jaakola, Minna (1997) "Genetiivin kanssa esiintyvien adpositioiden kieliopillistumisesta". [On the grammaticalization of adpositions governing the genitive.] Kieli 12, 121-156.
Kalliokoski, Jyrki (2005) "Referointi ja moniaanisyys kielenkayton ilmioina". [Reported speech and polyphony as a phenomenon of language use.] In Referointi ja moniaanisyys, 9-42. M. Haakana, J. Kalliokoski, eds. (Tietolipas, 206.) Helsinki: Suomalaisen Kirjallisuuden Seura.
Kasik, Reet (2002) "Uudiste suntaks". [Syntax of the news.] In Catcher of the meaning: festschrift for professor Haldur Oim on the occasion of his 60th birthday, 200-218. Renate Pajusalu, Tiit Hennoste, eds. (Publications of the Department of general Linguistics of the University of Tartu, 3.) Tartu: University of Tartu.
Kasik, Reet (2005) "Ajakirjanduskeel 21. sajandi alguses". [Journalistic language at the beginning of the 21st century.] Paper presented at XXXVIII J. V. Veski day 27.06.2005 at the University of Tartu. [See Sepper 2005.]
Kerge, Krista (1979) Refereering tanapaeva eesti keeles. [Reported speech in contemporary Estonian.] Diploma thesis. University of Tartu.
Kunnap, Ago (1992) "Elanud kord ...". [Once there lived ...] Keel ja Kirjandus (Tallinn) 4, 209-215.
Kunnap, Ago (1994) "On the Uralic indirectal". In Ural-Altaische Jahrbucher (Wiesbaden) N.F. 13, 18-27.
Metslang, Helle (2004) "Imperative and related matters in everyday Estonian". Linguistica Uralica 41, 4, 243-256.
Muizniece, Liena, Helle Metslang, Karl Pajusalu (1999) "Eesti ja lati keele mineviku partitsiibi finiidistumine". [Past participle finitization in Estonian and Latvian.] Keel ja Kirjandus (Tallinn) 8, 522-534.
Muuk, Elmar (1928) Luhike eesti keeleopetus I. Haaliku- ja vormiopetus. [Estonian Grammar I. Fonology and Morphology.] 2nd ed. (Akadeemilise Emakeele Seltsi toimetised XIII.) Tartu: Eesti Kirjanduse Seltsi Kirjastus.
Muuk, Elmar (1933) Vaike oigekeelsus-sonaraamat. [Little Orthological Dictionary.] 2nd ed. Tartu: Eesti Kirjanduse Seltsi Kirjastus.
Magiste, Julius (1952) "Eesti nn. da-infinitiivilise kaudse koneviisi selgituseks". [For explanation of Estonian so-called da-infinitival oblique mood.] Tulimuld. Eesti Kirjanduse ja Kultuuri Ajakiri (Stockholm) 6, 357-361.
Ratsep, Huno (1971) "Kas kaudne koneviis on koneviis?". [Is the oblique mood a mood?] Keel ja struktuur (Tartu) 5, 45-69.
Ratsep, Huno (1972) "Eesti keele lihtlausemallidest ja nende esitamise metoodikast". [About syntactic pattern of Estonian simple clause.] Keel ja Struktuur (Tartu) 6, 25-83.
Ratsep, Huno (1978) Eesti keele lihtlausete tuubid. [Types of Estonian simple sentences.] (Eesti NSV Teaduste Akadeemia Emakeele Seltsi toimetised, 12.) Tallinn: Valgus.
Sahkai, Heete (2006) "Konstruktsioonipohise keelekirjelduse voimalustest adessiivse viisi- ja pohjusmaaruse naitel". [Construction-Based Description of Adessive Adverbials of Manner and Reason.] Keel ja Kirjandus (Tallinn) 10, 816-831.
Sepper, Maria-Maren (2005) "XXXVIII J. V. Veski paev". [XXXVIII J. V. Veski day.] Keel ja Kirjandus (Tallinn) 9, 772-773.
Stolz, Thomas (1991) Sprachbund im Baltikum? Estnisch und Lettisch im Zentrum einer sprachlichen Konvergenzlandschaft. Bochum: Brockmeyer.
Toomet, Piret (2000) "Monest kaudsuse valjendamise voimalusest tanapaeva eesti keeles". [Some possibilities of expressing indirect speech in Spoken Estonian.] Keel ja Kirjandus (Tallinn) 4, 251-259.
Viitso, Tiit-Rein (1976) "Eesti muutkondade susteemist". [On the inflection system in Estonian.] Keel ja Kirjandus (Tallinn) 3, 148-162.
Willett, Thomas (1988) "A cross-linguistic survey of the grammaticalization of evidentiality". Studies in Language 12, 1, 51-97.
Institute of the Estonian Language
Roosikrantsi 6, 10119 Tallinn
Tel.: +372 6442 892
Institute of the Estonian Language
Table 1. Forms of indirect statement used in journalistic texts Form 1890 1930 1970 nud-, tud-participle 55 1 0 vat-marked quotative 11 19 1 da-infinitive 32 0 0 kuulukse, kuulma, kuulduma 28 3 0 da-infinitive + nud-, tud- 13 0 0 participle Predicate da-infinitive + ma-infinitive 5 0 0 pidada + ma-infinitive 4 0 0 pidi + ma-infinitive 1 1 0 indicative past perfect 1 0 0 (oli + -nud) Adpositional phrase 14 3 10 with verb 35 27 11 Reported with deverbal 3 0 0 speech Total 202 54 22 Form 1990 Total nud-, tud-participle 0 56 vat-marked quotative 1 32 da-infinitive 0 32 kuulukse, kuulma, kuulduma 0 31 da-infinitive + nud-, tud- 0 13 participle Predicate da-infinitive + ma-infinitive 0 5 pidada + ma-infinitive 0 4 pidi + ma-infinitive 0 2 indicative past perfect 0 1 (oli + -nud) Adpositional phrase 70 97 with verb 97 170 Reported with deverbal 0 3 speech Total 168 446 Table 2. Forms of indirect statement used in fiction texts Form 1890 1930 1970 1990 Total vat-marked quotative 11 11 7 6 35 nud-, tud-participle 2 6 1 6 15 da-infinitive + nud-, 2 1 2 1 6 tud- participle indicative past perfect 1 0 1 3 5 (oli + -nud) Predicate pidi + ma-infinitive 2 0 0 2 4 kuulukse, kuulma, 0 1 0 0 1 kuuldumada-infinitive 1 0 0 0 1 Adpositional phrase 0 1 0 3 4 Complex sentence 14 6 24 19 63 Total 33 26 35 40 134 Table 3. Indirectal verb forms in literary Estonian Indirectal quotative present and preterite means of [olevat; olevat + nud-/tud-participle olnuvat] expression Indicative personal or impersonal present perfect [on + nud-/tud-participle] Indicative personal or impersonal past perfect [oli + nud-/tud-participle] Indirectal Predicate participle infinite [nud-/tud-participle] forms da-infinitive [1) -da; 2) -da + nud-/tud-participle] Indirectal Past simple of the modal verb pidama with ma-infinitive modal [pidi + ma-infinitive] verbs Da-infinitive and ma-infinitive of the modal verb pidama [pidada + ma-infinitive] Perception verb kuulukse with vat-infinitive [kuulukse + vat-infinitive] Table 4. Reported speech in journalistic and fiction texts Primary speaking verb Secondary speaking verb Total Journalistic Fiction Journalistic Fiction texts texts texts texts JT FT 1890s 17 5 18 9 35 14 1930s 14 5 10 1 24 6 1970s 9 13 2 11 11 24 1990s 87 9 10 10 97 19 Total 127 32 40 31 167 63
|Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback|
|Date:||Sep 1, 2007|
|Previous Article:||Modelling speech temporal structure for Estonian text-to-speech synthesis: feature selection.|
|Next Article:||Technology-intensive FDI and economic development in a small country--the case of Estonia.|